GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEETING Thursday, March 10, 2016 8:00 a.m. REGULAR AGENDA CONSOLIDATED This document is a consolidation of the above-noted meeting agenda and includes the addition of the document(s) listed below. Note that documents listed below that have been brought forward at the meeting and form a part of the agenda will be found at the back of this agenda package. AGENDA ADDITIONS Agenda Item No. Subject C.1 − Okanagan Landing and District Community Association PowerPoint presentation E.5 − Water Allocation Purchase for 5862 Bella Vista Road, Vernon BC REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEETING Thursday, March 10, 2016 8:00 am REGULAR AGENDA A. APPROVAL OF AGENDA 1. Greater Vernon Advisory Committee – March 10, 2016 (Opportunity for Introduction of Late Items) (Opportunity for Introduction of Late Items – In Camera Agenda) RECOMMENDATION 1 That the Agenda of the March 10, 2016 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee meeting be approved as presented. B. ADOPTION OF MINUTES 1. Greater Vernon Advisory Committee – February 11, 2016 RECOMMENDATION 2 Page 1 That the minutes of the February 11, 2016 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee meeting be adopted as circulated. 2. Greater Vernon Advisory Committee – Special – February 23, 2016 RECOMMENDATION 3 Page 6 That the minutes of the February 23, 2016 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee Special meeting be adopted as circulated. C. DELEGATIONS 1. Okanagan Landing & District Community Association [HEUMAN, Val] - Delegation Request Form Page 8 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee Agenda – Regular D. UNFINISHED BUSINESS E. NEW BUSINESS -2- March 10, 2016 1. Greater Vernon Water Treatment Cost Summary − Staff report dated March 10, 2016 RECOMMENDATION 4 Page 9 That the report dated March 10, 2016 from the General Manager, Engineering regarding a Greater Vernon Water treatment cost summary be received for information. 2. Greater Vernon Advisory Committee – June 2016 Regular Meeting Date The Federation of Canadian Municipalities Conference is scheduled for June 2-5, 2016. RECOMMENDATION 5 That it be recommended to the Board of Directors the June 2, 2016 regular meeting of the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee be rescheduled to June 9, 2016. 3. Greater Vernon Cultural Plan 2016 – Greater Vernon Cultural Plan – Draft Plan Review (as amended) At the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee meeting held on February 23, 2016 the following motion was moved and seconded: That it be recommended to the Board of Directors, the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan 2016, included in the report dated February 15, 2016 and titled Greater Vernon Cultural Plan – Draft Plan Review, as amended at the February 23, 2016 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee meeting, be endorsed. FOR INFORMATION Page 12 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee Agenda – Regular -3- March 10, 2016 4. 2016 Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Project Grant – Staff report dated January 29, 2016 At the Board of Directors meeting held on February 24, 2016 it was moved and seconded: That the North Okanagan Optimists Club Heritage Fair be approved for grant funding in the amount of $2,500; and further, That the remaining applications be deferred to the March 10, 2016 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee for consideration. FOR DISCUSSION F. BUSINESS ARISING FROM DELEGATIONS G. REPORTS Page 78 1. Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes RECOMMENDATION 6 That the following minutes of the Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee meetings be received for information: - February 18, 2016 Page 93 - February 25, 2016 Page 96 - February 29, 2016 Page 99 2. Chief Administrative Officer’s Report 3. Chair’s Report Greater Vernon Advisory Committee Agenda – Regular H. -4- March 10, 2016 IN CAMERA RECOMMENDATION 7 That the regular meeting of the Board of Directors convene In Camera to deal with matters deemed closed to the public in accordance with the following paragraphs of Section 90(1) of the Community Charter: (e) the acquisition, disposition or expropriation of land or improvements, if the council considers that disclosure could reasonably be expected to harm the interests of the municipality (g) litigation or potential litigation affecting the municipality I. ADJOURNMENT GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item B.1 REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN MINUTES of a REGULAR meeting of the GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE of the REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN held in the Boardroom at the Regional District Office on Thursday, February 11, 2016. Members: Director J. Cunningham Alternate Director J. Garlick Director D. Dirk Director B. Fleming Director M. Macnabb Alternate Director B. Spiers Director A. Mund T. Osborn City of Vernon District of Coldstream District of Coldstream Electoral Area “B” Electoral Area “C” City of Vernon City of Vernon Agricultural Representative Staff: D. Sewell D. McTaggart S. Banmen T. Nelson* K. Pinkoski* P. Juniper Z. Marcolin R. Clark* D. Douglas Chief Administrative Officer General Manager, Engineering General Manager, Finance Community Development Coordinator Manager, Parks Deputy Corporate Officer Manager, Greater Vernon Water Water Quality Manager Clerk, Engineering Also Present: Director R. Fairbairn* Director C. Lord Councillor G. Taylor Councillor G. Kiss Media and Public Electoral Area “D” City of Vernon District of Coldstream District of Coldstream Chair Vice Chair Board Chair * Denotes presence for part of meeting CALL MEETING TO ORDER The meeting was called to order at 8:02 a.m. APPROVAL OF AGENDA Greater Vernon Advisory Committee – February 11, 2016 Moved and seconded by Director Fleming and Alternate Director Garlick That the Agenda of the February 11, 2016 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee meeting be approved as presented. CARRIED Page 1 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item B.1 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee Minutes – Regular -2- February 11, 2016 ADOPTION OF MINUTES Greater Vernon Advisory Committee – January 7, 2016 Moved and seconded by Director Mund and Alternate Director Spiers That the minutes of the January 7, 2016 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee meeting be adopted as circulated. CARRIED Greater Vernon Advisory Committee – Special – January 20, 2016 Moved and seconded by Directors Macnabb and Fleming That the minutes of the January 20, 2016 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee Special meeting be adopted as circulated. CARRIED Greater Vernon Advisory Committee – Special – January 28, 2016 Moved and seconded by Agricultural Representative Osborn and Alternate Director Garlick That the minutes of the January 28, 2016 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee Special meeting be adopted as circulated. CARRIED DELEGATIONS Water Allocation Purchase for 5862 Bella Vista Road, Vernon [PIGHIN] No one was present to speak to the application. Water Allocation Purchase for 9000 Buchanan Road, Coldstream [SMITH, TUTTLE] No one was present to speak to the application. NEW BUSINESS Bylaw No. 2707 - Greater Vernon Water Rates Imposition A motion relating to Greater Vernon Water Rates Imposition Bylaw No. 2707, 2016 was moved and seconded by Directors Macnabb and Fleming. Moved and seconded by Alternate Director Spiers and Director Dirk to amend Schedule A to Greater Vernon Water Rates Imposition Bylaw No. 2707, 2016 as presented as follows: − 2.b.ii be changed from $1.58 to $1.59 − 2.b.iii be changed from $2.37 to $2.32 − 2.c be changed from $1.58 per cubic metre to $1.67 CARRIED Opposed: Directors Cunningham, Macnabb and Fleming The main motion as amended was carried with the final wording being as follows: That it be recommended to the Board of Directors Greater Vernon Water Rates Imposition Bylaw No. 2707, 2016 as amended at the February 11, 2016 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee be Page 2 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item B.1 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee Minutes – Regular -3- February 11, 2016 given First, Second and Third Readings; and further, That Greater Vernon Water Rates Imposition Bylaw No. 2707, 2016 be Adopted. CARRIED Opposed: Directors Cunningham, Macnabb and Fleming Bylaw Enforcement Officer Appointment Moved and seconded by Directors Dirk and Fleming That it be recommended to the Board of Directors Mike Phillips, AScT, Engineering Technologist, be appointed as Bylaw Enforcement Officer for the Regional District of North Okanagan. CARRIED Water Allocation Purchase for 5862 Bella Vista Road, Vernon [PIGHIN] Moved and seconded by Agricultural Representative Osborn and Alternate Director Garlick That it be recommended to the Board of Directors, the purchase of 0.8 hectare (ha) of water allocation for the property located at 5862 Bella Vista Road, Vernon, B.C. and legally described as Lot 1, Plan KAP18017 be authorized. CARRIED Water Allocation Purchase for 9000 Buchanan Road, Coldstream [SMITH, TUTTLE] Moved and seconded by Agricultural Representative Osborn and Alternate Director Garlick That it be recommended to the Board of Directors, the purchase of 2.26 hectares (ha) of water Allocation for the property located at 9000 Buchanan Road, Coldstream B.C. and legally described as Lot 161, Section 19, Township 6, Plan KAP1217 Except Plan KAP46623 be authorized. CARRIED Drought Stakeholder Working Group Moved and seconded by Director Dirk and Alternate Director Garlick That it be recommended to the Board of Directors, the establishment of an informal Drought Stakeholder Working Group with the intent to provide stakeholder input to drought/water supply issues and communication strategies be endorsed. CARRIED Information requested from the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee January 7, 2016 Moved and seconded by Directors Dirk and Fleming That the memo from Stantec dated March 12, 2015 and titled “Duteau Creek Water Treatment Plant – Filtration Pilot Testing Report Peer Review”, be received for information. CARRIED Amendment to Community Gardens in Greater Vernon – Policy No. GVPRC-002 Moved and seconded by Directors Fleming and Dirk That it be recommended to the Board of Directors, the Regional District Policy No. GVPRC-002 be amended to include a list of designated Greater Vernon community gardens, as outlined in the report dated January 19, 2016, and titled Amendment to Community Gardens in Greater Vernon – Policy No. GVPRC-002. CARRIED Page 3 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item B.1 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee Minutes – Regular -4- February 11, 2016 Lease Renewal – Community Garden at Okanagan College Moved and seconded by Directors Dirk and Fleming That it be recommended to the Board of Directors, the lease agreement between Okanagan College and the Regional District of North Okanagan, dated May 1, 2012, for the Regional District’s use of property owned by Okanagan College for the purposes of operating a community garden, be renewed according to the terms of the Renewal Agreement letter dated January 18, 2016. CARRIED Moved and seconded by Directors Dirk and Fleming That it be recommended to the Board of Directors, the 1.7 acre area legally described as: Parcel Identifier: 011-381-400, Lot 5, Section 22, Township 6, ODYD Plan 1961 Except Plans 37599 and 38856, Vernon BC, and locally referred to as Patchwork Farms, be added as a designated community garden within Schedule “A” of the Community Gardens in Greater Vernon Policy No. GVPRC-002. CARRIED 2016 Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Project Grant A motion regarding funding from the Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth project grant program for 2016 was moved and seconded by Director Dirk and Alternate Director Garlick. After debate and amendments the following motion was voted on: That it be recommended to the Board of Directors, North Okanagan Optimists Club Heritage Fair be approved for grant funding in the amount of $2,500; and further, That the remaining applications be deferred to the March 10, 2016 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee for consideration. CARRIED Greater Vernon Parks, Recreation and Culture Moved and seconded by Directors Dirk and Fleming That the letter from the District of Coldstream, dated January 14, 2016 and titled “Assent for Adding the Science Centre building and subsequently the Science Centre to the Sub-Regional Parks and Recreation Service”, be received for information. CARRIED Page 4 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item B.1 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee Minutes – Regular -5- February 11, 2016 REPORTS Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes Moved and seconded by Director Dirk and Agricultural Representative Osborn That the following minutes of the Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee meetings be received for information: - January 14, 2016 - January 21, 2016 CARRIED IN CAMERA Moved and seconded by Directors Fleming and Mund That the regular meeting of the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee convene In Camera to deal with matters deemed closed to the public in accordance with the following paragraph(s) of Section 90(1)(e) of the Community Charter. CARRIED The regular meeting of the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee adjourned to meet In Camera at 9:30 a.m. The regular meeting of the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee reconvened at 9:37 a.m. ADJOURNMENT There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 9:38 a.m. CERTIFIED CORRECT Chair Juliette Cunningham Deputy Corporate Officer Paddy Juniper Page 5 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item B.2 REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN MINUTES of a SPECIAL meeting of the GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE of the REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN held in the Boardroom at the Regional District Office on Tuesday, February 23, 2016. Members: Director J. Cunningham Alternate Director J. Garlick Director D. Dirk Director B. Fleming Director M. Macnabb Director C. Lord Director A. Mund City of Vernon District of Coldstream District of Coldstream Electoral Area “B” Electoral Area “C” City of Vernon City of Vernon Staff: D. Sewell S. Banmen T. Nelson Chief Administrative Officer General Manager, Finance Community Development Coordinator Also Present: Director R. Fairbairn Councillor G. Taylor Electoral Area “D” District of Coldstream Chair Vice Chair Board Chair Media and Public CALL MEETING TO ORDER The meeting was called to order at 8:00 a.m. APPROVAL OF AGENDA Greater Vernon Advisory Committee – February 23, 2016 Moved and seconded by Director Macnabb and Alternate Director Garlick That the Agenda of the February 23, 2016 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee special meeting be approved as presented. CARRIED NEW BUSINESS Greater Vernon Cultural Plan – Draft Plan Review A motion relating to the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan Draft Plan Review was moved and seconded by Directors Fleming and Mund. Moved and seconded by Directors Dirk and Mund to amend the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan as presented as follows: That the following item be added to the 2016 Greater Vernon Cultural Plan document after “Role and Scope of the Regional District’s Greater Vernon Cultural Services” under a new subtitle “Context”: Page 6 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item B.2 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee Minutes – Special - -2- February 23, 2016 It is recognized that "Culture" has a wide horizon of activities and that the Regional District works within a finite capacity in providing support and venues to facilitate cultural activities. CARRIED After debate and amendments, the main motion as amended was carried with the final wording being as follows: That it be recommended to the Board of Directors, the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan 2016, included in the report dated February 15, 2016 and titled Greater Vernon Cultural Plan – Draft Plan Review, as amended at the February 23, 2016 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee meeting, be endorsed. CARRIED ADJOURNMENT There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 9:28 a.m. CERTIFIED CORRECT Chair Juliette Cunningham Chief Administrative Officer David Sewell Page 7 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item C.1 REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN REQUEST TO APPEAR AS A DELEGATION OKANAGAN LANDING & DISTRICT COMMUNITY ASSOC. Name of Person or Group Making Presentation: (Please Print) Contact Information: First Name: Street Address: City: Province: Phone: VAL Last Name: HEUMAN 7813 OKANAGAN LANDING RD. VERNON BC Postal Code: V1H1H2 250-308-4830 Email: [email protected] In order that we may process your request, please indicate which department and / or staff member you have been in contact with: TANNIS NELSON Subject of Presentation: PICNIC PAVILION IN PADDLEWHEEL PARK Purpose of Presentation: ✔ Information Only Request a Letter of Support Request Funding Other (provide details) The Okanagan Landing & District Community Association is requesting that RDNO Parks and Recreation Department join in partnership with a few other organizations and businesses in Vernon to fund a Picnic Pavilion in Paddlewheel Park for use by the residents of Vernon and surrounding area as well as many visiting tourists. Are there any deadlines around your request? yes no Will you be providing supporting documentation? yes no If yes: ✔ Deadline Date: April 1, 2016 provide handouts at meeting included in agenda package (submit one copy no later than 10 day prior to your requested appearance) Technical Requirements: Will you be using a PowerPoint presentation? yes no If yes, you are required to submit your presentation prior to the meeting date to allow sufficient time to transfer the presentation onto the Boardroom computer and to ensure that your software requirement is compatible with the Regional District’s software system. Please note that delegations are limited to 10 minutes in length unless otherwise previously arranged or unanimous vote of the Board or Committee members present. Following receipt of your request, your information will be reviewed by the Corporate Officer and you will be notified as to how your request will proceed. Be advised that submission of your request does not constitute approval to appear. If you receive confirmation that your request has been approved or denied, you will be advised as such. If you receive approval to appear as a delegation, you will be provided with the date, time and location of the meeting. INTERNAL USE ONLY Reviewed and Approved to Appear as a Delegation Type of Meeting: Greater Vernon Advisory Committee Date: March 10, 2016 Please note that all information provided on the request form will be included in a public meeting agenda and as such considered a matter of public information. Page 8 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.1 REGIONAL DISTRICT of NORTH OKANAGAN REPORT File No.: 5720.16.08 TO: Greater Vernon Advisory Committee FROM: Engineering DATE: March 10, 2016 SUBJECT: Greater Vernon Water Treatment Cost Summary RECOMMENDATION: That the report dated March 10, 2016 from the General Manager, Engineering regarding a Greater Vernon Water treatment cost summary be received for information. BACKGROUND: At the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee (GVAC) meeting held on January 20, 2016, staff were requested to prepare a report regarding the differences concerning the total treatment cost and total volume of water treated at the Duteau Creek and Mission Hill Water Treatment Plants in the 2011 Greater Vernon Water (GVW) Annual Report vs . that reported in the December 17, 2015 GVW 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee minutes. To clarify the request by Councillor Kiss, at our request he provided the following clarification of what he would like staff to comment on: "is that comparing unit costs of treatment between Duteau and Mission Hill is like comparing apples to oranges. All of the treated water from Mission Hill (MH) is billed to domestic customers (domestic and /Cl). Only about 25% of Duteau Creek (DC) treated water is billed to the same customers. Thus, in reality the treatment costs are magnified at DC. For instance, if all customers were billed domestic rates at DC for 2011 then the $127 would be representative. But since only about 25% of the water was billed to domestic rates, the actual cost was more like $508/megalitre (ML) (some water in Coldstream is supplied by MH). Even if I use% for DC, the cost per ML would be $470. That is still 6 times higher than ML." DISCUSSION: The Duteau Creek Water Treatment Plant (DCWTP) was commissioned in the fall of 2010. A summary of the water treatment plant cost vs. total water treated at both of our major water treatment plants has been prepared annually since 2011. Our accounting of costs for each water treatment plant has been improving every year since 2011. In 2011 and 2012, many operating costs were an estimate as the City of Vernon operated the plants. A more detailed accounting system was implemented in 2013 when the Regional District of North Okanagan (RDNO) took over the operation of each plant and actual operating costs are now allocated to the DCWTP or the Mission Hill Water Treatment Plant (MHWTP); however, we must still provide estimates for man-hours at each treatment plant. The summary for annual water supply and cost at each plant is prepared as a tool to compare the relative efficiencies for water treatment at the respective plants and is attached to this report for information. Page 9 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.1 Report to: From: Re: GVAC Engineering Greater Vernon Water Treatment Cost Summary File No.: 5720.16.08 March 10, 2016 Page 2 of 2 The summary provides an estimate for actual treatment cost and is not intended to separate the cost for production of agricultural water vs. domestic water. Should GVW move in the direction to fully separate the agricultural and domestic supplies then it would be appropriate to assess the cost of production of water for agricu ltural vs. domestic customers. Currently, given the degree of separation for the agricultural sector, we must provide treated water for agricultural purposes whether the water is supplied from MHWTP or the DCWTP. Currently, a majority of the treated agricultural supply comes from the DCWTP for the following reasons: • the configuration of the water distribution system has a trunk water distribution system to deliver the large volume of water required over the summer months, • the supply of the large volumes of water can be supplied through a gravity system, and • the limited water licence volume of 8,842 megalitres/ year on Kalama lka Lake vs . 