Declaration of J. Stading on Behalf of Best Buy

EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
Declaration of J. Stading on Behalf of Best Buy
Stores, L.P., August 14,2008
eX-2176
Notice of Deposition to ASUS, April 17, 2008
eX-2I77
Notice of Deposition to ASUS, April 29, 2008
eX-2178
Notice of Deposition to ASUS, May 2,2008
eX-2179
Notice of Deposition to ASUS, August 1, 2008
eX-2I80
eX-218le
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
ASUS 214181ASUS 214209
Response to August 31, 2007 ASUS Rebuttal of
IDM Proof Packages presented April 13, 2007
eX-2182
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
eX-2183
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
eX-2184
eX-2185
eX-2I86
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
eX-2I87
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
eX-2188
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
eX-2l89
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
--
.........
-
~
-201-
Infringement
SPONSORING
WITNESS
Admitw/o
witness
Admitw/o
witness
Admitw/o
witness
Admitw/o
witness
Admitw/o
witness
V.Hong
H. Huston
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
Rejected
Admitted
Admitted
Admitted
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
CX-2191
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CX-2192
Declaration of J. Stading on Behalf of Best Buy
Stores, L.P., August 14,2008
J. Phinney
N. Polish
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CX-2194
CX-2195
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CX-2196
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CX-2197
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CX-2198C
ASUS 214041ASUS 214119
CX-2199C
IBMOOO03180IBMOOO03258
CX-2202C
CX-2203C
Infringement
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CX-2193
CX-2201C
SPONSORING
WITNESS
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CX-2190
CX-2200C
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
ASUS SC282554ASUS SC282624
ASUS SCS0025199ASUS SCS0025248
ASUS SCS0024945ASUS SCS0025026
ASUS- SCSOO13065~
IBM Patent Presentation to ASUSTek, April 13,
2007
IBM Patent Presentation to ASUSTek, April 13,
2007
Infringement
Domestic Industry"
Infringement
Domestic Industry
P5LD2 Motherboard BIOS Source Code
(Baseboard.asm)
Infringement
P5GDl Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5E WS PRO Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5E Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
-202-
N. Polish
H. Huston
V.Hong
H. Huston
N. Polish
G. Chen
N. Polish
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Admitted
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
I
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CX-2204C
CX-2205C
CX-2206C
CX-2207C
CX-2208C
CX-2209C
CX-2210C
CX-221lC
CX-2212C
CX-2213C
CX-2214C
CX-221SC
CX-2216C
CX-2217C
BATES NUMBER
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
SCSOO13153
SCSOO12678SCSOO12734
SCSOO12735SCSOO 12785
SCSOO48018SCSOO48067
SCSOO47574SCSOO47606
SCSOO25384SCSOO25461
SCSOO13555SCSOO13630
SCSOO61848SCSOO61892
SCSOO61942SCSOO61988
SCSOO13400SCSOO13439
SCSOO25344SCSOO2S383
SCSOO 13178 SCSOO13198
SCSOO2S249SCSOO25343
SCSOO61667SCSOO61719
SCSOO13245-
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PURPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
P5B-VM DO (ChanneVSI) Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5B-VM SE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5B-PLUS Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4VP-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5K Deluxe Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5K Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5GV-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5GZ-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
PSGPL-X SE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
PSGPL-X Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
PSG-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5GL-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
PSGD2 Deluxe Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5GC-VM Schematic
Infringement
-203-
~
_~ Polish
STATUS OF
RECEIPT I
INTO
EVIDENCE I
Admitted I
Not
Admitted I
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
i
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
- ' - - Not
J
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CX-2218C
CX-2219C
CX-2220C
CX-2221C
CX-2222C
CX-2223C
CX-2224C
CX-222SC
CX-2226C
CX-2227C
CX-2228C
CX-2229C
CX-2230C
CX-2231C
BATES NUMBER
ASUS SCSOO13298
ASUS SCS0050180ASUS SCS0050216
ASUS SCS0050 113 ASUS SCSOOS0147
ASUS SCS0024600ASUS SCS0024637
ASUS_ SCS0047209 ASUS SCS0047235
ASUS SCS0047348ASUS SCS0047386
ASUS- SCS0024504ASUS SCS0024551
ASUS SCS0027468ASUS SCS0027491
ASUS SCS0048971 ASUS SCS00490 10
ASUS SCS0049089ASUS SCS0049127
ASUS SCS0032510ASUS SCS0032549
ASUS SCS0024164ASUS- S(;S002423l
ASUS SCS0024232ASUS SCS0024312
ASUS SCS0024121 ASUS SCS0024163
ASUS SCS0068967-
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATEMENT OF
PURPOSE
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
P4P800-VM Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4P800-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4P800-E Deluxe Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4GE-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4P800 Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4C800-E Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4B Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M2V-MX SE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M2V-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M2N-VM DVI Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M3A Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M3A32-MVP Deluxe Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M2V Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M2N-SLI Schematic
-
-204-
JI1frirl:gem~L_
-
N. Polish
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
I
I
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTo
,
EVIDENCE I
CX-2232C
CX-2233C
CX-2234C
CX-2235C
CX-2236C
CX-2237C
CX-2238C
CX-2239C
CX-2240C
CX-2241C
CX-2242C
CX-2243C
CX-2244C
CX-224SC
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
SCS00690 18
SCS0026622SCS0026659
SCS0043436SCS0043503
SCSOOll047SCSOOllll0
SCS0023022SCSOO23071
SCSOO23689SCSOO23744
SCS0023625SCSOO23688
SCS0023860SCS0023896
SCSOO23232SCSOO23269
SCSOO23480SCSOO23519
SCS0023402SCSOO23439
SCSOO23977SCSOO24019
SCSOO23364SCS002340 1
SCSOOO1507SCSOOO1528
SCS0047476-
M2N-PLUS Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
LIN64-SLI WSIB Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M2A-VM Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M2N Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M2N32-SLI Deluxe Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M2N32 WS Professional Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M2N4-SLI Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M2N-E SLI Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M2N-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M2N-MX SE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M2NPV-VM Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M2N-MX SE PLUS Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4S800-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4S800D-X Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
-205-
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
---'-
~---
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
BATES NUMBER
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATEMENT OF
PuRPoSE
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTo
EVIDENCE
ASUS SCS0047513
ASUS_SCS0049168 CX-2246C
ASUS SCS0049207
ASUS SCS0067040CX-2247C
ASUS SCSOO67108
ASUS SCSOO15533CX-2248C
ASUS SCSOO15542
ASUS_SCS0053677 CX-2249C
ASUS SCS0053727
ASUS_SCS0053391 CX-2250C
ASUS SCS0053437
ASUS SCS0064627CX-2251C
ASUS SCS0064673
ASUS_ SCS0027254 CX-2252C
ASUS SCS0027304
ASUS SCS0053337CX-2253C
ASUS SCS0053390
ASUS SCSOOO1746CX-2254C
ASUS SCSOOO 1792
ASUS SCS0027721 CX-2255C
ASUS SCSOO27770
ASUS SCS0070254CX-2256C
ASUS SCS0070314
ASUS SCS0070516CX-2257C
ASUS SCS0070581
ASUS SCS0069954CX-22S8C
ASUS SCS0069991
CX-2259C ASUS SCS0070110 ----.-~~
------~~----
M2V-TVM Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5N32-SLI PremiumIWiFi-AP Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5N32-SLI Premium Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5L-VM 1394 Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5L-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5LD2-X Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5LD2-VM Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5LD2-CIIPAT Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5LD2 SE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5LD2 Motherboard Schematic
Infringement
G. Chen
N. Polish
P5WD2-E Premium Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5WDG2-WS Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
PSVD2-X Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
PSVDC-X Schematic
-
~-
-- .....
-
--
-206-
Infring~eI!t ___
-
N.-Polish
----
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
I
Admitted I
i
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
I
Not
Admitted I
No~
STATUS OF
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CX-2260C
CX-2261C
CX-2262C
CX-2263C
CX-2264C
CX-2265C
CX-2266C
CX-2267C
BATES NUMBER
.
ASUS SCS0070157
ASUS SCSOO16138ASUS SCSOO16138
ASUS SCSOO06345ASUS SCSOOO6361
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
SCS0041767SCS0041802
SCSOO42207SCS0042252
SCSOO41658SCS0041693
SCSOOO9977SCSOOI0019
SCSOO06583SCSOO06641
SCSOO31787SCS0031S32
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
SCS0031751 SCS00317S6
SCSOO70315SCSOO70381
SCS0070032SCSOO70070
SCSOO05673SCSOOO5718
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
P5VDC-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
AGP RV350 128M TSOP VGA DVI VO
Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
KSU-X Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
K8V and K8V Deluxe Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
KSS-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
KSN-E Deluxe Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
COMMANDO Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
ASV-VM Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
i
Admitted I
Not
Admitted ,
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted :
Not
I
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
I
Admitted
Not
Admitted
I
CX-2268C
CX-2269C
CX-2270C
CX-2271C
A8V -MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5WDG2-WS PRO Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5VDC-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A8N-E Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
-207-
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
I
I
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CX-2272C
CX-2273C
CX-2274C
CX-2275C
CX-2276C
CX-2277C
CX-2278C
CX-2279C
CX-2280C
BATES NUMBER
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
SCS0030943SCS0030989
SCSOO05813SCSOO05854
SCSOO05897SCSOO05955
SCSOO05511SCSOO05552
SCSOO05765SCSOO05812
SCSOO05719SCSOO05764
SCSOO06003SCSOO06049
SCSOO05479SCSOOO5510
SCS0030658SCS0030696
STATEMENT OF
PURPoSE
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
A8N5X Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A8N-VM CSM Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A8N32-SLI DELUXE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A 7V880 Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
i
EVIDENCE
Not
.
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted i
Not
Admitted
i
Not
Admitted i
Not
I
Admitted
!
A8N-SLI SE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A8N-SLI PREMIUM Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A8R-MVP Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A 7V266 Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A 7V400-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
I
Not
I
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
!
I
CX-2281C
CX-2282C
CX-2283C
CX-2284C
CX-2285C
ASUS SCS0031440A8N-VM Schematic
ASUS SCS0031481
ASUS SCSOO18477A8V-VM SE Sclie:matic
ASUS SCSOO 18520
ASUS SCSOO18340A8S-X Schematic
ASUS SCSOO18382
ASUS SCSOOI8288A8R32-MVP Schematic
ASUS SCSOO18339
ASUSSCS0006131- . . . ,~8V:QELU~SchetIla!ic__
-.-
-208-
--
Infringement
N. Polish
Infringement
N. Polish
Infringement
N. Polish
Infringement
N. Polish
Infringement
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PURPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTo
EVIDENCE
ASUS SCSOO06177
ASUS SCS0032389CX-2286C
ASUS SCS0032481
ASUS SCS0032011CX-2287C
ASUS SCS0032052
ASUS_SCS0026234CX-2288C
ASUS SCS0026249
ASUS SCS0026117CX-2289C
ASUS SCS0026137
ASUS_ SCS0026080CX-2290C
ASUS SCS0026097
ASUS SCS0025985CX-2291C
ASUS SCS0026003
ASUS_ SCS0025948CX-2292C
ASUS SCS0025968
ASUS_ SCS005 I 532CX-2293C
ASUS SCS0051579
ASUS _ SCS0026299CX-2294C
ASUS- SCS0026311
ASUS- SCSOOO 1328CX-2295C
ASUS SCSOOO 1348
ASUS_SCSOOO 13 04CX-2296C
ASUS SCSOOO1327
ASUS SCS0029047CX-2297C
ASUS SCS0029068
ASUS SCOOO7222CX-2298C
ASUS SCSOOO7239
CX-2299C ASUS SCS0033867-
A TIS BLITZ FORMULA Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A8V-XE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
C2291TD/4L Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A880ps Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
RV530-A671SP Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A676PS Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
RV630 GDDR3 Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
NV44A NVIDlA Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
C262GITD 14L or NV44 Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
G84/G86 Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
G71-GT Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
NI8 Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
RV530IRV515 Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M2A MVP Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
-209-
~-
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted I
Not
Admitted I
Not
Admitted I
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not - - - - -.......
•
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
ASUS SCS0033884
ASUS SCSOO10869CX-2300C
ASUS SCSOOI0936
ASUS SCOO10937CX-2301C
ASUS SCSOO10982
ASUS SCSOO10152CX-2302C
ASUS SCSOO10192
ASUS SCS0022007CX-2303C
ASUS SCS0022048
ASUS SCS0041999CX-2304C
ASUS SCS0042040
ASUS SCS0041879CX-2305C
ASUS SCS0041920
ASUS SCS0047764CX-2306C
ASUS SCSOO47813
ASUS SCS0050554CX-2307C
ASUS SCS0050608
ASUS SCS0050883CX-2308C
ASUS SCS0050928
ASUS SCSOO12522CX-2309C
ASUS SCSOO12575
ASUS SCSOO50665CX-231OC
ASUS SCSOO50712
ASUS SCS005073 7CX-2311C
ASUS SCS0050785
ASUS SCS0050460CX-2312C
ASUS SCS0050498
SCSOO68410~~-2313C__ -ASUS
------
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
LlN6a4-SLI WS Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
M2A MVP Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
KSV-X SE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
KSV-VM ULTRA Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
K8V -VM Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
K8V-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5B SE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5B-Deluxe Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5B-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5AD2-E Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5B Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5B-E Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4U800-X Schematic
Infiingement
N. Polish
P4VSX-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
I
Admitted I
i
Not
Admitted
Not
!
•
-210-
-
EmmIT
NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
BATES NUMBER
ASUS SCSOO68440
ASUS SCSOO12480CX-2314C
ASUS SCSOO12521
ASUS SCSOO68335CX-2315C
ASUS SCSOO68371
ASUS SCSOO12421CX-2316C
ASUS SCSOO12450
ASUS SCS004744SCX-2317C
ASUS SCSOO47475
ASUS SCSOO51732CX-2318C
ASUS SCSOO51761
ASUS SCSOOOOO98CX-2319C
ASUS SCOOOO127
ASUS_ SCSOO50336CX-2320C
ASUS SCSOO50358
ASUS SCSOOS0427CX-2321C
ASUS SCSOO50459
ASUS _ SCSOOOOO76CX-2322C
ASUS SCOOOOOO97
ASUS SCSOOO0l28CX-2323C
ASUS SCSOOOO173
ASUS SCSOO24668CX-2324C
ASUS SCSOO24705
ASUS SCSOOOOOOlCX-2325C
ASUS SCSOOOOO29
ASUS SCSOOO1477CX-2326C
ASUS SCSOOOlS06
CX-2327C ASUS- SCSOO68260-
----_ .. -
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
STATUS OF
SPONSORING
WITNESS
P4V800D-X Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4SDX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4S8X Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4S8X-X Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4S8X-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4S533 Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4S333 MNM Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4S800 Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4S333-FX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4S333-MNM Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4S800D (P4S800D-E) Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4S333 Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P4S800-MX SE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
, Infripgement
N. Polish
P4PE2-X
- - -Schematic ------
--.~
-~.
~-
-211-
-
RECEIPT
INTo
EVIDENCE
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted,
Not
Admitted
,
Not
Admitted •
Not
,
Admitted :
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
I
Admitted
Not
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CX-2328C
CX-2329C
CX-2330C
CX-2331C
CX-2332C
CX-2333C
CX-2334C
CX-2335C
CX-2336C
CX-2337C
BATES NUMBER
ASUS SCSOO68286
ASUS SCSOO50148ASUS SCSOO50168
ASUS SCSOO62036ASUS SCSOO62113
ASUS SCSOO51762ASUS SCSOO51838
ASUS SCSOO52435ASUS SCSOO52515
ASUS SCSOO52597ASUS SCSOO52672
ASUS SCSOO51916ASUS SCSOO51994
ASUS-SCSOO52877ASUS SCSOO52955
ASUS SCSOO52829ASUS SCSOO52876
ASUS SCSOOO5376ASUS SCSOOOO5417
ASUS SCSOO30251ASUS SCSOO30295
CX-2338
CX-2339C
CX-2340C
CX-2341C
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPoSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
PrP0800S-X Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5K PREMIUM Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5K3 DELUXE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5KC Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5K3 DELUXE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5K65 WS Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5KV Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5KPS-VM Schematic
Infringement
N.Polish
A7S333 Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A 7N8X Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
SCSOO32204SCSOO32295
SCSOO26556SCSOO26621
SCSOO30780-
BLITZ EXTREME Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
CROSSHAIR Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A7V MB Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
-212-
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
I
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CX-2342C
CX-2343C
CX-2344C
CX-2345C
CX-2346C
CX-2347C
CX-2348C
CX-2349C
CX-2350C
CX-2351C
CX-2352C
CX-2353C
CX-2354C
CX-2355C
BATES NUMBER
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
SCSOO30835
SCSOO30381SCS0030416
SCSOO30341SCOO30380
SCSOO63006SCSOO63075
SCSOO62184SCSOO62251
SCSOO64120SCSOO64171
SCSOOO6387SCSOOO6421
SCSOO18082SCSOO18122
SCSOOO6491SCSOOO6582
SCSOO25900SCSOO25947
SCSOO41252SCSOO41294
SCSOO16297SCSOO16359
SCSOO6991SSCSOO69953
SCSOO67494SCSOO67533
SCSOO67534-
"
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
A7S8X-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A 7N8X-VM Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5K-VM Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5K SE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5LD2 Deluxe Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
19550GElTO Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A7V8X-X Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
BLITZ FORMULA Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A8V-E Deluxe Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
K8N Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5W64 WS PRO Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5VD2-VM SE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5P800-VM Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5P800S Schematic
Infring~ent
-213-
.
