Survey of Abalone Populations at Stryker Island,

Survey of Abalone Populations at Stryker Island,
Survey of Abalone Populations at Stryker Island,
Tribal Group and Simonds Group, Central Coast
of British Columbia, May, 1997
A. Campbell, and K. Cripps
Fisheries and Oceans Canada
Science Branch, Pacific Region
Paci'fic Biological Station
Nanaimo, British Columbia
V9R 5K6
1998
Canadian Manuscript Report of
Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 2451
1+1
Fisheries and Oceans
Canada
Peches et Oceans
Canada
Science
Sciences
(REVISED)
Canada
Canadian Manuscript Report of
Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
Manuscript reports contain scientific and technical information that contn"butes to
existing knowledge but which deals with national or regional problems. Distnoution is restricted
to institutions or individuals located in particular regions of Canada However, no restriction is
placed on subject matter, and the series reflects the broad interests and policies of the Department
of Fisheries and Oceans. namely, fisheries and aquatic sciences.
Manuscript reports may be cited as full publications. The correct citation appears above
the abstract of each report. Each report is abstracted in Aquatic Sciences and Fisheries Abstracts
and indexed in the Department's annual index to scientific and technical publications.
Numbers 1-900 in this series were issued as Manuscript Reports (Biological Series) of
the Biological Board of Canada. and subsequent to 1937 when the name of the Board was
changed by Act of Parliament, as Manuscript Reports (Biological Series) of the Fisheries
Research Board of Canada. Numbers 1426 - 1550 were issued as Department of Fisheries and
the Environment, Fisheries and Marine Service Manuscript Reports. The current series name
was changed with report number 1551.
Manuscript reports are produced regionally but are numbered nationally. Requests for
individual reports will be filled by the issuing establishment listed on the front cover and title
page. Out-of-stock reports will be supplied for a fee by commercial agents.
Rapport manuscrit canadien des
sciences halieutiques et aquatiques
Les rapports manuscrits contiennent des renseignements scientifiques et techniques ques
qui constituent one contribution aux connaissances actuelles, mais qui traitent de problemes
nationaux ou regionaux. La distribution en est limitee aux organismes et aux personnes de
regions particulieres du Canada. 11 n'y a aucune restriction Quant au sujet; de fait, Ia serie reflete
la vaste gamme des inte..ets et des politiques du ministere des PSches et des Oceans, c'est-a-dire
les sciences halieutiques et aquatiques.
Les rapports manuscrits peuvent atre cites comme des publications completes. Le titre
exact parait au-dessus du resume de chaque rapport. Les rapports manuscrits sont resumes dans
la revue Resumes des sciences aquatiques et ha!ieutiques, et Us sont classes dans I'index annual
des publications scientifiques et techniques du Ministere.
Les numeros 1 a 900 de cette serie ont ete publies a titre de manuscrits (serie biologique)
de l'Office de biologie du Canada. et apres Ie changement de la designation de cet organisme par
decret du Parlement, en 1937, ont ete classes conune manuscrits (sene biologique) de l'Office des
recherches sur les pecheries du Canada. Les numeros 901 a 1425 ont ete publies a titre de
rapports manuscrits de l'Office des recherches sur les pecheries du Canada. Les numeros 1426 a
1550 sont parus a titre de rapports manuscrits du Service des peches et de Ia mer, ministeredes
PSches et de l'Environnement. Le nom actuel de Ia serie a ete etabli lors de la parution du
numero 1551.
Les rapports manuscrits sont produits a I'echelon regional, mais numerotes a I'echelon
national. Les demandes de rapports seront satisfaites par I'etablissement auteur dont Ie nom
figure sur la couverture et la page du titre. Les rapports epuises seront foomis contre retribution
par des agents commerciaux.
Canadian Manuscript Report of
Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 2451
1998
SURVEY OF ABALONE POPULATIONS AT STRYKER ISLAND, TRIBAL GROUP
AND SIMONDS GROUP, CENTRAL COAST OF BRITISH COLUMBIA, MAY, 1997
by
A. Campbell, and K. Cripps I
Fisheries and Oceans Canada
Science Branch, Pacific Region
Pacific Biological Station
Nanaimo, British Columbia
V9R5K6
Eco-Pacific Resource-Management and Heiltsuk Fisheries Program,
Waglisla, B.C. VOT lZ0
1
ii
© Minister of Public Works and Government Services Canada 1998
Cat. No. Fs 97-4/2451 E
ISSN 0706-6473
Correct citation for this publication:
Campbell, A., and K. Cripps. 1998. Survey of abalone populations at Stryker Island,
Tribal Group and Simonds Group, central coast of British Columbia, May, 1997.
Can. Manuscr. Rep. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 2451: 21 p.
iii
ABSTRACT
Campbell, A., and K. Cripps. 1998. Survey of abalone populations at Stryker Island,
Tribal Group and Simonds Group, central coast of British Columbia, May, 1997.
Can. Manuscr. Rep. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 2451: 21 p.
Transect surveys were conducted to determine the density of the northern abalone,
Haliotis kamtschatkana, from intertidal to approximate 8m depths, in the Tribal and
Simonds, Stryker group of islands ofthe central coast of British Columbia during May,
1997. Most (>96 %) adult abalone C2: 70 mm shell length SL) were exposed or emergent
(visible on rocks). Mean abalone sizes were generally largest in the -1-3 m depth range
and smallest in > 7 m depths. Adult abalone were more abundant < 5 m depths, whereas
small juveniles «50 mm SL) were found at all depths, but less frequently in the
intertidal. Mean densities for all sizes of abalone were similar (0.49, 0.54 and 0.53 per
m 2) between areas. Abalone densities were highest in the 0 - 1 m depth range, with fewer
abalone found in the intertidal areas and to depths >4 m.