34,582 megalitres/year on Duteau Creek. Even though we can supply irrigation water from either the MHWTP or DCWTP, operationally we choose to supply a majority of the irrigation water through the Duteau Creek system for the above reasons and when we supply irrigation water from the MHWTP, additional pumping is required to service a majority of the agricultural lands. Attachment: Summary of Water Treatment Plant Cost per Megalitre Page 10 of 101 Page 11 of 101 -- -~ $625,577 $524,275 $0 $0 $108 Total O&M Cost Summer Average cost/ML Winter Average cost/ML Annual Average cost/ML I 36% $133 I $205 $468 $2,105,173 2. The additional cost to pump Kalamalka Lake water from PZ 483 to PZ 580 is $40/ML. $100 $408 $1,976,104 $146 15,816 I 37% 15,964 $114 $540 $165 II 2014 I $104 I $82 $131 $1,823,395 50% % of Water Licence $2,327,779 2013 19,768 46% 2012 I 2011 I 21,585 Volume Treated (ML) Year 43,424 ML/year Water Licen se available = $128 $150 Total of both sources - $71 - 75% 6,609 2014 $121 $83 $409 $690,135 $83 $107 $654,858 58% $76 - 2013 I 5,116 27% 2014 I 9,355 $1,133,260 8,842 ML/year $136 $318 $98 Annual Average cost/ML - - $1,450,315 Winter Average cost/ML $59 - 84% 7,413 Summer Average cost/ML Total O&M Cost 93% - 8,210 Volume Treated (ML) % of Water Licence Notes: 1. Final 2015 financial statements have not been posted. - 2011 Year 2012 Water License available = Kalamalka Lake Water Source $118 Annual Average cost/ML $127.27 $325 ~ $87 $1,451,830 Winter Average cost/ML - $1,702,202 39% % of Water Licence Total O&M Cost -Summer Average cost/ML 10,700 12,355 I 13,375 I 31% 2013 2012 2011 Year Volume Treated (ML) 36% 34,582 ML/year Water License available = Duteau Creek Water Source Summary of Water Treatment Plant Cost per Megalitre - $86 2015 $120 $241 $118 $397 $174 39% $2,024,028 17,142 2015 $115 $88 $156 $745,392 6,475 -73% -- - $1,278,636 31% 10,667 2015 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.1 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 REGIONAL DISTRICT of NORTH OKANAGAN REPORT File No.: 5809.04/GVCulturalPlan TO: Greater Vernon Advisory Committee FROM: Parks, Recreation and Culture DATE: February 29, 2016 SUBJECT: Greater Vernon Cultural Plan, 2016 SUMMARY: At a special meeting of the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee, held on February 23, 2016, the Committee passed the following motion: That it be recommended to the Board of Directors, the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan 2016, included in the report dated February 15, 2016 and titled Greater Vernon Cultural Plan - Draft Plan Review, as amended at the February 23, 2016 Greater Vernon Advisory Committee meeting, be endorsed. The amended draft of the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan, 2016, has been included as Attachment "A", and is being brought back to the Committee for information, highlighting the amendments from the February 23rd meeting in red text. NEXT STEPS: The final Cultural Plan document will be sent to the Board of Directors for endorsement, as recommended by the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee. is son unity Development Coordinator General Manager, Finance Page 12 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" 2016 GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN Page |13 of 101 | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 BL AN K PA G E Attachment "A" | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN Page 14 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" Executive Summary The development of the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan, 2016, adopted in March 2016, was a notable achievement being the first adopted cultural plan for the Greater Vernon community. The plan provides clarity and direction that will help to facilitate a coordinated effort in support of the cultural health and development of the community. In March 2014 the Regional District approved the terms of reference for the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan Steering Team. A twenty-four person committee that was comprised of Regional District Directors, community representatives, and municipal and Regional District staff, the Steering Team was mandated to work alongside the political lead, being the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee, on the development of Greater Vernon’s long-term plan for culture. The planning process was extensive; a multi-pronged approach to research, plan development and community consultation was accomplished through a thorough review of local planning documents, six Steering Team workshops, nine Greater Vernon Advisory Committee workshops, and eleven public input opportunities. These in-person opportunities were supplemented with outreach through a questionnaire that was made available in the Greater Vernon Leisure Guide and online. Ensure intergovernmental and community implementation of the cultural plan. Support Greater Vernon arts and culture projects. Monitor and report on progress of cultural plan implementation. P la ce s & Sp ace s Ensure the healthy use and condition of existing cultural facilities. Enable the development of new cultural facilities. Encourage a culturally vibrant and connected public realm. Promote natural areas as cultural assets. Increase economic development through cultural development. Cultural Capacity Leadership The following are the strategic themes and key objectives that were distilled from the extensive community input and outlined in this Culture Plan: Support the health and development of cultural not-for-profit organizations. Support and encourage special events. Celebrate and protect our cultural heritage. Increase awareness of and participation in local cultural activities. Support youth engagement in culture. Increase communication and collaboration with Okanagan First Nations. Support neighbourhood cultural projects. Protect, support and encourage public art. This plan provides clarity around roles and responsibilities, in addition to strategies that will support the many community partners in working together toward their common vision of a culturally vital and inspired community. GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN Page |15 of 101 | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" TABLE OF CONTENTS | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN Page 16 of 101 MACKIE LAKE HOUSE (FOUNDATION) GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" INTRODUCTION What is Culture? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Why Culture Matters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Culture in Greater Vernon . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 The Historical Role of the Regional District . . . . . . 5 PL AN OVERVIEW + PROCESS Plan Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Issues and Opportunities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 VISION + GUIDING PRINCIPLES Vision . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 Guiding Principles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 ROLE AND SCOPE OF REGIONAL DISTRICT GREATER VERNON CULTURAL SERVICES Role . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 Scope . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 PL AN OBJECTIVES & STRATEGIES Cultural Leadership . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 Cultural Capacity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 Cultural Places and Spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36 APPENDICES Motion extracts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 50 Volume 2 documents . . . . . . . . . Found separately GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN Page |17 of 101 | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" INTRODUCTION What is Culture? Why Culture Matters Culture in Greater Vernon The Historical Role of RDNO | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN Page 18 of 101 VERNON & DISTRICT PERFORMING ARTS CENTRE GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 The purpose of the Cultural Plan for Greater Vernon is to: Attachment "A" • Articulate a sustainable, authentic, long-term vision for cultural vitality in Greater Vernon. • Identify possibilities for connections and partnerships between and among cultural organizations and other stakeholders. • Present opportunities for collaboration among the Regional District of North Okanagan, the City of Vernon and the District of Coldstream. • Provide policy directions, as well as direction and considerations for Plan implementation. What is Culture? Culture in Greater Vernon is the interaction between the community’s values, atmosphere or feel, education, creativity, and the cultural resources of it’s places and the people who live or have lived there. VALUES MACKIE LAKE HOUSE (FOUNDATION) Memories, stories, ideas, and beliefs that are cherished and preserved for present and future generations. ATMOSPHERE VERNON & DISTRICT PERFORMING ARTS CENTRE F eelings we get from a place, the activity, and the energy that spills out onto the street, or the active culture of a place that is experienced in local shops, restaurants, public places & spaces. CREATIVITY VERNON PUBLIC ART GALLERY Experiences of excellence and creative expression that is conveyed and created through artist talent in theatres, studios, community programs and spaces, and galleries, to name a few. Every community has values, atmosphere and creative talent, and it is the characteristics and interplay between these elements that make a place distinctive from other communities. REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 1 Page 19 of 101 INTRODUCTION GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Why Culture Matters Attachment "A" Culture and Quality of Life Culture enriches people’s day-to-day lives, sometimes in intangible ways. Culture provides enjoyment and appreciation of all creative endeavours, and through culture, the community shares its stories and history, and is able to learn about itself and others. Culture includes the richness of knowledge about an area’s social history, and the wonders of the natural world. A successful community is one that is responsive to the needs of all its residents for the varied experiences that go under the heading “culture.” This can include enjoying a live jazz performance and participating in a public debate about books; glass-blowing at a community art centre and quiet contemplation of a masterpiece in a gallery; dance classes for children and birding groups for seniors; and so on. Cultural spaces and places help foster the development of community identity and a pride of place that not only attracts and retains residents, but also create interesting and engaging cultural experiences for visitors to the community. Greater Vernon’s cultural spaces and places give it a welcoming, charming and unique character that residents and visitors alike recognize as a place they can create, perform, exhibit, learn, engage and be entertained. Culture can also enhance quality of life through special cultural events, festivals, and performances, of which Greater Vernon enjoys many over the course of the year. Like Greater Vernon’s cultural places, these events provide opportunities for residents to gather socially and celebrate the culture and diversity of the community by showcasing local cultural resources and artistic talent to both residents and visitors. “Greater Vernon’s culture is vital, rich and alive – keep it up!” ~ Public input received at Sunshine Festival 2 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN INTRODUCTION Page 20 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 The Economic Benefits of Culture Attachment "A" The economic contribution of artists, artisans, creators and the many other participants in the emerging creative economy is very significant. When their impact on the retail sector, tourism, culinary, hospitality, travel and many other key elements of the Greater Vernon economy are included, the creative economy is a multi-million dollar part of the local economy that has significant and rapid growth potential to add to local jobs and improve our prosperity as a major community in the Okanagan region and province. Today, a vibrant art and cultural sector is crucial to attracting and retaining a talented labor force, creating an environment favourable to innovation, attracting investment and promoting tourism. The rich and distinctive cultures of large cities such as Vancouver, Seattle, Calgary and Toronto, and smaller communities such as Tofino, Whistler, Osoyoos and Kelowna are not so much evidence of these communities’ economic prosperity as they are factors that give rise to it. Municipalities that adopt culture as an economic engine have gained positive economic benefits for their communities. Cultural industries create job growth, turn commonplace communities into desired destinations, generate interconnections between arts and business, invigorate urban areas, entice skilled workers, and create spin-off industries. Greater Vernon’s economic base is diverse, including natural resources, agriculture, retail, military, and manufacturing, and increasingly, creative and knowledge-based industry dependent on skilled creative professionals. Greater Vernon is well positioned to benefit from integrated cultural planning because the community already offers a quality lifestyle that is the desire of many other cities and is becoming more and more appealing. The community has a growing wealth of cultural assets that can leveraged to attract creative people in many fields to live, work and invest in Greater Vernon. REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 3 Page 21 of 101 INTRODUCTION GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Culture in Greater Vernon Attachment "A" Greater Vernon is home to many organizations that together create a rich diversity of culture, which includes artist organizations, performance venues, museums, galleries, historic buildings and sites, nature clubs, and festivals. Some of Greater Vernon’s key cultural assets include facilities and organizations that provide a wide range of cultural programs to the community. This (by no means complete) list includes: • Allan Brooks Nature Centre • Arts Council of the North Okanagan • Bishop Wild Bird Sanctuary • Caetani Cultural Centre • Coldstream Women’s Institute Hall • Gallery Vertigo • Greater Vernon Museum and Archives • Mackie Lake House • North Okanagan Chapter Federation of Canadian Artists • Okanagan Science Centre • Okanagan Symphony Orchestra • O’Keefe Ranch • Powerhouse Theatre • Vernon Community Arts Centre • Vernon Community Music School • Vernon and District Performing Arts Centre • Vernon Camera Club • Vernon Film Society • Vernon Jazz Club • Vernon Public Art Gallery • Vernon Public Library 4 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN INTRODUCTION Page 22 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" The Historical Role of the Regional District in Greater Vernon Cultural Services The Regional District of North Okanagan has historically provided cultural services to the Greater Vernon area, as set out by a service establishment bylaw (Greater Vernon Parks, Recreation and Culture Service Conversion and Service Establishment Bylaw No. 1648, 2000). This Bylaw defines the scope of the Regional District’s role in providing cultural services by determining the types of cultural services and organizations it will support, as well as identifying how these services and organizations will be supported. The cultural functions and/or facilities included in the Bylaw are: Museum; Art Gallery; Boys and Girls Club; Arts Council; Caetani House; and Cultural grants; Literacy and Youth Initiatives Society of the North Okanagan (Teen Junction). Over the years, the provision for “cultural grants” has allowed other groups and services not specified within the bylaw to be eligible for funding. The Regional District supports these organizations and/or the services provided by these organizations through operating grants, as well as grants-in-aid. The Regional District also offers a project grants program, which provides funding to non-profit organizations for a variety of types of projects, including festivals, events, and capital improvements. Additionally, cultural Services in Greater Vernon are supported by the equivalent of a 0.8 FTE (full-time employee), which is currently split between three employees within the Regional District. In 2015, the Regional District dedicated annual funding of roughly $1.65 million to support Greater Vernon cultural facilities, organizations and activities, amounting to an investment of $27* per capita. This per capita investment is in-line with other Okanagan communities, including its culturally-vital neighbour, Kelowna. the reduction is due to the debt from the PAC being removed in order to make the annual funding investment consistent, and therefore comparable, with Kelowna’s annual investment calculation. The per capita investment did not change, as the population numbers used in the initial calculation were from census 2011, and the new figures were from the 2015 BC Stats *This calculation did not include debt payments associated with the Performing Arts Centre, or any value that would be associated with the free use of the publicly-owned buildings, including tax exemption. It also does not include the Vernon branch of the Okanagan Regional library (which has debt payments associated to it for City of Vernon residents), or any contribution that the City of Vernon independently makes towards arts and culture (such as their contribution to the murals, or the Civic Sounds music in the park). The calculation also excludes any cultural investment by the District of Coldstream, including the recent acquisition of the Coldstream Women’s Institute Hall, which is used primarily for cultural activities such as dances and farmers markets. REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 5 Page 23 of 101 INTRODUCTION GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" PLAN PROCESS + DEVELOPMENT 6 1 Plan Process 2 Issues and Opportunities | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN Page 24 of 101 GALLERY VERTIGO NORTH OKANAGAN ARTISTS ALTERNATIVE GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" Plan Process The development process of the plan included three phases: audit and analysis; direction setting and plan development. Audit and Analysis In order to be effective, a cultural plan needs to be positioned within the community context, and create links between other local government planning document and decision-making processes. It also must encourage the consideration of culture in future planning exercises. This is particularly important in the case of Greater Vernon, where the provision of the community’s cultural services is through a sub-regional partnership at the Regional District level; in this case, some aspects of supporting policy and services are the responsibility of the other municipal partners, such as the City of Vernon or the District of Coldstream. The following image depicts a few of the key planning documents that were reviewed as part of the development of this plan. District of Coldstream RDNO RDNO Silver Star Official Community Plan, RGS Monitoring & Evaluation Report, 2011 2004 Central Coldstream Neighbourhood Plan, 2011 RDNO RDNO Official Community Plan Electoral Areas B & C, 2014 Regional Growth Strategy, 2011 District Coldstream Arts Council North Okanagan, of of the Draft OCP 2015 City of Vernon City of Vernon Economic Dev Strategic Action Plan: 2014-2015 City Centre Neighbourhood Plan, 2011 City of Vernon Official Community Plan City of Vernon Tourism & Marketing Plan, 2015 City of Vernon Economic Development Plan, 2013 Greater Vernon Museum & Archives Vernon District Performing Arts Centre Society Strategic Plan 2009-2013 Strategic Plan 2009-2013 Greater Vernon Chamber of Commerce Cultural Plan, City of Vernon 2014 Social Planning Council Vernon Immigration Survey Results, 2014 Vernon Settlement Strategy Strategic Plan 2009-2013 Strategic Plan 2015 Greater Vernon Council Strategic Plan: 2015-2018 Vernon Public Art Gallery and Downtown Vernon Association Strategic Plan 2015-2017 Phase 1 - Community Mapping Strategic Plan Community Futures of the North Okanagan NOAA - Gallery Vertigo Strategic Plan 2009-2013 Mackie Lake House Foundation Strategic Plan 2009-2013 Okanagan Science Centre Strategic Plan 2009-2013 2014-2015 Annual Report Many of the plans that were reviewed indicated some consideration of cultural development. The hope is that some of the objectives within the Culture Plan may be supported through goals and actions identified within other strategies, and that the Plan may serve as a guide