N. Polish
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CX-2356C
CX-2357C
CX-2358C
CX-2359C
CX-2360C
CX-2361C
CX-2362C
CX-2363C
CX-2364C
CX-2365C
CX-2366C
CX-2367C
CX-2368C
CX-2369C
BATES NUMBER
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
SCSOO67568
SCSOO67453SCSOO67493
SCSOO66225SCSOO66276
SCSOO67842SCSOO67885
SCSOO66322SCSOO66366
SCSOO67279SCSOO67329
SCSOO67569SCSOO67605
SCSOO15543SCSOO15581
SCSOO26250SCSOO26263
SCSOO26312SCSOO26332
SCSOO26464SCSOO26485
SCSOO25969SCSOO25984
SCSOO26176SCSOO26194
SCSOO54167SCSOO54207
SCSOO71124-
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
P5P800 Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5N-EM HDMI Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5RDI-VM Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5N-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5NSLI Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5PE-VM Schematic
Infringement
P5P800-MX Schematic
Infringement
VGA Schematic (C381: G72, DDR2)
Infringement
VGA Schematic (R345-AOl DESIGN-G73,
256MBDDR2)
Infringement
VGA Schematic (P401-A02-G84-400)
Infringement
EAX300SE Schematic
Infringement
EAX550GE Schematic
Infringement
P5P800 SE Schematic
Infringement
STRIKER Extreme Schematic
-214-
_
Infringement
N. Polish
N. Polish
N. Polish
N. Polish
N. Polish
N. Polish
N. Polish
N. Polish
N. Polish
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
1
I
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted I
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
I
Admitted I
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CX-2370C
CX-2371C
CX-2372C
CX-2373C
CX-2374C
CX-237SC
CX-2376C
CX-2377C
CX-2378C
CX-2379C
CX-2380
CX-2381
CX-2382
CX-2383C
BATES NUMBER
ASUS SCS0071193
ASUS SCS00661S8ASUS SCS0066224
ASUS SCS0069831ASUS SCS0069875
ASUS SCS0069796ASUS SCS0069830
ASUS SCS0069717ASUS SCS0069760
ASUS SCS0069266ASUS SCS0069312
ASUS SCS0069642ASUS SCS0069682
ASUS SCSOO15309ASUS SCSOO15368
ASUS SCS005S148ASUS SCS0055208
ASUS SCS0055270ASUS SCS0055323
ASUS SCS0031923ASUS SCS0031966
IBMOO038663IBMOO038802
IBMOO026079IBMOO026164
IBMOO0226309IBMOO0226370
ASUS SCS00690 19-
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
N. Polish
PSN-E SLI Schematic
Infringement
PSVDI-X Schematic
Infringement
P5V800-MX Schematic
Infringement
P5SD2-X Schematic
Infringement
PSPL2 Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5S-MX SE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
P5ND2-SLI Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish'
P5W DH Deluxe Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
PSWD2-Premium Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A8V-VM ULTRA Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
EEE PC 40, 40 Surf and 80 Manual
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
EEE PC 901 & 903 Series Manual
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
EEE PC 904/905 & 1000 Series Manual
Infringement
N. Polish
Admittedj
P4V800D-X Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
N. Polish
N. Polish
N. Polish
i
I
-215-
-
I
Not
I
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CX-2384C
CX-2385C
CX-2386C
CX-2387C
CX-2388C
CX-2389C
CX-2390C
CX-2391C
CX-2392C
CX-2393C
CX-2394C
CX-2395
CX-2396
CX-2397
BATES NUMBER
ASUS SCSOO69060
ASUS SCS0050291ASUS SCSOO50335
ASUS SCSOO47162ASUS SCSOO47208
ASUS SCSOO60842ASUS SCSOO60889
ASUS SCSOO63826ASUS SCSOO63876
ASUS SCSOO41338ASUS SCS0041389
ASUS SCS0054208ASUS SCSOO54247
ASUS SCS0030658ASUS SCS0030696
ASUS SCS0031440ASUS SCS0031481
ASUS SCSOOI8477ASUS SCSOO18520
ASUS SCSOO18340ASUS SCSOO18382
ASUS SCSOO18288ASUS SCSOO18339
IBMOO038663IBMOO038802
IBMOO226079IBM00226164
IBM00226309-
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTo
EVIDENCE
Admitted
Pundit R350 (P4R8L) Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
T2-R (P4R8T) Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
T2-PHl (p5G6T) Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
V3-P5945G (P5L-VM) Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
K8N-DL Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
Vintage PEl (p5P800-VM) Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A 7V400-MX Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A8N-VM Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A8V-VM SE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A8S-X Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
A8R32-MVP DELUXE Schematic
Infringement
N. Polish
EEE PC 4G, 4G Surf and 8G Manual
Infringement
N. Polish
EEE PC 901 & 903 Series Manual
Infringement
N. Polish
EEE PC 904/905 & 1000 Series Manual
Infringement
N. Polish
•
-216-
I
I
Not
Admitted . .
Not
Admitted
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
I
Admitted!
Not
Admitted·
Not
Admitted
Not
I
Admitted i
Not
i
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
IBM00226370
Receipts for Components Purchased to Combine
with ASUS Barebones and Server Products
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CX-2398
CX-2399
Infringement
J. Phinney
Infringement
N. Polish
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CX-2400
,
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CX-2401
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CX-2402
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CX-2403
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CX-2404
CX-2405C
SC 588381SC_588328
SC_594017SC_594005
SC_594274SC_594243
SC_594242SC_594172
SC_594171SC_594112
SC_594111SC 594018
Gl Notebook source Code (proj.asm,
TZSMI.ASM, history. txt, asus.asm, kemel.asm,
equates.equ, historyl.txt)
-217-
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CX-2406C
CX-2407C
BATES NUMBER
SC 594004SC 593896
SC 587726SC 587783
SC 587713SC 587725
SC- 587656SC- 587712
SC 587565SC 587655
SC 587498SC 587564
SC 587497SC 587384
SC 599875SC 599933
SC 599796SC 599874
SC- 599709SC- 599795
SC 599685SC 599708
SC 599673SC 599684
SC 599625SC 599672
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
A8JS Notebook Source Code (kemel.asm,
TZSMLASM, PROJ.ASM, equates.equ,
history. txt, historyl.txt, asus.asm)
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
Infringement
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
W7J Notebook Source Code (Kemel.asm,
equates.equ, asus.asm, PROJ.asm, TZSMLASM,
history_ A8J.txt)
-218-
Infringemment
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CX-2408C
CX-2409C
BATES NUMBER
SC 593770SC 593747
SC 593746SC 593735
SC- 593734SC- 593648
SC 593647SC 593600
SC 593599SC 593541
SC 593460SC 593382
SC 593330SC 593319
SC 593216SC 593214
SC 593213SC 593143
SC 593259SC 593223
SC 593381SC 593331
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRpOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTo
EVIDENCE ,
I
W7JT Notebook Source Code (proj.asm,
TZSMI.ASM, asus.asm, history. txt, kemel.asm,
equates.equ)
Infringement
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
I
S6F Notebook Source Code (TZSMI.ASM,
ADT7450.equ, ASUS.ASM, S6F.SDL,
PROJ.ASM, PROJ.EQU, History(S6F).txt)
Infringement
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
SC 593222SC 593217
SC 593142
CX-241OC
SC 599624-
S6FM Notebook Source Code (TZSMI.ASM,
-219-
Not
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CX-2411C
BATES NUMBER
SC 599613
SC 599612SC 599610
SC 599609SC_599537
SC 599536SC 599502
SC 599501SC 599451
SC 599450SC_599445
SC 599444SC 599424
SC 598633SC 598543
SC 599247SC 599194
SC 599347SC_599259
SC_599258SC 599248
SC 599423SC 599348
SC 599193SC 599140
SC 599139-
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
ADT7450.equ, ASUS.ASM, S6F.SDL,
PROJ.ASM, PROJ.EQU, History(S6F).txt)
U6S Notebook Source Code (asus.asm, proj.asm,
equates.equ, TZSMLASM, kemel.asm,
DTS.ASM, History.txt)
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE.
Admitted
Infringement
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
I
--
-
---
-220-
~
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
SC 599118
j
CX-2412C
SC 598733SC_598634
SC 593072SC_593 009
SC 593008SC 592916
SC 593083SC 593073
SC 592915SC_592839
SC 593141SC 593084
SC 592838SC 592823
U3S Notebook Source Code (asus.asm,
proj.asm, equates.equ, TZSMLASM, kernel.asm,
DTS.ASM, History.txt)
Infringement
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
CX-2413C
SC 598542SC 598440
SC_598937SC 598873
SC 599033SC 598938
SC 598872SC 598862
SC 599117SC 599034
SC 598861-
VX2S Notebook Source Code (asus.asm,
proj.asm, equates.equ, TZSMLASM, kernel.asm,
DTS.ASM, History.txt)
Infringement
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
I
-221-
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PURPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
SC 598804
SC 598803SC 598734
CX-24 I 4
CX-2415
CX-2416
ffiMOOOO1230
ffiM006623 06ffiM00662389
ffiM00662281ffiM00662305
U.S. Patent No. 5,166,931
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
EeePC 1000H User's Manual
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
•
I
I
Admitted
i
EN8800GT Graphics Card Speed Setup Guide
Infringement
N. Polish
Sales Chart, 852-Related ASUS Products
Infringement
P. Francis
Sales Chart, 852-Related ASUS Products
Infringement
P. Francis
Sales Chart, 852-Related ASUS Products
Infringement
P. Francis
Sales Chart, 852-Related ASUS Products
Infringement
P. Francis
Not
Admitted
IBM00233287IBM00223318
Cisco Systems, Inc. Amendment to License, May
31,2005
Domestic Industry
H. Huston
Not
Admitted
CX-2422
None
CV of Paul Francis
Background
P. Francis
Admitted
CX-2423
None
Background
I. Phinney
CX-2424
None
Background
N. Polish
Admitted I
Admitted I
CX-2425
None
CV of Joshua Phinney
CV of Nathaniel Polish
"Circuits, Devices and Systems" 4ID Edition by
Ralph J. Smith
Infringement
I. Phinney
Admitted
CX-2426
IBM00015888 IBMOOO15989.
Infringement
I. Phinney
Admitted
CX-2417C
CX-2418C
CX-2419C
CX-2420C
CX-2421C
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
ASUS
112581112944
068911068966
236283236289
067497067511
V2-PH2 User Guide
-222-
Not
Admitted
I
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CX-2427C
CX-2428C
CX-2429C
CX-2430
CX-2431
CX-2432
CX-2433
CX-2434
CX-2435
CX-2436
CX-2437
CX-2438
CX-2439
CX-2440
CX-2441
CX-2442
CX-2443
CX-2444
CX-244SC
CX-2446C
CX-2447C
BATES NUMBER
ASUS 324201ASUS 324211
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
MP2307 Data sheet
Appendix E of Phinney Initial ReportADP3180* Data Sheet
Appendix E of Phinney Initial Report - TPS5130
Data Sheet
ADP3180 Data Sheet
MAX1987 Data Sheet
ADP3181 Data Sheet
ADP3186 Data Sheet
ADP3188 Data Sheet
APW7120 Data Sheet
FAN5019 Data Sheet
ISL6218CRZ Data Sheet
ISL6227 Data Sheet
ISL6312 Data Sheet
MAX8760 Data Sheet
SC2643VX Data Sheet
TPS5130 Data Sheet
MP2307 Data Sheet
ADP8 Data Sheet
Draft Complaint, October 26, 2007
Deposition Designations of Eric (Chun Wei) Ko,
dated June 18, 2008
Deposition Designations of George Chen, dated
June 6, 2008
-223-
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS OF I
RECEIPT !
INTO
EVIDENCE
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Infringement
N. Polish
Infringement
J. Phinney
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted
Infringement
Infringement
Infringement
Infringement
Infringement
Infringement
Infringement
Infringement
Infringement
Infringement
Infringement
Infringement
Infringement
Infringement
Infringement
Infringement
J. Phinney
J. Phinney
1. Phinney
J. Phinney
J. Phinney
J. Phinney
J. Phinney
J. Phinney
J. Phinney
J.Phinney
J. Phinney
J. Phinney
J. Phinney
J. Phinney
J.Phinney
H. Huston
N. Polish
Admitted
Withdrawn
Admitted
Admitted
Admitted
Admitted
Admitted
Admitted
Admitted
Admitted
Admitted
Admitted
Admitted
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Infringement
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Infringement
Withdrawn
--
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
BATES NUMBER
Deposition Designations of Rick (Bao Yu) Su,
dated June 21, 2008
IBM Dictionary of Computing
IBM Dictionary of Computing: Information
Processing, Personal Computing,
Telecommunications, Office Systems, IBMspecific Terms
Realtek RTL8650IRTL8651 Home Gateway
Controller ROME Software Programming Guide,
Issue 29: June 2005
Source Code to Realtek router
R&TTE Technical Construction File
The DUNIX Distributed Operating System, by
Ami Litman
CX-2448C
CX-2449
CX-2450
CX-2451C
CX-2452C
CX-2453C
CX-2454
CX-2455
OSF DCE Release 1.0 S3, dated March 25, 1991
Amoeba: A Distributed Operating System for the
1990s
-Switched-mode power supply - Wikipedia article
Netrino: Introduction to Pulse Width Modulation
CX-2456
CX-2457
CX-2458
--_._-
--
(P~
--
--
-224-
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
Infringement
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
Not
Admitted
Admitted
I
Not
I
Admitted
I
Admitted
Admitted
Admitted
Not
Admitted
i
I
Not
,
Admitted
Not
Admitted '
Admitted
Admitted
DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBITS:
Exhibit
Number
Bates Number
Descriptive Title
Statement of
Purpose
Sponsoring
Witness
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
Not
Admitted
CDX-l
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-2
List of Exhibts to the Rebuttal Expert Report of
Dr. Stevenson
CDX-3
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-4
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-5
INITIALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-6
ASUS List of Accused ASUS Products
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-7
List of Notebook Product Subcategories
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted i
CDX-8
List of Server Product Subcategories
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-9
'829 Patent Claim Construction
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-IO
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-ll
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Infringement
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-12
-225-
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Exhibit
Number
Bates Number
Statement of
Purpose
Descriptive Title
Sponsoring
Witness
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
Not
Admitted
CDX-13
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-14
A3H Notebook Claim Chart (,829, Claim 1)
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-IS
A3H Notebook Claim Chart (,829, Claim 2)
Infringement
J.Phinney
Admitted
.
Not
Admitted
CDX-16
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-17
A8M Notebook Claim Chart (,829, Claim 1)
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-18
A8M Notebook Claim Chart ('829, Claim 2)
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-19
Appendix B of Phinney Initial Report Documents and Infonnation Considered
Infringement
J. Phinney
Not
Admitted
CDX-20
Appendix D of Phinney Initial Report
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-21
INITIALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-22
INITIALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-23
INITIALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-24
INITIALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-2S
INITIALLY LEFT BLANK
-~--
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
~-.--
- _.. __ .. _--
-226-
CDX-26
INITIALLY LEFT BLANK
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
Not
Admitted
CDX-27
INITIALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-28
INITIALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-29
INITIALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-30
INITIALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-31
INITIALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-32
INITIALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
Exhibit
Number
CDX-33C
CDX-34
Bates Number
Descriptive Title
Statement of
Purpose
Sponsoring
Witness
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Eee PC 2G Surf (P700) Claim Chart ('829,
Claim I)
Eee PC 2G Surf (P700) Claim Chart (,829,
Claim 2)
CDX-35
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-36C
KFN4-DI6/SAS Server Claim Chart (,829,
Claim I)
CDX-37
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
-227-
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Infringement
1. Phinney
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Exhibit
Number
Bates Number
Statement of
Purpose
Descriptive Title
Sponsoring
Witness
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
CDX-38C
RS120-E3 Server Claim Chart ('829, Claim 1)
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-39
RS120-E3 Server Claim Chart (,829, Claim 2)
Infringement
J.Phinney
Admitted
CDX-40
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-41
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-42C
V2-PH2 Barebones Claim Chart ('829, Claim 1)
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-43
V2-PH2 Barebones Claim Chart (,829, Claim 2)
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted I
CDX-44
Video: Infringement by ASUS of' 829 Patent by
ASUS Barebones Products
Infringement
J.Phinney
Admitted
CDX-45C
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-46
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-47
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-48
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
!
I
I
Not
I
Admitted I
~-
-228-
I
............. ----
:...-.__ ............
_-_
.......
- - . - -...
--
.. -~ .. -.--.~-
~
.... ~-
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
--
1
I
I
I
•
--~~-.
Exhibit
Number
Bates Number
Descriptive Title
CDX-49
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-50
Documents and Infonnation Considered by Dr.
Francis for his Direct Report
CDX-51
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-52
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Statement of
Purpose
Infringement
Sponsoring
Witness
P. Francis
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
CDX-53
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-54
INITIALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-55
INITIALLY LEFT BLANK
COX-56
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-57C
RX3141 - Flow chart - alternate path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-58C
RX3141 - Flow chart - infringing path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-59C
RX3141 - Flow chart - table setup
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-60C
RX3141 Router comparison document with
WL-330gE
Infringement
J. Chang
P. Francis
Not
Admitted
-229-
j
I
Exhibit
Number
Bates Number
Statement of
Purpose
Descriptive Title
Sponsoring
Witness
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
CDX-61C
Video Demonstration of Dr. Francis
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-62C
SL-500 & SLl 000 - Flow chart - infringing path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-63C
SUIrirnary Chart of ASUS Commercial Invoices
and Other Sales Data for Accused Products and
Motherboards
Infringement,
Contributory /
Inducement
CDX-64
Video: Infringement of '829 Patent by ASUS
Server Products
Infringement
CDX-65C
INTENTlONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-66C
WL-300g flow chart - alternate path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-67C
WL-300g - Flow chart - infringing path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-68C
WL-300g - Flow chart - table setup
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-69C
WL-300g WLAN Comparison Document with
WL-330gE
Infringement
J. Chang
P. Francis
Not
Admitted
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-70C
CDX-7lC
J. Phinney
Admitted
Admitted
Not
Admitted
WL-320gE &WL-320gP - Flow chart - alternate
path
WL-320gE & WL-320gP - Flow chartinfringing path
-
-230-
N. Polish
Exhibit
Number
Bates Number
Descriptive Title
Statement of
Purpose
Sponsoring
Witness
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
CDX-72C
WL-320gE & WL-320gP Flow chart - table
setup
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-73C
WL-320gE and WL-320gP WLAN comparison
document with WL-330gE
Infringement
J. Chang
P. Francis
Not
Admitted
CDX-74
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-75C
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-76C
Demonstrative of Fig 4 vin the '852 Patent
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-77C
WL-330gE - Flow chart - alternate path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-78C
WL-330gE - Flow chart - infringing path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-79C
WL-330gE - Flow chart - table setup
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-80
ASUS Representative Product Summary Chart
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
CDX-81C
'829 Patent Indirect Infringement Barebones &
Server Animation
Infringement
I. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-82C
Demonstrative of Fig 10 in the '852 Patent
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-83
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
-231-
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Exhibit
Number
Statement of
Purpose
Descriptive Title
Bates Number
"829 Patent Indirect Infringement Barebones &
Server Still
CDX-84C
Demonstrative of Col. 5 Ln 12-19 in the '852
Patent
WL-500g RT &WL-500G Deluxe, WL-400G
Premium, WL-550gE RT - Flow chartalternate path
WL-500g RT & WL-500G RT, WL-500G
Deluxe, WL-500g Premium, WL-550gE RT, Flow chart - infringing path
WL-500g RT & WL-500G Deluxe, WL-550GE
RT - Flow chart - table setup
WL-500g RT, WL-500g Deluxe, WL-500g
Premium and WL-550gE comparison document
with WL-330gE
WL-500gP & WL-500g P2 - Flow chart alternate path
CDX-85C
CDX-86C
CDX-87C
CDX-88C
CDX-89C
CDX-90C
Sponsoring
Witness
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
Infringement
J. Chang
P. Francis
Not
Admitted
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-91C
WL-500gP & WL-500gP2 - Flow chart infringing path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-92C
WL-500gP & WL-500GP2 - Flow chart - table
setup
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-93C
WL-500gP and WL-500gP V2 comparison
document with WL-330gE
Infringement
J. Chang
P. Francis
Not
Admitted
____
L....