RESUME
Campbell, A., and K. Cripps. 1998. Survey of abalone populations at Stryker Island,
Tribal Group and Simonds Group, central coast of British Columbia, May, 1997.
Can. Manuscr. Rep. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 2451: 21 p.
Nous avons effectue en mai 1997 des releves sur transects pour determiner la
densittS de l'ormeau nordique (Haliotis kamtschatkana), de la zone intertidale a une
profondeur d'environ 8 m, dans les nes Tribal et Simonds, du groupe Stryker, dans la
zone centrale de la cote de Colombie-Britannique. La plupart (> 96 %) des ormeaux
adultes (:2: 70 mm, LS de la coquille) etaient exondes ou emergents (visibles sur les
rochers). La taille moyenne des ormeaux etait generalement au maximum dans la zone de
profondeur de 1-3 met au minimum a des profondeurs de plus de 7 m. Les adultes etaient
plus abondants a des profondeurs de moins de 5 m, tandis que les petits juveniles
« 50 mm LS) se retrouvaient atoutes les profondeurs, mais moins frequemment dans la
zone intertidale. Les densites moyennes etaient semblables pour toutes les tailles (0,49,
0,54 et 0,53 au m2) d'une zone a l'autre. Les densites des ormeaux etaient au plus haut
dans la plage de profondeur de 0-1 m, et les ormeaux etaient moins nombreux dans les
zones intertidales et ades profondeurs de plus de 4 m.
INTRODUCTION
The 'northern' or 'pinto' abalone, Haliotis kamtschatkana, generally occurs in
patchy distribution on exposed and semi-exposed coasts from Sitka Island, Alaska to Baja
California, including British Columbia (B.C.) (Sloan and Breen 1988). Northern abalone
were harvested by first nations and in commercial, and recreational fisheries in B.C. until
1990. Previous surveys at index sites in southeastern Queen Charlotte Islands and the
north central coast of B.C. indicated that the abundance of northern abalone had declined
more than 75% between the period of 1978-84 and remained low until 1994 (Winther et
al. 1995; Thomas and Campbell 1996). Faced with the possibility of abalone population
collapse the northern abalone fishery has remained closed since 1990 due to conservation
concerns. The standard broad-scale survey design has remained essentially the same since
1978 (Breen and Adkins 1979) and consisted of counting and measuring abalone in 16
alternate 1 m2 quadrats per index site. Apart from a few samples made by Breen and
Adkins (1982) of abalone densities at Spider Island, Triquet Island and the Goose Group
during 1980, little was known of the status of abalone stocks in the Heiltsuk First Nations
traditional fishing area. Consequently, the traditional broad-scale survey ofthe Central
coast of B.C. (Thomas and Campbell 1996) was extended to include sample sites in the
Stryker, Simonds and Breadner group of islands (Campbell et al. 1998). The objectives
of the present paper were to estimate the density of abalone using a random transect
method (Cripps and Campbell 1998) and to determine whether there was a relation
between depth and abalone size and density at the Tribal, Simonds and Stryker islands
(Fig. 1).
METHODS
Transects were randomly placed on a nautical chart by positioning a metric ruler,
marked in mm, along the length of shoreline to be surveyed. A random numbers table
was used to select the position along the ruler where survey transects were to be placed.
The survey method was the same as that described by Cripps and Campbell (1998). The
primary sampling unit was a "transect", made up of a cluster or variable number of
secondary units. Each transect was one meter wide and variable in length depending on
the slope of the substrate within the depth range of 0 to 8m. The secondary sampling unit
consisted of a 1 m 2 quadrat that was placed on the right side of the transect line. Lead
line was deployed perpendicular to the isolepths to a depth of approximately 10 meters
below chart datum. Transect origin was determined by indescriminantly throwing a lead
cannon ball into the intertidal zone. Divers, equipped with a 1m x 1m quadrat, flipped
the quadrat parallel to the transect line, from deep to shallow, and the number of
"emergent" or "exposed" (visible on rocks) abalone, shell length (SL in mm) of each
abalone, depth, substrate type, and dominant algal cover was recorded for every second
quadrat. All kelp, sea urchins and starfish were removed from the quadrat to ensure
abalone were easily detectable, however, boulders were not rolled to examine for cryptic
2
abalone. Caution was exercised to ensure that abalone in upcoming quadrats were not
disturbed. Sampling only exposed abalone is an efficient sampling strategy, since the
majority of mature abalone (e.g., ?.70 mm SL) of interest to the survey are exposed
(Campbell 1996).
All depth recordings were converted to depth at datum. The surveys were
conducted from the intertidal zone to about 8 m below chart datum. Surveying deeper
would have greatly reduce the number of transects that could be safely completed in a
day.
To determine the detectability of exposed animals and the cryptic proportion of
the population, a few transects in each area were randomly chosen and subjected to more
intensive sampling protocol. The number of transects intensively surveyed at the Tribal
group was 4, Simonds group was 6, and Stryker Island was 3. The intensive survey
protocol involved examining each quadrat three times before moving onto subsequent
quadrats. Depth, substrate, dominant algal cover, number of exposed (emergent) abalone
on first examination, number of emergent abalone on second examination, and number of
cryptic abalone were recorded for each quadrat. The first examination involved
identifying and harvesting all the exposed animals. Sampled abalone were placed in a
marked collection bag. The quadrat was then more closely examined to see if any
exposed abalone were missed during the first pass. If an abalone was missed on the first
pass the animal was removed and placed in a separate labeled collection bag. On the
third examination, the cryptic component of the population was sampled by removing and
inspecting all of the moveable material within the quadrat. The cryptic abalone were also
removed and placed in a labeled collection bag. The shell length (mm) was recorded for
each abalone in each collection bag. Once the abalone were measured they were returned
to the area from where they were sampled.