for ensuring that culture is considered in the development of future planning documents. REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 7 Page 25 of 101 PLAN PROCESS & DEVELOPMENT GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Plan Process Attachment "A" Greater Vernon Advisory Committee & Steering Team Workshops This plan was developed with ongoing input and over-sight from the RDNO Cultural Services staff, the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee (GVAC), and a project Steering Committee – a twenty-four member body representing the cultural sector, business community, and the RDNO. From June to September 2014, both these groups met five times – roughly once a month. Through this process, the groups were able to help identify key issues and opportunities, and develop a vision and guiding principles, as well as draft policy directions. Public Engagement The Plan has also been informed by ongoing input from the public. Over the course of the project, RDNO Community Development Coordinator attended, along with members of the Steering Team, eleven separate public events in Greater Vernon with a pop-up Cultural Plan display and information booth and interactive feedback poster board. This highly effective form of direct outreach helped raise the profile of the Plan in the community and generated hundreds of individual comments on cultural issues and opportunities. This direct outreach was supplemented by a questionnaire which was placed in the Greater Vernon Parks and Leisure Guide, and an online questionnaire which was available on the RDNO website. Development of implementation actions SUNSHINE FEST EVENT 8 From the direction set by the Policy Directions document, the Steering Team met again, along with several meetings of the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee in order to determine the steps that would be necessary to achieve each of the objectives. The Greater Vernon Advisory Committee strongly focused on the Cultural Leadership and Places and Spaces issues, while the Steering Team worked on the Cultural Capacity issues. | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN PLAN PROCESS & DEVELOPMENT Page 26 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" Issues and Opportunities At the initial direction setting step in the planning process, the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee (GVAC) and Steering Team identified the following key issues and opportunities that they wanted to see addressed through the Cultural Plan: 1. Review the Regional District’s approach to cultural funding Both the Regional District representatives, as well as members of the cultural community identified issues with the mechanics of how the Regional District funds and supports cultural services. While the current bylaws and policies do provide some direction on how cultural services should be funded, they have also been interpreted in different ways over the years. This has led to a situation where neither the Regional District nor the cultural community has the desired level of certainty over which cultural organizations are eligible for certain types of funding, and at what funding levels and expectations. The Plan provides recommendations that will give greater clarity for both the decisionmakers as well as potential funding applicants. 2. Establish priority facility needs Steering Team and GVAC members noted the need for a clearer and criteria-based decision-making process for establishing funding priorities for new cultural facilities. They identified that the process should take into consideration the spacial needs of the community for cultural programming, the existing spacial capacity that may be available, and the financial capacity of the community. 3. Provide greater stability in funding For the most part, the RDNO provides funding on a year-to-year basis. Short term funding provides maximum flexibility and reduces risk to the RDNO. On the other hand, longer term funding such as through a multi-year funding agreement, provides the facility operator with greater security of tenure, which can assist in obtaining private financing. It can also provide greater budgeting security to the RDNO. 4. Improve community access to publicly-owned and funded resources Many publicly funded facilities and spaces are not fully accessible to non-profit groups. The situation, by comparison, is better with recreation facilities, which offer subsidized rates for youth participants, for example. Also, onerous fees and insurance requirements can act as a barrier to small groups looking to organize arts and cultural events in local parks. 5. Foster collaboration and partnerships The Plan should identify ways to foster cultural collaboration. In the case of collaboration among cultural groups, this might include making it easier for groups to share space, equipment, and information. There are several good examples of collaboration between the cultural community and government, but this could be broadened. The Plan should also facilitate collaboration between business and cultural groups. Additionally, the Plan should explore the feasibility of collaborative efforts to: • Better incorporate the arts into the education system • Provide opportunities for involvement in arts and culture as part of health / mental health programs • Include agricultural and environmental issues into the Plan • Encourage greater ethnic diversity and First Nations inclusion in cultural events REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 9 Page 27 of 101 PLAN PROCESS & DEVELOPMENT GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" VERNON MARKET 6. Help make information related to culture more accessible Greater Vernon needs a one-stop source of information on all things to do with culture: upcoming events, programs, and cultural organizations. While there are many sources of information, no one source is recognized by the community as being adequately comprehensive and up-to-date. 7. Promote and strengthen the local cultural scene to help attract new residents and visitors to Greater Vernon It is recognized that a community’s cultural amenities are an important determinant in attracting new residents and visitors, and that attracting new residents and visitors is an important component of an economic development strategy. The Plan should identify ways for Greater Vernon to promote its existing cultural amenities in order to help grow the local tourism sector as well as attract new residents. 8. Make Greater Vernon more culturally vibrant Some participants, both on the Steering Team as well as the public, feel that Greater Vernon is lacking in cultural vitality. The scope of what it means to improve the local cultural scene in general is admittedly broad, but there are many potential initiatives and ideas that have been investigated and included as part of the Plan. COLDSTREAM MARKET 10 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN PLAN PROCESS & DEVELOPMENT Page 28 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" Summary of public feedback Results of Public Input The following tables show the most common responses to each of the questions. Responses shown are those that were given by at least 5% of respondents. The full results of the public input can be found in the Policy Directions document included in Volume 2 to the Cultural Plan. 1. When it comes to culture, Greater Vernon needs ... More venues for performing arts, especially live music 16% More special events/ festivals 16% More cultural facilities and activities for youth 14% A new art gallery 13% A more vibrant downtown/cultural district 9% A new/expanded museum 6% 2. It would be great if Greater Vernon had ... More special events/festivals 15% A more vibrant downtown/cultural district 11% More venues for live music / theatre 10% 3. The cultural facility I frequent the most is ... Vernon and District Performing Arts Centre 30% Library 9% Towne Theatre 8% Powerhouse Theatre 6% Museum 5% REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 11 Page 29 of 101 PLAN PROCESS & DEVELOPMENT GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" 4. I wish everyone in Greater Vernon knew about ... Greater Vernon’s local music scene 19% The Vernon Public Art Gallery, and its need for more space 14% 5. The best thing about Greater Vernon’s cultural scene is ... Its variety and high quality 19% Its outdoor culture 14% Its live music scene 10% The Vernon and District Performing Arts Centre 10% Library 5% MACKIE LAKE HOUSE 12 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN PLAN PROCESS & DEVELOPMENT Page 30 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" Key Findings from Public Input 1. A need for a variety of new or expanded cultural spaces and places Public perception of cultural needs and gaps in Greater Vernon was tested through the following two questions: “When it comes to culture, Greater Vernon needs…” and “It would be great if Greater Vernon had…” The results of the responses to these two questions shows that the Greater Vernon public would like to see a number of additional or improved cultural facilities and/or districts, with the priorities being: • More venues for performing arts, especially live music • More cultural places and activities for youth • A new art gallery • A more vibrant downtown/public realm • A new/expanded museum 2. A desire for more special cultural events The responses to the questions “When it comes to culture, Greater Vernon needs…” and “It would be great if Greater Vernon had…” indicate that the public would like to see more public special events, such as festivals and live performances. 3. An appreciation for Greater Vernon’s cultural assets The questions: “The cultural facility I frequent most is…”, “I wish everyone in Greater Vernon knew about…”, and “The best thing about Greater Vernon’s cultural scene is…” were posed in order to gauge the public’s preferences for particular cultural facilities, programs and activities. These questions found that the public is greatly appreciative of Greater Vernon’s overall variety and quality of culture, noting particularly its music scene, outdoor culture, and the Vernon and District Performing Arts Centre. RIOT ON THE ROOF REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 13 Page 31 of 101 PLAN PROCESS & DEVELOPMENT GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" VISION + GUIDING PRINCIPLES 14 1 Vision 2 Guiding Principles | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN Page 32 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" Vision The following vision statement captures the culture planning process community input and will guide future cultural initiatives and actions: We see a community where: Greater Vernon’s culture is a measure of our daily lives; a reflection of our historical roots and present diversity; and a recognition that our community and cultural vitality rises from our creative spirit. MACKIE LAKE HOUSE (FOUNDATION) REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 15 Page 33 of 101 VISION + GUIDING PRINCIPLES GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" Guiding Principles The Guiding Principles are values and perspectives which reflect the Vision and inform the Goals and Strategies of the Plan. They function as a filter through which all Goals and Strategies are considered. Embrace accessibility, inclusivity and diversity Ensure that cultural learning opportunities, resources and activities are embraced and fostered, and are accessible regardless of age groups, physical abilities, ethnicity and socioeconomic households. Promote innovation and creativity Seize opportunities to encourage creativity and innovation to build a culturally vibrant community that attract skilled creative professionals to live and work in Greater Vernon. Encourage collaboration and communication Foster collaboration between and among citizens, cultural organizations, local government, educational institutions, and the business and tourism sector. Build on strengths and support new initiatives Enhance and enrich Greater Vernon’s existing cultural facilities and programs, while also supporting new initiatives. Recognize culture’s role in promoting economic vitality Acknowledge that culture is a driving force to economic vibrancy, where the community’s uniqueness and cultural contributions are celebrated in order to help bring Greater Vernon to the world and the world to Greater Vernon. Celebrate history of yesterday, today and tomorrow Collect, preserve and display Greater Vernon’s cultural heritage, while promoting creativity, supporting wider educational efforts, and fostering innovation. Be accountable and fiscally responsible Ensure cultural sustainability for future generations is in harmony with the community’s economic health, social equity and environmental responsibility that include continuous monitoring and accountability, and provide guidance on the fair allocation of public resources. 16 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN VISION + GUIDING PRINCIPLES Page 34 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" Role and scope of the Regional District’s Greater Vernon Cultural Services On November 5, 2015, the Regional District endorsed the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan Policy Directions document, which has guided the development of the strategies within this plan. Clarifying the role that the Regional District plays in supporting culture in Greater Vernon was a key objective identified within the Policy Directions document, and is necessary in order to develop and apply consistent and transparent decision making processes, and establish roles and responsibilities within the implementation plan. As a result of workshops with the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee, and in consideration of the public consultation received throughout the planning process, the Regional District has agreed that they will support culture in Greater Vernon in accordance with the following: CONTEXT It is recognized that “Culture” has a wide horizon of activities, and that the Regional District works within a finite capacity in providing support and venues to facilitate cultural activities. ROLE For the benefit of all Greater Vernon residents, the Regional District will support cultural development and increase capacity in the cultural sector through the facilitation of administrative expertise, coordination and knowledge, and the ownership and provision of facilities for the purposes of cultural programming. The Regional District will not directly deliver cultural programming, but may provide funding to support cultural projects within Greater Vernon, and funding to support operating costs associated with delivering cultural programming within Regional District owned or licensed facilities. In consideration of the above role, it was also necessary that the Regional District establish the scope of that which it supports, and develop a clear and documented process with which to expand or modify that scope. REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN - GREATER VERNON CULTURAL SERVICES CONTINUUM PROGRAMMING PROGRAM DELIVERY INFRASTRUCTURE ORGANIZATIONAL CAPACITY SUPPORT NOT-FOR-PROFIT ORGANIZATION BUILDING OCCUPANCY COSTS BUILDING MAINTENANCE NEW CONSTRUCTION REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 17 Page 35 of 101 ROLE AND SCOPE OF RDNO GREATER VERNON CULTURAL SERVICES GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" SCOPE Leadership • The Regional District will play a lead role in the development, update, and coordination of the implementation of this long-range cultural plan for Greater Vernon. • The Regional District will work with community partners to build local and visitor awareness of Greater Vernon’s cultural resources and assets. Capacity building • The Regional District will help build capacity in the cultural sector through: the facilitation of a Greater Vernon Cultural Plan implementation advisory team for the purpose of guiding the implementation of the Cultural Plan; and the provision of administrative expertise, coordination and knowledge. removed the word capacity • The Regional District may provide not-for-profit organizational support, such as: funding for Board of Directors training, support for strategic long-term planning, facilitation of strategic partnership development, or support for external funding applications. Programming The Regional District will not directly provide cultural programming, but may: • through the Regional District Project Grant program, provide annually defined funding to support cultural projects within Greater Vernon, including but not limited to special cultural events, small capital projects and special cultural programs or initiatives. • provide funding, through multi-year agreements, to support the operational costs associated with the delivery of cultural programming within Regional District owned/licensed facilities to independent, registered not-for-profit societies, which currently include: INVENTORY OF CULTURAL OPERATING FUNDING RECIPIENTS • Greater Vernon Museum and Archives • Arts Council of the North Okanagan • Vernon Public Art Gallery • Vernon and District Performing Arts Centre Infrastructure • The Regional District will own (and where necessary, lease or license) facilities, which it will provide for use by registered not-for-profit cultural societies, by way of multi-year agreements, for cultural programming purposes. These facilities include: INVENTORY OF REGIONAL DISTRICT FACILITIES PURPOSE ADDRESS LEGAL OCCUPIED BY Cultural Public history 3400 30 St. PID 010-862-927 lot a, Greater Vernon conservation museum & archives Vernon BC ODYD, pl 39576 sec 34 Museum & Archives & exhibition Public art gallery 3228 31 Ave, Lot A, DL 72, ODYD, Plan Vernon Public Art 32802 Gallery Society Vernon, BC Community Community arts 2704a Hwy 6 cultural centre Vernon BC programming Community theatre 3800 33 st. Vernon BC 18 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN That part of BLK 31, Lots Arts Council of the 4-7, ODYD, Plan 327C North Okanagan PID 023-127-598 That part of Lot 1, Sec 3, ODYD, KAP76941 Page 36 of 101 Vernon & District Performing Arts Centre Society GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" • The Regional District may provide funding for maintenance and other expenses associated with existing Regional District facilities according to adopted guidelines (shown on page 39) • The Regional District will facilitate the planning and development of any new cultural facilities that it will ultimately own or lease/license, in accordance with the New Facility Development Process (shown on page 44) SCOPE AMENDMENT PROCESS The legislative framework and limitations of the cultural services provided by the Regional District within Greater Vernon are provided within the Local Government Act and the service establishment bylaw for the Greater Vernon Parks, Recreation and Culture (currently Bylaw 1648). Where the establishment bylaw does not allow for a particular situation involving cultural facilities, services or grants, consideration to amending the scope of the service, and subsequently the service establishment bylaw, would need to occur. Process for scope amendment: 1. Consider the proposed scope amendment against the existing services provided by the Regional District to ensure the addition would not create duplication, inconsistencies, or conflicts with the existing services provided. 2. In the case of a new or replacement facility, the New Facility Development Process would be initiated, and the Regional District must give approval to the project as per Step 6 in the Process shown on page 44 of the “Greater Vernon Cultural Plan, 2016”. 3. Gather the necessary information on the proposed scope amendment, confirming all financial and resource implications for the Regional District as a result of the proposed service scope amendment. 4. With supporting information, the service scope amendment is considered by the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee and the Board of Directors, and approval in principle is provided contingent upon unanimous consent of all service participants, being the councils of the participating municipalities and the Directors of the participating electoral areas that make up the service. 5. The proposed service scope amendment is referred out to all service participants, with supporting information, including but not limited to financial and resource implications, with a request for consent to proceed with the service scope amendment. UNANIMOUS CONSENT PROVIDED UNANIMOUS CONSENT NOT PROVIDED 6. Provided all service participants consent to proceed with the scope amendment, initiate the steps to amend the service establishment bylaw to reflect the change in scope. 6. If all service participants do not consent to proceed with the scope amendment, the service scope amendment does not proceed. 7. If the service establishment bylaw is successfully amended, any necessary policies or guiding documents should be amended to reflect the change. 