ANIMAL NUTRITION
Seventh Edition
P. McDonald R. A. Edwards J. F. D. Greenhalgh
C. A. Morgan L. A. Sinclair R. G. Wilkinson
Animal Nutrition is a core text for undergraduates in Animal Science, Veterinary Science, Agriculture,
Biology and Biochemistry studying this subject. It also provides a standard reference text for agricultural
advisers, animal nutritionists and manufacturers of animal feeds.
The latest edition of this classic text continues to provide a clear and comprehensive introduction to the
science and practice of animal nutrition. The text is supported by key experimental evidence throughout.
Quantitative aspects of the subject are clearly explained and illustrated by worked examples. Chapters
that deal with the calculation of requirements include problems and solutions to aid student learning. Other
chapters include essay-type questions that students can use as a guide to revision.
The new edition of Animal Nutrition has been completely updated and has been reorganised to
present the subject in six sections:
the components of foods – carbohydrates, lipids, proteins, vitamins and minerals
•
the digestion and metabolism of nutrients – how animals obtain and utilise nutrients from foods
•
quantifying the nutrients supplied by foods – digestibility, energy and protein values
•
the nutrient requirements of animals – maintenance and production
•
a description of the foods commonly given to animals – their nutrient content and factors
affecting their use
•
the contribution of animal products to human nutrition – including effects on health and the
environment
The Appendix provides comprehensive tables on the composition of foods and the latest feeding
standards for dairy and beef cattle, sheep, pigs and poultry, and horses.
P McDonald was formerly Head of the Department of Agricultural Biochemistry at the Edinburgh School
of Agriculture. R A Edwards was formerly Head of the Department of Animal Nutrition at the Edinburgh
School of Agriculture. J F D Greenhalgh is Emeritus Professor of Animal Production and Health at
the University of Aberdeen. C A Morgan is an animal nutritionist at the Scottish Agricultural College,
Edinburgh. L A Sinclair is Professor of Animal Science at Harper Adams University College. R G Wilkinson
is Principal Lecturer in Ruminant Nutrition at Harper Adams University College
Front cover image: © Getty Images
CVR_MCDO4238_07_SE_CVR.indd 1
Seventh Edition
Animal Nutrition
P. McDonald
R. A. Edwards
J. F. D. Greenhalgh
C. A. Morgan
L. A. Sinclair
R. G. Wilkinson
McDonald Edwards Greenhalgh
Morgan Sinclair Wilkinson
•
Animal Nutrition
Animal Nutrition
Seventh
Edition
www.pearson-books.com
20/12/2010 15:00
ANIMAL NUTRITION
We work with leading authors to develop the strongest
educational materials in biology, bringing cutting-edge
thinking and best learning practice to a global market.
Under a range of well-known imprints, including
Prentice Hall, we craft high-quality print and electronic
publications which help readers to understand and apply
their content, whether studying or at work.
To find out more about the complete range of our
publishing, please visit us on the World Wide Web at:
www.pearsoned.co.uk
ANIMAL NUTRITION
SEVENTH EDITION
P McDonald
Formerly Reader in Agricultural Biochemistry, University of
Edinburgh, and Head of the Department of Agricultural
Biochemistry, Edinburgh School of Agriculture
R A Edwards
Formerly Head of the Department of Animal Nutrition,
Edinburgh School of Agriculture
J F D Greenhalgh
Emeritus Professor of Animal Production and Health,
University of Aberdeen
C A Morgan
Scottish Agricultural College
L A Sinclair
Harper Adams University College
R G Wilkinson
Harper Adams University College
Contents
Preface to the seventh edition
Acknowledgements
Part 1
THE COMPONENTS OF FOODS
1 The animal and its food
1.1 Water
1.2 Dry matter and its components
1.3 Analysis and characterisation of foods
Summary
Further reading
2 Carbohydrates
2.1
2.2
2.3
2.4
2.5
2.6
Classification of carbohydrates
Monosaccharides
Monosaccharide derivatives
Oligosaccharides
Polysaccharides
Lignin
Summary
Further reading
xi
xii
1
3
4
5
5
14
15
16
16
18
20
23
26
30
30
31
3 Lipids
32
3.1
3.2
3.3
3.4
3.5
3.6
3.7
32
33
43
44
46
47
50
51
51
52
Classification of lipids
Fats
Glycolipids
Phospholipids
Waxes
Steroids
Terpenes
Summary
Questions
Further reading
4 Proteins, nucleic acids and other nitrogenous compounds
4.1
4.2
4.3
4.4
4.5
4.6
4.7
Proteins
Amino acids
Peptides
Structure of proteins
Properties of proteins
Classification of proteins
Nucleic acids
53
53
53
59
60
61
61
63
v
Contents
4.8 Other nitrogenous compounds
4.9 Nitrates
4.10 Alkaloids
Summary
Further reading
5 Vitamins
5.1
5.2
5.3
5.4
5.5
Introduction
Fat-soluble vitamins
The vitamin B complex
Vitamin C
Hypervitaminosis
Summary
Further reading
6 Minerals
6.1
6.2
6.3
6.4
6.5
6.6
Functions of minerals
Natural and supplementary sources of minerals
Acid–base balance
Major elements
Trace elements
Other elements
Summary
Further reading
Part 2
THE DIGESTION AND METABOLISM OF NUTRIENTS
7 Enzymes
7.1
7.2
7.3
7.4
7.5
7.6
Classification of enzymes
Nature of enzymes
Mechanism of enzyme action
Specific nature of enzymes
Factors affecting enzyme activity
Nomenclature of enzymes
Summary
Further reading
8 Digestion
8.1
8.2
8.3
8.4
Digestion in monogastric mammals
Microbial digestion in ruminants and other herbivores
Alternative sites of microbial digestion
Nutrient digestion and the environment
Summary
Further reading
Historical reference
9 Metabolism
9.1 Energy metabolism
9.2 Protein synthesis
vi
66
67
68
68
69
70
70
74
87
99
100
101
102
103
103
107
110
112
121
135
136
136
139
141
142
144
146
148
150
154
155
155
156
156
171
186
188
189
191
191
192
194
213
Contents
9.3 Fat synthesis
9.4 Carbohydrate synthesis
9.5 Control of metabolism
Summary
Further reading
219
226
232
233
234
Part 3
QUANTIFYING THE NUTRIENT CONTENT OF FOODS:
DIGESTIBILITY, ENERGY AND PROTEIN VALUES
235
10 Evaluation of foods: digestibility
237
10.1
10.2
10.3
10.4
10.5
Measurement of digestibility
Validity of digestibility coefficients
Digestibility in different sections of the digestive tract
Factors affecting digestibility
Measurement of mineral availability
Summary
Questions
Further reading
11 Evaluation of foods: energy content of foods
and energy partition within the animal
11.1 Demand for energy
11.2 Supply of energy
11.3 Animal calorimetry: methods for measuring heat production
and energy retention
11.4 Utilisation of metabolisable energy
Summary
Questions
Further reading
12 Evaluation of foods: systems for expressing
the energy value of foods
12.1
12.2
12.3
12.4
12.5
Energy systems and energy models
Energy systems for ruminants
Energy systems for pigs and poultry
Energy systems for horses
Predicting the energy value of foods
Summary
Questions
Further reading
Historical references
13 Evaluation of foods: protein
13.1
13.2
13.3
13.4
13.5
Crude protein
Digestible crude protein
Determination of endogenous nitrogen
Measures of protein quality for monogastric animals
Measures of food protein used in practice in the feeding
of pigs and poultry
238
243
244
247
251
252
252
253
254
254
255
262
270
278
279
280
281
282
283
295
297
298
300
301
301
302
303
303
305
306
308
315
vii
Contents
13.6
13.7
13.8
13.9
Measures of food protein used in practice in the feeding of horses
Measures of protein quality for ruminant animals
The UK metabolisable protein system
Feed into Milk
Summary
Questions
Further reading
Part 4
THE NUTRIENT REQUIREMENTS OF ANIMALS
341
14 Feeding standards for maintenance and growth
343
14.1
14.2
14.3
14.4
Nutrient requirements for maintenance
Nutrient requirements for growth
Nutrient requirements for wool production
Mineral and vitamin requirements for maintenance
and growth
14.5 Nutritional control of growth
Summary
Questions
Further reading
Historical reference
15 Feeding standards for reproduction
15.1
15.2
15.3
15.4
Nutrition and the initiation of reproductive ability
Plane of nutrition, fertility and fecundity
Egg production in poultry
Nutrition and the growth of the foetus
Summary
Questions
Further reading
16 Lactation
16.1
16.2
16.3
16.4
16.5
16.6
Sources of milk constituents
Nutrient requirements of the lactating dairy cow
Nutrient requirements of the lactating goat
Nutrient requirements of the lactating ewe
Nutrient requirements of the lactating sow
Nutrient requirements of the lactating mare
Summary
Questions
Further reading
17 Voluntary intake of food
17.1 Food intake in monogastric animals
17.2 Food intake in ruminants
17.3 Food intake in horses
viii
317
318
331
333
337
338
339
345
361
373
375
378
381
383
383
383
384
385
387
391
395
402
403
403
405
406
410
440
444
449
453
457
458
459
461
462
468
474
Contents
17.4 Prediction of food intake
Summary
Questions
Further reading
474
476
477
477
Part 5
THE NUTRITIONAL CHARACTERISTICS OF FOODS
479
18 Grass and forage crops
481
18.1
18.2
18.3
18.4
Pastures and grazing animals
Grasses
Legumes
Other forages
Summary
Questions
Further reading
19 Silage
19.1
19.2
19.3
19.4
19.5
19.6
19.7
Silage, ensilage and silos
Role of plant enzymes in ensilage
Role of microorganisms in ensilage
Nutrient losses in ensilage
Classification of silages
Nutritive value of silages
Whole crop cereal and legume silages
Summary
Questions
Further reading
20 Hay, artificially dried forages, straws and chaff
20.1 Hay
20.2 Artificially dried forages
20.3 Straws and related by-products
Summary
Questions
Further reading
21 Roots, tubers and related by-products
21.1 Roots
21.2 Tubers
Summary
Questions
Further reading
481
482
491
494
497
498
498
499
499
500
501
505
506
511
517
519
520
520
521
521
526
527
532
532
532
533
533
537
539
539
540
22 Cereal grains and cereal by-products
541
22.1 The nutrient composition of grains
22.2 Barley
22.3 Maize
541
543
551
ix
Contents
22.4
22.5
22.6
22.7
Oats
Wheat
Other cereals
Cereal processing
Summary
Questions
Further reading
23 Protein concentrates
23.1
23.2
23.3
23.4
23.5
23.6
23.7
23.8
Oilseed cakes and meals
Oilseed residues of minor importance
Leguminous seeds
Animal protein concentrates
Milk products
Single-cell protein
Synthetic amino acids
Non-protein nitrogen compounds as protein sources
Summary
Questions
Further reading
24 Food additives
24.1
24.2
24.3
24.4
24.5
24.6
24.7
Antibiotics
Probiotics
Oligosaccharides
Enzymes
Organic acids
Spray-dried plasma
Modifiers of rumen fermentation
Summary
Questions
Further reading
563
563
575
576
579
584
585
586
587
591
592
592
594
594
596
599
600
602
604
605
606
607
607
Part 6
ANIMAL PRODUCTS AND HUMAN NUTRITION
609
25 Animal nutrition and the consumers of animal products
611
25.1
25.2
25.3
25.4
Comparative nutrition
The contribution of animal products to human requirements
Objections to the use of animal products
Future trends in the consumption of animal products
Summary
Questions
Further reading
Appendix 1: Solutions to numerical questions
Appendix 2: Notes on tables
Index
x
553
554
555
558
561
562
562
611
613
617
622
623
623
623
625
631
665
Preface to the seventh edition
The science of animal nutrition continues to advance and this has necessitated, to
varying degrees, the updating of most chapters. In particular the new developments
in dairy cow nutrition in the Feed into Milk System and the new nutrient requirements of pigs proposed by the British Society of Animal Science have been incorporated in the middle chapters and the Appendix tables. In addition new
information, published in recent reviews of nutrient requirements by the National
Research Council of the United States, and the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation of Australia has been included.
The emphasis of research has shifted during the lifetime of the seven editions of
this book from mainly outcomes and the effects of nutrition on the whole animal in
the earlier editions to mechanisms, both at a tissue and organ level and increasingly
at a molecular level.The authors are mindful of the need to extend the text in this direction and have included reference to developments in this area.
For this edition Alun Edwards decided he would step down and we wish him well.
The two remaining authors felt that, in view of the extent of revision required to incorporate the new information, new authors would be required to replace Peter McDonald
and Alun Edwards. Therefore, Liam Sinclair and Robert Wilkinson, Professor of
Animal Science and Principal Lecturer in Ruminant Nutrition, respectively, of Harper
Adams University College were invited to join the team. These new authors contribute a broad knowledge of animal nutrition and will ensure that the book can go
to further editions.
In this edition we have attempted to address comments and suggestions made by
reviewers in order to improve the book. The subject matter is constantly changing
and the authors welcome comments and feedback from readers so that the book can
remain relevant and useful.
Reviewing the book involved many discussions with colleagues and the authors
are grateful for their constructive comments, suggestions and support.
C A Morgan, J F D Greenhalgh, L A Sinclair and R G Wilkinson
August 2010
xi
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to the following for permission to reproduce copyright material:
Figures
Figure 1.1 after Response in the Yield of Milk Constituents to the Intake of Nutrients
by Dairy Cows. AFRC Technical Committee on Responses to Nutrients, Report
No. 11, CABI Publishing International,Wallingford (1998); Figure 5.1 adapted from
Roche Vitec Animal Nutrition and Vitamin News, Vol. 1, A1-10/2 (1984); Figure 5.4
after Effects of vitamin E and selenium on the performance and immune status of
ewes and lambs, Journal of Agricultural Science, 142:3, pp. 253–262 (Rooke J A,
Robinson J J and Arthur J R 2004), © The Nutrition Society, published by
Cambridge University Press, reproduced by permission of the publisher and the author;
Figure 6.1 from Quantitative Aspects of Ruminant Digestion and Metabolism, 2nd
ed., CAB International,Wallingford (eds Forbes J M and France J 1993) p. 481; Figure
7.7 after mechanisms related to enzyme catalysis, Advances in Enzymology and
Related Areas of Molecular Biology, 24, p. 464 (Westheimer, F H 1962); Figures 8.1,
8.2 after The Comparative Nutrition of Fowl and Swine: The Gastrointestinal Systems, Office for Educational Practice, University of Guelph (Moran E T Jr 1982); Figure 8.3 after Comparative physiology of the digestive system, Dukes’ Physiology of
Domestic Animals, 9th ed., pp. 216–232. ((ed.) Swenson, Melvin J. 1977), Copyright
1933 by H H Dukes; Copyright © 1977 by Cornell University. Used by permission
of the publisher, Cornell University Press; Figure 8.4 after Feeding and Care of the
Horse, Lea & Febiger (Lewis, Lon 1982), reproduced with permission of John Wiley
& Sons Inc.; Figure 8.5 after Metabolism in the Rumen, Methuen & Co. (Annison E F
and Lewis D 1959) p. 14; Figure 10.1 adapted from Comparison of two in vitro
procedures using rumen liquor-pepsin or pepsin-cellulase for prediction of forage
digestibility, Grass and Forage Science: Journal of the British Grassland Society,
33 (1), pp. 13–18 (Terry R A, Mundell D C and Osbourn D F 1978); Figure 10.2
adapted from A study of artificial fibre bag technique for determining the digestibility of feeds in the rumen, Journal of Agricultural Science, 88, pp. 645–650 (Mehrez
A Z and Ørskov E R 1977), © Cambridge University Press, reproduced with permission of the publisher and the author; Figure 12.1 from Feed into Milk: A New Applied
Feeding System for Dairy Cows, Nottingham University Press (Ed.Thomas C 2004);
Figure 12.2 adapted from Comparison of energy evaluation systems for dairy cow
feeds, Livestock Production Science, 51, pp. 255–266 (Kaustell K, Tuori M and
Huhtanen P 1997), with permission from Elsevier; Figure 12.3 from Comparison of
energy evaluation systems and a mechanistic model for milk production by dairy cattle
offered fresh grass-based diets, Animal Feed Science and Technology, 143, pp. 203–219
(Dijksra J et al. 2008), with permission from Elsevier; Figure 13.4 from Chalupa W
and Sniffen C J, Carbohydrate, protein and amino acid nutrition of lactating dairy
xii
Acknowledgements
cattle, Recent Advances in Animal Nutrition, pp. 265–74 (eds. Garnsworthy P C,
Cole D J A 1994); Figure 16.4 after The Energy Metabolism of Ruminants, Hutchinson
(Blaxter K L 1967) p. 259 reproduced by permission of the publisher and the author;
Figure 16.7 adapted from A review of the potential of nutrition to modify milk fat
and protein, Livestock Production Science 23 (3–4), pp. 219–237 (Sutton J D and
Morant S V 1989), with permission from Elsevier; Figure 16.8 adapted from Update
on theories of diet-induced milk fat depression and potential applications, Recent
Advances in Animal Nutrition, pp. 115–55 (Griinari J M and Bauman D E 2003);
Figure 16.10 from The growth of lambs before and after birth in relation to the level
of nutrition, Journal of Agricultural Science, 38 (2), pp. 93–153 (Wallace R L 1948),
© Cambridge University Press, reproduced with permission of the publisher and
the author; Figure 16.11 adapted from The yield and composition of the milk of
Finnish Landrace ⫻ Blackface ewes: I. Ewes and lambs maintained indoors, Journal of
Agricultural Science, 79 (2), pp. 303–313 (Peart J N, Edwards R A and Donaldson E
1972), © Cambridge University Press, reproduced with permission of the publisher
and the author; Figure 16.13 after Variations in the chemical composition of milk
with particular reference to the solids-not-fat: I.The effect of stage of lactation, season of
year and age of cow, Journal of Dairy Research, 23 (1), pp. 65–81 (Waite R,White J C D
and Robertson A 1956), © Proprietors of Journal of Dairy Research, published by
Cambridge University Press, reproduced with permission of the publisher and the
Journal of Dairy Research; Figure 17.2 after The effect of lactation on intake in the
dairy cow, Proceedings, New Zealand Society for Animal Production, 23, pp. 39–52
(Hutton J B 1963); Figure 24.1 adapted from The Living Gut, Context (Ewing W N and
Cole D J A 1994) p. 105, Context, 52 Mill Street, Packington, LE65 1WN. Tel. 01530
415 338, Fax: 01530 412673, Email: context@totalize.co.uk; Figure 24.2 adapted
from Yeast culture: its role in maximising fibre digestion in the rumen, Feed Compounder, January, pp. 16–19 (Offer N W 1991); Figure 24.3 from The Living Gut,
Context (Ewing W N and Cole D J A 1994) p. 142, Context, 52 Mill Street, Packington, LE65 1WN. Tel. 01530 415 338, Fax: 01530 412673, Email: context@
totalize.co.uk
Tables
Tables 2.11 and 2.12 adapted from Nutrient Requirements of Horses, 5th rev. ed.,
National Academies Press (1989) Table 5.1 and 5.3, Reprinted with permission from
the National Academies Press, Copyright 1989, National Academy of Sciences;
Table 1.3 adapted from Principles of Pig Science, Nottingham University Press ((eds)
Cole D J A, Wiseman J and Varley M A 1994) pp. 169–95, App. 1; Table 3.6 from
Textbook of Biochemistry with Clinical Correlations, 4th ed., John Wiley & Sons
Inc. (Devlin,Thomas M 1997) p. 56,This material is used by permission of John Wiley
& Sons Inc.; Table 6.2 adapted from Supplemental organically-bound mineral
compounds in livestock nutrition, Recent Advances in Animal Nutrition, pp. 67–91
(Ammerman C B, Henry P R and Miles R D 1988); Table 10.1 after The effect in sheep
of physical form and stage of growth on the sites of digestion of a dried grass, British
Journal of Nutrition, 28 (3), pp. 347–356 (Beever D E, Coelho de Silva J P, Prescott
J H D and Armstrong D G 1972), © The Nutrition Society, published by Cambridge
University Press, reproduced with permission of the publisher and the author;
Table 10.2 adapted from Quantitative digestion of fresh herbage by sheep: II.The sites
xiii
Acknowledgements
of digestion of some nitrogenous constituents, Journal of Agricultural Science, 82 (2),
pp. 309–319 (MacRae J C and Ulyatt M J 1974), © Cambridge University Press,
reproduced with permission of the publisher and the author; Table 11.2 after Apparatus
for the determination of the energy exchange of calves and of sheep, Journal of
Agricultural Science, 45 (1), pp. 10–18 (Blaxter K L, Graham N McC, and Rook J A F
1954), © Cambridge University Press, reproduced with permission of the publisher
and the author; Table 11.3 after Plane of nutrition and starch equivalents, Journal of
Agricultural Science, 46 (3), pp. 292–306 (Blaxter K L and Graham N McC 1955), ©
Cambridge University Press, reproduced with permission of the publisher and the
author; Table 11.4 after Comparison of heat production of chickens measured by
energy balance and by gaseous exchange, Journal of Nutrition, 113 (7), pp. 1403–1408
(Fuller H L, Dale M N and Smith C F 1983), American Society for Nutrition; Table
13.2 adapted from Modern Methods in Protein Nutrition and Metabolism,Academic
Press (Sauer W C and de Lange K 1992) pp. 87–120; Table 13.4 adapted from A
method of determining the biological value of protein (Table XII), Journal of Biological Chemistry, 58 (3), p. 891 (Mitchell, H H 1924), Copyright 1924 The American
Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology; Table 13.5 adapted from Protein
nutrition and the utilization of dietary protein at different levels of intake by growing swine, Journal of Animal Science, 14, p. 53 (Armstrong D G and Mitchell H H 1955);
Table 13.6 adapted from Towards an improved utilization of dietary amino acids by
the growing pig, Recent Advances in Animal Nutrition, pp. 45–64 (Moughan P J 1991);
Tables 13.7 and 14.9 adapted from Nutrient Requirement Standards for Pigs, British
Society of Animal Science (Whittemore C T, Hazzledine M J and Close W H 2003);
Table 13.8 adapted from Carbohydrate, protein and amino acid nutrition of lactating
dairy cattle, Recent Advances in Animal Nutrition, pp. 265–75 (Chalupa W and Sniffen
C J 1994), Copyright 1994 W. Chalupa; Table 13.11 adapted from Microbial protein
synthesis and flows of nitrogen fractions to the duodenum of dairy cows (Table 2),
Journal of Dairy Science, 75 (8), p. 2306 (Clark J H, Klusmeyer T H and Cameron
M R 1992), with permission from Elsevier; Table 13.12 after Amino acid content of
noncell and cell wall fractions in feedstuffs, Journal of Dairy Science, 66 (10),
pp. 2198–2207 (Muscato T V, Sniffen C J, Krishnamoorthy U and Van Soest P J 1983),
with permission from Elsevier; Tables 14.6 and 15.4 adapted from The Nutrient
Requirements of Ruminant Livestock, Common Agricultural Bureaux (Agricultural
Research Council 1980); Table 14.7 adapted from Comparative Nutrition of Man
and Domestic Animals Vol. 1,Academic Press (Mitchell H H 1962); Table 14.11 after
Growth and development in the pig, with special reference to carcass quality characters: III. Effect of the plane of nutrition on the form and composition of the bacon
pig, Journal of Agricultural Science, 30 (4), pp. 511–569 (McMeekan C P 1940),
© Cambridge University Press, reproduced with permission; Table 15.1 from Effect
of dietary energy and protein density on body composition, attainment of puberty,
and ovarian follicular dynamics in dairy heifers, Theriogenology, 60 (4), pp. 707–725
(Chelikani P K,Ambrose J D and Kennelly J J 2003), with permission from Elsevier;
Table 15.2 after Fertility in Scottish Blackface ewes as influenced by nutrition and
body condition at mating, Journal of Agricultural Science, 73 (2), pp. 289–94
(Gunn R G, Doney J M and Russel A J F 1969), © Cambridge University Press,
reproduced with permission of the publisher and the author; Table 15.5 adapted from
The Nutrient Requirements of Pigs, Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux (Agricultural Research Council 1981); Table 15.6 adapted from Effects of maternal nutrition
xiv
Acknowledgements
on udder development during late pregnancy and on colostrum production in Scottish
Blackface ewes with twin lambs, Research in Veterinary Science, 39, pp. 230–234
(Mellor D J and Murray L 1985); Table 16.2 from Uptake and metabolism of fat
in the lactating mammary gland, Lactation (Proceedings of the 17th University of
Nottingham Easter School in Agricultural Science) (Bickerstaffe R 1970); Table 16.3
adapted from Effect of replacing calcium salts of palm oil distillate with rapeseed oil,
milled or whole rapeseeds on milk fatty-acid composition in cows fed maize silagebased diets, Animal, 3 (7), pp. 1067–1074 (Givens D I, Kliem K E, Humphries D J,
Shingfield K J and Morgan R 2009), © The Animal Consortium, published by Cambridge University Press, reproduced with permission of the publisher and the author;
Tables 16.4 and 16.5 adapted from National Milk Records Production Annual Report, NMR (2008); Table 16.6 adapted from Variation in the chemical composition of
cow milk, Dairy Science Abstracts, 23, pp. 251–58 (Rook J A F 1961); Table 16.7
adapted from Variation in the chemical composition of cow milk, Dairy Science
Abstracts, 23, pp. 251–258 (Rook J A F 1961); Table 16.8 after Variations in the
chemical composition of milk with particular reference to the solids-not-fat: I. The
effect of stage of lactation, season of year and age of cow, Journal of Dairy Research,
23 (1), pp. 65–81 (Waite R,White J C D and Robertson Alan 1956), © Proprietors of
Journal of Dairy Research, published by Cambridge University Press, reproduced
with permission of the publisher and the Journal of Dairy Research; Table 16.11 after
Milk fat depression in dairy cows: role of silage particle size, Journal of Dairy Science,
73 (7), pp. 1834–42 (Grant R J, Colenbrander V F and Mertens D R 1990), with permission from the American Dairy Science Association.; Tables 16.12, 16.13 adapted
from The Nutrition of Goats, Technical Committee on Responses to Nutrients
Report No. 10, CAB International (AFRC 1994); Table 16.15 after The quality of sheep
milk: a review, Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 37(4) pp. 485–504
(Bencini R and Pulina G 1997), Copyright © CSIRO 1997. Published by CSIRO
Publishing, Victoria, Australia – http://www.publish.csiro.au/72/paper/EA96014.htm;
Table 16.20 adapted from Equine Nutrition and Feeding, 2nd ed., Blackwell Science
(Frape D 1988), copyright 1998. Reproduced with permission of Blackwell Publishing Ltd; Table 16.21 after Nutrient Requirements of Horses, 5 rev. ed., National
Academy Press (National Research Council 1989), Reprinted with permission from
the National Academies Press, Copyright 1989, National Academy of Sciences; Table
17.1 after Studies of the energy requirements of chickens, Poultry Science, 33, pp.
112–119 (Hill F W and Dansky L M 1954); Tables 17.2 and 17.3 adapted from The
effects of pelleting diets on intake and digestibility in sheep and cattle, Animal Production, 16, pp. 223–233 (Greenhalgh J F D and Reid G W 1973); Table 18.3 after
The voluntary intake and in vivo digestibility of herbage harvested from indigenous
hill plant communities, Grass and Forage Science, 41 (1), pp. 53–60 (Armstrong R H,
Common T G and Smith H K 1986); Table 18.4 after Proceedings of the Eighth International Grassland Congress, p. 485 (Armstrong D G 1960); Table 18.6 adapted
from Tropical Feeds: Feed Information Summaries and Nutritive Values (FAO Animal Production and Health Series; No. 12), FAO (Gohl B 1981) p. 70, reproduced
with the permission of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations;
Table 18.7 adapted from Energy allowances and feeding systems for ruminants, Technical Bulletin, 33 (MAFF 1975), Crown Copyright material is reproduced with permission under the terms of the Click-Use Licence; Table 18.8 adapted from Ensilage
of whole-crop barley, Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 19, pp. 656–60,
xv
Acknowledgements
pp. 661–6 (Edwards R A, Donaldson E and MacGregor A W ; MacGregor A W and
Edwards R A 1968), Copyright by the Society of Chemistry. Reproduced by permission
of John Wiley and Sons Ltd on behalf of the SCI; Table 19.3 after Efficient silage
systems, Forage Conservation in the 80s. British Grassland Society Occasional
Symposium No, 11, pp. 186–197 (Zimmer E 1979); Table 19.5 adapted from Feeding
value of silage: silages made from freshly cut grass, wilted grass and formic acid treated
wilted grass, Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 27 (6), pp. 536–544
(Donaldson E and Edwards R A 1976); Table 19.5 adapted from The development of
plant components and their effects on the composition of fresh and ensiled forage
maize: 2. The effect of genotype, plant density and date of harvest on the composition of maize silage, Journal of Agricultural Science, 92 (2), pp. 485–491 (Wilkinson J M
and Phipps R H 1979), © Cambridge University Press, reproduced with permission
of the publisher and the author; Table 19.7 adapted from The effect of formic acid
and bacterial inoculants on the fermentation and nutritive value of perennial
ryegrass silages, Proceedings of the Eurobac Conference, Uppsala, August 1986,
pp. 93–98 (Henderson A R, Seale D R,Anderson D H and Heron S J E 1990) reproduced
by permission of the author; Table 19.8 adapted from The effect of silage additives
containing formaldehyde on the fermentation of ryegrass ensiled at different dry
matter levels and on the nutritive value of direct-cut silage, Animal Feed Science
and Technology 7 (3), pp. 303–14 (Henderson R A, McDonald P and Anderson D H
1982), with permission from Elsevier; Table 19.10 after Prediction of the organic
matter digestibility of grass silage, Animal Feed Science and Technology 28 (1–2),
pp. 115–28 (Barber G D et al. 1990), Reprinted with permission from Excerpta Medica
Inc.; Table 19.12 after Prediction of the voluntary intake potential of grass silage by
sheep and dairy cows from laboratory silage measurements, Animal Science, 66 (3),
pp. 357–367 (Offer N W, et al. 1998); Table 20.1 from The effect of some pre-treatments
on proteolysis during the ensiling of herbage, Grass and Forage Science, 34 (4),
pp. 311–315 (Carpintero M C, Henderson A R and McDonald P 1979); Table 20.3
after The Conservation of Grass and Forage Crops, Oliver and Boyd (Watson S J
and Nash M 1960) p. 156; Table 20.4 adapted from ADAS Science Arm Report,
HMSO (MAFF 1972), Crown Copyright material is reproduced with permission
under the terms of the Click-Use Licence; Table 20.5 adapted from Experimental
Work,The Edinburgh School of Agriculture (Mackenzie E J and Purves D 1967) p. 23,
reproduced by permission of the Scottish Agricultural College; Table 20.7 adapted
from Urea supplementation compared with pre-treatment. 1. Effects on intake, digestion
and live-weight change by sheep fed a rice straw, Animal Feed Science and Technology,
27, pp. 17–30 (Djajanegara A and Doyle P 1989), with permission from Elsevier;
Table 22.1 after Characterisation of induced high protein and high lysine mutants in
barley, Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 27 (6), pp. 545–52 (Balaravi
S P et al. 1976); Table 22.3 adapted from Occasional Publication No. 3, British Society of Animal Production (Barber W P and Lonsdale C R 1980) pp. 61–9; Table 22.4
adapted from Distillery By-products as Feeds for Livestock, Scottish Agricultural
College (Black H et al. 1991); Table 22.5 adapted from Effect of processing of cereals
on rumen fermentation, digestibility, rumination time, and firmness of subcutaneous
fat in lambs, British Journal of Nutrition, 32 (1), pp. 59–69 (Ørskov E R, Fraser C and
Gordon J G 1974), © The Nutrition Society, published by Cambridge University
Press, reproduced with permission of the publisher and the author; Table 22.5
adapted from Cereal processing and food utilization by sheep, Animal Production, 18,
p. 85 (Ørskov E R, Fraser C and McHattie I 1974); Table 23.1 adapted from Table 21
xvi
Acknowledgements
and Table 23, Feed Facts Quarterly, No. 1 (1999) and No. 1 (2000), reproduced by
permission of Simon Mounsey Ltd (www.feedstatistics.co.uk); Table 23.7 after Composition and nutritive value of single-cell protein (SCP), Animal Feed Science and
Technology, 1 (1), pp. 9–24 (Schulz E and Oslage H J 1976), with permission from
Elsevier; Table 24.1 adapted from Enzymes in feed: they really can be made to work,
Alltech European Lecture Tour, February–March (Rotter B A, Marquardt RR and
Guenter W 1989); Table 24.3 adapted from Acidification of diets for pigs, Recent
Advances in Animal Nutrition, p. 61 (Easter R A 1988); Table 25.1 adapted from
Human Nutrition and Dietetics, 10th ed., Churchill Livingstone (Garrow J S, James
W P T and Ralph A (eds) 2000); Table 25.2 adapted from Human Nutrition and
Dietetics, 10th ed., Churchill Livingstone (Garrow J S, James W P T and Ralph A
(eds) 2000); Tables 25.3, 25.4 adapted from FAO, reproduced with the permission of
the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations; Table 25.5 adapted
from FAO, 2008, reproduced with the permission of the Food and Agriculture
Organization of the United Nations; Table 25.6 from Family Food – Report on the
Expenditure and Food Survey, Her Majesty’s Stationery Office (Department for
Environment, Food and Rural Affairs 2006), Crown Copyright material is reproduced
with permission under the terms of the Click-Use Licence; Table 25.7 adapted from
Alternative futures for world cereal and meat consumption, Proceedings of the
Nutrition Society, 58 (2), pp. 219–234 (Rosegrant MW, Leach N and Gerpacio R V 1999)
Text
Box 6.1 adapted from The Mineral Nutrition of Livestock, 3rd ed., CABI Publishing
(Underwood E J and Suttle N F 1999); Box 25.2 adapted from Merck Veterinary
Manual (Table 01: Global Zoonoses), 9th ed., Merck and Co., Inc. (2008), Copyright
2005 by Merck & Co., Inc, Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA. All rights reserved. Used
with permission.
In some instances we have been unable to trace the owners of copyright material,
and we would appreciate any information that would enable us to do so.
xvii
PART 1
The components of foods
This part describes the chemistry of foods and the components that supply nutrients to
the animal.
Chapter 1 is concerned with the analysis of foods, from the early chemical analysis developed
in the 1800s to categorise chemical and nutrient groups, through to the sophisticated physical
and chemical methods used today to identify individual molecular components.
Chapters 2, 3 and 4 describe the major components of foods that supply energy and amino
acids, i.e. the carbohydrates and lipids, and the proteins.
Chapters 5 and 6 give details of the nutrients required in smaller amounts, the vitamins and
minerals which, nevertheless, are essential for the normal functions of the body and efficient
animal production.
1
The animal and its food
1.1
Water
1.2
Dry matter and its components
1.3
Analysis and characterisation of foods
Food is material that, after ingestion by animals, is capable of being digested, absorbed
and utilised. In a more general sense we use the term ‘food’ to describe edible material.
Grass and hay, for example, are described as foods, but not all their components are
digestible. Where the term ‘food’ is used in the general sense, as in this book, those
components capable of being utilised by animals are described as nutrients.
The animals associated with humans cover the spectrum from herbivores, the plant
eaters (ruminants, horses and small animals such as rabbits and guinea pigs); through omnivores, which eat all types of food (pigs and poultry); to carnivores, which eat chiefly meat
(dogs and cats). Under the control of humans these major classes of animal still pertain, but
the range of foods that animals are now offered is far greater than they might normally
consume in the wild (for example, ruminants are given plant by-products of various human
food industries and some dog foods contain appreciable amounts of cereals). Nevertheless,
plants and plant products form the major source of nutrients in animal nutrition.
The diet of farm animals in particular consists of plants and plant products, although
some foods of animal origin such as fishmeal and milk are used in limited amounts.
Animals depend upon plants for their existence and consequently a study of animal
nutrition must necessarily begin with the plant itself.
Plants are able to synthesise complex materials from simple substances such as carbon
dioxide from the air, and water and inorganic elements from the soil. By means of photosynthesis, energy from sunlight is trapped and used in these synthetic processes. The
greater part of the energy, however, is stored as chemical energy within the plant itself and
it is this energy that is used by the animal for the maintenance of life and synthesis of its
own body tissues. Plants and animals contain similar types of chemical substances, and we
can group these into classes according to constitution, properties and function. The main
components of foods, plants and animals are:
Water
Food
Organic
Dry matter
Inorganic
Carbohydrates
Lipids
Proteins
Nucleic acids
Organic acids
Vitamins
Minerals
3
Chapter 1 The animal and its food
1.1
WATER
The water content of the animal body varies with age. The newborn animal contains
750–800 g/kg water but this falls to about 500 g/kg in the mature fat animal. It is
vital to the life of the organism that the water content of the body be maintained: an
animal will die more rapidly if deprived of water than if deprived of food. Water
functions in the body as a solvent in which nutrients are transported about the body
and in which waste products are excreted. Many of the chemical reactions brought
about by enzymes take place in solution and involve hydrolysis. Because of the high
specific heat of water, large changes in heat production can take place within the
animal with very little alteration in body temperature. Water also has a high latent
heat of evaporation, and its evaporation from the lungs and skin gives it a further
role in the regulation of body temperature.
The animal obtains its water from three sources: drinking water, water present in its
food, and metabolic water, this last being formed during metabolism by the oxidation of
hydrogen-containing organic nutrients. The water content of foods is variable and can
range from as little as 60 g/kg in concentrates to over 900 g/kg in some root crops. Because of this great variation in water content, the composition of foods is often expressed on a dry matter basis, which allows a more valid comparison of nutrient content.
This is illustrated in Table 1.1, which lists a few examples of plant and animal products.
The water content of growing plants is related to the stage of growth, being greater
in younger plants than in older plants. In temperate climates the acquisition of drinking water is not usually a problem and animals are provided with a continuous supply.
There is no evidence that under normal conditions an excess of drinking water is
harmful, and animals normally drink what they require.
Table 1.1 Composition of some plant and animal products expressed on a fresh
basis and a dry matter basis
Fresh basis (g/kg)
Turnips
Grass (young)
Barley grain
Groundnuts
Dairy cow
Milk
Muscle
Egg
Dry matter basis (g/kg)
Turnips
Grass (young)
Barley grain
Groundnuts
Dairy cow
Milk
Muscle
Egg
4
Water
Carbohydrate
Lipid
Protein
Ash
910
800
140
60
570
876
720
667
70
137
730
201
2
47
6
8
2
8
15
449
206
36
44
100
11
35
93
268
172
33
215
118
7
20
22
22
50
8
15
107
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
778
685
849
214
5
379
21
24
22
40
17
478
479
290
157
300
122
175
108
285
400
266
768
355
78
100
26
23
116
65
54
321
Analysis and characterisation of foods
1.2
DRY MATTER AND ITS COMPONENTS
The dry matter (DM) of foods is conveniently divided into organic and inorganic material, although in living organisms there is no such sharp distinction. Many organic
compounds contain mineral elements as structural components. Proteins, for example, contain sulphur, and many lipids and carbohydrates contain phosphorus.
It can be seen from Table 1.1 that the main component of the DM of pasture grass
is carbohydrate, and this is true of all plants and many seeds. The oilseeds, such as
groundnuts, are exceptional in containing large amounts of protein and lipid material. In contrast, the carbohydrate content of the animal body is very low. One of the
main reasons for the difference between plants and animals is that, whereas the cell
walls of plants consist of carbohydrate material, mainly cellulose, the walls of animal
cells are composed almost entirely of lipid and protein. Furthermore, plants store
energy largely in the form of carbohydrates such as starch and fructans, whereas an
animal’s main energy store is in the form of lipid.
The lipid content of the animal body is variable and is related to age, the older animal containing a much greater proportion than the young animal.The lipid content of
living plants is relatively low, that of pasture grass, for example, being 40–50 g/kg DM.
In both plants and animals, proteins are the major nitrogen-containing compounds. In plants, in which most of the protein is present as enzymes, the concentration is high in the young growing plant and falls as the plant matures. In animals,
muscle, skin, hair, feathers, wool and nails consist mainly of protein.
Like proteins, nucleic acids are also nitrogen-containing compounds and they
play a basic role in the synthesis of proteins in all living organisms. They also carry
the genetic information of the living cell.
The organic acids that occur in plants and animals include citric, malic, fumaric,
succinic and pyruvic acids. Although these are normally present in small quantities,
they nevertheless play an important role as intermediates in the general metabolism
of the cell. Other organic acids occur as fermentation products in the rumen, or in
silage, and these include acetic, propionic, butyric and lactic acids.
Vitamins are present in plants and animals in minute amounts, and many of them
are important as components of enzyme systems. An important difference between
plants and animals is that, whereas the former can synthesise all the vitamins they
require for metabolism, animals cannot, or have very limited powers of synthesis,
and are dependent upon an external supply.
The inorganic matter contains all those elements present in plants and animals
other than carbon, hydrogen, oxygen and nitrogen. Calcium and phosphorus are the
major inorganic components of animals, whereas potassium and silicon are the main
inorganic elements in plants.
1.3
ANALYSIS AND CHARACTERISATION OF FOODS
Originally the most extensive information about the composition of foods was based
on a system of analysis described as the proximate analysis of foods, which was
devised over 100 years ago by two German scientists, Henneberg and Stohmann.
More recently, new analytical techniques have been introduced, and the information
about food composition is rapidly expanding (see below). However, the system of
5
Chapter 1 The animal and its food
proximate analysis still forms the basis for the statutory declaration of the composition of foods in Europe.
Proximate analysis of foods
This system of analysis divides the food into six fractions: moisture, ash, crude protein, ether extract, crude fibre and nitrogen-free extractives.
The moisture content is determined as the loss in weight that results from drying a
known weight of food to constant weight at 100 °C.This method is satisfactory for most
foods, but with a few, such as silage, significant losses of volatile material (short-chain
fatty acids and alcohols) may take place.Therefore, for silages, the moisture content can
be determined directly by distilling the water from the sample under toluene.The distillate is measured and corrected for the presence of fermentation acids and alcohols.
The ash content is determined by ignition of a known weight of the food at 550 °C
until all carbon has been removed. The residue is the ash and is taken to represent
the inorganic constituents of the food. The major component of ash is silica but ash
may, however, contain material of organic origin such as sulphur and phosphorus
from proteins, and some loss of volatile material in the form of sodium, chloride,
potassium, phosphorus and sulphur will take place during ignition.The ash content
is thus not truly representative of the inorganic material in the food either qualitatively or quantitatively. Animals do not have a requirement for ash per se but require the individual mineral elements that it contains and are determined by
methods such as atomic absorption spectrometry (see p. 12).
The crude protein (CP) content is calculated from the nitrogen content of the food,
determined by a modification of a technique originally devised by Kjeldahl over
100 years ago. In this method the food is digested with sulphuric acid, which converts
to ammonia all nitrogen present except that in the form of nitrate and nitrite. This
ammonia is liberated by adding sodium hydroxide to the digest, distilled off and
collected in standard acid, the quantity so collected being determined by titration or
by an automated colorimetric method. It is assumed that the nitrogen is derived from
protein containing 16 per cent nitrogen, and by multiplying the nitrogen figure by 6.25
(i.e. 100/16) an approximate protein value is obtained. This is not ‘true protein’ since
the method determines nitrogen from sources other than protein, such as free amino
acids, amines and nucleic acids, and the fraction is therefore designated crude protein.
The ether extract (EE) fraction is determined by subjecting the food to a continuous extraction with petroleum ether for a defined period. The residue, after evaporation of the solvent, is the ether extract. As well as lipids it contains organic acids,
alcohol and pigments.This procedure is referred to as method A. In the current official
method, the extraction with ether is preceded by hydrolysis of the sample with sulphuric acid and the resultant residue is the acid ether extract (method B).
The carbohydrate of the food is contained in two fractions, the crude fibre (CF)
and the nitrogen-free extractives (NFE). The former is determined by subjecting the
residual food from ether extraction to successive treatments with boiling acid and
alkali of defined concentration; the organic residue is the crude fibre.
When the sum of the amounts of moisture, ash, crude protein, ether extract and
crude fibre (expressed in g/kg) is subtracted from 1000, the difference is designated the
nitrogen-free extractives.The nitrogen-free extractives fraction is a heterogeneous mixture of all those components not determined in the other fractions. The crude fibre
fraction contains cellulose, lignin and hemicelluloses, but not necessarily the whole
6
Analysis and characterisation of foods
amounts of these that are present in the food: a variable proportion of the cell wall
material, depending upon the species and stage of growth of the plant material, is
dissolved during the crude fibre extraction and thus is contained in the nitrogen-free
extractives. This leads to an underestimation of the fibre and an overestimation of
the starch and sugars. Thus the nitrogen-free extractive fraction includes starch,
sugars, fructans, pectins, organic acids and pigments, in addition to those components
mentioned above.
Modern analytical methods
In recent years the proximate analysis procedure has been severely criticised by
many nutritionists as being archaic and imprecise, and in the majority of laboratories
it has been partially replaced by other analytical procedures. Most criticism has been
focused on the crude fibre, ash and nitrogen-free extractives fractions for the reasons
described above. The newer methods have been developed to characterise foods in
terms of the methods used to express nutrient requirements. In this way, an attempt
is made to use the analytical techniques to quantify the potential supply of nutrients
from the food. For example, for ruminants, analytical methods are being developed
that describe the supply of nutrients for the rumen microbes and the host digestive
enzyme system (Fig. 1.1).
Food measurements
NF
PFF
Total N
N solubility
N degradability
ADIN
WSC and pectins
Starch –
Rate
Extent
Cell walls – Rate
Extent
Rumen parameters
Absorbed nutrients
UDN
DUP AA
ERDN
Microbial
amino
acids
MP
Fermentable
energy
VFA
Microbial
fatty acids
ME
NFF
VFA
Lactate
Lipid
Non-fermentable
energy
LCFA
VFA
Glucose
Fig. 1.1 Proposed model for characterisation of foods for ruminants.
AA = amino acids, ADIN = acid detergent insoluble nitrogen, DUP = digestible undegradable
protein, ERDN = effective rumen degradable nitrogen, LCFA = long-chain fatty acids,
ME = metabolisable energy, MP = metabolisable protein, N = nitrogen, NF = nitrogen fraction,
NFF = non-fermentable fraction, PFF = potentially fermentable fraction, UDN = undegradable
nitrogen, VFA = volatile fatty acids, WSC = water-soluble carbohydrates.
From Agricultural and Food Research Council 1998 Technical Committee on Responses to Nutrients, report
no. 11, Wallingford, CABI.
7
Chapter 1 The animal and its food
Starch and sugars
Inadequacies in the nitrogen-free extractives fraction have been addressed by the
development of methods to quantify the non-structural carbohydrates, which are
mainly starches and sugars. Sugars can be determined colorimetrically after combination with a reagent such as anthrone. Starch is determined by dilute acid hydrolysis of the sample followed by polarimetric determination of the released sugars.
This gives a figure for total sugars (i.e. those originating from the hydrolysed starch
plus the simple sugars in the food). Sugars per se are determined by extracting the
sample with ethanol, acidifying the filtrate and taking a second polarimeter reading. The starch content is calculated from the difference between the two readings
multiplied by a known factor for the starch source. Starch can also be determined
enzymically. For example, in cereals starch is converted to glucose using ␣-amylase
followed by amyloglucosidase and then the glucose is measured using the glucose
oxidase-peroxidase reagent.
Fibre
Alternative procedures for fibre have been developed by Van Soest (Table 1.2). The
neutral-detergent fibre (NDF), which is the residue after extraction with boiling neutral solutions of sodium lauryl sulphate and ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA),
consists mainly of lignin, cellulose and hemicellulose and can be regarded as a measure of the plant cell wall material. The analytical method for determining NDF was
originally devised for forages, but it can also be used for starch-containing foods provided that an amylase treatment is included in the procedure. By analogy with the
nitrogen-free extractives fraction discussed above, the term non-structural carbohydrate (NSC) is sometimes used for the fraction obtained by subtracting the sum of
the amounts (g/kg) of CP, EE, ash and NDF from 1000.
The acid-detergent fibre (ADF) is the residue after refluxing with 0.5 M sulphuric
acid and cetyltrimethyl-ammonium bromide, and represents the crude lignin and
cellulose fractions of plant material but also includes silica.
Table 1.2 Classification of forage fractions using the detergent methods of
Van Soest
Fraction
Components
Cell contents (soluble in neutral detergent)
Lipids
Sugars, organic acids and
water-soluble matter
Pectin, starch
Non-protein nitrogen
Soluble protein
Cell wall constituents (fibre insoluble
in neutral detergent)
Soluble in acid detergent
Acid-detergent fibre
After Van Soest P J 1967 Journal of Animal Science 26: 119.
8
Hemicelluloses
Fibre-bound protein
Cellulose
Lignin
Lignified nitrogen
Silica
Analysis and characterisation of foods
The determination of ADF is particularly useful for forages as there is a good statistical correlation between it and the extent to which the food is digested (digestibility). In the UK the ADF method has been modified slightly, the duration of boiling
and acid strength being increased.The term modified acid-detergent fibre (MADF) is
used to describe this determination.
The acid-detergent lignin determination involves the preparation of aciddetergent fibre as the preparatory step. The ADF is treated with 72 per cent sulphuric acid, which dissolves cellulose. Ashing the residue determines crude lignin,
including cutin.
The Van Soest methods of fibre analysis are used in the system of food analysis
for ruminants developed at Cornell University (see Box 1.1).
In monogastric, and particularly human, nutrition the term dietary fibre is often
used and attention has been focused on its importance in relation to health. Dietary
fibre (DF) was defined as lignin plus those polysaccharides that cannot be digested
by monogastric endogenous enzymes. Initially epidemiological studies linked a lack
of DF to constipation, gut and bowel disorders, cardiovascular disease and type 2
diabetes; however, the causes of such diseases are multifactorial and in some cases
it is not just DF per se that has the beneficial effects but other aspects of the diet
also (e.g. antioxidants). Nevertheless, DF is a major component related to health in
humans and it has equally important effects in animals (see below).
The definition of DF has proved difficult, with definitions ranging through
physiological/botanical (derived from cell walls of plants, which are poorly digested);
chemical/botanical (non-starch polysaccharides (NSP) of plant cell walls); chemical (NSP and lignin); and nutritional/physiological (NSP not digested in the small
intestine). The common features of DF definitions are carbohydrates (polysaccharides, oligosaccharides and lignin) resistant to digestion in the small intestine but
that may be fermented in the large intestine and promote beneficial physiological effects. By virtue of its definition, DF is difficult to determine in the laboratory. The NSP in most foods, along with lignin, are considered to represent the
major components of cell walls. Methods for measurement of NSP fall into two
BOX 1.1 The Cornell net carbohydrate and protein system
The fractionation of the carbohydrates by analysis is currently most fully developed in the Cornell
net carbohydrate and protein system for ruminant diets.This is based on the Van Soest analytical system, with the addition of other standard techniques, to derive the following fractions in foods:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Total carbohydrate ⫽ 100 ⫺ (crude protein ⫹ fat ⫹ ash)
Non-structural carbohydrate (NSC) ⫽ 100 ⫺ (crude protein ⫹ fat ⫹ (NDF ⫺ NDF protein) ⫹ ash)
Sugar as a proportion of NSC
Starch, pectin, glucans, volatile fatty acids ⫽ NSC ⫺ sugar
Lignin
The carbohydrates are then classified according to their degradation rate by rumen microbes: fraction A – fast (comprising the sugars), fraction B1 – intermediate (starch, pectin, ␤-glucans), fraction
B2 – slow (available cell wall material represented by lignin-free NDF) and fraction C – indigestible
(unavailable cell wall in the form of lignin).
9
Chapter 1 The animal and its food
categories (with slight variations in the second category, depending on the research laboratory):
■
■
Enzymic–gravimetric methods, which measure a variety of components and give
no details of polysaccharide type. In the method of the Association of Official Analytical Chemists for total dietary fibre, samples are gelatinised by heating and
treated with enzymes to remove starch and proteins.The total dietary fibre is precipitated with ethanol and the residue is dried and weighed.
Enzymic–chromatographic methods, which identify the individual carbohydrates in the dietary NSP. The Englyst method can be used to determine total,
soluble and insoluble dietary fibre. Measurement of NSP by this method involves removal of starch with the enzymes pullulanase and ␣-amylase. After
precipitation with ethanol, the NSP residue is then hydrolysed with 12 M sulphuric acid. The individual monomeric neutral sugar constituents are determined by gas–liquid chromatography (see below) with separate determination
of uronic acids. Alternatively, the total sugars are determined colorimetrically
after reaction with dinitrosalicylate solution. Total NSP and insoluble NSP are
determined directly by analysis of separate subsamples and the soluble NSP are
calculated by difference. The major constituents of NSP are rhamnose, arabinose, xylose, glucose, galactose, mannose and glucuronic and galacturonic acids.
Cellulose is the major source of glucose, and hemicellulose provides xylose,
mannans and galactose. The degradation of pectins releases arabinose, galactose
and uronic acids. Following the adoption of methods to determine NSP, it became apparent that non-digestible oligosaccharides and resistant starch also
contributed to DF based on their physiological behaviour. In recognition of this,
enzymic procedures have been developed to determine these components. A
comparison of the dietary fibre contents for a range of food types is given in
Table 1.3.
In recent years attention has focused on the importance of both the soluble and
insoluble forms of fibrous material in the human diet.Water-soluble NSP is known to
lower serum cholesterol, and insoluble NSP increases faecal bulk and speeds up the
rate of colonic transit.This last effect is thought to be beneficial in preventing a number of diseases, including cancer of the bowel.
The NSP of foods may be degraded in the gut of pigs by microbial fermentation,
yielding volatile fatty acids, which are absorbed and contribute to the energy supply. A further benefit relates to the volatile fatty acid butyric acid, which is reported
to be an important source of energy for the growth of cells in the epithelium of the
colon; thus, the presence of this acid will promote development of the cells and enhance absorption. The extent of degradation depends on the conformation of the
polymers and their structural association with non-carbohydrate components, such
as lignin. In addition, the physical properties of the NSP, such as water-holding capacity and ion exchange properties, can influence the extent of fermentation. The
gel-forming NSPs, such as ␤-glucan, reduce the absorption of other nutrients from
the small intestine and depress digestibility and adversely affect faecal consistency
in pigs and poultry. On a positive note, the water-holding properties lead to beneficial effects on the behaviour of pregnant sows by increasing time spent eating and
resting owing to increased gut fill and by reducing inappropriate behaviour, such as
bar chewing.
10
102
158
348
154
196
221
602
485
512
Wheat
Barley
Maize gluten feed
Peas
Soya bean meal
Rapeseed meal
Sugar beet pulp
Grass meal
Wheat straw
2
1
2
3
4
3
15
1
1
Rhamnose
1
1
0
0
2
2
1
6
0
Fucose
23
25
66
32
25
43
163
28
21
Arabinose
37
50
96
10
17
18
20
128
169
Xylose
5
4
4
2
10
4
10
4
5
Mannose
4
3
17
8
49
16
40
12
7
Galactose
27
75
102
80
59
64
193
253
315
Glucose
7
12
29
23
36
48
161
29
18
Uronic acids
11
33
31
8
30
100
63
50
171
Lignin
105
210
400
194
115
256
490
723
752
NDF
35
89
114
110
83
206
276
389
465
ADF
Adapted from Dierick N A and Decuypere J A 1994 Enzymes and growth in pigs. In: Cole D J A, Wiseman J and Varley M A (eds) Principles of Pig Science, Loughborough,
Nottingham University Press, 169–95 and Table A2.1.1 for CF.
ADF = acid-detergent fibre, CF = crude fibre, NDF = neutral-detergent fibre, NSP = non-starch polysaccharide.
NSP
Food
Table 1.3 The fibre components (g/kg dry matter) of some common foods
26
53
39
63
58
152
203
210
417
CF
Analysis and characterisation of foods
11
Chapter 1 The animal and its food
Minerals
A simple ash determination provides very little information about the exact mineral
make-up of the food and, when this is required, analytical techniques involving spectroscopy are generally used. In atomic absorption spectroscopy, an acid solution of
the sample is heated in a flame and the vaporised atoms absorb energy, which brings
about transitions from the ground state to higher energy levels. The source of energy
for this transition is a cathode lamp, containing the element to be determined, which
emits radiation at a characteristic wavelength.The radiation absorbed by the atoms in
the flame is proportional to the concentration of the element in the food sample.
Flame emission spectroscopy measures the radiation from solutions of the sample heated in air/acetylene or oxygen/acetylene flames. Each element emits radiation at specific wavelengths and there are published tables of flame emission spectra.
Atomic absorption and flame emission spectrometry are being replaced by inductively coupled plasma emission spectroscopy, as this has a greater sensitivity for the
relatively inert elements and can be used to determine several elements simultaneously or sequentially. Energy from the inductively coupled plasma source is absorbed by argon ions and elements to form a conducting gaseous mixture at
temperatures up to 10 000 °C. The electromagnetic radiation emitted from atoms
and ions within the plasma is then measured.Alternatively the ions can be separated
and detected using a mass spectrometer.
Just as with other nutrients, a measure of the concentration of the element alone
is not sufficient to describe its usefulness to the animal.Attempts have been made to
assess the availability of minerals using chemical methods, such as solubility in water
or dilute acids, but these have had little success. At present animal experiments are
the only reliable way to measure mineral availability (see Chapter 10).
Amino acids, fatty acids and sugars
As an alternative to the standard Kjeldahl method for the determination of nitrogen
(crude protein) described above, the Dumas method is also now used. In this method
the sample is combusted in pure oxygen; the products are carbon dioxide, water, oxides of nitrogen and nitrogen. The carbon dioxide and water are absorbed on
columns and the oxides of nitrogen are converted to nitrogen with a column packed
with copper; the resulting total nitrogen is determined in a thermal conductivity detector. This method, although expensive in equipment, is rapid and does not rely on
hazardous chemicals.
Knowledge of the crude protein content of a food is not a sufficient measure of its
usefulness for non-ruminants. The amino acid composition of the protein is required
in order to assess how a food can meet the essential amino acid requirements (see
Chapter 4). Similarly, the total ether extract content does not give sufficient information on this fraction since it is important to know its fatty acid composition. In nonruminants, this has large effects on the composition of body fat and, if soft fat is to be
avoided, the level of unsaturated fatty acids in the diet must be controlled. In ruminants, a high proportion of unsaturates will depress fibre digestion in the rumen.
When detailed information on the amino acid composition of protein, the fatty acid
composition of fat or the individual sugars in NSP is required, then techniques involving chromatographic separation can be used. In gas–liquid chromatography, the
stationary phase is a liquid held in a porous solid, usually a resin, and the mobile
phase is a gas. Volatile substances partition between the liquid and the vapour and
12
Analysis and characterisation of foods
can be effectively isolated. This form of chromatography is, however, usually a slow
process; in order to speed up the separation procedure, high-performance liquid
chromatography has been developed. In this technique, pressure is used to force a
solution, containing the compounds to be separated, rapidly through the resin held
in a strong metal column. In addition to speeding up the process, high resolution is
also obtained. Gas–liquid chromatography and high-performance liquid chromatography can also be used for the determination of certain vitamins (e.g. A, E, B6, K),
but the measurement of available vitamins requires biological methods.