__________
---~--
-~.-----.-
-~--
-232-
.. --- .. ----~--
Exhibit
Number
Descriptive Title
Bates Number
Statement of
Purpose
Sponsoring
Witness
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
Not
Admitted
CDX-94
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-95
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-96C
Demonstrative of Col. 7 Ln 3-11 in the '852
Patent
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-97C
WL-500W RT - Flow chart - alternate path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
I
CDX-98C
WL-SOOW RT - Flow chart - infringing path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
I
Not
Admitted
,
CDX-99C
WL-SOOW R T - Flow chart - table setup
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted ,
CDX-IOOC
WL-SOOW WLAN comparison document with
WL-330gE
Infringement
J. Chang
P. Francis
Not
Admitted
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
Infringement
J. Chang
P. Francis
Not
Admitted
CDX-IOIC
CDX-102C
CDX-103C
WL-520g & WL520g RT Flow Chart Alternate Path
WL-S20g & WLS20g RT - Flow chart infringing path
WL-520g & WL-S20G RT - Flow chart - table
setup
CDX-I04C
WL-S20g and WL-S20g RT comparison
document with WL-330gE
CDX-I05C
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
....
-
-233-
i
I
Not
Admitted
i
Exhibit
Number
Bates Number
Statement of
Purpose
Descriptive Title
Sponsoring
Witness
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
Not
Admitted
CDX-I06C
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-I07C
Demonstrative of CoL 7 Ln 43-48 in the '852
Patent
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-I08C
WL-520gC - Flow chart - alternate path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-I09C
WL-520gC - Flow chart - infringing path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-II0C
WL-520gC - Flow chart - table setup
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-lllC
WL-520gC WLAN comparison document with
WL-330gE
Infringement
J. Chang
P. Francis
Not
Admitted •
CDX-112C
WL-S20gU - Flow chart - alternate path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted'
CDX-l13C
WL-S20gU - Flow chart - infringing path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted I
CDX-114C
WL-S20gU - Flow chart - table setup
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted I
CDX-115C
WL-S20gU WLAN comparison document with
WL-330gE
Infringement
J. Chang
P. Francis
Not
Admitted
CDX-116C
WL-530g & WL530g RT- Flow chart - alternate
path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-117C
WL-530g & WL-S30g RT- Flow chart infringing path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
-
-234-
j
Exhibit
Number
Bates Number
Descriptive Title
Statement of
Purpose
Sponsoring
Witness
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
I
COX-118C
WL-530g & WL-530G RT - Flow chart - table
setup
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
COX-119C
WL-530g and WL-530g RT comparison
document with WL-330gE
Infringement
1. Chang
P. Francis
Not
Admitted
COX-120
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-I21
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-122C
Demonstrative of Col. 10 Ln 68 - Col. 111 Ln 5
in the '852 Patent
COX-123
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-124C
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
COX-125C
'852 Patent Claim Chart
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
COX-126C
WL-700gE PS/802.ll g - Flow chart - alternate
path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
CDX-127C
WL-700gE PS/802.11g - Flow chart - infringing
path
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
COX-128C
WL-700gE PS/802.11 g - Flow chart - table
setup
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
-235-
I
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Exhibit
Number
Bates Number
Descriptive Title
Statement of
Purpose
Sponsoring
Witness
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
CDX-129C
WL-700gE WLAN comparison document with
WL-330gE
Infringement
J. Chang
P. Francis
Not
Admitted
CDX-130
Exhibit 5 to Polish Initial Expert Report
Infringement
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
CDX-131
Attachment A to Exhibit 5 of Polish Initial
Expert Report
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
CDX-132
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-133
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-134
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK,
Not
Admitted
CDX-135
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-136
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-137
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-138
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
-236-
Exhibit
Number
Bates Number
Descriptive Title
Statement of
Purpose
Sponsoring
Witness
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
CDX-139
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-140
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-141
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-142
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-143
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-I44
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-145
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-146
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-147
March 5, 2008 Letter from Brian Nester to Tony
Pezzano
Infringement
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
CDX-148
Illustrative Prior-Art Power Scheme Diagram
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted
-237-
'Status of
Exhibit
Number
,
Statement of
Purpose
Descriptive Title
Bates Number
Sponsoring
Witness
Receipt
Into
Evidence
CDX-149
Annotated Figure 4 from the '829 Patent
Showing Components of '829 Patent Claims
CDX-ISO
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-lSl
High Level Diagram of Notebook System
J.Phinney
Admitted
CDX-152
Animation of Schematics for the V2-PH2
Barebones Power On Sequence
J. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-153
Animation of Schematics for the PI-P5945G
Barebones Power On Sequence
J. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-154
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-155
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-156
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-157
Animation of eeePC 2G Surf (P70) Power On
Sequence
J.Phinney
Admitted
CDX-158C
Animation of eeePC 901 Power On Sequence
J. Phinney
Admitted
----
---_
...... _--_. __ .. _ - - - - - - - -
---
-238-
Infringement
J.Phinney
Admitted
Not
Admitted
~--
------------
Exhibit
Number
Bates Number
Descriptive Title
Statement of
Purpose
Sponsoring
Witness
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
CDX-159C
Animation of A3H Notebook Power On
Sequence
J. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-160C
Animation of GIS Notebook Power On
Sequence
1. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-161
Animation of A8M Notebook Power On
Sequence
1. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-162
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-163.
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-164
Animation ofRS120-E3 Server Power On
Sequence
1. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-165C
Animation ofTS500-E4 Server Power On
Sequence
1. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-166C
Animation ofKFN4-D 16/SAS Server
Schematics
J. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-167
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-168
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
-239-
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Exhibit
Number
Bates Number
Descriptive Title
Statement of
Purpose
Sponsoring
Witness
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
CDX-169
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-170
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-171
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-l72
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-173
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-174
Dr. Nathiel Polish - IP Experience
CDX-17SA
CDX-17S
Updated ASUS Accused Product List of User
Manuals, Source Code and Schematics with
Exhibit Numbers ('741 Patent)
ASUS Accused Product List of User Manuals,
Source Code and Schematics with Exhibit
Numbers ('741 Patent)
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
CDX-176C
ASUS Eee PC Animation ('741 Patent)
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
CDX-177C
Smart Cooling Mode ('741 Patent)
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
-240-
Exhibit
Number
Bates Number
Statement of
Purpose
Descriptive Title
Sponsoring
Witness
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
CDX-l78C
Auto Fan Control Mode ('741 Patent)
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
CDX-179C
ASUS Q-Fan Animation ('741 Patent)
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
CDX-180C
ASUS Notebook Animation ('741 Patent)
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
CDX-181C
'741 Patent Animation
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
CDX-182
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-183
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-184
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
Not
Admitted
CDX-185
ASUS Eee PC Video ('741 Patent)
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
CDX-186
ASUS VGA Card Video ('741 Patent)
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
CDX-187
ASUS Motherboard Video ('741 Patent)
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
--
-241-
-
------
Exhibit
Number
Bates Number
Descriptive Title
Statement of
Purpose
Sponsoring
Witness
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
CDX-188
ASUS Notebook Video ('741 Patent)
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
CDX-189
ASUS Barebones Video ('741 Patent)
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
CDX-190
ASUS Server Video ('741 Patent)
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
CDX-191C
IBM's Intellectual Property Licensing Program
Domestic Industry
H. Huston
Admitted
CDX-192C
IBM's Intellectual Properly Licensing Portfolio
Domestic Industry
H. Huston
Admitted
CDX-193
Animation of Power On Sequence: Figure 4 of
'829 Patent
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted
CDX-194
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
CDX-195C
Power-on Animation: eeePCs and Laptops
Not
Admitted
J. Phinney
Infringement
Admitted
.
CDX-196
'852 Patent Claim Chart
CDX-197
'852 Patent Claim Chart
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
Admitted
...
-242-
-
.--------
Exhibit
Number
CDX-198
Bates Number
Descriptive Title
Statement of
Purpose
Sponsoring
Witness
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
Not
Admitted
'852 Patent Claim Chart
'852 Patent Claim Chart
Not
Admitted
'852 Patent Claim Chart
. Not
Admitted
CDX-199
CDX-200
'852 Patent Claim Chart
CDX-2Ot
Admitted
'852 Patent Claim Chart
CDX-202
Admitted
'852 Patent Claim Chart
Not
Admitted
CDX-203
'852 Patent Claim Chart
CDX-204
Admitted
'852 Patent Claim Chart
CDX-205
Admitted
'852 Patent Claim Chart
CDX-206
Admitted
'852 Patent Claim Chart
Not
Admitted
CDX-207
-243-
Exhibit
Number
Descriptive Title
Bates Number
Statement of
Purpose
Sponsoring
Witness
'852 Patent Claim Chart
Status of
Receipt
Into
Evidence
Admitted
CDX-208
'852 Patent Claim Chart
Admitted
CDX-209
'852 Patent Claim Chart
CDX-210
Admitted
CDX1000
Admitted
CDX1001
Admitted
REBUTTAL EXHIBITS:
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTo
EVIDENCE
Documents and Infonnation Considered by
Polish for Rebuttal Report
CRX-IC
Admitted
Validity
Dr. S!evenson Expert Testimony Provided
CRX-2C
...
-
N. Polish
Validity
--~'-----
-244-
N. Polish
Admitted
,
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CRX-3C
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
List of Materials Considered for Stevensons
Initial Report
CRX-4
CRX-6C
CRX-7C
CRX-8C
CRX-9
CRX-lO
CRX-ll
CRX-12
N. Polish
Admitted
N. Polish
Admitted
N. Polish
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
N. Polish
Admitted
N. Polish
Admitted
N. Polish
Admitted
N. Polish
Admitted
N. Polish
Admitted
Validity
ASUS's Notice of Prior Art, dated July 11, 2008
CRX-5C
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
Validity
Polish Rebuttal Witness Statement
SuperMicro Patent License
Validity
Validity
SuperMicro Patent Presentation
Letter from Rama Elluru to Tony Pezzano, dated
July 25, 2008
Validity
Validity
Akitoshi - JP1226012 Japanese Patent Abstract
Validity
Suzuki - JP58099821 Japanese Patent Abstract
Vfl1idity
Takahashi - JP2254797 Japanese Patent Abstract
Validi!y
Kazunori - JP63281892 Japanese Patent Abstract
Validity
-245-
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTo
EVIDENCE
CRX-13
CRX-14
CRX-15
CRX-16
CRX-17
CRX-18
CRX-19
CRX-20
CRX-21C
UC3842 Datasheet - Current Mode PWM
Controller
Home page ofhttp://macfaq.org/with title "the
pickle's Low-End Mac FAQ"
Picture showing alkaline batteries placed in
parallel with the motherboard batteries of the
Mac II inspection computer (Figure 1 from Dr.
Phinney's Inspection Report)
Picture showing 1992 firmware date on one Mac
IIcx inspection computer (Figure 2 from Dr.
Phinney's Inspection Report)
Intentionally Left Blank
Validity
R. Francis
Validity
J. Phinney
Admitted
Exhibit 12 of Madisetti Deposition - Pictures of
Mac Hcx computer _____
-------
--------
!
-
Admitted
Validity
J. Phinney
•
Admitted
Validity
Validity
Intentionally Left Blank
Picture showing +5V continuous power at the
power pins SRAM of the IBM 5140 with the
computer turned "off' (Figure 5 from Dr.
Phinney's Inspection Report)
Printout from
http://lowendmac.com/iilmacintosh-ii.cx.html
that was cited in Dr. Phinney's Rebuttal Report
Not
Admitted
Validity
J. Phinney
R. Francis
Not
I
Admitted •
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
Admitted
Validity
J. Phinney
Validity
J. Phinney
Yali<!i!y__
J.Phinney
Admitted i
Admitted
i
•
-246-
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CRX-22C
CRX-23
CRX-24
CRX-25C
CRX-26
CRX-27
CRX-28
CRX-29
CRX-30
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
Exhibit 4 from Dr. Madisetti's Deposition
showing Madisetti Claim Construction (recreated
because missing from deposition exhibits
received from court reporter)
IntentionallyLeft Blank
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
Validity
Validity
Deposition Designations for Dr. Olivier
Intentionally Left Blank
Validity
Validity
Intentionally Left Blank
Validity
Intentionally Left Blank
Validity
Intentionally Left Blank
Validity
Validity
Intentionally Left Blank
-247-
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
Admitted
Validity
Intentional!y Left Blank
SPONSORING
WITNESS
J.Phinney
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted I
~~-
•
I
-~
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CRX-31
CRX-32
CRX-33
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
Validity
Intentionally Left Blank:
Intentionally Left Blank:
Validity
Intentionally Left Blank:
Validity
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTo
EVIDENCE
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
I
.
CRX-34
Intentionally Left Blank:
Validity
R. Francis
Not
Admitted I
Not
Admitted
I
CRX-35
CRX-36
CRX-37
CRX-38C
CRX-39C
CRX-40C
Intentionally Left Blank:
Validity
R. Francis
CD that ships with the ASUS RX-3141
Validity
R. Francis
CD that ships with the ASUS WLAN WL-330gE
Complainant's Second Supplemental Response to
Respondents' Interrogatory No.4, dated July 25,
2008
Validity
R. Francis
Admitted
!
Admitted
Validity
R. Francis
Order No. 11, dated July 11, 2008
Validity
R. Francis
Hance Huston Declaration
Validity
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Admitted
-248-
,
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
CRX-41
STATEMENT OF
PURPOSE
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
Intentionally Left Blank:
CRX-42
Validity
Intentionally Left Blank:
Validity
CRX-43C
Letter from Brian Nester to Tony Pezzano, dated
May 1,2008
CRX-44C
Letter from Brian Nester to James Adduci, dated
May 16, 2008
Validity
mM00168693 IDMOO168712
Letter from Brian Nester to Judge Essex, dated
May29,2008
Respondents' Opposition to Complainant mM's
Motion to Compel Respondents to Deliver
Electronic Copy of Source Code and Schematics
to Offices of Complainant's Outside Counsel,
dated July 1, 2008
Exhibit E to Respondents' Opposition to
Complainant mM's Motion to Compel
Respondents to Deliver Electronic Copy of
Source Code and Schematics to Offices of
Complainant's Outside Counsel, dated July 1,
2008
IDM00169733 mMOO169757
Letter from Brian Nester to Tony Pezzano, dated
July 03, 2008
~~idity
CRX-45C
CRX-46C
CRX-47C
CRX-48C
Validity
~~
-249-
Validity
SPONSORING
WITNESS
R. Francis
R. Francis
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Validity
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
Validity
R. Francis
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PURPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTo
EVIDENCE
Application for Issuance of a Subpoena Ad
Testificandum and a Subpoena Duces Tecum to
Real Communications, Incorporated, dated July
10,2008
CRX-49C
Not
Admitted
Validity
R. Francis
IBM00662438
Objections & Responses of Real
Communications, dated July 25, 2008
CRX-50C
CRX-51
CRX-52
CRX-53
CRX-54
IBM00662436
IBM00662437
IBM00662435
ASUS 322814ASUS 322822
CRX-55
CD that ships with the SL500
CD that ships with the SLl 000
CD that ships with the WL-300G
CD that ships with the WL-320GE
CD that ships with the WL-500G
CRX-57
-
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
Validity
CD that ships with the WL-320GP
CRX-56
Validity
CD that ships with the WL-500G.DELUXE
-250-
Not
Admitted
Validity
Not
Admitted
Validity
Not
Admitted
Validity
Validity
Validity
Validity
J.Phinney
J. Phinney
Not
Admitted
J.Phinney
Not
Admitted
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
I
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
CRX-S8
CD that ships with the WL-SOOGP
CRX-S9
CD that ships with the WL-500GP2
CRX-60
CD that ships with the WL-SOOW
CRX-61
CRX-62
CRX-63
CRX-64
CRX-65
CRX-66
CRX-67
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
CD that ships with the WL-S20G
ASUS 321122ASUS 321188
CD that ships with the WL-520GC
CD that ships with the WL-520GU
CD that ships with the WL-530G
CD that ships with the WL-S30G V2
CD that ships with the WL-550GE
CD that sh!ps with the WL-S66GM RT
-251-
STATEMENT OF
PuRPoSE
Validity
Validity
Validity
Validity
Validity
SPONSORING
WITNESS
N. Polish
N. Polish
J. Phinney
J.Phinney
J. Phinney
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Validity
Not
Admitted
Validity
Not
Admitted
Validity
J. Phinney
Not
Admitted
J.Phinney
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
Validity
Validity
,
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
CRX-68
DESCRIPTIVE DTLE
CD that ships with the WL-700GE PS802.11 G
Asustek Computer, Inc. 's, Asus Computer
International's, Pegatron Corporation's And
Unman COIporation's Supplemental Responses to
Complainant International Business Machines
Corporation's Interrogatories Nos. 17, 19,20-23,
46,54, 78-79 (10/14/08)
CRX-69C
Counter designations to ASUS's Attanasio
deposition designations (RX-535)
CRX-70C
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
Validity
SPONSORING
WITNESS
R. Francis
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
Not
Admitted
Admitted
N. Polish
Validity
Validity
R. Francis
Not
Admitted _
!
CRX-71C
Rebuttal Witness Statement of Dr. Francis
CRX-72C
Counter Designations of Hance Huston for
August 6, 2008
CRX-73C
Counter Designations of Hance Huston for
September 23, 2008
CRX-74C
Counter Designations of Roger Cox
CRX-75C
Counter Designations of Michael Deloye
CRX-76C
~
..........
gounter Designations of Robert Myers
-252-
Validity
Validity
Validity
Validity
Validity
Validity
R. Francis
R. Francis
Admitted
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
I
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CRX-77C
CRX-78C
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
ASUS 325669
Counter Designations ofWiIIiam Bistline
Validity
ASUS 325675
Counter Designations of William Johnson
Validity
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
N. Polish
Admitted
Withdrawn
R. Francis
Withdrawn
I
CRX-79C
CRX-80C
CRX-SIC
CRX-S2
CRX-83
CRX-84C
CRX-85C
Counter Designations of James Peterson
Validity
R. Francis
Withdrawn
Counter Designations ofHoa Phan
Validity
R. Francis
Withdrawn
Exhibit 22 from Dr. Madisetti's Deposition which
has the bates number ASUS 332671
Validity
Picture of Astec Power Supply from Mac IIcx
Inspection Computer No. I, Serial No.