7. The service participants who did provide consent may consider establishing a new, separate service that could accommodate the request. REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 19 Page 37 of 101 ROLE AND SCOPE OF RDNO GREATER VERNON CULTURAL SERVICES GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" 20 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN RIOT ON THE ROOF Page 38 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" PLAN OBJECTIVES & STRATEGIES Cultural Leadership Cultural Capacity Cultural Places and Spaces REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 21 Page 39 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 PLAN OBJECTIVE & STRATEGIES Attachment "A" The objectives and associated strategies within the Plan have been developed out of the direction provided in the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan Policy Directions document. The objectives are grouped into three cultural development areas, being: cultural leadership; cultural capacity; and cultural places and spaces. The Plan provides strategies and associated action items for achieving the following sixteen objectives: A. Ensure intergovernmental and community implementation of the cultural plan. B. Support Greater Vernon arts and culture projects. C. Monitor and report on progress of cultural plan implementation. D. Increase economic development through cultural development. E. Support the health and development of cultural not-for-profit organizations. F. Support and encourage special events. G. Celebrate and protect our cultural heritage. H. Increase awareness of and participation in local cultural activities. I. Support youth engagement in culture. J. Increase communication and collaboration with Okanagan First Nations. K. Support neighbourhood cultural projects. L. Ensure the healthy use and condition of existing cultural facilities. M. Enable the development of new cultural facilities. N. Encourage a culturally vibrant and connected public realm. O. Promote natural areas as cultural assets. P. Protect, support and encourage public art. Notes on the strategy tables: • RDNO - Regional District of North Okanagan • CoV - City of Vernon • DoC - District of Coldstream • NFP - Not-for-profit organization 22 • IAT - Implementation Advisory Team for the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan • ACNO- Arts Council of the North Okanagan | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN PLAN STRATEGIES Page 40 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" Within the timeline, start times are shown as: • Short term (SHORT TERM) – Years 0-2 Being those strategies that must precede another strategy, that were identified as a high priority by GVAC and the Steering Team, or that are time-sensitive and critical. • Medium term (MED TERM) – Years 3-6 Being those strategies that have actions that must first take place before they start, or that require additional research or consultation, or those that may not have the resources in place to initiate immediately. • On-going (ON-GOING) Being those strategies that will need to carry on throughout the duration of the term of the Cultural Plan, and perhaps beyond. It is recognized that this Plan can not govern partner municipalities or not-for-profit organizations, but the intention is to encourage the endorsement and involvement in the plan by all potential partners. CULTURAL LEADERSHIP A. Ensure intergovernmental and community implementation of the cultural plan. A1. Establish an implementation advisory team (IAT) Close collaboration between local government and the community helps make and implement better plans. In recognition of this, it was seen as a high priority by both the GVAC and the Steering team to continue the collaborative approach used in development of the Plan. An important first action in support of this objective will be for the Regional District to establish an Implementation Advisory Team (IAT), along with the necessary procedures to guide the work of this group over the course of Plan implementation. Once the IAT has been established, it will be able to work in collaboration with the Regional District, and other appropriate partners, on implementing appropriate portions of the Cultural Plan. The resources required by the IAT will be secured through external sources wherever possible, or support requested as part of the Regional District budgeting process. SHORT TERM A1. ACTION ITEMS Develop terms of reference for an implementation advisory team, which will define: members/composition; term of membership; purpose and goals; jurisdiction; resources/budget; governance; and communications, such as reporting between IAT, key community orgs. and local government. MED TERM ONGOING X LEAD RDNO A2. Align service delivery with scope of Greater Vernon’s cultural service. As a result of the defined role and scope, there will be necessary actions required to align the current service delivery with the scope. REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 23 Page 41 of 101 PLAN STRATEGIES GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" SHORT TERM A2. ACTION ITEMS MED TERM ON GOING LEAD Amend Greater Vernon Parks, Recreation and Cultural Service Establishment bylaw to reflect scope of service as outlined in the Cultural Plan. X RDNO Work with the Greater Vernon Museum and Archives to register the organization as an independent NFP society. X RDNO Enter into new or amended licenses for those facilities within the scope of the service. X RDNO Discontinue the annual operating funding provided to those organizations not listed within the scope of the service. X RDNO Initiate the Scope Amendment Process to consider adding the facility in which the Okanagan Science Centre is currently located. X RDNO Initiate the Scope Amendment Process to consider continued support for the Okanagan Science Centre. X RDNO Initiate the Scope Amendment Process to consider continued support for the Gallery Vertigo. X RDNO Undertake discussions with the City of Vernon’s Administration regarding the transfer of the Okanagan Boys and Girls Club to the City of Vernon with support being incorporated into the Recreation and Programming Grant Service (063) X RDNO A3. Create linkages between the cultural plan implementation actions and existing and future local government planning documents’ actions. Another key piece to the success of the plan will be the establishment of regular communication and harmonization of planning documents that may impact cultural development. Many of the implementation items within the plan will require cooperation between the Regional District and its municipal partners, and it will be important to establish mechanisms for this cooperation to take place. This is likely an area where the IAT can play a key role. 24 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN PLAN STRATEGIES Page 42 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" SHORT TERM A3. ACTION ITEMS MED TERM ONGOING LEAD Encourage a culture-integrated approach to policy development by incorporating an IAT referral process into the development of local government planning documents, bylaws or other strategies that may have an impact on cultural activities or services. X X RDNO/IAT Encourage and facilitate cooperation between the Regional District, the City of Vernon and the District of Coldstream on projects that are in-line with the Cultural Plan, or that support cultural development in Greater Vernon X X RDNO/IAT B. Support Greater Vernon arts and culture projects. B1. Continue with and make improvements to the Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth project grant. As part of the cultural services provided through the Greater Vernon Parks, Recreation and Culture Service (060), there has been an allocation of funding to support arts, culture or youth focused projects in the Greater Vernon community through an annual grant process. The application process and adjudication of these funds are supported by Regional District policy. This funding can support cultural projects, including special events, one time projects or small capital improvements, which allows the Regional District to provide seed money for a new event to get established, such as it did for the Okanagan Military Tattoo, or provide funding to enable cultural organizations to make smaller capital improvements to their facilities. There has been feedback through the cultural planning process that, although this program is a valuable community asset there may be opportunity to make some changes that would improve the program. DELETED increasing by inflation each year, whenever possible SHORT MED ONB1. ACTION ITEMS TERM TERM GOING Retain a budget for the Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth project grant. Continue to adjudicate the project grant using the Regional District approved evaluation criteria. LEAD X X RDNO X X RDNO REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 25 Page 43 of 101 PLAN STRATEGIES GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" Review the project grant policy and consider changes for efficacy, such as: • an additional application intake; • funding prioritization based on cultural plan objectives; • funding eligibility extended to NFP planning, and capacity building projects such as strategic plans or feasibility studies. X X RDNO C. Monitor and report on progress of cultural plan implementation. C1. Publicize the status of the progress made on the implementation of the Cultural Plan implementation, and any related projects. Communicating success of the Plan is important for maintaining enthusiasm and commitment to the Plan’s implementation. SHORT TERM C1. ACTION ITEMS Prepare an annual report to GVAC, Board of Directors and public , outlining the progress made on the implementation plan, to be submitted in the Fall. X Develop a page on the Regional District website that focuses on the Greater Vernon cultural services, and is kept up-to-date on progress and relevant projects. X MED TERM X LEAD RDNO/IAT RDNO Use established indicators of success to evaluate the benefits and effects of the Cultural Plan initiatives. Review the Cultural Plan strategies every three to four years, and update and amend when appropriate. ONGOING X X RDNO X RDNO Cultural Capacity D. Increase economic development through cultural development. D1. Support cultural economic development initiatives There is a high level of interest in exploring opportunities to strengthen the economic viability of the cultural sector in Greater Vernon, as well as for identifying ways that culture can make greater contributions to the broader Greater Vernon economy. 26 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN PLAN STRATEGIES Page 44 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" This is also supported in other existing public policy; for example, one of the goals in the City of Vernon`s Economic Development Strategic Action Plan is to develop ``...a cultural community with a strong sense of place.” (City of Vernon, 2012, pg 9). Both the Regional District and the community will play important roles in bringing an economic development perspective to the implementation of the Cultural Plan; however, it is recommended that the Implementation Advisory Team take leadership of this action. Members of the IAT, as representatives of the local cultural and business community, will be well positioned to stay up-to-date on new and emerging economic development opportunities as they arise. There is also opportunity for the IAT to work closely with and support partners such as the City of Vernon`s Economic Department, the Chamber of Commerce, the Downtown Vernon Association, and the Community Futures of the North Okanagan in economic development objectives with mutual benefit. This emphasis on economic development will run throughout the plan implementation. SHORT TERM D1. ACTION ITEMS MED TERM ONGOING LEAD Work with and support economic development focused/related organizations on arts and culture related initiatives that would support economic development. X X IAT Develop a process for regularly gathering cultural data and reviewing a variety of cultural vitality indicators, possibly through an existing program such as Vital Signs, in order to collect consistent and comparable information that could support economic development strategies, or act as a catalyst to garner other support for culture. X X IAT Strategy D2. Develop and promote Greater Vernon’s cultural brand. Most of the cultural organizations in the community have their own, pre-established marketing efforts and branding in place, however there remains to be a consistent Greater Vernon cultural brand. The lack of a collective cultural brand creates challenges for marketing the cultural offerings of the community through mechanisms like Tourism Vernon. Developing a collective brand, and implementing a marketing and promotions plan, could be done by the IAT, or in partnership with an organization like the Arts Council of the North Okanagan, whose mandate is to develop culture at a broader level in the community. SHORT TERM D2. ACTION ITEMS Develop a Greater Vernon Culture brand that is complimentary to local tourism branding. X MED TERM ONGOING LEAD IAT/ACNO REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 27 Page 45 of 101 PLAN STRATEGIES GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" Develop a formal connection between IAT and Tourism Vernon and the Thompson Okanagan Tourism Association, and work collaboratively on projects with mutual benefit. X X IAT, Tourism Vernon Work with Tourism Vernon to support the inclusion of elements of culture in updates to tourism planning documents, and development and marketing of new cultural experiences that may be developed, which could include: • visitor-focused programs, such as self-guided studio tours/cultural facility tours • cultural experience packages for visitors, created through partnerships between cultural service providers, accommodation providers and local businesses. X X IAT, Tourism Vernon X X IAT/RDNO X X IAT/RDNO/ ACNO Continue to work in cooperation with the City of Vernon’s new signage strategy (2015) to include, wherever possible, cultural facilities and attractions into new way-finding signage. Encourage cultural organizations to share event and exhibit information and space so that they can benefit from the collaborative programming and cross-marketing initiatives. Strategy D3. Support cultural business development. There are quite a number of established business development programs in place that can be utilized to help build the capacity of local creative industries and cultural businesses. The IAT can also support cultural business development by remaining aware of relevant policies and bylaws, and ensuring that they support and encourage local cultural entrepreneurship. SHORT TERM D3. ACTION ITEMS Advocate for and promote programs that help build capacity of local creative industries and cultural businesses, such as: the City of Vernon’s Small Business Support Program; Creative BC; Our Okanagan (CFNO); Business for the Arts; and the City Centre Neighbourhood Plan. Work with partners to deliver arts and culture focused business and professional development training opportunities. 28 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN PLAN STRATEGIES Page 46 of 101 MED TERM X ONGOING X X LEAD IAT IAT GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" Ensure that local government policies and bylaws support and encourage local cultural entrepreneurship. X Work with appropriate community partners, such as the Arts Council of the North Okanagan, to allow for small, unincorporated NFP groups to access financial support for cultural activities. Support projects within economic development focused plans that meet mutual objectives. X X X IAT/RDNO X IAT X IAT E. Support the health and development of cultural not-for-profit organizations. E1. Support the professional development of board members and staff of not-for-profit cultural organizations. Support building stronger leadership and organizational capacity among non-profit arts and cultural organizations (e.g. leadership and organizational challenges, questions of board governance, volunteer management, quality fundraising and sponsorships, audience, etc.). Building the capacity of an individual cultural organization helps to improve its ability to achieve its mission and sustain itself over time. When capacity building is successful, it strengthens a cultural organization’s ability to fulfill it’s mission, and helps the organizations to have a positive impact on lives and communities, therefore building the capacity of the community as a whole. SHORT TERM E1. ACTION ITEMS Promote and advocate for professional development opportunities to build capacity of staff members of NFP cultural organizations including, but not limited to: Share ED, ArtsBC, Creative BC, BC Arts Council, and the Chamber of Commerce. MED TERM ONGOING X IAT/RDNO Work with Community Futures or other appropriate partners to develop a Greater Vernon Creative Network, similar to Share ED, specifically for the professional development X and peer mentoring of Executive Directors of DELETED training culture-focused NFP organizations. Provide funding and support for Directors and Boards of the Greater Vernon cultural NFP community, as needs are identified and verified. X LEAD IAT/RDNO X RDNO REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 29 Page 47 of 101 PLAN STRATEGIES GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" Promote and advocate for existing training programs such as: Business for the Arts BoardLink program and the Chamber of Commerce Board Governance training. Support NFP cultural organizations in accessing and retaining the volunteers needed to serve in various capacities, including Board directors, and in establishing collaborative volunteer appreciation and incentive programs. X X IAT X IAT E2. Promote and advocate for a variety of funding sources to support not-for-profit cultural organizations. Most local cultural organizations rely on a variety of funding sources, from senior levels of government to larger organizations. There is always potential for some of these funding sources to be reduced, or even eliminated, which puts pressure on local government to make up the shortfall in order to prevent a significant decrease in service or even failure of an organization. The IAT and the Regional District can commit to playing an active advocacy role to ensure that historical funding levels, particularly from senior levels of government, are sustained. SHORT TERM E2. ACTION ITEMS Promote and advocate for funding programs that support NFP cultural organizations, such as: ArtsVest Sponsorship program, BC Arts Council, BC Gaming and Creative BC. Advocate for consistent and adequate provincial and federal funding level investment in arts and culture. 30 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN PLAN STRATEGIES Page 48 of 101 ONGOING LEAD X X RDNO/IAT X X RDNO/IAT X RDNO/IAT X ACNO Identify and establish a corporate sponsor(s) for the Greater Vernon Creative Network, and other professional development and training programs. Identify private and public sector operational and project funding sources to support cultural NFPs, and make this information available through appropriate channels. MED TERM X X GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" Ensure that local funding programs that support NFP cultural organizations are designed to be complimentary with private, public and federal funding sources and can be successfully used to leverage funding from other sources. X X RDNO/IAT F. Support and encourage special events. F1. Ensure local policies encourage and support special events. When it comes to planning special events, many local policies and bylaws can come into effect, which may not have been developed considering the implications on cultural activities. A review and audit of existing policies, along with future consultation with cultural activity providers during the development of new policies, can help ensure that the local policies achieve their objective while ensuring that they are not prohibitive to cultural activity. SHORT TERM F1. ACTION ITEMS MED TERM ONGOING LEAD Continue to provide funding for special cultural events through the Greater Vernon Arts, Cultural and Youth grant program. X X RDNO Regularly review local government policies and bylaws to ensure that they support and encourage special events. These may include noise bylaws and permitting processes. X X RDNO/IAT Strive to provide a stream-lined approach for event organizers to access publicly-owned spaces and facilities for special events, currently supported by the Special Event Permit Application process. X X RDNO, COV, DOC X X RDNO, COV, DOC Ensure that approvals for new special events consider impacts on well-established existing community events. F2. Encourage infrastructure to support special events. Most special events take place in publicly-owned spaces, such as parks or roadways. Having the infrastructure in place to support special events, such as power outlets for vendors, or elevated areas for ad hoc performance spaces, go a long way in encouraging special events to take place, creating community vitality. REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 31 Page 49 of 101 PLAN STRATEGIES GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" SHORT TERM F2. ACTION ITEMS MED TERM ONGOING LEAD Work with local government partners and event organizers to provide additional, visible and effective locations to post signage and other publications that promote special events. X RDNO, COV, DOC, IAT Consider strategic public space improvements at appropriate sub-regional parks, including Kin and Kal Beach, that would improve the usability of the spaces by outdoor festivals and events. X RDNO Work with local governments to, wherever possible, design and equip public outdoor spaces, such as parks, sidewalks, boulevard areas, public gathering spaces, etc., with required infrastructure to host festivals and special events. X IAT G. Celebrate and protect our cultural heritage. G1. Develop a cultural heritage strategy. The Greater Vernon area has a good number of heritage assets, from infrastructure to intangible assets, like stories. Given the depth of information to consider, it is recommended that a separate the development of a heritage strategy be explored in cooperation with the municipal partners. SHORT TERM G1. ACTION ITEMS Explore with local partners, the opportunity to develop a cultural heritage strategy. MED TERM X ONGOING LEAD RDNO G2. Compile and share local, cultural heritage stories. Given the wealth of local stories, there is an opportunity to share these stories as part of the promotion of the cultural assets of the community. Visitors are looking for unique experiences, and it is Greater Vernon’s history that makes it stand out from other Okanagan communities. There could be many partners involved with pulling together an inventory of community stories, including but not limited to the IAT, the Greater Vernon Museum and Archives, the Caetani Cultural Society, O’Keefe Ranch Society, and the Okanagan First Nations. 