An example of the application of high-performance liquid chromatography is
seen with food proteins, which are hydrolysed with acid and the released amino
acids are then determined using one of the following methods:
■
■
Ion-exchange chromatography – by which the amino acids are separated on the
column, and then mixed with a derivatisation agent, which reacts to give a complex that is detected by a spectrophotometer or fluorimeter.
Reverse-phase chromatography – in which the amino acids react with the reagent
to form fluorescent or ultraviolet-absorbing derivatives, which are then separated
using a more polar mobile phase (e.g. acetate buffer with a gradient of acetonitrile)
and a less polar stationary phase (e.g. octadecyl-bonded silica). The availability of
amino acids to the animal can be estimated by chemical methods. For example, for
lysine there are colorimetric methods that depend on the formation of compounds
between lysine and dyes (see Chapter 13).
Measurement of protein in foods for ruminants
The new methods of expressing the protein requirements of ruminants (see
Chapter 13) require more information than just the crude protein (nitrogen) content
of the food. The unavailable nitrogen is measured as acid detergent insoluble nitrogen. Information on the rate of degradation in the rumen of the available nitrogen is
also required and this can be estimated by biological methods. In the Cornell net carbohydrate and protein system, the neutral and acid detergent extractions of Van Soest,
described above, are used in combination with extraction with a borate–phosphate
buffer and trichloracetic acid solution to derive several protein fractions. These fractions describe the components that are degraded in the rumen or digested in the
small intestine (see Chapter 13).
Spectroscopy
It is now common for laboratories to use near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy
(NIRS) to estimate the composition of foods. The basis of this methodology lies in
the absorption of energy by hydrogen-containing functional groups in organic compounds present in the food (C–H, O–H, N–H and S–H). The reflected energy from
the sample provides information on its composition but, unlike normal spectroscopy,
is not related directly to concentration since the sample is heterogenous. Therefore,
empirical relationships are derived by calibrating the reflected spectrum with samples of known composition, as determined by standard methods. In practice, energy
in the wavelength range 1100–2500 nm is directed on to a cell containing the dried
milled sample, and the diffuse reflected energy is measured across the spectrum.The
spectral data are then related to the known chemical composition of the standard
samples by multiple linear regression. The relationships are then validated with a
second set of samples of known composition. Once satisfactory relationships have
13
Chapter 1 The animal and its food
been derived, they can be applied to the spectra of samples of unknown composition. The technique has been extended to the analysis of fresh silage samples, eliminating the need to dry and mill the sample. NIRS has the advantages that it is rapid
with minimal sample preparation, it gives instantaneous results and is non-destructive
of the sample, it allows simultaneous measurement of several parameters with high
precision, and it allows a high throughput of samples at low cost per sample. It is
particularly useful in the context of compound food manufacture where rapid analysis of raw materials and finished product is required for efficient mixing and quality
control standards. With forages, particularly grass and cereal silages, NIRS is now
routinely used to determine not only chemical composition but also a range of food
characteristics, including those that are the resultant of a number of nutrient concentrations such as digestibility, metabolisable energy and nitrogen degradability in the
rumen and potential silage intake (see Chapters 12, 13 and 17).
Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy is a complex technique that is used to
determine the constituents of foods. This method makes use of the fact that some
compounds contain certain atomic nuclei which can be identified from a nuclear
magnetic resonance spectrum, which measures variations in frequency of electromagnetic radiation absorbed. It provides more specific and detailed information of
the conformational structure of compounds than, for example, NIRS but is more
costly and requires more time and skill on the part of the operator. For these
reasons, it is more suited to research work and for cases in which the results from
simpler spectroscopy techniques require further investigation. Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy has been useful in the investigation of the soluble and structural components of forages.
SUMMARY
1. Water is an important component of animal
foods. It contributes to the water requirements
of animals and dilutes the nutrient content of
foods. Water content varies widely between
foods.
6. Fibrous constituents can be determined by
application of detergent solutions and weighing the residue or by the use of enzymes
followed by weighing or gas–liquid chromatography.
2. The constituents of dry matter comprise
carbohydrates (sugars, starches, fibres),
nitrogen-containing compounds (proteins,
amino acids, non-protein nitrogen compounds),
lipids (fatty acids, glycerides), minerals and
vitamins.
7. Individual mineral elements are measured
by atomic absorption spectroscopy, flame
photometry or inductively coupled plasma
emission spectroscopy.
3. Analytical techniques have been developed from
simple chemical/gravimetric determinations.
4. Modern analytical techniques attempt to
measure nutrients in foods in terms of the
nutrient requirements of the animal.
5. Starch is determined by polarimetry.
14
8. Gas–liquid chromatography is used to determine individual amino acids, fatty acids and
certain vitamins.
9. Near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy is used
routinely to determine food characteristics and
to predict nutritive value. Nuclear magnetic
resonance spectroscopy is a research technique
for determining the chemical structure of food
components.
Further reading
FURTHER READING
Agricultural and Food Research Council 1987 Technical Committee on Responses to Nutrients, report no. 2. Characterisation of feedstuffs: nitrogen. Nutrition Abstracts and
Reviews, Series B: Livestock Feeds and Feeding 57: 713–36.
Agricultural and Food Research Council 1988 Technical Committee on Responses to Nutrients, report no. 3. Characterisation of feedstuffs: other nutrients. Nutrition Abstracts and
Reviews, Series B: Livestock Feeds and Feeding 58: 549–71.
Asp N-G and Johansson C-G 1984 Dietary fibre analysis. Nutrition Abstracts and Reviews 54:
735–51.
Association of Official Analytical Chemists 1990 Official Methods of Analysis, 15th edn,
Washington, DC.
Chalupa W and Sniffen C J 1994 Carbohydrate, protein and amino acid nutrition of lactating
dairy cattle. In: Garnsworthy P C and Cole D J A (eds) Recent Advances in Animal Nutrition, Loughborough, Nottingham University Press, 265–75.
Champ M, Langkilde A-M, Brouns F, Kettlitz B and Le Bail Collet Y 2003 Advances in dietary
fibre characterization. 1. Definition of dietary fibre, physiological relevance, health benefits
and analytical aspects. Nutrition Research Reviews 16: 71–82.
Coultate T P 1989 Food: The Chemistry of its Components, 2nd edn, London, Royal Society
of Chemistry.
Givens D I, De Boever J L and Deaville E R 1997 The principles, practices and some future
applications of near infrared spectroscopy for predicting the nutritive value of foods for
animals and humans. Nutrition Research Reviews 10: 83–114.
Kritchevsky D, Bonfield C and Anderson J W 1988 Dietary Fiber, New York, Plenum Press.
Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food 1985 The Analysis of Agricultural Materials,
ref. book 427, London, HMSO.
The Feeding Stuffs (Sampling and Analysis) Regulations 1999, London, HMSO.
Van Soest P J 1994 Nutritional Ecology of the Ruminant, 2nd edn, Ithaca, NY, Comstock.
15
2
Carbohydrates
2.1
Classification of carbohydrates
2.2
Monosaccharides
2.3
Monosaccharide derivatives
2.4
Oligosaccharides
2.5
Polysaccharides
2.6
Lignin
In general, carbohydrates are neutral chemical compounds containing the elements
carbon, hydrogen and oxygen and have the empirical formula (CH2O)n, where n is 3 or
more. However, some compounds with general properties of the carbohydrates also
contain phosphorus, nitrogen or sulphur; and others, e.g. deoxyribose (C5H10O4), do not
have hydrogen and oxygen in the same ratio as that in water. The carbohydrate group
contains polyhydroxy aldehydes, ketones, alcohols and acids, their simple derivatives,
and any compound that may be hydrolysed to these.
2.1
CLASSIFICATION OF CARBOHYDRATES
The carbohydrates may be classified as shown in Fig. 2.1. The simplest sugars are the
monosaccharides, which are divided into subgroups – trioses (C3H6O3), tetroses
(C4H8O4), pentoses (C5H10O5), hexoses (C6H12O6) and heptoses (C7H14O7) depending upon the number of carbon atoms present in the molecule.The trioses and tetroses
occur as intermediates in the metabolism of other carbohydrates and their importance
will be considered in Chapter 9. Monosaccharides may be linked together, with the
elimination of one molecule of water at each linkage, to produce di-, tri-, tetra- or polysaccharides, containing, respectively, two, three, four or larger numbers of monosaccharide units.
The term sugar is generally restricted to those carbohydrates containing fewer than
ten monosaccharide residues, while the name oligosaccharides (from the Greek oligos,
a few) is frequently used to include all sugars other than the monosaccharides.
Polysaccharides, also called glycans, are polymers of monosaccharide units. They
are classified into two groups, the homoglycans, which contain only a single type of
monosaccharide unit, and the heteroglycans, which on hydrolysis yield mixtures of
16
Classification of carbohydrates
Trioses (C3H6O3)
Glyceraldehyde
Dihydroxyacetone
Tetroses (C4H8O4)
Erythrose
Monosaccharides Pentoses (C5H10O5)
Hexoses (C6H12O6)
Sugars
Heptoses (C7H14O7)
Glucose
Galactose
Mannose
Fructose
Sedoheptulose
Sucrose
Lactose
Maltose
Cellobiose
Disaccharides
Oligosaccharides
Arabinose
Xylose
Xylulose
Ribose
Ribulose
Trisaccharides
Raffinose
Kestose
Tetrasaccharides
Stachyose
Arabinans
Xylans
Glucans
Homoglycans
Starch
Dextrins
Glycogen
Cellulose
Callose
Fructans
Inulin
Galactans
Levan
Mannans
Glucosamines
Polysaccharides
Heteroglycans
Non-sugars
Pectic substances
Hemicelluloses
Exudate gums
Acidic mucilages
Hyaluronic acid
Chondroitin
Glycolipids
Complex
carbohydrates
Glycoproteins
Fig. 2.1 Classification of carbohydrates.
17
Chapter 2 Carbohydrates
monosaccharides and derived products. The molecular weight of polysaccharides
varies from as little as about 8000 in some plant fructans to as high as 100 million in
the amylopectin component of starch. Hydrolysis of these polymers to their constituent sugars can be effected by the action of either specific enzymes or acids.
The complex carbohydrates are an ill-defined group of compounds that contain
carbohydrates in combination with non-carbohydrate molecules. They include the
glycolipids and glycoproteins. The structure and biological importance of these two
groups of compounds are discussed in Chapters 3 and 4, respectively.
2.2
MONOSACCHARIDES
Structure
The monosaccharide sugars occur in a number of isomeric forms.Thus, glucose and
fructose (both hexoses) are structural isomers, glucose having an aldehyde group
and fructose having a ketone group. Both of these sugars occur in two mirror
image, stereoisomeric forms, dextro and laevo (D- and L-), according to the orientation of the OH group at carbon atom 5. Biologically the D-forms are the more
important.
1CHO
H2COH
HO3CH
CHO
HOCH
HCOH
1CH
2OH
2C
O
HO3CH
HOCH
HOCH
H
H5COH
HOCH
H5COH
D-Glucose
CH2OH
L-Glucose
6CH
O
HCOH
HOCH
2OH
C
4COH
H4COH
6CH
CH2OH
2OH
D-Fructose
CH2OH
L-Fructose
Under physiological conditions, sugars exist mainly in another isomeric form, as
ring or cyclic structures, rather than straight chains. Glucose forms a pyranose ring
and fructose most commonly forms a furanose ring. Each ring structure can occur in
two isomeric forms, designated ␣ and ␤. Starch and glycogen are polymers of the
␣-form, while cellulose is a polymer of the ␤-form.
Properties of the monosaccharides
Because of the presence of an active aldehyde or ketone grouping, the monosaccharides act as reducing substances. The reducing properties of these sugars are usually
demonstrated by their ability to reduce certain metal ions, notably copper or silver,
in alkaline solution. The aldehyde and ketone groups may also be reduced chemically, or enzymatically, to yield the corresponding sugar alcohols. Examples of oxidation and reduction products are given in the section dealing with monosaccharide
derivatives (see p. 20).
18
Monosaccharides
6
6
CH2OH
5C
5C
O
H
H
O
C
H
OH
H
1C
OH
H
C4
OH
HO
OH
C3
1C
H
H
H
C3
α-D-Glucose
C
H
OH
C
C
OH
H
OH
HO
2C
H
OH
C
H
HO
2C
O
H
H
C4
CH2OH
H
CH2OH
OH
β-D-Glucose
α-D-Fructose
Pentoses
The most important members of this group of simple sugars are the aldoses L-arabinose,
D-xylose and D-ribose, and the ketoses D-xylulose and D-ribulose.
H
O
H
O
OH
H
H
O
HOH2C
H
H
HOH2C
OH
H
H
OH
H
H
OH
OH
OH
H
OH
α-D-Xylose
α-L-Arabinose
H
H
H
OH
OH
OH
α-D-Ribose
L-Arabinose occurs as pentosans in arabinans. It is a component of hemicelluloses
and it is found in silage as a result of their hydrolysis. It is also a component of gum
arabic and other gums. D-Xylose also occurs as pentosans in xylans. These compounds form the main chain in grass hemicelluloses. Xylose, along with arabinose,
is produced in considerable quantities when herbage is hydrolysed with normal
sulphuric acid. D-Ribose is present in all living cells as a constituent of ribonucleic
acid (RNA), and it is also a component of several vitamins and coenzymes.
CH2OH
CH2OH
C
C
O
HOCH
HCOH
CH2OH
D-Xylulose
O
HCOH
HCOH
CH2OH
D-Ribulose
The phosphate derivatives of D-xylulose and D-ribulose occur as intermediates in
the pentose phosphate metabolic pathway (see p. 202).
19
Chapter 2 Carbohydrates
Hexoses
Glucose and fructose are the most important naturally occurring hexose sugars,
while mannose and galactose occur in plants in a polymerised form as mannans
and galactans.
D-Glucose, grape sugar or dextrose, exists in the free state as well as in combined
form. The sugar occurs free in plants, fruits, honey, blood, lymph and cerebrospinal
fluid, and it is the sole or major component of many oligosaccharides, polysaccharides and glucosides. In the pure state, glucose is a white crystalline solid and, like all
sugars, is soluble in water.
D-Fructose, fruit sugar or laevulose, occurs free in green leaves, fruits and honey.
It also occurs in the disaccharide sucrose and in fructans. Green leafy crops usually
contain appreciable amounts of this sugar, both free and in polymerised form. The
free sugar is a white crystalline solid and has a sweeter taste than sucrose.The exceptionally sweet taste of honey is due to this sugar.
D-Mannose does not occur free in nature but exists in polymerised form as mannan and also as a component of glycoproteins. Mannans are found widely distributed in yeasts, moulds and bacteria.
D-Galactose does not occur free in nature except as a breakdown product during
fermentation. It is present as a constituent of the disaccharide lactose, which occurs
in milk. Galactose also occurs as a component of the anthocyanin pigments, galactolipids, gums and mucilages.
Heptoses
D-Sedoheptulose is an important example of a monosaccharide containing seven
carbon atoms and occurs, as the phosphate, as an intermediate in the pentose phosphate metabolic pathway (see p. 202).
CH2OH
C
O
HOCH
HCOH
HCOH
HCOH
CH2OH
D-Sedoheptulose
2.3
MONOSACCHARIDE DERIVATIVES
Phosphoric acid esters
The phosphoric acid esters of sugars play an important role in a wide variety of
metabolic reactions in living organisms (see Chapter 9). The most commonly occurring derivatives are those formed from glucose, the esterification occurring at either
carbon atoms 1 or 6 or both.
20
Monosaccharide derivatives
OH
CH2O
CH2OH
H
H
H
O
O OH
H
O
H
P
H
OH
OH
H
OH
O
P
OH
H
OH
O
O
OH
H
H
OH
α-D-Glucose 1-phosphate
OH
α-D-Glucose 6-phosphate
Amino sugars
If the hydroxyl group on carbon atom 2 of an aldohexose is replaced by an amino
group (–NH2), the resulting compound is an amino sugar. Two such naturally occurring important compounds are D-glucosamine, a major component of chitin (see
p. 28), and D-galactosamine, a component of the polysaccharide of cartilage.
CH2OH
CH2OH
O
O
OH
H
OH
HO
H
H
OH
H
OH
H
HO
H
NH2
H
H
β-D-Glucosamine
H
H
NH2
β-D-Galactosamine
Deoxy sugars
Replacement of a hydroxyl group by hydrogen yields a deoxy sugar. The derivative
of ribose, deoxyribose, is a component of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA). Similarly,
deoxy derivatives of the two hexoses, galactose and mannose, occur as fucose and
rhamnose, respectively, these being components of certain heteropolysaccharides.
H
O
HOH2C
H
O
HO
OH
CH3
H
H
OH
H
OH
H
α-D-Deoxyribose
H
H
H
H
OH
OH
α-L-Rhamnose
21
Chapter 2 Carbohydrates
Sugar acids
The aldoses can be oxidised to produce a number of acids, of which the most
important are:
COOH
COOH
(CHOH)n
(CHOH)n
(CHOH)n
CH2OH
COOH
COOH
Aldonic acids
Aldaric acids
Uronic acids
CHO
In the case of glucose, the derivatives corresponding to these formulae are gluconic, glucaric and glucuronic acids, respectively. Of these compounds, the uronic
acids, particularly those derived from glucose and galactose, are important components of a number of heteropolysaccharides.
Sugar alcohols
Simple sugars can be reduced to polyhydric alcohols; for example, glucose yields
sorbitol, galactose yields dulcitol, and both mannose and fructose yield mannitol.
Mannitol occurs in grass silage and is formed by the action of certain anaerobic
bacteria on the fructose present in the grass.
CH2OH
CH2OH
C
HOCH
O
HOCH
CHO
+2H
HOCH
HOCH
+2H
HOCH
HCOH
HCOH
HCOH
HCOH
HCOH
HCOH
CH2OH
D-Fructose
CH2OH
CH2OH
D-Mannitol
D-Mannose
Glycosides
If the hydrogen of the hydroxyl group attached to the carbon 1 atom of glucose is
replaced by esterification, or by condensation, with an alcohol (including a sugar
molecule) or a phenol, the derivative so produced is termed a glucoside. Similarly
galactose forms galactosides and fructose forms fructosides.The general term glycoside is used collectively to describe these derivatives and the linkage is described as
a glycosidic bond.
Oligosaccharides and polysaccharides are classed as glycosides, and these compounds yield sugars or sugar derivatives on hydrolysis. Certain naturally occurring
glycosides contain non-sugar residues. For example, the nucleosides contain a sugar
combined with a heterocyclic nitrogenous base (see Chapter 4).
22
Oligosaccharides
Table 2.1 Some important naturally occurring cyanogenetic glycosides
Name
Source
Hydrolytic products in
addition to glucose and
hydrogen cyanide
Linamarin
(phaseolunatin)
Linseed (Linum usitatissimum),
Java beans (Phaseolus lunatus),
Cassava (Manihot esculenta)
Acetone
Vicianin
Seeds of wild vetch
(Vicia angustifolia)
Arabinose, benzaldehyde
Amygdalin
Bitter almonds, kernels of
peach, cherries, plums, apples
and fruits of Rosaceae
Benzaldehyde
Dhurrin
Leaves of the great millet
(Sorghum vulgare)
p-Hydroxy-benzaldehyde
Lotaustralin
Trefoil (Lotus australis),
White clover (Trifolium repens)
Methylethyl ketone
The cyanogenetic glycosides liberate hydrogen cyanide (HCN) on hydrolysis; because of the toxic nature of this compound, plants containing this type of glycoside
are potentially dangerous to animals. The glycoside itself is not toxic and must be
hydrolysed before poisoning occurs. However, the glycoside is easily broken down
to its components by means of an enzyme that is usually present in the plant. An
example of a cyanogenetic glycoside is linamarin (also called phaseolunatin), which
occurs in linseed, Java beans and cassava. If wet mashes or gruels containing these
foods are given to animals, it is advisable to boil them when mixing in order to inactivate any enzyme present. On hydrolysis, linamarin yields glucose, acetone and
hydrogen cyanide.
Examples of other cyanogenetic glycosides and their sources are shown in
Table 2.1.
2.4
OLIGOSACCHARIDES
Disaccharides
A large number of disaccharide compounds are theoretically possible, depending
upon the monosaccharides present and the manner in which they are linked.The most
nutritionally important disaccharides are sucrose, maltose, lactose and cellobiose,
which on hydrolysis yield two molecules of hexoses:
C12H22O11 + H2O : 2C6H12O6
Sucrose is formed from one molecule of ␣-D-glucose and one molecule of ␤-Dfructose joined together through an oxygen bridge between their respective carbon
atoms 1 and 2. As a consequence, sucrose has no active reducing group.
23
Chapter 2 Carbohydrates
CH2OH
CH2OH
O
H
O
H
H
H
OH
H
HO
H
O
H
OH
HO
OH
CH2OH
H
Sucrose
Sucrose is the most ubiquitous and abundantly occurring disaccharide in plants,
where it is the main transport form of carbon.This disaccharide is found in high concentration in sugar cane (200 g/kg) and in sugar beet (150–200 g/kg); it is also present in other roots such as mangels and carrots, and it occurs in many fruits. Sucrose
is easily hydrolysed by the enzyme sucrase or by dilute acids.When heated to a temperature of 160 °C it forms barley sugar and at a temperature of 200 °C it forms
caramel.
Lactose, or milk sugar, is a product of the mammary gland. Cow’s milk contains
43–48 g/kg lactose. It is not as soluble as sucrose and is less sweet, imparting only
a faint sweet taste to milk. Lactose is formed from one molecule of ␤-D-glucose
joined to one of ␤-D-galactose in a ␤-(1:4)-linkage and has one active reducing
group.
CH2OH
CH2OH
O
O
H
HO
H
OH
H
O
OH
OH
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
OH
OH
Lactose
Lactose readily undergoes fermentation by a number of organisms, including
Streptococcus lactis. This organism is responsible for souring milk by converting the
lactose into lactic acid (CH3.CHOH.COOH). If lactose is heated to 150 °C it turns
yellow; at a temperature of 175 °C the sugar is changed into a brown compound,
lactocaramel. On hydrolysis lactose produces one molecule of glucose and one
molecule of galactose.
Maltose, or malt sugar, is produced during the hydrolysis of starch and glycogen
by dilute acids or enzymes. It is produced from starch during the germination of barley by the action of the enzyme amylase. The barley, after controlled germination
and drying, is known as malt and is used in the manufacture of beer and Scotch malt
whisky. Maltose is water-soluble, but it is not as sweet as sucrose. Structurally it
24
Oligosaccharides
consists of two ␣-D-glucose residues linked in the ␣-1,4 positions; it has one active
reducing group.
CH2OH
CH2OH
O
O
H
H
H
H
OH
H
H
OH
H
HO
H
O
H
OH
H
OH
OH
Maltose
Cellobiose does not exist naturally as a free sugar, but it is the basic repeating unit
of cellulose. It is composed of two ␤-D-glucose residues linked through a ␤-(1:4)-bond.
This linkage cannot be split by mammalian digestive enzymes. It can, however, be
split by microbial enzymes. Like maltose, cellobiose has one active reducing group.
CH2OH
H
OH
OH
H
O
O
H
H
H
OH
H
HO
H
H
OH
H
O
H
CH2OH
OH
Cellobiose
Trisaccharides
Raffinose and kestose are two important naturally occurring trisaccharides.They are
both non-reducing and on hydrolysis produce three molecules of hexose sugars:
C18H32O16 + 2H2O : 3C6H12O6
Raffinose is the commonest member of the group, occurring almost as widely as
sucrose in plants. It exists in small amounts in sugar beet and accumulates in molasses
during the commercial preparation of sucrose. Cotton seed contains about 80 g/kg of
raffinose. On hydrolysis, this sugar produces glucose, fructose and galactose.
Kestose and its isomer isokestose occur in the vegetative parts and seeds of
grasses. These two trisaccharides consist of a fructose residue attached to a sucrose
molecule.
Tetrasaccharides
Tetrasaccharides are made up of four monosaccharide residues. Stachyose, a member of this group, is almost as ubiquitous as raffinose in higher plants and has been
25
Chapter 2 Carbohydrates
isolated from about 165 species. It is a non-reducing sugar and on hydrolysis
produces two molecules of galactose, one molecule of glucose and one of fructose:
C24H42O21 + 3H2O : 4C6H12O6
2.5
POLYSACCHARIDES
Homoglycans
These carbohydrates are very different from the sugars. The majority are of high
molecular weight, being composed of large numbers of pentose or hexose residues.
Homoglycans do not give the various sugar reactions characteristic of the aldoses
and ketoses. Many of them occur in plants either as reserve food materials such as
starch or as structural materials such as cellulose.
Arabinans and xylans
These are polymers of arabinose and xylose, respectively. Although homoglycans
based on these two pentoses are known, they are more commonly found in combination with other sugars as constituents of heteroglycans.
Glucans
Starch is a glucan and is present in many plants as a reserve carbohydrate. It is most
abundant in seeds, fruits, tubers and roots. Starch occurs naturally in the form of
granules, whose size and shape vary in different plants. The granules are built up in
concentric layers, and although glucan is the main component of the granules they
also contain minor constituents such as protein, fatty acids and phosphorus compounds, which may influence their properties.
Starches differ in their chemical composition and, except in rare instances, are
mixtures of two structurally different polysaccharides, amylose and amylopectin.
The proportions of these present in natural starches depend upon the source,
although in most starches amylopectin is the main component, amounting to about
70–80 per cent of the total. An important qualitative test for starch is its reaction
with iodine: amylose produces a deep blue colour and amylopectin solutions
produce a blue–violet or purple colour.
Amylose is mainly linear in structure, the ␣-D-glucose residues being linked between carbon atom 1 of one molecule and carbon atom 4 of the adjacent molecule.
A small proportion of ␣-(1:6) linkages may also be present.Amylopectin has a bushlike structure containing primarily ␣-(1:4) linkages, but it also has an appreciable
number of ␣-(1:6) linkages.
6CH
5
H
6CH
2OH
O
H
H
H
O
1
3
H
5
O
H
O
2
OH
1
OH
3
H
H
4
H
2
OH
1
OH
O
3
H
Part of amylose molecule showing 1,4 linkages
26
O
H
4
H
2OH
5
H
H
4
OH
6CH
2OH
H
2
OH
O
Polysaccharides
Starch granules are insoluble in cold water, but when a suspension in water is
heated the granules swell and eventually gelatinise. On gelatinisation, potato
starch granules swell greatly and then burst open; cereal starches swell but tend
not to burst.
Animals consume large quantities of starch in cereal grains, cereal by-products
and tubers.
Glycogen is a term used to describe a group of highly branched polysaccharides
isolated from animals or microorganisms. The molecules can be hydrolysed rapidly
in conditions requiring the mobilisation of glucose, such as exercise and stress.
Glycogens occur in liver, muscle and other animal tissues. They are glucans, analogous to amylopectin in structure, and have been referred to as ‘animal starches’.
Glycogen is the main carbohydrate storage product in the animal body and plays an
essential role in energy metabolism.
The molecular weights of glycogen molecules vary considerably according to
the animal species, the type of tissue and the physiological state of the animal.
The glycogen of rat liver, for example, has molecular weights in the range
1- 5 * 108, whereas that from rat muscle has a rather lower molecular weight of
about 5 * 106.
Dextrins are intermediate products of the hydrolysis of starch and glycogen:
Starch
Dextrins → maltose → glucose
Glycogen
Dextrins are soluble in water and produce gum-like solutions. The higher members of these transitional products produce a red colour with iodine, while the lower
members do not give a colour. The presence of dextrins gives a characteristic flavour
to bread crust, toast and partly charred cereal foods.
Cellulose is the most abundant single polymer in the plant kingdom, forming the
fundamental structure of plant cell walls. It is also found in a nearly pure form in cotton. Pure cellulose is a homoglycan of high molecular weight in which the repeating
unit is cellobiose. Here the ␤-glucose residues are 1,4-linked.
CH2OH
H
OH
CH2OH
O
H
OH
H
OH
OH
OH
H
O
O
H
H
H
H
OH
H
O
H
H
O
H
H
H
HO
H
H
H
H
OH
O
H
OH
O
H
CH2OH
OH
CH2OH
n
Cellulose
27
Chapter 2 Carbohydrates
In the plant, cellulose chains are formed in an ordered manner to produce compact aggregates (microfibrils), which are held together by both inter- and intramolecular
hydrogen bonding. In the plant cell wall, cellulose is closely associated, physically
and chemically, with other components, especially hemicelluloses and lignin.
Callose is a collective term for a group of polysaccharides consisting of ␤-(1,3)and frequently ␤-(1,4)-linked glucose residues.These ␤-glucans occur in higher plants
as components of special walls appearing at particular stages of development.A large
part of the endosperm cell wall of cereal grains is composed of ␤-glucans of this type.
They are also deposited by higher plants in response to wounding and infection.
Fructans
These occur as reserve material in roots, stems, leaves and seeds of a variety of
plants, but particularly in the Compositae and Gramineae. In the Gramineae, fructans are found only in temperate species. These polysaccharides are soluble in cold
water and are of a relatively low molecular weight. All known fructans contain ␤-Dfructose residues joined by 2,6 or 2,1 linkages. They can be divided into three
groups: (1) the levan group, characterised by 2,6 linkages; (2) the inulin group, containing 2,1 linkages; and (3) a group of highly branched fructans found, for example,
in couch grass (Agropyron repens) and in wheat endosperm. This group contains
both types of linkage.
Most fructans on hydrolysis yield, in addition to D-fructose, a small amount of Dglucose, which is derived from the terminal sucrose unit in the fructan molecule.The
structure of a typical grass fructan is depicted here:
CH2OH
CH2OH
O
O
O
CH2
O
CH2
O
O
O
OH
H
H
H
OH
HO
CH2OH H
H
H
HO
OH
CH2OH H
H
Grass fructan
H
OH
1-30
HO
H
OH
CH2OH
H
H
H
H
OH
(Sucrose residue)
Galactans and mannans
These are polymers of galactose and mannose, respectively, and occur in the cell walls
of plants. A mannan is the main component of the cell walls of palm seeds, where it
occurs as a food reserve and disappears during germination. A rich source of mannan
is the endosperm of nuts from the South American tagua palm tree (Phytelephas
macrocarpa); the hard endosperm of this nut is known as ‘vegetable ivory’.The seeds
of many legumes, including clovers, trefoil and lucerne, contain galactans.
Glucosaminans
Chitin is the only known example of a homoglycan containing glucosamine, being a
linear polymer of acetyl-D-glucosamine. Chitin is of widespread occurrence in lower
28
Polysaccharides
animals and is particularly abundant in Crustacea, in fungi and in some green algae.
After cellulose, it is probably the most abundant polysaccharide of nature.
Heteroglycans
Pectic substances
Pectic substances are a group of closely associated polysaccharides that are soluble
in hot water and occur as constituents of primary cell walls and intercellular regions
of higher plants.They are particularly abundant in soft tissues such as the peel of citrus fruits and sugar beet pulp. Pectin, the main member of this group, consists of a
linear chain of D-galacturonic acid units in which varying proportions of the acid
groups are present as methyl esters.The chains are interrupted at intervals by the insertion of L-rhamnose residues. Other constituent sugars, e.g. D-galactose, L-arabinose and D-xylose, are attached as side chains. Pectic acid is another member of this
class of compounds; it is similar in structure to pectin but is devoid of ester groups.
Pectic substances possess considerable gelling properties and are used commercially
in jam making.
Hemicelluloses
Hemicelluloses are defined as alkali-soluble cell wall polysaccharides that are
closely associated with cellulose. The name hemicellulose is misleading and implies
erroneously that the material is destined for conversion to cellulose. Structurally,
hemicelluloses are composed mainly of D-glucose, D-galactose, D-mannose, D-xylose
and L-arabinose units joined together in different combinations and by various glycosidic linkages. They may also contain uronic acids.
Hemicelluloses from grasses contain a main chain of xylan made up of ␤-(1:4)linked D-xylose units with side chains containing methylglucuronic acid and frequently glucose, galactose and arabinose.
Exudate gums and acid mucilages
Exudate gums are often produced from wounds in plants, although they may arise as
natural exudations from bark and leaves. The gums occur naturally as salts, especially of calcium and magnesium, and in some cases a proportion of the hydroxyl
groups are esterified, usually as acetates. Gum arabic (acacia gum) has long been a
familiar substance; on hydrolysis it yields arabinose, galactose, rhamnose and glucuronic acid. Acidic mucilages are obtained from the bark, roots, leaves and seeds of
a variety of plants. Linseed mucilage is a well-known example that produces arabinose, galactose, rhamnose and galacturonic acid on hydrolysis.
Hyaluronic acid and chondroitin
These two polysaccharides have a repeating unit consisting of an amino sugar and Dglucuronic acid. Hyaluronic acid, which contains acetyl-D-glucosamine, is present in
the skin, the synovial fluid and the umbilical cord. Solutions of this acid are viscous
and play an important part in the lubrication of joints. Chondroitin is chemically
similar to hyaluronic acid but contains galactosamine in place of glucosamine.
Sulphate esters of chondroitin are major structural components of cartilage, tendons
and bones.
29
Chapter 2 Carbohydrates
2.6
LIGNIN
Lignin, which is not a carbohydrate but is closely associated with this group of compounds, confers chemical and biological resistance to the cell wall, and mechanical
strength to the plant. Strictly speaking the term ‘lignin’ does not refer to a single,
well-defined compound but is a collective term that embraces a whole series of
closely related compounds.
Lignin is a polymer that originates from three derivatives of phenylpropane:
coumaryl alcohol, coniferyl alcohol and sinapyl alcohol. The lignin molecule is made
up of many phenylpropanoid units associated in a complex cross-linked structure:
CH
CH.CH2OH
R1
R
OH
(1) Coumaryl alcohol, where R = R1 = H
(2) Coniferyl alcohol, where R = H, R1 = OCH3
(3) Sinapyl alcohol, where R = R1 = OCH3
Lignin is of particular interest in animal nutrition because of its high resistance to
chemical degradation. Physical incrustation of plant fibres by lignin renders them inaccessible to enzymes that would normally digest them. There is evidence that strong
chemical bonds exist between lignin and many plant polysaccharides and cell wall proteins that render these compounds unavailable during digestion.Wood products, mature
hays and straws are rich in lignin and consequently are poorly digested unless treated
chemically to break the bonds between lignin and other carbohydrates (see p. 249).
SUMMARY
1. Carbohydrates are compounds containing
carbon, hydrogen and oxygen, with the last two
elements present in the same proportions as in
water, and are found especially in plant foods.
2. They range from the simple sugar molecules
(monosaccharides) with between three and
seven carbon atoms to combinations of two,
three or four molecules (di-, tri- and tetrasaccharides) and finally to complex polymers of
the sugar molecules (polysaccharides).
3. The monosaccharides have an active aldehyde
or ketone group and can take the mirror
image D- or L-formation.
4. Under physiological conditions the monosaccharides exist mainly in cyclic forms, which can
be ␣- or ␤-isomers.
30
5. The carbohydrate group also contains molecules derived from sugars that also contain
phosphorus, nitrogen and sulphur and other
derivatives that feature in intermediary metabolism, nucleic acid structure and substances
such as cyanogenetic glucosides.
6. The main carbohydrates occurring in foods
include the monosaccharides glucose, fructose,
arabinose, xylose and ribose; the disaccharides
sucrose and maltose; and the polysaccharides
starch, hemicellulose and cellulose. The disaccharide lactose occurs in milk.
7. Lignin, although not itself a carbohydrate, is
associated with carbohydrates in plant cell
walls.
Further reading
FURTHER READING
Aspinall G O (ed.) 1982–85 The Polysaccharides,Vols 1–3, New York, Academic Press.
Binkley R W 1988 Modern Carbohydrate Chemistry, New York, Marcel Dekker.
Dey P M and Dixon R A (eds) 1985 Biochemistry of Storage Carbohydrates in Green Plants,
London, Academic Press.
Duffus C M and Duffus J H 1984 Carbohydrate Metabolism in Plants, London, Longman.
Stumpf P K, Conn E E and Preiss J (eds) 1988 The Biochemistry of Plants, Vol. 14, Carbohydrates, New York, Academic Press.
Tipson R S and Horton D (eds) Advances in Carbohydrate Chemistry and Biochemistry,
(annual volumes since 1945), New York, Academic Press.
31
3
3.1
Lipids
3.1
Classification of lipids
3.2
Fats
3.3
Glycolipids
3.4
Phospholipids
3.5
Waxes
3.6
Steroids
3.7
Terpenes
CLASSIFICATION OF LIPIDS
The lipids are a group of substances found in plant and animal tissues.They are insoluble in water but soluble in common organic solvents such as benzene, ether and
chloroform. They act as electron carriers, as substrate carriers in enzymic reactions,
as components of biological membranes, and as sources and stores of energy. In the
proximate analysis of foods they are included in the ether extract fraction.They may
be classified as shown in Fig. 3.1.
Plant lipids are of two main types: structural and storage. The structural lipids are
present as constituents of various membranes and protective surface layers and make
up about 7 per cent of the leaves of higher plants.The surface lipids are mainly waxes,
with relatively minor contributions from long-chain hydrocarbons, fatty acids and
cutin. The membrane lipids, present in mitochondria, the endoplasmic reticulum and
the plasma membranes, are mainly glycolipids (40–50 per cent) and phosphoglycerides. Plant storage lipids occur in fruits and seeds and are, predominantly, triacylglycerols. Over 300 different fatty acids have been isolated from plant tissues, but only
about seven are of common occurrence. The most abundant is ␣-linolenic acid; the
most common saturated acid is palmitic acid and the most common monounsaturated
acid is oleic acid.
In animals, lipids are the major form of energy storage, mainly as fat, which may
constitute up to 97 per cent of the adipose tissue of obese animals. The yield of energy from the complete oxidation of fat is about 39 MJ/kg DM compared with about
17 MJ/kg DM from glycogen, the major carbohydrate form of stored energy. In
32
Fats
Lipids
Glycerol-based
Simple
Non-glycerol-based
Compound
Glycolipids
Fats Glucolipids
Galactolipids
Phosphoglycerides
Lecithins
Cephalins
Sphingomyelins
Cerebrosides
Waxes
Steroids
Terpenes
Eicosanoids
Fig. 3.1 Classification of the lipids.
addition, stored fat is almost anhydrous, whereas stored glycogen is highly hydrated.
Weight for weight, fat is, therefore, about six times as effective as glycogen as a
stored energy source.
The structural lipids of animal tissues, mainly phosphoglycerides, constitute
0.5–1 per cent of muscle and adipose tissue; the concentration in the liver is usually
2–3 per cent.The most important non-glyceride neutral lipid fraction of animal tissue
is made up of cholesterol and its esters, which together make up 0.06–0.09 per cent
of muscle and adipose tissue.
3.2
FATS
Fats and oils are constituents of both plants and animals and are important sources
of stored energy. Both have the same general structure but have different physical
and chemical properties. The melting points of the oils are such that at ordinary
room temperatures they are liquid and they tend to be more chemically reactive
than the more solid fats.The term ‘fat’ is frequently used in a general sense to include
both groups.As well as its major function of supplying energy, stored fat is important
as a thermal insulator and, in some warm-blooded animals, as a source of heat for
maintaining body temperature. This is especially important in animals that are born
hairless, those that hibernate and those that are cold-adapted. Such animals have
special deposits of ‘brown fat’ in which oxidation is uncoupled from adenosine
triphosphate (ATP) production (see Chapter 14) and all the energy is liberated as
heat. Palmitate oxidised to produce ATP would yield about 13 MJ/kg as heat, compared with the uncoupled yield of 39 MJ/kg. In these tissues, the mitochondria are
liberally supplied with respiratory electron carriers, particularly cytochromes, which
accounts for their brown colour.
33
Chapter 3 Lipids
Structure of fats
Fats are esters of fatty acids with the trihydric alcohol glycerol; they are also referred
to as glycerides or acylglycerols.When all three alcohol groups are esterified by fatty
acids, the compound is a triacylglycerol (triglyceride):
sn-1CH
2OH
sn-2CH
OH
sn-3CH
2OH
sn-1CH
+
Gycerol
3R.COOH
2.O.CO.R
sn-2CH.O.CO.R
sn-3CH
Fatty acid
+
3H2O
2.O.CO.R
Triacylglycerol
It is important to appreciate that, in stereochemical terms, the positions occupied
by the acid chains are not identical. Under the stereospecific numbering system the
positions are designated sn-1, sn-2 and sn-3, as shown.They are readily distinguished
by enzymes and this may lead to preferential reactivity at one or more of the positions. Phosphorylation, for example, always takes place at carbon atom sn-3 rather
than at carbon atom sn-1. Although triacylglycerols are predominant, mono- and diacylglycerols do occur naturally, but in much smaller amounts.
Triacylglycerols differ in type according to the nature and position of the fatty
acid residues. Those with three residues of the same fatty acid are termed simple triacylglycerols, as illustrated above.When more than one fatty acid is concerned in the
esterification, a mixed triacylglycerol results:
CH2.O.CO.R1
CH.O.CO.R2
CH2.O.CO.R3
Mixed triacylglycerol
R1, R2 and R3 represent the chains of different fatty acids. Naturally occurring fats
and oils are mixtures of such mixed triacylglycerols. Soya bean oil has been estimated to contain about 79 per cent of mixed triacylglycerols compared with about
21 per cent of the simple type. Comparable figures for linseed oil are 75 and 25 per
cent, respectively. Triacylglycerols with residues of one fatty acid only do occur naturally; laurel oil, for example, contains about 31 per cent of the triacylglycerol of
lauric acid.
Most of the naturally occurring fatty acids have an even number of carbon atoms,
which is to be expected in view of their mode of formation (see Chapter 9).The majority contain a single carboxyl group and an unbranched carbon chain, which may be
saturated or unsaturated. The unsaturated acids contain one (monoenoic), two
(dienoic), three (trienoic) or many (polyenoic) double bonds. Fatty acids with more
than one double bond are frequently referred to as polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA).
The unsaturated acids possess different physical and chemical properties from the saturated acids: they have lower melting points and are more chemically reactive.
The presence of a double bond in a fatty acid molecule means that the acid can
exist in two forms, depending upon the spatial arrangement of the hydrogen atoms
attached to the carbon atoms of the double bond. When the hydrogen atoms lie on
34
Fats
the same side of the double bond, the acid is said to be in the cis form, whereas it is
said to be in the trans form when the atoms lie on opposite sides, as shown here:
H
(CH2)7.COOH
H
C
C
H
(CH2)7.COOH
C
C
R
Cis
R
H
Trans
Most naturally occurring fatty acids have the cis configuration.
The fatty acids are named by replacing the final -e of the name of the parent hydrocarbon by the suffix -oic. Thus, a saturated 18-carbon acid would be named octadecanoic after the parent octadecane.An 18-carbon acid with one double bond would be
octadecenoic after octadecene. The position of the double bond is indicated by reference to the carboxyl carbon atom (carbon atom 1). Thus, 9-octadecenoic acid would
have 18 carbon atoms and a double bond between carbon atoms 9 and 10. Similarily,
9,12,15-octadecatrienoic acid would have 18 carbon atoms and double bonds between
carbon atoms 9 and 10, 12 and 13, and 15 and 16. The names may be abbreviated by
stating the number of carbon atoms followed by a colon, followed by the number of
double bonds (⌬), the positions of which are stated as a superscript. Thus, octadecatrienoic acid would be designated 18:3⌬9,12,15. Alternatively it may be written 9,12,
15-18:3. Carbon atoms 2 and 3 are designated alpha (␣) and beta (␤), respectively, and
the methyl carbon at the distal end of the chain as the omega (␻) carbon atom. In nutritional work, the unsaturated acids are frequently named in relation to the terminal
methyl as carbon atom 1. Under this system 9,12,15-octadecatrienoic acid would become ␻-3,6,9-octadecatrienoic acid, since carbon atoms 3, 6 and 9 correspond to carbon atoms 16, 13 and 10 under the former system.The abbreviated designation would
be ␻-3,6,9-18:3. It has become common practice to use n instead of ␻ and we then have
n-3,6,9-18:3 and frequently 18:3(n-3). In addition the configuration of the double
bonds is indicated by the use of the prefixes cis and trans.Thus, ␣-linolenic acid would
be all cis-9,12,15-octadecatrienoic, or more simply all cis 9,12,15-18:3.
For certain purposes the PUFA are grouped into families, based on oleic (n-9-18:1),
linoleic (n-6,9-18:2) and ␣-linolenic (n-3,6,9-18:3) as precursors.The families are called
omega-9 (␻-9), omega-6 (␻-6) and omega-3 (␻-3), referring to the positions of the double bonds nearest to the omega carbon atom in these acids. Again, n is frequently substituted for ␻. Some of the nutritionally important fatty acids are shown in Table 3.1.
Two low-molecular-weight saturated fatty acids, namely butyric (C3H7.COOH)
and caproic (C4H10.COOH), are found in significant amounts in the milk fats of ruminants, and caproic along with caprylic acid is present in a few oils such as palm
kernel and coconut. Other fatty acids containing two carboxyl groups, odd numbers
of carbon atoms and branched chains have been isolated from natural fats, but they
are not considered to be of great importance.
Triacylglycerols are named according to the fatty acids they contain, e.g:
CH2.O.CO.C17H33
CH2.O.CO.C15H31
CH.O.CO.C17H33
CH.O.CO.C17H33
CH2.O.CO.C17H33
CH2.O.CO.C17H35
Trioleoylgycerol (triolein)
1-Palmitoyl 2-oleoyl 3-stearoylglycerol (palmito-oleostearin)
35
Chapter 3 Lipids
Table 3.1 Common fatty acids of natural fats and oils
Acid
Formula
Saturated
Caprylic (octanoic)
Capric (decanoic)
Lauric (dodecanoic)
Myristic (tetradecanoic)
Palmitic (hexadecanoic)
Stearic (octadecanoic)
C7H15.COOH
C9H19.COOH
C11H23.COOH
C13H27.COOH
C15H31.COOH
C17H35.COOH
16.3
31.2
43.9
54.1
62.7
69.6
C15H29.COOH
C17H33.COOH
0
13
C17H31.COOH
-5
C17H29.COOH
-14.5
C19H31.COOH
-49.5
Unsaturated
Palmitoleic (9-hexadecenoic)
(9-16:1 or 16:1n-7)
Oleic (octadecenoic) (9-18:1 or 18:1n-9)
Linoleic (octadecadienoic)
(9,12-18:2 or 18:2n-6)
⬀-Linolenic (9,12,15-octadecatrienoic)
(9,12,15-18:3 or 18:3n-3)
Arachidonic (eicosatetraenoic)
(5,8,11,14-20:4 or 20:4n-6)
Timnodonic (eicosapentaenoic)
(5,8,11,14,17-20:5 or 20:5n-3)
Docosahexaenoic (5,8,11,14,17,20-22:6 or 22:6n-3)
Melting point (°C)
C19H29.COOH
C21H36.COOH
The fatty acid residues are not distributed randomly between the alcohol groups
of the parent glycerol. Thus, in cow’s milk fat, for example, the short-chain acids are
concentrated at position 3. In human milk fat, the unsaturated acids are predominantly at position 1 and the saturated acids at position 2. Animal depot fats tend to
have saturated acids at position 1 and unsaturated and short-chain acids at position 2;
PUFA tend to accumulate at position 3.
There is evidence that the configuration of the constituent triacylglycerols of fats
can influence the extent to which they are digested.Thus, palmitate (hexadecanoate)
distributed randomly throughout the 1, 2 and 3 positions was found to be less
digestible than that which occupied position 2, the favoured position for attack by
pancreatic lipase.
The fatty acid composition of the triacylglycerols determines their physical nature. Those with a high proportion of low-molecular-weight (short-chain) and unsaturated acids have low melting points. Thus, tristearin is solid at body temperature
whereas triolein is liquid.
Composition of fats
It is frequently important in nutritional investigations to assess the quality of the fat
being produced under a certain treatment.When the effect of the diet is considerable,
the results may be obvious in a softening or hardening of the fat. Less obvious
changes may occur, and for these a more objective assessment is necessary. Differences between fats are a function of their fatty acid composition since glycerol is common to all fats. The logical method of following changes in fats is, therefore, to
measure their fatty acid constitution. Analysis of fats for individual fatty acids has
36
Fats
Table 3.2 Fatty acid composition (g/100 g) of some common fats and oils
Rapeseed Soya bean Ryegrass Cocksfoot Linseed Butterfat Lard Beef tallow Menhaden Codliver
4:0
6:0
8:0
10:0
12:0
14:0
16:0
18:0
20:0
22:0
16:1
18:1n-9
20:1n-9
22:1n-9
18:2n-6
18:3n-3
20:4n-6
20:5n-3
22:6n-3
Others
–
–
–
–
–
Tr
4
1
1
Tr
2
54
–
–
23
10
–
–
–
5
–
–
–
–
–
Tr
10
4
Tr
Tr
Tr
25
–
–
52
7
–
–
–
2
–
–
–
–
–
Tr
12
2
–
–
2
15
–
–
68
–
–
–
–
7
–
–
–
–
–
Tr
11
3
–
–
2
–
–
–
79
–
–
–
–
0
–
–
–
–
–
Tr
6
3
–
–
–
17
–
–
13
55
–
–
–
6
3
2
1
3
4
12
31
10
–
–
2
23
–
–
2
Tr
–
–
–
1
–
–
–
–
–
Tr
32
8
–
–
48
–
–
11
Tr
–
–
–
1
–
–
–
–
–
3
26
19
–
–
6
40
–
–
5
–
–
–
–
4
–
–
–
–
–
8
22
3
–
–
11
21
2
2
2
–
2
14
10
1
–
–
–
–
–
1
19
5
–
4
4
15
10
2
2
–
1
6
27
2
presented great problems in the past, but the introduction of techniques such as gas
chromatography has allowed determinations to be made more easily and accurately.
As well as its major role as an energy source, fat has a vital role in providing individual fatty acids with specific nutritional roles within the animal body. Information on
fatty acid composition is, therefore, a prerequisite in the evaluation of fats in this
context.
Some typical values for a number of important fats and oils are given in Table 3.2.
In general, plant and marine oils, especially those of fish, are more highly unsaturated than those of mammalian origin. This is because of the presence of varying
amounts of linoleic and linolenic acids in addition to the monounsaturated oleic (cis9-octadecenoic) acid, which is quantitatively the major fatty acid in most natural
fats. In addition, the fish oils have significant concentrations of highly unsaturated
C20 and C22 acids. In mammalian depot fat, the proportion of the more unsaturated
acids is lower and there is a higher proportion of high-molecular-weight saturated
acids such as palmitic and stearic acids, with smaller but significant contributions
from lauric (dodecanoic) and myristic (tetradecanoic) acids. For this reason, fats such
as pig lard, and beef and mutton tallow are firm and hard, whereas fish and plant oils
are softer and frequently are oils in the true sense.
Within individual animals, subcutaneous fats contain a higher proportion of unsaturated acids and are thus softer than deep-body fat. The physical nature of fat varies
between animals, marine mammals having softer body fat than land mammals. The
reason in both cases is that animal fat has to maintain a degree of malleability at the
temperature of the tissue, which is influenced by ambient temperatures. Thus, the fats
37
Chapter 3 Lipids
of the feet and ears, which are inclined to be colder than the interior of the body, tend
to be unsaturated.
Ruminant milk fats are characterised by their high content of low-molecularweight fatty acids, these sometimes forming as much as 20 per cent of the total acids
present. As a result they are softer than the depot fats of the respective animals but
not as soft as fats of vegetable and marine origin, being semi-solid at ordinary temperatures. Milk fats of non-ruminants resemble the depot fat of the particular animal.
In most commercially important edible plant oils, the dominant fatty acids are
oleic, linoleic and linolenic acids. Coconut oil is an exception in having the saturated
12:0 lauric acid as its major acid. Families of plants tend to produce characteristic
oils that frequently contain unusual fatty acids. Examples are the erucic acid of rapeseed; ricinoleic acid, the 18-carbon, monoenoic, hydroxy acid of the castor bean;
and vernolic acid, the 18-carbon, trienoic, epoxy acid of the Compositae.
Essential fatty acids
In 1930, linoleic (cis, cis-9,12-octadecadienoic) acid was shown to be effective in preventing the development of certain conditions in rats given diets almost devoid of fat.
These animals showed a scaly appearance of the skin and suboptimal performance in
growth, reproduction and lactation; eventually they died as a result of the deficient
diet. More recent work has demonstrated a wide range of symptoms in a variety of
animals, including some in human beings under certain circumstances (Table 3.3).
Arachidonic (all cis 5,8,11,14-eicosatetraenoic) acid has been shown to have
equivalent or even greater activity than linoleic acid, and linolenic (all cis 9,12,15octadecadienoic) acid is about 1.5 times as effective as linoleic acid. Mammals cannot
synthesise fatty acids with double bonds closer than carbon atom 9 from the terminal
methyl group. Such acids have to be supplied in the diet. Linoleic acid (18:2n-6) and
␣-linolenic acid (18:3 n-3) are thus dietary essentials. Arachidonic acid is synthesised
in the body from linoleic acid. However, one of the steps in the synthesis, a ⌬-6 desaturation, is rate-limiting and production may be slow and an exogenous supply advantageous (see Box 3.1). Linoleic and ␣-linolenic acids are referred to as the essential
fatty acids (EFA). Like other polyunsaturated acids, they form part of various membranes and play a part in lipid transport and certain lipoprotein enzymes. In addition,
they are the source materials for the synthesis of the eicosanoids. These include the
prostaglandins, thromboxanes and leukotrienes, hormone-like substances that regulate
Table 3.3 Symptoms associated with essential fatty acid deficiencies
Growth retardation
Increased permeability to water and increased water consumption
Increased susceptibility to bacterial infections
Sterility
Less stable biomembranes
Capillary fragility
Kidney damage, haematuria and hypertension
Decreased visual acuity
Decreased myocardial contractility
Decreased ATP synthesis in liver and heart
Decreased nitrogen retention
38
Fats
Diet
α-Linolenic acid
Linoleic acid
γ-Linolenic acid
Dihomo-γ-Linolenic acid
Arachidonic acid
Eicosapentenoic acid
1-Series
prostaglandins and
thromboxanes
3-Series leukotrienes
2-Series
prostaglandins,
prostacyclins and
thromboxanes
3-Series
prostaglandins,
prostacyclins and
thromboxanes
3-Series leukotrienes
Fig. 3.2 Relationship between the essential fatty acids and the eicosanoids.
many functions, including blood clotting, blood pressure, smooth muscle contraction
and the immune response. They are also the source of other important C20 acids in
the form of eicosapentaenoic (EPA), hydroxy-eicosatrienoic (HETrR) and docosahexaenoic (DHA) acids. All are involved in maintaining the fluidity of mammalian
cell membranes. EPA is the precursor of the 3-series of prostaglandins and thromboxanes and the 5-series of leukotrienes. DHA is thought to play an important role in
brain and retinal function, and EPA and HETrR have a modulating effect on the production of eicosanoids from arachidonic acid. The relationship between the essential
fatty acids and the eicosanoids is illustrated in Fig. 3.2.
The 1- and 3-series prostaglandins are anti-inflammatory and inhibit platelet aggregation, whereas the 2-series are pro-inflammatory and pro-aggregatory.The 1- and
3-series thromboxanes mildly stimulate platelet aggregation and stimulate the contraction of respiratory, intestinal and vascular smooth muscle, as do the leukotrienes.
The 2-series thromboxanes have a much more powerful action in this respect.
As a general rule, mammals are considered to have an EFA requirement of 3 per
cent of the energy requirement (3en%) as linoleic acid, although estimates have
ranged from 1 per cent to 15 per cent. Estimates for individual species have been
more specific. Thus, The Nutrient Requirements of Pigs (see Further reading, Chapter 12) gives the requirements of pigs under 30 kg liveweight as 3en% as linoleic
acid or 2en% as arachidonic acid. For pigs of 30–90 kg, the figures are 1.5en% as
linoleic acid and 1en% as arachidonic acid.
BOX 3.1 Long-chain fatty acid metabolism in cats
Unlike other mammals, cats have a limited ⌬6 desaturase activity. This enzyme is necessary in the
conversion of linoleic acid and ␣-linolenic acid to other physiologically important PUFA such as
arachidonic acid, EPA and DHA.The provision of diets deficient in preformed long-chain PUFA but
containing linoleic acid and ␣-linolenic acid results in symptoms such as a dry coat, changes in
platelet aggregation and an enlarged fatty liver. The limited ⌬6 desaturase activity can be sufficient
for maintenance and conception in adult cats, but for gestation, lactation and growth a dietary supply of preformed n-6 and n-3 long-chain PUFAs, particularly arachidonic acid, is required.
39
Chapter 3 Lipids
The oilseeds are generally rich sources of linoleic acid, and linseed is a particularly
good source of ␣-linolenic acid. Pigs and poultry, which normally have considerable
quantities of oilseed residues in their diets, will, therefore, receive an adequate supply
of the essential fatty acids.
Ruminant animals are largely dependent on grasses and forages for their nutritional
needs and are thereby supplied with liberal quantities of linoleic and ␣-linolenic acids.
Although considerable hydrogenation of unsaturated acids to saturated takes place in the
rumen, with consequent overall reduction of EFA supply (on average 85–95 per cent is lost
between the mouth and the small intestine), the possibility of ruminants having a deficiency is remote. A certain proportion of dietary EFA escapes hydrogenation (approximately 5–15 per cent of dietary intake) and this, allied to very efficient utilisation and
conservation of EFA by ruminants, is enough to ensure adequacy under normal conditions. EFA deficiency is rare in human beings although, under certain conditions, it does
occur in infants, elderly people and people taking drugs that inhibit lipid absorption.
Properties of fats
Hydrolysis
Fats may be hydrolysed by boiling with alkalis to give glycerol and soaps:
CH2.O.CO.R
CH.O.CO.R
CH2OH
+
3KOH
CHOH
CH2.O.CO.R
CH2OH
Fat
Glycerol
+
3R.COOK
Soap
Such a hydrolysis is termed saponification since it produces soaps, which are sodium
and potassium salts of the fatty acids.The process of fat breakdown may take place naturally under the influence of enzymes, collectively known as lipases, when it is termed
lipolysis.The enzymes may have a certain specificity and preferentially catalyse hydrolysis at particular positions in the molecule. Removal of the fatty acid residue attached
to carbon atom 2 of an acylglycerol is more difficult than those at positions 1 and 3.
Under natural conditions, the products of lipolysis are usually mixtures of mono- and
diacylglycerols with free fatty acids. Most of these acids are odourless and tasteless, but
some of the lower ones, particularly butyric and caproic, have extremely powerful
tastes and smells; when such a breakdown takes place in an edible fat, it may frequently
be rendered completely unacceptable to the consumer. The lipases are mostly derived
from bacteria and moulds, which are chiefly responsible for this type of spoilage, commonly referred to as rancidity. Extensive lipolysis of dietary fats takes place in the duodenum and during their absorption from the small intestine. Lipolysis also precedes the
hydrogenation of fats in the rumen, and the oxidation of fats in the body.