F9384ULM5685
Validity
Picture of Astec Power Supply from Mac IIcx
Inspection Computer No.2, Serial No.
F9187lXM5615
Validity
ASUS Privilege Log dated April 15, 2008
ASUS Privilege Log dated April 28, 2008
Validity
Validity
Admitted
J.Phinney
Admitted
J. Phinney
Admitted
J. Phinney
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
R. Francis
Not
Admitted
I
CRX-86C
Admitted i
Dr. Phinney Rebuttal Witness Statement
-253-
Validity
R. Francis
-
L .....
~
__
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
BATES NUMBER
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS OF
RECEIPT
INTo
EVIDENCE
CRX-87C
Opening and Counter Designations of the
Deposition of Joaquin Hinojosa
Validity
CRX-88C
Opening and Counter Designations of the
Deposition of Stephen Smith, June 27, 2008
Validity
CRX-89C
Opening and Counter Designations of the
Deposition of Dan Frye, November 4, 2008
Validity
Complainant's Responses to Respondents
Asustek Computer, Inc.'S, Asus Computer
International's, Pegatro'n Corporation's and
Unihan Corporation's Requests for Productions
Nos. 195,199, and 207, dated October 17, 2008
Validity
CRX-90C
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Withdrawn
Not
Admitted
REBUTTAL DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBITS:
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
BATES NUMBER
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS
OF
RECEIPT I
INTo
EVIDENCE
List of Issued Patents Citing '741
CRDX-l
CRDX-2
Validity
Intentionally Left Blank
-
- -
-
---_.-
-254-
--
N. Polish
I
Admitted
Not
Admitted
I
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CRDX-3
CRDX-4
CRDX-5
CRDX-6
CRDX-7
CRDX-8
CRDX-9
CRDX-10
CRDX-l1
CRDX-12
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PURPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
Intentionally Left Blank
STATUS
OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Intentionally Left Blank
Flow diagram comparison of claimed invention
of 852 and SOCKS firewall processing an
mCOImng message
Figure 1 of ASUS Translation of Tanabe
Japanese Published Unexamined Patent App. No.
1-241606
Figure 3 of ASUS Translation of Tanabe
Japanese Published Unexamined Patent App. No.
1-241606
Validity
R. Francis
Admitted
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Figure 3 of Cope U.S. Patent No. 5,121,281
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
'741 File History Demonstrative
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Figure 1 of ASUS Translation of Takahashi
Japanese Published Unexamined Patent App. No.
H02-254797
Disclosure in Takahashi Abstract and ASUS
Takahashi Translation Demonstrative
Figure 1 of ASUS Translation of Akitoshi
Japanese Published Unexamined Patent App. No.
HOl-226012
-255-
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PURPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS
OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
Figure 1 ofClaypole U.S. Patent 4,425,766
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Figure 1 of Braun U.S. Patent 5,040,377
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Figure 1 of ASUS Translation of Suzuki
Japanese Published Unexamined patent App. No.
S58-99821
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Figure 8 of Mondor U.S. Patent 4,728,160
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Figure 2 of Takamae U.S. Patent 4,756,473
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
CRDX-18
Figure 1 ofWrayU.S. Patent 4,817,865
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
CRDX-19
Figure 1 of ASUS Translation of Kazunori
Japanese Published Unexamined Patent App. No.
H02-127711
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
CRDX-20
Figure 3 of Brown U.S. Patent 4,656,553
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
CRDX-21
'741 Patent Bay 1 Embodiment Animation
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
'741 Patent Option Card Embodiment Animation
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
741 Patent Fan 1 Embodiment Animation
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
CRDX-13
CRDX-14
CRDX-15
CRDX-I6
CRDX-17
CRDX-22
CRDX-23
-
-256-
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS
OF
RECEIPT
INTo
EVIDENCE
CRDX~24
CRDX-25
CRDX-26
CRDX-27
CRDX-28
741 Patent User Designation Embodiment
Animation
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
'741 Patent Updates Embodiment Animation
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
'741 Patent Query Embodiment Animation
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
'741 Patent Determining Speed Value
Embodiment Animation
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
ASUS Eee PC User Manual Instructions
Validity/Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
Intentionally Left Blank
Not
Admitted
Intentionally Left Blank
Not
Admitted
Intentionally Left Blank
Not
Admitted
Intentionally Left Blank
Not
Admitted
CRDX-33
Intentionally Left Blank
Not
Admitted
CRDX-34
Dr. Madisetti's Changed Opinions Regarding the
Pepper Patent
Validity
J.Phinney
Admitted
CRDX-35
Power Supplies from Mac IIex Inspection
Computers
Validity
J.Phinney
Admitted
CRDX-29
CRDX-30
CRDX-31
..
CRDX-32
-257-
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
BATES NUMBER
Tektronix Oscilloscope Uses Battery-Powered
STATEMENT OF
PURPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS
OF
RECEIPT
INTo
EVIDENCE
Not
Admitted
Validity
J. Phinney
Mac H Rigged by ASUS to Allow Power-On
Validity
J. Phinney
Admitted
Hard Drive of Mac Hcx Serial No.
F9384ULM5685
Validity
J. Phinney
Admitted
IBM 5140's SRAM is Continuously Powered
Validity
J. Phinney
Admitted
Components of Mac IIcx Power Supply
Validity
J. Phinney
Admitted
CRDX-41
ASUS Notebook User Manual Instructions
Validity/Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
CRDX-42
ASUS VGA Card User Manual Instructions
ValiditylInfringement
N. Polish
Admitted
ASUS Motherboard User Manual Instructions
Validity/Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
CRDX-44
ASUS Barebones User Manual Instructions
Validity/Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
CRDX-45
ASUS Server User Manual Instructions
Validity/Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
IBM and ASUS Claim Construction Comparison
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
ASUS Claim Constructions of "Obtaining"
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
CRDX-36
CRDX-37C
CRDX-38
CRDX-39
CRDX-40C
CRDX-43
CRDX-46C
CRDX-47C
RAM
-258-
EXHlBIT
NUMBER
CRDX-48C
CRDX-49C
CRDX-SOC
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
BATES NUMBER
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
ASUS Claim Constructions of "Component"
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
ASUS Claim Constructions of "Varying"
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
CRDX-53C
CRDX-54C
IBM and ASUS Claim Construction Comparison
of "components"
CRDX-S2C
IBM and ASUS Claim Construction Comparison
CRDX-55C
SPONSORING
WITNESS
ASUS Clain Constructions of "Predetennined
Cooling Requirement"
Translation Summary of Chinese Language
Portions of ASUS Commercial Invoices (CX27C and CX-217SC)
IBM and ASUS Claim Construction Comparison
of "obtaining"
IBM and ASUS Claim Construction Comparison
of "predetermined cooling requirement"
CRDX-SIC
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
STATUS
OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
of "varying the rate"
IBM and ASUS Claim Construction Comparison
CRDX-56C
of Preamble
CRDX-57C
Sample Commercial Sales Invoice for ASUS
Notebooks
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
CRDX-58C
Sample Commercial Sales Invoice for ASUS Eee
PCs
Validity
N.Polish
Admitted
-259-
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS
OF
RECEIPT
INTo
EVIDENCE
CRDX-59C
Sample Commercial Sales Invoice for ASUS
VGACards
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
CRDX-60C
Sample Commercial Sales Invoice for ASUS
Motherboards
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
CRDX-62C
Sample Commercial Sales Invoice for ASUS
Servers
Sample Commercial Sales Invoice for ASUS
Barebones Products
CRDX-63C
Madisetti Transcript Excerpt Relating to Exhibit
12 - Pictures of Inspection Computer
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
CRDX-64C
Internal Email Messages Between ASUS
Employees Dated April 27-28, 2006
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
CRDX-65C
Internal Email Messages Between ASUS
Employees Dated March 16, 2005
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
CRDX-66C
Internal Email Messages Between ASUS
Employees Dated April 20, 2007
Validity
N. Polish
Admitted
CRDX-61C
PHYSICAL EXHIBITS:
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
-260-
STATEMENT OF
PURPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS
OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
EXBmIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PURPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS
OF
RECEIPT
INTo
EVIDENCE
CPX-1
CPX-2
CPX-3
CPX-4
CPX-5
CPX-6
CPX-7
CPX-8
CPX-9
CPX-lO
CPX-ll
CPX -12
Configured ASUS Barebones Computer System
('741 Patent}
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
ASUS Ess PC Computer ('741 Patent)
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
Computer System with ASUS Motherboard
('74 1Patent)
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
ASUS Notebook Computer ('741Patent)
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
ASUS Notebook Computer System ('741Patent)
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
Computer System with ASUS VGA Card
('741 Patent)
Infringement
N. Polish
Admitted
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
-261-
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS
OF
RECEIPT
INTo
EVIDENCE
CPX-13
CPX -14
CPX-IS
CPX -16
CPX-17
CPX -18
CPX -19
CPX-20
CPX-21
CPX-22
CPX-23
CPX-24
L-
----
Admitted
ASUS V3-PG33 Barebones Products
Infringement
J.Phinney
ASUS Eee PC Products Related to '829
Infringement
J.Phinney
Not
Admitted
ASUS Notebook Products Related to '829
Infringement
J. Phinney
Not
Admitted
ASUS PSMT-C Server Products
Infringement
J. Phinney
Admitted
ASUS SL-500 Router
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
ASUS WLAN WL-320gE
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
ASUS WLAN WL-320gP
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
ASUS WLAN WL-330gE
Infringement
P. Francis
Not
Admitted
ASUS WLAN WL-SOOg Premium V2
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
ASUS WLAN WL-SOOgW
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
ASUS WLAN WL-520gC
Infringement
P. Francis
Not
Admitted
ASUS WLAN WL-S20gU
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
--- L--
-262-
I
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS
OF
RECEIPT
INTo
EVIDENCE
CPX-2S
CPX-26
CPX-27
CPX-28
CPX-29
CPX-30
CPX -31
CPX-32
CPX -33
CPX-34
CPX -35
ASUS WLAN WL-S66gM
Infringement
Sample Products Received from ASUS
Infringement
ASUS A6K Notebook
Infringement
ASUS MSN Notebook
P. Francis
Admitted
N. Polish
P. Francis
I. Phinney
N. Polish
J. Phinney
Not
Admitted
Infringement
N. Polish
I. Phinney
Not
Admitted
ASUS A 7MIT Notebook
Infringement
N. Polish
I. Phinney
Not
Admitted
ASUS A7VS Notebook
Infringement
N. Polish
J. Phinney
Not
Admitted
ASUS A8T Notebook
Infringement
N. Polish
J. Phinney
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
ASUS GS2 (GS2g) Notebook
Infringement
N. Polish
J. Phinney
Not
Admitted
ASUS A 7K Notebook or ASUS Notebook
Equivalent
Infringement
N. Polish
J. Phinney
Not
Admitted
ASUS PC 904 EssPC
Infringement
N. Polish
J. Phinney
Not
Admitted
-263-
I
i
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CPX-36
CPX37
CPX38
CPX-39
CPX-40
CPX -41
CPX-42
CPX-43
CPX-44
CPX-45
CPX-46
CPX-47
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS
OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
N. Polish
J.Phinney
Not
Admitted
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
N. Polish
J.Phinney
N. Polish
J. Phinney
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Infringement
N. Polish
J.Phinney
Not
Admitted
ASUS VS-P5G9644 Barebones
Infringement
N. Polish
J. Phinney
Not
Admitted
ASUS P3P5G33 (P5K-VM) Barebones or ASUS
barebones equivalent
Infringement
ASUS KFN4-DRE Server
Infringement
Striker Extreme Motherboard
Infringement
ASUS P5LD2 Motherboard
Infringement
N. Polish
J.Phinney
N. Polish
J. Phinney
N. Polish
J. Phinney
N. Polish
J.Phinney
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
ASUS K8V Motherboard
Infringement
N. Polish
J. Phinney
Not
Admitted
ASUS RX 3141 Router
Infringement
P. Francis
Not
Admitted
ASUS PC 1000 EeePC
Infringement
ASUS EAX1550/SILENTITD/256M1A VGA
Card
Infringement
ASUS K8VQ Barebones
Infringement
ASUS P5RD2-VMlDP Barebones
Infringement
ASUS V2-PHI Barebones
-264-
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CPX-48
CPX-49
CPX-50
CPX -51
CPX-52
CPX-53
CPX-54
CPX-55
CPX-56
CPX-57
CPX-58
CPX-59
BATES NUMBER
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
STATEMENT OF
PuRPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS
OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
ASUS P700 EeePC
Infringement
N. Polish
J. Phinney
Not
Admitted
ASUS P701 EeePC
Infringement
N. Polish
J. Phinney
Not
Admitted
ASUS 4G_SURF EeePC
Infringement
Not
Admitted
ASUS 900 EeePC
Infringement
N. Polish
J. Phinney
N. Polish
J. Phinney
ASUS 901 EeePC
Infringement
N. Polish
J. Phinney
ASUS 1000(H) EeePC
Infringement
N. Polish
J. Phinney
ASUS EAX1550 VGA Card
Infringement
N. Polish
ASUS EN8800GT VGA Card
Infringement
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK
ASUS V3-P5G33 Barebones
Infringement
ASUS P5MT-C Server
Infringement
ASUS PrM2-M Server
Infringement
-265-
Not
Admitted
N. Polish
J. Phinney
Not
Admitted
N. Polish
J.Phinney
N. Polish
J.Phinney
Not
Admitted
Not
Admitted
EXHIBIT
NUMBER
CPX-60
CPX-61
CPX-62
CPX-63
CPX-64
CPX-65
CPX-66
DESCRIPTIVE TITLE
BATES NUMBER
STATEMENT OF
PURPOSE
SPONSORING
WITNESS
STATUS
OF
RECEIPT
INTO
EVIDENCE
ASUS P5E Motherboard
Infringement
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
ASUS M2N-E Motherboard
Infringement
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
ASUS 90-MSVAJO-GIDBNOOZ Motherboard
Infringement
N. Polish
Not
Admitted
Macintosh Laptop
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
Macintosh Laptop
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
PC Laptop
Infringement
P. Francis
Admitted
P. Francis
Admitted
Ethernet Cables (4 Blue Cables)
----------
---
Infringement
---
.--
IDM200109
-266-
-
--
I
I
Dated: February 3,2009
Respectfully submitted, ( }
\p~~(Ul- &M'---V. James Adduci II
Michael L. Doane
Patricia Larios
Gregory F. Geary
Katherine Lahnstein-Bertocci
ADDUCI MASTRIANI & SCHAUMBERG LLP
1200 Seventeenth Street, N.W., Fifth Floor
Washington, DC 20036
(202) 467-6300
Christopher A. Hughes
TonyV. Pezzano
James T. Bailey
John T. Moehringer
CADWALADER, WICKERSHAM & TAFT LLP
One Wodd Financial Center
New York, New York 10281-0006
(212) 504-6000
Counsel for International Business Machines Corporation
ffiM200109
-267-
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that a copy of the foregoing COMPLAINANT INTERNATIONAL
BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATION'S CORRECTED FINAL EXHIBIT LIST
(PUBLIC) was served as indicated, to the parties listed below, on this 3rd day of February 2009:
The Honorable Marilyn R. Abbott
SECRETARY
U.S. INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION
500 E Street, S.W., Room 112A
Washington, DC 20436
(VIA HAND DELIVERY - Original + 6 copies)
The Honorable Theodore R. Essex
ADMINISTRATIVE LA W JunGE
U.S. INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION
500 E Street, S.W., Room 317
Washington, DC 20436
(VIA HAND DELIVERY - 2 copies)
VU Q. Bui, Esq.
INVESTIGATIVE ATIORNEY
OFFICE OF UNFAIR IMPORT INVESTIGATIONS
U.S. rNTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION
500 E Street, S.W., Room 401
Washington, DC 20436
(VIA HAND DELIVERY)
COUNSEL FOR RESPONDENTS ASUSTEK COMPUTER, INC.; ASUS COMPUTER
INTERNATIONAL; PEGATRON TECHNOLOGY AND UNIHAN TECHNOLOGY CORPORATION
Brian R. Nester, Esq.
Jeffrey R. Whieldon, Esq.
FISH & RICHARDSON PC
1425 K Street, NW
Washington, DC 20007
(VIA HAND DELIVERY)
John P. Schnurer, Esq.
FISH & RICHARDSON PC
12390 EI Camino Real
San Diego, California 92130
(VIA FEDERAL EXPRESS)
Troy D. Vahidi, Esq.
LA W OFFICE OF TROY D. VAHIDI
578 Sutton Way #252
Grass Valley, California 95945
(VIA FEDERAL EXPRESS)
::P #-4J-~
rucr, MASTRIANI & SCHAUMBERG, L.L.P.
1200 Seventeenth Street, N.W., Fifth Floor
Washington, DC 20036
IBMI00008
UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION
Wa$hlnglon, D.C. :20436
Before the Honorable Theodore R. e..ex
Administrative Law Judge
In The Matter of
Certain Computer Products, Computer Components
And Products Containing Same
Inv.No.
337·TA-tl28
RESPONDENT ASUSTeK COMPUTER. INC•• ASUS COMPUTER INTERNATIONAl..
PEGATRON CORPORATION AND UNIHAN CORP:S FINAL ADMITTEP EXHIBIT UST OF DIRECT, PHYSICAL. DEMONSTRATIVE AND
REBUTTAL EXHIBITS
Statement of
8~tcs
Exhibit #
oilte
RX-l
RX·2
RX·3
RX-4
RX·5
RX·6
RX·7
RX-tI
RX-9
RX·l0
RX-11
RX·12
RX·13
RX·14
RX-15
RX-1S
RX·17C
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
9111/2008 Complainant International Business Machines
NO BATES
Corporation's Second and ThIn! Supplemental and
Amended Responses, Respectlvaly, to
RespOndents Asustek Computer, inC. 's , ASUS
Computer Intematlonars, Pegatron Corporation's
and Unlhan Corporation's Interrogatory Nos. 2 and 4
RX·18
RX-19C
RX-20
RX-21
RX-22
RX-23
RX-24C
Exhlbll DeSCription
WITHDRAWN
913012008 ComIcted Appendix C for the '829 Patent from IBM's NO BATES
Supp\ementattnterroga(ory Responses
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
Witness statement of Kevin Huano
NO BATES
Witness Statement of James Olivier
NO BATES
Sponsoring
\Nltncss
Received Into
EVidence
1112112008
Invall~~y:
NonlnfTlogement
1112112008
InvalIdHy;
Noninfrinaement
Hueng
Olivier
11121/2008
1112112008
Madisetti
1112112008
Stevenson
11121/2008
Stevenson
11121/2008
ASUS_333196
InvalldHy
Stevenson
1112112008
NO BATES
Invalidity
Stevenson
1112112008
NO BATES
Invalidity
Stevenson
1112112008
ASUS_308993ASUS_308996
Invalidity
Stevenson
1112012008
ASUS_332631ASUS_332638
InvalldHy
Stevenson
1112012008
Wllness Statement of ViJay Madisettl
NO BATES
RX-26
Witness Statement of Robert Stevenson
NO BATES
RX-27
312411968 Certified Translation of Japanese Published
Unexamined Patent App. No. 1·241606, Tanabe
Takayuki [2008..()1-25 Stavenson Initial Report
Exhibit 21
Certificate of Translation of Japanese Published
Unexamined Patent App. No. 1-241606, Tanabe
Takayukl
Screen shot of the file properties (metadata) for tho
lranslator certification for Ihe Tanabe reference
RX-29
Purpose
Baci<oround
InvaUdlty;
Nonlnfrinoement
InvalldHy;
Noninfrlngement
Invalidny;
Noninfrlngement
InvalldHy
RX·25C
RX-28
Number
ASUS_332647ASUS_332656
.