32 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN PLAN STRATEGIES Page 50 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" SHORT TERM G2. ACTION ITEMS MED TERM Working with appropriate expertise, incorporate local cultural heritage stories in appropriate sources, such as parks and trail brochures, interpretive signage, public art and Tourism publications. ONGOING X LEAD RDNO, IAT H. Increase awareness of and participation in local cultural activities. H1. Increase public awareness of Greater Vernon’s cultural assets. Although Greater Vernon offers extensive and varied cultural activity and programming, it can currently be challenging to get a full picture of all of the activity taking place. The lack of both a complete event calendar, and a full and accessible inventory with map of the community’s cultural assets, leaves locals and visitors alike struggling to get the information they need to attend the cultural activities available. By streamlining an event calendar, maintaining an inventory of cultural assets, and taking advantage of cross-promotion between cultural organizations, the existing cultural programs can receive greater exposure and attract new participants and larger audiences. SHORT TERM H1. ACTION ITEMS Identify an appropriate lead organization and mechanism for maintaining and delivering a comprehensive Greater Vernon cultural events calendar. X Integrate the cultural asset inventory into public mapping systems, using interactive programs that allow the integration of photos and supplemental information for visitors, and make the mapping information available to the public. ONGOING LEAD X RDNO, ACNO, Tourism Vernon X Locally embrace, participate in and promote national Culture Days program. Consider developing a Greater Vernon reciprocal membership program to encourage regular users of certain cultural facilities to visit other cultural facilities through the membership benefits and incentives. MED TERM RDNO, IAT X X IAT/All orgs IAT REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 33 Page 51 of 101 PLAN STRATEGIES GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" Support the Community Foundation of the North Okanagan in its regular reporting on the state of arts and culture in the community, through the Vital Signs program. Encourage standardized data collection by publicly funded and privately operated cultural service providers, which will contribute to better community reporting and auditing, and support accountability requirements associated with public funding. X X IAT, RDNO X X RDNO, IAT H2. Improve access to and participation rates of cultural programming. Working with social agencies and cultural services providers, the IAT can help to develop strategies for providing additional low-cost or free opportunities for engagement in arts and cultural activities, focusing on demographics that are currently underserved in cultural program participation. Use of existing programs should be considered, such as the Institute for Canadian Citizenship’s Cultural Access Pass, which provides one year of free access to cultural facilities for new immigrants. SHORT TERM H2. ACTION ITEMS Working with cultural service providers, develop strategies for increasing low-cost or free opportunities for engagement in cultural activities, focusing on demographics that are currently underserved in cultural program participation. Partner with organizations on projects or initiatives with shared objectives of improving accessibility, inclusivity and participation in cultural activities. MED TERM ONGOING X LEAD IAT X IAT H3. Promote and support existing local programs that recognize local cultural icons and success stories. A number of existing programs in the community celebrate local cultural icons and success stories, including the Okanagan Arts Awards, the Okanagan Sports Hall of Fame and the local business awards. Supporting these programs, and in the case of the business awards, encouraging participation from the creative and cultural industries will help ensure that they continue to celebrate these icons and provide a source of stories that help to define our collective community identity. 34 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN PLAN STRATEGIES Page 52 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" SHORT TERM H3. ACTION ITEMS MED TERM Support the recognition of local cultural icons and success stories by supporting, promoting, and encouraging local nominations to programs such as: Okanagan Arts Awards, Okanagan Sports Hall of Fame, Local business awards ONGOING X Profile local cultural icons or stories through signage, public art and at local festivals or events. X LEAD IAT IAT I. Support youth engagement in culture. I1. Target youth for participation in volunteer and work opportunities with local cultural organizations. Engaging youth in local cultural and creative industry employment and volunteerism will help with the succession planning for these organizations and businesses. Youth participation also brings new ideas, expanding on the diverse fabric that makes up our community. SHORT TERM I1. ACTION ITEMS Establish formal connections with local cultural organizations and existing and emerging youth employment programs. MED TERM X Encourage NFP boards to actively seek out youth participation on their boards as volunteers. X X LEAD IAT X Develop a partnership with Okanagan College and UBC Okanagan to encourage course-related project work to be connected with and support local cultural organizations. Continue to seek out priority actions that would support youth engagement in culture, which may include: • consultation with OUC, UBCO and SD22 or the NOYFSS Youth Engagement Committee • an audit of existing opportunities for youth engagement in culture. • identifying and addressing the barriers to participation in cultural programming and events. ONGOING IAT IAT X IAT REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 35 Page 53 of 101 PLAN STRATEGIES GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" • Encourage and support events that engage, celebrate and recognize youth in the community, such as YAA Fest or the discontinued Our Kids Have Talent. X IAT, RDNO J. Okanagan First Nations. J1. Increase communication and collaboration with Okanagan First Nations. Okanagan First Nations participation on the IAT should be encouraged as the integral part of Vernon’s cultural scene that they are. Okanagan First Nation stories, cultural traditions and artists’ work should be shared and celebrated within the Greater Vernon community. SHORT TERM J1. ACTION ITEMS MED TERM ONGOING LEAD Share the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan with the Okanagan First Nations X RDNO Establish a First Nations contact and/or representative for the Cultural Plan/IAT X RDNO Identify and, wherever possible, proceed with projects that support shared goals cultural development goals. X RDNO, IAT K. Support neighbourhood cultural projects. K1. Support grassroots neighbourhood culture initiatives Cultural activity at a neighbourhood level helps to build community. SHORT TERM K1. ACTION ITEMS 36 MED TERM ONGOING LEAD Support local community associations or neighbourhood groups in the implementation of neighbourhood cultural initiatives, such as the installation of public art, or recognition of heritage locations or stories X IAT, COV, RDNO, DOC Review and, where necessary, recommend amendments to local government bylaws, policies, and processes to allow for neighbourhood produced cultural activities, such as neighbourhood block parties or localized events. X IAT, COV, RDNO, DOC | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN PLAN STRATEGIES Page 54 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" K2. Incorporate cultural considerations in local neighbourhood projects and planning. SHORT TERM K2. ACTION ITEMS MED TERM ONGOING Encourage and support local governments in incorporating cultural aspects into neighbourhood development projects, wherever possible. X LEAD IAT Cultural Places and Spaces Great places and spaces support and enhance Greater Vernon’s cultural vitality. Greater Vernon is in an enviable position of having an assembly of cultural resources and facilities that remain relevant, meaningful, and useful to the community. Many in the community feel that Greater Vernon needs new or enhanced spaces for various arts and cultural purposes, including: space for performing arts (especially music); more cultural facilities and activities for youth; a new art gallery; and others. These community perceptions have been tested through a needs assessment that was conducted as part of the Plan, with details included in the Greater Vernon Cultural Facilities Discussion Paper, included in Volume 2 to this Plan. The assessment found that a number of existing publicly-owned cultural facilities are not adequate for their intended purpose, and provided a list of priorities for cultural infrastructure investment for the next ten years and beyond. The needs assessment also recognized that most of Greater Vernon’s publicly-owned cultural infrastructure, with the exception of the Vernon and District Performing Arts Centre, is aging and will require regular and significant maintenance and, in the case of the Vernon Public Art Gallery and the Greater Vernon Museum and Archives, significant renovations or replacement. L. Support the healthy use, condition and development of cultural facilities. L1. Protect and maintain existing Regional District cultural facilities. As part of their support for culture, the Regional District has agreed to own (freehold or license) facilities that it will provide for the cultural purposes as listed in the scope of the service. In order to ensure that these facilities service the community well into the future, there must be a commitment to regular maintenance and long-term replacement planning. SHORT TERM L1. ACTION ITEMS Establish agreements between the Regional District and those organizations occupying Regional District cultural facilities, outlining roles and responsibilities for facility maintenance, using the guidelines outlined in the Roles and Responsibilities for the Maintenance of Regional District Cultural Facilities, shown on page 39 of the Cultural Plan. X MED TERM ONGOING LEAD RDNO REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 37 Page 55 of 101 PLAN STRATEGIES GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" Conduct a building assessment for all Regional District cultural facilities, and develop or update a preventative maintenance/replacement program for each. X Use the Cultural Infrastructure Investment Guidelines, outlined on page 43 of the Cultural Plan, for evaluating all funding requests to support major repairs, replacement or improvement projects within Regional District cultural facilities. X Develop a long-range improvement/replacement program for Regional District cultural facilities. Establish and build up a Cultural Facility Reserve for new or significant repairs/improvements to Regional District cultural facilities. Explore with local partners, the opportunity to develop a collective cultural heritage strategy which would provide direction around ownership, maintenance and operation of heritage facilities, including the Caetani Cultural Centre. GALLERY VERTIGO NORTH OKANAGAN ARTISTS ALTERNATIVE, YOUTH DRUMMING 38 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN PLAN STRATEGIES Page 56 of 101 RDNO X X X RDNO RDNO RDNO X RDNO, COV, DOC GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" ROLES AND RESPONSIBILITIES FOR THE MAINTENANCE OF REGIONAL DISTRICT CULTURAL FACILITIES (adopted January 20, 2016) The following general guidelines be used for drafting the operating and management agreements with not-for-profit organizations occupying Regional District facilities: The Regional District: • will, at its own expense, be responsible for maintaining the structural components of the building (i.e. the building envelope); subject to building assessments and agreements with building owners regarding pre-existing conditions. • will set aside an annual budget allocation for capital funding to be used for facility replacement items, such as mechanical, electrical, plumbing and flooring. • may provide funding to offset building occupancy costs associated with the facility, including utilities; and, • will, at its own expense, be responsible for maintaining property insurance, except for contents insurance, for Regional District owned and licensed facilities. The occupant not-for-profit organization will: • be responsible for the operation and programming of the facility in accordance with the guidelines and expectations outlined in a multi-year operating and management agreement; and • be responsible for maintaining the interior of the facility, including repair and replacement required due to regular wear and tear, with funding responsibilities to be negotiated as part of each operating and management agreement. L2. Maximize the community benefit and value of Regional District cultural facilities. As the cultural facilities provided by the Regional District are for the benefit of the community, it should be ensured that all reasonable steps are taken to maximize the use of the facilities, and that the use of the facilities is appropriate and adheres to guidelines outlined by the Regional District. REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 39 Page 57 of 101 PLAN STRATEGIES GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" SHORT TERM L2. ACTION ITEMS MED TERM ONGOING LEAD Where agreements exist, or are to be established, between the Regional District and registered NFP organizations who occupy Regional District owned cultural facilities, include expectations and conditions of funding in the agreement document, as guided by performance indicators shown below. X X RDNO Regularly review the quality of service being provided within the Regional District cultural facilities, ensuring: • adherence to funding eligibility criteria (if applicable), • adequate support levels, and • value for investment based on the NFP Performance Indicators shown below. X X RDNO Ensure that Regional District cultural facilities are being utilized by the community to their maximum reasonable potential. X X RDNO NOT-FOR-PROFIT ORGANIZATION PERFORMANCE INDICATORS • Demonstrate good governance, through the establishment of long term plans and a well-functioning Board of Directors. • Demonstrate healthy operations through policy manuals, sound operating practices and evidence of good standing as a society. • Provide efficient, high quality and inclusive service to the community, demonstrated through diverse and increasing participation and membership. • Demonstrate financial stability through growth of own-source revenue streams, including fees, funding from other levels of government and private sources. • Maintain good records, such as visitorship numbers and demographics, volunteer hours, etc. • Demonstrate collaborative spirit, and cooperation in joint projects of mutual benefit with other community partners. • Adheres to all reporting requirements and other commitments as outlined in standing agreements with the Regional District. 40 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN PLAN STRATEGIES Page 58 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" L3. Remove barriers to cultural use of publicly-owned facilities. The use of publicly owned facilities and spaces (such as parks) for cultural special events and temporary cultural uses are important when providing access to and variation of cultural activity. SHORT TERM L3. ACTION ITEMS MED TERM ONGOING LEAD Work with user groups and appropriate local government departments to continue to identify and, wherever possible, remove existing and emerging barriers to the community use of local government owned facilities for cultural activities. This may include: • establishing joint-use agreements with SD22 • enabling short-term rental agreements or longer-term lease agreements for special purposes (such as the Print-Triennial Pop-up Art Gallery) X X RDNO, COV, DOC • harmonize existing policies, bylaws and permitting processes to support cultural activity at publicly-owned facilities or spaces (such as parks, streetways). L4. Support the development, maintenance and sharing of a detailed cultural facility inventory. Maintaining an inventory of available and suitable spaces for cultural activities will help to find possible solutions for space needs within existing facilities. Keeping a record of existing cultural facilities and spaces may also help identify gaps when considering new cultural spaces. SHORT TERM L4. ACTION ITEMS Working with information collected during the development of the Cultural Plan, expand on and keep current a list of specific cultural space gaps/needs in the community. Establish a cultural facility and spaces inventory, which would include both public and private spaces, and explore the opportunity to make the inventory public and searchable to maximize the use of available spaces. MED TERM X X ONGOING X LEAD IAT IAT REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 41 Page 59 of 101 PLAN STRATEGIES GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" Use the cultural facility inventory to identify and help find solutions to address gaps in facilities and services. X IAT, RDNO Develop a process to align community cultural gaps and needs with vacant and appropriate spaces, utilizing the cultural facility and spaces inventory, or other existing sources of information, such as the City of Vernon’s SpaceList database of commercial properties. X IAT Encourage the use of shared spaces amongst NFP cultural organizations. X IAT, RDNO M. Enable the development of new cultural facilities. M1. Support the development of new/improved cultural facilities and spaces. The use of guidelines when considering investment in new/expansion of cultural infrastructure, ensures that there is consistency and equity in each instance. The Cultural Infrastructure Investment Guidelines on page 43 were adopted by the Regional District Board of Directors on December 9, 2015. For new construction, all long-term planning for new facilities that will be owned by the Regional District must be endorsed and facilitated by the Regional District prior to being initiated. SHORT TERM M1. ACTION ITEMS Apply the Cultural Infrastructure Investment Guidelines on page 43 to any new cultural infrastructure investment. 42 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN PLAN STRATEGIES Page 60 of 101 MED TERM ONGOING LEAD X RDNO GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" C U LT U R A L I N F R A ST R U C T U R E I N V EST M E N T G U I D E L I N ES N E W FAC I L I T I ES (adopted December 9, 2015) The following guidelines will be used by the Regional District for investing in new, repurposed or expanded cultural facilities: • New, repurposed or expanded spaces / facilities will be flexible and adaptable. • New, repurposed or expanded spaces / facilities will be multi-purpose with a partnership approach, and collocation of facilities will be considered. • New, repurposed or expanded spaces / facilities will be located within the City of Vernon’s City Centre Neighbourhood area, wherever possible. • A minimum contribution of 10% of the total project cost will come from sources other than the Regional District. • There will be demonstrated support from the community, justified by evidence of demand. • There will be a realistic plan for adequate, ongoing operating funding for the facility. E X I ST I N G FAC I L I T I ES The Regional District will use the following guidelines for prioritizing funding of major maintenance/replacement/improvements of existing Regional District cultural facilities: Urgent/essential repairs/replacement at existing facility 1. health/safety 2. asset preservation/protection Non Urgent/essential repairs/replacement at existing facility 3. energy efficiency improvements/items with reasonable payback period 4. items to meet long-term plans Improvements/upgrades to existing facility 5. provides increased capacity 6. provides increased service / enhanced user experience 7. achieves aesthetic improvement REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 43 Page 61 of 101 PLAN STRATEGIES GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 NEW FACILITY DEVELOPMENT PROCESS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 44 44 Cultural facility needs identified Facility needs are identified through a needs assessment by way of: Attachment "A" • recommendationwithinanadoptedRegionalDistrictplanningdocument; • imminent facility failure / loss of access; and/or • demonstrated evidence that regular programming demand has chronically exceeded facility capacity for several years. Inadditiontotheabovetriggers,theremustbeadherancetotheCulturalInfrastructureInvestmentGuidelines(page 43) and demonstrated on-going community need. The demonstrated need must consider impacts that related trends mayhaveonthepastorfuturelevelsofdemand.Thismayincludetrendssuchaspopulation,demographics,program/ service popularity, or program/service delivery methods (i.e. certain services may be increasingly provided on-line; newactivities,whichareincreasinginpopularity,requiredifferenttypes/amountsofspaces). Regional District agrees to preliminary exploration of project InordertoproceedtoexplorethedevelopmentofanewfacilitythatwouldultimatelybeownedbytheRegional District,theRegionalDistrictmustgiveapprovalforpreliminaryexplorationoftheproject.Thiswillrequirethatall participantsoftheserviceareagreeabletoputti ngresourcestowardsteps3and4.Theremustbeahighdegree ofinterestinaddressingtheidentifiedneedsforanewfacility,aswellasawillingnesstocommitti ngtheresources necessary,withinreason,asexpectationswillbeestablishedbyinitiatingthisprocess. Cultural programming plan Theculturalprogramplanistheprocessofdefiningwhatneedsweareconstructingthefacilitytomeet.Thisis thestepwherewetakeourneedsassessmentanddeterminewhetherthereareotherculturalorganizationswith facilityneedsthatwouldhavepracticalsynergies,whereco-locationcouldbeusedtoincreasetheuse/valueofa new facility/space. This may mean joint occupancy, or it could just be regular rental/tenancy. This is also the point whereavalue-addedspace(s)maybeconsidered,suchastheadditionofacaféorothercomplimentaryservice thatcouldberentedoutforthegenerationofrevenuetooffsetoperatingorconstructioncosts. Building program Oncewehaveclearlyidentifiedthepurposesforwhichthefacilitywillbebuilttoaddress,wecanthenstartto designthefacilitytomeetthosepurposes.Insomecasestheremaybestandardsandbestpracticesthatcanbe usedtohelpwiththisstep,howevertheprocessmustalsobeguidedbythefinancialrealityofbothconstructing andoperatingthefacility,sincethedesignofthebuildingwillhaveimplicationsforboth. Thisstepwilllikelybeiterativeandwillrequirefacilitation,particularlyiftherearemultiplestakeholders(whichwill almost always be the case). It will also be dependent on the size and availability of land and may result in having to move back to the cultural program development stage, if the appropriate property can not be obtained. Budget development Thefinancialplanforboththecapitalcostandtheongoingoperatingbudgetforthenewfacilitywilldependon acombinationoftheculturalprogramplanandthebuildingprogram.Theculturalprogramplanmayinclude opportunitiestogeneraterevenue,whichcanbeusedtooffsettheoveralloperatingorconstructioncostsofthe facility(suchascommercialrentalrevenue).Thisadditionalsquarefootagecouldalsobeincludedaspartofalongterm growth plan, where the cultural programming can move into the commercial rental space. Regional District agrees to proceed with project In order for the project to proceed, the Regional District must have an eligible service and be in agreement to fund theconstructionandanynecessaryon-goingoperatingcosts.Thismayrequireanamendmentofscopeofan existingservice,ortheestablishmentofanewservice.Theprojectwillnotcontinuepastthisstepifagreementis not achieved. Financing Thefinancingforthecapitalconstructionofanewfacilitymayincludeanumberofdifferentsources.As outlinedintheendorsedguidingprinciplesfornewculturalfacilities,aminimumof10%ofthecapital funding for any new cultural facility must come from sources other than the Regional District (without conditions).TheRegionalDistrictmaychoosetoprovidesomeoralloftheremainderofthenecessary funding,andithasacoupleofmechanismsavailable.Responsibiltyforalloperatingfundingshouldbe clearlyidentifiedanddocumented. | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN Construction Page 62 of 101 ConstructionwillbeleadbytheRegionalDistrictthroughaconstructi onmanagementteam. STEPS GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 2. REGIONAL DISTRICT AGREES TO PRELIMINARY EXPLORATION OF PROJECT Attachment "A" 3. CULTURAL PROGRAMMING PLAN 1. Compile a list of space needs as determined through a recognized needs assessment measure. 