Oxidation
The unsaturated fatty acids readily undergo oxidation at the carbon atom adjacent to
the double bond to form hydroperoxides:
CH2.CH:CH.CH2.CH2.
O2
CH2.CH:CH.CH2.CH2.
OOH
40
Fats
These break down to give shorter-chain products, including free radicals, which then
attack other fatty acids much more readily than does the original oxygen. More free
radicals are produced, with the result that the speed of the oxidation increases exponentially. Eventually the concentration of free radicals becomes such that they react
with each other and the reaction is terminated. Such a reaction, in which the products catalyse the reaction, is described as autocatalytic. This particular reaction is an
autoxidation. The formation of the free radicals is catalysed by ultraviolet light and
certain metal ions, particularly copper, and the presence of either increases the rate
of oxidation dramatically.
The products of oxidation include shorter-chain fatty acids, fatty acid polymers,
aldehydes (alkanals), ketones (alkanones), epoxides and hydrocarbons.The acids and
alkanals are major contributors to the smells and flavours associated with oxidised
fat, and they significantly reduce its palatability. The potency of these compounds is
typified by deca-2,4 dienal, which is detectable in water at concentrations of as little
as 1 in 10 000 million.
Oxidation of saturated fatty acids results in the development of a sweet, heavy
taste and smell commonly known as ketonic rancidity. This is due to the presence
of the methyl ketones resulting from the oxidation, which may be represented as
follows:
CH3
CH3
CH3
CH2
CH2
CH2
CH2
CH2
CH2
C:O
C:O
CH2
CH2
CH3
COOH
COOH
CH2
+
Caproic acid
O
+
CO2
Pentanone
Similar reactions following mould-induced lipolysis are responsible for the characteristic flavours of various soft and blue cheeses.
Antioxidants
Natural fats possess a certain degree of resistance to oxidation, owing to the presence of compounds termed antioxidants. These prevent the oxidation of unsaturated fats until they themselves have been transformed into inert products. A
number of compounds have this antioxidant property, including phenols,
quinones, tocopherols, gallic acid and gallates. In the European Union, propyl,
octyl or dodecyl-gallate, butylated hydroxyanisole, butylated hydroxytoluene and
ethoxyquin may be added to edible oils as antioxidants in amounts specified in the
EC Community Register of Feed Additives 2009. Other substances such as synthetic ␣-, ␥- and ␦-tocopherols and various derivatives of ascorbic acid may be
used without limit.
The most important naturally occurring antioxidant is vitamin E, which protects
fat by preferential acceptance of free radicals.The possible effects of fat oxidation in
diets in which vitamin E levels are marginal are of considerable importance.
41
Chapter 3 Lipids
Hydrogenation
This is the process whereby hydrogen is added to the double bonds of the unsaturated acids of a fat, thereby converting them to their saturated analogues. Oleic acid,
for example, yields stearic acid:
CH2
(CH2)7
CH3
CH
+
H
(CH2)16
CH
H
COOH
(CH2)7
COOH
Oleic acid
Stearic acid
The process (hardening) is important commercially for producing firm hard fats
from vegetable and fish oils in the manufacture of margarine. The hardening results
from the higher melting point of the saturated acids. For the rate of reaction to be practicable, a catalyst has to be used, usually finely divided nickel. Hardening has the
added advantage of improving the keeping quality of the fat, since removal of the double bonds eliminates the chief centres of reactivity in the material.
Dietary fats consumed by ruminants first undergo hydrolysis in the rumen and
this is followed by progressive hydrogenation of the unsaturated free fatty acids
(mainly 18:2 and 18:3 acids) to stearic acid.This helps to explain the apparent anomaly that, whereas their dietary fats are highly unsaturated, the body fats of ruminants
are highly saturated.
Hydrogenation results in the production not only of saturated acids but also of
trans acids. In addition a redistribution of double bonds within the fatty acid chain
takes place, accounting for the presence in ruminant fats of vaccenic (trans-11,18:1)
and elaidic (trans-9,18:1) acids. A similar transformation occurs in the industrial hydrogenation of plant and fish oils. Partially hydrogenated vegetable oils, for example,
commonly contain 3–5 g trans acids/100 g of the total fatty acids, and partially hydrogenated fish oils about 20 g.
Digestion, absorption and metabolism of the trans acids is comparable with that
of their counterparts. They have higher melting points than their cis analogues and
their incorporation into ruminant body fats contributes to the hardness of the latter.
Trans acids do not possess essential fatty acid activity, but there is evidence that
some may enter pathways leading to eicosanoid formation and give rise to substances of unknown physiological effects. There is evidence, too, that they decrease
the activity of the desaturases involved in EFA metabolism. However, it would appear that, as long as EFA intake is adequate and trans acids intake is not excessive,
they do not have any significant effect on EFA status. Trans fatty acids, particularly
those produced from the partial hydrogenation of vegetable oils (PHVO), have also
been associated with an increased risk of cardiovascular disease, cancer, inflammation and type II diabetes. This has led in the USA to the requirement for the trans
fatty acid content of food to be included on the labelling, with a view to eliminating
trans fatty acids from the human diet. The profile of trans fatty acids in ruminant
products is, however, quite different from that of PHVO, and there is evidence that
42
Glycolipids
some of these, such as trans-11, 18:1 (vaccenic acid) and cis-9,trans-11 conjugated
linoleic acid (rumenic acid), which are found in ruminant milk and meat, have beneficial effects on reducing diseases such as cancer and atherosclerosis.
3.3
GLYCOLIPIDS
In these compounds two of the alcohol groups of the glycerol are esterified by fatty
acids and the other is linked to a sugar residue. The lipids of grasses and clovers,
which form the major part of the dietary fat of ruminants, are predominantly (about
60 per cent) galactolipids. Here the sugar is galactose and we have:
CH2OH
O
OH
O
CH2
CHOCOR
OH
CH2OCOR
OH
Galactolipid
Galactolipids
The galactolipids of grasses are mainly of the monogalactosyl type illustrated above,
but smaller quantities of the digalactosyl compounds are also present.These have two
galactose residues at the first carbon atom.The fatty acids of the galactosides of grasses
and clovers consist largely of linoleic and ␣-linolenic acids, as shown in Table 3.4.
Rumen microorganisms are able to break down the galactolipids to give galactose,
fatty acids and glycerol. Preliminary lipolysis appears to be a prerequisite for the
galactosyl glycerides to be hydrolysed by the microbial galactosidases.
In animal tissues, glycolipids are present mainly in the brain and nerve fibres.The
glycerol of the plant glycolipids is here replaced as the basic unit by the nitrogenous
base sphingosine:
OH NH2
CH3.(CH2)12.CH:CH.CH.CH.CH2OH
Sphingosine
Table 3.4 Fatty acid composition of some forage lipids (g/100 g)
Perennial ryegrass
14:0
16:0
16:1
18:0
18:1
18:2
18:3
2.0
20.9
1.0
4.4
5.1
13.2
51.6
Cocksfoot
2.0
20.8
1.0
3.1
2.6
15.0
52.8
Red clover
1.0
15.4
0.1
2.3
2.3
20.8
59.5
White clover
1.1
16.8
0.2
1.9
2.1
19.6
59.7
Pasture
1.7
19.7
0.8
3.5
4.0
15.3
54.1
43
Chapter 3 Lipids
In their simplest form, the cerebrosides, the glycolipids have the amino group of
the sphingosine linked to the carboxyl group of a long-chain fatty acid and the terminal alcohol group to a sugar residue, usually galactose. The typical structure is:
Acid
OH NH
CH3.(CH2)12.CH:CH.CH.CH.CH2
Sphingosine
CO.R
O
O
Galactose
More complex substances, the gangliosides, are found in the brain. They have the
terminal alcohol group linked to a branched chain of sugars with sialic acid as the
terminal residue of at least one of the chains.
3.4
PHOSPHOLIPIDS
The role of the phospholipids is primarily as constituents of the lipoprotein complexes of biological membranes. They are widely distributed, being particularly
abundant in the heart, kidneys and nervous tissues. Myelin of the nerve axons, for
example, contains up to 55 per cent of phospholipid. Eggs are one of the best animal
sources and, among the plants, soya beans contain relatively large amounts. The
phospholipids contain phosphorus in addition to carbon, hydrogen and oxygen.
Phosphoglycerides
These are esters of glycerol in which only two of the alcohol groups are esterified by
fatty acids, with the third esterified by phosphoric acid.The parent compound of the
phosphoglycerides is, thus, phosphatidic acid, which may be regarded as the simplest
phosphoglyceride.
CH2.O.CO.R1
CH.O.CO.R2
O
CH2.O.P.O H
OH
Phosphatidic acid
Phosphoglycerides are commonly referred to as phosphatides. In the major biologically important compounds, the phosphate group is esterified by one of several alcohols, the commonest of which are serine, choline, glycerol, inositol and ethanolamine.
The chief fatty acids present are the 16-carbon saturated and the 18-carbon saturated
and monoenoic, although others with 14–24 carbon atoms do occur. The most commonly occurring phosphoglycerides in higher plants and animals are the lecithins and
the cephalins.
44
Phospholipids
Lecithins
Lecithins have the phosphoric acid esterified by the nitrogenous base choline and
are more correctly termed phosphatidylcholines. A typical example would have the
formula:
CH2.O.CO.C15H31
CH.O.CO.C17H33
CH2.O. PO3.CH2.CH2.N+(CH3)3
Lecithin
The fatty acid residues at sn-1 are mostly palmitic (16:0) or stearic (18:0) acid. At
sn-2 they are primarily oleic (18:1), linoleic (18:2) or ␣-linolenic (18:3) acid.
Cephalins
Cephalins differ from the lecithins in having ethanolamine instead of choline and
are correctly termed phosphatidylethanolamines. Ethanolamine has the following
formula:
NH2
CH2.CH2OH
The fatty acids at sn-1 are the same as in lecithin, but those at sn-2 are unsaturated, mainly linoleic, eicosatetraenoic and docosahexaenoic acid.
Phosphoglycerides are white waxy solids that turn brown when exposed to the
air, owing to oxidation followed by polymerisation.When placed in water, the phosphoglycerides appear to dissolve. However, the true solubility is very low, the apparent solubility being due to the formation of micelles.
Phosphoglycerides are hydrolysed by naturally occurring enzymes, the phospholipases, which specifically cleave certain bonds within the molecule to release fatty
acids, the phosphate ester, the alcohol and glycerol.The release of choline, when followed by further oxidative breakdown, has been considered to be responsible for the
development of fishy taints by the release of the trimethyl amine group or its oxide;
currently these taints are considered to be the result of fat oxidation and not of
lecithin breakdown.
The phosphoglycerides combine within the same molecule both the hydrophilic
(water-loving) phosphate ester groups and the hydrophobic fatty acid chains. They
are therefore surface-active and play a role as emulsifying agents in biological systems, for example in the duodenum. Their surface-active nature also explains their
function as constituents of various biological membranes.
Sphingomyelins
Sphingomyelins belong to a large group, the sphingolipids, which have sphingosine
instead of glycerol as the parent material.They differ from the cerebrosides in having
the terminal hydroxyl group linked to phosphoric acid instead of a sugar residue.The
phosphoric acid is esterified by either choline or ethanolamine. The sphingomyelins
45
Chapter 3 Lipids
also have the amino group linked to the carboxyl group of a long-chain fatty acid by
means of a peptide linkage:
Sphingosine
Phosphoryl choline
CH3.(CH2)12.CH:CH.CHOH.CH.CH2.O.PO3–.CH2.CH2.N+(CH3)3
NH.CO.R
Sphingomyelin
Like the lecithins and cephalins, the sphingomyelins are surface-active and are
important as components of membranes, particularly in nervous tissue. They may
constitute up to 25 per cent of the total lipid in the myelin sheath that protects the
nerve cells, but they are absent from, or present only in very low concentrations in,
energy-generating tissue.
Ether phospholipids
Ether phospholipids are glycerol-based but have an alkyl rather than an acyl group
at carbon atom 1, as is the case in the glycerides.Typical are the plasmologens, which
have a vinyl ether grouping as shown here:
CH2.O.CH:CH.R
CH.O.CO.R
CH2.O.PO3–.CH2.CH2.NH3+
Such compounds may form up to 50 per cent of the phospholipids of heart tissue,
but their function is unclear.An ether phospholipid called platelet activating factor is
a highly potent aggregator of blood platelets.
3.5
WAXES
Waxes are simple, relatively non-polar lipids consisting of a long-chain fatty acid
combined with a monohydric alcohol of high molecular weight. They are usually
solid at ordinary temperatures. The fatty acids present in waxes are those found in
fats, although acids lower than lauric acid are very rare; higher acids such as carnaubic (C23H47.COOH) and mellissic (C30H61.COOH) acid may also be present.The
most common alcohols found in waxes are carnaubyl (C24H49.OH) and cetyl
(C16H33OH) alcohol.
Natural waxes are usually mixtures of a number of esters. Beeswax is known to
consist of at least five esters, the main one being myricyl palmitate:
C15H31.COOH + C31H63OH : C15H31.COOC31H63 + H2O
Waxes are widely distributed in plants and animals, where they often have a protective function. The hydrophobic nature of the wax coating reduces water losses caused
by transpiration in plants, and provides wool and feathers with waterproofing in
46
Steroids
animals. Among better-known animal waxes are lanolin, obtained from wool, and
spermaceti, a product of marine animals. In plants, waxes are usually included in the
cuticular fraction, where they form a matrix in which cutin and suberin are embedded.
The term wax is used here in the collective sense and, although true waxes are always
present, the major part is made up of a complex mixture of substances.Alkanes (from
C21 to C37) make up a large proportion of the whole, with odd-chain compounds predominating. Branched-chain hydrocarbons, aldehydes, free fatty acids (from C12 to
C36) and various ketols are commonly occurring though minor constituents. Free alcohols are usually of minor importance but may form up to half of some waxes.
Cutin is a mixture of polymers of C16 and C18 monomers, commonly 16-hydroxypalmitic and 10,16-dihydroxypalmitic acids. Phenolic constituents such as paracoumaric and ferulic acids are usually present, but in small amounts only. Suberin is
found in the surfaces of the underground parts of plants and on healed wound surfaces.The major aliphatic constituents are ␻-hydroxy acids, the corresponding dicarboxylic acids and very-long-chain acids and alcohols. There are also substantial
amounts of phenolic substances, mainly p-coumaric acid, which form a phenolic core
to which the acids are attached. Both cutin and suberin are highly resistant to breakdown and are not of any significant nutritional value.The waxes, too, are resistant to
breakdown and are poorly utilised by animals. Their presence in foods in large
amounts leads to high ether extract figures and may result in the nutritive value
being overestimated.
3.6
STEROIDS
The steroids include such biologically important compounds as the sterols, the bile
acids, the adrenal hormones and the sex hormones. They have a common structural
unit of a phenanthrene nucleus linked to a cyclopentane ring (Fig. 3.3).
The individual compounds differ in the number and positions of their double
bonds and in the nature of the side chain at carbon atom 17.
Sterols
These have eight to ten carbon atoms in the side chain, an alcohol group at carbon
atom 3, but no carbonyl or carboxyl groups. They may be classified into:
■
■
■
the phytosterols of plant origin;
the mycosterols of fungal origin;
the zoosterols of animal origin.
11
2
3
1
4
10
5
9
6
12
13
14
17
16
15
8
7
Phenanthrene
nucleus
Cyclopentane
ring
Fig. 3.3 Basic steroid structural unit.
47
Chapter 3 Lipids
The phytosterols and the mycosterols are not absorbed from the gut and are not
found in animal tissues.
Cholesterol
Cholesterol is a zoosterol that is present in all animal cells. It has a low solubility in
water, about 0.2 mg/100 ml. It is the major sterol in human beings and is important as
a constituent of various biological membranes. It is particularly important in the
myelinated structures of the brain and central nervous system and may constitute up
to 170 g/kg. It is the precursor of the steroid hormones. It is also the precursor of the
bile acids.
Normal concentrations in the blood plasma are in the range 1200–2200 mg/l.
Some 30 per cent of this is in the free state, the remainder being bound to
lipoproteins. These are complexes of proteins and lipids held together by non-covalent bonds. Each has a characteristic size, molecular weight, chemical composition and density. They are classified on the basis of their density. The five classes,
of which one, the chylomicrons, occurs only in the post-absorptive state, are
shown in Table 3.5.
In the plasma, the lipoproteins exist as spherical structures with a core of triacylglycerols and cholesterol esters. This is surrounded by a shell, about 20 Å thick, containing proteins, unesterified cholesterol and phosphatidylcholines. Since they have
a greater surface to volume ratio, the smaller particles have a higher protein to lipid
ratio and are more dense.Thus, the HDLP fraction has about 45 per cent protein and
55 per cent lipid, whereas the VLDLP fraction has about 10 per cent protein and
90 per cent lipid. Cholesterol is very insoluble and prolonged high levels in blood result in its deposition on the walls of the blood vessels. These deposits eventually
harden to atherosclerotic plaque. This narrows the blood vessel and serves as a site
for clot formation and may precipitate myocardial infarction or heart attack.
There is strong evidence that the risk of coronary heart disease is directly related
to the plasma concentration of LDL-cholesterol and inversely related to that of
HDL-cholesterol, and that the risk is reduced significantly by lowering elevated
serum cholesterol levels. It has been known for many years that one of the most important dietary factors regulating serum cholesterol levels is the ratio of polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA) to saturated fatty acids (SFA). The SFA increase and the
PUFA decrease cholesterol levels, except for the trans PUFA, which have a similar
effect to the SFA.A ratio of 0.5–0.9 SFA : PUFA is considered to be satisfactory. It is
Table 3.5 Density-based classes of lipoproteins
48
Class
Density (g/ml)
Molecular weight
(daltons)
Diameter (Å)
High-density lipoproteins
Low-density lipoproteins
Intermediate-density
lipoproteins (IDLP)
Very low-density
lipoproteins (VLDLP)
Chylomicrons
1.063–1.210
1.019–1.063
4–2 * 105
2 * 106
50–130 (HDLP)
200–280 (LDLP)
1.006–1.019
4.5 * 106
250
0.95–1.006
<0.95
5 * 106–107
109–1010
250–750
103–104
Steroids
important to appreciate that the different families of PUFA affect lipid metabolism in
different ways.Thus, the ␻-6 acids significantly decrease serum cholesterol levels and
have a minor effect only on triacylglycerol levels, whereas the ␻-3 acids have a
minor effect on serum cholesterol but significantly lower triacylglycerol levels.This is
important in the light of recent evidence that high serum triacylglycerol level per se
is an important risk factor in coronary heart disease.The ␻-3 acids are the precursors
of the 3-series of prostaglandins and thromboxanes. The former strongly inhibit
platelet aggregation and the latter are weakly pro-aggregating.The ␻-6 acids are precursors of the 2-series of prostaglandins and thromboxanes, the former being
strongly pro-aggregating and the latter weakly anti-aggregating. On balance, from
this point of view, the ␻-3 acids may be regarded as having a more beneficial effect
than the ␻-6 acids.They have a further beneficial effect in that they inhibit the transformation of the ␻-6 acids to their eicosanoid products.
7-Dehydrocholesterol
This substance, which is derived from cholesterol, is important as the precursor
of vitamin D3, which is produced when the sterol is exposed to ultraviolet light
(Fig. 3.4).
C8H17
CH3
CH3
CH2
CH3
OH
C8H17
OH
7-Dehydrocholesterol
Cholecalciferol
(vitamin D3)
Fig. 3.4 Formation of vitamin D3.
This is a good illustration of how relatively small changes in chemical structure
may bring about radical changes in physiological activity.
Ergosterol
This phytosterol is widely distributed in brown algae, bacteria and higher plants. It is
important as the precursor of ergocalciferol or vitamin D2, into which it is converted
by ultraviolet irradiation.The change is the same as that which takes place in the formation of vitamin D3 from 7-dehydrocholesterol and involves opening of the second
phenanthrene ring.
Bile acids
The bile acids have a five-carbon side chain at carbon atom 17 which terminates in a
carboxyl group bound by an amide linkage to glycine or taurine (Fig. 3.5).
49
Chapter 3 Lipids
CH3
OH
OH
CH.(CH2)2.C.N.CH2.COOH
CH3
OH
OH
Fig. 3.5 Glycocholic acid.
The bile acids are synthesised from cholesterol and this constitutes the major end
point of cholesterol metabolism. Under physiological conditions the acids exist as
salts. They are produced in the liver, stored in the gall bladder and secreted into the
upper small intestine. They are important in several ways:
■
■
■
■
■
They provide the major excretory pathway for cholesterol, which cannot be
catabolised to carbon dioxide and water by mammals. Bile contains high concentrations of free cholesterol, about 390 mg/100 ml.
The bile salts assist, along with the detergent action of phospholipids, in preventing the cholesterol in the bile fluid from crystallising out of solution.
They act as emulsifying agents in preparing dietary triacylglycerols for hydrolysis,
by pancreatic lipase, in the process of digestion.
They may have a role in activating pancreatic lipase.
They facilitate the absorption, from the digestive tract, of the fat-soluble vitamins.
Steroid hormones
These include the female sex hormones (oestrogens), the male sex hormones (androgens) and progesterone, as well as cortisol, aldosterone and corticosterone, which are
produced in the adrenal cortex.The adrenal hormones have an important role in the
control of glucose and fat metabolism.
3.7
TERPENES
Terpenes are made up of a number of isoprene units linked together to form chains
or cyclic structures. Isoprene is a five-carbon compound with the following structure:
CH2:C.CH:CH2
CH3
Isoprene
Many terpenes found in plants have strong characteristic odours and flavours and
are components of essential oils such as lemon or camphor oil. The word ‘essential’
is used to indicate the occurrence of the oils in essences and not to imply that they
are required by animals. Among the more important plant terpenes are the phytol
50
Questions
moiety of chlorophyll, the carotenoid pigments, plant hormones such as giberellic
acid and vitamins A, E and K. In animals, some of the coenzymes, including those of
the coenzyme Q group, are terpenes.
SUMMARY
1. Lipids are a group of substances that are
insoluble in water but soluble in common
organic solvents. They include the fats and
oils, the glycolipids, the phospholipids, the
lipoproteins, the steroids and the terpenes.
5. Waxes are mixtures of esters of high-molecularweight fatty acids with high-molecularweight alcohols. They are chemically inert,
have little or no nutritive value, and are
mainly protective in function.
2. Fats and oils are major sources of stored energy in both plants and animals. They are esters of fatty acids with glycerol. Their physical
and chemical nature is determined by their
fatty acid composition; high-molecularweight saturated acids confer chemical stability and physical hardness, whereas
unsaturated acids confer chemical reactivity
and physical softness.
6. The steroids have a basic structural unit of a
phenanthrene nucleus linked to a cyclopentane ring. They include the sterols, the bile
acids and the adrenal and sex hormones.
3. Linoleic and linolenic acids are termed the essential fatty acids, although only linoleic acid
is considered truly a dietary essential. They
are the source materials of the eicosanoids,
which include the prostaglandins, the thromboxanes and the leukotrienes.
4. Phospholipids are phosphorus-containing
compounds based on fatty acids esterified
with glycerol or a nitrogenous base. They are
important as constituents of the lipoprotein
complexes of biological membranes.
7. Cholesterol is the precursor of many sterols. It
is present in all animal cells and is particularly
important in the myelinated structures of the
brain and nervous tissue. There is strong evidence that the risk of coronary heart disease
is directly related to the concentration of lowdensity lipoprotein cholesterol in the blood.
8. 7-Dehydrocholesterol and ergosterol are important as the precursors of vitamins D3 and
D2, respectively.
9. The lipids in the form of triacylglycerols,
cholesterol esters, low-density lipoproteins
and the lipid-derived eicosanoids are intimately involved in the aetiology of heart
disease.
QUESTIONS
3.1
Discuss how the structure of an individual fatty acid affects its function within
the body of domesticated animals.
3.2
Discuss the difference in structure and function between triglycerides, phosphoglycerides and sphingomyelins in animal tissues.
3.3
Discuss why the diet of ruminants is generally high in polyunsaturated fatty
acids, and yet ruminant meat and milk are generally low in polyunsaturated
fatty acids and high in saturated fatty acids.
3.4
Discuss the role and function of steroids in the body of domesticated
animals.
51
Chapter 3 Lipids
FURTHER READING
Garton G A 1969 Lipid metabolism of farm animals. In: Cuthbertson D P (ed.) Nutrition of
Animals of Agricultural Importance, Oxford, Pergamon Press.
Harwood J L 1997 Plant lipid metabolism. In: Dey P M and Harborne J (eds) Plant Biochemistry, London, Academic Press.
Palmquist D L 1988 The feeding value of fats. In: Ørskov E R (ed.) World Animal Science,
Amsterdam, Elsevier.
Devlin T M (ed.) 2002 Textbook of Biochemistry with Clinical Correlations, 5th edn, New
York,Wiley-Liss.
52
4
Proteins, nucleic acids and other
nitrogenous compounds
4.1
Proteins
4.2
Amino acids
4.3
Peptides
4.4
Structure of proteins
4.5
Properties of proteins
4.6
Classification of proteins
4.7
Nucleic acids
4.8
Other nitrogenous compounds
4.9
4.10
4.1
Nitrates
Alkaloids
PROTEINS
Proteins are complex organic compounds of high molecular weight. In common with
carbohydrates and fats they contain carbon, hydrogen and oxygen, but in addition
they all contain nitrogen and generally sulphur.
Proteins are found in all living cells, where they are intimately connected with all
phases of activity that constitute the life of the cell. Each species has its own specific
proteins, and a single organism has many different proteins in its cells and tissues. It
follows therefore that a large number of proteins occur in nature.
4.2
AMINO ACIDS
Amino acids are produced when proteins are hydrolysed by enzymes, acids or alkalis. Although over 200 amino acids have been isolated from biological materials,
only 20 of these are commonly found as components of proteins.
Amino acids are characterised by having a basic nitrogenous group, generally an
amino group (–NH2), and an acidic carboxyl unit (–COOH). Most amino acids occurring naturally in proteins are of the ␣ type, having the amino group attached to
53
Chapter 4 Proteins, nucleic acids and other nitrogenous compounds
the carbon atom adjacent to the carboxyl group, and can be represented by the
general formula:
NH2
R
C
H
COOH
The exception is proline, which has an imino (–NH) instead of an amino group.
The nature of the R group, which is referred to as the side chain, varies in different
amino acids. It may simply be a hydrogen atom, as in glycine, or it may be a more
complex radical containing, for example, a phenyl group.
The chemical structures of the 20 amino acids commonly found in natural proteins
are shown in Table 4.1.
Special amino acids
Some proteins contain special amino acids that are derivatives of common amino
acids. For example, collagen, the fibrous protein of connective tissue, contains hydroxyproline and hydroxylysine, which are the hydroxylated derivatives of proline
and lysine, respectively.
CH2NH2
CHOH
HO
CH
CH2
CH2
CH2
CH
NH
CH2
COOH
NH2CHCOOH
Hydroxyproline
Hydroxylysine
Two iodine derivatives of tyrosine, triiodothyronine and tetraiodothyronine
(thyroxine), act as important hormones in the body and are also amino acid components of the protein thyroglobulin (see p. 127).
I
I
H
HO
O
CH2
C
NH2
I
Triiodothyronine
54
COOH
Amino acids
Table 4.1 Amino acids commonly found in proteins
Monoamino-monocarboxylic acids
CH2OH
Glycine
NH2CH2COOH
Serine
NH2CHCOOH
CH3
Alanine
CH3
NH2CHCOOH
HCOH
CH3
CH3
Threonine
NH2CHCOOH
CH
Valine
NH2CHCOOH
CH3
CH3
CH3
CH
CH2
Leucine
CH3
CH2
CH
NH2CHCOOH
Isoleucine
NH 2CHCOOH
Sulpur-containing amino acids
CH3
S
CH2
CH2SH
Cysteine
NH2CHCOOH
CH2
Methionine
NH2CHCOOH
Monoamino-dicarboxylic acids and their amine derivatives
COOH
Aspartic acid
COOH
CH2
CH2
CH2
NH2CHCOOH
Glutamic acid
NH2CHCOOH
CO
CO
NH2
CH2
CH2
Asparagine
NH2CHCOOH
NH2
CH2
Glutamine
NH2CHCOOH
55
Chapter 4 Proteins, nucleic acids and other nitrogenous compounds
Table 4.1 Continued
Basic amino acids
CH2NH2
N
HC
CH2
Lysine
CH
CH2
C
CH2
CH2
NH2CHCOOH
Histidine
NH
NH2CHCOOH
NH2
N
NH
NH
(CH2)3
Arginine
NH2CHCOOH
Aromatic and heterocyclic amino acids
OH
CH2
CH2
Phenylalanine NH2CHCOOH
Tyrosine
NH2CHCOOH
CH
HC
C
HC
C
CH
Tryptophan
C
CH2
CH
CH
COOH
NH2
N
H
CH2
CH2
CH
CH2
Proline
56
N
H
COOH
Amino acids
I
I
H
HO
O
CH2
C
COOH
NH2
I
I
Tetraiodothyronine (thyroxine)
A derivative of glutamic acid, γ-carboxyglutamic acid, is an amino acid present in
the protein thrombin.This amino acid is capable of binding calcium ions and plays an
important role in blood clotting (see p. 86).
HOOC
COOH
CH
CH2
NH2CHCOOH
γ-Carboxyglutamic acid
The amino acid γ-aminobutyric acid functions in the body as a neurotransmitter.
It is also found in silage as a fermentation product of glutamic acid (see p. 502).
NH2CH2CH2CH2COOH
γ-Aminobutyric acid
The sulphur-containing amino acid cysteine also requires special mention. It may
occur in protein in two forms, either as itself or as cystine, in which two cysteine
molecules are joined together by a disulphide bridge:
CH2
S
NH2CHCOOH
S
CH2
NH2CHCOOH
Cystine
Properties of amino acids
Because of the presence of an amino group and a carboxyl group, amino acids are
amphoteric, i.e. they have both basic and acidic properties. Molecules such as these,
with basic and acidic groups, may exist as uncharged molecules, or as dipolar ions
with opposite ionic charges, or as a mixture of these.Amino acids in aqueous solution
exist as dipolar ions or zwitter ions (from the German Zwitter, a hermaphrodite):
NH3+
R
C
H
COO–
57
Chapter 4 Proteins, nucleic acids and other nitrogenous compounds
In a strongly acid solution an amino acid exists largely as a cation, while in alkaline solution it occurs mainly as an anion. There is a pH value for a given amino
acid at which it is electrically neutral; this value is known as the isoelectric point.
Because of their amphoteric nature, amino acids act as buffers, resisting changes
in pH.
All the α-amino acids except glycine are optically active. As with the carbohydrates (see Chapter 2), amino acids can take two mirror image forms, D- and L-.
COOH
H
C
COOH
NH2
NH2
R
D-Amino
C
H
R
acid
L-Amino
acid
All the amino acids involved in protein structure have an L-configuration of
the carbon atom. If supplied in the D-form, some amino acids can be converted to
the L-form by deamination of the amino acid to the keto acid and reamination to the
L-form (see Chapter 9).
Essential amino acids
Plants and many microorganisms are able to synthesise proteins from simple nitrogenous compounds such as nitrates.Animals cannot synthesise the amino group, and in
order to build up body proteins they must have a dietary source of amino acids. Certain amino acids can be produced from others by a process known as transamination
(see Chapter 9), but the carbon skeletons of a number of amino acids cannot be synthesised in the animal body; these are referred to as essential or indispensible amino
acids.
Most of the early work in determining which amino acids could be classed as essential was carried out with rats fed on purified diets. The following ten essential
amino acids are required for growth in the rat:
Arginine
Histidine
Isoleucine
Leucine
Lysine
Methionine
Phenylalanine
Threonine
Tryptophan
Valine
The chick requires a dietary supply of the ten amino acids listed above but in addition needs a dietary source of glycine. Birds require arginine because their metabolism does not include the urea cycle (see Chapter 9), which would normally supply
this amino acid. The list of essential amino acids required by the pig is similar to
that for the rat, with the exception of arginine, which can be synthesised by the pig.
It has been reported that rapidly growing animals may respond to arginine because
the very active metabolism of the liver results in little of the amino acid being available to the general circulation. Cats require a dietary supply of arginine, owing to
their limited ability to synthesise ornithine from glutamate, and a deficiency of arginine results in the accumulation of ammonia from denatured amino acids in the
blood. Cats also require the β-sulphonic amino acid taurine in their diet as they are
58
Peptides
unable to synthesise this from cysteine. Taurine is required for bile acid conjugation
(see p. 49). Poultry have a limited capacity to synthesise proline. The actual dietary
requirement of certain essential amino acids is dependent upon the presence of
other amino acids. For example, the requirement for methionine is partially dependent on the cysteine content of the diet (see p. 312).
In the case of the ruminant, all the essential amino acids can be synthesised by
the rumen microorganisms, which theoretically makes this class of animal independent of a dietary source once the rumen microorganisms have become established. However, the supply of amino acids from microbial protein is limiting in
quantity and quality for maximum rates of growth in young animals and for maximum milk production.The biological value (see Chapter 13) of microbial protein is
limited by its content of certain essential amino acids, particularly lysine and methionine. For maximum productivity the microbial protein must be supplemented
with a supply of dietary amino acids, from foods or synthetic amino acids, in a
suitable form that is not degraded by the microorganisms in the rumen (see
Chapter 8).
4.3
PEPTIDES
Peptides are built up from amino acids by means of a linkage between the α-carboxyl
of one amino acid and the α-amino group of another acid, as shown here:
H
H
R
O
N
C
C
OH
+
H
R1
O
N
C
C
OH
H
H
H
H
H
R
O
H
R1
O
N
C
C
N
C
C
H
OH
+
H2O
H
This type of linkage is known as the peptide linkage; in the example shown, a
dipeptide has been produced from two amino acids. Large numbers of amino acids
can be joined together by this means, with the elimination of one molecule of water
at each linkage, to produce polypeptides.
Besides being important building blocks in the construction of proteins, some
peptides possess their own biological activity. Milk, in particular, is a source of many
biologically active peptides. The enzymatic hydrolysis of the milk protein casein releases opioid peptides, which have pharmacological activities such as analgesia and
sleep-inducing effects. Other peptides derived from casein are involved in calcium
flow in tissues and modification of the immune system response. Other milk peptides
59
Chapter 4 Proteins, nucleic acids and other nitrogenous compounds
stimulate growth of desirable bacteria and suppress harmful bacteria, and some act
as growth factors for intestinal cells.
Other peptides, including bombesin, enterostatin, glucagon and leptin, are important in the control of food intake.
Peptides play an important role in the flavour and sensory properties of foods
such as yeast extract, cheese and fruit juices.
4.4
STRUCTURE OF PROTEINS
For convenience the structure of proteins can be considered under four basic
headings.
Primary structure
The sequence of amino acids along the polypeptide chain of a protein, as described
above, is called the primary structure of the protein.
Secondary structure
The secondary structure of proteins refers to the conformation of the chain of amino
acids resulting from the formation of hydrogen bonds between the imino and carbonyl groups of adjacent amino acids, as shown in Fig. 4.1.
The secondary structure may be regular, in which case the polypeptide chains
exist in the form of an α-helix or a β-pleated sheet, or it may be irregular and exist
as, for example, a random coil.
Tertiary structure
The tertiary structure describes how the chains of the secondary structure further interact through the R groups of the amino acid residues. This interaction causes folding and bending of the polypeptide chain, the specific manner of the folding giving
each protein its characteristic biological activity.
H
O
N
C
C
H
R
R
H
C
C
O
R
C
C
H
O
O
H
C
N
C
H
O
H
C
N
N
N
H
H
R
C
H
R
R
H
C
C
N
O
H
Fig. 4.1 Configuration of polypeptide chain. Dotted lines represent possible
hydrogen bonds.
60
Classification of proteins
Quaternary structure
Proteins possess quaternary structure if they contain more than one polypeptide
chain. The forces that stabilise these aggregates are hydrogen bonds and electrostatic
or salt bonds formed between residues on the surfaces of the polypeptide chains.
4.5
PROPERTIES OF PROTEINS
All proteins have colloidal properties; they differ in their solubility in water, ranging
from insoluble keratin to albumins, which are highly soluble. Soluble proteins can be
precipitated from solution by the addition of certain salts such as sodium chloride or
ammonium sulphate. This is a physical effect and the properties of the proteins are
not altered. On dilution the proteins can easily be redissolved.
Although the amino and carboxyl groups in the peptide linkage are nonfunctional in acid–base reactions, all proteins contain a number of free amino and
carboxyl groups, either as terminal units or in the side chain of amino acid residues.
Like amino acids, proteins are therefore amphoteric. They exhibit characteristic isoelectric points and have buffering properties.
All proteins can be denatured or changed from their natural state. Denaturation
has been defined by Neurath and coworkers as ‘any non-proteolytic modification of
the unique structure of a native protein, giving rise to definite changes in chemical,
physical or biological properties’. Products of protein hydrolysis are not included
under this term. Several agents can bring about denaturation of proteins; these
include heat, acids, alkalis, alcohols, urea and salts of heavy metals. The effect of
heat on proteins is of special interest in nutrition as this results in new linkages
within and between peptide chains. Some of these new linkages resist hydrolysis by
proteases produced in the digestive tract and impede their access to adjacent peptide bonds.
Susceptibility of proteins to heat damage is increased in the presence of various
carbohydrates, owing to the occurrence of Maillard-type reactions, which initially involve a condensation between the carbonyl group of a reducing sugar with the free
amino group of an amino acid or protein. Lysine is particularly susceptible. With increasing severity of heat treatment, further reactions involving protein side chains
can occur and result in the browning of foods. The dark coloration of overheated
hays and silages is symptomatic of these types of reaction.
4.6
CLASSIFICATION OF PROTEINS
Proteins may be classified into two main groups: simple proteins and conjugated
proteins.
Simple proteins
These proteins produce only amino acids on hydrolysis. They are subdivided into
two groups, fibrous and globular proteins, according to shape, solubility and chemical composition.
61
Chapter 4 Proteins, nucleic acids and other nitrogenous compounds
Fibrous proteins
These proteins, which in most cases have structural roles in animal cells and tissues,
are insoluble and are very resistant to animal digestive enzymes.They are composed
of elongated filamentous chains joined together by cross-linkages. The group includes collagens, elastin and keratins.
Collagens are the main proteins of connective tissues and constitute about 30 per
cent of the total proteins in the mammalian body. As mentioned earlier (p. 54), the
amino acid hydroxyproline is an important component of collagen. Hydroxylation
of proline to hydroxyproline involves vitamin C; if this vitamin is deficient, collagen
fibres are weakened and may give rise to gum and skin lesions (see p. 100). The indispensable amino acid tryptophan is not found in these proteins.
Elastin is the protein found in elastic tissues such as tendons and arteries. The
polypeptide chain of elastin is rich in alanine and glycine and is very flexible. It contains cross-links involving lysine side chains, which prevent the protein from extending excessively under tension and allow it to return to its normal length when
tension is removed.
Keratins are classified into two types. The α-keratins are the main proteins of
wool and hair. The β-keratins occur in feathers, skin, beaks and scales of most birds
and reptiles. These proteins are very rich in the sulphur-containing amino acid cysteine; wool protein, for example, contains about 4 per cent of sulphur (see p. 373).
Globular proteins
Globular proteins are so called because their polypeptide chains are folded into compact structures. The group includes all the enzymes, antigens and those hormones that
are proteins. Its first subgroup, albumins, are water-soluble and heat-coagulable and
occur in milk, the blood, eggs and many plants. Histones are basic proteins that occur in
cell nuclei, where they are associated with DNA (see p. 64).They are soluble in salt solutions, are not heat-coagulable, and on hydrolysis yield large quantities of arginine and
lysine. Protamines are basic proteins of relatively low molecular weight, which are associated with nucleic acids and are found in large quantities in the mature male germ
cells of vertebrates. Protamines are rich in arginine but contain no tyrosine, tryptophan
or sulphur-containing amino acids. Globulins occur in milk, eggs and blood, and are the
main reserve protein in many seeds.
Conjugated proteins
Conjugated proteins contain, in addition to amino acids, a non-protein moiety
termed a prosthetic group. Some important examples of conjugated proteins are glycoproteins, lipoproteins, phosphoproteins and chromoproteins.
Glycoproteins are proteins with one or more heteroglycans as prosthetic
groups. In most glycoproteins the heteroglycans contain a hexosamine, either glucosamine or galactosamine or both; in addition, galactose and mannose may also
be present. Glycoproteins are components of mucous secretions, which act as lubricants in many parts of the body. The storage protein in egg white, ovalbumin, is
a glycoprotein.
Lipoproteins, which are proteins conjugated with lipids such as triacylglycerols
and cholesterol, are the main components of cell membranes and are also the form
in which lipids are transported in the bloodstream to tissues, either for oxidation or
62
Nucleic acids
for energy storage. They can be classified into five main categories in increasing
order of density: chylomicrons, very-low-density lipoproteins (VLDL), low-density
lipoproteins (LDL), intermediate-density lipoproteins (IDL) and high-density lipoproteins (HDL) (see Chapter 3).
Phosphoproteins, which contain phosphoric acid as the prosthetic group, include
the caseins of milk (see p. 406) and phosvitin in egg yolk.
Chromoproteins contain a pigment as the prosthetic group. Examples are haemoglobin and cytochromes, in which the prosthetic group is the iron-containing compound haem, and flavoproteins, which contain flavins (see p. 90).
4.7
NUCLEIC ACIDS
Nucleic acids are high-molecular-weight compounds that play a fundamental role in
living organisms as a store of genetic information; they are the means by which this
information is utilised in the synthesis of proteins. On hydrolysis, nucleic acids yield
a mixture of basic nitrogenous compounds (purines and pyrimidines), a pentose (ribose or deoxyribose) and phosphoric acid.
The main pyrimidines found in nucleic acids are cytosine, thymine and uracil.The
relationships between these compounds and the parent material, pyrimidine, are
shown below:
N
N
Pyrimidine
NH2
O
O
CH3
N
O
HN
HN
N
H
O
O
N
H
Thymine
Cytosine
N
H
Uracil
Adenine and guanine are the principal purine bases present in nucleic acids.
NH2
O
N
N
N
N
N
HN
NH
NH
N
N
Purine
Adenine
NH
H2N
N
Guanine
63
Chapter 4 Proteins, nucleic acids and other nitrogenous compounds
The compound formed by linking one of the above nitrogenous compounds to a
pentose is termed a nucleoside. For example:
NH2
NH2
CH2OH
N
N
+
NH
N
OH
O
C
H
H
H
C
C
OH
OH
C
N
N
+
H2O
N
H
N
CH2OH O
Adenine
D-Ribose
C
H
H
H
C
C
OH
OH
C
H
Adenosine
If nucleosides such as adenosine are esterified with phosphoric acid they form
nucleotides, e.g. adenosine monophosphate (AMP):
NH2
N
N
N
N
H2O3POCH2
O
C
H
H
H
C
C
OH
OH
C
H
Nucleic acids are polynucleotides of very high molecular weight, generally
measured in several millions. A nucleotide containing ribose is termed ribonucleic
acid (RNA), while one containing deoxyribose is referred to as deoxyribonucleic
acid (DNA).
The nucleotides are arranged in a certain pattern; DNA normally consists of a
double-strand spiral or helix (Fig. 4.2). Each strand consists of alternate units of the
deoxyribose and phosphate groups. Attached to each sugar group is one of the four
bases, cytosine, thymine, adenine or guanine.The bases on the two strands of the spiral are joined in pairs by hydrogen bonds, the thymine on one strand always being
paired with the adenine on the other and the cytosine with the guanine. The sequence of bases along these strands carries the genetic information of the living cell
(see p. 217). DNA is found in the nuclei of cells as part of the chromosome structure.
There are several distinct types of ribonucleic acid, which are defined in terms of
molecular size, base composition and functional properties.They differ from DNA in
64
Nucleic acids
P
A
D
T
P
D
P
A
T
P
D
D
P
C
G
P
D
D
P
T
A
D
P
D
P
C
D
G
P
D
P
P
Fig. 4.2 Diagrammatic representation of part of the ladder-like DNA molecule,
showing the two strands of alternate phosphate (P) and deoxyribose (D) molecules.
The horizontal rods represent the pairs of bases held by hydrogen bonds (represented
by dotted lines).
A = adenine, T = thymine, C = cytosine, G = guanine.
the nature of their sugar moiety and also in the types of nitrogenous base present.
RNA contains the pyrimidine uracil in place of thymine.There is evidence to indicate
that unlike DNA, most RNA molecules exist in the form of single, folded chains
arranged spirally. There are three main forms of RNA, termed messenger RNA, ribosomal RNA and transfer RNA. The functions of these three forms of RNA are dealt
with in the protein synthesis section of Chapter 9.
Apart from their importance in the structure of nucleic acids, nucleotides exist
free as monomers and many play an important role in cellular metabolism.
Although nucleotides are synthesised de novo it appears that this synthesis is not
always adequate. In such cases (abrupt early weaning of piglets and times of disease
challenge) a dietary supply augments the natural synthesis and enhances immune
function and the proliferation of cells.
Reference has been made previously to the phosphorylation of adenosine to form
adenosine monophosphate (AMP). Successive additions of phosphate residues give
adenosine diphosphate (ADP) and then the triphosphate (ATP). The importance of
ATP in energy transformations is described in Chapter 9.
65
Chapter 4 Proteins, nucleic acids and other nitrogenous compounds
4.8
OTHER NITROGENOUS COMPOUNDS
A considerable variety of nitrogen-containing compounds, other than proteins and
nucleic acids, occur in plants and animals. In plants, free amino acids are usually
present; those in greatest amount include glutamic acid, aspartic acid, alanine, serine, glycine and proline. Other compounds are nitrogenous lipids, amines, amides,
purines, pyrimidines, nitrates and alkaloids. In addition, most members of the vitamin B complex contain nitrogen in their structure.
It is impossible to deal with these compounds in any detail here, and only some of
the important ones not previously mentioned will be discussed.
Amines
Amines are basic compounds present in small amounts in most plant and animal tissues. Many occur as decomposition products in decaying organic matter and have
toxic properties.
A number of microorganisms are capable of producing amines by decarboxylation of amino acids (Table 4.2). These may be produced in the rumen under certain
conditions and can occur in fermented foods such as cheese, wine, sauerkraut and
sausage. They are termed biogenic amines and may give rise to physiological symptoms; histamine, for example, is an amine formed from the amino acid histidine and in
cases of anaphylactic shock is found in the blood in relatively large amounts. Histamine has also been implicated in dietary-induced migraine. Silages in which clostridia
have dominated the fermentation usually contain appreciable amounts of amines (see
Chapter 19).
In contrast to the harmful biogenic amines, the polyamines putrescene, spermidine and spermine are necessary for optimal growth and function of cells. They are
involved in DNA, RNA and protein synthesis, regulation of gene expression, enzyme
activity, cell proliferation and cell signalling.
Several metabolic pathways (e.g. lipid metabolism, creatine and carnitine synthesis) require methyl groups and these can be supplied by choline or methionine. During the process of transmethylation, betaine, a tertiary amine, is formed by the
oxidation of choline. Betaine can be added to the diet to act as a more direct supply
of methyl groups, thus sparing choline for its other functions of lecithin and acetylcholine formation, and methionine for protein synthesis. Betaine occurs in sugar beet,
Table 4.2 Some important amines and their parent
amino acids
66
Amino acid
Amine
Arginine
Histidine
Lysine
Phenylalanine
Tyrosine
Tryptophan
Putrescine
Histamine
Cadaverine
Phenylethylamine
Tyramine
Tryptamine
Nitrates
and the young leaves may contain about 25 g/kg; it is this amine that is responsible
for the fishy aroma frequently associated with the commercial extraction of sugar
from beet. In the animal body, betaine may be transformed into trimethylamine, and
it is this that gives the fishy taint to milk produced by cows that have been given excessive amounts of sugar beet by-products.
Amides
Asparagine and glutamine are important amide derivatives of the amino acids aspartic
acid and glutamic acid. These two amides are also classed as amino acids (Table 4.1)
and occur as components of proteins.They also occur as free amides and play an important role in transamination reactions.
Urea is an amide that is the main end product of nitrogen metabolism in mammals, but it also occurs in many plants and has been detected in wheat, soya bean,
potato and cabbage.
NH2
O
C
NH2
Urea
In humans and other primates, uric acid is the end product of purine metabolism
and is found in the urine. In subprimate mammals the uric acid is oxidised to
allantoin before being excreted.
In birds, uric acid is the principal end product of nitrogen metabolism and thus
corresponds, in its function, to urea in mammals.
O
H
N
N
O
H2N
C
H
N
O
O
O
N
H
N
H
Uric acid
4.9
O
N
H
H
N
H
Allantoin
NITRATES
Nitrates may be present in plant materials and, whereas nitrate itself may not be
toxic to animals, it is reduced readily under favourable conditions, as in the rumen,
to nitrite, which is toxic. Oat hay poisoning is attributed to the relatively large
amounts of nitrate present in green oats.
Quite high levels of nitrate have been reported in herbage given heavy dressings
of nitrogenous fertilisers (see Chapter 18).
67
Chapter 4 Proteins, nucleic acids and other nitrogenous compounds
4.10
ALKALOIDS
These compounds are of particular interest since many of them have poisonous
properties. In plants, their presence is restricted to a few orders of the dicotyledons. A number of the more important alkaloids, with their sources, are listed in
Table 4.3. The alkaloid in ragwort, for example, attacks the liver and much of
this organ can be destroyed before symptoms appear. Another nutritionally significant source of alkaloids is the fungus ergot, which grows on cereal grains (see
Chapter 22).
Table 4.3 Some important alkaloids occurring in plants
Name
Source
Coniine
Nicotine
Ricinine
Atropine
Cocaine
Jacobine
Quinine
Strychnine
Morphine
Solanine
Hemlock
Tobacco
Castor plant seeds
Deadly nightshade
Leaves of coca plant
Ragwort
Cinchona bark
Seeds of Nuxvomica
Dried latex of opium poppy
Unripe potatoes and potato sprouts
SUMMARY
1. Proteins are complex organic compounds of
high molecular weight containing carbon,
hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen and generally
sulphur.
5. Proteins have colloidal properties and can be
denatured by heat, creating new linkages between the chains, some of which are resistant
to hydrolysis.
2. Proteins are made up from a pool of 20
amino acids, about ten of which are essential
(indispensable) for non-ruminants.
6. Proteins may be simple, either fibrous or
globular, or conjugated to a non-protein
molecule.
3. Amino acids join together by a peptide linkage between the ␣-carboxyl group of one
acid and the ␣-amino group of another.
7. Nucleic acids act as a store of genetic information when arranged to form DNA and RNA.
4. The primary structure of a protein refers to
the sequence of amino acids in the polypeptide chain; the conformation of the chain as
a result of hydrogen bonding is the secondary structure; folding of the chain gives the
tertiary structure; the quaternary structure
refers to the configuration of those proteins with more than one polypeptide
chain.
68
8. Amines are derivatives of amino acids and
some possess physiological activity.
9. Urea is an important member of the amide
group of compounds.
10. Nitrate is converted to the toxic nitrite in the
rumen.
11. Alkaloids are poisonous nitrogen-containing
compounds formed by some plants and fungi.
Further reading
FURTHER READING
Creighton T E 1992 Proteins: Structures and Molecular Properties, 2nd edn, Oxford, W H
Freeman.
D’Mello J P F 1995 Amino Acids in Animal Nutrition,Wallingford, CABI.
Horton H R, Moran L A, Ochs R S, Rawn J D and Scrimgeour K G 1993 Principles of
Biochemistry, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, Prentice Hall.
Lehninger A L, Nelson D L and Cox M M 1993 Principles of Biochemistry, 2nd edn, New York,
Worth.
Mathews C K and van Holde K E 1990 Biochemistry, Redwood City, CA, Benjamin Cummings
Publishing Co.
Neurath H and Hill R L (eds) 1982 The Proteins, New York, Academic Press.
69
5
5.1
Vitamins
5.1
Introduction
5.2
Fat-soluble vitamins
5.3
The vitamin B complex
5.4
Vitamin C
5.5
Hypervitaminosis
INTRODUCTION
Discovery of vitamins
The discovery and isolation of many of the vitamins were originally achieved
through work on rats given diets of purified proteins, fats, carbohydrates and
inorganic salts. Using this technique, Hopkins in 1912 showed that a synthetic
diet of this type was inadequate for the normal growth of rats, but that when a small
quantity of milk was added to the diet the animals developed normally. This proved
that there was some essential factor, or factors, lacking in the pure diet.
About this time the term ‘vitamines’, derived from ‘vital amines’, was coined by
Funk to describe these accessory food factors, which he thought contained aminonitrogen. It is now known that only a few of these substances contain amino-nitrogen
and the word has been shortened to vitamins, a term that has been generally accepted
as a group name.
Although the discovery of the vitamins dates from the beginning of the twentieth
century, the association of certain diseases with dietary deficiencies had been recognised much earlier. In 1753 Lind, a British naval physician, published a treatise on
scurvy, proving that this disease could be prevented in human beings by including
salads and summer fruits in their diet. The action of lemon juice in curing and preventing scurvy had been known, however, since the beginning of the seventeenth
century. The use of cod-liver oil in preventing rickets has long been appreciated, and
Eijkmann knew at the end of the nineteenth century that beri-beri, a disease common
in the Far East, could be cured by giving the patients brown rice grain rather than
polished rice.
70
Introduction
Vitamins and biochemistry
Vitamins are usually defined as organic compounds that are required in small
amounts for normal growth and maintenance of animal life. But this definition
ignores the important part that these substances play in plants and their importance
generally in the metabolism of all living organisms. Unlike the nutrients covered in
Chapters 2–4, vitamins are not merely building blocks or energy-yielding compounds but are involved in, or are mediators of, the biochemical pathways (Fig. 5.1).
For example, many of the B vitamins act as cofactors in enzyme systems but it is not
always clear how the symptoms of deficiency are related to the failure of the metabolic pathway.
In addition to avoiding explicit vitamin deficiency symptoms (see below) or a
general depression in production due to a subclinical deficiency, some vitamins are
added to the diet at higher levels in order to (1) enhance the quality of the animal
product, e.g. vitamin D for eggshell strength and vitamin E for prolonging the shelf
BOX 5.1 Vitamin supplementation of diets
Most food mixes prepared as supplements for ruminants and horses or as the sole food for pigs,
poultry, dogs and cats are supplemented with vitamins. With other nutrients, such as energy and
protein, it is possible to demonstrate a response to increments in intake, which can be evaluated
against the cost of the increment. This is not possible with vitamins, for which the cost is relatively
small in relation to the consequences of deficiency.Therefore, vitamins are usually supplied at levels
greater than those shown to be required under experimental conditions. This oversupply allows for
uncertainties met under practical conditions (e.g. variable vitamin content and availability in foods,
loss of vitamin potency in storage, range of management practices, quality of the environment,
health status, extra requirements due to stress).This is not to say that such safety margins should be
excessive, since this would be wasteful: in addition, an excess of one vitamin may increase the requirement for another. For example, the fat-soluble vitamins share absorption mechanisms and
compete with each other; thus, an excess of vitamin A will increase the dietary requirements of
vitamins E, D and K.
Originally, vitamins for supplements were isolated from plant products. However, yields from
such sources are low and the vitamins can be expensive. Yields can be increased when vitamins are
produced from microorganisms by fermentation. Nowadays many vitamins are produced in multistage chemical processes that are controllable and the yield is predictable.
For ease of handling in the feed mill the vitamin supplement needs to (1) be free-flowing, (2) not
be dusty and (3) mix homogeneously with other diet ingredients (vitamins are added in minute
amounts but must be thoroughly dispersed throughout the mix); the vitamin must remain stable and
yet be biologically available when consumed by the animal. Some of these criteria are incompatible
and a compromise has to be reached. Oily vitamins are absorbed on to silica; others are coated or
micro-encapsulated and antioxidants are added to prevent breakdown of those vitamins that are
susceptible to oxidation. The manufacturers also make use of stable derivatives of vitamins (e.g. the
acetate form of ␣-tocopherol as opposed to the alcohol form).
Maintenance of vitamin activity in the supplement is affected by temperature, humidity, acidity/
alkalinity, oxygen, ultraviolet light, the presence of some trace minerals (dietary supplements are
usually combinations of vitamins, minerals and trace elements), physical factors such as hammer
milling and the length of time the supplement is stored. For example, choline chloride can destroy
other vitamins during storage.
71
72
H
K
B6
B12
B6
ine
Folic Chol-
B6
Calpan
Glutamate
B6
B6
Aspartate
CoA
B6
H
B6
Calpan
PP
Calpan
α-Ketoglutarate
PP
Isocitrate
Krebs
Cycle
Citrate
C
Inositol
PP
B1
2H
CO2
PP
Calpan
Succinate
Adapted from Roche Vitec Animal Nutrition and Vitamin News 1: A1–10/2 November 1984.
PP
Fumarate
Malate
B2
Succinyl-CoA
Oxalacetate
B6
Acetyl-CoA
H
Pyruvate
B1
Carbohydrate
metabolism
H
Fig. 5.1 Diagram showing the involvement of vitamins in biochemical pathways.
Protein
metabolism
Folic PP
H
PP
B2
B6
B12
Folic
Nucleic
acids
PP
B12 PP
H
B12
B1
PP
Calpan
B1
B2 Calpan
Energy
output
B1
Propionate
H
B1
B2
E
PP
B1
H
PP
E
Chol- Caline pan
Niacin
Vitamin K
Vitamin B12
Vitamin E
K
B12
Ascorbic acid
Choline
Choline
E
Folacin
Folic
C
Biotin
H
Pantothenic acid
Pyridoxine
PP
Calpan
Riboflavin
B6
Thiamin
B2
B1
KEY
Fat metabolism
B12
Cholesterol
Acyl-CoA
Calpan Choline
Acetylcholine
Cal- Cholpan ine
Acetate
B1
Malonyl-CoA
Chapter 5 Vitamins
Introduction
life of carcasses, or (2) improve health, e.g. vitamin A to improve the health status of
the mammary gland in dairy cows.
Vitamins are required by animals in very small amounts compared with other nutrients; for example, the vitamin B1 (thiamin) requirement of a 50 kg pig is only
about 3 mg/day. Nevertheless, a continuous deficiency in the diet results in disordered metabolism and eventually disease.
Some compounds function as vitamins only after undergoing a chemical change;
such compounds, which include ␤-carotene and certain sterols, are described as
provitamins or vitamin precursors.
Many vitamins are destroyed by oxidation, a process speeded up by the action of
heat, light and certain metals such as iron. This fact is important since the conditions
under which a food is stored will affect the final vitamin potency. Some commercial
vitamin preparations are dispersed in wax or gelatin, which act as a protective layer
against oxidation (for further details of vitamin supplementation of diets, see Box 5.1).