The mean density, d (number / m 2), was calculated as
(1)
The standard error of the mean density, se (d), was calculated as
se(d) =
.,Jl - n / N
n(n -1)a
2
(2)
where for each i1h transect, Ci = the number of abalone observed in a transect, ai = the area
of transect (number of quadrats) surveyed in square metres, a = the mean transect area for
all transects, n is the number of transects sampled, and N is the total population of
possible transects. Adjusting densities for detectability was calculated by substituting ci
3
with Ci / e, where e = mean proportion of total population estimated to be detectable
(exposed abalone / (exposed + cryptic abalone)). This method accounted for the variable
length of transects. Mean and standard error of densities by depth range and abalone size
class was also calculated by subsampling each transect. The depth ranges were (1) <0 m,
(2) 0 - 1.5 m, (3) 1.51 - 3.0 m, (4).3.01 - 4.50 m, (5) 4.51 - 6.00 m, (6) 6.01 -7.50 m, (7)
>7.50 m. The size classes were "mature" 2: 70 mm SL [Le., about 100 % of abalone
would be mature (Campbell et al. 1992)], "prerecruit" 92-99 mm SL, "legal" 2: 100 mm
SL, "new recruit" 100-106 mm SL and "total" which included all size classes. Although
some of the size categories, overlap they were included in the analyses so that the results
could be compared with those from previous surveys of abalone from other areas. The
"immature" <70 mm SL size class was not included in the density estimates (except as
part of the "total") because of the difficulty of finding small abalone.
RESULTS
SURVEY LOGISTICS SUMMARY
The number of transects surveyed off the Tribal Group was 29, the Simonds
Group was 32, and Stryker Island was 20 (Table 1,2). The mean length of transect was
23.0 m for the Tribal Group, 25.7 m for Simonds Group, and 22.2 m for the Stryker
Group.
POPULATION SIZE STRUCTURE
Juvenile exposed abalone « 50 mm SL) made up 22.5 %, 20.3 % and 23.3 % of
the population for the Tribal, Simonds, and Stryker group, respectively. The length
frequency distribution of exposed abalone indicated that the majority of the animals
sampled at both locations were less than 100 mm SL, with most abalone between 70 and
100 mm SL (Fig. 2, Table 3). Abalone 2: 70 mm SL were 43.2 %, 55.4 and 55.1 % ofthe
population for the Tribal, Simonds, and Stryker group, respectively. The percentage of
legal abalone (2: 100 mm SL) was greater for the Simonds (18 %) than for those for
Stryker (5 %) and Tribal group (2 %).
Detectability expressed as a percent of exposed compared to total (exposed +
cryptic) abalone was higher for sizes 2: 70 mm SL than smaller abalone (Table 4, Fig. 3).
Most cryptic animals were < 70 mm SL. These results were similar to those reported for
other surveys (Campbell 1996; Cripps and Campbell 1998). These detectability factors
were used to estimate the combined cryptic and exposed abalone densities (Table 5).
Size frequencies and mean SL of exposed abalone generally decreased as depth
increased (Fig. 4, 5). Adult abalone were more abundant < 5 m depths, whereas small
juveniles «50 mm SL) were found at all depths, but less frequently in the intertidal (Fig.
4A, 4 B, 4C).
4
DENSITY ESTIMATES
Mean densities per transect ranged from 0 to 2.72 total exposed abalone per m 2
(Fig. 6). Total mean densities of exposed, and adjusted for detectability, were similar for
each area (Table 5). Abalone densities were generally highest in the 1-3 m depth range,
although abalone were found at all depths surveyed (Fig. 7).
DISCUSSION
This study showed that there were differences in mean size and density of abalone
with increases in mean depth. Abalone were most abundant between 1 to 3 m depth, and
both density and mean abalone size declined with increasing depth in all three study
areas. Reduced density and size with increasing depth has been reported previously for
H kamtschatkana (Sloan and Breen 1988; Cripps and Campbell 1998). All abalone were
found on firm substrates in this survey, although northen abalone are reported to be
capable of moving across sand or gravel (Sloan and Breen 1988). The decrease in mean
length with depth was probably due to adult abalone preferentially inhabiting shallow
water habitats for spawning (Breen and Adkins 1980) with juveniles found throughout
the 1 - 7 m depths in this study. Breen and Adkins (1979, 1982) found juvenile northern
abalone were generally distributed deeper (5 - 15 m) than adults (Sloan and Breen 1988).
In general, the estimated mean total densities of abalone (adjusted for
detectability) found in this study appear to be similar to the densities found in previous
surveys of abalone in the central coast. Using the same transect method, Cripps and
Campbell (1998) estimated similar abalone densities in east Higgins Pass compared to
those found in the present study. Thomas and Campbell (1996) reported slightly higher
densities from a survey of abalone at 25 sites further north along the central coast ofB.C.
conducted during 1993 (in this survey, the mean density of the total was 0.53, legals was
0.09). The differences in mean density were probably a result of differences between the
depth ranges sampled by the index site 16-quadrat method (1 - 4 m) (Thomas and
Campbell 1996; Campbell et al. 1998) and the present transect survey method (intertidal
to 8 m). After standardizing the data to similar depth ranges, Campbell et al. (1998)
found abalone densities, estimated by the two survey methods at Simonds and Stryker
Islands, during May, 1997, to be similar. The results of the present survey and those of
Campbell et al (1998) indicated that northern abalone densities in southern areas of the
central coast of B.C. were at density levels when the fishery was closed in 1990, and were
well below those reported by Breen and Adkins (1982) in a few samples during 1980.
Studies suggest that abalone growth and recruitment can differ dramatically from
one small area to another depending on local conditions, such as habitat type, food
availability, substrate type, and exposure to wave action (Sloan and Breen 1988). Future
surveys and studies of abalone in these areas should involve estimates of growth,
5
mortality and recruitment rates so that the productivity and surplus abalone production
for possible exploitation can be determined. Due to uncertainties about abalone
productivity and ability of abalone populations to recover from previous exploitation
there still remains conservation concerns for H kamtschatkana along the central coast of
B.C.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We thank J. Bolton, S. Humchitt and P. Newman for helping with the dive survey,
the Heiltsuk Band Council and the Aboriginal Fisheries Strategy for funds and providing
logistic support for the abalone surveys, L. Barton for chart/figure preparation and B.