!
RX-30
RX-31
I
RX-32
,
I
RX-33
Screen shot of the file plOperlies (metada1a) for the
translation of the Tanabe reference
31711988 Certlfled Translation of Japanese Published
Unexamined Patent App. No. HOI-226012, Aklloshl
Hara [20OB"()1-25 Stevenson Inilial Report exhibit
3f
41711987 U.S. Patent No. 4,656,533. Electronically
Programmable Universal Brushless DC Fan W~
Inlegraltracklng And locked RotorProtedlon, Fred
A. Brown [200B-07·25 Stevenson Initial Report
Exhibit 41
WITHDRAWN
I
I
ESE!‘ WlTHDRAWN
——_§
———
Invalidity
stevenson
1112012008
RX-41
8/2011991 U.S. Patent No. 5,040,377. COOLING SYSTEM
ASU3__316131VWTH IMPROVED FAN CONTROL AND METHOD. ASUS__31B143
James E. Braun [2003-07-25 Stevanson Inltlal
R - it Exttlblt 13
Rx-42
— WITHDRAWN
*—
1 1/20/2008
RX-43
fie/1992 U.S. Patent No. 5,121,291. VENTILATION SYSTEM ASUS_316355Invalidity
liiiflj
RX47
11/7/198: Cenilled Tramtation ol Japanose Published
Unexamined Patanukpp. No. H02-127711. Dovlaa
Coollng System. Kazunorl Klta (2008-07-25
3.
§§
' Certified Translation of Japanese Publlshod
ASUS__332638«
Unexamlnqd Patent App. No. H02-254797. Package ASUS_332642
Cooling Dsvloa. Tadao Tatmhashi [2008-07-25
_
Rx-19
1218/1981 certllled Translatlon of Japanese Published
Asus_332s43Unexamined PatnntApp.No.S$8-99821. Coating ASUS_332B46
Fan Controlling System. Hiroshl Suzuki [2008-07-2
Stevenson lnltlal Re - rt Exnlblt 21
lE?&»i5jj_
Exfijj‘
TO
*
IBM Tecnnlcal Disclosure Bulletin. Vol. 20, No. 8,
IBM Carp. (2008-07-25 Stevanson Initial Repon
-7s
—
—
*2
—
w5%
— ITHDRAWN
0450 — E
— WHDRAWN
axezc
fl THDRAWN
2- -2'
'7?
11/20/2008
E
11l17/200B
%
11l17I2008
i
U!
§3
1 1/20/2008
Exolbllil
RX-B3
D"to
t:Xhlblt
Descnp"tton
Ba~cs
Number
RX-l01
RX·l02
RX-l03
RX-l04
RX-l05
RX·l06
RX-l07
RX-l08
RX-l09
WITHDRAWN
"Variable Air Cooling For Computer Andlor
IBMOOOOO988Electronic Equipment, IBM TeCh DlsCklsure Bulletin, IBMoo000992
Vol. 32, No. lOA, Mar. 1990 12008-07-25 Stevenson
Initial Report ExhlbH 25)
WITHDRAWN
W.L Brogan, Modem Control Theory (1985)
ASUS_320782ASUS 320784
G.F. Franklin, J.D. Powell, A. Emaml-Naelnl,
ASUS_320785Feedback Control of Dynamtc SYstems {f 9861
MUS 320794
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
Petsonal Comput.ar Family Service Infomtation
16Moo18TI46ManuBl 2nd Edition IBM COl'll.
181.100188108
IBM 5160,5155, and 5160 Setvlce Summary, 16M 16Moo188168·
18MOO188475
COI'D.
WITHDRAWN
Enrletto. RA and podhajsky. G., CooHng Control, 16MOOOOOS84IBM Technical DlsclOsUrB Bulletin, Vol. 18, No.6,
181.100000987
IBMCOI'J>.
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
Dr Stevenson's Clniculum Vitae
NO BATES
RX-110
IBM Technical Disclosure Bulletin Vol. 32 No. lOA
RX~C
RX-B5C
RX-B6
RX·87
RX-88
RX-B9
RX·90
RX-91
RX·92
RX-93
RX·94
RX·95
RX-96
RX-97C
RX-98C
RX·99
RX-l0OC
RX·111
RX·112
RX-113
RX·114
RX-115
RX-116
RX-117
RX-118
RX-119
RX-120
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
Patent Abslrads of Japan
9/212008 Documents consIdered for expert report of Vllay K.
Madlsettl regarding InvelldHy 01 U.S. Palen! No.
5,008,829 [2008-07-25 Madlsetll InRIal Report
COlTe(;ted Exhibit AI
Clniculum VItae for Vllay K. Madlsellll2008-07-25
Madlsettl Iniflal Report Exhibil BI
Us! 0( PubUcatlons IIy Viley K. Madlsettll2008-0725 Madisettl InItial Reoort ExhIbit CI
USI of Case$ Vilay K. Madlsettl has signed a
Prolective Order testified aa an expert or has
subml!!ed statements or opinions wtthln the previous
two years 12008-07-25 MadIseW Initial Report
Exhibit 01
WITHDRAWN
21211988 U.S. Patent 4,723,269. Method and Apparatus for
Power·Up of Unattended Computer, Summa"ln.
12006-06-01 Madlselll Rebuttal Report Attachment
IBMOOOQ0988.
IBMOOOOO992
ASUS 315879
NO BATES
Statement of
Purpose
Sponsoring
Witness
00J00I1986
RX-122
00I00I1988
RX-123
00I00I1989
RX-124
00I00I2003
I
IBM PC ConveltllJle Technical Referen~ Manual •
vol. 1, IBM. Seleclad Portions [2008.0&-01 Madlsettl
Rebuttal ReDort Attachment 31"
illingworth, Valerie, The Penguin DldIonary of
E/eclmn/cs. pp. 72, 90, 121, 125, 165, 442 and 522,
Penguin Books 2nd Edition (2008-06-01 MadlseHI
Rebuttal Reoort Attachment 61
Patl<er, Syblll P., McGI'/lw-HilI Dic1fona/)l of
ScJentlllcand Technical TemtS, pp. 839, 1194 and
1730, McGraw·HIII Book Company 4th Edklon [2OOf
08-01 Mad/Hili Rebuttal Report AlteChment 9J
Into
EVljcncc
Invalidity
Stevenson
1112112008
Invalidity
Stevenson
11/20/2008
Invalidity
Stevenson
1112112008
Invalidity
Stevenson: Phan;
Madlsettl
Stevenson: Phan;
Madlletti
1112112008
Invalidity
Stevenson
1112012008
Inv~:~rnt
Nonl
Invalidity
Stevenson
1112012008
Stevenson
11/2012008
Invalldllv~
Stevenson
Madlsedl
1112112008
1112112008
Invalidity
Invalidity
1112112008
NO BATES
Background
Madlsett/
11/2112008
NO BATES
Beckground
MadisetU
1112112008
NO BATES
Background
Madlsetti
1112112008
ASUS_311317ASUS_311326
Invalidity
Madlse!!!
1112112008
IBMoo17976516M00160117
Invalidity
ASUS_33241,ASUS_332428
Invalidity,
Nonlnfrlngement
Madlsettl; E. Ko; G.
Chen; M. Chen; R.
Su;S.Wang
11/2112008
ASUS_332391ASUS_332410
invalidity;
Nonlnfringemant
Madlsettl: E. Ko; G.
Chen: M. Chan; R.
Su;S.Weng
11121/2008
Invalidity;
Nontnfrlngement
Madlsettl; E. Ko; G.
Chen: M. Chen; R.
Su;S.Weng
1112112008
11
RX-121C
Rc~e'ved
NO BATES
Technlcsl Paper - App/yfnfl the lEe and IL 60950
Slaooards 10 Telecommunication TransfOnners.
Tyco Electronics Corp. Selected Portions 120Q8.0601 Madlsettl RebUttal Attachment II)
11/2112008
Durlros. main: 0. Taylor and Tlmolhy E. Franklin
ASUS_310472
—
li5I!Ej_————
———
clrculz. John G. K - lra
ASUS 310119
T"S”‘°'~“‘°“‘*
‘"“°"““’
RX-137
5/29/1990 u.s. Parent 4.930.052. Computer Power Supply wun ASUS_310995lnvalldlly
,
11121/zoos
optically
ASUS__310959
Yamada lsolated Shutdown Clrculls. Masanorl
——
fl
——
——
——
——
IBM PC Convertible Technical Reference , vol. 2.
lBM Corp...
IBM PC Convertible Guide to operations. 1st
Edition, IBM Corp.
Pending Ruling _
on Marion to
Carmel Exhibits
Madlsetll; E. Ko; G. 11121/2008
Chen; M. Chen: R.
lBMOO180392lBMOO180691
[§I§B——
—*
l'i‘I§J— WWHDRAWN
*—*
o9/oo/zoos Morrison. Oavld. ureumeAcMevementAwaru
ASUS_318390lnvalldlty
Madlseltl
11/21/2003
Recipient Robor Mammano . Power Electrorllcs
ASUS_31B393
Techno!
—
—
la Maclnlosh
PC
ASUS 321188
_A
Plctures
of varlousllcxcomponents
01 and related to the ASUS__321122lnvallclrty
Madlsalti; Albln
ASUS 323865
Madlsetli‘ Albln
— MAC llcx ower su 1 measurement
— WlTHDRAWN
—
RX-158C
3lD7IO89
Macintosh llcx: Technlcal Sperziflcations
APPLE 01420-APPLE lnvalidlly
Madlsetll; Albln
01424
MT
233251
RX-160
_ ASUS
ASUS_232974Invalidlty
Madlseltl; Albln
T WFTHDRAWN
—
T
l
WFTHDRAWN
M
—
Asus_321os7Madlsal1l:Albin
A - e Maclmosh ll PC
321121
IBMOO1B0391
- me
Plclures
of various components 01 and related to ASUS
——
—
E3
» Madlselti;Albln
Su
Measurements
ASUS
323860
W1
RX-168
Fujitsu Semiconductor Data Sheet - Swltchlng
ASUS_322354lnvalidily
Madl:el1|;A|bln
Regulator Controller (swllchable bclween push-pull A$US_322379
and sl - Ie-end functions - M83579
RX-168
Manual» Flrsl Edition
ASUS 322685
Motorola Semiconductor Technical Data - M66881 ASUS__322686Technical Summary HCMOS Floallng-Polnl
_
Coprocassor. M6800 Family Releranca Manual
RX-169
Pictures of vwious components of and related to me ASUS_322757A la Maclnlosh II PC
ASUS 322777
11/21/2008
1112112008
1 I/2112008
11/21/zoos
11121/zoos
11r21/2oos
11I21I2008
5' <9.E-<
Madlse1ti;Albln
11/21/2008
lnvalldlty
Msdlselfl: Albln
1 1/21/2008
ExhIbit #
RX·170
RX-171
RX-172
RX-I73
RX-174
RX-175
RX·176
RX-1T7
RX·I78C
RX-I79
RX·180
RX·181
RX·182C
RX·183C
RX·184C
RX-185C
RX·186C
RX-187
RX·188
RX-189C
RX·l90
RX-191
RX-192
RX-193
RX·I9<1
RX-195
RX-I96
RX·197
RX-198
RX-I99
RX-2oo
RX-201
RX-202
RX·203
RX·204
RX-205
RX·.206
RX·207
RX-208
RX-209
RX·210
RX·211
RX-212
RX·213
RX-214
RX-215
RX·21e
RX-217
RX-218
RX·219
RX-220
RX-221
RX-222
'U<-223
'<X-224
,X·225
,X·226
'U<·227
Dale
Exhlb t Des:nptlon
,
<
gates Number
WITHDRAWN
ASUS_318oo2Macintosh Family Hardware Reference, AddisonASUS 318190
Weslev Publishing CompanY, Inc.
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
4J2J1986 IBM AMouncement Letter No. 186-049, IBM 5140 IBMool72436IBMoo172447
PC Convertible Models 2 and 22 IBM 5144 PC
Convertible Monochrome Display Modell IBM 5145
PC COI'Ivertlble Color Disolav Modell
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
IBM 514D Power SuPPly Analysis· Computer Model ASUS_323831·
IBM 5140, SIN 2683100-2s.oo40134, Measurement ASUS_323832
1: +5V Continuous
IBM 5140 Power Supply Analysis· Computer Model ASUS_323833IBM 5140, SIN 26831QO.26-OD4D134, Measurement ASUS_323834
2: PWM Control Signal \I4len Power push Button IS
actuated
IBM 5140 Power Supply Analysis. Computer Model ASUS_323835IBM 5140, SIN 2683100-26-0040134, Measurement ASUS_323838
3: +5V Power SuPPlv Rail
IBM 5140 Power Supply Analysis· Computer Model ASUS_323837·
IBM 5140, SIN 2683100-26-0040134, Measurement ASUS_323838
4: CPU VCIJ \I4len Power Push Button Is actuated
0010011988
IBM 5140 Power SUPPly Analysis· Computer Model ASUS_323839IBM 5140, SIN 2683100.2&OO4D134, Measuremant ASUS_32384D
5: PWM vs. +5V
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
IBM 5140 Power supply PWM measurement
ASUS_324oo1·
ASUS 32<1002
WITHDRAWN
. WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHMAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
Fujitsu Semiconductor Data Sheet· ASSP SwItching ASUS_323074ASUS 323099
Reaulator Controller - MB3T75
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
Statement of
Purpose
,Sponsonng
WltOt:SS
Rec€l\Jed into
Ev denee
Invalidity
MadlseW; Albin
1112112006
Invallditv
Madiselti
1112112006
Invalidity
MadiseW
1112112006
Invalidity
MadiseW
1112112008
Invalidity
Madlsetll
11121/2006
Invalldltv
Madlaeltl
1112112008
Invalidity
Madlsettl
1112112008
InvaUdily
Madisetll
11121/2008
Invalidity
Madlsettl
1112112008
Dole
6I00I1997
ExhrlJit Description
Invalidity
ASUS_320568ASUS 320634
ASUS_320674ASUS 320675
InvalldHy
Madlsettl
1112112008
Invalidity
Madlsettl: Albin
11/2112008
ASUS_320695ASUS 320704
ASUS_323819ASUS 323826
Invalidity
Madlsettl; Albin
11/21/2008
Invalidity
Madlsettl; Albin
1112112008
InvalldHy
Madiselti
11/2112008
InvalldHy
Madlsetti
11121/2008
ASUS_322875ASUS_3229oo
Invalidity
Madlsatti
1112112008
ASUS_324053
InvalldHy
Madlsettl; Albin
1112112008
NO BATES
Background
Madise\1l
11/2112008
ASUS_319657ASUS 319895
Noninfrlngement
MadisaUi
11121/2008
ASUS_332n7.
ASUS 3326S4
ASUS_3328S5ASUS 332904
Invalidity
Madlsettl; Albin
1112112008
Invalidity
Madisettl; Albin
1112112008
IBM00172458IBMOO172480
Invalidity
Madlsattl
11/21/2008
IBM00000906IBM00000925
InvaHdHy:
Noninfrlngement
Madlsettl; E. Ko; G.
Chen: M. Chen; R.
Su; S.Weng
11121/2008
ASUS_170827ASUS 171141
ASUS_'90963ASUS_'91238
Invallldty
MadiseUi
11/2112008
InvatidHy;
Nonlnfrlngement
Madlsettl; E. Ko; G.
Chen; M. Cheri; R.
Su;S. Weng
1112112008
Br,tes Number
Texas Insllument. Data Sheet- Current Mode PWM IBMOOO06165Controller UC1642131415, UC26421314/5 and
IBMOOOO6187
Statement of ,
Recel ve:i Into
Sponsoflng ,
' W,lness
Madiselti
"
E,tllb,t #
RX-228
Purpose
Evidence
1112112008
UC38421314/5
RX-229
RX-230
RX-231
RX-232
RX-233
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
Pictures of IBM 5140
RX-234
Pictures of the back and front of the Macintosh II
comllUfer
WITHDRAWN
Pictures of Mac II
RX-235
RX-236
RX-237C
RX-238
RX-239
RX-240
RX-241
RX-242
RX-243
RX-244
RX-245
RX-246
RX-247
RX-248
RX-249
RX-250
RX-251
RX-252
RX-253
RX-254
RX-255
RX-256
RX-257
RX-258
RX-259
RX-260
RX-261
RX-262
RX-263
RX-264
RX-265
RX-266
RX-267
RX-268
RX-269
RX-270
RX-271
IRX-272
7/17/2008 GraphS measuring signal strengthS of USB ports
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
8131/1994 Philips Semiconductors Data Sheet, Current-mode
PWM controller - UC3B42
5I00I2002
UnHrode Products ~ata Sheet, UC 1642131415
UC2842J314J5 UC3842131415 Current Mode PWM
Controller
WITHDRAWN
00/0011988 Motorola Semiconductor Technical Summary· ,
HCMOS Enhanced Floating-Point Coprocessor MC68882
81812008 Screen Shot of Search Results from \he Federal
Communlc:atlons Commission - OffICe of
Engineering and Technology
WITHDRAWN
Joshua W. Phinney Professional Profile {Phinney
Initial Report APP8Rd1x AI
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
Excerpts from ASUSWortd Catalog Vol. 61 shOwing
KFN4-D16
WITHDRAWN
00100/1989 Macintosh Ik:x Own8l'll Guide - Part 1
00I00I1989
Macintosh 1Ic:.x Owners Guide· Pari 2
WITHDRAWN
IBM Announcement Letter No. 189-107, IBM 5140
PC Convertible Products and Selected Features
WIthdrawal from IBM Marketina
The Wlnn Rosch Hardware Bible
RX·273
RX.274C
RX-275C
RX-276
Motorola Linear and Interface IC's
RX-2n
Hardware Maintenance and Service PelSOnal
Computer AT Vol. 2
~.~---
ASUS_322805ASUS 322813
ASUS_322814ASUS_322822
Exhlbll
n
DOle
Handwritten notes on US 5.008,829
RX-278
RX·279
RX-2BO
RX·281
RX·282
RX·283
RX·284
RX·285
RX·288
RX·2S7
RX·288
RX·2B9
RX·290
RX·291
RX·292
RX·293
RX·294
RX·295
RX·296
RX·297
RX·298
RX·299
RX·300
RX-301
RX-302
RX-303
RX-3Q4
RX-305
RX·306
RX·3D7
RX-308
RX·309
RX-310
RX-311
RX-312
RX-313
RX·314
RX·315
RX·31B
RX·317
RX-318
RX·319
RX·320
RX-321
RX-322
iRX-323
RX-324
RX·325
RX-32&
RX·327
RX·328
RX·329
RX·330
RX·331
RX·332
RX-333
RX·334
RX-335
RX·33&
RX-337
RX-338
RX-339
RX-340
RX-341
RX·342
RX-343
RX·344
RX·345
RX·34&
RX·347
RX·348
R)(.349
Exhibit Descnptlon
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WiTHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN· ADMITTED AS JX·8
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
612912007 GPL Ven;1cn 3
061-11991
GPI. Vel$lon 2
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITl-lDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
[)oCUment Entitled SOCKS by David Kobles and
Michelle Kobles
Bales Number
ASUS_OOOOO5
S'atement of
Purpose
Invalidity;
Noninfringement
Sponsonng
"'illness
Received into
Madlsatli; Ko; G.