The system of naming the vitamins by letters of the alphabet was most convenient and was generally accepted before the discovery of their chemical nature. Although this system of nomenclature is still widely used with some vitamins, the
modern tendency is to use the chemical name, particularly in describing members of
the B complex.
At least 14 vitamins have been accepted as essential food factors, and a few
others have been proposed. Only those that are of nutritional importance are dealt
with in this chapter.
It is convenient to divide the vitamins into two main groups: fat-soluble and
water-soluble. Table 5.1 lists the important members of these two groups.
Table 5.1 Vitamins important in animal nutrition
Vitamin
Chemical name
Fat-soluble vitamins
A
D2
D3
E
K
Retinol
Ergocalciferol
Cholecalciferol
Tocopherola
Phylloquinoneb
Water-soluble vitamins
B complex
B1
B2
B6
B12
C
Thiamin
Riboflavin
Nicotinamide
Pyridoxine
Pantothenic acid
Biotin
Folic acid
Choline
Cyanocobalamin
Ascorbic acid
a
A number of tocopherols have vitamin E activity.
Several naphthoquinone derivatives possessing vitamin K activity are known.
b
73
Chapter 5 Vitamins
5.2
FAT-SOLUBLE VITAMINS
Vitamin A
Chemical nature
Vitamin A (C20H29OH), known chemically as retinol, is an unsaturated monohydric
alcohol with the following structural formula:
CH3
CH3
H3C
CH3
CH2OH
CH3
Vitamin A (all-trans form)
The vitamin is a pale yellow crystalline solid, insoluble in water but soluble in fat
and various fat solvents. It is readily destroyed by oxidation on exposure to air and
light. A related compound with the formula C20H27OH, originally found in fish, has
been designated dehydroretinol or vitamin A2.
Sources
Vitamin A accumulates in the liver and this organ is likely to be a good source; the
amount present varies with species of animal and diet. Table 5.2 shows some typical
liver reserves of vitamin A in different species, although these values vary widely within
each species.
The oils from livers of certain fish, especially cod and halibut, have long been
used as an important dietary source of the vitamin. Egg yolk and milk fat also are
usually rich sources, although the vitamin content of these depends, to a large extent, upon the diet of the animal from which it has been produced.
Vitamin A is manufactured synthetically and can be obtained in a pure form.
Table 5.2 Some typical values for liver reserves of vitamin
A in different speciesa
Species
Pig
Cow
Rat
Man
Sheep
Horse
Hen
Codfish
Halibut
Polar bear
Soup-fin shark
Vitamin A (µg/g liver)
30
45
75
90
180
180
270
600
3000
6000
15000
a
In every species, wide individual variations are to be expected.
Adapted from Moore T 1969 In: Morton R A (ed.) Fat Soluble Vitamins,
Oxford, Pergamon Press, p. 233.
74
Fat-soluble vitamins
Provitamins
Vitamin A does not exist as such in plants, but it is present as precursors or provitamins in the form of certain carotenoids, which can be converted into the vitamin.
At least 600 naturally occurring carotenoids are known, but only a few of these are
precursors of the vitamin.
In plants, carotenoids have yellow, orange or red colours but their colours are frequently masked by the green colour of chlorophyll.When ingested, they are responsible
for many of the varied and natural colours that occur in crustaceans, insects, birds and
fish.They are also found in egg yolk, butterfat and the body fat of cattle and horses, but
not in sheep or pigs. Carotenoids may be divided into two main categories: carotenes
and xanthophylls. The latter include a wide range of compounds, for example lutein,
cryptoxanthin and zeaxanthin, most of which cannot be converted into vitamin A. Of
the carotenes, ␤-carotene is the most important member and this compound forms the
main source of vitaminA in the diets of farm animals. Its structure is shown here:
H3C
CH3
H3C
CH3
CH3
H3C
CH3
CH3
CH3
CH3
β-Carotene
The long unsaturated hydrocarbon chains in carotenes (and vitamin A) are easily
oxidised to by-products that have no vitamin potency. Oxidation is increased by heat,
light, moisture and the presence of heavy metals. Consequently, foods exposed to air
and sunlight rapidly lose their vitamin A potency, so that large losses can occur during
the sun-drying of crops. For example, lucerne hay has around 15 mg ␤-carotene/kg, but
artificially dried lucerne and grass meals have 95 mg/kg and 155 mg/kg, respectively.
Fresh grass is an excellent source (250 mg/kg DM), but this is halved during ensilage.
Carotenoids and supplemental vitamin A are prone to destruction in the rumen,
especially with high concentrate diets. Recent studies indicate that naturally occurring carotenoids in forages may not be degraded to the same extent as purified products used as supplements. The gelatin preparations of vitamin A, with stabilising
agents, are intended to protect the vitamin from this destruction but still remain
available to be absorbed from the duodenum. In monogastrics the availability varies
between foods. In humans it has been found that oil solutions of carotenoids are
more available than those naturally occurring in foods. This is reflected in the fact
that the efficiency of absorption is largely dependent on the quality and quantity of
fat in the diet. The measurement of availability of carotenoids in foods and factors
that affect it are currently an active area of research in animals and humans.
Conversion of carotene into vitamin A can occur in the liver but usually takes
place in the intestinal mucosa. Theoretically, hydrolysis of one molecule of the C40
compound ␤-carotene should yield two molecules of the C20 compound retinol, but
although central cleavage of this type is thought to occur, it is considered likely that
the carotene is degraded from one end of the chain by step-wise oxidation until only
one molecule of the C20 compound retinol remains.Although the maximum conversion measured in the rat is 2 mg ␤-carotene into 1 mg retinol, authorities differ
75
Chapter 5 Vitamins
regarding the conversion efficiency in other animals with ranges from 3 : 1 to 12 : 1.
Ruminants convert about 6 mg of ␤-carotene into 1 mg of retinol.The corresponding
conversion efficiency for pigs and poultry is usually taken as 11 : 1 and 3 : 1, respectively. Cats do not have the enzyme to convert carotene to vitamin A. Since their
diet comprises meat, which usually contains sufficient vitamin A and low levels of
carotenoids, the conversion pathway is redundant.The vitamin A values of foods are
often stated in terms of international units (iu), one iu of vitamin A being defined as
the activity of 0.3 µg of crystalline retinol.
Metabolism
Vitamin A appears to play two different roles in the body according to whether it is
acting in the eye or in the general system.
In the retinal cells of the eye, vitamin A (all-trans-retinol) is converted into the
11-cis-isomer, which is then oxidised to 11-cis-retinaldehde. In the dark the latter
then combines with the protein opsin to form rhodopsin (visual purple), which is the
photoreceptor for vision at low light intensities. When light falls on the retina, the
cis-retinaldehyde molecule is converted back into the all-trans form and is released
from the opsin.This conversion results in the transmission of an impulse up the optic
nerve. The all-trans-retinaldehyde is converted to all-trans-retinol, which re-enters
the cycle, thus continually renewing the light sensitivity of the retina (Fig. 5.2).
In its second role, in the regulation of cellular differentiation, vitamin A is involved
in the formation and protection of epithelial tissues and mucous membranes. In this
way it has particular importance in growth, reproduction and immune response.Vitamin A is important in the resistance to disease and promotion of healing through its
effect on the immune system and epithelial integrity. In addition, it acts, along with
vitamins E and C and ␤-carotene, as a scavenger of free radicals (see Box 5.2, p. 83).
The placental transfer of vitamin A to the foetus is limited and the neonate has
low stores of the vitamin and relies on consumption of colostrum to establish adequate tissue stores.
All-trans-retinol
11-Cis-retinol
11-Cis-retinal
Dark
Rhodopsin
Opsin
Light
All-trans-retinal
Nerve impulse
Fig. 5.2 The role of vitamin A (retinol) in the visual cycle.
76
Fat-soluble vitamins
Deficiency symptoms
Ability to see in dim light depends upon the rate of resynthesis of rhodopsin; when
vitamin A is deficient, rhodopsin formation is impaired. One of the earliest symptoms of a deficiency of vitamin A in all animals is a lessened ability to see in dim
light, commonly known as ‘night blindness’.
It has long been realised that vitamin A plays an important role in combating infection, and it has been termed the ‘anti-infective vitamin’. In several species, vitamin A
deficiency has been shown to be accompanied by low levels of immunoglobulins,
although the exact function of the vitamin in the formation of these important proteins
is uncertain.
In adult cattle, a mild deficiency of vitamin A is associated with roughened hair
and scaly skin. If it is prolonged the eyes are affected, leading to excessive watering,
softening and cloudiness of the cornea and development of xerophthalmia, which is
characterised by a drying of the conjunctiva. Constriction of the optic nerve canal
may cause blindness in calves. In breeding animals a deficiency may lead to infertility,
and in pregnant animals deficiency may lead to failure of embryo growth, disrupted
organ development, abortion, short gestation, retained placenta or the production of
dead, weak or blind calves. Less severe deficiencies may result in metritis and dermatitis and calves born with low reserves of the vitamin; it is then imperative that
colostrum, rich in antibodies and vitamin A, should be given at birth, otherwise the
susceptibility of such animals to infection leads to scours and, if the deficiency is not
rectified, they frequently die of pneumonia. The National Research Council of the
United States has increased the recommended allowance for dairy cows in order to
improve the health of the mammary gland and reduce mastitis.
In practice, severe deficiency symptoms are unlikely to occur in adult animals except after prolonged deprivation. Grazing animals generally obtain more than adequate amounts of provitamin from pasture grass and normally build up liver reserves.
If cattle are fed on silage or well-preserved hay during the winter months, deficiencies are unlikely to occur. Cases of vitamin A deficiency have been reported among
cattle fed indoors on high cereal rations, and under these conditions a high vitamin
supplement is recommended.
In ewes, in addition to night blindness, severe cases of deficiency may result in
lambs being born weak or dead. A deficiency is not common in sheep, however, because of adequate dietary intakes on pasture.
In pigs, eye disorders such as xerophthalmia and blindness may occur. A deficiency in pregnant animals may result in the production of weak, blind, dead or deformed litters. In view of the apparent importance of vitamin A in preventing
reproductive disorders in pigs, it has been suggested that the retinoids may have a
role in embryo development (cell differentation, gene transcription). Alternatively,
they may regulate ovarian steroid production and influence the establishment and
maintenance of pregnancy. In less severe cases of deficiency, appetite is impaired and
growth retarded. Where pigs are reared out of doors and have access to green food,
deficiencies are unlikely to occur, except possibly during the winter. Pigs kept indoors on concentrates may not receive adequate amounts of vitamin A in the diet
and supplements may be required.
In poultry consuming a diet deficient in vitamin A, the mortality rate is usually
high. Early symptoms include retarded growth, weakness, ruffled plumage and a staggering gait. In mature birds, egg production and hatchability are reduced. Since most
concentrated foods present in the diets of poultry are low or lacking in vitamin A or
77
Chapter 5 Vitamins
its precursors, vitamin A deficiency may be a problem unless precautions are taken.
Yellow maize, dried grass or other green food, or alternatively cod- or other fish-liver
oils or vitamin A concentrate, can be added to the diet.
In horses, the signs of deficiency include the catalogue of symptoms seen in other
farm animals: night blindness, keratinisation of the skin and cornea, susceptibility to
infection and infertility.
Dogs and cats show similar symptoms. In addition dogs have ataxia and anorexia
and cats have reproductive and developmental disorders.
It has been suggested that, in addition to vitamin A, some species may have a
dietary requirement for ␤-carotene per se. The ovaries of bovine species are known
to contain high concentrations of ␤-carotene during the luteal phase – indeed, it is
an integral component of the mucosal membrane of luteal cells – and it has been
postulated that certain fertility disorders in dairy cattle, such as retarded ovulation
and early embryonic mortality, may be caused by a deficiency of the provitamin in
the diet. In sows, injections of ␤-carotene have reduced embryonic mortality and increased litter sizes. It is suggested that it influences steroidogenesis and, through its
antioxidant properties, it may protect the highly active ovarian cells from damage by
free radicals. Supplementation of the diet of dogs with ␤-carotene resulted in increased
plasma progesterone concentration.
Vitamin D
Chemical nature
A number of forms of vitamin D are known,although not all of these are naturally occurring compounds.The two most important forms are ergocalciferol (D2) and cholecalciferol (D3).The term D1 was originally suggested by earlier workers for an activated sterol,
which was found later to be impure and to consist mainly of ergocalciferol, which had already been designated D2.The result of this confusion is that in the group of D vitamins,
the term vitamin D1 has been abolished.The structures of vitamins D2 and D3 are:
CH3
CH3
CH3
CH3
CHCH
CHCH
CHCH3
H2C
HO
Vitamin D2 (ergocalciferol)
CH3
CH3
CH3
CHCH2CH2CH2CHCH3
H2C
HO
Vitamin D3 (cholecalciferol)
78
Fat-soluble vitamins
The D vitamins are insoluble in water but soluble in fats and fat solvents. The
sulphate derivative of vitamin D present in milk is a water-soluble form of the vitamin. Both D2 and D3 are more resistant to oxidation than vitamin A, D3 being more
stable than D2.
Sources
The D vitamins are limited in distribution. They rarely occur in plants except in sundried roughages and the dead leaves of growing plants. In the animal kingdom vitamin D3 occurs in small amounts in certain tissues and is abundant only in some
fishes. Halibut-liver and cod-liver oils are rich sources of vitamin D3. Egg yolk is also
a good source, but cow’s milk is normally a poor source, although summer milk
tends to be richer than winter milk. Colostrum usually contains six to ten times the
amount present in ordinary milk.
Clinical manifestations of avitaminosis D, and other vitamin deficiencies, are frequently treated by injection of the vitamin into the animal.
Provitamins
Reference has been made (p. 49) to two sterols, ergosterol and 7-dehydrocholesterol,
as being precursors of vitamins D2 and D3, respectively.The provitamins, as such, have
no vitamin value and must be converted into calciferols before they are of any use to
the animal. For this conversion it is necessary to impart a definite quantity of energy to
the sterol molecule, and this can be brought about by the ultraviolet light present in
sunlight, by artificially produced radiant energy or by certain kinds of physical treatment. Under natural conditions activation is brought about by irradiation from the
sun. The activation occurs most efficiently with light of wavelength 290–315 nm, so
that the range capable of vitamin formation is small. The amount of ultraviolet radiation that reaches the earth’s surface depends upon latitude and atmospheric conditions:
the presence of clouds, smoke and dust reduces the radiation. Ultraviolet radiation is
greater in the tropics than in the temperate regions, and the amount reaching the more
northern areas in winter may be slight. Since ultraviolet light cannot pass through
ordinary window glass, animals housed indoors receive little, if any, suitable radiation
for the production of the vitamin. Irradiation is apparently more effective in animals
with light-coloured skins. If irradiation is continued for a prolonged period, then the
vitamin may be altered to compounds that can be toxic.
The chemical transformation occurs in the skin and also in the skin secretions,
which are known to contain the precursor. Absorption of the vitamin can take place
from the skin, since deficiency can be treated successfully by rubbing cod-liver oil
into the skin.
Vitamin D requirements are often expressed in terms of international units (iu).
One iu of vitamin D is defined as the vitamin D activity of 0.025 µg of crystalline
vitamin D3.
Metabolism
Dietary vitamins D2 and D3 are absorbed from the small intestine and are transported in the blood to the liver, where they are converted into 25-hydroxycholecalciferol. The latter is then transported to the kidney, where it is converted into
1,25-dihydroxycholecalciferol, the most biologically active form of the vitamin. This
compound is then transported in the blood to the various target tissues, the intestine,
79
Chapter 5 Vitamins
Food
Skin
Cholecalciferol
7-Dehydrocholesterol
(Ultraviolet radiation)
Cholecalciferol
Liver
25-Hydroxycholecalciferol
Kidney
1,25-Dihydroxycholecalciferol
Target tissues
Fig. 5.3 Metabolic pathway showing production of the hormonally active form
of vitamin D.
bones and the eggshell gland in birds. The compound 1,25-dihydroxycholecalciferol
acts in a similar way to a steroid hormone, regulating DNA transcription in the intestinal microvilli, inducing the synthesis of specific messenger RNA (see Chapter 9),
which is responsible for the production of calcium-binding protein. This protein is involved in the absorption of calcium from the intestinal lumen. The various pathways
involved in these transformations are summarised in Fig. 5.3. Cats do not obtain vitamin D by exposure to sunlight.The natural diet of the cat contains adequate amounts
of vitamin D to meet their requirements.Their metabolism has become adapted such
that 7-dehydroxycholesterol is converted to cholesterol and is not available for
vitamin D synthesis.
The amount of 1,25-dihydroxycholecalciferol produced by the kidney is controlled by parathyroid hormone. When the level of calcium in the blood is low
(hypocalcaemia), the parathyroid gland is stimulated to secrete more parathyroid
hormone, which induces the kidney to produce more 1,25-dihydroxycholecalciferol,
which in turn enhances the intestinal absorption of calcium.
In addition to increasing intestinal absorption of calcium, 1,25-dihydroxycholecalciferol increases the absorption of phosphorus from the intestine and also enhances calcium and phosphorus reabsorption from the kidney and bone.
Recently it has been discovered that 1,25-dihydroxycholecalciferol regulates the
expression of genes and the activity of cells associated with the immune system.
Deficiency symptoms
A deficiency of vitamin D in the young animal results in rickets, a disease of growing
bone in which the deposition of calcium and phosphorus is disturbed; as a result the
bones are weak and easily broken and the legs may be bowed. In young cattle the
symptoms include swollen knees and hocks and arching of the back. In pigs the symptoms are usually enlarged joints, broken bones, stiffness of the joints and occasionally
80
Fat-soluble vitamins
paralysis.The growth rate is generally adversely affected.The term ‘rickets’ is confined
to young growing animals; in older animals vitamin D deficiency causes osteomalacia,
in which there is reabsorption of bone already laid down. Osteomalacia due to vitamin
D deficiency is not common in farm animals, although a similar condition can occur in
pregnant and lactating animals, which require increased amounts of calcium and phosphorus. Rickets and osteomalacia are not specific diseases necessarily caused by vitamin D deficiency; they can also be caused by lack of calcium or phosphorus or an
imbalance between these two elements.
In poultry, a deficiency of vitamin D causes the bones and beak to become soft
and rubbery; growth is usually retarded and the legs become weak. Egg production
is reduced and eggshell quality deteriorates. Most foods of pigs and poultry, with the
possible exception of fishmeal, contain little or no vitamin D, and the vitamin is generally supplied to these animals, if reared indoors, in the form of fish-liver oils or
synthetic preparations.
The need for supplementing the diets of cattle and sheep with vitamin D is generally not so great as that for pigs and poultry. Adult ruminants can receive adequate
amounts of the vitamin from hay in the winter months, and from irradiation while
grazing. However, since the vitamin D content of hays is extremely variable, it is possible that vitamin D supplementation may be desirable, especially with young growing
animals or pregnant animals, on winter diets. There is a considerable lack of information about the vitamin D needs of farm animals under practical conditions.
For cattle, sheep and pigs vitamins D2 and D3 have the same potency, but for
poultry vitamin D2 has only about 10 per cent of the potency of D3.
Certain foods, such as fresh green cereals and yeast, have been shown to have
rachitogenic (rickets-causing) properties for mammals, and raw liver and isolated
soya bean protein have a similar effect on poultry. In one study it was shown that in
order to overcome the rachitogenic activity of whole raw soya bean meal, a tenfold
increase in vitamin D supplement was necessary. Heating destroys the rachitogenic
activity.
Vitamin E
Chemical nature
Vitamin E is a group that includes a number of closely related active compounds.
Eight naturally occurring forms of the vitamin are known, and these can be divided
into two groups according to whether the side chain of the molecule, as shown
below, is saturated or unsaturated.
The four saturated vitamins are designated ␣-, ␤-, ␥- and ␦-tocopherol. Of these
the ␣-form is the most biologically active and most widely distributed.
CH3
CH3
CH3
H3C
O
CH2(CH2
CH2
CH
CH2)3H
HO
CH3
α-Tocopherol
81
Chapter 5 Vitamins
The ␤-, ␥- and ␦-forms have only about 45, 13 and 0.4 per cent of the activity of
the ␣-form, respectively. The unsaturated forms of the vitamin have been designated ␣-, ␤-, ␥- and ␦-tocotrienols. Of these only the ␣-form appears to have any
significant vitamin E activity, and then only about 13 per cent of its saturated
counterpart.
The ␣-tocopherol molecule has three centres where stereoisomers can occur. The
naturally occurring molecule is the D-␣-tocopherol (or RRR-␣-tocopherol) configuration and has the highest vitamin activity. Synthetic DL-␣-tocopherol acetate (also
called all racemic ␣-tocopherol acetate) is used as a vitamin E supplement and comprises all eight possible stereoisomers; only one molecule in eight is in the RRR
form. The vitamin activity of the four stereoisomers in the L forms is considerably
lower than the four that make up the D forms; in the latter the RRR form is the most
active.
Sources
Vitamin E, unlike vitamin A, is not stored in the animal body in large amounts for
any length of time and consequently a regular dietary source is important. Fortunately, the vitamin is widely distributed in foods. Green fodders are good sources
of ␣-tocopherol, young grass being a better source than mature herbage. The
leaves contain 20–30 times as much vitamin E as the stems. Losses during haymaking can be as high as 90 per cent, but losses during ensilage or artificial drying are low.
Cereal grains are also good sources of the vitamin, but the tocopherol composition varies with species.Wheat and barley grain resemble grass in containing mainly
␣-tocopherol, but maize contains, in addition to ␣-tocopherol, appreciable quantities
of ␥-tocopherol. During the storage of moist grain in silos, the vitamin E activity can
decline markedly. Reduction in the concentration of the vitamin from 9 to 1 mg/kg
DM has been reported in moist barley stored for 12 weeks.
Animal products are relatively poor sources of the vitamin, although the amount
present is related to the level of vitamin E in the diet.
The vitamin E values of foods are often stated in terms of international units, one
iu of vitamin E being defined as the specific activity of 1 mg of synthetic all-racemic
␣-tocopherol acetate. It is generally accepted that 1 mg of RRR-␣-tocopherol is
equivalent to 1.49 iu vitamin E and 1 mg RRR-␣-tocopherol acetate is equivalent to
1.36 iu vitamin E. However, recent evidence suggests that the equivalence of allracemic to RRR forms is related to species, age and the criteria used to assess them
and that it may be as high as 2 : 1.
Metabolism
Vitamin E functions in the animal mainly as a biological antioxidant; in association with the selenium-containing enzyme glutathione peroxidase and other vitamins and trace-element-containing enzymes, it protects cells against oxidative
damage caused by free radicals. Free radicals are formed during cellular metabolism and, as they are capable of damaging cell membranes, enzymes and cell
nuclear material, they must be converted into less reactive substances if the animal is to survive. This protection is particularly important in preventing oxidation
of polyunsaturated fatty acids, which function as primary constituents of subcellular membranes and precursors of prostaglandins. Oxidation of unsaturated fatty
82
Fat-soluble vitamins
acids produces hydroperoxides, which also damage cell tissues, and more lipid
free radicals, so that prevention of such oxidation is of vital importance in maintaining the health of the living animal. The animal has complementary methods
of protecting itself against oxidative damage: scavenging of radicals by vitamin E
and destruction of any peroxides formed by glutathione peroxidase (see
Box 5.2).
BOX 5.2 Free radicals and antioxidants
Antioxidants are required to protect the animal’s cells from damage due to the presence of free radicals. These are highly reactive molecules containing one or more unpaired electrons and can exist
independently (e.g. superoxide, O*2 -, and hydroxyl, OH*). Their high reactivity is a result of their
trying to lose or gain an electron to achieve stability.Within cells hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) can easily break down, especially in the presence of transition ions (e.g. Fe2+), to produce the hydroxyl radical, which is the most reactive and damaging of the free radicals:
H2O2 + Fe2+ → OH* + OH- + Fe3+
Free radicals are generated during normal cellular metabolism owing to leakage from the electron transport chain in mitochondria and leakage from peroxidation of polyunsaturated fatty acids
in the pathway of conversion of arachidonic acid to prostaglandins and related compounds. Also
O2*- plays an essential role in the extracellular killing of microorganisms by activated phagocytes,
and activation of this system can lead to further leakage.
All classes of biological molecules are vulnerable to free radical damage, but especially lipids,
proteins and DNA. Cell membranes are an important target because of the enzyme systems contained within them. Lipids are the most susceptible; oxidative destruction of polyunsaturated fatty
acids can be extremely damaging, since it proceeds as a self-perpetuating chain reaction. The more
active cells, such as muscle cells, are at greatest risk of damage because they depend on the utilisation of lipids as energy sources.
To maintain cell integrity the animal’s cells require protection mechanisms and these are provided by the antioxidant system, which involves a group of vitamins and enzymes containing trace
elements working in series.The initial line of defence is by the enzymes superoxide dismutase (containing copper), glutathione peroxidases (containing selenium) and catalase. Superoxide dismutase
eliminates superoxide radicals formed in the cell and prevents the reaction of the radical with biological membranes or their participation in the production of more powerful radicals. Glutathione
peroxidase detoxifies lipid hydroperoxides that are formed in the membrane during lipid peroxidation. Catalase can also break down hydrogen peroxide.
If large amounts of radicals are produced the enzyme systems will be insufficient to prevent
damage and the second antioxidant system is brought into action. Antioxidants break the chain reaction by scavenging peroxyl radicals and thus interfere with the propagation steps in the lipid peroxidation process. Vitamin E is the main antioxidant but the carotenoids, vitamin A and vitamin C
are also involved. In mammalian cells vitamin E is located in the mitochondria and endothelial
reticulum. It donates a hydrogen atom to the free radical to form a stable molecule, thereby breaking the chain. The amount of vitamin E in the cell membranes is low and it must be regenerated so
(Continued)
83
Chapter 5 Vitamins
NAD(P)H
ROOH,
ROH
α-Tocopheroxyl
radical
TRXox
GSSG
Vitamin E
cycle
Thiol cycle
α-Tocopherol
Reductases
NAD(P)
Ascorbate
TRXred
GSH
Vitamin C
cycle
ROO•, RO•
PUFA
Semi-ascorbyl
radical
Peroxide and other
radicals
Dehydroascorbate
Fig. 5.4 The regeneration of vitamin E.
After Rooke J A, Robinson J J and Arthur J R 2004 Journal of Agricultural Science 142: 253–62.
that there is sufficient to act against other radicals. The regeneration is carried out by reaction with
vitamin C and the ascorbate radical in turn is reduced by NADH-dependent enzymes (Fig. 5.4). It
has been reported that vitamin C also acts as an antioxidant in extracellular fluid, where it operates
as a scavenger preventing the initiation of lipid peroxidation. It contributes up to one-quarter of the
total antioxidant activity in plasma.
Vitamin E also plays an important role in the development and function of the
immune system. In recognition of this the National Research Council requirements
for dairy cows have been increased to reduce the incidence of mastitis. In studies
with several species, supplementation of diets with the vitamin provided some protection against infection with pathogenic organisms.
Recent research has indicated that vitamin E is also involved in the regulation of
cell signalling and gene expression.
Like vitamin A, it was thought that the transfer of vitamin E across the placenta
was limited, with the neonate relying on colostrum to meet its requirements. More
recent evidence in sheep indicates that placental transfer does occur, with increased
muscle and brain concentrations in lambs born from ewes fed higher levels.
Nonetheless, colostrum is a very important source of vitamin E for the new born.
84
Fat-soluble vitamins
Deficiency symptoms
The most frequent and, from a diagnostic point of view, the most important manifestation of vitamin E deficiency in farm animals is muscle degeneration (myopathy).
Nutritional myopathy, also known as muscular dystrophy, frequently occurs in cattle,
particularly calves, when they are turned out on to spring pasture. It is associated
with low vitamin E and selenium intakes during the in-wintering period and possibly the relatively high concentration of polyunsaturated fatty acids in the young
grass lipids. The requirement for the vitamin increases with increasing concentrations of polyunsaturated fatty acids in the diet. The myopathy primarily affects the
skeletal muscles and the affected animals have weak leg muscles, a condition manifested by difficulty in standing and, after standing, a trembling and staggering gait.
Eventually, the animals are unable to rise, and weakness of the neck muscles prevents them from raising the head. A popular descriptive name for this condition is
‘white muscle disease’, owing to the presence of pale patches or white streaks in the
muscles.The heart muscle may also be affected and death may result. Serum creatine
phosphokinase and glutamic oxaloacetic transaminase levels are elevated in animals
deficient in vitamin E.
Nutritional myopathy also occurs in lambs, with similar symptoms to those of
calves. The condition is frequently referred to as ‘stiff lamb disease’. Dietary supplements of vitamin E given to pregnant ewes have resulted in increased birth weight
and improved vigour and viability of neonatal lambs through quicker times to stand
and suck. The National Research Council has recently increased the dietary recommendation for vitamin E several fold owing to its beneficial effects on prolonging the
shelf life of lamb at retail.
In pigs, the two main diseases associated with vitamin E and selenium deficiency
are myopathy and cardiac disease. Nutritional myopathy affects in particular young
fast-growing pigs, but it may occur at any age.The pigs demonstrate an uncoordinated
staggering gait or are unable to rise. In contrast to other animals, it is the pig’s heart
muscle that is more often affected. Sudden cardiac failure occurs; on post-mortem
examination, large amounts of fluid are found around the heart and lungs and the
lesions of the cardiac muscles are seen as haemorrhagic and pale areas.This condition
is commonly known as ‘mulberry heart disease’. Sometimes the liver is also affected
and it becomes enlarged and mottled. Supplemental vitamin E has improved litter
size in pigs, probably through its antioxidant properties protecting arachidonic acid
and maintaining the functional integrity of the reproductive organs.
Vitamin E deficiency in chicks may lead to a number of distinct diseases: myopathy, encephalomalacia and exudative diathesis. In nutritional myopathy the main
muscles affected are the pectorals, although the leg muscles also may be involved.
Nutritional encephalomalacia, or ‘crazy chick disease’, is a condition in which the
chick is unable to walk or stand and is accompanied by haemorrhages and necrosis
of brain cells. Exudative diathesis is a vascular disease of chicks characterised by a
generalised oedema of the subcutaneous fatty tissues, associated with an abnormal
permeability of the capillary walls. Both selenium and vitamin E appear to be involved in nutritional myopathy and in exudative diathesis, but the element does not
seem to be important in nutritional encephalomacia. It should be stressed that selenium itself is a very toxic element and care is required in its use as a dietary additive.
The toxic nature of selenium is discussed in Chapter 7.
In horses, vitamin E deficiency results in the previously mentioned problems, i.e.
lameness and muscle rigidity (‘tying up’) associated with skeletal and heart muscles.
85
Chapter 5 Vitamins
The red blood cells become fragile and the release of myoglobin from damaged muscle cells gives rise to coffee-coloured urine.
Vitamin K
Vitamin K was discovered in 1935 to be an essential factor in the prevention of
haemorrhagic symptoms in chicks.The discovery was made by a group of Danish scientists, who gave the name ‘koagulation factor’ to the vitamin, which became shortened to the K factor and eventually to vitamin K.
Chemical nature
A number of forms of vitamin K are known to exist. All compounds exhibiting vitamin K activity possess a 2-methyl-1,4-naphthoquinone ring (menadione), which
animals are unable to synthesise but plants and bacteria can.
O
CH3
O
Menadione (2-methyl-1,4-naphthoquinone)
The form of the vitamin present in plants is 2-methyl-3-phytyl-1,4-naphthoquinone, generally referred to as phylloquinone or vitamin K1.
The compound originally isolated from putrified fishmeal and designated vitamin
K2 is now known to be only one of a series of K vitamins with unsaturated side
chains synthesised by bacteria and referred to as menaquinones. The predominant
vitamins of the menaquinone series contain six to ten isoprenoid (CH2:CCH3:
CH:CH2) side-chain units. Menadione is the synthetic form of the vitamin and is
designated as vitamin K3.
Vitamins K are relatively stable at ordinary temperatures but are rapidly destroyed on exposure to sunlight.
Sources
Phylloquinone is present in most green leafy materials, with lucerne, cabbage and
kale being good sources. The amounts present in foods of animal origin are usually
related to the diet, but egg yolk, liver and fishmeal are generally good sources.
Menaquinones are synthesised by bacteria in the digestive tract of animals.
Metabolism
Vitamin K is necessary for the synthesis of prothrombin in the liver. In the blood-clotting
process, prothrombin is the inactive precursor of thrombin, an enzyme that converts
the protein fibrinogen in blood plasma into fibrin, the insoluble fibrous protein that
holds blood clots together. Prothrombin normally must bind to calcium ions before it
can be activated. If the supply of vitamin K is inadequate, then the prothrombin molecule is deficient in ␥-carboxyglutamic acid, a specific amino acid responsible for
86
The vitamin B complex
calcium binding. Proteins containing ␥-carboxyglutamic acid, dependent on vitamin K
for their formation, are also present in bone, kidney and other tissues.
Deficiency symptoms
Symptoms of vitamin K deficiency have not been reported in ruminants, horses and
pigs under normal conditions, and it is generally considered that bacterial synthesis
in the digestive tract supplies sufficient vitamin for the animal’s needs. A number of
microorganisms are known to synthesise vitamin K, including Escherichia coli. Medicines that affect the bacteria in the gut may depress the production of vitamin K. A
disease of cattle called ‘sweet clover disease’ is associated with vitamin K. Sweet
clover (Melilotus albus) naturally contains compounds called coumarins which,
when the crop is preserved as hay or silage, may be converted by a variety of fungi,
such as the Aspergillus species, to dicoumarol. This compound lowers the prothrombin content of the blood and thereby impairs the blood-clotting process. The disease
can be overcome by administering vitamin K to the animals. For this reason dicoumarol is sometimes referred to as an ‘anti-vitamin’.
The symptoms of vitamin K deficiency in chicks are anaemia and a delayed clotting
time of the blood; birds are easily injured and may bleed to death. It is doubtful
whether, in birds, microbially synthesised vitamin K is available by direct absorption
from the digestive tract, because the site of its formation is too distal to permit absorption of adequate amounts except by ingestion of faecal material (coprophagy).
5.3
THE VITAMIN B COMPLEX
The vitamins included under this heading are all soluble in water and most of them
are components of coenzymes (see Table 5.3). Although the mechanism of action in
this role is known, the connection between the observed deficiency symptoms and
the failure of the metabolic pathways is not always clear.
Unlike the fat-soluble vitamins, members of the vitamin B complex, with the exception of cyanocobalamin, are not stored in the tissues in appreciable amounts and a
Table 5.3 Some coenzymes and enzyme prosthetic groups involving the B vitamins
Vitamin
Coenzyme or prosthetic group
Enzyme or other function
Thiamin
Riboflavin
Riboflavin
Oxidative decarboxylation
Hydrogen carrier
Hydrogen carrier
Pyridoxine
Thiamin pyrophosphate (TPP)
Flavin mononucleotide (FMN)
Flavin adenine dinucleotide
(FAD)
Nicotinamide adenine
dinucleotide (NAD)
Nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide
phosphate (NADP)
Pyridoxal phosphate
Pantothenic acid
Folic acid
Biotin
Cyanocobalamin
Coenzyme A (CoA)
Tetrahydrofolic acid
Biotin
Methylcobalamin
Nicotinamide
Nicotinamide
Hydrogen carrier
Hydrogen carrier
Transaminases,
decarboxylases
Acyl transfer
One carbon transfer
Carbon dioxide transfer
Isomerases, dehydrases
87
Chapter 5 Vitamins
regular exogenous supply is essential. In ruminants, all the vitamins in this group can
be synthesised by microbial action in the rumen and generally this will provide satisfactory amounts for normal metabolism in the host and secretion of adequate quantities into milk. For example, it has been estimated that the amount of thiamin
synthesised in the rumen is equal to the thiamin requirement. However, under certain
conditions, deficiencies of thiamin and cyanocobalamin can occur in ruminants. In
horses, the B vitamins synthesised by the microbial population of the gut plus those
vitamins occurring in the food can meet the requirements of most adult animals.
Thiamin
Chemical nature
Thiamin (vitamin B1) is a complex nitrogenous base containing a pyrimidine ring
joined to a thiazole ring. Because of the presence of a hydroxyl group at the end of
the side chain, thiamin can form esters.The main form of thiamin in animal tissues is
the diphosphate ester, commonly known as thiamin pyrophosphate (TPP). The vitamin is very soluble in water and is fairly stable in mildly acidic solution but readily
decomposes in neutral solutions.
H3C
N
N
S
NH2
CH2
N
CH2.CH2.OH
CH3
Cl
Thiamin chloride
Sources
Thiamin is widely distributed in foods. It is concentrated in the outer layers of seeds,
the germ, and in the growing areas of roots, leaves and shoots. Fermentation products, such as brewer’s yeast, are rich sources.Animal products rich in thiamin include
egg yolk, liver, kidney and pork muscle. The synthetic vitamin is available, usually
marketed as the hydrochloride.
Metabolism
Thiamin pyrophosphate (or thiamin diphosphate) is a coenzyme involved in (1) the
oxidative decarboxylation of pyruvate to acetyl coenzyme A (enzyme: pyruvate
dehydrogenase), (2) the oxidative decarboxylation of ␣-ketoglutarate to succinyl
coenzyme A (␣-ketoglutarate dehydrogenase) in the tricarboxylic acid cycle, (3) the
pentose phosphate pathway (transketolase) and (4) the synthesis of branched-chain
amino acids such as valine (branched-chain ketoacid dehydrogenase) in bacteria,
yeasts and plants.
Thiamin triphosphate is involved in the activation of the chloride ion channel in
the membranes of nerves, possibly by phosphorylation of the channel protein.
Deficiency symptoms
Early signs of thiamin deficiency in most species include loss of appetite, emaciation,
muscular weakness and a progressive dysfunction of the nervous system. In pigs, appetite and growth are adversely affected and the animals may vomit and have respiratory troubles.
88
The vitamin B complex
Chicks reared on thiamin-deficient diets have poor appetites and consequently
are emaciated.After about 10 days they develop polyneuritis, which is characterised
by head retraction, nerve degeneration and paralysis.
Many of these deficiency conditions in animals can be explained in terms of the
role of TPP in the oxidative decarboxylation of pyruvic acid. On a thiamin-deficient
diet animals accumulate pyruvic acid and its reduction product lactic acid in their tissues, which leads to muscular weakness. Nerve cells are particularly dependent on
the utilisation of carbohydrate and for this reason a deficiency of the vitamin has a
particularly serious effect on nervous tissue. Since acetyl coenzyme A is an important metabolite in the synthesis of fatty acids (see p. 220), lipogenesis is reduced.The
pentose phosphate pathway is also impaired by a deficiency of thiamin but there is
little effect on the activity of the citric acid cycle.
Because thiamin is fairly widely distributed in foods and, in particular, because
cereal grains are rich sources of the vitamin, pigs and poultry are in practice unlikely
to suffer from thiamin deficiency.
In ruminants, microbial synthesis of the vitamin in the digestive tract, together
with that present in the diet, will normally provide adequate amounts of thiamin to
satisfy the animal’s requirements. However, under certain conditions, bacterial thiaminases can be produced in the rumen, which destroy the vitamin, thereby causing
the deficiency condition known as cerebrocortical necrosis (CCN). This condition is
characterised by circling movements, head pressing, blindness and muscular tremors.
There are two types of thiaminase: one splits the molecule in two and the other substitutes an N-containing ring for the thiazole ring.The resulting compound is absorbed
and blocks the reactions involving thiamin. It has been suggested that lactic acidosis
caused by feeding with rapidly fermentable foods may be an important factor in the
production of thiaminases. Young animals appear to be the most susceptible.
Thiaminase is present in bracken (Pteridium aquilinum), and thiamin deficiency
symptoms have been reported in horses consuming this material. Raw fish also contains the enzyme, which destroys the thiamin in foods with which the fish is mixed.
The activity of the thiaminase is, however, destroyed by cooking.
Riboflavin
Chemical nature
Riboflavin (vitamin B2) consists of a dimethyl-isoalloxazine nucleus combined with
ribitol. Its structure is shown here:
HO
CH2
CH3
N
CH3
N
OH OH
C
C
H
H
C
CH2OH
H
O
N
NH
O
Riboflavin
89
Chapter 5 Vitamins
It is a yellow crystalline compound, which has a yellowish-green fluorescence in
aqueous solution. Riboflavin is only sparingly soluble in water; it is heat-stable in
acid or neutral solutions, but it is destroyed by alkali. It is unstable to light, particularly ultraviolet light.
Sources
Riboflavin occurs in all biological materials. The vitamin can be synthesised by all
green plants, yeasts, fungi and most bacteria, although the lactobacilli are a notable
exception and require an exogenous source. Rich sources are yeast, liver, milk (especially whey) and green leafy crops. Cereal grains are poor sources.
Metabolism
Riboflavin is an important constituent of the flavoproteins. The prosthetic group of
these compound proteins contains riboflavin in the form of the phosphate (flavin
mononucleotide, FMN) or in a more complex form as flavin adenine dinucleotide
(FAD). There are several flavoproteins that function in the animal body; they
are all concerned with chemical reactions involving the transport of hydrogen.
Further details of the importance of flavoproteins in carbohydrate and amino
acid metabolism are discussed in Chapter 9. Flavin adenine dinucleotide plays a
role in the oxidative phosphorylation system (see Fig. 9.2 on p. 196) and forms the
prosthetic group of the enzyme succinic dehydrogenase, which converts succinic
acid to fumaric acid in the citric acid cycle. It is also the coenzyme for acyl-CoA
dehydrogenase.
Deficiency symptoms
In pigs, deficiency symptoms include poor appetite, with consequent retardation in
growth, vomiting, skin eruptions and eye abnormalities. Riboflavin is essential in the
diet of sows to maintain normal oestrus activity and prevent premature parturition.
Chicks reared on a riboflavin-deficient diet grow slowly and develop ‘curled toe
paralysis’, a specific symptom caused by peripheral nerve degeneration, in which the
chicks walk on their hocks with the toes curled inwards. In breeding hens, a deficiency reduces hatchability. Embryonic abnormalities occur, including the characteristic ‘clubbed down’ condition in which the down feather continues to grow inside
the follicle, resulting in a coiled feather.
The vitamin is synthesised in the rumen and deficiencies in animals with functional rumens are unlikely to occur. However, riboflavin deficiencies have been
demonstrated in young calves and lambs. Symptoms include loss of appetite, diarrhoea and lesions in the corners of the mouth.
Nicotinamide
Chemical nature
Another member of the B vitamin complex, nicotinamide is the amide derivative of
nicotinic acid (pyridine 3-carboxylic acid) and is the form in which it functions in the
90
The vitamin B complex
body.The relationship between nicotinic acid, nicotinamide and the amino acid tryptophan, which can act as a precursor, is shown here:
COOH
CONH2
CH2
CH
COOH
NH2
N
Nicotinic acid
N
Nicotinamide
N
H
Tryptophan
Nicotinamide is a stable vitamin and is not easily destroyed by heat, acids, alkalis
or oxidation.
Sources
Nicotinic acid can be synthesised from tryptophan in the body tissues; since animals can convert the acid to the amide-containing coenzyme (see below), it follows that if the diet is adequately supplied with proteins rich in tryptophan, then
the dietary requirement for the vitamin itself should be low. However, the efficiency of conversion of tryptophan into nicotinamide is poor. Studies with chicks
have shown that the amino acid was converted into the vitamin at a ratio of only
45 : 1 on a weight basis and with some foods, such as soya bean meal, the conversion ratio may be even greater. Because of this it is generally considered that an
exogenous source of the vitamin is also necessary. Although cats possess the
enzymes for the conversion of tryptophan to nicotinic acid, the activity of an
enzyme in a competing pathway is very high and no nicotinic acid is synthesised.
Cats do not need to produce nicotinic acid because their natural diet is well
supplied with NAD and NADH. Rich sources of the vitamin are liver, yeast,
groundnut and sunflower meals. Although cereal grains contain the vitamin, much
of it is present in a bound form that is not readily available to pigs and poultry.
Milk and eggs are almost devoid of the vitamin, although they contain the precursor tryptophan.
Metabolism
Nicotinamide functions in the animal body as the active group of two important
coenzymes: nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD) and nicotinamide adenine
dinucleotide phosphate (NADP).These coenzymes are involved in the mechanism of
hydrogen transfer in living cells (see Chapter 9): NAD is involved in the oxidative
phosphorylation system, the tricyclic acid (TCA) cycle and the metabolism of many
molecules, including pyruvate, acetate, ␤-hydroxy-butyrate, glycerol, fatty acids and
glutamate; NADPH is the hydrogen acceptor in the pentose phosphate pathway.
Deficiency symptoms
In pigs, deficiency symptoms include poor growth, anorexia, enteritis, vomiting
and dermatitis. In fowls, a deficiency of the vitamin causes bone disorders,
91
Chapter 5 Vitamins
feathering abnormalities, and inflammation of the mouth and upper part of the
oesophagus.
Deficiency symptoms are particularly likely in pigs and poultry if diets with a
high maize content are used, since maize contains very little of the vitamin or of
tryptophan.
It has been suggested that through its effects on (1) rumen fermentation (some
experiments have shown increased microbial growth and increased propionic acid
production) and (2) cell metabolism (increased utilisation of carbohydrate and reduced lipid mobilisation), nicotinic acid may be a useful supplement to dairy cows,
particularly in situations of subclinical ketosis. However, the experimental evidence
is not consistent. Nicotinic acid does not always give positive responses in the rumen
and increases in blood concentrations were not observed in all experiments. Current
recommendations do not advocate the supplementation of dairy cow diets in order
to increase milk yield and composition.
Vitamin B6
Chemical nature
The vitamin exists in three forms, which are interconvertible in the body tissues.The
parent substance is known as pyridoxine, the corresponding aldehyde derivative as
pyridoxal and the amine as pyridoxamine. The term vitamin B6 is generally used to
describe all three forms.
CH2OH
CHO
CH2OH
HO
N
H3C
Pyridoxine
CH2OH
HO
H 3C
CH2NH2
N
Pyridoxal
CH2OH
HO
H3C
N
Pyridoxamine
The amine and aldehyde derivatives are less stable than pyridoxine and are
destroyed by heat.
Sources
The vitamin is present in plants as pyridoxine, whereas animal products may also
contain pyridoxal and pyridoxamine. Pyridoxine and its derivatives are widely distributed: yeast, pulses, cereal grains, liver and milk are rich sources.
Metabolism
Of the three related compounds, the most actively functioning is pyridoxal in the
form of the phosphate. Pyridoxal phosphate plays a central role as a coenzyme in
the reactions by which a cell transforms nutrient amino acids into mixtures of
amino acids and other nitrogenous compounds required for its own metabolism.
92
The vitamin B complex
These reactions involve the activities of transaminases and decarboxylases (see
p. 210), and over 50 pyridoxal phosphate-dependent enzymes have been identified.
In transamination, pyridoxal phosphate accepts the ␣-amino group of the amino
acid to form pyridoxamine phosphate and a keto acid. The amino group of pyridoxamine phosphate can be transferred to another keto acid, regenerating pyridoxal phosphate. The vitamin is believed to play a role in the absorption of amino
acids from the intestine.
Deficiency symptoms
Because of the numerous enzymes requiring pyridoxal phosphate, a large variety of
biochemical lesions are associated with vitamin B6 deficiency. These lesions are concerned primarily with amino acid metabolism, and a deficiency affects the animal’s
growth rate. Convulsions may also occur, possibly because a reduction in the activity
of glutamic acid decarboxylase results in an accumulation of glutamic acid. In addition, pigs reduce their food intake and may develop anaemia. Chicks on a deficient
diet show jerky movements; in adult birds, hatchability and egg production are adversely affected. In practice, vitamin B6 deficiency is unlikely to occur in farm animals because of the vitamin’s wide distribution.
Pantothenic acid
Chemical nature
Pantothenic acid, another member of the vitamin B complex, is an amide of pantoic
acid and ␤-alanine and has the following formula:
CH3 OH
HOCH2
C
CH
CONHCH2CH2COOH
CH3
Pantothenic acid
Sources
The vitamin is widely distributed; indeed, the name is derived from the Greek
pantothen, ‘from everywhere’, indicating its ubiquitous distribution. Rich sources are
liver, egg yolk, groundnuts, peas, yeast and molasses. Cereal grains and potatoes are
also good sources of the vitamin. The free acid is unstable. The synthetically prepared
calcium pantothenate is the commonest product used commercially.
Metabolism
Pantothenic acid is a constituent of coenzyme A, which is the important coenzyme
in fatty acid oxidation, acetate metabolism, and cholesterol and steroid synthesis. It
forms the prosthetic group of acyl carrier protein in fatty acid synthesis. Chemically,
93
Chapter 5 Vitamins
coenzyme A is 3-phospho-adenosine-5-diphospho-pantotheine. The importance of
this coenzyme in metabolism is discussed in Chapter 9.
NH2
N
O
CH
O
N
N
CH2
O
P
OH
H
H
H
OH
O
HO
P
O
O
P
OH
H
C
H
H3C
C
CH3
HO
C
H
C
O
O
OH
O
H
N
H
C
H
H
C
H
C
O
H
N
H
C
H
H
C
H
S
H
Pantotheine
N
Coenzyme A
Deficiency symptoms
Deficiency of pantothenic acid in pigs causes slow growth, diarrhoea, loss of hair,
scaliness of the skin and a characteristic ‘goose-stepping’ gait; in severe cases,
animals are unable to stand. In the chick, growth is retarded and dermatitis occurs.
In mature birds, hatchability is reduced. Pantothenic acid, like all the B complex
vitamins, can be synthesised by rumen microorganisms; Escherichia coli, for example, is known to produce this vitamin. Pantothenic acid deficiencies are considered to be rare in practice because of the wide distribution of the vitamin,
although deficiency symptoms have been reported in commercial herds of
Landrace pigs.
Folic acid
Chemical nature
This B complex vitamin was first discovered in the 1930s when it was found that a
certain type of anaemia in human beings could be cured by treatment with yeast
94
The vitamin B complex
or liver extracts. The active component in the extracts, which was also shown to be
essential for the growth of chicks, was found to be present in large quantities in
green leaves and was named folic acid (Latin folium, a leaf).
The chemical name for folic acid is pteroylmonoglutamic acid. It is made up of
three moieties: p-aminobenzoic acid, glutamic acid and a pteridine nucleus.
NH2
N
N
COOH
N
CH2
NH
CONHCHCH2CH2COOH
N
OH
Pteroylmonoglutamic acid
Several active derivatives of the vitamin are known to occur, these containing up
to 11 glutamate residues in the molecule. The monoglutamate form is readily absorbed from the digestive tract but the polyglutamates must be degraded by enzymes to the monoglutamate form before they can be absorbed.
Sources
Folic acid is widely distributed in nature; green leafy materials, cereals and extracted oilseed meals are good sources of the vitamin. Folic acid is reasonably stable
in foods stored under dry conditions, but it is readily degraded by moisture, particularly at high temperatures. It is also destroyed by ultraviolet light.
Metabolism
After absorption into the cell, folic acid is converted into tetrahydrofolic acid, which
functions as a coenzyme in the mobilisation and utilisation of single-carbon groups
(e.g. formyl, methyl) that are added to, or removed from, such metabolites as histidine, serine, glycine, methionine and purines. It is involved in the synthesis of RNA,
DNA and neurotransmitters.
Deficiency symptoms
A variety of deficiency symptoms in chicks and young turkeys have been reported, including poor growth, anaemia, poor bone development and poor egg
hatchability. Folic acid deficiency symptoms rarely occur in other farm animals because of synthesis by intestinal bacteria. Injections of folic acid in sows has increased litter size. In one experiment, dietary supplements resulted in higher foetal
survival, thought to be related to prostaglandin activity, but the response has not
been substantiated in other experiments, possibly because of the variable content
of folic acid in foods. Its role in nucleic acid metabolism concurs with the view
that supplements might be beneficial at times of growth and differentiation of embryonic tissue.
95
Chapter 5 Vitamins
Biotin
Chemical nature
A part of the vitamin B complex, biotin is chemically 2-keto-3,4-imidazolido-2tetrahydrothiophene-n-valeric acid. Its structure is:
O
C
HN
NH
HC
CH
H2C
CH
(CH2)4
COOH
S
Biotin
Sources
Biotin is widely distributed in foods: liver, milk, yeast, oilseeds and vegetables are rich
sources. However, in some foods, much of the bound vitamin may not be released during digestion and hence may be unavailable. Studies with chicks and pigs have shown
that the availability of biotin in barley and wheat is very low, whereas the biotin in
maize and certain oilseed meals, such as soya bean meal, is completely available.
Metabolism
Biotin serves as the prosthetic group of several enzymes that catalyse the transfer of
carbon dioxide from one substrate to another. In animals there are three biotindependent enzymes of particular importance: pyruvate carboxylase (carbohydrate
synthesis from lactate), acetyl coenzyme A carboxylase (fatty acid synthesis) and
propionyl coenzyme A carboxylase (the pathway of conversion of propionate to
succinyl-CoA). The specific role of these enzymes in metabolism is discussed in
Chapter 9.
Deficiency symptoms
In pigs, biotin deficiency causes foot lesions, alopecia (hair loss) and dry scaly skin.
In growing pigs, both growth rate and food utilisation are adversely affected. In
breeding sows, a deficiency of the vitamin can adversely influence reproductive performance.
In poultry, biotin deficiency causes reduced growth, dermatitis, leg bone abnormalities, cracked feet, poor feathering, and fatty liver and kidney syndrome (FLKS).This last
condition, which mainly affects 2- to 5-week-old chicks, is characterised by a lethargic
state with death frequently following within a few hours. On autopsy, the liver and
kidneys, which are pale and swollen, contain abnormal depositions of lipid.
Although ruminants and horses do not have a requirement for dietary biotin,
microbial production in the gut normally being adequate, feeding biotin has
improved hoof structure and strength.
Biotin deficiency can be induced by giving animals avidin, a protein present in the
raw white of eggs, which combines with the vitamin and prevents its absorption
from the intestine. Certain bacteria of the Streptomyces spp. that are present in soil
96
The vitamin B complex
and manure produce streptavidin and stravidin, which have a similar action to the
egg white protein. Heating inactivates these antagonist proteins.
Choline
Chemical nature
The chemical structure of choline is:
CH3
CH3
+
N
CH2CH2OH
CH3
Choline
Sources
Green leafy materials, yeast, egg yolk and cereals are rich sources of choline.
Metabolism
Unlike the other B vitamins, choline is not a metabolic catalyst but forms an essential structural component of body tissues. It is a component of lecithins, which play
a vital role in cellular structure and activity. It also plays an important part in lipid
metabolism in the liver, where it converts excess fat into lecithin or increases the utilisation of fatty acids, thereby preventing the accumulation of fat in the liver. Choline
is a component of acetylcholine, which is responsible for the transmission of nerve
impulses. Finally, choline serves as a donor of methyl groups in transmethylation
reactions that involve folic acid or vitamin B12. Although other compounds, such as
methionine and betaine, can also act as methyl donors, they cannot replace choline
in its other functions.
Choline can be synthesised in the liver from methionine; the exogenous requirement for this vitamin is therefore influenced by the level of methionine in the diet.
Deficiency symptoms
Deficiency symptoms, including slow growth and fatty infiltration of the liver, have
been produced in chicks and pigs. Choline is also concerned with the prevention of
perosis or slipped tendon in chicks.The choline requirement of animals is unusually
large for a vitamin, but in spite of this, deficiency symptoms are not common in
farm animals because of its wide distribution and its high concentrations in foods,
and because it can be readily derived from methionine.
Vitamin B12
Chemical nature
Vitamin B12 has the most complex structure of all the vitamins.The basic unit is a corrin nucleus, which consists of a ring structure comprising four five-membered rings
containing nitrogen. In the active centre of the nucleus is a cobalt atom.A cyano group
is usually attached to the cobalt as an artefact of isolation and, as this is the most stable form of the vitamin, it is the form in which the vitamin is commercially produced.
97
Chapter 5 Vitamins
CONH2
CH2
CH2
H
CH3
CH3
CH2.CONH2
NH2.CO.CH2
H3C
A
B
CN
N
H3C
CH2.CH2.CONH2
N
Co
N
N
D
C
NH2.CO.CH2
CH3
CH3
CO.CH2.CH2
CH3
CH3
CH2.CH2.CONH2
NH
CH2
CH.CH3
O
N
CH3
N
CH3
O
P
O
H
O
H
O
C
C
H
H
C
H2COH
CH
O
Vitamin B12 (cyanocobalamin)
In the animal, the cyanide ion is replaced by a variety of ions, e.g. hydroxyl
(hydroxocobalamin), methyl (methylcobalamin) and 5-deoxyadenosyl (5-deoxyadenosylcobalamin), the last two forms acting as coenzymes in animal metabolism.
Sources
Vitamin B12 is considered to be synthesised exclusively by microorganisms and its presence in foods is thought to be ultimately of microbial origin.The main natural sources
of the vitamin are foods of animal origin, liver being a particularly rich source. Its limited occurrence in higher plants is still controversial, since many think that its presence
in trace amounts may result from contamination with bacteria or insect remains.
Metabolism
Before vitamin B12 can be absorbed from the intestine it must be bound to a highly
specific glycoprotein, termed the intrinsic factor, which is secreted by the gastric mucosa. In humans, the intrinsic factor may be lacking, which leads to poor absorption
of the vitamin and results in a condition known as pernicious anaemia.
The coenzymic forms of vitamin B12 function in several important enzyme systems. These include isomerases, dehydrases and enzymes involved in the biosynthesis
98
Vitamin C
of methionine from homocysteine. Of special interest in ruminant nutrition is the role
of vitamin B12 in the metabolism of propionic acid into succinic acid. In this pathway,
the vitamin is necessary for the conversion of methylmalonyl coenzyme A into succinyl coenzyme A (see p. 203).
Deficiency symptoms
Adult animals are generally less affected by a vitamin B12 deficiency than are young
growing animals, in which growth is severely retarded and mortality high.
In poultry, in addition to the effect on growth, feathering is poor and kidney damage may occur. Hens deprived of the vitamin remain healthy, but hatchability is
adversely affected.
On vitamin B12-deficient diets, baby pigs grow poorly and show lack of coordination of the hind legs. In older pigs, dermatitis, a rough coat and suboptimal growth
result. Intestinal synthesis of the vitamin occurs in pigs and poultry. Organisms that
synthesise vitamin B12 have been isolated from poultry excreta; this fact has an important practical bearing on poultry housed with access to litter, where a majority, if
not all, of the vitamin requirements can be obtained from the litter.
Vitamin B12 and a number of biologically inactive vitamin B12 analogues are synthesised by microorganisms in the rumen and, in spite of poor absorption of the vitamin
from the intestine, the ruminant normally obtains an adequate amount of the vitamin
from this source. However, if levels of cobalt in the diet are low, a deficiency of the vitamin can arise and cause reduced appetite, emaciation and anaemia (see p. 125). If cobalt
levels are adequate, then except with very young ruminant animals, a dietary source of
the vitamin is not essential. Horses also are supplied with sufficient B12 from microbial
fermentation when sufficient cobalt is supplied. Parasitised horses have responded to
vitamin B12 supplementation, presumably as a result of impaired digestive activity.