Lucas and J. Perry for assisting with data analyses.
6
REFERENCES CITED
Breen, P. A., and B. E. Adkins. 1979. A survey of abalone populations on the east coast of
the Queen Charlotte Islands, August 1978. Fish. Mar. Servo MS Rep. 1490: 125 p.
Breen, P. A., and B. E. Adkins. 1980. Spawning in a British Columbia population of
northern abalone, Haliotis kamtschatkana. Veliger 23: 177 - 179.
Breen, P. A., and B. E. Adkins. 1982. Observations of abalone populations on the north
coast of British Columbia, July 1980. Can. Manuscr Rep. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 1633:
55 p.
Campbell, A. 1996. An evaluation of abalone surveys off southeast Queen Charlotte
Island. Can. Tech. Rep. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 2089: 111 - 131.
Campbell, A., I. Manley, and W. Carolsfeld. 1992. Size at maturity and fecundity of the
abalone, Haliotis kamtschatkana, in northern British Columbia. Can Manuscr.
Rep. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 2169: 47-65.
Campbell, A., I. Winther, B. Adkins, D. Brouwer, and D. Miller. 1998. Survey of
northern abalone, Haliotis kamtschatkana, in the central coast of British
Columbia, May 1997. Canadian Stock Assessment Secretariat Research
Document 98/89. 29 p.
Cripps, K., and A. Campbell. 1998. Survey of abalone populations at Dallain Point and
Higgins Pass, central coast of British Columbia, 1995 - 96. Can. Manuscr. Rep.
Fish. Aquat. Sci. 2445: 35 p.
Sloan, N. A., and P. A. Breen. 1988. Northern abalone, Haliotis kamtschatkana, in
British Columbia: fisheries and synopsis of life history information. Can Special
Pub. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 103: 46 p.
Thomas, G., and A. Campbell. 1996. Abalone resurvey in Aristazabal Island, the
Estevan group and Banks Island, June 1993. Can. Tech. Rep. Fish. Aquat. Sci.
2089: 97 - 109.
Winther, I., A. Campbell, G. A. Thomas, B.E. Adkins, and B.G. Clapp. 1995. Abalone
resurvey in the southeast Queen Charlotte Islands, 1994. Can Manuscr. Rep. Fish.
Aquat. Sci. 2273: 46 p.
7
Table 1. Dive survey summary for abalone transects surveyed in the Tribal, Simonds and Stryker
groups, May 1997.
Time
Depth(m)
Number of Total #
Bottom
Transect
Date
Tribal Group
May 21
101
May 21
102
May 22
103
May 21
104
May 22
105
May 22
106
May 22
107
May
22
108
May 22
109
110
May 22
111
May 21
112
May 21
113
May21
May21
114
115
May 21
May21
116
May21
117
118
May 22
119
May 22
121
May 23
122
May 23
123
May 23
124
May 23
125
May 23
126
May 23
May 23
127
May 23
128
May 23
129
May 23
130
Simonds Group
May 25
201
May 25
202
203
May 25
204
May 25
205
May 26
206
May 26
207
May 26
208
May 25
209
May 25
210
May 25
211
May 25
212
May 25
213
May 25
214
May 25
215
May 26
Density
Quadrats of Abalone (No.lm2)
Start
Finish
Time
Min
Max
14:35
15:00
9:14
11:20
11:40
9:50
14:50
11:40
11:10
13:42
10:29
11:00
11:20
13:15
14:00
11:43
10:01
15:47
16:12
15:16
14:43
14:15
12:45
12:17
11:41
11:00
10:23
16:06
16:24
.14:50
15:45
9:34
11:33
11:57
10:03
15:32
11:57
11:30
14:37
10:48
11:15
11:33
13:30
14:12
11:58
10:16
16:00
16:25
15:28
15:05
14:45
13:15
12:34
12:06
11:25
10:51
16:15
16:34
0:15
0:45
0:20
0:13
0:17
0:13
0:42
0:17
0:20
0:55
0:19
0:15
0:13
0:15
0:12
0:15
0:15
0:13
0:13
0:12
0:22
0:30
0:30
0:17
0:25
0:25
0:28
0:09
0:10
0.12
-2.74
-0.76
-2.07
-2.77
-1.13
-1.28
-2.77
-2.41
-2.62
-1.46
-1.52
-1.46
-2.26
-2.50
-2.65
-1.92
-1.80
-1.55
-2.29
-2.62
-2.01
-1.74
-1.83
-1.71
-1.68
-1.49
-1.07
-2.13
7.86
8.38
7.68
7.86
5.70
6.98
6.00
6.31
7.04
7.19
7.35
6.89
7.25
7.22
7.62
6.34
8.66
7.77
6.83
5.70
5.61
6.31
6.25
7.89
7.22
8.44
8.35
5.70
6.19
7
17
9
9
15
10
21
11
10
20
15
11
11
8
8
8
11
9
10
12
11
12
26
10
14
14
17
6
6
0
18
9
2
12
2
17
0
13
19
2
0
0
16
8
6
3
1
2
1
4
4
1
4
2
7
19
0
0
0.000
1.059
1.000
0.222
0.800
0.200
0.810
0.000
1.300
0.950
0.133
0.000
0.000
2.000
1.000
0.750
0.273
0.111
0.200
0.083
0.364
0.333
0.038
0.400
0.143
0.500
1.118
0.000
0.000
14:10
9:16
14:46
10:29
11:04
10:40
12:45
11:19
10:50
10:29
9:51
9:16
9:00
11:40
9:52
14:30
9:44
15:29
10:47
11:28
10:57
13:11
11:32
11:11
10:47
10:21
9:44
9:09
12:14
10:05
0:20
0:28
0:43
0:18
0:24
0:17
0:26
0:13
0:21
0:18
0:30
0:28
0:09
0:34
0:13
-2.16
0.40
-3.63
1.86
0.24
-0.27
-1.10
-0.67
-0.46
-0.27
0.46
-0.21
-0.34
-1.19
-0.12
7.53
8.41
7.10
10.18
9.17
9.20
8.99
8.32
8.26
8.35
9.02
9.94
7.96
7.77
9.11
16
20
39
21
13
11
12
10
8
11
16
15
7
17
8
0
14
11
22
3
4
14
4
10
9
17
10
0
26
1
0.000
0.700
0.282
1.048
0.231
0.364
1.167
0.400
1.250
0.818
1.063
0.667
0.000
1.529
0.125
8
Table 1 (cont'd).