2. Refer list of needs to the a steering team of stakeholders, facilitated by the Regional District, who will consider the needsandidentifypotentialsynergies,inconsultationwithaffectedserviceproviders/organizations. 3. Thesteeringteamwilldevelopalistofstrengths,weaknesses,opportunitiesandthreatsforthepotentialsynergies beingaccommodatedinonebuilding,withgeneralfinancialparametersprovidedbytheRegionalDistrict. 4. BUILDING PROGRAM 1. Using the recommended list of building space needs as a result of the cultural program plan, start to develop the buildingprogram,whichincludesthebuildingrequirementsfortheidentifiedneeds(HVACconsiderations,etc), andspacesizes,proximities.Thiswillrequiresignificantconsultationwiththeserviceproviders/organizations,as wellassupportfromanexperiencedarchitectandquantitysurveyor. 2. Oncethesizeofthefacilityisdetermined,existingpublicly-ownedpropertiesshouldbeexaminedandassessedfor suitability.Thiscouldincludenew-buildorre-purposingofexistingbuildings,providedthattheyarelargeenough and suitable for re-purposing. The area of focus should be the Vernon’s City Centre Neighbourhood area. The buildingprogramprocessmaybeiterativeifasuitablysizedsitecannotbesecured,orthebudgetisgreaterthan availableoracceptable;howevercareshouldbetakennottocompromisetheobjectivesoftheprojectforsavings in size or cost. 5. BUDGET DEVELOPMENT 1. If the budget scope comes back greater than available or acceptable, the building program should be reviewed for areastocut-back,usingcautiontonotcompromisetheobjectivesoftheproject. 2. Financingoftheconstructioncostsshouldbediscussed,androles,responsibilities,andsourcesofrevenueshould beidentifiedforoperatingcosts,includingbothgeneralfacilitycostsandanticipatedprogrammingcosts. 3. Oncethefinalconstructionbudgetiscompleted,inadditiontotheanticipatedoperatingbudget,thefinancial implicationsfortheRegionalDistrictmustbetakenbacktotheRegionalDistrictforfinalapproval. 6. REGIONAL DISTRICT AGREES TO PROCEED WITH PROJECT 1. Understandingthefinancialimplicationsofboththeconstructionandongoingoperatingcostsoftheproject,ifall participantsoftheexistingserviceareinagreementtoproceedwiththeproject,theService Scope Amendment Process shouldbeinitiated(ifrequired). 2. Ifnotallparticipantsareinsupport,butthosethataresupportivearewillingtocreateanewservicetosupportthe new facility, then a new service should be established. 7. FINANCING 1. CAPITAL • Allidentifiedsourcesofcapitalfunding,otherthanthattobeprovidedbytheRegionalDistrict,shouldbesecured. • IfRegionalDistrictborrowingisrequiredfortheconstructioncostsoftheproject,theprocessforobtainingelector assentshouldbeinitiated(suggestedlead-timeforreferendumis6months,includingpubliceducation) 2. OPERATING • Agreementswithallpartieswhowilloccupythenewfacilityshouldbeestablished,usingtheguidelines established in the cultural plan and clarifying levels and mechanisms for any Regional District funding. 8. CONSTRUCTION 1. Establishaconstructionmanagementteamwhowilloverseetheconstructionoftheproject. 2. Establishtheconstructionprocess(ie.Design-Build,constructionmanagement,engineer-procure-constructor design-bid-build, etc.) and suitable contract types (cost-plus, lump sum, guaranteed maximum, etc.). REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN 3. Initiateconstruction,tobeleadbytheRegionalDistrictthroughaconstructionmanagementteam. Page 63 of 101 | 45 45 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" SHORT TERM M1. ACTION ITEMS MED TERM ONGOING LEAD Initiate the New Facility Development Process, shown on page 44/45, for a new multi-purpose cultural facility, that would seek to address the identified gaps and deficiencies of: • Public Art Gallery, as identified in the Vernon Public Art Gallery - Canadian Conservation Institute Assessment (2014) • Museum and Archives, as identified in the Greater Vernon Museum and Archives Canadian Conservation Institute Assessment (2014) • adaptable (black-box) small performance space (suggested seating for 75-100) X RDNO The process should also consider other community needs and potential synergies, such as those of Gallery Vertigo, and the potential for space to accommodate more youth-focused programming, ensuring that any resulting change in scope to the Regional District’s Greater Vernon Cultural Services follows the appropriate process as outlined in the Scope Amendment Process shown on page 19. Advocate for consistent and adequate provincial and federal funding level investment for new cultural facilities and maintenance of existing cultural facilities. Encourage the City of Vernon and the District of Coldstream to investigate potential incentive programs and development approval processes, in addition to existing revitalization tax exemption programs, that could encourage the construction of new cultural facilities. Encourage the consideration of adding space to meet cultural space needs when planning for the expansion or new construction of any new public facilities, not exclusive to Regional District or purpose-built cultural facilities. This could involve the development of partnerships. 46 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN PLAN STRATEGIES Page 64 of 101 X X RDNO, IAT X IAT X IAT GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" N. Encourage a culturally vibrant and connected public realm. N1. Support infrastructure that encourages a culturally vibrant community. By ensuring that public spaces are equipped with the infrastructure to support cultural activity, such as power outlets for vendors in parks or wide sidewalks to allow for street performances, we can encourage activity that creates a more vibrant community. SHORT TERM N1. ACTION ITEMS Work with local government wherever possible, design and equip public outdoor spaces (parks, sidewalks, boulevard areas, public gathering spaces) for cultural activity such as festivals and special events, presentations, street performances or public art. This could include the provision of power in parks, wider affordances on sidewalks, or the provision of space for public art. MED TERM X ONGOING X LEAD IAT N2. Encourage and support projects and policy that support activating public areas. External funding for festivals and special events exists, but often requires that an event has been run for at least one year. The seed money that is provided for events through the Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth grant can enable these initiatives to get started and ultimately become self-sustainable. SHORT TERM N2. ACTION ITEMS MED TERM ONGOING LEAD Support organizations in their efforts to develop programs or activities that activate public areas, which may include: • continued funding through the appropriate grant streams for activities such as festivals or events; • assistance with meeting regulatory and permitting requirements; X RDNO, COV, DOC • facilitation of promotion and marketing of programs or activities through new or existing channels. REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 47 Page 65 of 101 PLAN STRATEGIES GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" O. Promote natural areas as cultural assets. Community consultation indicated that natural areas, such as trails and lakes, were considered to be important cultural assets in the community. These assets should be included in the larger inventory, and the promotion of natural areas and trails harmonized with the cultural branding and promotion. SHORT TERM O1. ACTION ITEMS MED TERM ONGOING LEAD Create, maintain and promote an inventory of key natural areas that are culturally significant to Greater Vernon. X RDNO Harmonize the marketing of the community’s natural areas and trails with Greater Vernon’s cultural brand. X RDNO X RDNO Encourage cultural programming that is inspired by nature, or located in Greater Vernon’s natural environment, with consideration of the use of financial incentives (such as increased weighting in the project grant program) P. Protect, support and encourage public art. P1. Promote and protect existing public art. Greater Vernon’s existing public art is unique, and helps enhance Greater Vernon’s story. SHORT TERM P1. ACTION ITEMS Encourage the promotion of existing public art, such as the Downtown Vernon Association murals, the multi-cultural mosaic at City Hall, and the sculptures and masks at the Vernon and District Performing Arts Centre. Advocate for the maintenance and support of existing public art, and have existing public art considered in future public art programs. 48 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN PLAN STRATEGIES Page 66 of 101 MED TERM ONGOING LEAD X IAT X IAT GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" P2. Develop local government policy to support and encourage public art. Encouraging the development of public art and associated policies will require cooperation with the local municipalities. IAT can play a support role. SHORT TERM P2. ACTION ITEMS Encourage and support the City of Vernon, the District of Coldstream and, where appropriate, the Regional District Electoral Areas B and C, in the development of public art policies and sustainable public art programs. Develop a public art policy for parks under the management of the Regional District that is complimentary, or combined as part of, the public art policies of the City of Vernon and the District of Coldstream Encourage partnership promotion of public art programs with municipal neighbours, where appropriate. Encourage partnerships with community organizations to enable the installation of public art that increases awareness of, or helps to address, some of the community’s social objectives (Literacy in the Environment; Welcoming Communities; EmbraceBC), or tell the community’s stories. MED TERM ONGOING LEAD X IAT X RDNO X IAT X IAT REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN | 2016 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 49 Page 67 of 101 PLAN STRATEGIES GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" APPENDICES Appendix A - Motion Extracts related to the development of the Cultural Plan passed by the Regional District of North Okanagan Board of Directors VOLUME 2 Volume 2 includes the following background documents: Huhtala, K. (2014). Greater Vernon Cultural Plan - Policy Directions (pp. 1-41). Coldstream, BC: Regional District of North Okanagan. Lippa, S. and Nelson, T (2015). Greater Vernon Cultural Facilities - Discussion Paper (pp. 1-18). Vancouver, BC: City Spaces Consulting Ltd. Karsten, I. F. (2015). Facility Assessment for Vernon Public Art Gallery (pp. 1-37, Rep. No. Report No. 126672a). Ottawa, ON: Canadian Conservation Institute. Karsten, I. F. (2015). Facility Assessment for Greater Vernon Museum and Archives (pp. 1-37, Rep. No. Report No. 126672a). Ottawa, ON: Canadian Conservation Institute. 50 | GREATER VERNON CULTURAL PLAN | 2016 | REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN Page 68 of 101 APPENDICES GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 APPENDIX A Regional District Board of Directors Motion Extracts related to the development of the Cultural Plan Attachment "A" Meeting Date Report Titled March 19, 2014 Greater Vernon Cultural Plan, 2014‐ Terms of Reference November 5, 2014 Greater Vernon Cultural Plan Policy Directions April 15, 2015 June 17, 2015 Greater Vernon Cultural Plan – Prioritization and Implementation Planning Greater Vernon Cultural Plan (direction re: scope) October 21, 2015 Vernon Public Art Gallery (receipt of letter) December 9, 2015 Greater Vernon Cultural Plan – Workshop 8 (new facility guidelines) January 6, 2016 Greater Vernon Cultural Plan – Workshop 9 (direction re new/existing facilities) Greater Vernon Cultural Plan – Notice of Motion February 10, 2016 Page 69 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN Extract from the Minutes of a Meeting of the Board of Directors Held on March 19, 2014 Greater Vernon Cultural Plan, 2014- Terms of Reference That the Terms of Reference for the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan, as outlined in the staff report dated February 18, 2014 and titled "Greater Vernon Cultural Plan, 2014 Terms of Reference", be approved; and further, That Director Juliette Cunningham, Director Bob Fleming and District of Coldstream Councillor Maria Besso be appointed to sit on the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan Steering Team for the duration of the Cultural Plan project; and further, That a letter be sent to the City of Vernon, requesting a planning or tourism staff representative to sit on the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan Steering Team for the duration of the Cultural Plan project; and further, That a letter be sent to the District of Coldstream, requesting a planning or tourism staff representative to sit on the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan Steering Team for the duration of the Cultural Plan project. CARRIED Opposed: Directors Lord and O'Keefe Page 70 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN Extract from the Minutes of a Meeting of the Board of Directors Held on November 5, 2014 Greater Vernon Cultural Plan Policy Directions Moved and seconded by Directors Cunningham and Macnabb That the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan Policy Directions, be endorsed as presented. CARRIED Page 71 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN Extract from the Minutes of a Meeting of the Board of Directors Held on April 15, 2015 Greater Vernon Cultural Plan – Prioritization and Implementation Planning Moved and seconded by Directors Cunningham and Macnabb That the results of the prioritization workshop exercise completed by the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee at the Regular meeting on April 2, 2015, be considered for inclusion in the implementation plan for the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan. CARRIED Page 72 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN Extract from the Minutes of a Meeting of the Board of Directors Held on June 17, 2015 Greater Vernon Cultural Plan Moved and seconded by Directors Cunningham and Quiring That working within existing resources, the following direction be provided to support the development of the Greater Vernon Cultural Implementation Plan: The Regional District will only fund independent registered societies Any operating funding provided by the Regional District will have an operating agreement and/or contract for services (multi-year) in place The Regional District will provide facilities (not direct programming) for the following: o Cultural Conservation and Exhibition o Community Cultural Programming CARRIED Page 73 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN Extract from the Minutes of a Meeting of the Board of Directors Held on December 9, 2015 Greater Vernon Cultural Plan – GVAC Workshop No. 8 Moved and seconded by Directors Cunningham and Quiring That staff be directed to undertake discussions with the City of Vernon’s Administration regarding the transfer of the Okanagan Boys and Girls Club to the City of Vernon with support being incorporated into the Recreation and Programming Grant Service (063). CARRIED Moved and seconded by Directors Cunningham and Lord That the Regional District will use the following guidelines for investing in new, repurposed or expanded cultural facilities in Greater Vernon: - New, repurposed or expanded spaces / facilities will be flexible and adaptable. - New, repurposed or expanded spaces / facilities will be multi-purpose with a partnership approach, and co-location of facilities will be considered. - New, repurposed or expanded spaces / facilities will be located on public lands, wherever possible, and located within the Vernon’s City Centre Neighbourhood Plan area, wherever possible. - A minimum unconditional contribution of 10% of the total project capital cost will come from sources other than the Regional District. - There will be demonstrated support from the community, justified by evidence of demand. - There will be a realistic plan for adequate, ongoing operating funding for the facility. CARRIED Page 74 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN Extract from the Minutes of a Meeting of the Board of Directors Held on January 6, 2016 Greater Vernon Cultural Plan – GVAC Workshop No. 9 Moved and seconded by Directors Dirk and Cunningham That the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan include policy that both land and structure for any new purpose-built Cultural Facility in Greater Vernon be owned by the Regional District of North Okanagan. CARRIED Moved and seconded by Directors Dirk and Cunningham That staff be directed to develop new and/or amended license agreements with the City of Vernon for the following facilities: - 3400 30 Street, Vernon, BC That part of PID 010-862-927, Lot A, PL 39576 Sec. 34 TWP 9 ODYD - 2704A Hwy 6, Vernon, BC That part of BLK 31, Lots 4-7, Plan 327C ODYD - 2704A Hwy 6, Vernon, BC That part of PID 012-245-976, BLK A, Lot 6, Plan 327C Sec. 34 TWP 91 - 3800 33 Street, Vernon, BC PID 026-127-598, PL KAP76941, Lot 1, Sec. 3 TWP 8 ODYD CARRIED Moved and seconded by Directors Cunningham and Quiring That the Regional District follow the process for planning and development of new cultural facilities, as outlined in the report dated November 20, 2015, and titled, Cultural Facilities Workshop 9. CARRIED Moved and seconded by Directors Lord and Mund That the Regional District establish a Cultural Facility Reserve and set aside funds annually to support major cultural facility enhancement or new cultural facilities. CARRIED 1 Motion was amended to remove this facility on February 10, 2016. Page 75 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN Extract from the Minutes of a Meeting of the Board of Directors Held on January 20, 2016 Greater Vernon Cultural Plan – GVAC Workshop No. 9 Moved and seconded by Directors Cunningham and Quiring That staff be directed to develop five-year operating and management agreements with currently and annually funded organizations for the management and operation of Regional District owned or licensed cultural facilities; and further, That the following general guidelines be used for drafting the operating and management agreements with the not-for-profit organizations: The Regional District: - will, at its own expense, be responsible for maintaining the structural components of the building (i.e. the building envelope); subject to building assessments and agreements with building owners regarding pre-existing conditions. - will set aside an annual budget allocation for capital funding to be used for facility replacement items, such as mechanical, electrical, plumbing and flooring. - may provide funding to offset building occupancy costs associated with the facility, including utilities; and, - will, at its own expense, be responsible for maintaining property insurance, except for contents insurance, for