Other growth factors included in the vitamin B complex
A number of other chemical substances of an organic nature have been included in
the vitamin B complex.These include inositol, orotic acid, lipoic acid, rutin, carnitine
and pangamic acid, but it is doubtful whether these compounds have much practical
significance in the nutrition of farm animals.
5.4
VITAMIN C
Chemical nature
Vitamin C is chemically known as L-ascorbic acid and has the following formula:
O
C
HO
C
HO
C
H
C
HO
C
O
H
CH2OH
L-Ascorbic
acid
99
Chapter 5 Vitamins
The vitamin is a colourless, crystalline, water-soluble compound with acidic and
strong reducing properties. It is heat-stable in acid solution but is readily decomposed in the presence of alkali. The destruction of the vitamin is accelerated by
exposure to light.
Sources
Well-known sources of this vitamin are citrus fruits and green leafy vegetables.
Synthetic ascorbic acid is available commercially.
Metabolism
Ascorbic acid plays an important part in various oxidation–reduction mechanisms in
living cells.The vitamin is necessary for the maintenance of normal collagen metabolism. It also plays an important role in the transport of iron ions from transferrin,
found in the plasma, to ferritin, which acts as a store of iron in the bone marrow, liver
and spleen. As an antioxidant, ascorbic acid works in conjunction with vitamin E in
protecting cells against oxidative damage caused by free radicals (see Box 5.2). The
vitamin is required in the diet of only a few vertebrates – humans, other primates,
guinea pigs, the red-vented bulbul bird and the fruit-eating bat (both native to India)
and certain fishes. Some insects and other invertebrates also require a dietary source
of vitamin C. Other species synthesise the vitamin from glucose, via glucuronic acid
and gulonic acid lactone; the enzyme L-gulonolactone oxidase is required for the synthesis, and species requiring ascorbic acid are genetically deficient in this enzyme.
Deficiency symptoms
The classic condition in humans arising from a deficiency of vitamin C is scurvy,
characterised by oedema, emaciation and diarrhoea. Failure in collagen formation
results in structural defects in bone, teeth, cartilage, connective tissues and muscles.
Resistance to infection is reduced.
Since farm animals can synthesise vitamin C, deficiency symptoms normally do
not arise. However, it has been suggested that under certain conditions, e.g. climatic
stress in poultry, the demand for ascorbic acid becomes greater than can be provided
for by normal tissue synthesis, and a dietary supplement may then be beneficial.
5.5
HYPERVITAMINOSIS
Hypervitaminosis is the name given to pathological conditions resulting from an
overdose of vitamins. Under ‘natural’ conditions it is unlikely that farm animals will
receive excessive doses of vitamins, although when synthetic vitamins are added to
diets there is always the risk that abnormally large amounts may be ingested if errors
are made during mixing. There is experimental evidence that toxic symptoms can
occur if animals are given excessive quantities of vitamin A or D.
Clinical signs of hypervitaminosis A in young chicks kept under experimental
conditions and given very high doses of vitamin A include loss of appetite, poor
growth, diarrhoea, encrustation around the mouth and reddening of the eyelids. In
pigs, toxic symptoms include rough coat, scaly skin, hyperirritability, haemorrhages
over the limbs and abdomen, periodic tremors and death.
100
Summary
Excessive intake of vitamin D causes abnormally high levels of calcium and phosphorus in the blood, which results in the deposition of calcium salts in the arteries
and organs. Symptoms of hypervitaminosis D have been noted in cattle and calves.
In the UK, the maximum amount of vitamin D supplement added to diets for farm
animals is controlled by legislation.
Depression in growth and anaemia caused by excessive doses of menadione (vitamin K) have been reported.
SUMMARY
Vitamins are involved in metabolic pathways as coenzymes, and some act as protectors in antioxidant
and immune systems. The sources and functions of individual vitamins, and the disorders caused by
their deficiencies, are summarised below.
Vitamin
Source
Actions
Deficiency symptoms
A, retinol
Fish-liver oil
Sight,
epithelial tissues
Blindness,
epithelial infection
D3, cholecalciferol
Fish-liver oil,
sun-dried roughage
Calcium absorption
Rickets
E, a-tocopherol
Green foods, cereals
Antioxidant
K, menadione
Green foods, egg yolk
Prothrombin
synthesis
Muscle degeneration,
liver damage
Anaemia, delayed
clotting
B1, thiamin
Seeds
Carbohydrate and
fat metabolism
Poor growth,
polyneuritis
B2, riboflavin
Green foods, milk
Carbohydrate and
amino acid
metabolism
Poor growth, curled toe
paralysis
Nicotinamide
Yeast, liver, tryptophan
Hydrogen transfer
(NAD and NADP)
Poor growth, dermatitis
B6, pyridoxine
Cereals, yeast
Amino acid metabolism
Poor growth, convulsions
Pantothenic acid
Liver, yeast, cereals
Acetate and fatty acid
metabolism
(coenzyme A)
Poor growth, scaly
skin, ‘goose-stepping’
in pigs
Folic acid
Green foods, cereals,
oilseed meals
Metabolism of single
carbon compounds
Poor growth, anaemia,
poor hatchability
Biotin
Liver, vegetables
Carbon dioxide transfer
Foot lesions, hair loss,
FLKS
Choline
Green foods, cereals,
methionine
Component of lecithin
Poor growth, fatty liver,
perosis
B12, cyanocobalamin
Microorganisms, liver
Propionate metabolism
Poor growth, anaemia,
poor coat/feathering
C, ascorbic acid
Citrus fruits, leafy
vegetables
Oxidation–reduction
reactions
Reduced resistance to
infection
FLKS = fatty liver and kidney syndrome.
101
Chapter 5 Vitamins
FURTHER READING
Bender, D A 1992 Nutritional Biochemistry of the Vitamins, Cambridge, Cambridge
University Press.
Bieber-Wlaschny M 1988 Vitamin requirements of the dairy cow. In: Garnsworthy P C (ed.)
Nutrition and Lactation in the Dairy Cow, London, Butterworth, pp. 135–56.
Chew B P 1995 The influence of vitamins on reproduction in pigs. In: Garnsworthy P C and
Cole D J A (eds) Recent Advances in Animal Nutrition 1995, Nottingham, Nottingham
University Press, pp. 223–39.
Debier, C and Larondelle, Y 2005 Vitamins A and E: metabolism, roles and transfer to
offspring. British Journal of Nutrition 93: 153–74.
Latscha T 1990 Carotenoids: Their Nature and Significance in Animal Feeds, Basel,
Hoffmann–La Roche.
Morris J G 2002 Idiosyncratic nutrient requirements of cats appear to be diet-induced evolutionary adaptations. Nutrition Research Reviews 15: 153–68.
National Research Council 1994 Nutrient Requirements of Poultry, 9th edn,Washington, DC,
National Academy Press.
National Research Council 1998 Nutrient Requirements of Swine, 10th edn,Washington, DC,
National Academy Press.
National Research Council 2000 Nutrient Requirements of Beef Cattle, 7th edn, Washington,
DC, National Academy Press.
National Research Council 2001 Nutrient Requirements of Dairy Cattle, 7th edn,Washington,
DC, National Academy Press.
National Research Council 2006 Nutrient Requirements of Dogs and Cats, Washington, DC,
National Academy Press.
National Research Council 2007 Nutrient Requirements of Horses, 6th edn, Washington, DC,
National Academy Press.
National Research Council 2007 Nutrient Requirements of Small Ruminants, Washington,
DC, National Academy Press.
Whitehead C C 1986 Requirements for vitamins. In: Fisher C and Boorman K N (eds)
Nutrient Requirements of Poultry and Nutrition Research, London, Butterworth,
pp. 173–89.
102
6
6.1
Minerals
6.1
Functions of minerals
6.2
Natural and supplementary sources of minerals
6.3
Acid–base balance
6.4
Major elements
6.5
Trace elements
6.6
Other elements
FUNCTIONS OF MINERALS
Although most of the naturally occurring mineral elements are found in animal tissues, many are thought to be present merely because they are constituents of the
animal’s food and may not have an essential function in the animal’s metabolism.
The term ‘essential mineral element’ is restricted to a mineral element that has been
proven to have a metabolic role in the body. Before an element can be classed as
essential it is generally considered necessary to prove that purified diets lacking
the element cause deficiency symptoms in animals and that those symptoms can be
eradicated or prevented by adding the element to the experimental diet. Most
research on mineral nutrition has been carried out in this way. However, some of the
mineral elements required by animals for normal health and growth are needed in
such minute amounts that the construction of deficient diets is often difficult to
achieve and deficiency has been demonstrated only in laboratory animals under special conditions. In such studies it is necessary not only to monitor food and water
supplies but also to ensure that animals do not obtain the element under investigation from cages, troughs, attendants or dust in the atmosphere.
Requirements or allowances for minerals may be derived factorially from the
amounts required to meet endogenous losses and the mineral retained or excreted in
products, or, more usually for the trace elements, empirically from dose responses to
levels in the diet. The main problem for the minerals with more than one function is
deciding on the criterion for adequacy. Dietary levels of mineral that are sufficient
for one function may be inadequate for another. Adequacy for the short period of
growth of animals slaughtered for meat may not cover the long-term needs of breeding and longevity of adult stock. Also, for the minerals involved in bone formation,
there are many criteria, such as bone dimensions, strength, histology and composition. Depletion of body reserves in times of undernutrition will supply the mineral
103
Chapter 6 Minerals
for its metabolic functions, and this needs to be considered if requirements are to be
measured accurately.
Until 1950, 13 mineral elements were classified as essential: these comprised
the major elements (calcium, phosphorus, potassium, sodium, chlorine, sulphur,
magnesium) and the micro or trace elements (iron, iodine, copper, manganese, zinc
and cobalt). By 1970, molybdenum, selenium, chromium and fluorine had been
added to the list; subsequently, arsenic, boron, lead, lithium, nickel, silicon, tin,
vanadium, rubidium and aluminium have also been included, the list varying
slightly according to the different authorities. Plant and animal tissues contain a
further 30 mineral elements, in small quantities, for which no essential function
has been found. They may be acquired from the environment, but it has been suggested that as many as 40 or more elements may have metabolic roles in mammalian tissues. Fortunately, many of these trace elements, especially those of more
recent discovery, are required in such minute quantities, or are so widely distributed in foods for animals, that deficiencies are likely to be extremely rare under
normal practical conditions.
The classification of the essential minerals into major elements and trace elements depends upon their concentration in the animal or amounts required in
the diet. Normally trace elements are present in the animal body in a concentration
not greater than 50 mg/kg and are required at less than 100 mg/kg diet. Those essential mineral elements that are of particular nutritional importance together with
their approximate concentrations in the animal body are shown in Table 6.1.
The minerals are held in different forms in the body, which can be considered as
compartments. There is a central reserve or interchange compartment, which is usually blood plasma, and one or more compartments that interchange the mineral with
the central compartment at various rates, e.g. compartments easy or difficult to mobilise. Metabolic processes take place via the central reserve (plasma), which receives minerals from other compartments, the digestive tract and the difficult to
mobilise compartment. The central reserve secretes mineral into the readily mobilised compartments, the difficult to mobilise compartment, the gastrointestinal
tract, the kidneys and milk.The flux between the compartments can be measured by
a combination of balance trials and injection of radioactive marker followed by sampling the tissues over time. An example of the body compartments of copper is
shown in Fig. 6.1.
Table 6.1 Nutritionally important essential mineral elements and their
approximate concentration in the animal
Major elements
Calcium
Phosphorus
Potassium
Sodium
Chlorine
Sulphur
Magnesium
104
g/kg
Trace elements
mg/kg
15
10
2
1.6
1.1
1.5
0.4
Iron
Zinc
Copper
Molybdenum
Selenium
Iodine
Manganese
Cobalt
20–80
10–50
1–5
1–4
1–2
0.3–0.6
0.2–0.5
0.02–0.1
Functions of minerals
Dietary
copper
Tissue
Foetus
Milk
Blood
Kidney
Absorbed
Endogenous
loss
(i)
Bile
Faecal
copper
(unabsorbed
dietary and
endogenous)
(ii)
Liver
A
Liver
B
Liver
C
(iii)
Urine
Fig. 6.1 Diagram of the possible routes of movement of copper in the ruminant
body. A is a temporary storage compartment for copper in the liver destined for
exchange with blood and excretion into bile, B represents a temporary storage
for incorporation into caeruloplasmin and C represents a long-term storage
compartment.
Adapted from Symonds H W and Forbes J M 1993 Mineral metabolism. In: Forbes J M and France J (eds)
Quantitative Aspects of Ruminant Digestion and Metabolism, Wallingford, CABI.
Nearly all the essential mineral elements, both major and trace, are believed to
have one or more catalytic functions in the cell. Some mineral elements are firmly
bound to the proteins of enzymes (see Box 6.1), while others are present in prosthetic groups in chelated form. A chelate is a cyclic compound that is formed between an organic molecule and a metallic ion, the latter being held within the
organic molecule as if by a claw (‘chelate’ is derived from the Greek work meaning
‘claw’). Examples of naturally occurring chelates are the chlorophylls, cytochromes,
haemoglobin and vitamin B12.
Elements such as sodium, potassium and chlorine have primarily an electrochemical or physiological function and are concerned with the maintenance of acid–base
balance, membrane permeability and the osmotic control of water distribution
within the body. Some elements have a structural role, for example calcium and
phosphorus are essential components of the skeleton and sulphur is necessary for
the synthesis of structural proteins. Finally, certain elements have a regulatory function in controlling cell replication and differentiation; zinc acts in this way by influencing the transcription process, in which genetic information in the nucleotide
sequence of DNA is transferred to that of an RNA molecule. It is not uncommon for
an element to have a number of different roles; for example, magnesium functions
catalytically, electrochemically and structurally.
A number of elements have unique functions. Iron is important as a constituent
of haem, which is an essential part of a number of cytochromes important in respiration. Cobalt is a component of vitamin B12 and iodine forms part of the hormone
thyroxine.
105
Chapter 6 Minerals
BOX 6.1 Mineral elements and enzymes
Below are some examples of the involvement of minerals in enzymes (summarised from Underwood
and Suttle – see Further reading).
Mineral
Enzyme
Function
Iron
Succinate dehydrogenase
Cytochromes a, b and c
Aerobic oxidation of carbohydrates
Electron transfer
Copper
Cytochrome oxidase
Ceruloplasmin (ferroxidase)
Superoxide dismutase
Terminal oxidase
Iron utilisation: copper transport
Dismutation of superoxide radical O*2 -
Zinc
Carbonic anhydrase
Alcohol dehydrogenase
Carboxypeptidase A
Alkaline phosphatase
CO2 formation
Alcohol metabolism
Protein digestion
Hydrolysis of phosphate esters
Manganese
Pyruvate carboxylase
Superoxide dismutase
Pyruvate metabolism
Antioxidant by removing O*2 -
Molybdenum
Xanthine dehydrogenase
Sulphite oxidase
Purine metabolism
Sulphite oxidation
Selenium
Glutathione peroxidases
Type I and III deiodinases
Removal of H2O2 and hydroperoxides
Conversion of thyroxine to active form
Some elements, for example calcium and molybdenum, may interfere with the
absorption, transport, function, storage or excretion of other elements. There are
many ways in which minerals may interact, but the three major ways involve the
formation of unabsorbable compounds, competition for metabolic pathways and
the induction of metal-binding proteins.The interaction of minerals with each other
is an important factor in animal nutrition, and an imbalance of mineral elements –
as distinct from a simple deficiency – is important in the aetiology of certain nutritional disorders of farm animals. The use of radioactive isotopes in recent years has
advanced our knowledge of mineral nutrition, although there are many nutritional
diseases associated with minerals whose exact causes are still unknown.
Although we have been considering the essential role of minerals in animal
nutrition, it is important to realise that many are toxic – causing illness or death – if
given to the animal in excessive quantities. This is particularly true of copper, selenium, molybdenum, fluorine, vanadium and arsenic. Copper is a cumulative poison,
the animal body being unable to excrete it efficiently; small amounts of copper
given in excess of the animal’s daily needs will, in time, produce toxic symptoms.
This also applies to the element fluorine. Supplementation of any diet with minerals should always be carried out with great care, and the indiscriminate use of trace
elements in particular must be avoided. Ideally, the supplement should be tailored
to the target animal and a blanket oversupply should be avoided as it is wasteful
and potentially dangerous. Minerals should be added to concentrate foods via a
premix and thoroughly mixed to avoid ‘hot spots’ of high concentration and potential toxicity.
106
Natural and supplementary sources of minerals
6.2
NATURAL AND SUPPLEMENTARY SOURCES OF MINERALS
Plants and plant products form the main supply of nutrients to animals, and the composition of plants will influence the animal’s mineral intake.Thus, the species and stage of
maturity of the plant, the type of soil and climate, and the seasonal conditions are important factors. Legumes tend to be richer in the major minerals and certain trace elements than are grasses, and this is also the case with the seeds of legumes compared
with the seeds of grasses and cereals. Soil conditions and mineral content affect the uptake of minerals by plants, and this can be further influenced by fertiliser application.
One of the major influences is soil pH, the effect of which differs among the elements.
For example, molybdenum uptake by plants increases with an increase in soil pH, but
cobalt and manganese contents decrease.Therefore, adjusting soil pH with lime will influence the mineral content of plants. Herbage magnesium content and availability can
be reduced by potassium and nitrogen fertilisers.The main animal products used in animal feeding, fishmeal, whey and skimmed milk, are good sources of the major minerals.
Usually, diets for farm animals contain a mineral/trace element/vitamin supplement and, on occasions, it is necessary to include extra supplies of some minerals,
e.g. calcium for laying hens. Common sources of minerals used in mineral supplements are limestone for calcium, dicalcium phosphate for phosphorus, common salt
for sodium, and calcined magnesite for magnesium. Trace elements are usually supplied in a salt form, e.g. selenium as sodium selenite. When considering sources of
mineral, the cost, chemical and physical form, and freedom from impurities are
taken into account. It is also necessary to take account of the availability of the element in question (see Chapter 10). Calcium tends to have a high availability from
most sources and the phosphorus in ortho- and meta-phosphates has an availability
of 80–100 per cent.The availability of phosphorus from rock phosphates can be very
low. Magnesium from calcined magnesite has an availability of 50–60 per cent,
whereas that from magnesium sulphate is up to 70 per cent. Sulphur from sulphates
is 50–90 per cent available.The availability of trace elements in the form of sulphate,
chloride or nitrate salts is high because they are water-soluble. Table 6.2 shows the
availability of minerals in a number of sources relative to a standard source. In these
examples the criteria used to assess the relative availability of the different minerals
vary, e.g. absorption, accumulation in tissues, production of metabolically active
compounds; hence, some sources in Table 6.2 have values greater than 100 per cent
when compared with the standard source of the mineral.
Free ions from inorganic sources can form complexes with other dietary constituents, resulting in low absorbability and availability to the animal. Minerals in
‘chelated’ or ‘organic’ form (where the element is in combination with an organic
molecule such as an amino acid) are protected from reaction with other constituents
and theoretically have a greater absorbability than inorganic sources. Chelates were
mentioned above and the addition of chelated minerals as supplements to diets is
currently an active area of research. One of the most potent chelating agents is the
synthetic compound ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA), which has the property of forming stable chelates with heavy metals. In vitro, however, chelates of
cobalt were not more effective than cobalt chloride in stimulating microbial synthesis of vitamin B12, and oral supplements of cobalt EDTA and cobalt sulphate gave
similar liver and serum vitamin B12 contents. The addition of chelating agents such
as EDTA to poultry diets may in some cases improve the availability of the mineral
element. However, the bonding between the metal and EDTA is strong, and work
107
Chapter 6 Minerals
Table 6.2 Examples of the relative availability (%) of mineral elements from
mineral compounds
Mineral compound
Cobaltous sulphate
Cobalt glucoheptate
Cobalt carbonate
Cupric sulphate
Copper-lysine
Copper-methionine
Cupric carbonate
Cupric chloride
Ferrous sulphate (7H2O)
Ferric citrate
Ferric oxide
Ferrous chloride
Iron-methionine
Iron-proteinate
Manganese sulphate
Manganese carbonate
Manganese-methionine
Manganous chloride
Sodium selenite
Seleno-cystine
Seleno-methionine
Seleno-yeast
Zinc chloride
Zinc sulphate
Zinc-lysine
Zinc-methionine
Poultry
–
–
–
100
105
90
65
110
100
75
10
100
–
–
100
55
120
100
100
110
80a/115b
–
100
100
–
125
Pigs
–
–
–
100
–
110
85
–
100
150
10
–
185
125
–
–
–
–
100
–
120a/150b
–
100
–
100
100
Cattle
Sheep
–
–
–
100
100
–
–
115
100
110
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
100
–
–
290
–
100
–
–
100
85
100
100
–
–
–
115
100
–
5
–
100
30
125
–
100
–
–
100
–
100
–
100
a
Assessed from glutathione peroxidase production or incidence of exudative diathesis.
Assessed from whole body or tissue selenium retention or incidence of pancreatic fibrosis.
b
Summarised from Ammerman C B, Henry P R and Miles R D 1998 Supplemental organically-bound mineral
compounds in livestock nutrition. In: Garnsworthy P C and Wiseman J (eds) Recent Advances in Animal
Nutrition, Nottingham, Nottingham University Press, pp. 67–91.
with copper chelates in sheep has shown that the copper is no more available than in
inorganic salts. Recently the manufacture of different forms of trace element–organic
complex has increased. In 1998 the Association of American Feed Control Officials
defined four categories of such complexes:
■
■
■
108
Metal amino acid complex: The product resulting from complexing of a soluble
metal salt with an amino acid.
Metal amino acid chelate: The product of the reaction of a metal ion from a soluble metal salt with amino acids with a mole ratio of one mole of metal to three
moles (preferably two) of amino acids to form coordinate covalent bonds. The
average weight of the hydrolysed amino acids must be approximately 150 and
the resulting molecular weight of the chelate must not exceed 800.
Metal polysaccharide complex: The product resulting from complexing of a soluble salt with a polysaccharide solution.
Natural and supplementary sources of minerals
■
Metal proteinate: The product resulting from the chelation of a soluble salt with
amino acids and/or partially hydrolysed protein.
Amino acid and peptide chelates are absorbed efficiently, possibly because they are
taken up by the peptide absorption mechanism rather than the active transport
mechanism for minerals (see Chapter 8), although this has not been proven. Levels
of iron in the tissues of piglets and piglet growth have been improved by giving an
iron proteinate to the sow. However, the piglets also had access to the sow’s faeces
and may have obtained iron from these. Again, although zinc methionine has improved tissue levels of zinc in pigs, results have not been consistent.The replacement
of sodium selenite by selenium-enriched yeast has improved the selenium content of
serum, milk and tissues of gilts and the selenium status of their offspring. Seleniumenriched yeast in diets for lactating cows has increased the transfer of selenium to
milk when compared with selenite. In the case of selenium the element is not in the
form of one of the complexes mentioned above but replaces sulphur in the amino
acids that normally contain sulphur. However, inorganic selenium supplements are
also effective and at a lower cost. Owing to the different properties of the chelating
agents and the variable reponses observed, their use as mineral supplements is controversial.There are many reports in the popular press claiming increased responses.
A critical review by Underwood and Suttle (1999; see Further reading) suggests caution at this stage until evidence of consistent responses is published in scientific journals. In view of their cost, it is unlikely that they will replace inorganic sources of
mineral entirely, but they may be appropriate for special applications. It is suggested
that ‘organic’ minerals provide an extra supply of the element when there is reduced
efficiency of inorganic sources owing to interference from other minerals. These
preparations have also been advocated for use to reduce the excretion of unabsorbed
mineral and thus reduce the effect on the environment. The EU legislation on feeding stuffs permits only named supplements.
Mineral supplementation of animals at pasture can be a problem. Minerals can be
incorporated into free-access feed blocks, which also provide a source of energy and
nitrogen. However, individual animal intake can be variable. Intake depends on season, weather conditions, the siting and number of blocks (to minimise competition),
frequency of renewal and availability of water. The inclusion of oil or molasses improves palatability.
Spraying the pasture with soluble salts of trace elements can increase the element
content of the pasture. Alternatively, trace elements can be included in fertilisers in
order to increase the herbage content via the soil. However, if the deficiency is due to
poor availability of the element, then this type of application will not be successful.
For some of the trace elements, e.g. cobalt and copper, a solid bolus can be deposited into the rumen using a dosing gun. This bolus dissolves slowly over a period
of months, giving a steady release of the element. There can be problems of regurgitation of the bolus and they may become coated, thereby reducing the effective release of the mineral. Recently, boluses formed from soluble glass have been
produced that are not susceptible to this coating action. The glass boluses may contain more than one element (e.g. cobalt and selenium), anthelmintics, and vitamins
A, D or E. Needles of copper oxide, which have a high specific gravity and are
retained in the abomasum, have also been used in this way. For certain minerals
(e.g. copper, iodine and selenium), oral doses, drenches or injections with solutions
or pastes can be given at appropriate intervals, but the labour requirement is high.
109
Chapter 6 Minerals
6.3
ACID–BASE BALANCE
Normally in nutrition, minerals, including those with electrolytic properties, are considered functionally as separate entities. In physiological terms, however, the electrolytes need to be taken together since cells require a specific balance of anions and
cations to function efficiently. Physiological processes operate within a narrow range
of conditions, especially with respect to pH. In addition, enzyme systems, and hence
cell metabolism, are sensitive to pH. Thus, changes in acid–base status have a wide
influence on cell function and the animal must regulate the input and output of ions
to maintain acid–base homeostasis. Failure to maintain the correct electrolyte balance within the cell means that metabolic pathways are unable to function efficiently
and resources are diverted to achieving homeostasis at the expense of growth. The
diet is important in the maintenance of the correct intracellular electrolyte balance
owing to the metabolisable anions and cations that it contains and that consume or
generate acid during metabolism. Thus, an excess of anions will result in the production of hydrogen ions to counterbalance the anions, giving metabolic acidosis,
whereas an excess of cations requires ions such as acetate and bicarbonate and
causes alkalosis. These effects are independent of the specific metabolic or physiological roles of the particular element. The balance of acids and bases influences
many functions such as growth rate, appetite, amino acid and energy metabolism,
calcium utilisation, vitamin metabolism, intestinal absorption and kidney function.
Changes in cellular pH are often accompanied by changes in blood and urine pH.
Dietary influence in this respect may be assessed by measuring the dietary electrolyte
balance, defined as:
Na+ + K+ - Clwhere Na+, K+ and Cl- are the concentrations of the elements in mequiv per unit
weight. The dietary electrolyte balance is commonly used to assess the diets of pigs
and poultry. Pigs are more susceptible to excess anions than to cations, and the optimal dietary electrolyte balance is around 250 mequiv/kg. In poultry, eggshell formation has an effect on the acid–base balance as hydrogen ions are generated when
calcium carbonate is being synthesised. A dietary electrolyte balance of 200–
300 mequiv/kg is recommended for laying hens. In conditions of heat stress, elevated
respiration rate (panting) leads to respiratory alkalosis and in poultry and dairy cows
the acid–base balance of the diet has been adjusted to alleviate this. Ideally, other
elements making a contribution to electrolyte balance should be considered and a
more sophisticated assessment may be achieved by calculating (Na+ + K+ + Ca++ +
Mg++) - (Cl- + H2PO4- + HPO4- - + SO4- - ).This is termed the dietary undetermined
anion.The latter requires a substantial analytical facility and in practice the less comprehensive dietary electrolyte balance is generally considered to be sufficient. Recently, in ruminant nutrition the cation–anion balance or dietary cation–anion
difference (DCAD) has been used to assess the electrolyte status of diets. This is
calculated as (Na+ + K+) - (Cl- + SO4- - ) or alternatively as (Na+ + K+ ) - (Cl- + S- - ).
Manipulation of the cation–anion difference is now recommended as part of the
dietary management of dairy cows in order to avoid hypocalcaemia or milk fever
(see Box 6.2).
In the above it is seen that there may be confusion with terminology and the
method of calculation (i.e. which ions are included) of the acid–base status of the
110
Acid–base balance
BOX 6.2 Dietary cation–anion difference and milk fever
The metabolic acid–base balance affects the sensitivity of bone to parathyroid hormone (PTH) and
the synthesis of 1,25-dihydroxycholecalciferol. Therefore, acknowledging this when balancing the
mineral content of the diet can have an effect on the incidence of milk fever. Conditions that promote
an alkalotic state (high dietary cations, Na+ and K+) reduce the sensitivity of bone to PTH and can
limit the release of calcium. Conversely, an acidotic state (high dietary anions, Cl- and S- - ) increases
the sensitivity to PTH, increases 1,25-dihydroxycholecalciferol production and hence increases the
calcium supply.Through these metabolic responses, manipulation of the acid–base balance in the diet
of the pre-calving cow has been successful in reducing the incidence of milk fever.
Early work used the dietary electrolyte balance calculation (Na+ + K + - Cl-), but subsequently it
was found that the inclusion of SO4- - or S- - was beneficial. Thus, dietary cation–anion difference
(DCAD) as (Na+ + K+) - (Cl- + SO4-) or (Na+ + K+) - (Cl- + S-) is used when calculating and manipulating the acid–base balance of the diet. The recommended target for the latter calculation is
around -100 mequiv/kg. The optimal DCAD probably varies with several factors such as breed and
feeding management. Recent studies have shown that Cl- ions are more acidogenic than S- ions,
probably owing to differences in dissociation in and absorption from the digestive tract.
In practice, manipulation of the diet involves minimising foods high in potassium and sodium.
Grass silage is the major problem, often containing 30–40 g potassium/kg DM, and alkali-treated grain
and molasses should also be avoided. The cereal by-product, brewer’s grains, is a food that is low in
sodium and potassium. Unlike the low-calcium diet strategy, the DCAD strategy requires a moderate
to high calcium intake to be maintained. Supplementary anionic salts (e.g. ammonium chloride, ammonium sulphate, magnesium chloride, calcium chloride) can be used to adjust the DCAD, but they
tend to be unpalatable. Practical application of this stategy requires knowledge of the mineral contents
of the foods.To ensure there is adequate magnesium for effective calcium absorption and mobilisation,
the magnesium content of the diet is adjusted to 3.5 g/kg DM using magnesium sulphate or magnesium chloride, and the sulphur content is set at 4 g/kg DM using calcium or ammonium sulphate.
Higher magnesium (up to 4 g/kg DM) may be required if the potassium content of the diet is high in
view of the latter’s effect on magnesium absorption.The DCAD can then be manipulated with ammonium or calcium chloride. Calcium intake is maintained at 120–150 g/day and phosphorus at 50 g/day.
This approach to the problem of milk fever requires careful management, since the high quantities of
anionic salts involved may reduce food intake and precipitate other metabolic problems.The effectiveness of the strategy can be checked by measuring urine pH, which should be slightly acidic at around
6.5. It is recommended that the diets are given for at least 2 weeks but no more than 4 weeks before
calving. Although pregnant heifers show the same responses as cows in terms of increased blood calcium with decreasing DCAD, food intake was depressed and they did not have increased milk yields.
It is currently recommended that heifers should not be given supplementary anions. Current research
is investigating alterations to DCAD to improve food intake and milk production. Early lactation diets
contain large amounts of rumen-fermentable carbohydrate and a positive DCAD would, in theory,
help to reduce rumen and blood acidosis.
diet. Some authorities suggest the inclusion of NH4+, HCO3- and CO3- -, while others
recommend that the absorption coefficient should also be accounted for. However,
such refinement will require much more research and information before this type of
model can be applied.
Certain pathological conditions may cause disturbances in electrolyte balance,
e.g. vomiting (loss of chloride), diarrhoea (loss of bicarbonate) and excessive amino
111
Chapter 6 Minerals
acid oxidation (excess acid production). These, however, are largely outside the control of the nutritionist.
6.4
MAJOR ELEMENTS
Calcium
Calcium is the most abundant mineral element in the animal body. It is an important
constituent of the skeleton and teeth, in which about 99 per cent of the total body
calcium is found; in addition, it is an essential constituent of living cells and tissue
fluids. Calcium is essential for the activity of a number of enzyme systems, including
those necessary for the transmission of nerve impulses and for the contractile properties of muscle. It is also concerned in the coagulation of blood. In blood, the element occurs in the plasma; the plasma of mammals usually contains 80–120 mg
calcium/l, but that of laying hens contains more (300–400 mg/l).
Composition of bone
Bone is highly complex in structure, the dry matter consisting of approximately 460 g
mineral matter/kg, 360 g protein/kg and 180 g fat/kg. The composition varies, however, according to the age and nutritional status of the animal. Calcium and phosphorus are the two most abundant mineral elements in bone; they are combined in a
form similar to that found in the mineral hydroxyapatite, 3Ca3(PO4)2.Ca(OH)2.
Bone ash contains approximately 360 g calcium/kg, 170 g phosphorus/kg and 10 g
magnesium/kg.
The skeleton is not a stable unit in the chemical sense, since large amounts of the
calcium and phosphorus in bone can be liberated by reabsorption. This takes place
particularly during lactation and egg production, although the exchange of calcium
and phosphorus between bones and soft tissue is always a continuous process. Resorption of calcium is controlled by the action of the parathyroid gland. If animals
are fed on a low-calcium diet, the ionic calcium concentration in the extracellular
fluid falls, the parathyroid gland is stimulated and the hormone produced causes resorption of bone, liberating calcium to meet the requirements of the animal. Since
calcium is combined with phosphorus in bone, the phosphorus is also liberated and
excreted by the animal.
The parathyroid hormone also plays an important role in regulating the amount
of the calcium absorbed from the intestine by influencing the production of 1,25dihydroxycholecalciferol, a derivative of vitamin D, which is concerned with the
formation of calcium-binding protein (see p. 80). Finally, the hormone stimulates the
kidney to resorb urinary calcium.
Deficiency symptoms
If calcium is deficient in the diet of young growing animals, then satisfactory bone formation cannot occur and the condition known as rickets is produced. The symptoms
of rickets are misshapen bones, enlargement of the joints, lameness and stiffness. In
adult animals, calcium deficiency produces osteomalacia, in which the calcium in the
112
Major elements
bone is withdrawn and not replaced. In osteomalacia, the bones become weak and
are easily broken. In hens, deficiency symptoms are soft beak and bones, retarded
growth and bowed legs; the eggs have thin shells and egg production may be reduced.
The symptoms described above for rickets and osteomalacia are not specific for calcium and can also be produced by a deficiency of phosphorus, an abnormal calcium :
phosphorus ratio or a deficiency of vitamin D (see p. 80). A number of factors can be
responsible for subnormal calcification.
Milk fever (parturient paresis) is a condition that most commonly occurs in dairy
cows shortly after calving. It is characterised by a lowering of the serum calcium
level, muscular spasms and, in extreme cases, paralysis and unconsciousness. The
exact cause of hypocalcaemia associated with milk fever is obscure, but it is generally considered that, with the onset of lactation, the parathyroid gland is unable to
respond rapidly enough to increase calcium absorption from the intestine to meet
the extra demand. Normal levels of blood calcium can be restored by intravenous injections of calcium gluconate, but this may not always have a permanent effect. It
has been shown that avoiding excessive intakes of calcium while maintaining adequate dietary levels of phosphorus during the dry period reduces the incidence of
milk fever. Deliberate use of low-calcium diets to increase calcium absorption in the
practical prevention of milk fever requires a good estimate of calving date, otherwise
calcium deficiency may occur. Also low-calcium diets are hard to achieve with forages unless straw is used. Recently, success in controlling milk fever has been
achieved by manipulating the acid–base balance of the diet (see Box 6.2). Administration of large doses of vitamin D3 for a short period before parturition has also
proved beneficial, but the timing is critical. Hypocalcaemia in ewes bearing twins
often occurs before lambing.
Sources of calcium
Milk, green leafy crops, especially legumes, and sugar beet pulp are good sources of
calcium; cereals and roots are poor sources. In some lucerne crops, calcium associated with oxalates is unavailable. Animal by-products containing bone, such as fishmeal, are excellent sources. Calcium-containing mineral supplements that are
frequently given to farm animals, especially lactating animals and laying hens, include ground limestone, steamed bone flour and dicalcium phosphate. If rock calcium phosphate is given to animals it is important to ensure that fluorine is absent,
otherwise this supplement may be toxic. High levels of fat in the diet of monogastric
animals result in the formation of calcium soaps of fatty acids, which reduce the absorbability of calcium.
Calcium : phosphorus ratio
When giving calcium supplements to animals it is important to consider the calcium :
phosphorus ratio of the diet, since an abnormal ratio may be as harmful as a deficiency of either element in the diet. The calcium : phosphorus ratio considered most
suitable for farm animals other than poultry is generally within the range 1 : 1 to 2 : 1,
although there is evidence that suggests that ruminants can tolerate rather higher
ratios providing that the phosphorus requirements are met. In the case of the calcium
and phosphorus requirements for ruminants published by the Agriculture and Food
Research Council’s Technical Committee on Responses to Nutrients, the requirement
113
Chapter 6 Minerals
for phosphorus can exceed that of calcium in some circumstances. The proportion of
calcium for laying hens is much larger, since they require great amounts of the element
for eggshell production. The calcium is usually given to laying hens as ground limestone mixed with the diet or, alternatively, calcareous grit may be given ad libitum.
Granular limestone is more effective since the large particles are retained in the
gizzard for a longer time.
Phosphorus
Phosphorus has more known functions than any other mineral element in the animal
body. The close association of phosphorus with calcium in bone has already been
mentioned. In addition, phosphorus occurs in phosphoproteins, nucleic acids and
phospholipids. The element plays a vital role in energy metabolism in the formation
of sugar-phosphates and adenosine di- and triphosphates (see Chapter 9).The importance of vitamin D in calcium and phosphorus metabolism has already been discussed in Chapter 5. The phosphorus content of the animal body is considerably less
than that of calcium content. Whereas 99 per cent of the calcium found in the body
occurs in the bones and teeth, the proportion of the phosphorus in these structures is
about 80–85 per cent of the total; the remainder is in the soft tissues and fluids,
where it serves the essential functions mentioned above. The control of phosphorus
metabolism is different from that of calcium. If it is in an available form, phosphorus
is absorbed well even when there is an excess over requirement. The excess is excreted via the kidney or the gut (via saliva). In monogastric animals, the kidney is
the primary route of excretion. Plasma phosphorus diffuses into saliva and in ruminants the large amount of chewing during rumination results in saliva being the
major input of phosphorus into the rumen rather than the food.
Deficiency symptoms
Extensive areas of phosphorus-deficient soils occur throughout the world, especially
in tropical and subtropical areas, and a deficiency of phosphorus can be regarded as
the most widespread and economically important of all the mineral disabilities affecting grazing livestock.
Like calcium, phosphorus is required for bone formation and a deficiency can also
cause rickets or osteomalacia. Pica, or depraved appetite, has been noted in cattle
when there is a deficiency of phosphorus in the diet; the affected animals have abnormal appetites and chew wood, bones, rags and other foreign materials. Pica is not
specifically a sign of phosphorus deficiency, since it may be caused by other factors.
Evidence of phosphorus deficiency may be obtained from an analysis of blood
serum, which shows a phosphorus content lower than normal. In chronic phosphorus
deficiency, animals may have stiff joints and muscular weakness.
Low dietary intake of phosphorus has also been associated with poor fertility,
with apparent dysfunction of the ovaries causing inhibition, depression or irregularity of oestrus.There are many examples throughout the world of phosphorus supplementation increasing fertility in grazing cattle. In cows, a deficiency of this element
may also reduce milk yield. In hens, there is reduced egg yield, hatchability and shell
thickness.
Subnormal growth in young animals and low liveweight gains in mature animals
are characteristic symptoms of phosphorus deficiency in all species. Phosphorus
deficiency is usually more common in cattle than in sheep, as the latter tend to have
114
Major elements
more selective grazing habits and choose the growing parts of plants, which happen
to be richer in phosphorus.
Sources of phosphorus
Milk, cereal grains and fishmeal products containing bone are good sources of phosphorus; the content in hays and straws is generally very low. Considerable attention
has been paid to the availability of phosphorus. Much of the element present in
cereal grains is in the form of phytates, which are salts of phytic acid, a phosphoric
acid derivative:
H
P
C
C
OH
H
P
P
H
C
C
P
P
H
H
C
H
P
O
P
O
OH
P
C
=
Phytic acid
Insoluble calcium and magnesium phytates occur in cereals and other plant products. Experiments with chicks have shown that the phosphorus of calcium phytate is
utilised only 10 per cent as effectively as disodium phosphate. In studies with laying
hens, phytate phosphorus was utilised about half as well as dicalcium phosphate.
Certain plant foods, such as wheat, contain phytase and in the pig stomach some of
the phytate phosphorus is made available by the action of this enzyme. However, it
is likely that the phytase is destroyed in the acid conditions once the acid secreted
penetrates the food mass in the stomach. Intestinal phytase activity from the microflora has been observed, but it appears to be of little importance in the pig. It has
been shown with sheep that hydrolysis of phytates by bacterial phytases occurs in
the rumen. Bacteria in the hind gut also have phytase activity, but the significance of
this in phosphorus supply for the monogastric is not clear. Phytate phosphorus appears therefore to be utilised by ruminants as readily as other forms of phosphorus,
although studies using radioactive isotopes indicate that the availability of phosphorus may range from 0.33 to 0.90. Recent studies with a fungal source of phytase
added to the diet of pigs have shown significant increases in ileal and total tract digestibility of phytate phosphorus (see Chapter 24).
Feeding with high levels of phosphorus should be avoided as the excess is excreted and contributes to pollution by encouraging the growth of algae in water
courses. High phosphorus intake in association with magnesium can lead to the formation of mineral deposits in the bladder and urethra (urolithiasis or urinary calculi)
and blockage of the flow of urine in male sheep and cattle.
Potassium
Potassium plays a very important part, along with sodium, chlorine and bicarbonate
ions, in osmotic regulation of the body fluids and in the acid–base balance in the
animal. Whereas sodium is the main inorganic cation of extracellular tissue fluids,
115
Chapter 6 Minerals
potassium functions principally as the cation of cells. Potassium plays an important part in nerve and muscle excitability and is also involved in carbohydrate
metabolism.
Deficiency symptoms
The potassium content of plants is generally very high, that of grass, for example,
being frequently above 25 g/kg DM, so that it is normally ingested by animals in
larger amounts than any other element. Consequently, potassium deficiency is rare in
farm animals kept under natural conditions. One exception to this is provided by distiller’s grains (draff; see p. 547), which, as a result of the removal of the liquid after
fermentation, is deficient in several soluble elements, including potassium. Appropriate supplementation is necessary where draff forms a large proportion of the diet.
There are certain areas in the world where soil potassium levels are naturally low.
Such areas occur in Brazil, Panama and Uganda, and it is suggested that in these tropical regions, potassium deficiencies may arise in grazing animals, especially at the end
of the long dry season, when potassium levels in the mature herbage are low.
Deficiency symptoms have been produced in chicks given experimental diets low
in potassium.They include retarded growth, weakness and tetany, followed by death.
Deficiency symptoms, including severe paralysis, have also been recorded for calves
given synthetic milk diets low in potassium.
A dietary excess of potassium is normally excreted rapidly from the body, chiefly
in the urine. Some research workers believe that high intake of the element may interfere with the absorption and metabolism of magnesium in the animal, which may
be an important factor in the aetiology of hypomagnesaemic tetany (see p. 119).
Sodium
Most of the sodium of the animal body is present in the soft tissues and body fluids.
Like potassium, sodium is concerned with the acid–base balance and osmotic regulation of the body fluids. Sodium is the chief cation of blood plasma and other extracellular fluids of the body.The sodium concentration within the cells is relatively low,
the element being replaced largely by potassium and magnesium. Sodium also plays
a role in the transmission of nerve impulses and in the absorption of sugars and
amino acids from the digestive tract (see p. 168).
Much of the sodium is ingested in the form of sodium chloride (common salt),
and it is mainly in this form that the element is excreted from the body. There is evidence that sodium rather than chlorine is the chief limiting factor in salt-deficient
diets of sheep and cows.
Deficiency symptoms
Sodium deficiency in animals occurs in many parts of the world, but especially in the
tropical areas of Africa and the arid inland areas of Australia, where pastures contain
very low concentrations of the element.A deficiency of sodium in the diet leads to a
lowering of the osmotic pressure, which results in dehydration of the body. Symptoms of sodium deficiency include poor growth and reduced utilisation of digested
proteins and energy. In hens, egg production and growth are adversely affected. Rats
given experimental diets low in sodium had eye lesions and reproductive disturbances, and eventually died.
116
Major elements
Sources of sodium
Most foods of vegetable origin have comparatively low sodium contents; animal
products, especially foods of marine origin, are richer sources. The commonest mineral supplement given to farm animals is common salt.
Chlorine
Chlorine is associated with sodium and potassium in acid–base relationships and osmotic regulation. Chlorine also plays an important part in the gastric secretion,
where it occurs as hydrochloric acid as well as chloride salts. Chlorine is excreted
from the body in the urine and is also lost from the body, along with sodium and
potassium, in perspiration.
A dietary deficiency of chlorine may lead to an abnormal increase of the alkali reserve of the blood (alkalosis) caused by an excess of bicarbonate, since inadequate
levels of chlorine in the body are partly compensated for by increases in bicarbonate. Experiments with rats on chlorine-deficient diets have shown that growth was
retarded, but no other symptoms developed.
Sources of chlorine
With the exception of fishmeals, the chlorine content of most foods is comparatively
low. The chlorine content of pasture grass varies widely and figures ranging from
3 g/kg to 25 g/kg DM have been reported. The main source of this element for most
animals is common salt.
Salt
Since plants tend to be low in both sodium and chlorine, it is the usual practice to
give common salt to herbivores. Unless salt is available, deficiencies are likely to
occur in both cattle and sheep. Experiments carried out in the USA with dairy cows
on salt-deficient diets showed that animals did not exhibit immediate ill effects, but
eventually appetite declined, with subsequent loss in weight and lowered milk production. The addition of salt to the diet produced an immediate cure.
Salt is also important in the diet of hens, and it is known to counteract feather picking and cannibalism. Salt is generally given to pigs on vegetable diets, but if fishmeal is
given the need for added salt is reduced. Swill can also be a rich source of salt, although the product is very variable and can contain excessive amounts of salt. Too
much salt in the diet is definitely harmful and causes excessive thirst, muscular weakness and oedema. Salt poisoning is quite common in pigs and poultry, especially where
fresh drinking water is limited. When the concentration of salt in the diet of hens exceeds 40 g/kg DM and the supply of drinking water is limited, then death may occur.
Hens can tolerate larger amounts of salt if plenty of water is available. Chicks cannot
tolerate salt as well as adults can, and 20 g/kg DM in the diet should be regarded as the
absolute maximum.This value should also not be exceeded in the diets of pigs.Turkey
poults are even less tolerant, and 10 g/kg of salt in the diet should not be exceeded.
Sulphur
Most of the sulphur in the animal body occurs in proteins containing the amino acids
cystine, cysteine and methionine. The two vitamins biotin and thiamin, the hormone
insulin and the important metabolite coenzyme A also contain sulphur.The structural
117
Chapter 6 Minerals
compound chondroitin sulphate is a component of cartilage, bone, tendons and the
walls of blood vessels. Sulphur-containing compounds are also important in elements
of the respiratory process from haemoglobin through to cytochromes. Only a small
amount of sulphur is present in the body in inorganic form, though sulphates are
known to occur in the blood in small quantities. Wool is rich in cystine and contains
about 4 per cent of sulphur.
Traditionally, little attention has been paid to the importance of sulphur in animal nutrition, since the intake of this element is mainly in the form of protein, and
a deficiency of sulphur would indicate a protein deficiency. In recent years, however, with the increasing use of urea as a partial nitrogen replacement for protein
nitrogen and as a method for treating cereal grains (see Chapter 22), it has been
realised that the amount of sulphur present in the diet may be the limiting factor for
the synthesis in the rumen of cystine, cysteine and methionine. Under these conditions, the addition of sulphur to urea-containing rations is beneficial. There is evidence that sulphate (as sodium sulphate) can be used by ruminal microorganisms
more efficiently than elemental sulphur. The mean of the estimates of the ratio of
sulphur to nitrogen in microbial protein is around 0.07, which, incidentally, is approximately the ratio found in animal tissue and milk protein. The UK Agricultural
Research Council has recommended that the requirement for rumen-degradable
sulphur should be calculated by multiplying the rumen-degradable nitrogen requirement by 0.07 (i.e. equivalent to a N : S ratio of 14 : 1). The ratio of nitrogen to
sulphur in wool protein is narrower, at 5 : 1, and the supply of sulphur-containing
amino acids may be limiting for sheep with a high rate of wool production. This
limitation cannot be overcome by increasing the ratio of rumen-degradable sulphur
to degradable nitrogen, since this will not alter the rate of microbial protein production. However, the limitation can be alleviated by supplying sulphur containing
amino acids in forms that bypass the rumen or in proteins that have low rumen
degradability.
Consideration of sulphur in animal nutrition is important in areas of intensive
livestock production where sulphur in soils is not replaced regularly by fertiliser
application.
Inorganic sulphur seems to be of less practical importance for monogastric
animals, although studies with pigs, chicks and poults have indicated that inorganic
sulphate can have a sparing effect on the requirement for sulphur-containing amino
acids in the diet.
Toxicity can result from excess dietary sulphur, which is converted to hydrogen
sulphide, a toxic agent, by the gastrointestinal flora.This reduces rumen motility and
causes nervous and respiratory distress.
Magnesium
Magnesium is closely associated with calcium and phosphorus. About 70 per cent
of the total magnesium is found in the skeleton but the remainder, which is distributed in the soft tissues and fluids, is of crucial importance to the well-being of the
animal. Magnesium is the commonest enzyme activator, for example in systems
with thiamin pyrophosphate as a cofactor, and oxidative phosphorylation is reduced in magnesium deficiency. Magnesium is an essential activator of phosphate
transferases (e.g. creatine kinase) and it activates pyruvate carboxylase, pyruvate
oxidase and reactions of the tricarboxylic acid cycle; therefore, it is essential for the
118
Major elements
efficient metabolism of carbohydrates and lipids. In addition, magnesium is involved in cellular respiration and many other cellular reactions, forming complexes
with adenosine tri-, di- and monophosphates. The formation of cyclic AMP and
other secondary messengers requires magnesium. Magnesium ions moderate neuromuscular activity and, through binding to phospholipid, are involved in cell membrane integrity. The interaction of parathyroid hormone, which is responsible for
calcium mobilisation (see p. 112), with its receptors on bone and kidney cells involves magnesium, and low blood levels of the element are associated with
hypocalcaemia. Thus, it can be seen that magnesium is a key element in cellular
biochemistry and function. Magnesium is absorbed from the small and large intestine of monogastric animals, and requirements are usually met with cereal and soya
bean meal diets. In ruminants, absorbability can be low and potassium reduces the
efficiency of absorption by inhibiting the two active transport systems in the rumen
wall that carry magnesium against the electrochemical gradient. Potassium does not
affect absorption beyond the rumen.
Deficiency symptoms
Symptoms due to a simple deficiency of magnesium in the diet have been reported
for a number of animals. In rats fed on purified diets, the symptoms include increased nervous irritability and convulsions. Experimental low-magnesium milk
diets for calves caused low serum magnesium levels, depleted bone magnesium,
tetany and death.The condition is not uncommon in milk-fed calves about 50–70 days
old. Colostrum is high in magnesium content but milk is low in magnesium, and this
is compounded by a reduction in the efficiency of absorption of magnesium as the
calf ages.
In adult ruminants, a condition known as hypomagnesaemic tetany, associated
with low blood levels of magnesium (hypomagnesaemia), has been recognised since
the early 1930s. A great deal of attention has been given to this condition in recent
years, since it is widespread and the death rate is high. Hypomagnesaemic tetany has
been known under a variety of names, including magnesium tetany, lactation tetany
and grass staggers, but most of these terms have been discarded because the disease
is not always associated with lactation or with grazing animals.The condition can affect stall-fed dairy cattle, hill cattle, cattle at grass, and sheep.There is some evidence
of a breed susceptibility in the UK, where the condition appears to be more common
in Ayrshire and least common in Jersey animals. Most cases occur in grazing animals
and, in Europe and North America, the trouble is particularly common in the spring
when the animals are turned out on to young, succulent pasture. Because the tetany
can develop within a day or two of animals being turned out to graze, the condition
has been referred to as the acute form. In this acute type, blood magnesium levels
fall so rapidly that the reserve of magnesium within the body cannot be mobilised
rapidly enough. In the chronic form of the disease, plasma magnesium levels fall over
a period of time to low concentrations. This type is not uncommon in suckler herds.
Clinical signs of the disease are often brought on by stress factors such as cold, wet
and windy weather. In adult animals, bone magnesium is not as readily available as
it is in the young calf.
In New Zealand, where cows are pastured throughout the year, hypomagnesaemic tetany occurs most frequently in late winter and early spring. In Australia, a
high incidence of the disease has been associated with periods of rapid winter
growth of pastures.
119
Chapter 6 Minerals
The normal magnesium content of blood serum in cattle is within the range of
17–40 mg magnesium/litre, but levels below 17 mg/l frequently occur without
clinical symptoms of disease. Tetany is usually preceded by a fall in blood serum
magnesium to about 5 mg/l. Urine magnesium is a better indicator of deficiency
than serum magnesium because levels of the latter do not fall until there is a
severe deficiency. However, a lack of magnesium is immediately reflected in urine
levels, for which 10 mg/100 ml is satisfactory, 2–10 mg/100 ml is inadequate and
less than 2 mg/100 ml indicates a severe deficiency. Subcutaneous injection of
magnesium sulphate, or preferably magnesium lactate, can generally be expected
to cure the animal if given early, but in practice this is sometimes difficult. Treatment of this kind is not a permanent cure and oral treatment with magnesium
oxide, as described below, should be started immediately. Typical symptoms of
tetany are nervousness, tremors, twitching of the facial muscles, staggering gait
and convulsions.
The exact cause of hypomagnesaemic tetany in ruminant animals is unknown,
although a dietary deficiency of magnesium may be a contributory factor. Some
research workers consider the condition to be caused by a cation–anion imbalance
in the diet, and there is evidence of a positive relationship between tetany and
heavy dressings of pasture with nitrogenous and potassic fertilisers. It has been
suggested that the concentration of potassium in spring pasture should not exceed
25 g/kg DM and the application of potassium fertilisers should be managed
carefully.
The use of radioactive magnesium in tracer studies indicates that the magnesium present in food is poorly absorbed from the alimentary canal; in some cases
only 50 g/kg of the herbage magnesium can be utilised by the ruminant. Why this
is so in ruminants is not known. Since adult animals have only very small readily
available reserves of body magnesium, they are dependent upon a regular dietary
supply.
Although the exact cause of hypomagnesaemia is still uncertain, the primary factor would appear to be inadequate absorption of magnesium from the digestive
tract. A high degree of success in preventing hypomagnesaemia may be obtained by
increasing the magnesium intake. This can be effected by feeding with magnesiumrich mineral mixtures or, alternatively, by increasing the magnesium content of pasture by the application of magnesium fertilisers.
Sources of magnesium
Wheat bran, dried yeast and most vegetable protein concentrates, especially cotton
seed cake and linseed cake, are good sources of magnesium. Clovers are usually
richer in magnesium than grasses, although the magnesium content of forage crops
varies widely.As mentioned previously, draff is deficient in soluble minerals and high
levels of this food in the diet require appropriate supplementation. The mineral supplement used most frequently is magnesium oxide, which is sold commercially as
calcined magnesite. When hypomagnesaemic tetany is likely to occur, it is generally
considered that about 50 g of magnesium oxide per head per day should be given to
cows as a prophylactic measure. The daily prophylactic dose for calves is 7–15 g of
the oxide, while that for lactating ewes is about 7 g. The mineral supplement can be
given mixed with the concentrate ration. Alternatively, a mixture of magnesium
acetate solution and molasses can be used, which is frequently made available on a
free-choice basis from ball feeders placed in the field.
120
Trace elements
6.5
TRACE ELEMENTS
Iron
More than 90 per cent of the iron in the body is combined with proteins, the most
important being haemoglobin, which contains about 3.4 g/kg of the element. Iron
also occurs in blood serum in a protein called transferrin, which is concerned with
the transport of iron from one part of the body to another. Ferritin, a protein containing up to 200 g/kg of iron, is present in the spleen, liver, kidney and bone marrow and provides a form of storage for iron. Haemosiderin is a similar storage
compound and may contain up to 350 g/kg of iron. Iron has a major role in a host of
biochemical reactions, particularly in connection with enzymes of the electron transport chain (cytochromes). Electrons are transported by the oxidation and reduction
activity of bound iron. Among the enzymes containing or activated by iron are catalase, peroxidases, phenylalanine hydroxylase and many others, including all the tricarboxylic acid cycle enzymes.
Deficiency symptoms
Since more than half the iron present in the body occurs as haemoglobin, a dietary deficiency of iron would clearly be expected to affect the formation of this compound.
The red blood corpuscles contain haemoglobin, and these cells are continually being
produced in the bone marrow to replace those red cells destroyed in the animal body
as a result of catabolism. Although the haemoglobin molecule is destroyed in the catabolism of these red blood corpuscles, the iron liberated is made use of in the resynthesis of haemoglobin, and because of this the daily requirement of iron by a healthy
animal is usually small. If the need for iron increases, as it does after prolonged haemorrhage or during pregnancy, then haemoglobin synthesis may be inadequate and
anaemia will result. Anaemia due to iron deficiency occurs most commonly in rapidly
growing sucklings, since the iron content of milk is usually very low. This can occur in
piglets housed in pens without access to soil. The piglet is born with very limited iron
reserves and sow’s milk provides only about 1 mg per day.The rapidly growing piglet’s
requirement is 15 mg per day, which, in extensive systems, could be obtained by ingestion of soil. Providing the sow with supplementary iron in gestation does not increase
the foetal piglet’s liver iron or the amount in the milk. Therefore, it is routinely supplied by intramuscular injection as a dextran complex or gleptoferron, by 3 days of
age. Usually 200 mg of iron is injected. Alternatively, oral iron supplements are available in the form of a paste of the citrate or fumarate or granules of iron dextran, but
these may not be eaten or the iron may be lost if diarrhoea occurs.Attempts have been
made to increase the supply of iron to the piglet by supplementing the sow’s diet and
relying on the piglet’s consumption of the sow’s faeces during exploration activity.
However, this has produced uneven uptake, and injection of iron compounds is more
effective. Anaemia in piglets is characterised by poor appetite and growth. Breathing
becomes laboured and spasmodic – hence the descriptive term ‘thumps’ for this condition. Although iron deficiency is not common in older animals, increased supplementation is required when high levels of copper are used for growth promotion.