Time
Transect
Date
Start
Simonds Group (cont'd)
9:28
216
May 26
8:47
May 26
217
15:18
218
May 24
May 24
14:58
219
14:31
May 24
220
14:07
May 24
221
May 24
13:40
222
May 24
13:07
223
May 24
11:07
224
May 24
225
10:12
May
24
9:56
226
May 24
9:41
227
May 24
228
9:26
229
May 24
9:06
May 26
12:45
230
May 26
231
13:20
232
May 26
13:39
Stryker Island
301
May 29
11:40
May 29
302
11:13
May 29
303
10:37
304
May 29
10:55
305
May 29
9:48
May 29
9:17
306
May 28
8:38
311
9:19
312
May 28
10:24
314
May 28
316
May 28
11:33
317
May 28
11:01
May 28
12:08
318
319
May 28
12:26
May 28
320
12:46
May 28
321
13:04
May 28
13:20
322
May 28
13:47
323
324
May 28
14:10
325
May 28
14:43
326
May 28
9:44
Bottom
Depth(m)
Number of
Total #
Density
of Abalone (No.lm 2)
Finish
Time
Min
Max
Quadrats
9:47
9:18
15:38
15:10
14:46
14:19
13:57
13:32
11:38
10:55
10:07
9:50
9:35
9:20
13:11
13:32
13:59
0:19
0:31
0:20
0:12
0:15
0:12
0:17
0:25
0:31
0:43
0:11
0:09
0:09
0:14
0:26
0:12
0:20
-0.61
-0.73
-2.90
-2.87
-2.77
-2.26
-2.32
-2.62
-1.25
-0.98
1.62
1.10
0.55
0.24
10
14
14
8
12
9
11
17
20
21
9
6
5
8
18
10
11
1
2
1
4
7
0
6
25
12
4
1
0
0
0
11
1
9
0.100
0.143
0.071
0.500
0.583
0.000
0.545
-1.98
-2.07
9.91
8.75
6.86
7.22
6.80
7.01
7.62
7.77
8.93
8.87
8.69
8.14
8.17
8.20
8.99
7.92
8.90
11:55
11:31
10:47
11:05
10:30
9:39
9:09
9:36
10:47
11:58
11:21
12:20
12:36
12:57
13:14
13:40
14:00
14:32
15:02
10:10
0:15
0:18
0:10
0:10
0:42
0:22
0:31
0:17
0:23
0:25
0:20
0:12
0:10
0:11
0:10
0:20
0:13
0:22
0:19
0:26
-1.10
-1.34
7.56
7.96
8
21
6
14
14
14
16
9
11
13
29
7
7
10
8
16
12
12
18
9
4
3
2
0
16
3
10
0
10
16
4
7
1
1
0
20
2
33
2
2
0.500
0.143
0.333
0.000
1.143
0.214
0.625
0.000
0.909
1.231
0.138
1.000
0.143
0.100
0.000
1.250
0.167
2.750
0.111
0.222
-lAO
-lAO
8044
-0.30
-2.23
-3.14
-1.71
-1.52
-0.79
-1.16
-1.07
-0.70
0.55
-1.04
-1.10
-1.22
-0.76
-1.07
-1.10
-0.61
7.10
7.96
8.35
8.11
8044
8.29
8.72
7.01
8.14
8.17
9.05
9.33
7041
7.86
8.90
6043
8.84
10471
0.600
0.190
0.111
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.611
0.100
0.818
9
Table 2. Summary statistics of transect survey of exposed abalone from the Tribal,
Simonds and Stryker groups, May, 1997. Values in brackets are standard errors.
Details per transect
Dates
Number of transects
Mean transect length (m)
Mean depth (m)
Mean number of quadrats
Mean minutes
Mean minutes/quadrat
Tribal Group
21-24 May
29
23.00 (1.73)
2.41 (0.09)
12.0 (0.9)
20.5 (2.0)
1.59 (0.14)
Simonds Group
24-26 May
32
25.69 (2.29)
3.75 (0.09)
13.3 (1.2)
20.9 (1.6)
1.60 (0.07)
Stryker Group
28-29 May
20
24.40 (2.48)
3.21 (0.12)
12.7 (1.2)
18.8 (1.8)
1.69 (0.08)
10
Table 3. Mean shell length (mm SL) of exposed abalone of different size groups for
all transect surveys of the Tribal, Simonds and Stryker Island groups, May, 1997.
N = number of abalone. Values in brackets are standard errors.