Chen; M. Chen; R.
Su;S.Wal1g
1112112008
EVIdence
e.
NO BATES
ASUS_32086!>ASUS 320876
ASUS_320859·
ASUS 320864
1112112008
I.lcenslng
Olivier, Chang
1112112008
Ucenslng
Olivier; Chang
1112112008
I
,
ASUS 2161&8ASUS-216174
Invalidity
Olivier; Koblas
1112112008
Exhibit #
RX-350
RX·351
RX·352
RX-353
RX-354
RX·355
RX-356
RX·357
RX-358
RX-359C
RX-38OC
RX-361
RX·362
RX·363
RX·364
RX-365
RX-366
RX·367
RX-368
RX·369
RX-370
RX-371
RX·372
RX-373
RX-374
RX-375
RX-376
RX-377
RX-378
RX·379
RX-380
RX-361
RX-382
RX·383
RX·384
RX·385
03te
Exhibit DesCnpflon
Bates Number
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WL\\WL330gElboradcomlsrcUinuxlnet\lpv4lneUilter: ASUS_SC27178.
Source Code
ASUS_SC27182;
ASUS_SC27242·
ASUS_SC27270:
ASUS_027341·
ASUS_027347;
ASUS_027378ASUS_027401:
ASUS_027471.
ASUS_027476;
ASUS_027503ASUS_027509;
ASUS_02754oASUS_027572;
ASUS_027572;
ASUS_028077.
ASUS_028104;
ASUS_229128ASUS_229130:
ASUS_22914S·
ASUS_229152;
ASUS_248305ASUS 248337
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
CotI:irldge, Heilig & Slater, "Packet Filtering In an IP ASUS_311407·
Router "LISA V· San Diego CA
ASUS 311412
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
U.S. Patent No. 5.166,931
IBMOOOOI230IBMOOOO1242
WITHDRAWN
Ulman, Ami, The DUNIX 0isIIfbut8d Operating
ASUS_216917ASUS 216206
SYstem Bell Communications Research
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WiTHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
ASUS Annual Report 2007
ASUS_332998ASUS_333174
Statement 01
Purpose
Sponsonng
li'Jitness
Received Into
EVidence
Nonlnlringemen1:
licensing
Olivier, Chang
1112112008
Invalidity
Olivier
1112112008
Nonlnfringement
Olivier
11121/2008
Noninfrlngement;
invalidI1v .
Olivier
1112112008
----
8ackgl'Olmd
Huang
Pending Ruling
on Motion to
Correct Exhibits
RX·386
RX-387
RX·388
!RX·389
RX·390
RX·391
RX·392
RX·393
RX·394
RX·395
RX·396
RX-397
RX·398
RX-399
RX-400
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
Exhibit #
RX-401
RX-402C
RX-403
RX-404
RX-405
RX-406
RX-407
RX-408
RX-409
RX-410
RX-411
RX-412
RX-413
RX-414
RX-415
RX-416
RX-417
RX-418
RX-419
RX-420
RX-421
RX-422
RX-423
RX-424
RX-425
RX-426
RX-427C
RX-428
RX-429
RX-430
RX-431C
O,j+e
-Exhibit Oescnptlon
WITHDRAWN
Exhibit A Assigned Patents - Utility Patents and
IADDlications
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
101111989 Licensa Agreement between IBM and InIal
Corporation
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
612712008 L/cansa Agreament batwean IBM and NVIDIA
Corooratlon
RX-432
RX-433
RX-434
RX-435
R*436'"
RX-437
RX-438
RX-439C
RX-440
RX-441
RX-442
RX-443
RX-444
RX-445C
RX-446C
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
912112007 license Agreement between IBM and Wlnbond
Electronics CorD.
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
5/8/200S BOM_BarebOOes T3-P5945GCX Bia
5I8l2OO6 BOM_BarebOnes Pl-P5945GC
RX-447
RX-448C
WITHDRAWN
712912008 8OM_EEE PC 900
RX-449C
712912008 BOM_EEE PC 901
Bales Number
Statement of
Purpose
Sponsorng
Witness
Received Irto
EVidence
IBMOO172076IBMOO172122
Ownership
Huston
1112112008
IBMOO105096tBMOO105150
licensing
HUtlton
11/17J2008
IBM00237697IBMOO237710
licensing
HU5\on
11/17J2008
IBM00236819IBM00236839
licensing
Hu!;\on
1111712008
ASUS_'92636ASUS_192637
Licensing;
Nonlnfrlngement
1112112008
ASUS_'9264BASUS_I92651
licensing;
Nonlntrfngement
Madiselll;
Slevenson; C. 1<0;
G. Chen; M. Chen;
R. Su; S. Weng; J.
llaw; B. Chen; J.
Dlno
Madlsetti;
Stevenson: E. Ko;
G. Chen; M. Chen;
R. Su; S. Weog; J.
llaw; B. Chen; J.
DIM
ASUS_323544ASUS_323564
Ue&IIslng;
Nonlnfrlngemenl
Madiselll;
Slevenson: E. Ko;
G. Chen; M. Chen;
R. Su: S. Weng; J.
liaw; B. Chen; J.
11/2112008
ASUS_323565ASUS_32358B
Licensing;
Noninfrtngement
Dlno
Madise1li;
Stevenson; E. Ko;
G. Chen; M. Chen;
R. Su; S. Wang: J.
llaw; S. Chen; J.
Olnn
!
1f121J2008
1112112008
Exhibit
~
ExhlOlt Description
Date
Bates Number
Slatemeni of
Purpose
RX-45OC
7/2912008 BOM_EEE PC 1000 ..OGC
ASUS_323257·
ASUS_323279
Weenslng;
NOIIlnfrlngement
RX-451C
7/2912008 BOM_EEE PC 1000 N437
ASUS_323235ASUS_323256
Ueenslng;
Noninfringemenl
RX-452C
7/2912008 BOM_EEE PC 1000H
ASUS_323280ASUS_323302
Ueenslng;
Noninfringemenl
RX-453C
5/812008 BOM_NBF3E
ASUS_'96945ASUS_'96957
Ucensing;
Nonlnfrlngement
RX-454C
5/812008 BOM_NB VX2S 2000
ASUS_'96008ASUS_'96025
UcenSing:
Nonlnfrlngemenl
RX-455C
51812008 BOM_NBVX2S
ASUS_'95988ASUS_'96005
Licensing;
Noninfrlngement
RX-456C
518/2008 BOM_Server RSI61-E5-PA2
ASUS_'98073ASUS_'98074
RX-457C
5/812008 BOM_Seever RS162-E4-RX4
ASUS_,98045ASUS_'98047
RX-458C
518/2008 BOM_Server RS163-C4-RX4
ASUS_'98080ASUS_'98082
518/2008 BOM_Server RS260-E4-RXB
ASUS_'98064ASUS_'96088
RX-46OC
5/812008 80M_Server TS50O-E4-PM
ASUS_19B05B·
ASUS_198060
RX·4B1C
51812008 BOM_Server TS700-E4-RXB
ASUS_'98083ASUS_I980B4
I
RX-462
RX-463
RX-4B4
RX-465
RX-46B
RX-467
WITHDRAWN
WiTHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
Wllness
MadlseHI;
Stevenson; E. Ko:
G. Chen; M. Chen;
R. Su; S. Weng; J.
LIaw; B. Chen; J.
Ding
Madlsetti:
Stevenson; E. Ko;
G. Chen; M. Chen:
R. Su; S. Weng; J.
LIaw; B. Chen; J.
Ding
MadlseHl;
Stevenson; E. Ko;
G. Chen; M. Chen;
R. Su: S. Weng; J.
LIaw; B. Chen; J.
DII'lll
Madisetti;
Stevenson; E. Ko:
G. Chen; M. Chen;
R. Su: S. Weng; J.
Llaw; B. Chen; J.
Dina
Madlsetti;
Stevenson; E. Ko;
G. Chen; M. Chen;
R. Su; S. Weng: J.
Llaw; B. Chen; J.
Dlog
MadlseW;
Stevenson: E. Ko:
G. Chen: M. Chen:
R. Su: S. Weng: J.
Liaw: B. Chen: J.
D!oo
I
RX-459C
• Sponsoring
Medisetti;
Ste.,enson; E. Ko;
G. Chen; M. Chen;
R. Su; S. Weng; J.
Liaw; B. Chen; J.
DII1!I
Licensing;
Medisetti;
Stevenson; E. Ko;
Nonlnfringement
G. Chen; M. Chen;
R. Su; S. Weng: J.
Liaw: B. Chen; J.
Ding
UcenSing;
Madisetti;
NOIIlnfrlngemenl Stevenson; E. Ko;
G. Chen; M. Chen;
R. Su: S. Weng; J.
Llaw: B. Chen; J.
Dina
LiCensing;
MadlseW;
Stevenson; E. Ko;
Nonlnfrlngemenl
G. Chen; M. Chen;
R. Su; S. Weng; J.
Llaw; B, Chen; J.
Ding
LiCensing:
, Medlseltl;
Nonlnfrlngement
Stevenson; E. Ko:
G. Chen; M. Chen:
R. 50; S. Weng; J.
lisw; B. Chen; J.
Ding
MadiseW;
licensing;
Nonlnfrlngement Stevenson; E. Ko:
G. Chen; M. Chen;
R. Su; S. Weng; J.
Llaw: B. Chen; J.
Ding
licensing:
Noninfringemenl
Received Into
EVidence
1112112008
1112112008
1112112008
11/2112008
11/2112008
1112112008
11/2112008
11/2112008
11/2112008
11121/2008
1112112008
111211200B
iX-475
RX-476
tX-477
FtX-478
RX-479
181
!8~
~
1Rx-48SFtX-487
FtX-488
[V(-489
RX-400c-
I
IWiTHe
WITHDF
WITHDF
WITHDRAW
WITHDRAW
\iIIITHDR ....
I WITHDRAWN
IWITHDRAWN
IY\IlllioRAWN
IWIT~
WlTHDI
~~
WITHDRA
..
WITHDRAW ..
WITHDRAW·'
WITHDRAW
51912008IRSI2()'ES BOM
RX-491
. ·RX-492
tX-493
tX-494
FtX-495
",)(-496
IX-497
tX-498C
IWITHDRA'
IWITHDRAV
WITHDRAW
WITHDRAW
WITHDRAW,
WITHDRAW
WITHDRAW
TS700-E4-FtX8 DSBF_DI2_SAS_TS7oo(139553]
ASUS_198023ASUS_198030
I
/\SUS
IASUS-
"V:,
ILlcenslng;
Nonlnflingement
MBdiSetli; E. Ko; G.!
Cllen; M. Chen; R.
Su;S.Weng
\
11/2112008
MadlseUl;
Stevenson; E. Ko;
1112112008
G. Chen; M. Chen;
R. Su; S. Weng; J.
Liaw; B. Chen; J.
DinQ
IRX-499
FtX-6OOC
IWITHDRAWN
411812007 A3H NB
"'Y~""'"
IASUS
!ASUS·
IRX-llOl
!RX.S02C
8/13/20071 EEE PC 2G SL.rf
IFtX.S03
FtX-504C
.u~ 1/
WITHDRAWN
V2-PH2 BB PC
ASUS_030912-
,sus
!ASUS
IRX-505
IWITHDRAWN
",12()'E3 ..erver
IRX-506C
H11I11I111!:ICl11la11l
IASUS_030959
"W'" "'''''
l;,,,,g
ASUS_ov.;;)VU,"t,.,,,,..
ASUS_SCSOOl4845
I
lORA\/)
IDRAVI
IDRAVI
IDRAW
I11C
~
~
IFtX-f
~16C~
I..... u'/~'"
r:sE'Sct'effla.UUi
IASUS
IASUS'
11/21J:ZOO8
I
G.I
11/2112008
I
Madlsettl; E. Ko;
Chen; M. Chen; R.
j:;u;S. Weng
G·I
1112112008
! Madlsetll; E. Ko; G.!
Chen; M. Chen; R.
Su;S. Wang
11/2112008
IMadlsettl; E. Ko; G.I
CIlen; M. Chen; R.
Su;S.Weng
1112112008
!
11/2112008
Madlsettl; E. 1<0;
Chen; M. Chen; R.
Su;S. Weng
INonlnfrlng.
I
I
Llcenslng;
1~.adIseW;
Nonin&&..
1· .. .....
Q~t,;;V~lilUI't E. Ko;
G. Chen; M. Chen;
R. Su; S. Weng; J.
Uaw; 9. Chen; J.
Ding
/AWN
/AWN
/AWN
QI#.';»"'UUQI1UUU"_~
fAsus
IASUS
IFtX-517
LicenSing;
fWl)
G.I
IMadlSetti; E. Ko;
Chen; M. CIlen; R.
:;u;S. Weng
·tI~
j
RX-529C
1/29/2007 KFN5-DR Schematics (RS163-E4-RX4)
ASUS__SCSD026957ASUS_SCSOO27005
ASUS_SCS0028497ASUS_SCS0028539
'
Madlsetti;
Stevenson: E. Ko;
G. Chen: M. Chen;
Madlselti;
Stevenson: E. Ko;
G. Chen: M. Chen;
R. Su; 5. Wang; J.
Llaw; B. Chen: J.
Di -2
Madisem;
Stevenson: E. K0:
G. Chen: M. Chen:
R. Su; 3. Wang; J.
Liaw; B. Chen; J.
Dln
Madisattl:
11I21I2D08
11:21/zooa
1 1/21/2008
R:
SH:B.5.Chen:
Wang;J.J.
Uaw:
Rx‘534c
RS161
ASUS_SC ooo2se4.
A$US__SCS0002649
11l21l200B
[i3I£Ej— WITHDRAWN
———*
—**——
———_fl
E‘J—~*_—
RX-540
_———_
lE!Zij—————
——_——
‘—*——
——_—
::———
——*_—
—_—*
————
—*:_—
Asus 214370
NX .4
Translator Nat:Pmlim1 »= Des
ASUS 214615
'
”""“‘“°""“'“““‘"°“"°“““°’°“
T
“’*"’°°“
Princlles Protocols mdkchhecture
WITHDRAWN
03/-(1988 David R. Cherrlon. ‘The V Distributed System’
Communlcatfions of the ACM. Match 1988. V01. 31
Number 3
ASUS 215772
ASUS_.214541ASUS_2145so
Nonfnlri amwt
j
lnvafldlnr.
Olivier. Chang
11/21/2008
Nomnmngement
Nonin ~« ament
RX-555
- James ouvier. mo. Curriculum Vitae
Invanany,
11/21/2003
l3Jj
JJJj
RX-557
J WITHDRAWN
j
RX-558
WITHDRAWN
*
I531-£jj
JJJj
j
RX-561
J W1THDRAWN
j
Exhlilit #
RX·562
RX·553
RX·564
RX-565
Date
Exhibit Dcscnplion
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
Pictures of Mee computers
RX-566
Pictures of Alarl Slacy
RX-567C
RX-568C
WITHDRAWN - ADMITTED AS JX·34C
SdlemaUcs (Hinojosa Depo ExhibH 10)
RX-569C
RX-57OC
RX-571C
RX-572C
RX-573
RX-514
RX-515C
RX-516
RX-5nC
RX·578
RX-579
RX-56OC
RX-581C
RX-582C
RX-553C
RX·587C
RX-588C
Schematics (Hinojosa Depo Exhlbll33)
RX-565C
RX-586C
RX·569C
Schematics (Hlnojose Depo ExhlbH 34)
RX-59OC
Schematics (Hinojosa Depo Extllbft 35)
RX·691C
Schematics (Hinojosa Depo Exhlbll36)
RX-592C
Sdlennallcs (Circuit diagram) (Hinojosa Depo
exhibit 371
Schematics Hinojosa Oepo Exhibit 38
Handwritten Notel (Hinojosa Depo Exhlb1139)
RX-593C
RX-594C
RX-595
RX-596
RX·597
RX·598
RX·598C
RX-600C
RX-501
RX-602
RX-603C
ASUS_320635ASUS 320658
ASUS_320706ASUS 320731
18M_239055IBM 2390S4
Engineering Change Hlslory (Hinojosa Depo exhibit 18M_239492 to
III
IBM 239511
Handwritten Nctes (Hinojosa Cepo Exhibit 12)
18M_23922DIBM 239250
SchemaUcs (Hinojosa Dapo ExhibH 13)
18M_237642·
IBM 237661
Schematics (Hinojosa Depo Exhibit 14)
18M..237662IBM 237663
Photo {Hno'osa DeDO ExhibH 15
ASUS 333197
WITHDRAWN
Handwritten Notes (Hinojosa Oepo Extllblt 17)
18MOO239251 18MOO239285
Handwritten Notes (Hinojosa Oepo Exhibi118)
18MOO23928618MOO239352
Handwrllten Notes (Hinojosa Oepo ExtllbI119)
18M00239353 18MOO239430
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
Engineering Specifications Reference {Hinojosa
18MOO237620 DeDO exhibit 25'1
IBMOO237B30
Engineering Specifications Referenee (Hinojosa
IBMOO239474DaPO Exhlbll26)
18MOO239491
Engineering Specillcatlons Referenee (Hinojosa
IBMOO239456Oepo Exhlbll 27)
IBMOO239473
Engineering Specifications Referenee (Hinojosa
OePO Exhibit 28)
engineering SpecIf1cauons Reference (Hinojosa
DePO Exhlbll29)
Englneenng Specifications Reference (Hinojosa
DeDO Exhibit 30\
Engineering Specifications Reference (Hinojosa
DePO Exhibit 31)
Item/BOM Report (HinOjosa Depo Eldllbll 32)
RX-584C
Bates Number
WITHDRAWN
Sept, 14-16, UNIX Security Symposium III
1992
About the natfllterllptables project
WITHDRAWN
Complainant Intematlonal Business Machines
Corponrtlon's Supplemental Responses to
Respondents Asustek Computer, Inc:$ ASUS
Computer Intematlonal's, pegatron Corporation's
and Unihan Corporation's Interrogatory Nos, 116,
1011712008 119-121
Letter frOm Nester 10 Pezzano re acceptance of
IBM's offer to produce Huston as a 3O(b)(6)
911712008 dePOnent
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
Spllf1re xSeries Streaming Appliances OSSC
Review
18MOO239529 'BM00239540
IBM0023956!1IBM00239581
IBM00239541IBM00239550
18M0023958218M00239593
IBMOO237631IBMOO237636
RETAlNE08Y
COUNSEL
IBM00239551IBM00239552
IBMOO239553'BMOO239568
18M00237638IBM00237641
NO BATES
Statement 01
Purpose
Spor.so'lng
Witness
Received Into
EVidence
InvalidHy
Madlsettl; Albin
11/2112008
InvalldHy
Madiselll
1112112008
InvalldHy
Madlselll
11121/2008
11/2112008
InvalidHy
Madisettl
11/2112008
Invalidity
Madlsetli
11/2112008
Invalidity
MediseHI
1112112008
Invalidity
Madisettl
1112112008
Invalidilll
Madlselll
11/2112008
Invalidity
Medlselll
11/2112008
Invalidity
Madisalll
1112112008
Invalidity
Madlsattl
11121/2008
fnvalldlly
Madlsettf
1112112008
Invalidity
Madlsetll
11121/2008
Invalidity
Madlsatll
Pending Ruling
invalidity
Madisettl
on Motion to
Correct E>ihibit.