Iron-deficiency anaemia is not common in lambs and calves because in practice it
is unusual to restrict them to a milk diet without supplementary feeding. It does,
however, sometimes occur in laying hens, since egg production represents a considerable drain on the body reserves.
121
Chapter 6 Minerals
Sources of iron
Iron is widely distributed in foods. Good sources of the element are green leafy materials, most leguminous plants and seed coats. Feeds of animal origin, such as blood
and fishmeals, are excellent sources of iron. As mentioned previously, milk is a poor
source of the element.
Iron is absorbed throughout the gastrointestinal tract, but mainly in the duodenum and jejunum. Absorption is poor and is, to a large extent, independent of the
dietary source. The efficiency of absorption is increased during periods of iron need
and decreased during periods of iron overload. The mechanisms whereby the body
carries this out are not fully understood. A number of theories have been advanced
and one of these, the ‘mucosal block’ theory, propounded in 1943, is still widely held
by many to explain the mechanism. According to this theory, the mucosal cells of the
gastrointestinal tract absorb iron and convert it into ferritin; when the cells become
physiologically saturated with ferritin, further absorption is impeded until the iron is
released and transferred to plasma. Another, more recent theory proposes that the
main regulator of iron uptake is the iron concentration in the epithelial cells of the
duodenal mucosa.
The adult’s need for iron is normally low, as the iron produced from the destruction of haemoglobin is made available for haemoglobin regeneration, only about
10 per cent of the element escaping from this cycle.
Iron toxicity
Iron toxicity is not a common problem in farm animals, but it can result from prolonged oral administration of the element. Ferrous ions are reported to generate
oxygen-based free radicals, contributing to oxidative stress in the cell (see Chapter 5).
Normally iron is protein-bound or in chemical form, which prevents it from causing
oxidation. Chronic iron toxicity results in alimentary disturbances, reduced growth
and phosphorus deficiency.
Copper
Evidence that copper is a dietary essential was obtained in 1924, when experiments with rats showed that copper was necessary for haemoglobin formation. Although copper is not actually a constituent of haemoglobin, it is present in certain
other plasma proteins, such as ceruloplasmin, concerned with the release of iron
from the cells into the plasma. A deficiency of copper impairs the animal’s ability
to absorb iron, mobilise it from the tissues and utilise it in haemoglobin synthesis.
Copper is also a component of other proteins in blood. One of these, erythrocuprein, occurs in erythrocytes, where it plays a role in oxygen metabolism. The
element is also known to play a vital role in many enzyme systems; for example,
copper is a component of cytochrome oxidase, which is important in oxidative
phosphorylation. It is also a component of superoxide dismutase, which forms part
of the cell’s antioxidant system. The element also occurs in certain pigments,
notably turacin, a pigment of feathers. Copper is necessary for the normal pigmentation of hair, fur and wool. It is thought to be present in all body cells, being
particularly concentrated in the liver, which acts as the main copper storage organ
of the body. Copper has been shown to reduce the susceptibility to infection in
lambs directly.
122
Trace elements
Deficiency symptoms
Since copper performs many functions in the animal body, there are a variety of deficiency symptoms. These include anaemia, poor growth, bone disorders, scouring,
infertility, depigmentation of hair and wool, gastrointestinal disturbances, and lesions in the brain stem and spinal cord. The lesions are associated with muscular incoordination and occur, especially, in young lambs. A copper deficiency condition
known as ‘enzootic ataxia’ has been known for some time in Australia; the disorder
there is associated with pastures low in copper content (2–4 mg/kg DM) and can be
prevented by feeding with a copper salt.A similar condition that affects lambs occurs
in the UK and is known as ‘swayback’. The signs of swayback range from complete
paralysis of the newborn lamb to a swaying staggering gait that affects, in particular,
the hind limbs. The condition can occur in two forms, one congenital, in which the
signs are apparent at birth and are due to the failure of the myelin sheath of nerves
to develop, and the other in which the onset of the clinical disease is delayed for several weeks.The congenital form of the condition is irreversible and can be prevented
only by ensuring that the ewe receives an adequate level of copper in her diet. Delayed swayback can be prevented or retarded in copper-deficient lambs by parenteral injection of small doses of copper complexes.
Although the dietary level of copper is an important factor in the aetiology of
swayback, the condition does not appear to be invariably caused by a simple dietary
deficiency of the element. Swayback has been reported to occur on pastures apparently normal or even high (7–15 mg/kg DM) in copper content. One important factor
is that the efficiency of absorption of dietary copper is very variable. For example,
there is about a tenfold variation in the efficiency with which Scottish Blackface ewes
absorb copper from autumn pasture (1.2 per cent) and from leafy brassicas (13.2 per
cent). It is also known that genetic factors influence the concentration of copper in the
blood, liver and brain of the sheep, and hence the incidence of swayback can be
affected by genotype. Blackface lambs given a copper-supplemented barley and
fishmeal diet retained 6 per cent of the dietary copper in the liver, whereas Texel
lambs retained 13 per cent. Finnish Landrace and Suffolk lambs were intermediate,
at 8–9 per cent retention.
Copper plays an important role in the production of ‘crimp’ in wool. The element
is present in an enzyme that is responsible for the disulphide bridge in two adjacent
cysteine molecules. In the absence of the enzyme, the protein molecules of the wool
do not form their bridge and the wool, which lacks crimp, is referred to as ‘stringy’ or
‘steely’ (see p. 375).
Nutritional anaemia resulting from copper deficiency has been produced experimentally in young pigs by diets very low in the element, and this type of anaemia
could easily arise in such animals fed solely on milk. In older animals, copper deficiency is unlikely to occur and copper supplementation of practical rations is generally considered unnecessary. There are, however, certain areas in the world where
copper deficiency in cattle occurs. A condition in Australia known locally as ‘falling
disease’ was found to be related to a progressive degeneration of the myocardium of
animals grazing on copper-deficient pastures.
Copper–molybdenum–sulphur interrelations
Certain pastures on calcareous soils in parts of England and Wales have been known
for over 100 years to be associated with a condition in cattle known as ‘teart’, which
123
Chapter 6 Minerals
is characterised by unthriftiness and scouring.A similar disorder occurs on reclaimed
peat lands in New Zealand, where it is known as ‘peat scours’. Molybdenum levels in
teart pasture are of the order of 20–100 mg/kg DM compared with 0.5–3.0 mg/kg DM
in normal pastures, and teart was originally regarded as being a straightforward
molybdenosis. In the late 1930s, however, it was demonstrated that feeding with
copper sulphate controlled the scouring and hence a molybdenum–copper relationship was established.
It is now known that the effect of molybdenum is complex, and it is considered
that the element exerts its limiting effect on copper retention in the animal only in
the presence of sulphur. Sulphide is formed by ruminal microorganisms from dietary
sulphate or organic sulphur compounds; the sulphide then reacts with molybdate to
form thiomolybdate, which in turn combines with copper to form an insoluble copper thiomolybdate (CuMoS4), thereby limiting the absorption of dietary copper. In
addition, it is considered likely that if thiomolybdate is formed in excess, it may be
absorbed from the digestive tract and exert a systemic effect on copper metabolism
in the animal.
Sources of copper
Copper is widely distributed in foods, and under normal conditions the diet of farm
animals is likely to contain adequate amounts.The copper content of crops is related
to some extent to the soil copper level, but it is also affected by other factors such as
drainage conditions and the herbage species. Seeds and seed by-products are usually
rich in copper, but straws contain little.The normal copper content of pasture ranges
from about 4 mg/kg to 8 mg/kg DM. The copper content of milk is low, and hence it
is customary when dosing young animals, especially piglets, with an iron salt to include a trace of copper sulphate.
Copper toxicity
It has long been known that copper salts given in excess to animals are toxic. Continuous ingestion of copper in excess of nutritional requirements leads to an accumulation of the element in the body tissues, especially in the liver. Copper can be
regarded as a cumulative poison, so that considerable care is required in administering copper salts to animals. The tolerance to copper varies considerably between
species. Pigs are highly tolerant (see Box 6.3) and cattle relatively so. On the other
BOX 6.3 Copper as growth promoter
In the late 1950s and early 1960s Barber, Braude, Mitchell and their colleagues at the National Institute for Research in Dairying at Reading demonstrated that pigs given high levels of copper (up to
250 mg/kg) in the diet had faster growth rates and better food conversion efficiency than unsupplemented pigs. Most of this copper is not absorbed but passes through the digestive tract, achieving its
effect by altering the microbial population in much the same way as antibiotic growth promoters, although its effect is independent of and in addition to that caused by antibiotics.
Concern about pollution of the environment has resulted in restrictions on the use of copper
as a growth promoter in Europe. The maximum permitted dietary level is 170 mg/kg for pigs up to
12 weeks of age, and then it must be reduced to 35 mg/kg as for other classes of pig. Furthermore, it
is essential that sheep do not have access to pasture that has recently been fertilised with pig slurry.
124
Trace elements
hand, sheep are particularly susceptible and chronic copper poisoning has been encountered in housed sheep on concentrate diets. There is a gradual accumulation of
copper in the liver of sheep until the danger level of about 1000 mg/kg fat-free DM
is reached. Poisoning has been known to occur in areas where the herbage contains
copper of the order of 10–20 mg/kg DM and low levels of molybdenum. Chronic
copper poisoning results in necrosis of the liver cells, jaundice, loss of appetite and
death from hepatic coma. The slow accumulation of copper in the liver causes damage to the organ without overt symptoms. There is leakage of enzymes from the
damaged cells into the blood. Eventually there is a sudden release of copper and
haemolysis, which can occur spontaneously or as a result of stressors such as parturition or infection. There is a genetic variation in animals’ susceptibility to copper
poisoning related to the efficiency of retention, with the Scottish Blackface being the
least susceptible and continental breeds, such as the Texel, being highly susceptible.
The EU maximum permitted level for copper in sheep diets is 15 mg/kg – this should
not be exceeded if toxicity is to be avoided. For susceptible breeds, a dietary level of
10 mg/kg can be excessive. It is unwise to administer copper supplements to sheep
unless deficiency conditions are liable to occur – many cases of death due to copper
poisoning caused by the indiscriminate use of copper-fortified diets have been reported. Chronic copper poisoning in sheep has occurred under natural conditions in
parts of Australia where the copper content of the pasture is high. Care should be
taken when sheep are given antiprotozoal compounds such as monensin, which may
eliminate the protozoa that produce the sulphide that normally reduces copper
availability.
Cobalt
A number of disorders of cattle and sheep, characterised by emaciation, anaemia
and listlessness, have been recognised for many years and have been described as
‘pining’, ‘salt sick’, ‘bush sickness’ and ‘wasting disease’. These disorders occur in
Europe, Australia, New Zealand and the USA. In the UK, ‘pining pastures’ occur in
many counties and are particularly common in the border counties of England and
Scotland.
As early as 1807, Hogg, an Ettrick shepherd, recognised pining or ‘vinquish’ as
being a dietary upset. Pining is associated with a dietary deficiency of cobalt caused
by low concentrations of the element in the soil and herbage. Pining can be prevented in these areas by feeding with small amounts of cobalt.
The physiological function of cobalt was discovered only when vitamin B12 was
isolated and was shown to contain the element. Cobalt is required by microorganisms in the rumen for the synthesis of vitamin B12; if the element is deficient in the
diet, then the vitamin cannot be produced in the rumen in amounts sufficient to satisfy the animal’s requirements and symptoms of pining occur. Pining is therefore regarded as being due to a deficiency of vitamin B12. There is evidence for this, since
injections of vitamin B12 into the blood alleviate the condition, whereas cobalt injections have little beneficial effect. Although vitamin B12 therapy will prevent pining
occurring in ruminant animals, it is more convenient and cheaper in cobalt-deficient
areas to supplement the diet with the element, allowing the microorganisms in the
rumen to synthesise the vitamin for subsequent absorption by the host.
When ruminants are confined to cobalt-deficient pastures it may be several
months before any manifestations of pine occur because of body reserves of vitamin
125
Chapter 6 Minerals
B12 in the liver and kidneys. When these are depleted there is a gradual decrease in
appetite, with consequent loss of weight followed by muscular wasting, pica, severe
anaemia and eventually death. If the deficiency is less severe, then a vague unthriftiness, difficult to diagnose, may be the only sign. Deficiency symptoms are likely to
occur where levels of cobalt in the herbage are below 0.1 mg/kg DM. Under grazing
conditions, lambs are the most sensitive to cobalt deficiency, followed by mature
sheep, calves and mature cattle in that order.
Ruminants have a higher requirement for the element than non-ruminants because some of the element is wasted in microbial synthesis of organic compounds
with no physiological activity in the host’s tissues. Furthermore, vitamin B12 is
poorly absorbed from the digestive tract of ruminants, the availability in some cases
being as low as 0.03.The ruminant has an additional requirement for the vitamin because of its involvement in the metabolism of propionic acid (see p. 202), an important acid absorbed from the rumen.
There is evidence that the intestinal microorganisms in non-ruminants also can
synthesise vitamin B12, although in pigs and poultry this synthesis may be insufficient to meet their requirements. It is common practice to include in pig and poultry
diets some animal protein food rich in vitamin B12 and/or a vitamin supplement, in
preference to including a cobalt salt.
Apart from the importance of cobalt as a component of vitamin B12, the element
is believed to have other functions in the animal body as an activating ion in certain
enzyme reactions.
Sources of cobalt
Most foods contain traces of cobalt. Normal pasture herbages have a cobalt content
within the range 100–250 µg/kg DM.
Cobalt deficiency in ruminants can be prevented by dosing the animals with a solution of cobalt salts, although this form of treatment has to be repeated at short intervals and precautions must be taken when handling the solution (see below).
Alternatively the animals can be given access to cobalt-containing salt licks. A continuous supply from a single dose can be obtained by giving a cobalt bullet containing 900 g cobaltic oxide/kg; the bullet remains in the reticulum and slowly releases
the element over a long period. Some of this cobalt is not utilised by the animal and
is excreted, and this of course has the effect of improving the cobalt status of the pasture.Alternatively, deficient pastures can be treated with cobalt-containing fertilisers
or with small amounts of cobalt salt solutions.
Cobalt toxicity
Although an excess of cobalt can be toxic to animals, there is a wide margin of
safety between the nutritional requirement and the toxic level. Cobalt toxicosis is
extremely unlikely to occur under practical farming conditions. Unlike copper,
cobalt is poorly retained by the body tissues and an excess of the element is soon excreted. The toxic level of cobalt for cattle is 1 mg cobalt/kg body weight daily. Sheep
are less susceptible to cobalt toxicosis than cattle and have been shown to tolerate
levels up to 3.5 mg/kg. Excessive cobalt supplementation of ruminant diets can lead
to the production of analogues of vitamin B12 and a reduction in the quantity of the
true vitamin. Cobalt compounds pose a risk to human health as they cause cancer if
inhaled and they irritate the skin; for this reason, their use has been restricted in the
126
Trace elements
EU, where materials with more than 100 mg Co/kg must be labelled as hazardous
and should be handled only with appropriate personal protection equipment. The
European Food Safety Authority has recommended that the supplementation of
diets for farm animals with cobalt be limited to ruminants (except milk replacers),
horses and rabbits at a level of 0.3 mg/kg DM of supplemental cobalt, and the maximum amount permitted in the complete diet in the EU is 2 mg/kg DM.
Iodine
The concentration of iodine present in the animal body is very small and in the adult
is usually less than 600 µg/kg. Although the element is distributed throughout the
tissues and secretions, its only known role is in the synthesis of the two hormones,
triiodothyronine (T3) and tetraiodothyronine (T4, thyroxine) produced in the thyroid
gland (see p. 54).
Iodine is removed from iodides in the blood and combined with the amino acid tyrosine to form monoiodotyrosine (T1) and diiodotyrosine (T2).Two molecules of T2 are
condensed to produce T4, the physiologically inactive transport form of the hormone,
which is stored in the thyroid gland.T4 is released into the blood capillaries as required
and is activated by deiodinase enzymes to produce the physiologically active T3. The
enzymes are selenium-dependent (see p. 131) and occur in the periphery where the
hormone is needed, mainly in the liver and kidneys but also in the skin.
The thyroid hormones accelerate reactions in most organs and tissues in the body,
thus increasing the basal metabolic rate, accelerating growth and increasing the oxygen consumption of the whole organism. They also control the development of the
foetus and are involved in immune defence, digestion, muscle function and seasonality of reproduction.
Deficiency symptoms
When the diet contains insufficient iodine, the production of thyroxine is decreased. The main indication of such a deficiency is an enlargement of the thyroid
gland, termed endemic goitre, and is caused by compensatory hypertrophy of the
gland. As the thyroid is situated in the neck, the deficiency condition in farm animals manifests itself as a swelling of the neck, so-called ‘big neck’. Reproductive abnormalities are one of the most outstanding consequences of reduced thyroid
function; breeding animals deficient in iodine give birth to hairless, weak or dead
young; brain development is impaired; oestrus is suppressed or irregular; and male
fertility is reduced.
A dietary deficiency of iodine is not the sole cause of goitre: it is known that certain foods contain goitrogenic compounds and cause goitre in animals if given in
large amounts. These foods include most members of the Brassica genus, especially
kale, cabbage and rape, and also soya beans, linseed, peas and groundnuts. Goitrogens have been reported in milk of cows fed on goitrogenic plants. A goitrogen present in brassicas has been identified as L-5-vinyl-2-oxazolidine-2-thione (goitrin),
which inhibits the iodination of tyrosine and thus interferes with thyroxine synthesis.Therefore, it cannot be overcome by adding more iodine to the diet.Thiocyanate,
which may also be present in members of the Brassica genus, is known to be goitrogenic and may be produced in the tissues from a cyanogenetic glycoside present in
some foods. Goitrogenic activity of the thiocyanate type is prevented by supplying
127
Chapter 6 Minerals
adequate iodine in the diet. It has been reported that high dietary nitrate levels inhibit the uptake of iodine.
Sources of iodine
Iodine occurs in traces in most foods and is present mainly as inorganic iodide, in
which form it is absorbed from the digestive tract.The richest sources of this element
are foods of marine origin, and values as high as 6 g/kg DM have been reported for
some seaweeds; fishmeal is also a rich source of iodine. The iodine content of land
plants is related to the amount of iodine present in the soil, and consequently wide
variations occur in similar crops grown in different areas.
In areas where goitre is endemic, precautions are generally taken by supplementing the diet with the element, usually in the form of iodised salt. This contains the
element either as sodium or potassium iodide or as sodium iodate.
Iodine toxicity
The minimum toxic dietary level of iodine for calves of 80–112 kg body weight has
been shown to be about 50 mg/kg, although some experimental animals have been
adversely affected at lower levels. Symptoms of toxicity include depressions in
weight gain and feed intake. In studies with laying hens, diets with iodine contents of
312–5000 mg/kg DM stopped egg production within the first week at the higher
level and reduced egg production at the lower level. The fertility of the eggs produced was not affected, but early embryonic death, reduced hatchability and delayed
hatching resulted. Excessively high levels of iodine supplementation should be
avoided in diets for ewes in pregnancy because this has resulted in lambs with a reduced ability to absorb immunoglobulins and vitamin E from colostrum. Pigs seem
to be more tolerant of excess iodine and the minimum toxic level is considered to lie
between 400 mg/kg and 800 mg/kg.
Manganese
The amount of manganese present in the animal body is extremely small. Most tissues
contain traces of the element, the highest concentrations occurring in the bones, liver,
kidney, pancreas and pituitary gland. Manganese is important in the animal body as
an activator of many enzymes such as hydrolases and kinases and as a constituent of
arginase, pyruvate carboxylase and manganese superoxide dismutase.
Deficiency symptoms
Manganese deficiency has been found in ruminants, pigs and poultry. The effects of
acute deficiency are similar in all species and include retarded growth, skeletal abnormalities, ataxia of the newborn and reproductive failure. Manganese, through its
activation of glycosyl transferases, is required for the formation of the mucopolysaccharide that forms the organic matrix of bone.
Deficiencies of manganese in grazing ruminants are likely to be rare, although the
reproductive performance of grazing Dorset Horn ewes in Australia was improved by
giving manganese over two consecutive years. Low-manganese diets for cows and
goats have been reported to depress or delay oestrus and conception, and to increase
abortion. Manganese is an important element in the diet of young chicks, a deficiency leading to perosis or ‘slipped tendon’, a malformation of the leg bones. Manganese deficiency is not, however, the only factor involved in the aetiology of this
128
Trace elements
condition, as perosis in young birds may be aggravated by high dietary intakes of calcium and phosphorus or a deficiency of choline. Another link between manganese
and choline deficiencies is shown in fatty infiltration of the liver and changes in the
ultrastructure of the liver.
Manganese deficiency in breeding birds reduces hatchability and shell thickness,
and in chicks causes head retraction. In pigs, lameness is a symptom. Other abnormalities associated with manganese deficiency include impaired glucose utilisation
and a reduced vitamin K-induced blood-clotting response.
Sources of manganese
The element is widely distributed in foods, and most forages contain 40–200 mg/kg
DM. The manganese content of pasture herbages, however, can vary over a much
wider range and in acid conditions may be as high as 500–600 mg/kg DM. Seeds and
seed products contain moderate amounts, except for maize, which is low in the element.Yeast and most foods of animal origin are also poor sources of manganese. Rich
sources are rice bran and wheat offals. Most green foods contain adequate amounts.
Manganese toxicity
There is a wide margin of safety between the toxic dose of manganese and the normal level in foods. Levels as high as 1 g/kg DM in the diet have been given to hens
without evidence of toxicity. Growing pigs are less tolerant, levels of 0.5 g/kg DM
having been shown to depress appetite and retard growth.
Zinc
Zinc has been found in every tissue in the animal body. The element tends to accumulate in the bones rather than the liver, which is the main storage organ of many of
the other trace elements. High concentrations have been found in the skin, hair and
wool of animals. Several enzymes in the animal body are known to contain zinc;
these enzymes include carbonic anhydrase, pancreatic carboxypeptidase, lactate dehydrogenase, alcohol dehydrogenase, alkaline phosphatase and thymidine kinase. In
addition, zinc is an activator of several enzyme systems. It is involved in cell replication and differentiation, particularly in nucleic acid metabolism. Among the other
physiological functions of zinc are the production, storage and secretion of hormones, involvement in the immune system and electrolyte balance.
Deficiency symptoms
Zinc deficiency in pigs is characterised by subnormal growth, depressed appetite,
poor food conversion and parakeratosis. The latter is a reddening of the skin followed by eruptions that develop into scabs. A deficiency of this element is particularly liable to occur in young, intensively housed pigs offered a dry diet ad libitum,
though a similar diet given wet may not cause the condition. It is aggravated by high
calcium levels in the diet and reduced by decreased calcium and increased phosphorus levels. Pigs given a diet supplemented with high levels of copper, for growth promotion, have an increased requirement for zinc. Gross signs of zinc deficiency in
chicks are retarded growth, foot abnormalities, ‘frizzled’ feathers, parakeratosis and
a bone abnormality referred to as ‘swollen hock syndrome’.
Symptoms of zinc deficiency in calves include inflammation of the nose and
mouth, stiffness of the joints, swollen feet and parakeratosis.The response of severely
129
Chapter 6 Minerals
zinc-deficient calves to supplemental zinc is rapid and dramatic. Improvements in
skin condition are usually noted within 2–3 days.
Manifestations of zinc deficiency, responsive to zinc therapy, have been observed
in growing and mature cattle in parts of Guyana, Greece, Australia and Scandinavia.
As levels in the pasture herbage are apparently comparable with those of other
areas, the deficiency is believed to be conditioned by some factor in the herbage or
general environment. In dairy cows, low dietary zinc concentrations are associated
with high somatic cell counts in their milk.
Sources of zinc
The element is fairly widely distributed. Yeast is a rich source, and zinc is concentrated in the bran and germ of cereal grains.Animal protein by-products, such as fishmeal, are usually richer sources of the element than are plant protein supplements.
Zinc toxicity
Although cases of zinc poisoning have been reported, most animals have a high tolerance for this element. Excessive amounts of zinc in the diet are known to depress
food consumption and may induce copper deficiency.
Molybdenum
The first indication of an essential metabolic role for molybdenum was obtained in
1953, when it was discovered that xanthine oxidase, important in purine metabolism, was a metalloenzyme containing molybdenum. Subsequently the element was
shown to be a component of two other enzymes, aldehyde oxidase and sulphite
oxidase.The biological functions of molybdenum, apart from its reactions with copper
(see p. 123), are concerned with the formation and activities of these three enzymes.
In addition to being a component of xanthine oxidase, molybdenum participates in the
reaction of the enzyme with cytochrome C and also facilitates the reduction of
cytochrome C by aldehyde oxidase.
Deficiency symptoms
In early studies with rats, low-molybdenum diets resulted in reduced levels of xanthine oxidase but did not affect growth or purine metabolism. Similar molybdenumdeficient diets have been given to chicks without adverse effects, but when tungstate
(a molybdenum antagonist) was added, growth was reduced and the chick’s ability to
oxidise xanthine to uric acid was impaired. These effects were prevented by the addition of molybdenum to the diet. A significant growth response has been obtained
in young lambs by the addition of molybdate to a semi-purified diet low in the element. It has been suggested that this growth effect could have arisen indirectly by
stimulation of cellulose breakdown by ruminal microorganisms. Molybdenum deficiency has not been observed under natural conditions in any species.
Molybdenum toxicity
The toxic role of molybdenum in the condition known as ‘teart’ is described under
the section on copper (see p. 123). All cattle are susceptible to molybdenosis, with
milking cows and young animals suffering most. Sheep are less affected and horses
are not affected on teart pastures. Scouring and weight loss are the dominant manifestations of the toxicity.
130
Trace elements
Selenium
The nutritional importance of selenium became evident in the 1950s, when it was
shown that most myopathies in sheep and cattle, and exudative diathesis in
chicks, could be prevented by supplementing the diet with the element or vitamin
E (see p. 85). A biochemical role of selenium in the animal body was demonstrated in 1973, when it was discovered that the element was a component of glutathione peroxidase, an enzyme that catalyses the removal of hydrogen peroxide,
thereby protecting cell membranes from oxidative damage. Glutathione peroxidase contains four selenium atoms and forms a second line of defence after vitamin E, since some peroxidases remain even if vitamin E levels are adequate.
Selenium has a sparing effect on vitamin E by ensuring normal absorption of the
vitamin. This is due to its role in preserving the integrity of the pancreas and
thereby ensuring satisfactory fat digestion. Selenium also reduces the amount of
vitamin E required to maintain the integrity of lipid membranes and aids the
retention of vitamin E in plasma. Conversely, vitamin E spares selenium by maintaining the element in its active form and preventing its loss. It reduces the production of hydroperoxides and thus the amount of glutathione peroxidase needed
to protect cells. However, there are limits to the mutual substitution of selenium
and vitamin E.
Vitamin E and selenium have roles in the immune system and protect against
heavy metal toxicity. Other mutual functions and effects of deficiency in farm animals are discussed in the section on vitamin E (see pp. 81–86).
The other major role of selenium is in the production of the thyroid hormones
(see p. 127), for which it is a component of the enzyme type I iodothyronine deiodinase (ID1), which converts T4 to the physiologically active T3. When there is a deficiency of selenium the ratio of T4 : T3 increases.The enzyme is found primarily in the
liver and kidney and not in the thyroid of farm animals. Type II iodothyronine deiodinase (ID2) does not contain selenium and also converts T4 to T3, but as it is under
feedback control from T4 an increase in the latter, when selenium is deficient, compounds the problem. The major enzyme in ruminants is ID1 and in non-ruminants
ID2.A third selenium-containing enzyme, ID3, has been found in the placenta. ID1 is
particularly important in the brown adipose tissue of newborn ruminants and
releases T3 for use in other tissues.
Deficiency symptoms
As mentioned above, the effects of selenium deficiency are often similar to those
of vitamin E. In parts of Australia and New Zealand, a condition known as ‘ill
thrift’ occurs in lambs, beef cattle and dairy cows at pasture. The clinical signs include loss of weight and sometimes death. Ill thrift can be prevented by selenium
treatment with, in some instances, dramatic increases in growth and wool yield.
Similar responses with sheep have also been noted in experiments carried out in
selenium-deficient areas of Scotland, Canada and the USA. In hens, selenium deficiency reduces hatchability and egg production. The reduction in use of feed wheat
from seleniferous regions of North America and Canada has reduced the plantbased dietary supply of selenium, especially in pig and poultry diets, resulting in
greater supplementation being required than previously. Owing to its role in thyroid hormone production, a lack of selenium can produce the symptoms of iodine
deficiency.
131
Chapter 6 Minerals
Sources of selenium
The main form of selenium in most foods is protein-bound seleno-methionine. Supplements of selenium are provided by mineral salts containing sodium selenite, slowrelease capsules and selenium-enriched yeast.
Selenium toxicity
The level of selenium in foods of plant origin is extremely variable and depends mainly
on the soil conditions under which they are grown. Normal levels of the element in pasture herbage are usually in the range 100–300 µg/kg DM. Some species of plants that
grow in seleniferous areas contain very high levels of selenium. One such plant,
Astragalus racemosus, grown in Wyoming, was reported to contain 14 g selenium/kg
DM, while the legume Neptunia amplexicaulis grown on a selenised soil in Queensland contained over 4 g/kg DM of the element. Localised seleniferous areas have also
been identified in Ireland, Israel and South Africa. Selenium is a highly toxic element
and a concentration in a dry diet of 5 mg/kg or 500 µg/kg in milk or water may be potentially dangerous to farm animals. ‘Alkali disease’ and ‘blind staggers’ are localised
names for chronic diseases of animals grazing certain seleniferous areas in the USA.
Symptoms include dullness, stiffness of the joints, loss of hair from the mane or tail,
and hoof deformities.Acute poisoning, which results in death from respiratory failure,
can arise from sudden exposure to high selenium intakes.
Fluorine
The importance of fluorine in the prevention of dental caries in humans is well established. Fluorine was added to the list of essential elements in 1972 when it was
shown that the growth rate of rats was improved after small amounts were added to
a low-fluorine diet. Under normal conditions a straightforward deficiency syndrome
in farm animals has not been observed, and even the results of studies with rodents
are equivocal.
Most plants have a limited capacity to absorb fluorine from the soil, and normal
levels in pasture herbage range from about 2 mg/kg to 20 mg/kg DM. Cereals and
other grains usually contain about 1–3 mg/kg DM only.
Fluorine is a very toxic element, with ruminants being more susceptible than nonruminants. Levels of more than 20 mg/kg DM in the diet of cattle have resulted in
dental pitting and wear, leading to exposed pulp cavities. Further increases in fluorine cause depression of appetite, lameness and reduced production. Bone and joint
abnormalities also occur, probably owing to ingested fluorine being deposited in the
bone crystal lattice as calcium fluoride. The commonest sources of danger from this
element are fluoride-containing water, herbage contaminated by dust from industrial
pollution, and the use of soft or raw rock phosphate supplements. Processed phosphates are generally safe.
Silicon
Rats previously fed on specially purified foods showed increased growth rates from
the addition to the diet of 500 mg/kg of silicon (as sodium metasilicate).
Similar results have been obtained with chicks. Silicon is essential for growth and
skeletal development in these two species. The element is believed to function as a
biological cross-linking agent, possibly as an ether derivative of silicic acid of the
132
Trace elements
type R1—O—Si—O—R2. Such bridges are important in the strength, structure and
resilience of connective tissue. In silicon-deficient rats and chicks, bone abnormalities occur because of a reduction in mucopolysaccharide synthesis in the formation
of cartilage. Silicon is required for maximal activity of the enzyme prolyl hydroxylase, which is involved in collagen synthesis. It is also thought to be involved in other
processes involving mucopolysaccharides such as the growth and maintenance of arterial walls and the skin.
Silicon is so widely distributed in the environment and in foods that it is difficult
to foresee any deficiencies of this element arising under practical conditions. Whole
grasses and cereals may contain as much as 14–19 g Si/kg DM, with levels of up to
28 g/kg DM in some range grasses.
Silicon toxicity (silicosis) has long been known as an illness of miners caused by
the inhalation of silical particles into the lungs. Under some conditions, part of the
silicon present in urine is deposited in the kidney, bladder or urethra to form calculi
or uroliths. Silica urolithiasis occurs in grazing wethers in Western Australia and in
grazing steers in western Canada and northwestern parts of the USA. Excessive silica in feeds, for example in rice straw, is known to depress organic matter digestibility. In mature forage, silicon is in the form of solid particles, which are harder than
dental tissue and lead to teeth wear in sheep.
Chromium
Chromium was first shown to be essential for normal glucose utilisation in rats.
Mice and rats fed on diets composed of cereals and skimmed milk and containing
100 µg chromium/kg wet weight were subsequently shown to grow faster if given
a supplement of chromium acetate. Chromium appears to have a role in glucose
tolerance, possibly forming a complex between insulin and its receptors. It has restored glucose tolerance in malnourished children. Chromium may also play a role
in lipid synthesis, and experiments have shown decreased serum cholesterol and
increased high-density lipoprotein cholesterol in cases of deficiency. There is also
thought to be an involvement in protein and nucleic acid metabolism. Investigations with pigs have supported the above putative roles, with increased lean and
decreased fat deposition as a result of more efficient glucose metabolism and sparing of protein catabolism. Improved reproduction in sows has been reported with
supplements of organic sources of chromium. There have been positive responses
to chromium supplements where animals are under physiological stress, for example periparturient dairy cattle and stressed feedlot calves. Immune response, energy status, dry matter intake and milk yield have been increased in primiparous
cows and morbidity has been reduced in calves. The practical significance of the
element in the nutrition of farm animals is still being investigated and no recommendations for dietary levels have been made. Chromium is not a particularly toxic
element in its trivalent form, and a wide margin of safety exists between the normal amounts ingested and those likely to produce deleterious effects. The hexavalent form is more toxic because it enters the cells to a greater extent and suppresses
oxygen consumption and damages DNA. Levels of 50 mg chromium/kg DM in the
diet have caused growth depression and liver and kidney damage in rats.
Chromium in the form of its insoluble oxide is often used as a marker in digestibility trials (see p. 241).
133
Chapter 6 Minerals
Vanadium
No specific biochemical function has been identified for vanadium, but it may have
a role in the regulation of the activity of sodium–potassium ATPase, phosphoryl
transferase enzymes, adenyl cyclase and protein kinase. It may also act as a cofactor
for certain enzymes. Vanadium deficiency has been demonstrated in rats, goats and
chicks. Deficiency symptoms included impaired growth and reproduction, and disturbed lipid metabolism. In chicks consuming diets containing less than 10 µg
vanadium/kg DM, growth of wing and tail feathers was significantly reduced. Subsequent studies with chicks demonstrated a significant growth response when dietary
vanadium concentrations were increased from 30 µg to 3 mg/kg DM. In goats fed on
diets containing less than 10 µg vanadium/kg there was no effect on growth, but
there was increased incidence of abortion, reduced milk fat production and a high
death rate in the kids.
There is little information about the vanadium content of foods, but levels in the
range 30–110 µg/kg DM have been reported for ryegrass. Herring meal appears to
be a relatively rich source, containing about 2.7 mg/kg DM.Vanadium is a relatively
toxic element. When diets containing 30 mg/kg DM of the element were given to
chicks, the growth rate was depressed; at levels of 200 mg/kg DM, the mortality rate
was high.
Nickel
A discrete biochemical function has not been firmly established for nickel, but it is
thought that it may be a cofactor or structural component in metalloenzymes. It may
also play a role in nucleic acid metabolism.
Physiological symptoms of nickel deficiency have been produced in chicks, rats
and pigs kept under laboratory conditions. Chicks given a diet containing nickel in a
concentration of less than 400 µg/kg DM developed skin pigmentation changes, dermatitis and swollen hocks. Diets with a low nickel content have produced scaly and
crusty skin in pigs, similar to the parakeratosis seen in zinc deficiency, which suggests
an involvement in zinc metabolism. Supplements of nickel have increased rumen
bacterial urease activity.
Normal levels of the element in pasture herbage are 0.5–3.5 mg/kg DM, while
wheat grain contains 0.3–0.6 mg/kg DM. Nickel is a relatively non-toxic element, is
poorly absorbed from the digestive tract and does not normally present a serious
health hazard.
Tin
In 1971 it was reported that a significant growth effect, in rats maintained on purified amino acid diets in a trace-element-free environment, was obtained when
the diets were supplemented with tin. These studies suggested that tin was an essential trace element for mammals. The element is normally present in foods in
amounts less than 1 mg/kg DM, the values in pasture herbage grown in Scotland,
for example, being of the order of 300–400 µg/kg DM. The nutritional importance
of this element has yet to be determined, but it is suggested that tin contributes to
the tertiary structure of protein or other macromolecules. Tin is poorly absorbed
134
Other elements
BOX 6.4 Enhanced trace element supplementation and health status and fertility
in dairy cows
Several authors have reported that when dairy cows were given dietary supplements of certain trace
elements, above the levels necessary for production, their health status (incidence of mastitis) and
fertility were improved. In a review, Cottrill and Rymer (see Further reading) concluded that for
iodine and manganese there is no evidence that feeding levels above requirements have any benefits. In some studies, raised levels of copper improved fertility and udder health, but results were inconsistent and no recommendation could be made with respect to the appropriate level of
supplementation. The authors also pointed out the complexity surrounding copper absorption
(molybdenum, sulphur and iron – see p. 123) and the potential cumulative toxicity of copper. In the
case of chromium, there were potential benefits but again there was insufficient evidence to make
recommendations. Udder health has been improved by increased levels of selenium, but the vitamin
E status influences the effect. Again with zinc, the effects on somatic cell counts and mastitis have
been too inconsistent to recommend giving zinc above requirements.
This is an area of continuing research, especially with the use of ‘organic’ mineral supplements
(see p. 107).
from the digestive tract, especially in the inorganic form, and ingested tin has a
low toxicity.
Arsenic
Arsenic is widely distributed throughout the tissues and fluids of the body but is
concentrated particularly in the skin, nails and hair. It has been shown that the
element is essential for the rat, chick, pig and goat. It is needed to form metabolites
of methionine, including cystine. Animals given an arsenic-deficient diet had rough
coats and slower growth rates than control animals given a supplement of arsenic.
A long-term study with goats showed interference with reproduction (abortion,
low birth weights) and milk production, and sudden death. The toxicity of the
element is well known; symptoms include nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea and severe
abdominal pain. The toxicity of its compounds differs widely; trivalent arsenicals,
which block lipoate-dependent enzymes, are more toxic than the pentavalent
compounds.
6.6
OTHER ELEMENTS
The essentiality of other elements, listed by some authorities, is the subject of debate. Often the levels required to produce a deficiency are so low as to be of no practical significance in normal animal nutrition. For example, boron, which is essential
to plants, has been shown to increase growth rate and tibia weight and strength in
broilers, but the response was obtained at levels found only in boron-deficient
plants. Lithium has been shown to be essential for goats, where it prevented growth
retardation, impaired fertility and low birth weights, but again deficiency is unlikely
under practical conditions.
135
Chapter 6 Minerals
SUMMARY
Minerals fulfil physiological, structural and regulatory functions. Mineral supplements take various
forms: mineral salts, rumen boluses, ‘organic’ compounds and pasture applications. The roles of
individual mineral elements, and the effects of their deficiencies, are summarised below:
Mineral element
Role
Effects of deficiency
Calcium
Bone and teeth, transmission
of nerve impulses
Bone and teeth, energy metabolism
Rickets, osteomalacia, thin eggshells,
milk fever
Rickets, osteomalacia, depraved
appetite, poor fertility
Retarded growth, weakness
Phosphorus
Potassium
Sodium
Chlorine
Sulphur
Magnesium
Iron
Copper
Cobalt
Iodine
Manganese
Zinc
Selenium
Osmoregulation, acid–base balance,
nerve and muscle excitation
Acid–base balance, osmoregulation
Acid–base balance, osmoregulation,
gastric secretion
Structure of amino acids, vitamins
and hormones, chondroitin
Bone, activator of enzymes for
carbohydrate and lipid metabolism
Haemoglobin, enzymes of electron
transport chain
Haemoglobin synthesis, enzyme
systems, pigments
Component of vitamin B12
Dehydration, poor growth, poor
egg production
Alkalosis
Equivalent to protein deficiency
(urea-supplemented diets)
Nervous irritability and convulsions,
hypomagnesaemia
Anaemia
Anaemia, poor growth, depigmentation
of hair and wool, swayback
Pining (emaciation, anaemia,
listlessness)
Thyroid hormones
Goitre; hairless, weak or dead young
Enzyme activation
Retarded growth, skeletal
abnormality, ataxia
Enzyme component and activator
Parakeratosis, poor growth,
depressed appetite
Component of glutathione peroxidase, Myopathy, exudative diathesis
iodine metabolism, immune function
FURTHER READING
Agricultural and Food Research Council 1991 Technical Committee on Responses to Nutrients, Report no. 6. A reappraisal of the calcium and phosphorus requirements of sheep and
cattle. Nutrition Abstracts and Reviews, Series B 61: 573–612.
Ammerman C B, Henry P R and Miles R D 1998 Supplemental organically-bound mineral
compounds in livestock nutrition. In: Garnsworthy P C and Wiseman J (eds) Recent
Advances in Animal Nutrition, Nottingham, Nottingham University Press, 67–91.
Cottrill B and Rymer C 2001 The Effect of Enhanced Supplementation of Trace Elements on
the Health and Performance of Dairy Cows and on the Composition of Their Milk: A
Report to the Milk Development Council, project no. 99/T2/27, Cirencester, Milk
Development Council.
136
Further reading
Ewing W N and Charlton S J 2005 The Minerals Directory, Packington, Context Publications.
McDowell L R 1992 Minerals in Animal and Human Nutrition, New York, Academic Press.
National Research Council 1980 Mineral Tolerances of Domestic Animals, Washington, DC,
National Academy of Sciences.
Thompson J K and Fowler V R 1990 The evaluation of minerals in the diets of farm animals. In:
Wiseman J and Cole D J A (eds) Feedstuff Evaluation, London, Butterworth, 235–59.
Underwood E J and Suttle N F 1999 The Mineral Nutrition of Livestock, 3rd edn,Wallingford,
CABI.
137
PART 2
The digestion and metabolism
of nutrients
This part describes the physical and chemical processes by which an animal obtains nutrients
from the chemical compounds that make up the foods ingested and explains how these
nutrients are subsequently utilised.
A key group of molecules required for both digestion and metabolism are the enzymes, and
Chapter 7 provides details of their chemistry, mode of action and the factors affecting their
activity.
Chapter 8 is concerned with both the structure of animal digestive tracts and the mechanisms
by which animals break down large molecules in foods during digestion to produce molecules
that are small enough to be absorbed through the gut wall. Variations on the ‘simple stomach’
monogastric system are described, leading on to specialised and highly developed systems
that are dependent on microbial activity in the digestive tract.
Once the digested molecules are absorbed, they are used to provide energy and to produce
the proteins, fats and carbohydrates that are required by the body. Chapter 9 describes the
metabolic processes by which cells utilise and transform molecules and how these processes
are controlled.
7
Enzymes
7.1
Classification of enzymes
7.2
Nature of enzymes
7.3
Mechanism of enzyme action
7.4
Specific nature of enzymes
7.5
Factors affecting enzyme activity
7.6
Nomenclature of enzymes
The existence of living things involves a continuous series of chemical reactions. Thus,
green plants synthesise chemical compounds such as sugars, starch and proteins and in
so doing fix and store energy. Subsequently these compounds are broken down by the
plants themselves, or the animals that consume them, and the stored energy is utilised.
The complex reactions involved in these processes are reversible and when not associated with living organisms are often very slow. Extremes of temperature or pressure are
often required to increase the velocity of these reactions to practicable levels. In living
organisms, such conditions do not exist; yet the storage and release of energy in such
organisms must take place quickly when required, necessitating a high velocity from the
reactions involved. The required velocity is achieved through the activity of numerous
catalysts present in living organisms.
A catalyst in the classical chemical sense is a substance that affects the velocity of a
chemical reaction without appearing in the final products; characteristically, the catalyst
remains unchanged in mass upon completion of the reaction. The catalysts found in
living organisms are organic in nature and are known as enzymes. They are capable of
increasing the rate of chemical reaction by a factor of as much as 109–1012 times that of
the non-catalysed reaction. The reactions catalysed by enzymes are theoretically
reversible and should reach equilibrium. In living cells, reaction products are removed
and the reactions are largely unidirectional and do not reach equilibrium. Rather, they
reach a steady state in which the concentrations of the reactants and products remain
relatively constant. Reactions will speed up under demand, or slow down when the
products are not removed quickly enough to maintain the steady state. Enzymes affect
both the forward and the reverse reactions equally so that the steady state is not
changed; it is, however, attained more quickly. When one or more of the products is decomposed, the reaction may become virtually irreversible.
141
Chapter 7 Enzymes
Each living cell contains hundreds of enzymes and can function efficiently only if the
action of these enzymes is suitably coordinated. It is important to appreciate that within
the cell, the enzymes exist in different compartments; the cell is not a bag of randomly
distributed enzymes. Thus, the enzymes used in the first stage of the oxidation of glucose (glycolysis) are present in the cytoplasm, whereas those involved in the formation
of acetyl-CoA from pyruvate and its subsequent oxidation via the tricarboxylic acid cycle
are found in the mitochondria (see Chapter 9).
7.1
CLASSIFICATION OF ENZYMES
Enzymes are classified into six major groups according to their mode of action.
Oxidoreductases
The oxidoreductases catalyse the transfer of hydrogen, oxygen or electrons from one
molecule to another. For example, lactate is oxidised to pyruvate in the presence of
lactate dehydrogenase. In the process, two electrons and two hydrogen atoms are removed from the alcohol group, and are transferred to NAD to form NADH(⫹H⫹),
leaving a ketone.
CH3
CHOH
CH3
+
NAD+
COO–
Lactate
C:O
+
NADH(+H+)
COO–
Nicotinamide
adenine
dinucleotide
Pyruvate Reduced NAD+
This group includes:
■
■
■
■
■
■
dehydrogenases;
oxidases;
peroxidases;
catalases;
oxygenases;
hydroxylases.
Transferases
The transferases are a large group of enzymes that catalyse the transfer of groups
such as acetyl, amino and phosphate from one molecule to another. For example, in
the formation of citrate from oxalacetate during the release of energy in the body,
addition of an acetyl group takes place in the presence of citrate synthetase:
142
Classification of enzymes
CO.COO–
CH2.COO–
CH2.COO–
CH3
+
COS.CoA
+
H2O
C.OH.COO–
+
HS.CoA +
H+
CH2.COO–
Oxalacetate
Citrate
Acetyl-CoA
Coenzyme A
This group includes:
■
■
■
■
transaldolases and transketolases;
acyl, glucosyl and phosphoryl transferases;
kinases;
phosphomutases.
Hydrolases
The hydrolases catalyse hydrolytic cleavage. Typical are the hydrolyses associated
with fat and protein digestion, which are essential for the normal functioning of the
organism. A fat may be broken down to glycerides (acylglycerols) and fatty acids
under the influence of a lipase:
CH2.O.CO.R1
CH.O.CO.R2
CH2OH
+
2H2O
CH.O.CO.R2
+
R3.COOH
CH2.O.CO.R3
CH2OH
Triglyceride
(triacylglycerol)
Monoglyceride
(monoacylglycerol)
+
R1.COOH
Fatty acids
Similarly, peptidases split proteins by hydrolysis of the peptide linkages between
the constituent amino acids.
This is a large group, including:
■
■
■
■
■
■
■
■
■
esterases;
glycosidases;
peptidases;
phosphatases;
thiolases;
phospholipases;
amidases;
deaminases;
ribonucleases.
Lyases
The lyases are enzymes that catalyse non-hydrolytic decompositions involving the
removal of certain groups such as in decarboxylation and deamination reactions.
143
Chapter 7 Enzymes
Pyruvate decarboxylase, for example, catalyses the conversion of a 2-oxo-acid to an
aldehyde, and carbon dioxide is removed:
R
R
C:O
CHO
+
CO2
COOH
In addition to the above, the group includes:
■
■
■
■
■
aldolases;
hydratases;
dehydratases;
synthases;
lyases.
Isomerases
The isomerases catalyse intramolecular rearrangement in optical and positional
isomers. Typical of this class are the epimerases, such as uridine diphosphate glucose
4-epimerase. This enzyme catalyses the change of configuration at the fourth carbon
atom of glucose, and galactose is produced (see Chapter 9).The group includes:
■
■
■
racemases;
isomerases;
some of the mutases.
Ligases
The ligases, as the name implies, catalyse reactions where two molecules are bound
together, with the breakdown of high-energy phosphate bonds such as in ATP, which
provides the energy for the reaction to take place. The production of acetyl-CoA
from acetate by acetyl coenzyme A synthetase is typical:
CH3
7.2
H
+
+
ATP
CH3
+
COOH
S.COA
COS.CoA
Acetic acid
Coenzyme A
Acetyl-CoA
H2O
+
AMP
+
PP
Pyrophosphate
NATURE OF ENZYMES
The majority of enzymes are based on complex, high-molecular-weight proteins, but
there are exceptions, such as the ribozymes, which are RNA-based. Some proteins
may themselves act as efficient catalysts, but many require the assistance of smaller
entities to achieve this. Such substances, bound to the protein, are termed cofactors.
Coenzymes
Organic cofactors are known as coenzymes. They are relatively few in number, but
each coenzyme may be associated with a number of different enzymes and so plays
a part in a large number of chemical reactions.Among the most important coenzymes
144
Nature of enzymes
CH2O
P
O
CHOH
OH
OH
CHOH
CHOH
CH2
CH3
N
∗
N
O
C
∗
N
CH3
NH
C
O
Fig. 7.1 Flavin mononucleotide.
are nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD), thiamine pyrophosphate, pyridoxal
phosphate and flavin mononucleotide. In such cases, the protein, referred to as the
apoprotein, is catalytically inactive. However, when bound to the coenzyme it forms
the active holoenzyme. Flavin mononucleotide (Fig. 7.1) is a typical example of a
coenzyme. Exchange of hydrogen atoms takes place at the positions marked *.
In some cases the coenzyme does not remain permanently attached to the apoenzyme but is released after the reaction is completed.Thus, the oxidised form of NAD is
strongly bound to the apoenzyme in dehydrogenase systems, but when the oxidation is
complete the reduced form is released from the enzyme and the oxidised form is regenerated by reaction with other electron acceptors. In such cases, the coenzyme is acting
more as a second substrate than a true coenzyme. Many enzymes act out either or both
of these roles, depending upon the reaction with which they are concerned.
Metal cofactors
Some two-thirds of enzymes require metal cofactors if they are to carry out their
proper function. In some cases, the metals are attached by coordinate covalent linkages to the enzyme protein or they may form part of prosthetic groups within the
enzyme, as in the case of iron in the haem proteins (Fig. 7.2). Good examples of
CH
N N
CH Fe
CH
N N
CH
Fig. 7.2 Haem grouping within the cytochrome molecule.
145
Chapter 7 Enzymes
protein-bound metal cofactors are zinc and iron. Carboxypeptidase is a zinc
protease that catalyses the hydrolytic cleavage of peptide bonds. The zinc generates
hydrogen and hydroxyl ions, from bound water, which attack the peptide bond as
shown here:
H
Enzyme
Zn++ +
O
H
OH–
O
H
R.CH2CH2
C
N
R.CH2.CH2COOH
Acid
H+
CH2.CH2.R
NH2.CH2.CH2.R
Amine
The cytochromes are important in certain oxidation reactions in the body in
which they accept electrons from reduced substances, which are consequently oxidised. The iron forms part of the haem grouping within the cytochrome molecule, as
shown in Fig. 7.2. The exchange of electrons takes place at the iron atom.
Metal cofactors do not always bind to the enzyme but rather bind to the primary
substrate. The resulting substrate–metal complex binds to the enzyme and facilitates its activity. Creatine kinase catalyses the transfer of phosphoryl groups from
adenosine triphosphate (ATP), which is broken down to adenosine diphosphate
(ADP). The reaction requires the presence of magnesium ions. These, however, do
not bind to the enzyme but bind to ATP, forming an ATP–Mg complex. It is this
complex that binds to the enzyme and allows transfer of the phosphoryl group:
ATP + Mg ++
ATP–Mg complex + enzyme
Creatine
ATP–Mg complex
ATP–Mg–enzyme complex
Phosphocreatine
ATP–Mg–enzyme ADP + enzyme + Mg++
Some enzymes are present in an inactive form that is changed to an active state at
the place and time when its action is required.Thus, trypsinogen is synthesised in the
pancreas, transported to the small intestine and there changed to the active digestive
enzyme trypsin. This kind of mechanism confers considerable control over the siting
and timing of enzyme activity. The inactive precursors are known as zymogens.
7.3
MECHANISM OF ENZYME ACTION
If a chemical reaction is to take place, the reacting molecules must pass through a highenergy transition state.This may be envisaged as an intermediate stage in the reaction
in which the molecules are distorted or strained, or have an unfavourable electronic
arrangement. At any particular moment the molecules in a sample have differing
energies, but only a few will be able to pass the energy barrier represented by the transition state. In this situation, the reaction will not proceed or may do so only very
146
Mechanism of enzyme action
Activation
energy of
uncatalysed
reaction
Activation
energy of
catalysed
reaction
Free
energy
Substrate
Product
Reaction
Fig. 7.3 Mechanism of enzyme catalysis.
slowly. In the gaseous state or in solution, the energies of the molecules may be raised
by the provision of an outside source of energy in the form of heat; more molecules
will pass the energy barrier and the reaction is speeded up. In the body this is not an
option, owing to the strict control exerted on body temperature. In such a situation,
the same end may be achieved by lowering the barrier instead of increasing the energy
of the molecules.This is the function performed by a catalyst.
In Fig. 7.3 the unbroken line illustrates the effect, on the rate of an uncatalysed reaction, of increasing inputs of energy.The apex of the curve represents the transition
state and the energy that a molecule must possess for the reaction to take place. The
free energy that must be provided to achieve this is the activation energy.The broken
line shows a similar plot for the catalysed reaction. In this case, the activation energy
required by the molecule to achieve the transition state is lower. Consequently, more
molecules are able to attain it and the reaction rate is increased. It is important to appreciate that the catalyst does not change the equilibrium but merely changes the
speed with which equilibrium is attained.
Enzyme action involves the formation of a complex between the enzyme and the
substrate or substrates. The complex then undergoes breakdown, yielding the products and the unchanged enzyme:
E + S Δ ES Δ E + P
The complexes are formed between the substrate and relatively few active sites
on the enzyme surface. The bonding may be ionic:
COO– +H3N.R
E
COO– +H3N.R
147
Chapter 7 Enzymes
or by hydrogen bonds:
HN
C:O
or by covalent bonds typified by sulphydryl groups on the enzyme:
H
S
C
R
OH
or by van der Waals bonds. These latter bonds arise as a result of non-specific attractive forces between atoms when the distance between them is 3–4 Å. They are
weaker than the ionic and hydrogen bonds but may be important because of the
large number that may be formed when conditions are favourable.
The type of reaction envisaged for enzyme catalysis is illustrated by that suggested for the chymotrypsin-catalysed hydrolysis of an ester shown in Fig. 7.4, where
the groups involved in the catalysis are the alcohol group of serine and the imidazole
of histidine.
The active sites are always small compared with the enzyme molecule and are
three-dimensional. They are usually clefts, crevices or pockets and have specific
shapes. They are usually surrounded by amino acid chains, some of which help to
bind the substrate and others that play a part in the actual catalytic process.
7.4
SPECIFIC NATURE OF ENZYMES
Enzyme specificity is said to be absolute if the action of the enzyme is limited to one
substrate only. An example is urease, which only catalyses the breakdown of urea to
carbon dioxide and ammonia:
NH2
C:O + H2O
2NH3 + CO2
NH2
In most cases enzymes are able to catalyse reactions in more than one group of
substrates. In such cases the specificity is said to be relative. Such group specificity
may be of a low order, such as in the case of the digestive enzymes trypsin and
pepsin, which catalyse the rupture of peptide bonds. In other cases it may be much
higher. Chymotrypsin, for example, catalyses the hydrolytic cleavage only of peptide
bonds in which the carboxyl residue is derived from an aromatic amino acid.
Enzyme specificity arises from the need for spatial conjunction of the active
groups of the substrate with the active site of the enzyme.This requires an exact fit of
148
Specific nature of enzymes
R
R
A
H
O
CH2
Serine
C
O
H
+
O
A
H
O
CH2
O
C
H
R
R
N
N
Histidine
CH2
CH2
NH
Enzyme
Ester
NH
Enzyme–substrate complex
Alcohol (P1)
R
HO–R
A
CH2
O
C
H
N
R
CH2
O
O
A
H
O
CH2
O
C
H
N
R
CH2
NH
O
NH
H2O
A
H
CH2
H
CH2
O
OH
H
C
N
R
OH
Serine
CH2
Acid (P2)
A
O
C
H
N
R
NH
O
Histidine
CH2
O
NH
Fig. 7.4 Chymotrypsin-catalysed hydrolysis of an ester.
After Westheimer F H 1962 Advances in Enzymology 24: 464.
the substrate into the active site as a key fits into a lock. In the lock and key model of
enzyme action (Fig. 7.5), the necessary structures are considered to be preformed.
Although the lock and key model accounts for enzyme specificity, it does not
explain certain other aspects, and the induced-fit model is currently pre-eminent.
This model predicates that the reacting sites need not be fully preformed but only so
149
Chapter 7 Enzymes
+
Substrate
Enzyme
Fig. 7.5 Lock and key model of enzyme–substrate complex formation.
+
Fig. 7.6 Induced-fit model of enzyme–substrate complex formation.
far as to allow the substrate to position itself close to an active site on the enzyme.
Interaction then causes distortion of both the enzyme and substrate, as a result of
which structures are produced that allow for complete conjunction of the two and
successful complex formation (Fig. 7.6). As a result of the distortion involved in
complex formation, strain is induced in the enzyme and this helps to pull the substrate into the transition state conformation.
In addition to distorting their substrates, enzymes frequently position groups in
the right position for the catalytic action to take place, especially in the case of
acid–base catalysis. In other instances, the enzyme sets a metal ion in just the right
position to allow metal ion catalysis.
7.5
FACTORS AFFECTING ENZYME ACTIVITY
Substrate concentration
In a system where the enzyme is in excess and the concentration remains constant, an
increase in substrate concentration increases the velocity of a reaction. This is due to
increased utilisation of the available active sites of the enzyme. If the substrate concentration continues to increase, utilisation of the available active sites becomes maximal
and there is no further increase in the rate of reaction. In fact, continued increases in
substrate concentration may lead to a reduced rate, owing to an incomplete linkage of
150
Factors affecting enzyme activity
enzyme and substrate resulting from competition for the active sites by the excess substrate molecules.