Size group
(mm SL)
Tribal Group
Mature
~70
Pre Recruit
92 -99
New Recruit 100 - 106
Legal
~ 100
Total
all sizes
Simonds Group
Mature
~70
Pre Recruit
92 - 99
New Recruit 100 - 106
Legal
~ 100
Total
all sizes
Stryker Group
Mature
~70
Pre Recruit
92 - 99
New Recruit 100 - 106
Legal
~ 100
Total
all sizes
N
% of total
Shell Length
73
13
2
4
169
43.20
7.69
1.18
2.37
100.00
83.6 (1.1)
94.8 (0.5)
102.5 (2.5)
106.3 (2.7)
64.4 (1.6)
123
24
17
40
222
55.41
10.81
7.66
18.02
100.00
92.5 (1.2)
95.5 (0.4)
102.5 (0.5)
108.3 (1.0)
71.3 (2.0)
66
8
6
7
129
51.16
6.20
4.65
5.43
100.00
83.4 (1.3)
95.8 (0.9)
103.5 (0.9)
105.0 (1.7)
66.6 (2.1)
11
Table 4. Detectability as a percent of total abalone by size category for cryptic and exposed abalone
from intensive samples at all depths from the Tribal (4 transects), Simonds (6 transects) and Stryker
(3 transects) groups of islands, May, 1997.
Tribal Group
Details
Number % of Total
Immature Abalone < 70 rnrn SL
Cryptic
20.00
6
Exposed
24
80.00
Total
30
Mature Abalone ~ 70 mm SL
Cryptic
0
0.00
Exposed
28
100.00
Total
28
All sizes of Abalone
Cryptic
6
10.34
Exposed
52
89.66
Total
58
Simonds Group
Number % of Total
Stryker Group
Number % of Total
Total of Three areas
Number % of Total
1
8
9
11.11
88.89
10
20
30
33.33
66.67
17
52
69
24.64
75.36
1
14
15
6.67
93.33
1
12
13
7.69
92.31
2
54
56
3.57
96.43
2
22
24
8.33
91.67
11
25.58
74.42
19
106
125
15.20
84.80
32
43
12
Table 5. Mean density (number/m2) of exposed abalone of different size groups for all depths
from Tribal, Simonds and Stryker group of islands, May, 1997. Means unadjusted and adjusted for
detectability. Values in brackets are standard errors.
Size group
mm SL
Unadjusted
Mature
~ 70
Pre Recruit
92 - 99
New Recruit
100 - 106
Legal
~ 100
Total
all sizes
Adjusted for detectability
Mature
~70
Pre Recruit
92 - 99
New Recruit
100 - 106
Legal
~ 100
Total
all sizes
Number of transects
Tribal
Simonds
Stryker
0.210 (0.051)
0.037 (0.012)
0.006 (0.004)
0.011 (0.007)
0.494 (0.089)
0.289 (0.079)
0.056 (0.019)
0.040 (0.018)
0.094 (0.041)
0.536 (0.086)
0.272 (0.103)
0.034 (0.016)
0.025 (0.012)
0.029 (0.015)
0.528 (0.156)
0.210(0.051)
0.037 (0.012)
0.006 (0.004)
0.011 (0.007)
0.551 (0.099)
29
0.310 (0.085)
0.060 (0.020)
0.043 (0.019)
0.101 (0.044)
0.585 (0.094)
32
0.295 (0.112)
0.037 (0.017)
0.027 (0.013)
0.031 (0.016)
0.709 (0.210)
20
13
128:20
128:30
....o
o
Campbell
Island
lO
01
(\J
o
01
I\)
o
~.
lO
1
o
01
c\j
o
o
I\)
o
lO
.~
lO
lO
d'
....lO
2
01
01
01
Scale in Meters
:
o
I
2700 5400 8100 10800 13500
128:30
128:20
Fig. 1. General location of study areas (l) Tribal (in statistical area 7 -18), (2) Simonds
(in statistical area 7 -25)" and (3) Stryker group of islands (in statistical areas 7 -18, 7 ­
19), in the central coast of British Columbia surveyed for abalone during May, 1997.
14
8
7
8
A
TRIBAL
6
MEAN = 64
N = 169
g
u
6
"tl
5
'E
7
0.04
0.03
4
a
"8
a0
::J
0.02
3
~
...
B
SIMONDS
MEAN = 71
N =222
0.03
"tl
a
5
'E
g
u
0.02
4
::J
...
<D
lD
o
o
0.01
50
...
.........----'0.0
100
150
0.01
0.0
150
_L__---'
50
SHELL LENGTH (MM)
100
SHELL LENGTH (MM)
12...-------y------r------,0.09
10
C
MEAN =67
STRYKER N = 129
0.08
0.07
"tl
a
8
0.06
"0
'E
g 6
0.05
g.
u
0.04
~
o
::J
4
...
0.03 ~
0.02
2
0.01
50
g.
"0
III
2
"0
0
-'-------' 0.0
150
100
SHELL LENGTH (MM)
Fig. 2. Size frequencies of exposed abalone from the (A) Tribal, (B) Simonds, and (C)
Stryker group of islands surveyed May, 1997.
OJ
~
15
CRYPTIC
3
EXPOSED
0.5
A
MEAN =22
N=6
2
"
0.4
B
MEAN =69
N =52
3
a"
0.05
0.31
C
~
0
:>
0.2 ~
0.07
0.06
0.04
!2
!"
...!l
0.03 !'i
m
~
0.02
g'
0.1
0.01
0
0
50
100
0.0
150
0
0
50
SHELL LENGTH (1.11.1)
0.0
150
100
SHELL LENGTH (1.11.1)
1.5
3
1.4
C
MEAN = 72
N=1
1.0
c
"
1.0 ~
0.8
8"
0
1.2
go:>
0.6 ~
0.5
MEAN = 83
N =22
2
50
100
0
0.06 ~
0
&
:>
0.4 ~
0.04
0.2
0.02
0.0
150
0
0
50
100
~
-0.0
150
3
2
m
SHELL LENGTH (1.11.1)
3
MEAN = 40
N = 11
a
"a
0.08
SHELL LENGTH (1.11.1)
E
0.10 "
C
m
0.0
0
0.12
0.09
F
MEAN 60
N = 32
0.2 "
~de
g
"
0.08
0.07 "
006
~
0.05 ~.