1112112008
Invalidity
Madisettl
11/21/2008
Invalidity
Madisetti
1112112008
invalidity
Madlsettl
1112112008
Invalidity
MadiseUI
11/2112008
InvalldHy
Madlsattl
1112112008
Invalidity
MadlselU
11/2112008
InvalidHy
Madise"1
11121/2006
Invalidity
Madisettl
1112112008
Invalidity
Madlaelll
1112112008
IBM00237664
IBM00239431IBMOO239455
Invalidity
Invalidity
Madisetti
Msdiset11
11/2112008
11/2112008
ASUS_335975ASUS 3359n
ASUS_335978ASUS 335983
Invalldlly
Olivier
1112112008
InvalldHy
Olivier
11121/2008
N08ATES
Nonlnfrinoement
Olivier; Frve
NO BATES
OINnershln
Huston
IBM00276255IBM00278263
Licensing;
Nonlnfringemenl
Huston, Frye
Pending Ruling
on Motion to
Correct Exhibits
1112112008
Pending Ruling
on Motion 10
Correct Exhibits
RX-S04C
IBM00279«8IBMOO2794n
RX-SOSC
RX-606C
911512001
RX·607C
8/412004
Email from Daniel Frye to Huizenga and McKenney IBMOO33OS35ueation abOut Andlea's code ...
IBM003305'38
Ie another
Huston F e
IBMOO535252·
N.M. Donofrio Remarks LlnuxWorid San Francisco IBMOO535275
K
RX-S08C
Licensing;
Noninfrl ement
onV2REAOME
IBMOO541634IBMOO541970
,Licensing;
Nonlnfrln
IBMOO543143IBM00543569
RX-609C
RX-Sl0
Pending Ruling
on Mocion to
C"",,CI Exhibits
Pending Ruling
on Motion to
Corm:! Exhibit,
Pending Ruling
on Motion to
Conect Exhibits
Peoding Ru ing ,
on Motion to I
Conect Exhibits
Pending Ruling
on Motion to
Correct Exhibit'
Pending Ruling
on Moritln to
Correct Exhibits
1112112008
RX·611C
9/1712008
NO BATES
Ownershl
Huston
RX·612C
9/1612008
Ownershl
Huston
RX·613
05I00I1987
NO BATES
ASUS325196ASUS325927
1112112008
11121/2008
11/2112008
RX-S14
1~-615L~_
ISMOO17976SIBM001B0117
Invalid
Madlsettl
Invalidity
Madlse1ti
11/2112008
UNITED STATES INTERNATlOI'lAL TRADE COMMISSION
W.shlnEton. D.C.lo.c36
Before the Honorable Theodore R. Euu
Admlnlslrati.e Law Judge,
I. tloeM._or
Cortaio Computer Prod.cts.Comp_ Compooe...
• tNt Pnduct. Cphllnina S.mt
1ft•• No.
331·1MlI
2~
UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20436
Before the Honorable Theodore R. Essex
Administrative Law Judge
)
)
)
)
)
Inv. No.
337-TA-628
RDX-053
RDX-054
DX-055
Stevenson
Stevenson
Stevenson
CiX-Os6
5X-057
5x:1i58
Rox:059
~.-------
::;;tAvAn!;1'V1
RDX-060
RDX-061
RDX-062
RDX-063
ROX-064
RDX-065
RDX-066
RDX-067
RDX-068
111?Ol?OOA
hnnMR
11/2012008
1112012008
.11@@Jl6
ox::ii69
11/20120C
""1'1i2OriOc
""1'1i2OriOc
""1'1i2OriOc
DX-070
DX·071
6X-072
i5'X-073
'i5X-074
1112012008
1112012008
1112012008
11/2012008
11/20/2008
1112012008
11120/2008
11/2012008
11/20/2008
1112012008
11/20/2008
DX-075
RDX-076
RDX-077
RDX·078
RDX-079
RDX·OBO .
RDX-081
RDX-082
RDX·OB3
Ri5x:ii84
Ri5X-Os5
:ox:Oe6
:ox::Os7
lDx·oee
mx::Oe9
IRD)(-090
[RDX-091
IRDX-092
[RDX-093
IRDX-:::094
111701:>OOR
11120/2008
11/2012008
11120/2008
WITHDRAWN
'liN
ItYITt-I[)RAWN
'liN
IBt;lX.095
[RDX-Q9Et
I WITHDRAWN
1R5)(..Q97
[WITHDRAWN
IWITHORAW
IVVUI1L1HAW
IRDX-D98
IROX-D99
RDX·l0C
ROX·101
RDX·102
OX-l03
5)(-104
OX·10!
[)l<
11/2012008
11/2012008
11120/2008
1112012008
1112012008
11120/2008
1112012008
1112012008
11/20/2006
fN
[WITHDRAW
IWITHORAW
IWITHDRAW
[WITHDRAWN
IWiTHDRAWN
ROX-l0;
RoX-1oi
Ri5'X-'1'ii
Ri5X-11o
11120/2008
1112012008
11120/2008
IRDX-l11
RDX-112
'RDX·113
111?0I200A
1112012008
1112012008
1112012008
)x:11'4
5X-'1'15
)X·116
)X-117
!RDX-118
RoX-119
~
ROX-121
RDX·122
741741
741·
741741741·
H1~
11/20/2008
11/2012008
,"'(
~
EX'1Iblt#
RDX-123
ROX-124
RDX-125
RDX-126
RDX-127
RDX-128
RDX-129
RDX-130
RDX-131
RDX-132
RDX·133
RDX-134
RDX-135
RDX-138
RDX-137
RDX-138
RDX-139
RDX-140
RDX-14l
RDX-142
RDX-143
RDX-144
RDX-145
RDX·14S
RDX-147
RDX-148
RDX-149
RDX-150
RDX-151
RDX-152
RDX-153
RDX-1S4
RDX·1SS
RDX·1S6
RDX-1S7
RDX·158
RDX-1S9
RDX·1S0
RDX-1S1
RDX-1S2
RDX-163
RDX·l64
RDX-1S5
RDX-168
RDX-167
RDX-166
RDX-1S9
RDX·170
RDX-171
RDX·112
RDX-113
RDX-174
RDX·115
RDX-176
RDX·ln
ROX·17S
ROX-179
RDX·1aO
RDX·181
RDX·182
RDX·183
RDX·184
ROX·1a5
RDX-1S6
RDX-167
RDX·166
ROX-169
RDX-190
RDX-191
RDX-192
RDX-193
Date
Exhibit Description
741 • Demonstrative
741- Demonstrative
741 • Demonstrative
741 - Demonstrative
741 - Demonstrative
741 - Demonstrative
741 • Demonstrative
741 - Demonstrative
741 • Demonstrative
741 - Demonstrative
741 - Demonstrative
741 - Demonstrative
741 - Demonstrative
741 - Demonstrative
741 - Demonstrative
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WlTIiDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
Bates Number
Statencent of Purpose
Sponsonnr. Witness
Received Into EVidence
11/2012006
1112012008
11120/2006
1112012006
11/2012008
1112012006
11120/2006
1112012008
11120/2006
11120/2008
1112012006
1112012008
1112012006
11120/2008
11120/2008
DX=194
Dx:19'5
WITHDRAW~
:0)(';196
W\THORAW~
:O~-197
RAM
OX-198
ROX-199
ROX-200
iCRAM
RAM
.wx:201
Olivier
1))(:202'
i'5iiVJ8r'
ox:203
tOX-204
tOX-205
~
Olivier
Olivier
Olivier
Olivier
~DX-207
[Olivier
~
~
Olivier
0iiVi8r
DX-21ii
~
iX-213
IT14
ler
5X-219
mx:22O
mx:221
mx:222
ier
~-231
!32
133
134
18r'
ier
I-I
1852-!
rnx::m
t:23O
11121/200tf
11/2112008
1112112006
1112112008
11121/2008
11/2112008
1112112008
11121/2008
11/21/2008
iSr
ox:218
fOX.:22B
.. '(':.229
:>Iivler
~
DX-217
~
~
11/2112008
11/21/2008
5iiVier
5iiVier
ox:z16
ti5X:224
~
iSr
.~
li5X:225
ier
ler
i2=i
ier
fer
12-1
852-1
852-1
852-J
852·
852852852,
8521652-
Ivler
ivier"
ivier"
ivier"
ier
ier
~
ier
i2-"
135
i2-'
OX-23S
12-1
:ox::23ii"
0X-239
QX:'24O
52!-
:ox::m
ier
ler
fer'"
i6r"'
5iiVi'8r
5iiVi'8r
5iiVier'
5iiVi'8r
i2-'"
5X-241
0x:242
ox::243
ox:244
)lIvier
Olivier
IRDX-247
15'iiV'ier
"SiMer
5iliiier
5iliiier
Olivier
852 - Demonstrative
1112112006
11121/2008
11/2112008
11/2112008
11/2112006
1112112008
11/2112008
11/2112008
1112112008
11121/2008
11/21/2008
11/21/2008
i17.21'i2i
i1'i21i'2i
'11i2i'i2(
w:
:>fivier
RQx:245
Ri3X-24B
Ri5X-249
"'11i21i2O
2008
1112112008
11/21/2008
11/21/2008
1112112008
11121/2008
11121/2008
1112112008
1112112008
11/2112006
Olivier
Olivier
~
RDX-250
IRDX-251
11/2112008
11/21/2008
11/21/2001)
11/2112005
11/2112008
1112112008
1112112008
1
652 -",.."
1~~~~~gI
r°tivler
111,,114\J\JtS
!852 - Ut:IIKJII~uauvt:
[llcenSlng/·
iOllvier
1112112008
IROX-254
[852 - Demonstrative
1~~~I~gl
[Olivier
11/2112008
IROX-255
1852 - 1
IU(..itUi:5lr.'",
Olivier
11121/2008
I.RDX-256
~... LltJUKJlt:Ii\l ctuva
i~neinnl
IOliVier
11/2112008
fRDX-i57
[852'
,llcel'l!llnoi
IOllvler·
IU"ULVUD
Exhbl\#
081e
Exhlbl\ De,cnp\lon
RDX·258
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·259
852 • Demonstrative
RDX·260
852 • Demonstrative
RDX-26t
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-282
852 • Demonstrative
RDX-283
852 • Demonstrative
RDX·264
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·265
852 - Oemonstrative
ROX·266
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·267
852 • Demonstrative
RDX-268
852 • Demonstrative
RDX.269
852 • Demonstrative
RDX-270
852 • Demonstrative
ROX-271
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-272
852 • Demonstrative
RDX·273
852 • Demonstrative
RDX-274
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·275
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-276
852 - Demonstrative
ROX·277
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·278
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·279
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-280
852 • Demonstrative
RDX-281
852 • Demonstrative
RDX-282
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-283
852 • Demonstrative
RDX·284
852· Demonstrative
ROX-285
RDX-286
RDX·287C
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
852 • Demonstrative
RDX-288C
852 - Demonstrative
ROX-289
852 • Demonstrative
ROX-290
852 - Demonstrative
ROX-291
B52 • Demonstrative
ROX·292
852· Demonstrative
RDX-293
852 • Demonstrative
Bates Number
Statement of Purpose
Licensingl
Nonlnfrinaement
Licensingl
Nonlnfrin()ement
Licensing!
Nonlnfringement
Licensing!
Noninfrinaement
Licensingl
Nonlnfrinaement
Licensingl
NonlnfrinQement
Llcenslngl
Noninfrlnaement
Licensing!
Noninfrinaement
Licensingl
NonlnfrinQement
Licensing!
NOninfrinaement
Licensing!
Noninfrinaement
Licensing!
Noninfrlngement
Licensing!
Nonlnfrinoement
Licenslngl
Noninfrinaement
Licensingl
NOninfrinaement
Licensing!
Noninfringement
Licensing!
Noninfrinaement
Licensing!
Noninfrin()ement
Licensing!
Noninfrinaement
Licensing!
NoninfrlnQement
Licensing!
Nonlnfrlngement
Licensing!
Nonlnfrlnaement
Licensing!
Nonlnfrlngement
Licensing!
Nonlnfringement
LIcensing!
NoninfrlnQement
Llcensingl
Noninfrlngement
LIcensing!
NoninfrillClement
Licenslngl
NoninfrinQement
licensing!
Nonintrtrlgement
licenSing!
Noninfrinoement
Licensing!
Noninfrinaement
Ucensing!
Noninfringemenl
LIcensing!
Nonlnfringement
Ucensing/
Noninfrinaement
Sponsoring Wllness
~ecelved Inlo Ev,del1c
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
11/2112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
11121/2008
Olivier
11121/2008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
11~112oo8
Olivier
11121/2008
Olivier
11121/2008
Olivier
11/2112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
11/2112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
11/2112008
Olivier
11/2112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
11121/2008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
11/2112008
Olivier
11/2112008
Olivier
11/21/2008
Olivier
11/21/2008
Olivier
11/2112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
11/2112008
Olivier
11121/2008
Olivier
11/211200B
OUvier
11/2112008
•
•
-
Exhibit 1/
RDX·294
Dale
Exhlb,1 Descnphon
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·295
852 • Demonstrative
RDX·296
852 • Demonstrative
RDX·297
852 • Demonstrative
RDX·298C
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-299C
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·3OOC
852 • Oernonstrative
RDX.301
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·302
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·303
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·304
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·305
852 - Oernonstrative
RDX-306
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·307
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-308C
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·30ge
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·310
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-311
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·312
852 • Demonstrative
RDX·313
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-314C
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-315
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-316C
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-317C
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-318C
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-319C
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-320C
852 • Oernonstrative
'RDX-321C
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-322C
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-323
852 • Demonstrative
RDX-324
852 - Oernonstrative
RDX·325
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·328C
852 • Demonstrative
RDX-327C
852 - Demonstrative
RDX·328C
852 - Demonstrative
__L
Bales Number
0
Statement of Purpose
Licensingl
Noninfrirmement
Licenslngl
Noninfrinaement
Licensingl
Nonlnfrinaement
Licensing!
Noninfrinaement
Licensingl
Nonlnfringement
licensing!
Nonlnfringement
Licensing!
Nonlnfrlnaement
Licensing!
Nonlnfrinaement
Llcensingl
Noninfrinoement
Llcensingl
Noninfrlngement
Licensing!
Noninfrinaement
Licensing/
Nonlnfrlnaement
Llcensingl
Naninfrirmement
Licensing!
Noninfringement
licensing!
Noninfrinaement
Licensing!
Nonlnfrlnaement
Licensing/
Noninfrlnaement
licenslngl
Nonlofrtnaement
Llcensingl
Noninfrlngement
Llcensingl
Noninfringement
Licensing!
Noninfringement
Llcensingl
Noninfrirmement
licensin91
Nonlnfringement
Llcensingl
Nonlnfrinaement
Licensing!
NoninfrinQement
Licensing!
Noninfrirmement
Ucensing!
Noninfringement
Ucensing!
Noninfringement
Licensing!
Noninfringement
Ucensingl
Noninfrinaement
Ucensing!
Noninfrirmement
Licensing!
Noninfrinaement
Licensing!