The effect of substrate concentration on the velocity of an enzyme-catalysed
reaction is frequently represented in terms of the Michaelis–Menten constant, Km.This
is the molar concentration of substrate at which half the centres of the enzyme are occupied by substrate and the rate of reaction is half the maximum.Above Km, the effect
of an increase in concentration of the substrate on the reaction decreases as the
maximum is approached. At substrate concentrations below Km, increases in concentration will give large responses in terms of reaction rate.When physiological substrate
concentrations are much above an enzyme’s Km, the substrate is unlikely to be the
controlling factor of a metabolic pathway. Many enzymes have Km values that approximate to their physiological concentrations. Changes in the latter will result in significant changes in reaction rate and are important in the control of metabolism.
Enzyme concentration
In a system where the substrate is present in excess, an increase in enzyme concentration gives a straight-line response in reaction velocity owing to the provision of
additional active sites for the formation of enzyme–substrate complexes. Further increases in the enzyme concentration may result in some limiting factor, such as the
availability of the coenzyme, becoming operative. Enzymes are rarely saturated with
substrate under physiological conditions.
Inhibitors
A wide variety of substances can act as inhibitors of enzyme activity. They fall into
two main groups: reversible and non-reversible.
Reversible inhibition
Such inhibition involves non-covalent bonding of the inhibitor to the enzyme. The
group divides into three subgroups: competitive, non-competitive and uncompetitive.
A competitive inhibitor resembles the substrate in its chemical structure and is able
to combine with the enzyme to form an enzyme–inhibitor complex. In so doing it
competes with the substrate for the active sites of the enzyme, and formation of the
enzyme–substrate complex is inhibited.This type of inhibition may be reversed by the
addition of excess substrate, which displaces the inhibitor, forming normal
enzyme–substrate complexes. One of the best-known examples is provided by the
sulphonamide drugs.The synthesis of folic acid from p-aminobenzoic acid (PABA) is a
vital metabolic process in the bacteria controlled by these drugs. The similarity
between PABA and sulphanilamide, released by the sulphonamides, is obvious:
COOH
SO2NH2
NH2
NH2
Para-aminobenzoic acid
Sulphanilamide
151
Chapter 7 Enzymes
Enzyme–PABA
complex
Enzyme
+ folic acid
Enzyme
+ PABA
+ sulphanilamide
Enzyme–sulphanilamide
complex
Fig. 7.7 Competitive inhibition of PABA.
The sulphanilamide forms a complex with the relevant enzyme, thus preventing normal enzyme–substrate combination and the formation of folic acid. Addition of excess
PABA overcomes the inhibition, since the formation of the enzyme–sulphanilamide
complex is reversible.The situation may be visualised as shown in Fig. 7.7.
The extent of the inhibition will depend upon the relative concentrations of the
true substrate and the inhibitor.
A non-competitive inhibitor does not bind to the active site but binds at some
other site on the enzyme surface and may cause distortion of the enzyme and reduce
catalytic activity. In the simplest case the inhibitor binds readily with both enzyme
and substrate. Three types of complex are formed:
■
■
■
enzyme–substrate (ES);
enzyme–inhibitor (EI);
enzyme–inhibitor–substrate (EIS).
The reaction rate will be slower owing to the removal of enzyme from the system.
The EI complex will be catalytically inert.The EIS complex may, however, be susceptible to reconversion to ES and make some contribution to catalytic activity. Noncompetitive inhibition cannot be reversed by excess substrate, but it may be reversed
by exhaustive dialysis.
In uncompetitive inhibition, the inhibitor binds to the enzyme–substrate complex
and renders it inactive.
Irreversible inhibition
Such inhibition involves covalent bonding at the active site and cannot be reversed
by excess substrate or by dialysis.The site is therefore blocked and made catalytically
inactive. Most inhibitors in this group are highly toxic, e.g. the organophosphorus
nerve poisons. Thus, diisopropyl fluorophosphate (DFP) reacts irreversibly with the
hydroxyl group of serine:
CH.(CH3)2
C:O
CH.CH2OH
NH
O
+
F.P:O
O
CH.(CH3)2
Enzyme
152
Diisopropyl
phosphofluoridate
CH.(CH3)2
C:O
O
CH.CH2.O.P:O
NH
+
HF
O
CH.(CH3)2
Inactive enzyme–inhibitor
complex
Factors affecting enzyme activity
Any enzyme having an essential serine at its active site will be irreversibly inactivated by it. The serine proteases and acetylcholinesterases are typical examples.
The latter is essential for nerve conduction and its inactivation results in rapid
paralysis of vital functions. It is this action that makes the organophosphates such
potent toxins.
Allosteric effects
The activity of some enzymes can be affected by molecules that bind to the enzymes
but that do not work in the same way as either competitive or non-competitive enzyme inhibitors. Such molecules that bind to macromolecules are known as ligands
and may be small and simple or large and complex like proteins. They may be activators or inhibitors and may even be substrates. They are commonly referred to as
effectors, modifiers or modulators.
Typically modulators bind to unique allosteric sites, which are quite distinct from
the sites binding the substrate. The binding brings about a conformational change in
the enzyme, resulting in a change in the affinity of the enzyme for the substrate. The
modulators may increase or decrease the affinity and bind to activator and inhibitory
sites, respectively.
The vast majority of allosteric enzymes are oligomers, i.e. they consist of several
subunits or protomers. Binding of a modulator to one protomer may affect binding
at the other protomers so that the effect of an activator on the affinity of an enzyme
for the substrate on one protomer has the same effect on the others.
Almost all metabolic pathways employ allosteric enzymes.The complex feedback
mechanisms controlling these pathways are, to a large part, the result of the action of
allosteric inhibitors and activators.
Environmental factors
A number of factors, including temperature, acidity and salt concentration, may influence enzyme activity, but in the living animal these are not likely to be of much
importance.
Temperature
Over a limited temperature range, the efficiency of enzyme-catalysed reactions is
increased by increasing the temperature.Very approximately, the speed of reaction is
doubled for each increase of 10 °C. As the temperature rises, a complicating factor
comes into play because denaturation of the enzyme protein begins. This is a molecular rearrangement that causes a loss of active sites on the enzyme surface and decreases reaction efficiency. Above 50 °C destruction of the enzyme becomes more
rapid, and most enzymes are destroyed when heated to 100 °C. The time for which
the enzyme is subjected to a given temperature affects the magnitude of the loss of
activity. Each enzyme has an optimum temperature at which it is most effective,
which approximates to that of the cells in which it occurs. Thus, enzymes of microorganisms adapted to cold conditions are able to function efficiently at temperatures
close to zero, and others adapted to life in hot springs have optima in the region
of 100 °C.
153
Chapter 7 Enzymes
Acidity
Hydrogen ion concentration has an important effect on the efficiency of enzyme
action. Most enzymes are most effective in the region of pH 6–7, which is similar to
that in cells. Extracellular enzymes may show maximum activity in the acid or alkaline pH ranges, but the actual range in which an individual enzyme works is only
about 2.5–3.0 units; outside this range, the activity declines very rapidly. The reduction in efficiency brought about by a change in pH is due to changes in the degree of
ionisation of the substrate and the enzyme.Where the linkage between active centres
is electrostatic, the mechanism by which the intermediate complex is formed is affected and consequently the efficiency of enzyme action is reduced. In addition,
highly acidic or alkaline conditions bring about denaturation of the enzyme and subsequent loss of activity.
7.6
NOMENCLATURE OF ENZYMES
Some enzymes were named in the early days of the study of enzymes and have
non-systematic names; for example, the digestive enzymes pepsin, trypsin and
ptyalin.
In 1972, the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry and the International Union of Biochemistry recommended the use of two systems of nomenclature
for enzymes, one systematic and one working or recommended. The recommended
name was not required to be very systematic but had to be short enough for convenient use.The systematic name, formed in accordance with definite rules, was to show
the action of the enzyme as exactly as possible, thus identifying it precisely. It was to
consist of two parts, the first naming the substrate and the second, ending -ase, indicating the type of reaction catalysed. In addition, code numbers were allocated to
enzymes according to the following scheme:
■
■
■
■
The first number shows to which of the six main classes the enzyme belongs.
The second number shows the subclass.
The third number shows the sub-subclass.
The fourth number identifies the enzyme.
Reaction
⫹ NAD⫹ to
pyruvate ⫹ NADH ⫹ H⫹
Hydrolysis of terminal
non-reducing 1,4-linked
alpha-D-glucose residues
of alpha glucose (e.g.
maltose to glucose)
L-Glutamate to
4-aminobutyrate ⫹ CO2
L-Lactate
154
Recommended
name
Systematic
name
Code
number
Lactate
dehydrogenase
Alpha-glucosidase
NAD⫹
oxidoreductase
Alpha-D-glucoside
glucohydrolase
1.1.1.27
Glutamate
decarboxylase
L-Glutamate
L-Lactate:
1-carboxylase
3.2.1.20
4.1.1.15
Further reading
SUMMARY
1. Enzymes are organic catalysts. They are classified into six major groups according to the
functions they perform:
■
■
■
■
■
■
Oxidoreductases catalyse the transfer of
hydrogen, oxygen or electrons from one
molecule to another.
Tranferases catalyse transfer of groups from
one molecule to another.
Hydrolases catalyse hydrolytic cleavage.
Lyases catalyse non-hydrolytic decompositions
such as decarboxylation and deamination.
Isomerases catalyse intramolecular
rearrangements.
Ligases catalyse bond formation, the energy
for which is derived from the breakdown of
high-energy compounds such as ATP.
2. The majority of enzymes are based on complex high-molecular-weight proteins, many of
which need organic cofactors (coenzymes) if
they are to work efficiently. Others need
metallic cofactors, either bound to the
enzyme by covalent bonds or forming an
integral part of the molecule. Others do not
bind to the molecule but bind to the primary
substrate.
3. An enzyme may be present in an inactive form
(zymogen), which is changed to the active
form as and when required. A number of the
digestive enzymes are of this type, for example, trypsin.
4. Enzymes function by lowering the activation
energy of reactions.
5. Most enzymes are able to catalyse the reactions of more than one group of substances
and are described as being relatively specific.
Others may catalyse one reaction for one substance, in which case the specificity is described
as absolute.
6. The rate of enzyme action is influenced by:
■
substrate concentration;
enzyme concentration;
■ temperature;
■ acidity;
■ environment.
■
7. The first part of the name of an enzyme
indicates the substrate attacked and the second part the type of reaction carried out. In
addition, numbers are used to delineate class,
subclass and sub-subclass.
FURTHER READING
Berg J M, Tymoczko J L and Stryer L 2006 Biochemistry, 6th edn, New York, W H Freeman.
Devlin T M (ed.) 1997 Textbook of Biochemistry with Clinical Correlations, 4th edn, New
York, John Wiley & Sons.
Enzyme Nomenclature 1973 Recommendations (1972) of the International Union of Pure
and Applied Chemistry and the International Union of Biochemistry, New York, American
Elsevier.
Mathews C K and van Holde K E 1999 Biochemistry, 3rd edn, Redwood City, CA, Benjamin
Cummings Publishing Co.
155
8
Digestion
8.1
Digestion in monogastric mammals
8.2
Microbial digestion in ruminants and other herbivores
8.3
Alternative sites of microbial digestion
8.4
Nutrient digestion and the environment
Many of the organic components of food are in the form of large insoluble molecules,
which have to be broken down into simpler compounds before they can pass through
the mucous membrane of the alimentary canal into the blood and lymph. The breakingdown process is termed ‘digestion’, and the passage of the digested nutrients through
the mucous membrane ‘absorption’.
The processes important in digestion may be grouped into mechanical, chemical and
microbial activities. The mechanical activities are mastication and the muscular contractions of the alimentary canal. The main chemical action is brought about by enzymes secreted by the animal in the various digestive juices, though it is possible that plant
enzymes present in unprocessed foods may in some instances play a minor role in food
digestion. Microbial digestion of food, also enzymic, is brought about by the action of
bacteria, protozoa and fungi, microorganisms that are of special significance in ruminant digestion. In monogastric animals, microbial activity occurs mainly in the large intestine, although there is a low level of activity in the crop of birds and the stomach and
small intestine of pigs.
8.1
DIGESTION IN MONOGASTRIC MAMMALS
The alimentary canal
The various parts of the alimentary canal and its associated organs of the pig, which
will be used as the reference animal, are shown in Fig. 8.1. Specific features of other
types of digestive tract will be described after that of the pig. The digestive tract can
be considered as a tube extending from mouth to anus, lined with mucous membrane, whose function is the prehension, ingestion, comminution, digestion and
absorption of food, and the elimination of solid waste material.The various parts are
mouth, pharynx, oesophagus, stomach, and small and large intestine. The movement
of the intestinal contents along the tract is produced by peristaltic waves, which are
156
Digestion in monogastric mammals
Liver
Pancreas
Cae
cum
Rectum
m
nu
Stomach
e
od
Du
Small
intestine
Colon
Fig. 8.1 Diagrammatic representation of the digestive tract of the pig.
Source: After Moran E J Jr – See Further Reading
contractions of the circular muscle of the intestinal wall. The contractions are involuntary and are under overall autonomic nervous control. The nervous plexus within
the tissue layers of the gut wall integrates the activity of the muscles. Several different
kinds of movement of the intestinal wall are recognised, the functions of these being
the transport of materials along the tract, the mixing of the digestive juices with the
food, and the bringing of the digested nutrients into contact with the intestinal
mucous membrane for subsequent absorption.
The small intestine, which comprises the duodenum, the jejunum and the ileum,
is the main absorption site and contains a series of finger-like projections, the villi,
which greatly increase the surface area available for absorption of nutrients. Each
villus contains an arteriole and venule, together with a drainage tube of the lymphatic system, a lacteal.The venules ultimately drain into the hepatic portal system,
and the lacteals into the thoracic lymphatic duct. The luminal side of each villus is
covered with projections, the microvilli, which are often referred to as the brush
border.
There are a number of secretions that flow into the alimentary canal from the
liver, the pancreas and the wall of the canal, and many of these contain enzymes that
bring about the hydrolysis of the various food components (see Table 8.1). Some of
the proteolytic enzymes present in the secretions are initially in the form of inactive
precursors termed zymogens. These are activated after secretion into the tract.
Digestion in the mouth
This is mainly mechanical, mastication helping to break up large particles of food
and to mix it with saliva, which acts as a lubricant and is a medium for taste perception. The lower incisor teeth are used for rooting and the inward-curved upper incisors grasp and shear food items.The premolars and molars are employed to crush the
food.The pig has taste buds throughout the oral cavity and they are concentrated on
the tongue.The saliva is secreted into the mouth by three pairs of salivary glands: the
parotids, which are sited in front of each ear; the submandibular (submaxillary)
glands, which lie on each side of the lower jaw; and the sublingual glands, which are
underneath the tongue. Saliva is about 99 per cent water, the remaining 1 per cent
consisting of mucin, inorganic salts and the enzymes ␣-amylase and the complex
157
158
RNase
–
–
Nucleosidase
Phosphatases
Phosphatide 2-acyl-hydrolase
Lysolecithin acyl-hydrolase
Lecithinase A
Lysolecithinase
DNase
–
N-Ribosyl-purine ribohydrolase
Ribonucleate 3⬘-pyrimidinooligonucleotidohydrolase
Dexoyribonucleate 5⬘oligonucleotidohydrolase
Triacylglycerol acylhydrolase
Sterol-ester hydrolase
1, 4-␣-D-Glucan glucanohydrolase
␣-D-Glucoside glucohydrolase
Dextrin 6-␣-glucanohydrolase
␤-D-Galactoside galactohydrolase
␤-D-Fructofuranoside fructohydrolase
Peptidyl-L-lysine (-L-arginine)
hydrolase
␣-Aminoacyl-peptide hydrolases
Dipeptide hydrolases
–
–
–
–
Peptidyl-L-amino-acid hydrolase
Systematic name
Lipase
–
Ribonuclease 1
Lysophospholipase
Deoxyribonuclease
Enzymes acting on
ester links
Triacylglycerol lipase
Cholesterol esterase
Phospholipase A2
␣-Amylase
␣-Glucosidase
Oligo-1,6-glucosidase
␤-Galactosidase
␤-Frutofuranosidase
Diastase
Maltase
Isomaltase
Lactase
Sucrase
–
–
Aminopeptidases
Dipeptidases
Enzymes hydrolysing
glycoside links
Protaminase
–
Rennin
–
–
Carboxypeptidase
Enzymes hydrolysing
peptide links
Pepsin
Chymosin
Trypsin
Chymotrypsin
Carboxypeptidase A
Carboxypeptidase B
Trivial name
Recommended name
Table 8.1 Main digestive enzymes
Small intestine
3.1.3
3.2.2.1
3.1.4.22
3.1.1.4
3.1.1.5
3.1.4.5
3.1.1.3
3.1.1.13
3.2.1.1
3.2.1.20
3.2.1.10
3.2.1.23
3.2.1.26
3.4.11
3.4.13
Small intestine
Small intestine
Pancreas and small intestine
Pancreas and small intestine
Small intestine
Pancreas and small intestine
Pancreas
Pancreas and small intestine
Saliva, pancreas
Small intestine
Small intestine
Small intestine
Small intestine
Small intestine
Small intestine
Small intestine
3.4.12.2
3.4.12.3
Gastric mucosa
Gastric mucosa (young calves)
Pancreas
Pancreas
Source
3.4.23
3.4.23.4
3.4.21.4
3.4.21.1
Number
Orthophosphoric acid esters
Nucleosides
RNA
Lecithins and cephalins
Lysolecithin
DNA
Triacylglycerols
Cholesterol esters
Starch, glycogen, dextrin
Maltose
Dextrins
Lactose
Sucrose
Peptides
Dipeptides
Peptides
Peptides
Proteins and peptides
Proteins and peptides
Proteins and peptides
Proteins and peptides
Substrate
Chapter 8 Digestion
Digestion in monogastric mammals
lysozyme. Some animals, such as the horse, cat and dog, lack salivary ␣-amylase,
whereas the saliva of other species, humans included, has strong ␣-amylase activity.
The enzyme is present in the saliva of the pig, but the activity is low. It is doubtful
whether much digestion occurs in the mouth, since the food is quickly swallowed
and passed along the oesophagus to the stomach, where the pH is unfavourable for
␣-amylase activity. It is possible, however, that some digestion of starch by the enzyme
can occur in the stomach, since the food mass is not immediately mixed intimately with
the gastric juice. The pH of pig’s saliva is about 7.3, which is only slightly above the
value regarded as optimal for ␣-amylase activity.This enzyme hydrolyses the ␣-(1S4)glucan links in polysaccharides containing three or more ␣-(1S4)-linked D-glucose
units. The enzyme therefore acts on starch, glycogen and related polysaccharides and
oligosaccharides.When amylose, which contains exclusively ␣-(1S4)-glucosidic bonds
(see p. 26), is attacked by ␣-amylase, random cleavages of these bonds give rise to a
mixture of glucose and maltose. Amylopectin, on the other hand, contains in addition
to ␣-(1S4)-glucosidic bonds a number of branched ␣-(1S6)-glucosidic bonds, which
are not attacked by ␣-amylase, and the products include a mixture of branched and
unbranched oligosaccharides (termed ‘limit dextrins’) in which ␣-(1S6)-bonds are
abundant.
The enzyme lysozyme has been detected in many tissues and body fluids. It is
capable of hydrolysing the ␤-(1S4)-N-acetyl-glucosaminidic linkage of the repeating
disaccharide unit in the polysaccharides of the cell walls of many species of bacteria,
thereby killing and dissolving them.
BOX 8.1 Studies of digestion
To study digestion in farm animals, especially ruminants, it is often necessary to obtain samples of
digesta from various sections of the alimentary tract. Stomach contents can be sampled by means of
a tube inserted via the oesophagus. However, the sampling of this and other sections of the tract
generally requires surgical modification of the animal by the formation of fistulas. A fistula is an
opening created between a digestive organ and the exterior of the animal, and it is maintained by
means of a rubber or plastic insert known as a cannula. For example, in ruminants a fistula may be
formed between the posterior dorsal sac of the rumen and the animal’s flank. Such a fistula is normally fitted with a cannula 25–125 mm in diameter, with a screw cap. Removal of the cap allows
samples of rumen contents to be taken. In both ruminants and pigs, similar, but smaller, cannulae
may be inserted into the true stomach and into selected points of the small or large intestines. The
intestines may also be fitted with a device known as a re-entrant cannula. For this the intestine is
severed and both ends are brought close to the skin surface and joined by a tube running outside
the animal.With this tube in position the digesta flow normally from the proximal to the distal portions of the intestine. However, if the tube is opened, digesta may be collected from the proximal
part, measured, sampled and returned to the distal part.The re-entrant cannula therefore allows the
flow of digesta to be measured directly. In pigs, for example, a cannula at the terminal ileum is used
to determine how much protein digestion has occurred before the food residues are attacked by
microorganisms in the caecum and colon.
Cannulated animals live a normal life and with care can be kept free of discomfort or pain for
long periods. Sheep with a rumen cannula are known to have survived for more than 10 years, well
beyond their normal lifespan.
159
Chapter 8 Digestion
Digestion in the stomach
The stomach of the adult pig has a capacity of about 8 l and consists of a simple compartment, which functions not only as an organ for the digestion of food but also for
storage. Viewed from the exterior, the stomach can be seen to be divided into the
cardia (entrance), fundus and pylorus (terminus), the cardia and pylorus being
sphincters controlling the passage of food through the stomach. The inner surface of
the stomach is increased in area by an infolding of the epithelium and has four distinct areas.The oesophageal area is an extension of the oesophagus into the stomach
and the surface has no glands. Here, ␣-amylase activity may continue and there is an
active microbial population, mainly lactobacilli and streptococci. The cardia area
covers about one-third of the surface and secretes an alkaline, enzyme-free, viscous
mucus formed of a gel-forming glycoprotein that protects the epithelium from acid
attack. The gastric gland region covers a further third of the surface and secretes a
glycoprotein and fucolipid mucus and contains the oxyntic cells, which produce
hydrochloric acid. In addition, this region also produces pepsinogen. The fourth area
is the pyloric region, which is before the entry to the small intestine. This, area has
glands, like those in the cardia region, which secrete a protective mucus. Thus, the
gastric juice consists of water, pepsinogens, inorganic salts, mucus, hydrochloric acid
and the intrinsic factor important for the efficient absorption of vitamin B12.
A number of factors are concerned with the stimulation of the glands to secrete
gastric juice. Initially, in the cephalic phase, stimuli such as the sight and smell of
food act via the vagus nerve. Then, in the gastric phase, secretion is maintained by
chemical sensors and distension of the stomach. Finally, the presence of digesta in
the duodenum elicits secretion by neural and hormonal messages.
The pig’s stomach is rarely completely empty between meals and the slow mixing
conditions are conducive to microbial fermentation at the oesophageal end and gastric
digestion at the pyloric end. Pepsinogens are the inactive forms of pepsins that hydrolyse proteins.The acid concentration of the gastric juice varies with the diet but is generally about 0.1 M, which is sufficient to lower the pH to 2.0. The acid activates the
pepsinogens, converting them into pepsins by removing low-molecular-weight peptides from each precursor molecule. Four pepsins have been found in the pig, which
have optimum activity at two different pH levels, 2.0 and 3.5. Pepsins preferentially attack those peptide bonds adjacent to aromatic amino acids, e.g. phenylalanine, tryptophan and tyrosine, but they also have a significant action on linkages involving
glutamic acid and cysteine. Pepsins also have a strong clotting action on milk. Rennin
or chymosin, an enzyme that occurs in the gastric juice of the calf and the young
piglet, resembles pepsins in its activity. The products of protein digestion in the stomach are mainly polypeptides of variable chain length and a few amino acids.
The emptying of the stomach contents into the duodenum is controlled by osmotic sensors in the duodenum. In addition, the presence of excess lipid reduces the
emptying rate.
The epithelial surface of the pig’s stomach is susceptible to ulceration related to
the degree of processing of cereals in the diet (see p. 558).
Digestion in the small intestine
The partially digested food leaving the stomach enters the small intestine, where it is
mixed with secretions from the duodenum, liver and pancreas.The majority of digestion
and absorption occurs in the small intestine, the duodenal area being the site for
160
Digestion in monogastric mammals
mixing digesta and secretions and the jejunal area being the site of absorption. The
duodenal (Brunner’s) glands produce an alkaline secretion, which enters the duodenum through ducts situated between the villi.This secretion acts as a lubricant and also
protects the duodenal wall from the hydrochloric acid entering from the stomach.
Bile is secreted by the liver and passes to the duodenum through the bile duct. It
contains the sodium and potassium salts of bile acids, chiefly glycocholic and taurocholic (see p. 49), phospholipids, the bile pigments biliverdin and bilirubin, which
are the end products of haem catabolism, cholesterol and mucin. In all farm animals
except the horse, bile is stored in the gall bladder until required. The bile salts play
an important part in digestion by activating pancreatic lipase and emulsifying fats.
The daily requirement for bile acids is greater than the synthetic capacity of the
liver, and an enterohepatic circulation exists to maintain the supply.
The pancreas is a gland that lies in the duodenal loop and has two secretory functions: the endocrine process for the production of insulin and the exocrine process for
the production of digestive enzymes (from the acinar cells), water and electrolytes
(from the duct cells), which together form the pancreatic juice, which is secreted into
the duodenum through the pancreatic duct.The proportions of the different enzymes
change in response to the nature of the diet.
A number of factors induce the pancreas to secrete its juice into the duodenum.
When acid enters the duodenum, the hormone secretin is liberated from the epithelium
of the small intestine into the blood. When it reaches the pancreatic circulation,
secretin stimulates the pancreatic cells to secrete a watery fluid containing a high
concentration of bicarbonate ions but very little enzyme. Another hormone, cholecystokinin (pancreozymin), is also liberated from the mucosa when peptides and
other digestive products reach the duodenum.This hormone stimulates the secretion
into the pancreatic juice of proenzymes and enzymes such as trypsinogen, chymotrypsinogen, procarboxypeptidases A and B, proelastase, ␣-amylase, lipase, lecithinases and nucleases. Unlike pepsin, these enzymes have pH optima around 7–9.
The inactive zymogen trypsinogen is converted to the active trypsin by enterokinase, an enzyme liberated from the duodenal mucosa. This activation is also catalysed by trypsin itself, thus constituting an autocatalytic reaction. The activation
process results in the liberation of a hexapeptide from the amino terminal end of
trypsinogen. Trypsin is very specific and acts only upon peptide linkages involving
the carboxyl groups of lysine and arginine. Trypsin also converts chymotrypsinogen
into the active enzyme chymotrypsin, which has a specificity towards peptide bonds
involving the carboxyl groups of tyrosine, tryptophan, phenylalanine and leucine.
Procarboxypeptidases are converted by trypsin into the proteolytic enzymes carboxypeptidases, which attack the peptides from the end of the chain, splitting off the
terminal amino acid, which has a free ␣-carboxyl group. Such an enzyme is classified
as an exopeptidase, as distinct from trypsin and chymotrypsin, which attack peptide
bonds in the interior of the molecule and which are known as endopeptidases.
Pancreatic ␣-amylase is similar in function to the salivary amylase and attacks the
␣-(1S4)-glucan links in starch and glycogen.
The breakdown of fats is achieved by pancreatic lipase.This enzyme does not completely hydrolyse triacylglycerols and the action stops at the monoacylglycerol stage.
Dietary fat leaves the stomach in the form of relatively large globules that are
difficult to hydrolyse rapidly. Fat hydrolysis is helped by emulsification, which is
brought about by the action of bile salts. These bile salts are detergents or amphipaths, the sterol nucleus being lipid-soluble and the hydroxyl groups and ionised
161
Chapter 8 Digestion
α’ CH2OOC.R1
R3.COOH
CH2OOC.R1
R1.COOH
CH2OH
β CHOOC.R2
CHOOC.R2
CHOOC.R2
α CH2OOC.R3
CH2OH
CH2OH
Triacylglycerol
Diacylglycerol
Monoacylglycerol
conjugate of glycine or taurine being water-soluble (see p. 50). These amphipaths, in
addition to being emulsifying agents, also have the property of being able to aggregate together to form micelles. Although triacylglycerols are insoluble in these micelles, monoacylglycerols and most fatty acids dissolve, forming mixed micelles.
Some fatty acids, e.g. stearic acid, are not readily soluble in pure bile salt micelles
but dissolve in mixed micelles.
Lecithinase A is an enzyme that hydrolyses the bond linking the fatty acid to the
␤-hydroxyl group of lecithin (see p. 45). The product formed from this hydrolysis,
lysolecithin, is further hydrolysed by lysolecithinase (lecithinase B) to form glycerolphosphocholine and a fatty acid. Cholesterol esterase catalyses the splitting of
cholesterol esters.
The nucleic acids DNA and RNA (see p. 64) are hydrolysed by the polynucleotidases deoxyribonuclease (DNase) and ribonuclease (RNase), respectively. These enzymes catalyse the cleavage of the ester bonds between the sugar and phosphoric
acid in the nucleic acids.The end products are the component nucleotides. Nucleosidases attack the linkage between the sugar and the nitrogenous bases, liberating the
free purines and pyrimidines. Phosphatases complete the hydrolysis by separating
the orthophosphoric acid from the ribose or deoxyribose.
The hydrolysis of oligosaccharides to monosaccharides and of small peptides to
amino acids is brought about by enzymes associated with the intestinal villi. Only a
small proportion of hydrolysis occurs intraluminally and arises from enzymes present
in aged cells discarded from the intestinal mucosa. Most of the enzymatic hydrolysis
occurs at the luminal surface of the epithelial cells, although some peptides are absorbed by the cells before being broken down by enzymes present in the cytoplasm.
Enzymes produced by the villi are sucrase, which converts sucrose to glucose and
fructose; maltase, which breaks down maltose to two molecules of glucose; lactase,
which hydrolyses lactose to one molecule of glucose and one of galactose; and oligo1,6-glucosidase, which attacks the ␣-(1S 6) links in limit dextrins. Aminopeptidases
act on the peptide bond adjacent to the free amino group of simple peptides,
whereas dipeptidases complete the breakdown of dipeptides to amino acids.
Although the large intestine is recognised as the site of major microbial fermentation (see below), there is a microbial population in the small intestine. Recent work
with sugar beet pulp given to pigs fitted with ileal cannulae showed that a large proportion (47 per cent) of the neutral detergent fibre fraction was digested before the
terminal ileum.This breakdown is the result of microbial activity in the stomach and
small intestine and acid hydrolysis of some of the fibre fractions.
Digestion in the large intestine
The main site of absorption of digested nutrients is the small intestine; by the time the
food material has reached the entrance to the colon, most of the hydrolysed nutrients
162
Digestion in monogastric mammals
have been absorbed.With normal diets there is always a certain amount of material that
is resistant to the action of the enzymes secreted into the alimentary canal. The large
intestine plays an important role in the retrieval of nutrients, electrolytes and water in
the digesta. Pigs have a short caecum and long colon compared with other monogastric
omnivores. The mucosal surface does not have villi, as in the small intestine, but there
are small projections that increase the surface area.As the ileal contents enter the large
intestine, the fluid and fine particles are preferentially retained by the ascending colon,
whereas the coarser particles move distally at a faster rate. Cellulose and many of the
hemicelluloses are not attacked by any of the enzymes present in the digestive secretions of the pig. In addition certain starches, such as raw potato starch, are resistant to
hydrolysis by amylase. Lignin is known to be completely unaffected and is thus indigestible. It is also conceivable that lignified tissues may trap proteins and carbohydrates
and protect them from the action of digestive enzymes.The glands of the large intestine
are mainly mucous glands, which do not produce enzymes, and digestion in the large
intestine is therefore brought about by enzymes that have been carried down in the
food from the upper part of the tract, or it occurs as a result of microbial activity.
Extensive microbial activity occurs in the large intestine, especially the caecum.
Here the slow rate of passage and abundant nutrient sources encourage the prolific
growth of bacteria. There is a complex population of aerobic and obligate anaerobic
bacteria, including lactobacilli, streptococci, coliforms, bacteroides, clostridia and
yeasts.These metabolise a wide range of nitrogen and carbohydrate sources from both
dietary and endogenous residues, resulting in the formation of a number of products,
including indole, skatole, phenol, hydrogen sulphide, amines, ammonia and the
volatile fatty acids (acetic, propionic and butyric).As with the rumen bacteria, the relative numbers of the species change in response to the material available for fermentation. More volatile fatty acids are produced from the finer particles as they have a
larger surface area for attack by the bacteria. The digestion of cellulose and other
higher polysaccharides is nevertheless small compared with that taking place in the
horse and ruminants, which have digestive systems adapted to deal with fibrous foods.
With conventional pig diets, microbial fermentation accounts for 8–16 per cent of the
organic matter disappearing from the gastrointestinal tract. The products of microbial
breakdown of polysaccharides are not sugars but are mainly the volatile fatty acids
listed above. Lactic acid can be produced under some circumstances.The volatile fatty
acids are absorbed and contribute to the energy supply of the pig.
Bacterial action in the large intestine may have a beneficial effect owing to the
synthesis of some of the B vitamins, which may be absorbed and utilised by the host.
Synthesis of most of the vitamins in the digestive tract of the pig is, however, insufficient to meet the daily requirements and a dietary source is needed.
The waste material, or faeces, voided from the large intestine via the anus consists
of water, undigested food residues, digestive secretions, epithelial cells from the
tract, inorganic salts, bacteria and products of microbial decomposition.
Digestion in the young pig
From birth until about the age of 5 weeks the concentration and activity of many digestive secretions in the young pig are different from those in the adult animal. During
the first few days after birth the intestine is permeable to native proteins. In the
young pig, as in other farm animals, this is essential for the transfer of ␥-globulins
(antibodies) via the mother’s milk to the newborn animal. The ability of the young
pig to absorb these proteins declines rapidly and is low by 24 hours postpartum.
163
Chapter 8 Digestion
Table 8.2 Weight of disaccharide hydrolysed per kilogram body weight per hour
by small intestine enzymes in young pigs
Lactose (g)
Sucrose (g)
Maltose (g)
5.9
0.8
0.06
1.3
0.3
2.5
Newborn
5 weeks
The piglet stomach initially produces only a limited amount of hydrochloric acid
and pepsinogen, but it does secrete chymosin. This operates at pH 3.5 to break the
peptide bonds between phenylalanine and methionine in casein. It clots milk,
thereby avoiding flooding the small intestine with nutrients. As the piglet develops,
pepsinogen and hydrochloric acid secretion increases.Table 8.2 shows the activity of
some of the important carbohydrases in the young pig.
The activity of lactase is high at birth and reaches a maximum in the first week of life
and then slowly declines over the third or fourth week. Maltase activity increases from
the fourth week, while sucrase reaches a constant level between weeks 4 and 8. The
activity of ␣-amylase is present at birth but remains low until about 4 weeks of age.
These differences in enzyme activities are of special significance where piglets are
reared on early weaning diets. If young pigs are weaned at 14 days of age, their diet,
especially regarding the types of carbohydrate, should be different from that for animals weaned later. Early weaning mixtures usually include a high proportion of
dried milk products containing lactose. For later weaning at 3–4 weeks, cooked
cereals are included in the diet, since raw starch is incompletely digested in the small
intestine and passes to the large intestine, where it is fermented by bacteria, causing
diarrhoea.
Digestion in the fowl
The enzymes present in the digestive secretions of the fowl are similar to those of
mammals, although lactase has not been detected. However, the digestive tract of
the fowl differs in a number of respects from that of the pig (see Fig. 8.2). In the fowl,
the lips and cheeks are replaced by the beak, the teeth being absent.Taste is limited,
the taste buds being located on the back half of the tongue and the adjacent pharynx.The crop is a diverticulum of the oesophagus, situated about two-thirds down its
length and just before its entry into the thorax. It is a pear-shaped sac formed as a
single lobe whose main function is to act as a reservoir for holding food. It is filled
and emptied by peristalsis. The crop wall does not have mucus-secreting glands. It is
not essential to the bird, but its presence gives more flexibility in feeding activity.
Salivary amylase is known to occur in the fowl, and the action of this enzyme on
starch continues in the crop. In addition, microbial activity occurs there during the
storage of food. Lactobacilli predominate, adhering to the crop wall.The major products of fermentation are lactic and acetic acids.
The oesophagus terminates at the proventriculus or glandular stomach. This produces hydrochloric acid and pepsinogen. The proventriculus has minimal inherent
motility and food passes through as a result of oesophageal contractions. It leads to
the gizzard, a muscular organ with internal ridges that undergoes rhythmic contractions
and grinds the food, with moisture, into a smooth paste. The gizzard wall produces
koilin, a protein–polysaccharide complex similar in its amino acid composition to
keratin, which hardens in the presence of hydrochloric acid. Digesta particles pass to
164
Digestion in monogastric mammals
Small
intestine
Crop
Caeca
Colon
Caeca
Cloaca
Liver
Proventriculus
Duodenum
Gizzard
Pancreas
Fig. 8.2 Diagrammatic representation of the digestive tract of the fowl.
Source: After Moran E T Jr – See Further Reading
the small intestine when ground sufficiently; reflux of intestinal digesta into the gizzard can also occur. The presence of grit in the gizzard, although not essential, has
been shown to increase the breakdown of whole grains by about 10 per cent. Proteolysis occurs in the lumen of the gizzard. Thus, the proventriculus and gizzard are
equivalent in function to the mammalian stomach.
The duodenum encloses the pancreas as in mammals. In the fowl, the three pancreatic and two bile ducts (one from the gall bladder and one from the right lobe of
the liver) open into the intestine at the termination of the duodenum. The arrangement and number of ducts differ among fowls, geese and turkeys.
The pancreatic juice of fowls contains the same enzymes as the mammalian secretion, and the digestion of proteins, fats and carbohydrates in the small intestine is believed to be similar to that occurring in the pig. The intestinal mucosa produces
mucin, ␣-amylase, maltase, sucrase and proteolytic enzymes.
Unlike young pigs, chicks have maltase and sucrase activities in their small intestine and, since they perform well on diets containing uncooked cereals, it can be
assumed that they possess satisfactory amylase activity.
Where the small intestine joins the large intestine, there are two long blind sacs
known as the caeca. These function as absorptive organs but are not essential to the
fowl, since surgical removal causes no harmful effects. There are bacteria associated
with the mucosal surface of the caeca, and peristaltic activity mixes these with the
digesta and leads to its fermentation, with the production of volatile fatty acids.
Experiments with adult fowls indicate that the cellulose present in cereal grains is not
broken down by microbial activity to any great extent during its passage through the
digestive tract, although some hemicellulose breakdown occurs. Similarly with geese,
ligation of the caeca does not alter crude fibre digestibility and so it is unlikely that
the volatile fatty acids make a large contribution to satisfying the energy requirement of poultry.
The caeca empty by peristaltic contraction into the relatively short colon, whose
main function is the transport of digesta to its termination at the cloaca. The cloaca,
165
Chapter 8 Digestion
from which faeces and urine are excreted together, combines the function of the rectum and bladder.
Digestion in the dog and cat
Dogs and cats are predominantly carnivores. The cat is the stricter carnivore
whereas the dog is more adaptable and omnivorous. In the natural state their food
is comprised mainly of fat and protein, with little carbohydrate. As a consequence,
the digestive tract of the dog and cat is simpler than that of the pig, with emphasis on digestion in the stomach and small intestine and a short large intestine
(Fig. 8.3).
The saliva of dogs and cats has no ␣-amylase activity, as the natural diet is low in
starch.The dog eats large meals and the stomach expands to provide temporary storage of food, but this is less important in the cat, which eats small meals.The stomach
secretes gastric lipase and pepsin, and the quantity of secretion is influenced by the
amount of protein in the food and the volume of the meal. Pepsin is most active when
the animal has ingested collagen and is important for the digestion of meat and, in view
of this, is more important in the cat. In dogs, gastric juice has antibacterial activity.
The large intestine accounts for only about 8 per cent of the total digestion of food in
the dog, depending on the diet. The proportion is increased with diets containing
legumes and resistant starch. Similar to the pig, young dogs and cats are less efficient
in digesting solid food than older animals.
Dog
(Canis familiaris)
Body length: 30 cm
0
cm
10
Fig. 8.3 Diagrammatic representation of the digestive tract of the dog.
Source: After Stevens C E and Hume I D 1995 Comparative Physiology of the Vertebrate Digestive System,
2nd edn, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
166
Digestion in monogastric mammals
Pre-caecal digestion in the horse
The horse is a non-ruminant herbivore, having a simple monogastric digestive tract
similar to that of the pig but with a much enlarged hind gut (especially the caecum),
which contains a microbial population (Fig. 8.4).
The small intestine is the main site for the digestion of non-fibrous carbohydrate,
protein and fat, and the microbes in the large intestine ferment fibrous materials, as
in the ruminant (see p. 171).Thus, unlike the ruminant, the horse has enzymic digestion before microbial fermentation, and it falls between the pig and the ruminant in
its ability to digest fibrous foods.The horse spends a long time chewing its food, during which copious amounts of mucus-containing saliva are added to ease swallowing.
The saliva has no digestive enzyme activity but does contain bicarbonate, which
buffers the swallowed digesta in the proximal region of the stomach. The stomach is
Oesophagus
Stomach
Small
intestine
Caecum
Right
dorsal
colon
Right
ventral
colon
Large
intestine
Rectum
Fig. 8.4 Diagrammatic representation of the digestive tract of the horse.
Source: After Colemann R Basic Horse Nutrition, www.ca.uky.edu/agc/pubs/asc/asc114/asc114.htm
accessed on 06/08/09.
167
Chapter 8 Digestion
relatively small, being only about 10 per cent of the total gastrointestinal tract, and
is suited to frequent consumption of small quantities of food. Its major role is to regulate the flow of digesta to the small intestine, ensuring efficient digestion there. The
stomach is rarely empty and the retention time of digesta in the stomach is short
(2–6 hours), particularly in the grazing horse.There is limited microbial fermentation
in the oesophageal and fundic regions of the stomach, with the production of lactic
acid.Towards the pyloric region hydrochloric acid is added and the pH of the digesta
falls. The small intestine represents about 30 per cent of the volume of the gastrointestinal tract and 75 per cent of its length, and movement of digesta through it is
rapid. It is the main site of digestion of protein to amino acids and their absorption.
Soluble carbohydrates, such as starches and sugars, are exposed to pancreatic amylase and ␣-glucosidase secreted by the cells in the wall of the small intestine. Amylase activity is low compared with that of the pig and may limit the rate of digestion
of starches, allowing some starches to reach the large intestine if given in large quantities. The disaccharidase activity is similar to that in the pig. The horse has no gall
bladder and thus cannot store bile: the presence of hydrochloric acid in the duodenum causes stimulation of bile secretion from the liver. The lack of a gall bladder
does not seem to affect the digestion of fat. It is not certain whether the pancreatic
secretions have lipase activity. The remaining undigested material then passes to the
large intestine and is exposed to microbial fermentation (see p. 186). Despite the
rapid transit of digesta through the small intestine, digestion and absorption are usually efficient and the composition of the material entering the large intestine is fairly
uniform. This is important for the correct functioning of the large intestine, and instances of disturbance often result from inefficient digestion in the small intestine.
Absorption of digested nutrients
The main organ for the absorption of dietary nutrients by the monogastric mammal
is the small intestine.This part of the tract is specially adapted for absorption because
its inner surface area is increased by folding and the presence of villi. Although the
duodenum has villi, this is primarily a mixing and neutralising site, and the jejunum
is the major absorptive site. Absorption of a nutrient from the lumen of the intestine
can take place by passive transport, involving simple diffusion, provided there is a
high concentration of the nutrient outside the cell and a low concentration inside.
The vascular system in the villi is arranged so that the concentration gradient is maximised. Nutrients such as monosaccharides, amino acids and small peptides are absorbed at a faster rate than can be accounted for by passive diffusion.The absorption
of such molecules is aided by specific carrier transport systems in which carrier proteins reversibly bind to and transfer the nutrient across the brush border and basolateral membranes of the epithelial cells. The transfer may be by facilitative transport,
in which the carrier transports the molecule down its concentration gradient. Alternatively, absorption may be by a process of active transport (or co-transport). Here,
the carrier has two specific binding sites and the organic nutrient is attached to one
of these while the other site picks up a sodium ion (in the case of monosaccharides
and amino acids) or a hydrogen ion (in the case of dipeptides).The sodium or hydrogen ion travels down the chemical gradient and the loaded carrier thus moves across
the intestinal membrane and deposits the organic nutrient and the sodium or hydrogen inside the cell.The empty carrier then returns across the membrane, free to pick
up more nutrients.The sodium ion is actively pumped back to the lumen by Na⫹/K⫹
168
Digestion in monogastric mammals
transporting ATPase. In the case of the dipeptide carrier, the hydrogen ion gradient is
maintained by a system involving Na⫹ and H⫹, which generates an acidic microclimate on the small intestine surface. A number of different carriers are thought to
exist, although some may carry more than one nutrient; for example, xylose can be
bound by the same carrier as glucose. The carrier proteins are large complex molecules and have binding sites for specific nutrients or related groups of nutrients. The
molecular weight can exceed 50 000 and the sodium-linked glucose transporter is
made up of 664 amino acid residues (or molecules).
Since there are costs to the animal in synthesising and maintaining the carrier
proteins, it would be inefficient to maintain a specific level of carrier when the substrate is not present. On the other hand, if insufficient carrier is available, the transport pathway will limit the assimilation of nutrients. Therefore, the carrier proteins
are regulated and show adaptation to the level of nutrient present in the gut.
A third method of absorption is by pinocytosis ‘cell drinking’, in which cells have
the capacity to engulf large molecules in solution or suspension. Such a process is
particularly important in many newborn suckled mammals in which immunoglobulins present in colostrum are absorbed intact.
Carbohydrates
The digestion of carbohydrates by enzymes secreted by the pig and other monogastric animals results in the production of monosaccharides. The formation of these
simple sugars from disaccharides takes place on the surface of the microvillus membrane. The aldoses, such as glucose, are actively transported across the cell after attachment to the specific carrier and carried by the portal blood systems to the liver.
The mechanism for the absorption of ketoses is unclear, although the existence of a
facilitative carrier for fructose has been established.The rates of absorption of various
sugars differ. At equal concentrations, galactose, glucose, fructose, mannose, xylose
and arabinose are absorbed in decreasing order of magnitude.
Fats
After digestion fats are present in the small intestine in the solubilised form of mixed
micelles. Efficient absorption requires a rapid movement of the highly hydrophobic
molecule through the unstirred water layer adjacent to the mucosa. This is the ratelimiting stage of absorption.The mixed bile salt micelles, with their hydrophilic groups,
aid this process.Absorption across the brush border membrane of the intestinal cells is
by passive diffusion and is at its maximum in the jejunum. The bile salts are absorbed
by an active process in the distal ileum. Following absorption there is a resynthesis of
triacyglycerols, a process that requires energy, and they are formed into chylomicrons
(minute fat droplets), which then pass into the lacteals of the villi, enter the thoracic
duct and join the general circulation. Medium- and short-chain fatty acids, such as
those occurring in butterfat, require neither bile salts nor micelle formation as they can
be absorbed very rapidly from the lumen of the intestine directly into the portal bloodstream. The entry of these fatty acids is sodium-dependent and takes place against a
concentration gradient by active transport. In fowls, the lymphatic system is negligible
and most of the fat is transported in the portal blood as low-density lipoproteins.
Proteins
The products of protein digestion in the lumen of the intestine are free amino acids
and small (oligo-) peptides. The latter enter the epithelial cells of the small intestine
169
Chapter 8 Digestion
where, in the main, they are hydrolysed by specific di- and tripeptidases. However,
some small peptides are absorbed intact and subsequently appear in the portal
blood.The amino acids, which subsequently pass into the portal blood and thence to
the liver, are absorbed from the small intestine by an active transport mechanism,
which in most cases is sodium-dependent. In the case of glycine, proline and lysine,
the sodium molecule is unnecessary. Several systems have been described for amino
acid transfer, and these can be classified into four main groups. One is concerned
with the transfer of neutral amino acids and separate carriers transfer dicarboxylic
and basic amino acids. In addition, there is a fourth system for the movement of the
imino acids and glycine. These mechanisms, however, are not completely rigid and
some amino acids can be transferred by more than one system. The rates of absorption of the amino acids differ; for example, the rate is higher for methionine than
valine, which in turn is higher than that for threonine.
Reference has already been made to the absorption of intact proteins, such as
immunoglobulins, in the newborn animal by pinocytosis.
Minerals
Absorption of mineral elements is either by simple diffusion or by carrier-mediated
transport. The exact mechanisms for all minerals have not been established, but the
absorption of calcium, for example, is regulated by 1,25-dehydroxycholecalciferol
(see p. 80). Low alimentary pH favours calcium absorption, but absorption is inhibited by a number of dietary factors such as the presence of oxalates and phytates.An
excess of either calcium or phosphorus interferes with the absorption of the other.
The absorption of calcium is also influenced by the requirements of the animal. For
example, the absorption of calcium from the digestive tract of laying hens is much
greater when shell formation is in progress than when the shell gland is inactive.
The absorption of iron is to a large extent independent of the dietary source. The
animal has difficulty in excreting iron from the body in any quantity, and a method
exists for regulating iron absorption to prevent excessive amounts entering the body
(see p. 122). In adults the absorption of the element is generally low, but after severe
bleeding and during pregnancy the requirement for iron is increased so that absorption of the element is also increased. Anaemia due to iron deficiency may, however,
develop on low-iron diets. Experiments carried out with dogs have shown that the
absorption of iron by anaemic animals may be 20 times as great as that by normal
healthy dogs.
Another example of the mechanism of mineral absorption is shown by zinc. This
mineral is absorbed through the small intestine by a carrier-mediated process, with
uptake at the brush border membrane being the rate-limiting step. In rats and humans, the carrier becomes saturated at levels of zinc below that normally seen in the
diet, and zinc uptake from aqueous solutions above this saturation level is by passive
diffusion. Calcium is believed to inhibit the absorption of zinc.
It is thought that iodine in organic combination is less well absorbed than the inorganic form. Plants contain a higher proportion of inorganic iodide than do foods of
animal origin.
Vitamins
The fat-soluble vitamins A, D, E and K pass through the intestinal mucosa mainly by
the same passive diffusion mechanism as for fats.Within the cells they may combine
with proteins and enter the general circulation as lipoproteins.
170
Microbial digestion in ruminants and other herbivores
Vitamin A is more readily absorbed from the digestive tract than its precursor
carotene, although it is thought that vitamin A esters must first be hydrolysed by an
esterase to the alcohol form before being absorbed. Phytosterols are poorly absorbed,
and it is generally considered that unless ergosterol has been irradiated to vitamin
D2 before ingestion it cannot be absorbed from the tract in any quantity.
Water-soluble vitamins are believed to be absorbed both by simple diffusion and
by carrier-mediated transport, which is sodium-dependent.Vitamin B6 is absorbed by
passive diffusion, mainly in the small intestine, and the amount absorbed is related
linearly to the amount in the digesta.The importance of a carrier glycoprotein (intrinsic factor) for the absorption of vitamin B12 has already been stressed (see p. 98).
Detoxification in the alimentary tract
Many food constituents are potentially toxic to the animal consuming them. Microbial contaminants are an obvious example; the digestive enzymes kill many bacteria,
but some organisms may damage the gut, which allows them or the toxins they produce to invade the animal’s tissues. Foreign proteins, especially those with endocrine
activity, could harm the animal if absorbed, but the gut provides an effective barrier
to prevent their absorption before they are hydrolysed. The same is true of nucleic
acids (whose breakdown is a matter of concern, as some animal foods may now be
derived from genetically modified plants). Some of the toxic constituents of pasture
plants are broken down in the rumen of cattle, sheep and goats (see p. 494).As mentioned above, the animal body avoids excessive intake of the mineral elements calcium and iron by selective absorption.
Some larger molecules are able to bypass the barrier presented by the gut. This
may be desirable in some instances (e.g. absorption of protein antibodies in the newborn animal and absorption of antibiotics administered orally), but undesirable in
others (e.g. apparent absorption of the proteins known as prions, which are responsible for bovine spongiform encephalopathy; see p. 579).
8.2
MICROBIAL DIGESTION IN RUMINANTS
AND OTHER HERBIVORES
The foods of ruminants, forages and fibrous roughages, consist mainly of ␤-linked
polysaccharides such as cellulose, which cannot be broken down by mammalian digestive enzymes. Ruminants have therefore evolved a special system of digestion
that involves microbial fermentation of food before its exposure to their own digestive enzymes. This part of the chapter describes the anatomical and physiological
adaptations of the ruminant that facilitate microbial digestion, and outlines the
biochemistry of this form of digestion and its nutritional consequences. Herbivores
other than ruminants, such as the horse, have adopted systems of microbial digestion
that differ from those of ruminants, and these will be briefly described.
Anatomy and physiology of ruminant digestion
The stomach of the ruminant is divided into four compartments (Fig. 8.5). In the
young suckling, the first two compartments, the rumen and its continuation the reticulum, are relatively undeveloped, and milk, on reaching the stomach, is channelled
171
Chapter 8 Digestion
Rumen
Small intestine
Oesophagus
Reticulum
Omasum
Rumen
Abomasum
Fig. 8.5 Diagrammatic representation of the rumen, reticulum, omasum and
abomasum of the ruminant, indicating the flow of digesta.
Source: After Annison E F and Lewis D 1959 Metabolism in the Rumen, London, Methuen and Co.
by a tube-like fold of tissue, known as the oesophageal or reticular groove, directly
to the third and fourth compartments, the omasum and abomasum. As the calf or
lamb begins to eat solid food, the first two compartments (often considered together
as the reticulo-rumen) enlarge greatly, until in the adult they comprise 85 per cent of
the total capacity of the stomach. The consumption of fibrous foods, such as straw
and hay, stimulates the enlargement of the reticulum. The fermentation of food by
microbes in the rumen produces volatile fatty acids (see p. 176) and these, particularly butyric acid from the fermentation of concentrates such as cereals, encourage
the formation of papillae on the rumen wall. Papillae are small finger-like projections
that increase the surface area for the absorption of nutrients. Thus, a combination of
fibrous and starchy foods encourages the development of the rumen and assists the
weaning process. In the adult, the oesophageal groove does not function under normal feeding conditions, and both food and water pass into the reticulo-rumen. However, the reflex closure of the groove to form a channel can be stimulated even in
adults, particularly if they are allowed to drink from a teat.
Ruminant teeth and chewing actions are adapted for the efficient comminution of
fibrous foods. The cheek teeth are large and form an extensive grinding surface with
many ridges, which are resistant to wear. The distance between the right and left
teeth in the lower jaw is less than that in the upper jaw, so that when the jaws are
closed centrally only a narrow strip of the lower and upper teeth are in contact. During chewing, the ruminant employs lateral jaw movements, which involve the teeth
on only one side at a time. Powerful muscles move the jaw in three phases – first the
jaw is dropped, second it is moved laterally to one side on which chewing will occur,
and finally it is vigorously carried up and inwards, engaging the teeth in a grinding
fashion. The food is diluted with copious amounts of saliva, first during eating and
again during rumination: typical quantities of saliva produced per day are 150 l in
cattle and 10 l in sheep. Rumen contents contain 850–930 g water/kg on average, but
they often exist in two phases: a lower liquid phase, in which the finer food particles
are suspended, and a drier upper layer of coarser solid material. The breakdown of
172
Microbial digestion in ruminants and other herbivores
food is accomplished partly by physical and partly by chemical means. The contents
of the rumen are continually mixed by the rhythmic contractions of its walls, and
during rumination material at the anterior end is drawn back into the oesophagus
and returned by a wave of contraction to the mouth.Any liquid is rapidly swallowed
again, but coarser material is thoroughly chewed before being returned to the
rumen.The major factor inducing the animal to ruminate is probably the tactile stimulation of the epithelium of the anterior rumen; some diets, notably those containing
little or no coarse roughage, may fail to provide sufficient stimulation for rumination.
The time spent by the animal in rumination depends on the fibre content of the food.
In grazing cattle it is commonly about 8 hours per day, or about equal to the time
spent in grazing. Each bolus of food regurgitated is chewed 40–50 times and thus receives a much more thorough mastication than during eating.
The reticulo-rumen provides a continuous culture system for anaerobic bacteria,
protozoa and fungi. Food and water enter the rumen and the food is partially fermented to yield principally volatile fatty acids, microbial cells and the gases
methane and carbon dioxide. The gases are lost by eructation (belching) and the
volatile fatty acids are mainly absorbed through the rumen wall. The microbial cells,
together with undegraded food components, pass to the abomasum and small intestine; there they are digested by enzymes secreted by the host animal, and the products of digestion are absorbed. In the large intestine there is a second phase of
microbial digestion. The volatile fatty acids produced in the large intestine are
absorbed, but microbial cells are excreted – with undigested food components – in
the faeces.
Like other continuous culture systems, the rumen requires a number of homeostatic mechanisms. The acids produced by fermentation are theoretically capable of reducing the pH of rumen liquor to 2.5–3.0, but under normal conditions the pH is
maintained at 5.5–6.5. Phosphate and bicarbonate contained in the saliva act as
buffers; in addition, the rapid absorption of the acids (and also of ammonia; see below)
helps to stabilise the pH. The osmotic pressure of rumen contents is kept near that of
blood by the flux of ions between them. Oxygen entering with the food is quickly used
up and anaerobiosis is maintained. In the absence of oxygen, carbon is the ultimate acceptor of hydrogen ions, hence the formation of methane. The temperature of rumen
liquor remains close to that of the animal (38–42 °C). Finally, the undigested components of the food, together with soluble nutrients and bacteria, are eventually removed
from the rumen by the passage of digesta through the reticulo-omasal orifice.
Rumen microorganisms
The bacteria number 109–1010 per millilitre of rumen contents. Over 200 species
have been identified, and for descriptions of them the reader is referred to the works
listed at the end of this chapter. Most of these bacteria are non-spore-forming anaerobes. Table 8.3 lists a number of the more important species and indicates the substrate they utilise and the products of the fermentation. This information is based on
studies of isolated species in vitro and is not completely applicable in vivo. For example, it appears from Table 8.3 that succinic acid is an important end product, but in
practice this is converted into propionic acid by other bacteria such as Selenomonas
ruminantium (see Fig. 8.6); such interactions between microorganisms are an important feature of rumen fermentation. A further point is that the activities of a given
species of bacteria may vary from one strain of that species to another. The total
173
Chapter 8 Digestion
Table 8.3 Typical rumen bacteria, their energy sources and fermentation products in vitro
Species
Fibrobacter
succinogenes
Ruminococcus
flavefaciens
Ruminococcus
albus
Streptococcus
bovis
Prevotella
ruminicola
Megasphaera
elsdenii
Lachnospira
multipara
Description
Gram-negative
rods
Catalase-negative
streptococci with
yellow colonies
Single or paired
cocci
Gram-positive,
short chains of
cocci, capsulated
Gram-negative,
oval or rod
Large cocci,
paired or in
chains
Gram-positive
curved rods
Typical
energy
sources
Typical fermentation products (excluding gases)
Acetic Propionic Butyric Lactic
Cellulose
⫹
Cellulose
⫹
Cellobiose
⫹
⫹
Succinic
Alternative
Formic energy
sources
⫹
⫹
⫹
⫹
⫹
Starch
⫹
Lactate
⫹
Pectins
⫹
⫹
⫹
Xylan
Glucose
⫹
Glucose
Glucose
(starch)
Xylan
⫹
⫹
⫹
Xylan,
starch
Glucose,
glycerol
Glucose,
fructose
number of bacteria and the relative population of individual species vary with the
animal’s diet; for example, diets rich in concentrate foods promote high total counts
and encourage the proliferation of lactobacilli.