Regional District owned and licensed facilities. The not-for-profit organization will: - be responsible for the operation and programming of the facility in accordance with the guidelines and expectations outlined in a multi-year operating and management agreement; and - be responsible for the maintenance of the facility, including repair and replacement required due to regular wear and tear, with funding responsibilities to be negotiated as part of each operating and management agreement. CARRIED Page 76 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.3 Attachment "A" REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN Extract from the Minutes of a Meeting of the Board of Directors Held on February 10, 2016 Notice of Motion – Greater Vernon Cultural Plan Moved and seconded by Directors Dirk and Fleming That the motion previously adopted at the Board of Directors Regular meeting held on January 6, 2016 regarding the Greater Vernon Cultural Plan – GVAC Workshop No. 9 be amended by deleting the following text from the previously adopted motion: 2704A Hwy 6, Vernon, B.C., That part of PID 012-245-976, BLK A, Lot 6, Plan 327C Sec. 34 TWP 9 ODYD. CARRIED Page 77 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.4 REGIONAL DISTRICT REPORT of NORTH OKANAGAN File No.: 5801.04.060.2016 TO: Greater Vernon Advisory Committee FROM: Parks, Recreation and Culture DATE: January 29, 2016 SUBJECT: Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Project Grant - 2016 RECOMMENDATION: That it be recommended to the Board of Directors, funding from the Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth project grant program be awarded as outlined in the report titled Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Project Grant- 2016 and dated January 29, 2016. BACKGROUND/HISTORY: In 2012 the Board of Directors adopted policy GVPRC-004 Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Project Grant Policy (Attachment "A"), which provides guidelines for a grant program for the purpose of supporting arts, culture and/or youth projects, through the Greater Vernon Parks, Recreation and Culture function (060). Each year the grant program is advertised in August, and applications are reviewed and brought forward to the Committee following the finalization of the Greater Vernon Parks, Recreation and Culture budget. DISCUSSION Grant Evaluation Process A grant evaluation rubric has been developed, and is included as Attachment "B". The Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Grant Evaluation Rubric includes three areas of evaluation: Excellence and Innovation; Impact; and Management. Excellence and Innovation focuses on application clarity, support of funding objectives (encourage the development of arts, culture and youth through project funding), project innovation and confidence in project success. This area of evaluation is given a weight of 40% of the overall application grade. Impact focuses on the accessibility of the project to the Greater Vernon community, multi-sector content (arts/culture/youth), involvement of community partners and the sustainability/contribution of the project. This area of evaluation is given a weight of 30% of the overall application grade. Management focuses on the history and ability of the applicant organization(s) and fiscal stability. This area of evaluation is given a weight of 30% of the overall application grade. Page 78 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.4 Report to: Greater Vernon Advisory Committee From: Parks, Recreation and Culture Re: Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Project Grant - 2016 File No.: 5801.04.060.2016 Date: January 29, 2016 Page 2 of 3 Grant Evaluation Results A summary of the 2016 applicants has been included as Attachment "C", and the full applications are available for review, upon request. There were nine applications received by the deadline, of which five are eligible as per the program guidelines outlined in the Policy. Two are ineligible because their application was for general operating funding, which is prohibited through the RDNO Policy: GVPRC-003, where organizations must be explicitly listed in the service establishment bylaw in order to receive operating funding. The other two ineligible projects are parks/recreation capital projects and, although both projects may offer a youth component, they have not been deemed appropriate for this funding opportunity. There may be opportunities to support these projects through other means in the future, as follows: 1. Vernon Rowing and Dragon Boat Club - Dock repair and expansion This project would see improvements to the existing dock owned by the Vernon Rowing and Dragon Boat Club, which is located on property south of the recently purchased Crane Road property (PIO 010-970-606). If the Club was unable to continue to operate on that location, the Regional District could look at opportunities to support the activity on the newly-purchased property. The dock proposed for construction on the new RDNO site would not be suitable for use by this Club, being too small. This project did receive funding through a discretionary grant from the City of Vernon. 2. Picnic Shelter at Paddlewheel Park This project would see the construction of a picnic shelter on property on Okanagan Lake that is owned by the Okanagan Landing and District Community Association, and leased (for public use) by the Regional District (Paddlewheel Park). This project could be considered in a future park planning process. The eligible applications have been evaluated using the Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Grant Evaluation Rubric, and the results are included as Attachment "D". Funding recommendations have been made, but it is anticipated that the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee may choose to make adjustments to these recommendations. EXISTING POLICY: RDNO Policy: GVPRC-004 Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Project Grant (Attachment "A") FINANCIAL/BUDGETARY CONSIDERATIONS: At a special budget meeting held on January 28, 2016, the Greater Vernon Advisory Committee recommended to the Board of Directors that $66,000 to be approved in the 2016 Greater Vernon Parks, Recreation and Culture (060) budget for the Greater Vernon Parks, Recreation and Culture Youth Project Grant. The intention of this funding is to support arts, culture and youth projects, with the application and selection process outlined in the GVPRC-004 Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Project Grant policy. The total cost of the grant awards, as recommended, is $23, 100 leaving $42,900 unallocated in the budget. The committee could choose to open a second intake, as there were groups that expressed interest after the deadline. The remaining funding could also be used for unforeseen projects that often come up mid-year, as was the case with the Vernon Public Art Gallery's - Pop-up Gallery. Page 79 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.4 Report to: Greater Vernon Advisory Committee From: Parks, Recreation and Culture Re: Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Project Grant - 2016 File No.: 5801.04.060.2016 Date: January 29, 2016 Page 3 of 3 COMMUNICATION CONSIDERATIONS: Organizations awarded funding will receive a formal letter of funding approval, and those who were unsuccessful will receive notice of such, along with an explanation regarding the decision not to award. ATTACHMENTS: A RDNO Policy: GVPRC-004 Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Project Grant B. Grant Evaluation Rubric C. 2016 Applications Summary D. Evaluation Results I Recommended Funding Levels Submitted by: / p.proved f r I cl I Tan Co 1 elson unity Development Coordinator stO~ General Manager, Finance ~ Page 80 of 101 n: GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.4 Attachment "A" REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN BOARD POLICY GVPRC -004 Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Project Grant Guidelines Board Approval Date: September 19th, 2012 Amendment Date(s): PURPOSE To provide guidelines for Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Project Grants, including eligibility, application process, and reporting requirements. DEFINITIONS Capital Improvement is the addition of a permanent structural improvement or the restoration of some aspect of a property that will either increase its useful life or enhance its value for existing or planned use. Project is an individual or collaborative enterprise that is carefully planned and designed to achieve a particular aim, which may be one-time and may be characterized by: • creation of new work or materials; • one-time capital improvement that will support on-going art, culture or youth programs and/or • new or emerging technologies, media, techniques and practices. Festival is a series of events, performances and/or activities that take place, usually in one place, which may occur over more than one day, and demonstrate established or potential audience support from a broad range of the community. Event is an organized performance, gathering, activity or cluster of activities that occurs on a single day. Art includes all genres within the following disciplines (list is not exhaustive and two or more genres or disciplines may be combined): • Performance (music, dance, theatre, spoken word, improvisation) • Visual (two and three dimensional I performance I fine or artisanal craft I site specific or temporary installation) • Literary (poetry/prose) • Media I new media (film/video/photography) • Design (fiber arts/graphic) Page 81 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.4 Attachment "A" Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Operating Grant Guidelines GVPRC -004 Culture is broadly conceived to include both tangible and intangible characteristics of the following elements, with activities and expression that explore, interpret and celebrate: • • • • Human diversity Ecology and environment (as themes for artistic practice or interpretation) Heritage collections, archives , documentation, interpretation Storytelling, narratives, traditions and values, artisanal methods Youth Programs are a system of services, activities or projects that focus on youth development through art, culture or recreation, which are designed to involve people who are 18 years or younger. Publicly Accessible means all members of the public can access the benefits of the Service without discrimination. POLICY STATEMENTS Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Project grants are intended to provide funding for a festival, event or project (including capital works) that feature publicly accessible arts, culture and/or youth based elements for the public benefit of Greater Vernon residents. Preference will be given to projects that demonstrate innovation and collaboration across sectors and interests. PROCEDURES 1.0 Funding Allocation The budget for project grants will be established annually by the Board of Directors. Funding applications will be approved by the Board of Directors based on recommendations from an adjudication process. 2.0 Eligibility In order to be eligible for Project Grants, all festivals, events and projects as defined above must: • Be open and/or accessible to the public, and reach beyond the organization's members and artists to the broader community; • Offer a unique experience not duplicated by other ongoing organizations and their activities; • Be a one-time or new initiative, or if existing, demonstrate expansion and growth (e.g. a trend of increase in audience, participation and/or activity); • Be supported by budgets which are distinct from regular operating budgets of the lead organization; and -2Page 82 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.4 Attachment "A" Greater Vernon Arts. Culture and Youth Operating Grant Guidelines GVPRC-004 • • Prominently feature art, cultural and/or youth content. Be conducted within the budget year for the funding awarded. • Be provided to Greater Vernon residents without exclusion to anyone by reason of religion, ethnicity, gender, age, sexual orientation, language, disability or income; Project grants will only be awarded to organizations that meet all of the following criteria: • Be a registered not-for-profit society that operates in Greater Vernon; • Have an independent, active governing body composed of volunteers (i.e. Board of Directors). Voting members of the Board of Directors of a Society receiving funds from RDNO may not concurrently hold a paid staff position with the society, and may not be paid for services to the society (excluding reimbursement for expenses); • Be in good standing with the B.C. Registrar of Societies and must have operated for at least one fiscal year prior to the application deadline; • Be able to demonstrate financial stability, sound administration and the organizational capacity necessary to carry out the project; • Demonstrate a proven track record of public service and excellence in programming and cultural production; • Demonstrate strong community ties and relationships; • Adhere to the accountability requirements set out with the approval of any discretionary grant; • Not be any one of the following: o lndividual(s); o Political parties and advocacy groups; o Religious groups; o Educational Institutions; o Third parties raising funds solely for charity or their own purposes. An organization's operating costs, including lease payments, staffing costs or other operating expenses, will not be eligible for funding within a Project Grant. 3.0 Application and Reporting Requirements Organizations must complete the application form, included as Schedule "A" and forming part of this policy. The application deadline for submission will be September 301h of the year prior to the year that the funding is requested for. Eligible organizations will have the opportunity to apply for project funds annually, using the application and reporting form attached and forming part of this policy. -3Page 83 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.4 Attachment "A" Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Operating Grant Guidelines GVPRC-004 Specific projects can only receive project funding for two consecutive years, and must demonstrate potential for growth to be eligible for a second year. -4- Page 84 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.4 Attachment "B" Grant Evaluation Rubric - Greater Vernon Arts, Culture and Youth Project Grant Value Description Excellent Strongly demonstrates public value of arts, culture 92-100 and/or youth. Merits investment of funding . Score .· Satisfactorily demonstrates public value of arts, 80-91 culture and/or youth. Merits investment of funding . Good ..· .. .. Fair Does not sufficiently demonstrate public value of arts, culture and/or youth. Does not merit investment of funding. 61-79 Weak Makes an incomplete or inadequate case for the public value of arts, culture and/or youth. Does not merit investment of funding. Information is unclear and/or lacks specific detail. 0-60 Page 85 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.4 ~ E Q) s:: ..c: (.) Jg <( Excellence and Innovation (up to 40 points) Support for Development of Arts, Culture and/or Youth Clear Project Description Identifies clear goals and Identifies clear goals and Identifies goals and fully measureable measureable objectives limited measureable objectives and activities objectives and activities Project strongly supports the development of arts, culture and/or youth in Greater Vernon. Project description Project description clearly describes describes proposed proposed project and the project and the project project prominently prominently features features arts, culture arts, culture and/or youth and/or youth. Project provides limited support for the development of arts, culture and/or youth in Greater Vernon. Project description describes proposed project but the project does not prominently feature arts, culture and/or youth. Fair 25-31 points Does not identify goals and very minimal objectives and activities. Project does not clearly provide support for the development of arts, culture and/or youth in Greater Vernon. Project description does not clearly describe project and the project does not prominently feature arts, culture and/or youth. Weak 0-24 points Good 32-36 points Clear Goals and Measureable Objectives Multiple concerns about the ability of the organization to carry out the proposal Excellent 37-40 points Confidence in Success Confident in the ability of Very minimal concerns Concerns about the the organization to carry about the ability of the ability of the organization out the project organization to carry out to carry out the proposal the proposal. Project supports the development of arts, culture and/or youth in Greater Vernon. Unique and Innovative Project offers an experience, not currently offered by other organizations. Project offers an Project offered by other experience that is similar organizations. to one provided by other organizations. Project offers a unique experience, not currently offered by other organizations. Page 86 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.4 ~ (]) c: ...... E ..c: 0 (ti ~ Features Art/CultureNouth Accessible to community Project prominently features a combination of art, cultural and/or youth content. Project is fully accessible to the public, and reach beyond the organization's members to the broader community; Excellent 28-30 points Project involves three or Project involves less more community than three community partners partners. Project features art, culture and/or youth content. Project is accessible to the public, and reach beyond the organization's members to the broader community; Good 24-27 points Project features minimal Project does not feature art, culture and/or youth art, culture and/or youth content. content. Project has limited accessibility to the public, and there is limited reach beyond the organization's members to the broader community. Fair 19-23 points Project is not accessible to the public and has limited or no reach beyond the organization's members to the broader community. Weak 0-18 points Impact (up to 30 points) Community Partners Project involves six or more community partners Reasonable activities are proposed and are achievable within the grant period. Concerns about sustainability Limited activities are proposed and/or there are concerns about achieving the activities within the grant period. Multiple concerns about sustainability. Very minimal activities are proposed and/or there are serious concerns about achieving the activities within the grant period. Project does not involve any community partners. Activity Extensive activities are proposed and are achievable within the grant period. Sustainability Very minimal concerns Very confident in the ability of the applicant to about sustainability sustain the project after the grant period. Page 87 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.4 Q) ~ _. c E ..!: ro (.) :t:: <( Key Personnel Key personnel and partners have clearly defined roles with related experience Excellent 28-30 points Key personnel have successfully completed a project of similar magnitude. Key personnel and partners have defined roles with some related experience Good 24-27 points Organization and/or key personnel have successfully completed a similar project of smaller scale. Key personnel and partners have loosely defined roles with minimal related experience Fair 19-23 points Organization and/or key personnel have not completed a similar project. Key personnel and partners do not have defined roles and/or have minimal related experience Weak 0-18 points Management (up to 30 points) Project History Organization has successfully completed a project of similar magnitude Minimal volunteer support provided. Multiple concerns about the organization's fiscal stability and ability to carry out the proposed activities given the proposed budget and fiscal information. Volunteer support is provided. Concerns about the organization's fiscal stability and/or ability to carry out the proposed actrivities given the proposed budget and fiscal information. Multiple concerns about the applicant's reporting history and current compliance. Volunteer Support Very minimal concerns about the organization's fiscal stability and ability to carry out the proposed activities given proposed budget and fiscal information. Concerns about the applicant's reporting history and current compliance. Volunteer training/support is provided. Fiscal Stability Very confident in the organization's fiscal stability and ability to carry out the proposed activities given proposed budget and fiscal information. Very minimal concerns about the applicant's reporting history and current compliance. Volunteer training/support is thorough. Reporting History Exemplary reporting history and current compliance. Page 88 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.4 Attachment "C" 2016 Greater Vernon Arts, Culture Youth Project Grant Summary North Okanagan Community Concert Association Project: Purchase of new, concert Grand Piano to be housed at VDPAC This request is to support the purchase of a new grand piano, which would be housed at the Vernon and District Performing Arts Centre. The current piano has served the community since 1953. Although the current piano has been well-maintained, and rebuilt I refurbished several times, it is simply no longer suitable for a concert hall like VDPAC. Therefore, NOCCA is purchasing and rebuilding a 30 year old 9 ft Hamburg Steinway concert grand piano and will take delivery in 2016. The cost of the new piano is approximately $86,000, including complete rebuild, refinishing, deliver and voicing. Most of that is being covered by NOCCA's piano fund that represents many years of savings. However, we are short $10,000. To help raise the funds, we are "selling" piano keys to music lovers in the community and we are asking RDNO for a grant of $5,000. If, however, the