Noninfrlnaement
Llcenslngl
Noninfrlnaement
Ucensingl
Noninfringement
Sponsoring Witness
Olivier
Received Into EVldenc
1112112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
11121/2008
OliVier
1112112008
Olivier
1112112008
OliVier
1112112008
Ollvfer
1112112008
Oiivier
1112112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
11/2112008
Onvier
11/21/2008
OUvier
11/21/2008
OUvier
11/2112008
Olivier
1112112008
OliVier
1112112008
OliVIer
11121/2008
Onvier
11/21/2008
Olivier
1112112008
Oiivier
1112112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
11121/2008
Olivier
11121/2008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
1112112006
Olivier
11121/2008
Olivier
11121/2008
Olivier
11/21/2008
Olivier
11121/2008
Olivier
11/21/2008
Exhibit #
Date
Exhibit Descnpllon
RDX-329C
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-330C
852 • Demonstrative
RDX-331C
. 852 - Demonstrative
RDX-332C
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-333C
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-334
852 • Demonstrative
RDX-335C
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-336C
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-337C
8S2 • Demonstrative
RDX-33Be
852 - Demonstrative
RDX-339
RDX-340
RDX-341
RDX.342
RDX-343
RDX-344
RDX-345
RDX-348
RDX·347
RDX-348
RDX-349
RDX-350
RDX-351
RDX-3S2
RDX-3S3
RDX·354
RDX-3SS
RDX·3S6
RDX-3S7
RDX-3S8
RDX-3S9
RDX-360
RDX-361
RDX-362
RDX-3S3
RDX·364
RDX-365
RDX-386
RDX-3S7
RDX·36B
RDX-3S9
RDX·370
RDX-371
RDX-372
RDX-373
RDX-374
RDX·375
RDX-378
RDX-377
RDX-378
RDX-379
RDX-380
RDX·381
RDX-382
RDX-383
RDX·3B4
RDX-38S
RDX-386
RDX-387
RDX-388
RDX-389
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
Bates Ntlmber
Stateme~t
Of Purpose
Licensingl
Nonlnfriru:lement
Licensingl
Nonlnfrtngement
Licensing(
Nonlnfrlngement
Licenslngl
Noninfrlngement
Licensingl
Nonlnfrlnaement
Licensing(
Nonlnfrinaement
Licenslngl
Noninfringement
Licensing(
Nonlnfrlnaement
Licensingl
Noninfringement
Licensingl
Noninfrlnaement
-
Sponsonng Witness
Olivier
ReceIVed Ir.to EVldenc
11/2112008
Olivier
11121/2008
Olivier
11/2112008
Olivier
11121/2008
Olivier
11/21/2008
Olivier
11/2112008
OIMer
11/21/2008
Olivier
1112112008
Olivier
11/2112008
Olivier
11/21/2008
Exhblt q
RDX-390
RDX-391
RDX-392
RDX-393
RDX-394
RDX-395
RDX-396
RDX-397
RDX-398
RDX-399
RDX-400
RDX-401
RDX-402
RDX-403
RDX-404
RDX-405
RDX-406
RDX-407
RDX-408
RDX-409
RDX-410
RDX-411
RDX-412
RDX-413
RDX-414
RDX-415
RDX-418
RDX-417
RDX-418
RDX-419
RDX-420
RDX-421
RDX-422
RDX-423
RDX-424
RDX-425
RDX-426
RDX-427
RDX-428
RDX-429
RDX-430
RDX-431
RDX-432
RDX-433
RDX-434
RDX-435
RDX-438
RDX-431
RDX-438
RDX-439
RDX-440
RDX-441
RDX-442
RDX-443
RDX-444
RDX-445
RDX-446
RDX-441
RDX-448
RDX-449
RDX-450
RDX-451
RDX-452
RDX-453
RDX-454
RDX-455
RDX-456
RDX-457
RDX-458
RDX-459
RDX-460
Date
Exhibit DC5cllption
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 • Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 • Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
Bates Number
Statement of Purpose
Invafldilv
Invalidity
Invallditll
Invalldltll
Invallditll
Invaliditll
InvalldHII
Invaliditv
Invallditv
Invalidilv
Invalidltll
Invalidilv
Invaliditv
Invallditv
Invaliditll
Invallditv
Invaliditv
Invalidilv
InvalidItY
Invalldllv
Invaliditv
Invalldllv
Invalldllv
llivallditv
InvalidItY
Sponsonng Witness
Inva/ldllv
Madisetfi
Madlsetfi
Madisetll
Madisetll
Madisetll
Madlsetli
Madisetll
Madisetfi
Madisetfi
Madisetti
Madisetti
Madiselli
Madisetfi
Madisetli
Madisel\l
Madiseltl
Madlseltl
Madiseltl
Madisetli
Madlselti
Madlseltl
Madlsetti
Madlsettl
Madlselli
Madisetli
Madlsetfi
Invaliditv
Invalidilv
Invalidllv
Invaliditv
Invalidilv
Invaliditv
I!1vslidilv
Invalidity
Madlsetfi
Madisetll
Madisetfi
Madlselli
Msdisetfi
Madlsetli
Madisetfi
Madlsetfi
RCcclved Into EVidence
1112112008
11/2112008
11/21/2008
1112112008
11121/2008
1112112008
1112112008
11/21/2008
11/2112008
11/21/2008
11/2112008
11/2112008
1112112008
1112112008
11121/2008
1112112008
11121/2008
11121/2008
11121/2008
1112112008
11121/2008
11121/2008
1112112008
1112112008
1112112008
1112112008
1112112008
11121/2008
11121/2008
11/21/2008
11/21/2008
1112112008
11121/2008
11/2112008
—
Madisetli
— Invaxidn
Madlsetfi
* lnvalidi
Madisem
—
Madxsem
_
Madlsefli
‘
Madisatfi
— lnvalidi
Madisetti
—
Madisetfi
l1mfiIEE’— Madlsetti
Invalid!
Madisetti
Madssem
validi
Madisetfl
validi
Madlsem
valid!
Madlsetti
nvalldl
Madisetti
va!id'
Madlsattl
nvalid‘
Madlsafli
nvalidl
Madxseni
rwalidl
Madisetfl
j
Madlsetti.
j
lmmj Madlsem
j
Madlsetti
j
Madisefli
1112112008
T
Madisetti
' - ‘.1121/2006
j
Madisettl
jj Madisettl
jjmmmj Madisett!
jj
jj
jjlmmj
jj
—:!nvaIIdit
j
jjmmmj
jj
jTmmj
jjlmmj
jjmmmj
jjmmmj
jTmm'j
jj lnvalidi
jjlmmj
j
jj
jj nnvauus
jjmmmj
jjmmmj
jjmamj
j
jTmm1'j
jjmmjmmi
jj Invauua
jjmmmvj
jTmIm'j
jj Invalid
j
jjlmmj
jj
jTlmE1I?j
;32
829829829829 - D
IRDX-5~
RDX-I';'
lOX-
"nva
I . ,"'"'
11121/2008
11/21/2008
Madisetti
1112112008
rMa.
11/21/2008
11/21/2008
11/21/2008
11/21/2008
11121/2008
11/21/200
11/21/200
11/21/2008
11/21/2008
11/21/2008
va
OX·
ox:!
DX-~
\.4,,1'1; ....111
i5X-f
IROX-540
RDX-541
Inve
Invalidl
)X':542
5X-543
iriVaiidi
ox:544-j
mstrative
Invalidity
'nvalidity
Invalidity
invalidity
1~Vallditv
''''''V'"t1
iX=547
»<=548
~
5X
In
Invalldl
ROX-551
RDX-552
ROX-553
ROX·554
J:1n"
I~I~
1112112001
u;ru-;:
11/2112001
1112112001
11/2112008
11/2112008
Madlsetll
Vj;ufJ~oft.+t·
1112112008
11/21/2008
111211200"
Aad'...... '
m
Invalidity
Invall,'"
~rt!'
~
IROX-55:
.. n.a.1
.-
829-
ROX-55a
Ri5X-559
.,0
IRDX-560
BPX-SS1
--
IrwalldiiV
IInvalid
,Dve
tlve
Madisetti
-
1829
!-
1-
X-565
)X-566'
B297
i?9-'
"1
~
ltive
five
--
829
-n
1829~-
ij:'
r.:-
j;rli
..:112008
1112112008
11/21/2008
11/21/2008
Inval
829 - Demonstrative
~=:-_r-___.f8~29~ .. nA""l'\ne.fr!:iIIfJuo
'O~l:t .. LJ~mu'I:;~iCI!~~
"1
r;;;;
-3,11?1/?nnA:
1adise'"
~
1
11i21i2Ooo
11/2'
....:ug:
A"r11
11121
=
\v~IUoI"
Ova
~
iVi3
M:uiicAt
·n~,.j
lad;'"
I
RDX-59.
RDX-593
RDX-594
Invalidity
nvalldlty
Invalidity
'nvalidity
,val'rl''''
I
mx:5s5
h,_
RDX-596
~
"Ro'X-'59
1829-
RDX·
RDX-60C
RDX-a01
RDX-602
629329·
329-
I
'?Il
i
InvaHriH
~
I Invalidity
Iinvalidi!)
Invalirfih
"1
.U
A~l'Ile.At1
11/2112008
11/2112008
11/21/2008
11121/2008
11/21/;
111211;
11i21i2008
11/21/2008
11121/2008
'fii21i2i
1112112008
11/21/2008
11/2112008
11/2112008
11/21/200"
11121/20C
11/21/20C
11121/2008
11/21/2008
RDX
RDx
RDx
RDx
RD)(
RD)( -609
RO)c -610
RO)c :-611
RO}( -612
RD)( -613
IX-I
-614
~ -515
IX-E
-616
~:-617
~:-818
IX -619
iX -620
IX-I
-621
!RDX-622
lx-I·623
IRDX.-624
Wx-o""
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829· Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829· Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 - Demonstrative
829 • Demonstrative
829· Demonstrative
... i._._ ......... _.
Invalidi
Invalldl
Invalldl
Invalidi
Invalldi
Invalidity
IX-626
IX-627
;x::mix:629
IRDX-530
IX-631
(RDX-633
<-634
(.635
~
c:e37
)X-638
;x::639
~
)X-541
829·
829829- n
829829WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
AWN
THDRAWN
THORAWN
~~43.
RDX-644
RDX-645
(RoX-64El
fRDX-64;
IRDX-648
(RD~49
IX-65C
RDX-651
ROX-l:
lX-E
ROX-E
)X-(
>X-E
)X-657
)X-658
ROx::659
ROX-(
~
!OX-(
!OX-l
DX-664
~OX-El65
OX-666
OX-667
DX-6El8
(ROX-ElEl9
IRDX-6;
RDX-671
RDX-672
IRDX-87~_
Invalldi
IInvalidi
Invalidity
Invalidity
Invalidi
Invalidi
Invalidity
Invalidity
Invalid
Invalidi
Invalidl
Invalidi
Invalidi
Invelld
Invalid
Invalidi
Invalidi
Invalldi
Invalidi
Invalidl
Invalldl
Invalidi
,Invalidity
,lnvaNdity
InvaNdi
Invalidi
Invalldi
Invalldi
Invalldi
Invalidi
Invalidl
IWITHDRAWN
IWITHDRAWN
(WITHDRAWN.
(WlItlPRl'oJ'llN
I WITHDRAWN
IWITHDRAWN
IWITHPRl'oW~
IWITHORAM
IWITHORAI/\
IwrrHDRA';1
IIJI!ITHORAIfI
IWIT.1"IPBAWN
IWITHDRAWN
IWlTHD~\:'I
~H()RA"
JWlTHORAV
TWITHDRAWN
IWITHDRAWN
iWITHpRAWN
IWITHDRAWN
IQRJ\WN
~WN
IDRAWIi
HUKAWN
WITHDRAWN
11/2112008
11/2112006
11/2112008
1112112008
11/2112008
1112112008
11/21/2008
Madisetli
Madisetli
Madisetli
Madlselli
Madisetti
Madlsetli
Madisetti
Madlsetli
Madisell
Madiselli
Madi58
Madi5et1i
Madlsetti
Madise'
Madlse
Madlsetli
Madisetli
Madise
Madiselti
Madisetti
Madiselli
MadiseH
MadiseH
Madlsell
MadiseH
Madisett
Madisetti
Madiseffi
Madisettl
Madisetli
MadlseW
Madlsetli
1112112008
11121/2006
11/2112008
11/21/2008
1112112008
11/21/2008
11121/2008
11/2112008
111211200B
1112112008
1112112008
1112112006
11121/2008
111211200B
1112112008
11121/2008
1112112008
1112112008
11/2112008
111211200B
-.1112112008_
1112112008
1112112008
11/21/200B
11/21/2008
1112112008
1112112008
11/2J-'~Q08
11121/2008
11121/2008
1112112008
11/2112008
11~J!2JlQ8
Exhibit #
RDX-B74
ROX-B7S
RDX-676
RDX-B77
RDX-678
RDX-679
RDX-680
RDX-681
RDX-682
RDX-B83
RDX-684
ROX-685
RDX-686
ROX-687
RDX-688
RDX-689
RDX-690
RDX-691
RDX-692
RDX-693
RDX-694
RDX-695
RDX-698
RDX-697
RDX-698
RDX-699
RDX-700
RDX-1000
RDX-1001
RDX-1002
RDX-1003
RDX-1004
RDX-l00S
RDX-1008
RDX-1007
RDX-1008
RDX-fOO9
RDX-101OC
RDX-1011C
ROX-f012
ROX-1013
ROX-1014
ROX·2000
ROX-2001
ROX-2002
ROX-3000
RDX-3001C
RDX-3002
RDX·3003
RDX-3004
Date
Exhibit Descnplion
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
WITHDRAWN
Drawina - Fixed Soeed Fan
Drawina - Variable Sneed Fan
Drawing - Problem with
Temperature Sensors (from
Col 1. 741 nalent
Fig. 1 and 2 from IBM
Technical Disclosure Bulletin
with handwritten notes
Fan Soeed 1
Fan 1 Saeed wI Hard Disk
Preamble
ASUS 332641 with notes
Suzuki
IBM00000200 with nOles
CDX-18OC with notes
Temoerature Sensor Reoulred
IBMOOOO0162 with notes
IBM 5120
ASUS 332652 Fan Soeed CR
852 Patent Figures 1 and 2
with handwritten notes
852 Patent Routing Incoming
Messages with handwritten
notes
852 Patant Routing lnoomlng
Messages with handwritten
notes
Hand drawing - Point of User
Control
CDX-1S1C with handwritten
notes
Fig. 4 from '829 patenl with
handwritten notes
829 Patent Claim Construction
wltl1 handwritten notes
Fig. 3 from '829 Patent with
handwritten notes
Bates Number
Statement of Purpose
Sponsoring \fIillness
Received tnto Ev.denc
i
,
Polish
Polish
11/1712008
1111712008
Polish
1111712008
Polish
Polish
Polish
Polish
Polisl1
Polish
Polish
Polish
Polish
Polish
Polish
Polish
1111712008
11/1712008
11/17/2008
11/1712008
1111712008
11/1712008
11/17/2008
11/1712008
11/1712008
11/171200B
11/1712008
1111712008
Polish
1112112008
Polish
1112112006
Polish
1112112008
Phlnnev
1112112008
Phlnnev
1112112008
Phlnnev
11121/2008
Phinney
11121/2008
PhlnneL
--
1'12112008
I
UNITED STATES IN't'ERNATlONAL TRADE COMMISSION
Washington. D.C. lO4J6
Before Ihe H.aarable Th•• d.... R. Essex
Adminialracive Law JudEe
1.IheM._O/
Certain Comput... Products. Computer Compo_IS
Pn>dacts C...talol.. S....
.n.
Iny.No.
J31.TA~18
24
T ————
ASU5__016344Noninfringemont Stevenson or G.Chen OX-2054C 11 3
j wnuomwn
1 11002003 ASU5W0fld. Issue 17
$5we
535§
no‘
AmNottbookSdxermlics
I§ mgamam Madiwt i
T WITHDRAWN
— Rebuttal Tasfimon of James Olivier
— Rebuttal Tesum ofv“ Madisetu
— Rebu -= Tastlm o{Roben Stovsnson
m
‘ Emarpfltmn Rabultai Expan Report er! Dr. Paul Francis
N0 BATES
3
lnvalidil
24
24
tn:Iovenson
Naninfrmueznori Frauds
cxgzoaac mzuos
garage”?
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on this 5th day of December, 2008, true and correct copies of the foregoing
RESPONDENTS' POST HEARING BRIEF were caused to be served as indicated below:
Honorable Marilyn R. Abbott
Secretary
U.S. INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION
500 E Street S.W., Room 112
Washington, D.C. 20436
VIA HAND FILING
(Original + 6)
The Honorable Theodore R. Essex
Administrative Law Judge
U.S. INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION
Office of the Administrative Law Judges
500 E Street, S. W., Room 317-F
Washington, D.C. 20436
VIA HAND DELIVERY
(Two copies)
Vu Bui
OFFICE OF UNFAIR IMPORT INVESTIGATIONS
U.S. INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION
500 E Street, S.W., Room 401R
Washington, D.C. 20436
Tel: 202-205-3352
VIA HAND DELIVERY
V. James Adduci, II
Michael L. Doane
ADDUCI, MASTRIANI & SCHAUMBERG LLP
1200 17th Street, N.W., Fifth Floor
Washington, D.C. 20036
Tel: 202-467-6300
Christopher A. Hughes
John T. Moehringer
James T. Bailey
Tony V. Pezzano
CADWALADER WICKERSHAM & TAFT LLP
One World Financial Center
New York, NY 10281-0006
Tel: 212-504-6000
Vu.Bui@usitc.gov
VIA HAND DELIVERY &
ELECTRONIC MAIL
IBM@adducLcom
Counsel for Complainant
International Business Machines
VIA HAND DELIVERY &
ELECTRONIC MAIL
ibmitc@cwt.com
Counsel for Complainant
International Business Machines
Q~
IN THE MATTER OF CERTAIN COMPUTER PRODUCTS,
COMPUTER COMPONENTS AND PRODUCTS CONTAINING
SAME
Inv. No. 337-TA-628
PUBLIC CERTIFICATE OF'SERVICE
I, Marilyn R. Abbott, hereby certify that the attached INITIAL DETERMINATION ON
VIOLATION OF SECTION 337 AND RECOMMENDED DETERMINATION ON REMEDY
AND BOND has been served by hand upon the Commission Investigative Attorney, VU Q. Bui,
Esq., and the following parties as indicated on
April 13,
2009.
A
filyn R. Abbott, Secretary
U.S:1'nternational Trade Commission
500 E Street, SW, Room 112A
Washington, D.C. 20436
COMPLAINANT INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES:
V. James Adduci II, Esq.
ADDUCI, MASTRIANI & SCHAUMBERG LLP
1200 Seventeenth Street, NW, Fifth Floor
Washington, DC 20036
( ) Via Hand Delivery
( ) Via Overnight Mail
~Via First Class Mail
( ) Other: _ _ __
RESPONDENTS ASUSTeK COMPUTER, INC. and
ASUS COMPUTER INTERNATIONAL, NON-NCS TECHNOLOGIES INC:
Brian R Nester, Esq.
Jeffrey R. Whieldon, Esq.
FISH & RICHARDSON PC
1425 K Street, NW, 11th Floor
Washington, DC 20005
( ) Via Hand Delivery
( ) Via Overnight Mail
~a First Class Mail
( ) Other: _ _ __
,
IN THE MATTER OF CERTAIN COMPUTER PRODUCTS,
COMPUTER COMPONENTS AND PRODUCTS CONTAINING
SAME
Inv. No. 337-TA-628
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE - PAGE 2
PUBLIC MAILING LIST
Heather Hall
LEXIS - NEXIS
9443 Springboro Pike
Miamisburg, OH 45342
) Via Hand Delivery
) Via Overnight Mail
~) Via First Class Mail
t )Dther: _ _ __
Kenneth Clair
THOMSON WEST
1100 Thirteen Street, NW, Suite 200
Washington, D.C. 20005
( ) Via Hand Delivery
( ) Via Overnight Mail
~) Via First Class Mail
( ) Other: _ _ __
(
(