§
Q
0
0.1 :
~
0.04
i
0.03
g'
0.02
0.01
o
o
50
100
SHELL LENGTH (1.11.1)
0.0
150
0
0
50
100
0.0
150
SHELL LENGTH (1.11.1)
Fig. 3. Size frequencies of cryptic and exposed abalone, respectively, (A) and (B) Tribal
Group, (C) and (D) Simonds Group, and (E) and (F) Stryker Group from intensive survey
samples May, 1997.
16
TRIBAL GROUP
•
•
1
0.06
3
O~
E
II
2
0
a
1
0
:>
0.03 ~
0.02
2
3
0.05 ."
0.06
50
0
100
2
0.04
0
i
O.~ ;;,
0.5
e:
0.02
0.01
0
0
50
100
0.0
0
0.0
150
50
100
1.5
3
0.5
0.2
5
0.10
6
008
~
0.06
g
OA
."
."
2
~.
E
"~
0
."
a
"8
~.
0
:>
0
0.1 ~
~
O~ ~
'"e:
a
1.0
0.31
E
:>
0
:>
0
0
0.2
0.5
50
100
SHELL LENGTH (mm)
00
150
0
0
50
100
SHELL LENGTH (mm)
0.0
150
0.0
0
~
'"e:
0.1
0.02
0
0
0.0
150
SHELL LENGTH (mmj
SHELL LENGTH (mm)
0
if
0.061
:>
0
0
0.02 ~
0.0
150
3
E
52
0.08
1.0
.,
0.12
4
g
i
0.10
E
0.03 ;;,
'"e:
SHELL LENGTH (mm)
•
if
oos1
0.01
0
3
0.07
E
II
1.5
0.08
50
100
SHELL LENGTH (mm)
Fig. 4A. Size frequencies by depth category of exposed abalone from the Tribal Group,
surveyed May, 1997. Depth category (1) < 0 m, (2) 0 - 1.50 m, (3) 1.51 - 3.00 m, (4) 3.01
- 4.50 m, (5) 4.51 - 6.00 m, (6) 6.01 -7.50 m.
0.0
150
17
SIMONDS GROUP
3
6
0.16
1
0.14
5
0.12 ~
2
0.10 }
~
0.08
.
"
0.06 ;;,
0.04
0.08
3
0.04
2
0.04 ~
2
0.06 }
~3
0.05
.."
a
4
~
3
0.10
2
~
~
0.03 }
0.02
W
0.02
~
W
0.01
0.02
0
0
50
'---0.0
100
150
0
0
4
C
g
2
0
50
100
0.2
6
0.12
C
0.08
"
0
0
8'
""
0.06 !!l
CD
0.04 !!l
0.01
0.02
0.0
0
0
150
.."
0.10 ~
2
0.02 !!l
SHELL LENGTH (MMl
0.0
150
1.5
CD
0
0
100
."
0.05 ~
"0
0.04 8'
"
0.03 ~
50
SHELL LENGTH (MM)
0.14
5
0.06
3
0
0
100
3
0.07
4
50
SHELL LENGTH (MM)
SHELL LENGTH (MM)
50
100
SHELL LENGTH (M!oIl
0.0
150
a
1.0
"0a
c
0
"
0.1 ~
0
0
!!l
0.5
0.0
0
CD
~
50
100
0.0
150
SHELL LENGTH (MMl
3
7
0.2
."
a
2
"8
a0
c
"
"
0
0
0.1 ~
CD
~
0
0
50
100
00
150
SHELL LENGTH (MMl
Fig. 48. Size frequencies by depth category of exposed abalone from the Simonds
Group, surveyed May, 1997. Depthcategory(I)<Om,(2)0-1.50m,(3) 1.51-3.00m,
(4) 3.01 - 4.50 m, (5) 4.51 - 6.00 m, (6) 6.01 - 7.50 m, (7) >7.50 m.
18
STRYKER GROUP
3
0.10
•
0.08 ."
3
6
1
2
0.1.
5
0.12 ."
2
0.101.
0.08
!
i
g
0.06
II
o.~
~
U
..'"
•
0. 06
3
1
0.2
."
!.
g
!2
o.~ ~
~
2
3
0.1
II
~
0.02
0.02
0
0
50
100
0.0
150
0
50
0
SHELL LENGTH (MM)
100
1.5
0
0
0.3
1.5
4
0.0
150
0.0
150
SHELL LENGTH (MM)
1.5
6
5
0.08
0.07
0.2
."
1.0
§
c:>
~
U
0.1 ~
0.5
a
1.0
a0
:>
0
U
o. 5
."
02 ~
1.0
"8
a
0
:>
0
0.1
0.5
-'"
0.01
o. 0
o
50
100
0.0
150
00
0
SHELL LENGTH (MM)
50
100
SHELL LENGTH (MM)
0.0
150
0.0
0
~
50
100
0.0
150
SHELL LENGTH (MM)
1.5
7
0.1.
0.12
."
1.0
0.10.g
0
g
"
0.06 ~
"0"
0.08
U
0.5
'"
o.~ '!:
0.02
0.0
0
50
100
0.0
150
SHELL LENGTH (MM)
Fig. 4C. Size frequencies by depth category of exposed abalone from the Stryker Group,
surveyed May, 1997. Depthcategory(l)<Om,(2)0-1.50m,(3) 1.51-3.00m,(4)3.01
- 4.50 m, (5) 4.51 - 6.00 m, (6) 6.01 - 7.50 m, (7) >7.50 m.
19
-~ 80
~
'-'70
I
I­
z 60
(9
W
---I
---I
---I
TRIBAL
50
/+
W 40
~
I
(J)
STRYKER
z 30
«w
~
x
20
10 L-...L----l...------l.------l..------L-----.l._L--..l...----l.....-----I.....-----J
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9 10
MEAN DEPTH (M)
Fig. 5. Mean shell length of exposed abalone by mean depth in the Tribal, Simonds, and
Stryker groups of islands during May, 1997.