RDNO would rather sponsor a key, they are being sold for $100 each, or you can sponsor an actave (12 keys, including sharps and flats, for $1200. A large graphic piano keyboard will be on display at VDPAC during the 2015/2016 season. It will illustrate each community member supporting the piano fund by indicating their name on the key or keys that they have selected. Caetani Cultural Centre Society Organizational Development This project would allow the Gaetani Cultural Centre to do planning and resarch into moving our heritage status forward, identifying possible project and operational funding sources during this transitional period, gathering updated designs and quotes for the installation of a fire-suppression system, developing sound fundraising strategies and, implementing a concrete business plan for transitioning into a public heritatge site, with a stronger more community focused facility accessand programming. The ability to have a presentation space for community programming for audiences of up to 50 hinges on a fire-suppression system for this 120 year old designated heritage house. North Okanagan Pipes and Drums Society General operating General operating funding requested Page 89 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.4 Attachment "C" 2016 Greater Vernon Arts, Culture Youth Project Grant Summary Okanagan Similkameen Stewardship Society Project: Creating Monarch and Pollinator Habitat and Art Project The objective of the project is to teach students about the importance of habitat, in particular native species and pollinators. Along with the sustantial expansion of the existing garden on school grounds, which provides habitat for butterflies and other pollinators, the kids participating in the program will make paper or felted butterflies, mail them to Pacific Grove (mimicking the migration of the butterflies), and the Museum will create an exhibit of these butterflies. This project encompasses a number of different aspects for learning - including art projects, science projects, hands-on activities, as well as poetry and prose, as children write about their experiencies and share their changing perspectives. Vernon Rowing and Dragon Boat Club Project: Dock Repair and Expansion The project will allow the further development of youth rowing opportunities in Vern on. The dock improvements will create a legacy in our community, creating improved access to sport and events for a broad range of participants. The dock is 17 years old and was donated by Go Rowing and Paddling Association in 2014. Sections of the dock need to be replaced as they pose saftey hazards to participants. The dock space is currently limiting program growth. Greater Vernon Museum and Archives Project: Silver Star Historic Landmark Plaques and Walking Tours The purpose of the project is to create and install interpretive plaques at historic landmarks on Silver Star Mountain. The plaques will become part of guided and self-guided walking tours on the Mountain. Plaque locations would include: Forest Lookout Tower, First Nations Use, Scenic Highway, Brewer's Pond, Pinnacles Day Lodge, Cabin Colony, the first ski lifts and tow bars, etc. Okanagan Landing and District Comm unity Association Project: Picnic Shelter for Paddlewheel Park This project will construct a picnic shelter in Paddlewheel Park for the use of the residents and visitors in the area. There is currently no shelter in the park, and it is a very popular destination in the summer season and the summer days are getting hotter each year. This park is well used by youth in the community, in addition to being the location for summer camps with the Boys and Girls Club and Greater Vernon Recreation Services. Page 90 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.4 Attachment "C" 2016 Greater Vernon Arts, Culture Youth Project Grant Summary Vernon Folk Roots Music Society Project: Vernon Folk-Roots Music Society 2015/2016 Season The Vernon Folk-Roots Music Society (VFRMS) was formed in the spring of 2014. We are a not-forprofit, volunteer-driven, organization dedicated to bringing the best in local and travelling musical artists to the North Okanagan. The request is for general operating in order to help them achieve some longterm objectives, including: 1. attracting larger audiences and increasing our community profile by booking more established artists with more name recognition. 2. finding a permanent venue for our shows. 3. reducing the costs of putting on shows by purchasing our own sound and light equipment. 4. providing a community legacy through annual bursary to deserving students and providing opportunities for mentorship/experience. North Okanagan Optimists Club Project: Heritage Fair 2016 To have children research and prepare a display/presentation regarding a Canadian topic relevanUsignificant to Canadian history or heritage. The grant would be used to revise this event, which hasn't been run for a number of years. The funds would be used to rent the venue, provide t-shirts and awards to participants, and costs related to materials and supplies. Page 91 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item E.4 ~ ~ C <( 94.2 Funding Recommended $5,000 GRANT EVALUATION POINTS 29.6 Management TOTAL Excellence I Innovation 36.8 27.8 NA Impact Percent of Er "bl igi e total ro·ect 6% Yes Eligibility Issues Funding Re uested $5,000 I $8,ooo Purchase of new Grand Piano 96.8 General operating Gaetani Cultural Centre Society Organizational development project Project Name 34.8 0.0 $5,000 Organization 25.8 0.0 95.4 $0 136.2 0.0 29.4 0.0 $2,600 NA 28.0 0.0 85.8 Rationale Ineligible - general operating funds requested capital project Parks and recreation Parks and recreation capital project Yes 38.0 0.0 27.2 $0 Ineligible - general operating funds requested 38% NA 0.0 25.2 0.0 $0 $8,000 Yes Parks/recreation capital request 33.4 0.0 North Okanagan Community Concert Association 22% No NA 0.0 0.0 $2,500 $0 $5,000 50% Yes 0.0 0.0 98.4 No Monarch and Pollinator - Art and habitat project $5,046 50% Parks/recreation capital request 0.0 29.6 unknown Okanagan Similkameen Stewardship Society Dock repair and expansion $2,600 No 28.8 $5,000 Vernon Rowing and Dragon Boat Club Silver Star Historic Landmark Plaques and Walking Tours 50% ~ North Okanagan Pipes and :::;: Drums Society ..S::: Greater Vernon Museum and Archives $24,670 No NA 40.0 Yes General operating 0.0 requested Okanagan Landing and District Picnic Shelter for Paddlewheel Community Association Park 38% 27% $10,000 2015/2016 Season $2,500 General operating 0.0 requested Vernon Folk Roots Music Society North Okanagan Optimists Club Heritage Fair 2016 $23,100 Page 92 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item G.1 REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN MINUTES of a REGULAR meeting of the GREATER VERNON WATER 2012 MASTER WATER PLAN STAKEHOLDER ADVISORY COMMITTEE of the REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN held in the Boardroom at the Regional District Office on Thursday, February 18, 2016. Members: Staff: Alternate Director J. Garlick Director J. Cunningham D. Bodenham M. Carlson R. Foisy D. Frost D. Gibbs M. Hubbs-Michiel J. Lainsbury T. Mooney D. Neden J. Westby M. Witt District of Coldstream Chair City of Vernon Vice Chair Residential Representative Residential Representative Residential Representative Vernon Jubilee Hospital Representative Tekmar Control Systems Representative Residential Representative Residential Representative Citizens for Changes to the Master Water Plan Representative Residential Representative School District # 22 Representative Agricultural Representative D. McTaggart Z. Marcolin D. Douglas General Manager, Engineering Manager, Greater Vernon Water Clerk, Engineering Also Present: B. deWynter M. Baker K. Flick AECOM District of Coldstream, Director of Engineering City of Vernon, Director of Community Development, Engineering & GIS Agricultural Representative Agricultural Representative Highlands Golf Course J. Kidston T. Ouchi B. Mitchell Media and Public CALL MEETING TO ORDER The meeting was called to order at 8:02 a.m. APPROVAL OF AGENDA Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee – February 18, 2016 Moved and seconded by Representatives Lainsbury and Mooney That the Agenda of the February 18, 2016 Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee meeting be approved as presented. CARRIED Page 93 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item G.1 Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee Minutes – Regular -2- February 18, 2016 ADOPTION OF MINUTES Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee – January 21, 2016 Moved and seconded by Representatives Frost and Witt That the minutes of the January 21, 2016 Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee meeting be adopted as circulated. CARRIED UNFINISHED BUSINESS Greater Vernon Water Master Water Plan – Decision Making Process Review Brett deWynter, P.Eng., AECOM provided a presentation on the following: - Review of the past non-cost consideration process; and The “Criterium Decision Plus Decision Modeling Software” was presented and how these decision model principals were used for the decision making process to rank the 9 Options. Option Evaluations for the Non-Cost Considerations Following discussion on the evaluation method of the non-cost considerations, the Committee agreed the Master Water Plan Options would be ranked as follows: 1 – low importance 9 – high importance Moved and seconded by Representatives Frost and Bodenham That the Greater Vernon Water Evaluation Factors Master Water Plan Non-Cost Considerations spreadsheet be used by the Committee for evaluating the different categories. CARRIED Opposed: Representative Mooney The Committee split into three (3) groups according to their representation (residential, agriculture, commercial and industrial) excluding Greater Vernon Advisory Committee (GVAC) representation and RDNO staff, to begin the process of non-cost consideration ranking of Options. The Committee members were split into the following groups to complete the ranking of the NonCost Considerations: Group 1 Don Gibbs Ray Foisy Denise Bodenham Group 2 Doug Neden Terry Mooney David Frost Monique Hubbs-Michiel Page 94 of 101 Group 3 Jerry Westby Michael Carlson Michael Witt John Lainsbury GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item G.1 Page 95 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item G.1 REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN MINUTES of a REGULAR meeting of the GREATER VERNON WATER 2012 MASTER WATER PLAN STAKEHOLDER ADVISORY COMMITTEE of the REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN held in the Boardroom at the Regional District Office on Thursday, February 25, 2016. Members: Staff: Alternate Director J. Garlick Director J. Cunningham D. Gibbs D. Frost J. Westby T. Mooney A. Mohammad M. Witt D. Neden R. Foisy M. Carlson J. Lainsbury M. Hubbs-Michiel District of Coldstream Chair City of Vernon Vice Chair Tekmar Control Systems Representative Vernon Jubilee Hospital Representative School District No. 22 Representative Citizens for Changes to the Master Water Plan Representative Agricultural Representative Agricultural Representative Residential Representative Residential Representative Residential Representative Residential Representative Residential Representative D. McTaggart Z. Marcolin D. Douglas K. Witwicki General Manager, Engineering Manager, Greater Vernon Water Clerk, Engineering Clerk, Engineering Also Present: B. deWynter Director D. Dirk Councillor P. MacLean* M. Baker J. Kidston T. Ouchi K. Flick AECOM District of Coldstream District of Coldstream District of Coldstream Agricultural Representative Agricultural Representative City of Vernon, Director of Community Development, Engineering & GIS * Denotes presence for part of meeting CALL MEETING TO ORDER The meeting was called to order at 8:02 a.m. APPROVAL OF AGENDA Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee – February 25, 2016 Moved and seconded by Representatives Foisy and Mooney That the Agenda of the February 25, 2016 Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee meeting be approved as presented. CARRIED Page 96 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item G.1 Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee Minutes – Regular -2- February 25, 2016 ADOPTION OF MINUTES Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee – February 18, 2016 Moved and seconded by Representatives Neden and Frost That the minutes of the February 18, 2016 Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee meeting be adopted as circulated. CARRIED UNFINISHED BUSINESS Greater Vernon Water Master Water Plan - Option Evaluations using Non-Cost Considerations The Committee separated into three (3) groups to continue with the exercise of ranking the nine Long Term Water Supply Options (Options) from TM9 of the 2012 Greater Vernon Water Master Water Plan (MWP) based on Non-Cost Considerations. The Chair added Representative Asif to Group 1 and the groups were as follows: Group 1 Don Gibbs Ray Foisy Denise Bodenham Asif Mohammad Group 2 Doug Neden Terry Mooney David Frost Monique Hubbs-Michiel Group 3 Jerry Westby Michael Carlson Michael Witt John Lainsbury The groups completed their ranking of the Options based on the Non-Cost criteria developed and endorsed by the Stakeholder Advisory Committee (SAC) at the February 18 and February 25 SAC meetings. After a set time of approximately 1 hour and 45 minutes for group discussion, the groups submitted their ranking results to staff where the results were tabulated. The weighted average of each group’s result and the average of all the groups was then calculated and presented. The attached table provides the rating and weighted results of each group and the numerical and weighted averages for each Option (Attachment 1). Group 1 had Option 5 as their first choice and Option 2 as their second choice, Group 2 ranked Options 1, 2 and 3 highest with each having an equivalent numerical ranking and Group 3 had Option 2 and 3 ranked the highest with both having an equivalent numerical ranking. After discussion, the majority of the group agreed that Option 2 was likely the preferred option but that the discussion would continue at the next meeting where the cost to benefit ratio would be presented and a final vote on the preferred option would occur. The Chair discussed the dates of the upcoming meetings. It was decided that the Committee would meet on the following dates: February 29, 2016 March 17, 2016 April 14, 2016 April 21, 2016 3:30 PM – 5:00 PM 8:00 AM – 11:00 AM 8:00 AM – 11:00 AM 8:00 AM – 11:00 AM RDNO Boardroom RDNO Boardroom RDNO Boardroom RDNO Boardroom Page 97 of 101 Choose Option TM 8 Review TM10 & Financial plan Financial plan continued if required GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item G.1 Page 98 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item G.1 REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN MINUTES of a REGULAR meeting of the GREATER VERNON WATER 2012 MASTER WATER PLAN STAKEHOLDER ADVISORY COMMITTEE of the REGIONAL DISTRICT OF NORTH OKANAGAN held in the Boardroom at the Regional District Office on Monday, February 29, 2016. Members: Staff: Alternate Director J. Garlick Director J. Cunningham D. Gibbs D. Frost T. Mooney A. Mohammad M. Witt D. Neden* R. Foisy M. Carlson J. Lainsbury M. Hubbs-Michiel D. Bodenham P. Williamson District of Coldstream Chair City of Vernon Vice Chair Tekmar Control Systems Representative Vernon Jubilee Hospital Representative Citizens for Changes to the Master Water Plan Representative Agricultural Representative Agricultural Representative Residential Representative Residential Representative Residential Representative Residential Representative Residential Representative Residential Representative Residential Representative Z. Marcolin P. Juniper* D. Douglas Manager, Greater Vernon Water Deputy Corporate Officer Clerk, Engineering Also Present: B. deWynter Director D. Dirk M. Baker AECOM District of Coldstream District of Coldstream, Director of Infrastructure Services Agricultural Representative, Greater Vernon Advisory Committee J. Kidston * Denotes presence for part of meeting CALL MEETING TO ORDER The meeting was called to order at 3:33 p.m. APPROVAL OF AGENDA Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee – February 29, 2016 Moved and seconded by Representatives Asif and Hubbs-Michiel That the Agenda of the February 29, 2016 Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee meeting be approved as presented. CARRIED Page 99 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item G.1 Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee Minutes – Regular -2- February 29, 2016 ADOPTION OF MINUTES Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee – February 25, 2016 Moved and seconded by Representatives Witt and Frost That the minutes of the February 25, 2016 Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee meeting be adopted as circulated. CARRIED UNFINISHED BUSINESS Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan – Option Evaluations Using Non-Cost Considerations The Chair advised that all Stakeholder Advisory Committee correspondence should be circulated to the entire Committee including the Chair, Vice Chair and Regional District of North Okanagan staff to ensure transparency of the process. B. deWynter provided a presentation on the Options selection, Net Present Value (NPV) and the Benefit to Cost Ratio. The Chair requested the Committee vote to remove some of the Options from the list to consider in the Greater Vernon Water Master Water Plan Financial Planning Stage in order to simplify the financial planning exercise. The following recommendations were made: Moved and seconded by Representatives Frost and Hubbs-Michiel That Options 4, 6, 7 and 8 be removed from the Options list based on the highest capital cost with lowest non-cost benefit ratio and not be considered in the Financial Planning Stage for the Stakeholder Advisory Committee review of the Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan. Moved and seconded by Representatives Neden and Lainsbury to amend the motion as follows: That Options 5 and 9 also be removed. DEFEATED Opposed: Representatives Gibbs, Foisy, Frost, Williamson, Bodenham, Mooney Moved and seconded by Representative Mooney and Bodenham to amend the motion as follows: That Option 7 be retained. DEFEATED Opposed: Representatives Gibbs, Neden, Williamson, Hubbs-Michiel, Witt, Lainsbury, Mohammad, Foisy, Carlson, Frost Page 100 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Item G.1 Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan Stakeholder Advisory Committee Minutes – Regular -3- February 29, 2016 Moved and seconded by Representatives Mohammad and Hubbs-Michiel to amend the motion as follows: That Option 9 be removed. CARRIED Opposed: Representatives Foisy, Frost, Gibbs, Bodenham The main motion as amended was adopted with the final wording being as follows: That Options 4, 6, 7, 8 and 9 be removed from the Options list based on the highest capital cost with lowest non-cost benefit ratio and not be considered in the Financial Planning Stage for the Stakeholder Advisory Committee review of the Greater Vernon Water 2012 Master Water Plan. CARRIED Representative Mohammad requested that a representative from Interior Health be at the next meeting. Representative Gibbs requested that a detailed description of the remaining Options (1, 2, 3 and 5) be provided at the next meeting. ADJOURNMENT There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 4:56 p.m. CERTIFIED CORRECT Chair Jim Garlick Zee Marcolin Manager – Greater Vernon Water Page 101 of 101 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Additional Item C.1 PICNICSHELTERIN PADDLEWHEELPARK GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Additional Item C.1 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Additional Item C.1 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Additional Item C.1 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Additional Item C.1 GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Late Item E.5 REGIONAL DISTRICT of NORTH OKANAGAN REPORT File No.: 5770.02.02.008-329-168 TO: Greater Vernon Advisory Committee FROM: Engineering DATE: March 9, 2016 SUBJECT: Water Allocation Purchase for 5862 Bella Vista Road, Vernon BC RECOMMENDATION: That the report dated March 9, 2016 from the Engineering Technologist regarding the water allocation purchase for 5862 Bella Vista Road, Vernon BC be received for information. BACKGROUND/HISTORY: At the February 24, 2016 Board of Directors meeting, the following resolution was made: "That the matter regarding the purchase of 0. 8 hectare (ha) of water a/location for the property located at 5862 Bella Vista Road, Vernon, BC and legally described as Jot 1, Plan KAP18017 be deferred to a Greater Vernon Advisory Committee meeting pending further information regarding the current rezoning application." DISCUSSION: The owner of 5862 Bella Vista Road, Mr. Damian Pighin, has applied to purchase 0.8 ha of Allocation for the property at 5862 Bella Vista Road. Mr. Pighin purchased this property with the intention of starting farming activities on the land. After making application to the RDNO to purchase allocation, Mr. Pighin made application at the City of Vernon for Rezoning of the property from A 1- Agriculture Within ALR to RS - Four-Plex Housing Residential. Mr Pighin has expressed in the email attached as Schedule "A" that he intends to farm the property for now. Attachment - Schedule "A" - Email dated March 8, 2016 from Mr. Damian Pighin Submitted by: Michael Phillips, ASct Engineering Technologist ( ! Reviewed and Endorsed by: 1 .. 1l r \ \ Dale MoTaggart, P.Eng General Manager, Engineering < ,I / ) David Sewel!J Chief Administrative fficer GREATER VERNON ADVISORY COMMITTEE - REGULAR AGENDA March 10, 2016 - Late Item E.5
* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
advertisement