20
12
10
8
c:
0='
12
0.4
A
8
10
MEAN = 0.47
N =29
0.3
a
u
0
...
g
='
0
a
6
0.2
()
u(I)
....
4
MEAN = 0.47
N = 32
"'0
OJ
III
8
"'0
a
u
0
c::
0.2
6
u
~
4
OJ
0.1 ~
2
0
0
1
2
3
0.0
0
MEAN ABALONE DENSITY PER TRANSECT
0
1
2
3
0.0
MEAN ABALONE DENSITY PER TRANSECT
7r-----r----,------.
c:
6
C
5
MEAN 0.53
N =20
0.3
=
"'0
0.2
4
o='
() 3
~
a
"8a
o
='
u
!!!
2
0.1
1
2
g.
='
()
0.1 ....
2
0.3
OJ
~
~o
MEAN ABALONE DENSITY PER TRANSECT
2
Fig. 6. Frequency distribution of mean densities (number per m ) of exposed abalone per
transect for all depths combined from the (A) Tribal, (B) Simonds, and (C) Stryker group
of islands surveyed during May, 1997.
21
w 2.5 r-r--r--r--r--T-T-r-r-r-r-T"""""'I
A
a:
ttl
:!E
2.0
ffi
ffi
1.5
AU
1.5
;i 28
m
«
z 0.5
0.0 L...-~L......JL......J--l--l--l.--I.....!l.~---1..-I
-2 -1
0
1 2
3
"
5
6
7
8
:!E
«
m
«
z
«
w
0.0 L......JL-J'--J.---L---I........L.......L--L.......L-....J.....--'--l
-2 -1
9 10
1.5...-r-..--r-..--..---r-..---r-...-...-T""""'1
o
:!E
TRIBAL
MATURE
d
fI)
o
1.0
(J)
o
28
23 9
0.0 L-.L-L...-~~L......JL......J:I:=..Io--..L---I.---I.--'
2
3 "
5
6
7
8
;i
m
«
z
«
w
:!E
SIMONDS
MATURE
fI)
a:
G
TRIBAL
LEGAL
fI)
(J)
o
;i
«
z
«
w
m
O.0 '"-=-'---'L-J---I.----l.--'----L.....u...~............J
0
~
1 2 3
4
5 6
7
8
28
9
0.0 L-J...o::::l......LL....:::LL-L..L.L-lo....-l.-l.-l.-L.-I
-2 -1
0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
MEDIAN DEPTH (M)
8
9 10
8
9 10
1.0
0.5
0.0 LJ-..1..--L....L..L...!LJIi:::t::::l:t::::n......LJ
-2 -1
0
H
SIMONDS
LEGAL
0.2
1 2
3
"
5
6
7
8
9 10
MEDIAN DEPTH (M)
0.3.--.---......,-r--r--.--,.....--,,.....--,,.....--,r--1r--1r--1
W
0::
I­
W
0.3 r-r--r--r--r--.-.-...-.-..-...-.,........,
I
STRYKER
LEGAL
:!E
d
(J)
Q.
Q.
W
0.2
w
W
Z
28
:!E
0::
;i
m
«
z
«w
7
STRYKER
MATURE
9 10
0::
o
5 6
W
Q.
w
0.1
4
0::
0.5
:!E
0.2
3
W
Z
W
d
2
:!E
26
0::
I­
w
;i
m
«
z
«
w
1
F
MEDIAN DEPTH (M)
0­
W
Z
o
-2 -1 0
d
1.0
-2 -1
9 10
0.3 r-y--y--r--y--y--y--y--..--T-T-T""""1
:!E
0.0 ':-':-''----'---'----'---.l.---I.---1........L---1..--1..-I
0::
I­
W
Z
1
0.5
MEDIAN DEPTH (M)
Q.
W
0.5
:!E
9 10
1.0
w
MEDIAN DEPTH (M)
d
7 8
E
0::
W
-2 -1 0
W
0::
I­
W
5 6
w
d
W
Z
:!E
3 "
:!E
Q.
;i
m
«
z
«
w
1 2
0::
I­
W
0::
W
o
1.5
MEDIAN DEPTH (M)
a:
ttl
STRYKER
ALL
w
o-Zl
1.0
MEDIAN DEPTH (M)
w
ffi
«
z 0.5 26
«
w
~
2.0
Q.
w
o-Zl
«
m
1.0
C
d
fI)
26
Q.
w
:!E
ttl
:!E
SIMONDS
d
fI)
Q.
oZ
ttl
w 2.5 r-r-r-Tr--r-r---r-..--r-r-..--..--.
a:
B
:!E 2.0
TRIBAL
ALL
d
fI)
w 2.5 r-r-r-r--1r--1r--1r--1'-''-'r--1r--1...,
a:
19
Z
o
0.1
26
:!E
;i
m
«
z
«
w
:!E
0.0_2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
MEDIAN DEPTH (M)
0.1
0.0 ....................................L.I.-.........L-Io..-.L-.L-.L-L.-I
-2 -1
0
1
2
3
4
5 6
7 8
MEDIAN DEPTH (M)
Fig. 7. Mean densities of abalone (adjusted for detectability, to include exposed and
cryptic) by size group and depth from the Tribal, Simonds, and Stryker group of islands,
respectively for (A, B, C) all sizes, (D, E, F) mature sizes (2:. 70 mm SL), and (G, H, I)
legal sizes (2:. 100 mm SL) surveyed during May, 1997. Vertical lines are ± 1 standard
error. Numbers represent number oftransects.
9 10
Was this manual useful for you? yes no
Thank you for your participation!

* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project

Download PDF

advertisement