Protozoa are present in much smaller numbers (106/ml) than bacteria but, being
larger, may equal the latter in total mass. Over 100 species have been identified in
the rumen. In adult animals, most of the protozoa are ciliates belonging to two families. The Isotrichidae, commonly called the holotrichs, are ovoid organisms covered
with cilia; they include the genera Isotricha and Dasytricha. The Ophryoscolecidae,
or oligotrichs, include many species that vary considerably in size, shape and
appearance; they include the genera Entodinium, Diplodinium, Epidinium and
Ophryoscolex. The oligotrichs can ingest food particles and cannot utilise cellulose.
A normal rumen flora (bacteria) and fauna (protozoa) is established quite early in
life, as early as 6 weeks of age in calves.
The fungi of the rumen have been studied for less than the other microorganisms,
and their place in the rumen ecosystem has yet to be fully characterised. They are
strictly anaerobic, and their lifecycle includes a motile phase (as a zoospore) and a
vegetative phase (sporangium). During the latter phase they become attached to
food particles by rhizoids, which can penetrate cell walls. At least 12 species or
strains have been identified, typically those belonging to the genus Neocallimastix.
The rumen fungi are capable of utilising most polysaccharides and many soluble sugars; some carbohydrates not used by these fungi are pectin, polygalacturonic acid,
arabinose, fucose, mannose and galactose.The contribution of the rumen fungi to the
fermentation of food has not yet been quantified, but it is known that they are most
numerous (constituting 10 per cent of the microbial biomass) when diets are rich in
fibre (i.e. not cereal diets or young pasture herbage).
174
Microbial digestion in ruminants and other herbivores
The rumen microorganisms can be envisaged as operating together, as so-called
consortia, to attack and break down foods. Some, like the fungi, are capable of invading and colonising plant tissues; others follow up to ferment the spoils of the invasion. Detailed studies, including some involving electron micrography, have shown
that 75 per cent of rumen bacteria are attached to food particles.
As the microbial mass synthesised in the rumen provides about 20 per cent of the
nutrients absorbed by the host animal, the composition of microorganisms is important.The bacterial dry matter contains about 100 g nitrogen/kg, but only 80 per cent
of this is in the form of amino acids, the remaining 20 per cent being present as
nucleic acid nitrogen. Moreover, some of the amino acids are contained in the peptidoglycan of the cell wall membrane and are not digested by the host animal.
Digestion of carbohydrates
The diet of the ruminant contains considerable quantities of cellulose, hemicelluloses, starch and water-soluble carbohydrates that are mainly in the form of fructans.
Thus, in young pasture herbage, which is frequently the sole food of the ruminant,
each kilogram of dry matter may contain about 400 g cellulose and hemicelluloses,
and 200 g of water-soluble carbohydrates. In mature herbage, and in hay and straw,
the proportion of cellulose and hemicelluloses is much higher, and that of watersoluble carbohydrates is much lower.The ␤-linked carbohydrates are associated with
lignin, which may comprise 20–120 g/kg DM. All the carbohydrates, but not lignin,
are attacked by the rumen microorganisms; the principal bacterial species involved
(see Table 8.3) are Fibrobacter succinogenes and the Ruminococci, and the fungi are
also thought to play an important role.
The breakdown of carbohydrates in the rumen may be divided into two stages,
the first of which is the digestion of complex carbohydrates to simple sugars. This is
brought about by extracellular microbial enzymes and is thus analogous to the digestion of carbohydrates in non-ruminants. Cellulose is decomposed by one or more ␤1,4-glucosidases to cellobiose, which is then converted either to glucose or, through
the action of a phosphorylase, to glucose-1-phosphate. Starch and dextrins are first
converted by amylases to maltose and isomaltose and then by maltases, maltose
phosphorylases or 1,6-glucosidases to glucose or glucose-1-phosphate. Fructans are
hydrolysed by enzymes attacking 2,1 and 2,6 linkages to give fructose, which may
also be produced – together with glucose – by the digestion of sucrose (see Fig. 8.6).
Pentoses are the major product of hemicellulose breakdown, which is brought
about by enzymes attacking the ␤-1,4 linkages to give xylose and uronic acids. The
latter are then converted to xylose. Uronic acids are also produced from pectins,
which are first hydrolysed to pectic acid and methanol by pectinesterase. The pectic
acid is then attacked by polygalacturonidases to give galacturonic acids, which in
turn yield xylose. Xylose may also be produced from hydrolysis of the xylans, which
may form a significant part of the dry matter of grasses.
The simple sugars produced in the first stage of carbohydrate digestion in the
rumen are rarely detectable in the rumen liquor because they are immediately taken
up and metabolised intracellularly by the microorganisms. For this second stage, the
pathways involved are in many respects similar to those involved in the metabolism
of carbohydrates by the animal itself, and are thus discussed in Chapter 10. However, the main pathways are outlined in Fig. 8.7. The key intermediate (i.e. linking
the pathways of Fig. 8.6 with those of Fig. 8.7) is pyruvate, and Fig. 8.7 shows the
175
Chapter 8 Digestion
Cellulose
Starch
Cellobiose
Maltose
Glucose-1-phosphate
Glucose
Isomaltose
Sucrose
Pectins
Glucose-6-phosphate
Uronic acids
Fructose-6-phosphate
Fructose
Fructans
Pentoses
Hemicelluloses
Fructose-1,6-phosphate
Pentosans
Pyruvate
Fig. 8.6 Conversion of carbohydrates to pyruvate in the rumen.
Pyruvate
Formate
CO2
H2
Methane
MalonylCoA
Acetyl phosphate
Acetyl Coenzyme A
Lactate
Oxalacetate
Acetoacetyl-CoA
Lactyl-CoA
Malate
Acrylyl-CoA
Fumarate
Propionyl-CoA
Succinate
β-Hydroxybutyryl-CoA
Crotonyl-CoA
Methylmalonyl-CoA
Succinyl-CoA
Butyryl-CoA
Acetate
Butyrate
Propionate
Fig. 8.7 Conversion of pyruvate to volatile fatty acids in the rumen.
pathways that link pyruvate with the major end products of rumen carbohydrate digestion, which are acetic, propionic and butyric acids, carbon dioxide and methane.
Additional fatty acids are also formed in the rumen, generally in small quantities, by
deamination of amino acids; these are isobutyric acid from valine, valeric acid from
proline, 2-methyl butyric acid from isoleucine and 3-methyl butyric acid from
leucine. Figure 8.7 shows that propionate can be produced from pyruvate by several
alternative pathways. The pathway through lactate and acrylate predominates when
the ruminant’s diet includes a high proportion of concentrates, and pathways
through succinate are employed when the diet consists mainly of fibrous roughages.
With concentrate diets, lactate produced by the first pathway may accumulate in the
rumen and threaten the animal with acidosis.
176
Microbial digestion in ruminants and other herbivores
The overall equation for the rumen fermentation of hexoses is:
65 acetate
57 Hexose
114 pyruvate
21 propionate
+
20 CO2 +
73 CH4
14 butyrate
Thus the molar proportions of the three volatile fatty acids (VFAs) derived from
hexose are acetate 0.65, propionate 0.21 and butyrate 0.14. Some examples of the
actual concentrations and proportions of VFA in the rumen are given in Table 8.4.
They differ from the proportions given above because carbohydrates other than
hexoses (and also amino acids) are fermented in the rumen.The relative concentrations of VFAs are often assumed to represent their relative rates of production
(which are more difficult to measure; see Box 8.2), but this may be misleading if
individual VFAs are absorbed at different rates. Their total concentration varies
widely according to the animal’s diet and the time that has elapsed since the previous meal, but it is normally in the range of 70–150 mmol/l (equivalent to approximately 5–10 g/l). The relative proportions of the acids also vary. Mature fibrous
forages give rise to VFA mixtures containing a high proportion (about 70 per cent)
of acetic acid. Less mature forages tend to give a rather lower proportion of acetic
and a higher proportion of propionic acid. The addition of concentrates to a forage
Table 8.4 Volatile fatty acids (VFAs) in the rumen liquor of cattle or sheep fed on
various diets
Animal
Sheep
Cattle
Cattle
Sheep
Cattle
Sheep
Cattle
Cattle
Diet
Young ryegrass
herbage
Mature ryegrass
herbage
Grass silage
Chopped lucerne hay
Ground lucerne hay
Long hay (0.4),
concentrates (0.6)
Pelleted hay (0.4),
concentrates (0.6)
Hay : concentrate
1:0
0.8 : 0.2
0.6 : 0.4
0.4 : 0.6
0.2 : 0.8
Barley (no ciliate
protozoa in rumen)
Barley (ciliates
present in rumen)
Individual VFA (molar proportions)
Total VFA
(mmoles/l)
Acetic
Propionic
Butyric
Others
107
0.60
0.24
0.12
0.04
137
0.64
0.22
0.11
0.03
108
113
105
96
0.74
0.63
0.65
0.61
0.17
0.23
0.19
0.18
0.07
0.10
0.11
0.13
0.03
0.04
0.05
0.08
140
0.50
0.30
0.11
0.09
97
80
87
76
70
146
0.66
0.61
0.61
0.52
0.40
0.48
0.22
0.25
0.23
0.34
0.40
0.28
0.09
0.11
0.13
0.12
0.15
0.14
0.03
0.03
0.02
0.03
0.05
0.10
105
0.62
0.14
0.18
0.06
177
Chapter 8 Digestion
BOX 8.2 Measurement of volatile fatty acid (VFA) production
The production rate of VFAs in the rumen can be measured by infusion of isotopically labelled
forms of the acids into the rumen via a cannula and by recording their dilution by newly formed
VFA. If only one VFA is infused, production of the others can be estimated from their relative proportions in rumen liquor. However, infusion of all three major acids provides more reliable estimates because it allows for differences between them in rates of production and/or absorption.
also increases the proportion of propionic at the expense of acetic, this effect being
particularly strong with diets containing a high proportion (0.6) of concentrates.
With all-concentrate diets, the proportion of propionic may even exceed that of
acetic. However, even with this type of diet, acetic acid predominates if the rumen
ciliate protozoa survive. Grinding and pelleting of forage has little effect on the
VFA proportions when the diet consists of forage alone, but it causes a switch from
acetic to propionic acid if the diet also contains concentrates. Table 8.4 also shows
that the proportion of butyric acid is less affected by diet than are the shorterchain acids.
The total weight of acids produced may be as high as 4 kg per day in cows. Much
of the acid produced is absorbed directly from the rumen, reticulum and omasum, although 10–20 per cent may pass through the abomasum and be absorbed in the
small intestine. In addition, some of the products of carbohydrate digestion in the
rumen are used by the microorganisms to form their own cellular polysaccharides,
but the amounts of these passing to the small intestine are probably small and hardly
significant.
The rate of gas production in the rumen is most rapid immediately after a meal and
in the cow may exceed 30 l/hour.The typical composition of rumen gas is 40 per cent
carbon dioxide, 30–40 per cent methane; 5 per cent hydrogen, and small and varying proportions of oxygen and nitrogen (from ingested air). Carbon dioxide is produced partly as a by-product of fermentation and partly by the reaction of organic
acids with the bicarbonate present in the saliva. The basic reaction by which
methane is formed is the reduction of carbon dioxide by hydrogen, some of which
may be derived from formate. Methanogenesis, however, is a complicated process
that involves folic acid and vitamin B12. About 4.5 g of methane is formed for every
100 g of carbohydrate digested, and the ruminant loses about 7 per cent of its food
energy as methane (see Chapter 11).
Most of the gas produced is lost by eructation; if gas accumulates it causes the
condition known as bloat, in which the distension of the rumen may be so great as to
result in the collapse and death of the animal. Bloat occurs most commonly in dairy
cows grazing on young, clover-rich herbage and is due not so much to excessive gas
production as to the failure of the animal to eructate. Frequently the gas is trapped in
the rumen in a foam, whose formation may be promoted by substances present in
the clover. It is also possible that the reflex controlling eructation is inhibited by a
physiologically active substance that is present in the food or formed during fermentation. Bloat is a particularly serious problem on the clover-rich pastures of New
Zealand, where it is prevented by dosing the cows or spraying the pasture with
antifoaming agents, such as vegetable oils.Another form of bloat, termed ‘feedlot bloat’,
178
Microbial digestion in ruminants and other herbivores
occurs in cattle fattened intensively on diets containing much concentrate and little
roughage. Bloat-preventing agents are discussed in Chapter 24.
The extent to which cellulose is digested in the rumen depends particularly on the
degree of lignification of the plant material. Lignin, and also the related substance
cutin, is resistant to attack by anaerobic bacteria, probably because of its low oxygen
content and its condensed structure (which inhibits hydrolysis). Lignin appears to
hinder the breakdown of the cellulose with which it is associated. Thus, in young
pasture grass containing only 50 g lignin/kg DM, 80 per cent of the cellulose may be
digested, but in older herbage with 100 g lignin/kg, the proportion of cellulose digested
may be less than 60 per cent. Ruminant diets based on cereals may contain as much
as 500 g/kg of starch (and sugars), of which over 90 per cent may be fermented in
the rumen and the rest digested in the small intestine.This fermentation is rapid, and
the resulting fall in the pH of rumen liquor inhibits cellulose-fermenting organisms
and thus depresses the breakdown of cellulose.
The breakdown of cellulose and other resistant polysaccharides is undoubtedly
the most important digestive process taking place in the rumen. Besides contributing
to the energy supply of the ruminant, it ensures that other nutrients that might escape
digestion are exposed to enzyme action. Although the main factor in the process is
the presence of microorganisms in the rumen, there are other factors of importance.
The great size of the rumen (its contents normally contribute 10–20 per cent of the
liveweight of ruminants) allows food to accumulate and ensures that sufficient
time is available for the rather slow breakdown of cellulose. In addition, the movements of the reticulo-rumen and the act of rumination play a part by breaking up the
food and exposing it to attack by microorganisms.
Digestion of protein
The digestion of protein in the rumen is illustrated in Fig. 8.8. Food proteins are
hydrolysed to peptides and amino acids by rumen microorganisms, but some amino
acids are degraded further, to organic acids, ammonia and carbon dioxide.An example of the deamination of amino acids is provided by valine, which, as mentioned
above, is converted to isobutyric acid. Thus, the branched-chain acids found in
rumen liquor are derived from amino acids. The main proteolytic organisms are
Prevotella ruminicola, Peptostreptococci species and the protozoa. The ammonia
produced, together with some small peptides and free amino acids, is utilised by the
rumen organisms to synthesise microbial proteins. Some of the microbial protein is
broken down in the rumen and its nitrogen is recycled (i.e. taken up by microorganisms).When the organisms are carried through to the abomasum and small intestine,
their cell proteins are digested and absorbed. An important feature of the formation
of microbial protein is that bacteria are capable of synthesising indispensable as well
as dispensable amino acids, thus rendering their host independent of dietary supplies
of the former.
The extent to which dietary protein is degraded to ammonia in the rumen, and
conversely the extent to which it escapes rumen degradation and is subsequently
digested in the small intestine, is discussed in Chapters 10 and 13. At this point it is
sufficient to emphasise that with most diets, the greater part (and sometimes all)
of the protein reaching the ruminant’s small intestine will be microbial protein of
reasonably constant composition. The lesser part will be undegraded food protein,
which will vary in amino acid composition according to the nature of the diet.
179
Chapter 8 Digestion
Food
Protein
Non-protein N
Salivary
glands
Undegradable protein
Degradable protein
Non-protein N
Peptides
Rumen
Liver
Amino acids
Ammonia
NH3
Urea
Microbial protein
Kidney
Digested
in
small intestine
Excreted in
urine
Fig. 8.8 Digestion and metabolism of nitrogenous compounds in the rumen.
The ammonia in rumen liquor is the key intermediate in microbial degradation
and synthesis of protein. If the diet is deficient in protein, or if the protein resists
degradation, then the concentration of rumen ammonia will be low (about 50 mg/l)
and the growth of rumen organisms will be slow; in consequence, the breakdown
of carbohydrates will be retarded. On the other hand, if protein degradation
proceeds more rapidly than synthesis, then ammonia will accumulate in rumen
liquor and the optimum concentration will be exceeded. When this happens, ammonia is absorbed into the blood, carried to the liver and converted to urea (see
Fig. 8.8). Some of this urea may be returned to the rumen via the saliva and also
directly through the rumen wall, but the greater part is excreted in the urine and
thus wasted.
Estimates of the optimum concentration of ammonia in rumen liquor vary widely,
from 85 mg/l to over 300 mg/l. Rather than expressing the optimum as the concentration in rumen liquor, it would probably be more realistic to relate ammonia to fermentable organic matter, since it is known that for each kilogram of organic matter
180
Microbial digestion in ruminants and other herbivores
fermented, an approximately constant quantity of nitrogen is taken up by rumen
bacteria as protein and nucleic acid (see below).
If the food is poorly supplied with protein and the concentration of ammonia in
rumen liquor is low, the quantity of nitrogen returned to the rumen as urea from the
blood (see Fig. 8.8) may exceed that absorbed from the rumen as ammonia. This net
gain in ‘recycled’ nitrogen is converted to microbial protein, which means that the
quantity of protein reaching the intestine may be greater than that in the food. In
this way the ruminant is able to conserve nitrogen by returning to the rumen urea
that would otherwise be excreted in urine.
Although digestion is primarily the breakdown of complex molecules into simpler substances, a key feature of the digestive processes in ruminants is the production of microbial cells and hence the synthesis of microbial protein. If this synthesis
is for any reason inefficient, food protein will be wasted and the host animal will
subsequently be presented with a mixture of digestible nutrients that is unbalanced
with respect to protein. In practice the rumen microorganisms synthesise protein in
proportion to the quantities of nutrients that they ferment. With most feeds each
kilogram of organic matter digested in the rumen yields approximately 200 g of
microbial protein. Some rapidly fermented foods, such as immature forages rich in
soluble carbohydrates, yield more microbial protein (up to 260 g/kg organic matter
digested). Conversely, foods that contain relatively high proportions of digestible
nutrients that are not fermented in the rumen give a lower yield of microbial protein
(about 130 g/kg organic matter digested). Foods rich in fats are in this category but
generally are not given to ruminants. Silages, however, contain nutrients that have
already been fermented or partly fermented; one of the major products of silage
fermentation is lactic acid (see Chapter 19), and although this may be further
metabolised in the rumen, the yield of rumen microbial protein per unit of organic
matter digested is lower with silages than with other foods.
The rumen microbes thus have a ‘levelling’ effect on the protein supply of the
ruminant; they supplement, in both quantity and quality, the protein of such foods as
low-quality roughages but have a deleterious effect on protein-rich concentrates. It is
possible to take additional advantage of the synthesising abilities of the rumen bacteria
by adding urea to the diet of ruminants (see below). A more recent development,
discussed on p. 186, is the protection of good-quality proteins from degradation in the
rumen.
Utilisation of non-protein nitrogen compounds by the ruminant
Dietary protein is not the only contributor to the ammonia pool in the rumen. As
much as 30 per cent of the nitrogen in ruminant foods may be in the form of simple
organic compounds such as amino acids, amides and amines (see Chapter 4) or of inorganic compounds such as nitrates. Most of these are readily degraded in the
rumen, their nitrogen entering the ammonia pool. In practice it is possible to capitalise on the ability of rumen microorganisms to convert non-protein nitrogenous
compounds to protein, by adding such compounds to the diet. The substance most
commonly employed is urea, but various derivatives of urea, and even ammonium
salts, may also be used.
Urea entering the rumen is rapidly hydrolysed to ammonia by bacterial urease,
and the rumen ammonia concentration is therefore liable to rise considerably. For
this ammonia to be efficiently incorporated in microbial protein, two conditions
181
Chapter 8 Digestion
must be met. First, the initial ammonia concentration must be below the optimum
(otherwise the ammonia ‘peak’ produced will simply be absorbed and lost from the
animal as described above); second, the microorganisms must have a readily available source of energy for protein synthesis. Feeding practices intended to meet these
conditions include mixing urea with other foods (to prolong the period over which it
is ingested and deaminated). Such foods should be low in rumen-degradable protein
and high in readily fermentable carbohydrate.
It is important to avoid accidental overconsumption of urea, since the subsequent
rapid absorption of ammonia from the rumen can overtax the ability of the liver to
reconvert it to urea, hence causing the ammonia concentration of peripheral blood
to reach toxic levels.
Derivatives of urea have been used for animal feeding with the intention of retarding the release of ammonia. Biuret is less rapidly hydrolysed than urea but requires a
period of several weeks for rumen microorganisms to adapt to it. However, neither
biuret nor isobutylidene diurea (IBDU) nor urea–starch compounds have consistently
proved superior to urea itself.
An additional non-protein nitrogenous compound that can be utilised by rumen
bacteria, and hence by the ruminant, is uric acid. This is present in high concentration in poultry excreta, and these are sometimes dried for inclusion in diets for
ruminants, although in some countries the use of excreta as a food is restricted or
prohibited.
The practical significance of these non-protein nitrogenous substances as potential protein sources is discussed in Chapter 23.
Digestion of lipids
The triacylglycerols present in the foods consumed by ruminants contain a high proportion of residues of the C18 polyunsaturated acids, linoleic and linolenic.These triacylglycerols are to a large extent hydrolysed in the rumen by bacterial lipases, as
are phospholipids. Once they are released from ester combination, the unsaturated
fatty acids are hydrogenated by bacteria, yielding first a monoenoic acid and, ultimately, stearic acid. Both linoleic and linolenic acid have all-cis double bonds, but
before they are hydrogenated one double bond in each is converted to the trans configuration; thus, trans acids can be detected in rumen contents. The rumen microorganisms also synthesise considerable quantities of lipids, which contain some
unusual fatty acids (such as those containing branched chains); these acids are eventually incorporated in the milk and body fats of ruminants.
The capacity of rumen microorganisms to digest lipids is strictly limited. The
lipid content of ruminant diets is normally low (i.e. ⬍50 g/kg), and if it is
increased above 100 g/kg the activities of the rumen microbes are reduced. The
fermentation of fibre is retarded and food intake falls. Saturated fatty acids affect
rumen fermentation less than do unsaturated fatty acids. Calcium salts of fatty
acids have little effect on rumen fermentation and are used as fat supplements for
ruminants.
Unlike their short-chain counterparts, long-chain fatty acids are not absorbed
directly from the rumen.When they reach the small intestine they are mainly saturated
and unesterified, but some – in the bacterial lipids – are esterified. Monoacylglycerols,
which play an important role in the formation of mixed micelles in non-ruminants, are
replaced in ruminants by lysophosphatidyl choline.
182
Microbial digestion in ruminants and other herbivores
As mentioned earlier (see p. 36), it is possible in non-ruminants to vary the fatty
acid composition of body fats by altering the composition of dietary fats. In ruminants, this is normally not the case, and the predominating fatty acid of ruminant
depot fats is the stearic acid resulting from hydrogenation in the rumen. However, it
is possible to treat dietary lipids in such a way that they are protected from attack in
the rumen but remain susceptible to enzymic hydrolysis and absorption in the small
intestine. If such lipids contain unsaturated acids, they will modify the composition
of body (and milk) fats (see Chapter 25).
Synthesis of vitamins
The synthesis by rumen microorganisms of all members of the vitamin B complex
and of vitamin K has already been mentioned (see Chapter 5). In ruminants receiving foods well supplied with B vitamins, the amounts synthesised are relatively
small, but they increase if the vitamin intake in the diet decreases. The adult ruminant is therefore independent of a dietary source of these vitamins, but it should be
remembered that adequate synthesis of vitamin B12 will take place only if there is
sufficient cobalt in the diet.
Dynamics of digestion in the ruminant
Food enters the rumen in the form of particles of various shapes and sizes, which are
at first suspended in the liquid phase. The soluble constituents of these particles
(such as sugars) are quickly dissolved and can thus be rapidly degraded by the rumen
microbes. The insoluble constituents are colonised by microbes and slowly broken
down. In addition to these two fractions, a third component will consist of cell walls
so heavily encrusted with lignin or silica as to be undegradable in the rumen. The
dynamics of the rumen must be such that potentially degradable material is retained
long enough to be digested, and that the products of digestion (together with
undegradable material) are passed out of the stomach, either by transit to the lower
gut or by absorption through the rumen wall.The partition required is aided by some
of the physical characteristics of the rumen contents.The liquid phase of rumen contents may be envisaged as a tank of fixed volume, so that liquid or food entering it
causes a corresponding volume to flow out through the reticulo-omasal orifice. This
liquid carries with it some of the soluble constituents of the food, some bacteria, the
volatile fatty acids that have not been absorbed through the rumen wall, and also
some fine particles of food.
Food particles that are large, irregular in shape (e.g. long and thin plant fragments) and of low specific gravity tend to move to the top of the rumen (in some
cases, floating on the liquid phase) and are retained; this is desirable, as large particles will not have been subjected to mechanical and microbial breakdown. When
these particles are reduced to smaller and denser fragments, they descend in the
rumen liquor and can be washed out, as described above.
A critical size for particles passing out of the rumen of sheep has been estimated
by sieving digesta as about 1 mm (i.e. particles held on a sieve with holes of 1 mm
are regarded as being too large to leave the rumen). For cattle, the critical size is considered likely to be 3–4 mm. However, the passage of particles from the rumen is too
complicated to be explained solely in terms of sieve dimensions.The reticulo-omasal
orifice is not a sieve and is large enough to allow the passage of particles much
183
Chapter 8 Digestion
greater in diameter than 1 mm.What seems to happen is that the mass of food particles itself acts as a sieve, by what is termed a filter-bed effect, with large particles
trapping smaller ones.
The rate of passage of liquids through the rumen is faster with roughage diets
than with those containing concentrates such as cereal grains, because greater rumination of roughages adds more saliva to the digesta.Adding salts to the diet increases
water intake and thus increases fluid flow through the rumen. An increased rate of
passage of liquid may ‘wash out’ bacteria, thus reducing cellulolysis and increasing
the proportion of propionate in the mixture of volatile fatty acids produced. More
generally, anything that increases the rate of passage of digesta from the rumen is
liable to reduce the extent of digestion in that organ; for the fibre constituents of
foods, this is likely to be disadvantageous, but it may be an advantage with constituents such as protein and starch, which can be more efficiently digested in the
lower gut (see below). As food intake rises, the ruminant responds by increasing the
quantity held in the rumen (rumen ‘fill’) and/or the rate of passage, but eventually
limits are reached that impose a restriction on intake. The feeding of ruminants for
greater productivity often depends on the raising of these limits, for example by replacing slowly digested forages with rapidly digested concentrates, or by grinding
forages to produce smaller, faster-moving particles.
Control and modification of rumen fermentation
As investigations have revealed the mechanisms of rumen digestion, attempts have
been made to alter the patterns of digestion in ways that should improve the nutrition of ruminants. The primary approach has been to modify the microbial population in order to suppress undesirable processes (e.g. methane production; see Section
8.4 and Chapter 11) or stimulate desirable processes (e.g. microbial protein synthesis).A secondary approach has been to protect nutrients from rumen fermentation in
order that they should be digested in the small intestine. Changing the bacterial
BOX 8.3 Measures of rumen dynamics
The movement of digesta from the rumen can be expressed either as a rate of passage or as its
reciprocal, a retention time. The rate of passage of liquids is also known as the dilution rate. These
can be measured by the use of marker substances, which are either natural constituents of foods or
indigestible additives (see p. 240). An example of the latter is the soluble but unabsorbable highmolecular-weight polymer polyethylene glycol. If a dose of this marker is injected into the rumen
and allowed to mix uniformly, the subsequent decline in its concentration over time can be used to
calculate the fractional rate of passage of liquid from the rumen.Typically this might be in the range
0.05–0.20 per hour, indicating that 5–20 per cent of the rumen liquor flows out of the organ each
hour. The passage of particulate matter from the rumen can be followed by marking or labelling
some of the food with the rare earth element ytterbium and then taking sequential samples of duodenal digesta. An older method employed dyes to mark food particles, which allowed undigested
particles in digesta or faeces to be identified and counted under a microscope. Typical rates of
passage of particulate matter are 0.012–0.030 per hour, and typical retention times are
30–80 hours. Studies of rumen dynamics have led to the development of complex mathematical
models (see Further reading at the end of this chapter).
184
Microbial digestion in ruminants and other herbivores
population through the introduction of specific organisms has generally proved difficult to achieve, or if achieved has failed to yield nutritional benefits. Changing an
existing population by adding antibiotics to feeds has proved more effective,
although the use of many antibiotics has been prohibited because of their value for
treating diseases in animals and humans, and the possibility that their wider application would lead to the evolution of resistant strains of disease-causing organisms.
The antibiotics used today are mostly of the ionophore type, examples being monensin and salinomycin. These are active against Gram-negative bacteria; by stimulating the production of propionate and reducing the production of acetate and
butyrate, they improve the efficiency of utilisation of feed by growing ruminants.Another recent development has been the use of substances known as probiotics, such
as live yeast cultures, to stimulate bacterial activity in the rumen. In some circumstances these can stabilise rumen pH, increase propionate and reduce acetate production, and reduce methane and ammonia production. The use of antibiotics and
probiotics as additives to the diet is discussed in Chapter 24.
The advent of genetic engineering has raised hopes of providing, for example,
bacteria with improved cellulolytic capabilities, or organisms able to manufacture
specific nutrients, such as the sulphur-containing amino acids needed for wool
growth (see Chapter 14). Establishing such modified organisms in the rumen ecosystem is still a problem, although one successful application of this technology has
been to modify bacteria to produce the enzyme fluoracetate dehalogenase, which
then protects ruminants against fluoracetate poisoning.
The rumen protozoal population has proved to be more susceptible to modification than the bacterial population, principally because protozoa can be totally eliminated from the rumen. Ruminants reared from birth in isolation from other
ruminants do not develop a protozoal population. Existing populations of protozoa
can be eradicated by the use of high-starch diets, or by the administration of defaunating agents such as copper sulphate. The ionophore monensin, which was originally used to kill coccidia in poultry, also kills protozoa in ruminants (although there
is some evidence that rumen protozoa can adapt to and tolerate monensin).
The contribution of protozoa to rumen digestion, and hence to the nutrition and
productivity of ruminants, has long been a matter of controversy.Although protozoa
make a significant contribution to the digestion of polysaccharides, they are retained
in the rumen and thus have the undesirable effect of ‘locking up’ microbial protein in
the rumen and preventing its passage to the small intestine. So although defaunation
of the rumen reduces the digestion of polysaccharides (especially the hemicelluloses), it increases the quantity of microbial protein reaching the duodenum by
about 25 per cent. If protozoa are absent from the rumen, their fibrolytic activity
may be taken over by fungi.There is, however, some evidence that protozoa have another valuable role in aiding the absorption of the minerals calcium, magnesium and
phosphorus from the gut.
The current view of rumen protozoa is that with low-protein, forage-based diets,
their presence is detrimental to the host, and defaunation can therefore increase
animal productivity. With concentrate-based diets, better supplied with protein, the
presence of protozoa is beneficial. Ironically, it is difficult to keep ruminants free of
protozoa when they are on a forage diet and difficult to maintain protozoa on a
concentrate diet.
A major objective in controlling rumen fermentation is to restrict the activity of
microbes to the components of the diet that the host animal cannot digest with its
185
Chapter 8 Digestion
own enzymes (principally the ␤-linked polysaccharides) or cannot utilise without
microbial intervention (non-protein nitrogenous compounds). The strategy for
achieving this objective is based on the protection of other nutrients (soluble carbohydrates, such as starch and sugars, and high-quality proteins) from attack in the
rumen.We shall see later in this book that rumen fermentation of sugars is energetically inefficient for the host animal and may also cause it to be short of glucose. Tactics for protecting nutrients from attack in the rumen are often based on heat
treatment or chemical treatment of foods. Treatment with tannins or formaldehyde
modifies the structure of proteins in such a way as to impede microbial attack but
still permit digestion by mammalian digestive enzymes. There are difficulties in
achieving precisely the right degree of protection, however, and a more practical way
of getting proteins past the rumen is to use foods to which rumen microorganisms
are unaccustomed and therefore unadapted; these are principally foods of animal
origin, such as fishmeals. Individual amino acids can be protected with agents based
on polymers or fats. Protecting soluble carbohydrates such as starch from rumen
fermentation is much more difficult, although the starch in some foods (rice byproducts and, to a much lesser degree, maize) partially escapes rumen fermentation.
If intensively fed ruminants are given an energy-rich supplement, this is often in the
form of the one class of nutrients that naturally escapes rumen fermentation, namely
the triglyceride fats.
Although man has had some success in arranging for nutrients to ‘bypass’ the
rumen, nature is more successful. In the young suckled ruminant, the oesophageal
groove mechanism (see p. 172) allows the high-quality nutrients contained in milk to
avoid rumen fermentation, even though the lamb or calf is consuming pasture herbage
and digesting it in a fully functional rumen. Attempts by man to prolong this efficient
partition into the adult life of the ruminant have been experimentally successful but
fail commercially because of the high cost of milk or milk substitutes.
Another aspect of the control of rumen fermentation arises from the need to synchronise the supplies of energy and protein to the microorganisms. As mentioned
earlier, the bacteria need a supply of energy to synthesise their cell proteins from degraded food proteins, and their energy sources, the carbohydrates, are made available at varying rates. It is therefore possible, for example, to supplement a rapidly
degraded source of protein with a rapidly degradable source of carbohydrate. An alternative approach to synchronisation would be to give rapidly and slowly degraded
foods at different times of the day. However, studies of rumen synchrony have yet to
be fully translated into feeding practice.
8.3
ALTERNATIVE SITES OF MICROBIAL DIGESTION
Its great size and its location at the anterior end of the gut make the rumen pre-eminent as a digestive organ for fibrous foods. Large quantities of food can be stored
rapidly for later mastication and fermentation; cell contents are released at an early
stage; and the main products of fermentation have ample opportunity to be absorbed in the remainder of the tract. These advantages of rumen digestion are, however, diminished by the disadvantage of all food constituents being exposed to
fermentation. If fermentation is delayed until food reaches the large intestine, this
disadvantage is overcome, but some of the benefits of the rumen are lost.
186
Alternative sites of microbial digestion
The parts of the large intestine that are capable of sustaining a significant microbial population are the colon and the caecum (see Fig. 8.1). The caecum is blindended and is duplicated in the fowl; in some animals the walls of both the caecum
and the colon are sacculated. The digestive capacity of these organs depends on
their volume relative to the rest of the tract, as that determines the time for which
food residues may be delayed for fermentation. The substrate for the large intestine
differs from that entering the rumen, because most of the more readily digestible
nutrients will have been removed, and also some endogenous materials (such as
mucopolysaccharides and enzymes) will have been added. However, as described
earlier (see p. 163), microbial digestion in the large intestine is similar to that occurring in the rumen. Volatile fatty acids are produced and absorbed; methane and
other gases are present. Proteins and non-protein sources of nitrogen (such as urea
from the bloodstream) are reformed into microbial proteins; in some cases, but not
invariably, these undergo proteolysis to amino acids, which may be absorbed.Watersoluble vitamins are synthesised and inorganic elements and water are reabsorbed.
But in general, hind gut fermentation is less effective than rumen digestion, because
digesta are not held for sufficient time and because many of the products of digestion (particularly microbial protein and vitamins) are not absorbed. Some species of
animal overcome the last problem by practising coprophagy (the consumption of
faeces). The rabbit has perfected this practice by producing two types of faeces, the
normal hard pellets, which are not eaten, and the soft faeces or caecotrophes, which
contain well-fermented material from the caecum and which are consumed, hence
the alternative term caecotrophy.This division of digesta is achieved by colonic contractions, which separate the fibrous particles that form the hard pellets. Antiperistaltic waves of contraction move fluid and non-fibre particles into the caecum,
where microbial fermentation takes place. The caecotrophes are soft pellets of caecal contents with a glossy coat and are eaten directly from the anus and swallowed
whole. They remain intact in the stomach for some time and fermentation continues. They then pass to the small intestine for digestion of the contents. Ruminants
have a substantial capacity for hind gut fermentation, and this is used to good effect
when the diet or the level of feeding causes much fibrous material to reach the
caecum.
The horse is capable of living solely on fibrous forages. Unlike the ruminant,
however, it has only one opportunity to chew its food and must therefore chew it
thoroughly as it ingests it. At this stage large amounts of saliva are added, and the
food is sufficiently buffered to permit a limited amount of fermentation in the
stomach. However, most microbial digestion takes place in the enlarged colon,
which has a capacity exceeding 60 l, and the caecum, with a capacity of 25–35 l.
These organs contain bacteria and protozoa, which digest the food constituents in
the same way as rumen microorganisms. It has been estimated that in the horse,
hind gut fermentation accounts for 30 per cent of the digestion of dietary protein,
15–30 per cent of that of soluble carbohydrate and 75–85 per cent of that of cell
wall carbohydrate. With diets of hay and concentrates, horses digest about 85 per
cent of the organic matter that would be digested by ruminants. In the pig, the hind
gut is less enlarged than in the horse, and forages are poorly digested. Nevertheless, the pig can digest as much as 50 per cent of the cellulose and hemicellulose of
cereal grains and their by-products. If starch grains escape digestion in the small
intestine, as happens when pigs are fed on uncooked potatoes, these will also be
fermented.
187
Chapter 8 Digestion
Although poultry have two caeca and a colon in which to ferment food residues,
they gain little or nothing from hind gut fermentation when fed on their usual concentrate diets. Indeed, it has been suggested that in poultry the intestinal flora are
more of a handicap than an advantage, as ‘germ-free’ birds (i.e. reared in isolation
and with no microorganisms) tend to grow larger than normal birds.
8.4
NUTRIENT DIGESTION AND THE ENVIRONMENT
Nutrition has important effects on the environment as a consequence of the
processes of digestion (methane and phosphorus) or a combination of digestion and
metabolism (nitrogen). Methane is produced by the fermentation of foods in the gut
by microbes, particularly in ruminants, and the decomposition of carbon compounds
in faeces stored as manure. Undigested phosphorus compounds are excreted in the
faeces. Undigested and waste products of the metabolism of nitrogen compounds are
excreted in the faeces and urine and the decomposition of these produces nitrous
oxide (N2O). Ammonia in animal wastes is responsible for soil acidification and nutrient enrichment.
Although carbon dioxide is the major gas contributing to climate change,
methane and nitrous oxide are also significant contributors because of their warming
potentials, which are 25 and 300 times that of carbon dioxide, respectively. The consequences of nitrogen digestion and metabolism on the environment are considered
in Chapter 13.
Methane
It has been estimated that 70 per cent of the methane in the earth’s atmosphere is a
result of human activity, and agriculture accounts for 60 per cent of this. Enteric fermentation makes up around 80 per cent of the agricultural production of methane
and around 20 per cent arises from animal wastes. Rumen and hind gut fermentation
are similar processes. During rumen fermentation of organic matter, hydrogen is produced and methanogenic bacteria use this with carbon dioxide to produce methane
and water. The methane leaves the rumen by eructation and this represents a loss of
6–10 per cent of the gross energy of fermented foods. However, the methanogenic
bacteria use the hydrogen as an energy source for growth and thereby make a small
contribution to the microbial matter to be digested in the small intestine.The removal
of hydrogen has a beneficial effect on the fermentation of plant cell wall carbohydrates. Hydrogen is also used by other bacteria to synthesise propionic and butyric
acids, and the pathway of use depends on the diet and the pH of the rumen contents.
The activity of methanogenic bacteria, and thus the amount of methane produced, is
reduced with increased rates of passage and digestion of food, increased levels of
feeding, reduced rumen pH and the fermentation of starchy foods, all of which favour
the channelling of carbon and hydrogen into propionate production.
In order to reduce the climatic influence of methane from agricultural sources,
ways of reducing the production from rumen fermentation are being investigated.
Substances added to the food to decrease methane production include halogen analogues of methane. However, their effects tend to decrease over time as the rumen
bacterial population adapts to their presence. Ionophore antibiotics (monensin; see
Chapter 24) decrease methane production and increase propionate formation and
188
Summary
probiotics (Sacchromyces cerevisiae; see Chapter 24) are also beneficial. Other
propionate-enhancing additives include fumaric and malic acids, which are precursors of propionate.Attempts to alter the microbial population in the rumen have met
with limited success, no doubt owing to the varied population and the capacity of
the organisms to adapt. Increasing animal productivity can reduce methane production indirectly and directly. Indirectly methane is reduced because fewer animals are
required to produce the same amount of meat or milk and the maintenance costs are
lower. Direct effects arise from the type of diet required to increase production,
namely high quantities of concentrate (starchy) foods and the low inclusion of
fibrous foods. As mentioned above, starchy foods increase the production of propionate and reduce methane as a result of the less favourable environment for the
methane-producing bacteria. However, there are drawbacks from this approach in
that the animal is more susceptible to acidosis (see p. 176) and the use of cereals
competes directly with humans (see Chapter 25).
Phosphorus
Undigested phosphorus-containing compounds in manure can potentially run off
into waterways and cause surface water pollution. In this way phosphorus can be
responsible for the enrichment of water courses with the detrimental effect of excessive growth of algae and other plants. Phosphorus-containing compounds in foods
vary in digestibility, and phytin phosphorus in cereals is poorly digested by nonruminants (see Chapter 6), with a large proportion appearing in the faeces. In order
to supply sufficient digestible phosphorus, the diets of non-ruminants are supplemented with inorganic phosphorus sources such as dicalcium phosphate. The key to
reducing the use of phosphorus supplements and the overall intake of phosphorus is
in making the element in the natural food sources more available to the animal. This
can be achieved by supplementing the diet of non-ruminants with the phytase
enzyme, which releases the phosphorus from phytin (see Chapter 24).
Dietary phosphorus supply in relation to requirements is coming under close
scrutiny, especially for dairy and beef cattle, where allowances are often significantly
above requirements in order to give a safety margin. There is increasing pressure to
reduce safety margins so that allowances are closer to requirements and phosphorus
is not wasted.
SUMMARY
1. In a simple-stomached animal, such as the pig,
digestion begins when food reaches the stomach. Proteins are hydrolysed by pepsins at pH
2.0–3.5 to polypeptides and a few amino acids.
2. In the small intestine, enzymes secreted by
the mucosa and by the pancreas continue the
breakdown of protein to amino acids
through the action of trypsin and carboxypeptidases. Fats are made water-soluble
through emulsification by the bile salts
(secreted by the liver) and by partial hydrolysis by lipases. Starch (and related ␣-linked
polysaccharides) are hydrolysed by amylase to
disaccharides, which are further hydrolysed
to monosaccharides by specific enzymes (e.g.
maltose by maltase, sucrose by sucrase, etc.).
3. In the large intestine, microorganisms
produce enzymes that hydrolyse and ferment ␤-linked polysaccharides, mainly to
volatile fatty acids.
189
Chapter 8 Digestion
4. In the young pig, enzyme activities are
restricted because the sole food is milk. In the
stomach, chymosin causes partial breakdown
and clotting of casein. Lactase activity is high,
but the activity of starch-digesting enzymes,
amylase and maltase, is low until the fourth
week of life.
5. In the fowl, digestion is aided by a storage
organ anterior to the proventriculus (the
crop) and a grinding organ posterior to the
stomach (the gizzard). As part of the hind
gut, the two blind-ended caeca facilitate
microbial digestion, but this is not quantitatively important.
6. Dogs and cats are predominantly meat eaters
and consume little fibrous material. Consequently their digestive tracts are adapted to
the digestion of protein and fat and the large
intestine is small.
7. Absorption of nutrients occurs mainly in the
small intestine. Carbohydrates are absorbed as
monosaccharides by active transport, a process
involving carrier proteins. Amino acids and
fatty acids are also absorbed by active transport, but emulsified triglycerides are absorbed
by passive diffusion. Large molecules, especially the immunoglobulins present in
colostrum, are absorbed by a process known
as pinocytosis. Many minerals and vitamins
require special processes of absorption.
8. The alimentary tract has a detoxifying role, as
it can inactivate some of the potentially damaging constituents of foods.
9. In ruminants, the large stomach compartment
known as the reticulo-rumen allows regurgitation of food for mechanical breakdown by
rumination and acts as a continuous fermentation system for anaerobic bacteria, protozoa
and fungi.
10. In the rumen, carbohydrates (both ␣- and
␤-linked) are hydrolysed by various routes to
pyruvic acid, which is then fermented to
acetic, propionic and butyric acids. The extent
of breakdown and the proportions of these
acids are determined by the nature of the
food. Lignin is not digested and tends to
interfere with the digestion of other nutrients.
190
The volatile fatty acids are absorbed through
the rumen wall. Methane and carbon dioxide
are by-products of rumen fermentation.
11. Proteins in the rumen are hydrolysed to peptides and amino acids, and the latter may be
deaminated to yield ammonia. Microorganisms use these products, and also non-protein
sources of nitrogen, such as urea and uric acid,
to synthesise microbial proteins. Microbial cells
pass from the rumen to the abomasum (true
stomach) and small intestine, where they are
digested by the host animal’s enzymes.
12. Lipids in the rumen are hydrolysed, and unsaturated fatty acids are then converted to
saturated fatty acids by hydrogenation.
13. For optimal rumen fermentation, foods must
be held in the organ to allow time for the
slow breakdown of plant cell walls, and the
microorganisms must receive balanced supplies of nitrogen (as ammonia) and energy
(as carbohydrate).
14. Rumen breakdown of food protein is not
always desirable, because microbial protein
may be inferior to it in both quantity and
quality. Thus, food proteins are sometimes
protected from attack by rumen microorganisms. In suckled ruminants, there is a device
known as the oesophageal groove, which
channels milk directly to the abomasum.
15. Microbial digestion continues in the large
intestine of ruminants; volatile fatty acids
and microbial protein are produced, but the
protein cannot be subsequently digested and
absorbed by the host animal.
16. In the horse, the large intestine is the principal site of microbial digestion.
17. The nutrition of animals has environmental
consequences. Methane, which contributes to
global warming, is produced by fermentation
in the gut and the degradation of manure.
Nitrous oxide, which also contributes to
global warming, arises from the degradation
of animal wastes. Undigested phosphorus in
manure can cause nutrient enrichment of
water courses.
Historical reference
FURTHER READING
Annison E F and Brydon W L 1998 Perspectives of ruminant nutrition and metabolism. 1.
Metabolism in the rumen. Nutrition Research Reviews 11: 173–98.
Church D C 1976 Digestive Physiology and Nutrition of Ruminants, Vol. 1. Digestive
Physiology, 2nd edn, Corvallis, OR, O and B Books.
Cronje P 2000 Ruminant Physiology: Digestion, Metabolism, Growth and Reproduction,
Proceedings of the Ninth International Symposium on Ruminant Physiology, Wallingford,
UK, CABI. [See also other volumes in this series.]
Czerkawski J W 1986 An Introduction to Rumen Studies, Oxford, Pergamon Press.
Forbes J M and France J (eds) 1993 Quantitative Aspects of Ruminant Digestion and
Metabolism,Wallingford, UK, CABI.
Frape D L 1998 Equine Nutrition and Feeding, 2nd edn, London, Blackwell Science.
Freeman B M (ed.) 1983 Physiology and Biochemistry of the Domestic Fowl, London,
Academic Press.
Hobson P N and Stewart C S 1997 The Rumen Microbial Ecosystem, 2nd edn, London,
Blackie Academic & Professional.
Kidder D E and Manners M J 1978 Digestion in the Pig, Bristol, Scientechnica.
Murray R K, Granner D K, Mayes P A and Rodwell V W 1993 Harper’s Biochemistry, 23rd edn,
Norwalk, CT, Appleton and Lange.
Moran E T Jr 1982 The Comparative Nutrition of Fowl and Swine: The Gastrointestinal
Systems, University of Guelph, Ontario.
Moss A R, Jouanny J-P and Newbold, J 2000 Methane production by ruminants: its contribution to global warming. Annales de Zootechnie 49: 231–53.
National Research Council 2006 The Nutrient Requirements of Dogs and Cats, Washington,
DC, National Academy Press.
Sandford P A 1982 Digestive System Physiology, London, Edward Arnold.
Stevens C E and Hume I D 1995 Comparative Physiology of the Vertebrate Digestive System,
2nd edn, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Swenson M J (ed.) 1984 Dukes’s Physiology of Domestic Animals, Ithaca, NY, Comstock.
Van Soest P J 1994 Nutritional Ecology of the Ruminant, 2nd edn, Ithaca, NY, Comstock.
HISTORICAL REFERENCE
Hungate R E 1966 The Rumen and its Microbes, New York, Academic Press.
191
9
Metabolism
9.1
Energy metabolism
9.2
Protein synthesis
9.3
Fat synthesis
9.4
Carbohydrate synthesis
9.5
Control of metabolism
Metabolism is the name given to the sequence, or succession, of chemical reactions that
take place in the living organism. Some of the reactions involve the degradation of
complex compounds to simpler materials and are designated catabolic reactions,
whereas other reactions involve the synthesis of more complex compounds from simpler
substances and are designated anabolic reactions. Waste products arise as a result of
metabolism and these have to be chemically transformed and ultimately excreted; the
reactions necessary for such transformations form part of general metabolism. As a result of various catabolic reactions, energy is made available for mechanical work, transportation and anabolic activity such as the synthesis of carbohydrates, proteins and
lipids. Figure 9.1 summarises the sources of the major metabolites available to the body
and their subsequent metabolism.
The starting points of metabolism are the substances absorbed after the digestion of
food. For all practical purposes we may regard the end products of carbohydrate digestion in the simple-stomached animal as glucose, together with very small amounts of
galactose and fructose. These are absorbed into the portal blood and carried to the liver.
In ruminant animals, the major part of the carbohydrate is broken down in the rumen to
acetic, propionic and butyric acids, together with small amounts of branched-chain and
higher volatile acids. Butyric acid is changed during its passage across the rumen wall and
passes into the portal blood as (D-)␤-hydroxybutyric acid (BHBA). Acetic acid and BHBA
pass from the liver via the systemic blood to various organs and tissues, where they are
used as sources of energy and fatty acids. Propionic acid is converted to glucose in the
liver and joins the liver glucose pool. This may be converted partly into glycogen and
stored, or to fatty acids, reduced coenzymes and L-glycerol-3-phosphate and used for triacylglycerol synthesis. The remainder of the glucose enters the systemic blood supply and
is carried to various body tissues, where it may be used as an energy source, as a source
of reduced coenzymes for fatty acid synthesis, and for glycogen synthesis.
192
Butyric
acid
BHBA
Glucose
Used for energy, fatty
acid, glycogen and
triglyceride syntheses:
+
NADPH (+H ) production
Systemic blood
Acetoacetate
BHBA
Triacylglycerol Acetoacetate
BHBA
Used for energy,
Used
triglyceride and
for
fatty acid syntheses
energy
Triacylglycerol
Free fatty
acids
Free fatty
acids
Urea
Excreted in
urine and
saliva
Urea
Ammonia
Keto acids
Glycerol
Triacylglycerols
BHBA ⫽ ␤-hydroxybutyric acid; NADPH (⫹H⫹) ⫽ reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate.
Fig. 9.1 Sources and fates of major body metabolites.
Used for energy and
fatty acid synthesis
Acetate
Glucose
Liver
Energy
Glucose
Propionic
acid
Glycogen
NADPH
+
(+H )
β-Hydroxy-butyric acid
Acetic
acid
Body tissues + diet
Amino acids
Used for protein
synthesis and
amino acid
syntheses
Proteins
Amino
acids
Metabolism
193
Chapter 9 Metabolism
Digestion of proteins results in the production of amino acids and small peptides,
which are absorbed via the intestinal villi into the portal blood and are carried to the
liver, where they join the amino acid pool. They may then be used for protein synthesis
in situ or may pass into the systemic blood, where they join the amino acids produced as a
result of tissue catabolism in providing the raw material for the synthesis of proteins
and other biologically important nitrogenous compounds. Amino acids in excess of this
requirement are carried to the liver and broken down to ammonia and keto acids. The
latter may be used for amino acid synthesis or the production of energy. Some of the
ammonia may be used in amination, but the majority is converted into urea and either
excreted in the urine or recycled in the saliva. In the ruminant animal a considerable
amount of ammonia may be absorbed from the rumen into the portal blood, transformed into urea by the liver, and then excreted or recycled via saliva or through the
rumen wall.
Most dietary lipids enter the lacteals as chylomicrons, which enter the venous blood
vessels via the thoracic duct. The chylomicrons are about 500 nm in diameter with a thin
lipoprotein envelope. A very small proportion of dietary triacylglycerols may be hydrolysed to glycerol and low-molecular-weight acids in the digestive tract and these are absorbed directly into the portal blood supply. Circulating chylomicrons are absorbed by
the liver and the triacylglycerols are hydrolysed. The fatty acids so produced, along with
free fatty acids absorbed from the blood by the liver, may be catabolised for energy production or used for the synthesis of triacylglycerols. These then re-enter the blood supply in the form of lipoprotein and are carried to various organs and tissues, where they
may be used for lipid synthesis, for energy production and for fatty acid synthesis. Fatty
acids catabolised in excess of the liver’s requirement for energy are changed to
(L-)␤-hydroxybutyrate and acetoacetate, which are transported to various tissues and
used as sources of energy.
9.1
ENERGY METABOLISM
Energy may be defined as the capacity to do work. There are various forms of energy, such as chemical, thermal, electrical and radiant, all of which are interconvertible by suitable means. For example, the radiant energy of the sun is used by green
plants, via photosynthesis, to produce complex plant constituents, which are then
stored. The plants are consumed by animals and the constituents broken down, releasing energy, which is used by animals for mechanical work, for transport, for
maintaining the integrity of cell membranes, for the synthesis of body components
and for providing heat under cold conditions.
Since all forms of energy can be converted to heat, heat units have been used to
represent the energy involved in metabolism. Traditionally, the basic unit used has
been the thermochemical calorie (cal), based on the calorific value of benzoic acid as
the reference standard. However, the calorie is too small a unit for routine use and
the kilocalorie (1000 cal) or megacalorie (1 000 000 cal) is more commonly used in
practice. However, the International Union of Nutritional Sciences and the National
Committee of the International Union of Physiological Sciences have now suggested
the joule (J) as the unit of energy for use in nutritional, metabolic and physiological
studies. This suggestion has been almost universally adopted and is followed in this
book. The joule is defined as 1 newton per metre, and 4.184 J ⫽ 1 cal.
194
Energy metabolism
The chemical reactions taking place in the animal’s body are accompanied by
changes in the energy of the system. The portion of the energy change that is available to do work is termed the free energy change, designated ⌬G.When ⌬G is negative, the reaction is said to be exergonic and takes place spontaneously; when ⌬G is
large and negative, the reaction proceeds almost to completion.When ⌬G is positive,
the reaction is termed endergonic and free energy has to be fed into the system in
order for the reaction to take place.When ⌬G is large and positive, there is little tendency for the reaction to take place. Most of the synthetic reactions of the body are
endergonic and the energy needed to drive them is obtained from exergonic catabolic reactions. Before the energy released by these changes can be utilised for syntheses and other vital body processes, a link between the two must be established.
This is provided by mediating compounds that take part in both processes, picking
up energy from one and transferring it to the other. Typical are adenosine triphosphate (ATP), guanosine triphosphate (GTP), cytidine triphosphate (CTP) and uridine
triphosphate (UTP). By far the most important nucleotide triphosphate is ATP.
Adenosine is formed from the purine base adenine and the sugar D-ribose. Phosphorylation of the hydroxyl group at carbon atom 5 of the sugar gives adenosine
monophosphate (AMP) (see Chapter 4); successive additions of phosphate residues
give adenosine diphosphate (ADP) and then the triphosphate. In its reactions within
the cell, ATP functions as a complex with magnesium. The addition of the last two
phosphate bonds requires a considerable amount of energy, which may be obtained
directly by reaction of AMP or ADP with an energy-rich material. For example, in
carbohydrate breakdown, one of the steps is the change of phosphoenolpyruvate to
pyruvate, which results in one molecule of ATP being produced from ADP.
CH3
CH2
C:O~ P
+
ADP
Mg2+
C:O
+
COO–
COO–
Phosphoenolpyruvate
Pyruvate
ATP *
When production of ATP from ADP takes place directly during a reaction, as in
this case, the process is known as substrate-level phosphorylation.
Alternatively, ATP may be produced indirectly. Most biological oxidations involve the removal of hydrogen from a substrate. However, the final combination of
hydrogen with oxygen to form water occurs only at the end of a series of reactions.
A typical example is the removal of hydrogen coupled to nicotinamide adenine
dinucleotide (NAD⫹), as illustrated in Fig. 9.2 for the oxidation of isocitrate to
␣-ketoglutarate.
In this example, hydrogen removed from isocitrate is accepted by NAD⫹ and is
then passed to the flavin coenzyme. This donates two electrons to ubiquinone, and
two protons (2H⫹) are formed. The electrons are then transferred via the sequential cytochromes to cytochrome a3, which is capable of transferring the electrons to
oxygen. The negatively charged oxygen finally unites with the two protons, yielding water. During the operation of this pathway, ATP is produced from ADP and
inorganic phosphate, the process being called oxidative phosphorylation. It is
confined to the mitochondria and to the reduced NAD⫹ produced within them.
195
Chapter 9 Metabolism
α-Ketoglutarate
Isocitrate
NAD+
NAD(+H+)
FADH2
FAD
ADP + Pi
ATP
Ubiquinone + 2H+
Ubiquinone
2 Cytochrome b
Fe2+
ATP
2 Cytochrome b
Fe3+
ADP + Pi
2 Cytochrome c1
Fe3+
2 Cytochrome c1
Fe2+
2 Cytochrome c
Fe2+
2 Cytochrome c
Fe3+
2 Cytochrome a
Fe3+
ATP
2 Cytochrome a
Fe2+
ADP + Pi
2 Cytochrome a3
Fe2+
2 Cytochrome a3
Fe2+
H2O
2e
½O2
Fig. 9.2 The oxidative phosphorylation system.
Considerations of energy release indicate that production of ATP takes place at the
transfer of hydrogen from reduced FAD to ubiquinone, at the transfer of electrons
from cytochrome b to c1, and from cytochrome a to cytochrome a3.The flow of electrons leads to the transfer of protons from the matrix to the cytoplasmic side of the
inner mitochondrial membrane. A proton-motive force consisting of a pH gradient
(matrix side basic) and a membrane potential (matrix side negative) is then generated. The flow of protons back to the matrix side through ATP synthase drives ATP
synthesis. The flow of electrons from NADH or FADH to O2 through the transfer
chain generates sufficient proton motive force for the synthesis of 2.5 and 1.5 moles
of ATP, respectively. The series of reactions may be represented as:
NADH(+H+) ⫹ O ⫹ 2.5ADP ⫹ 2.5Pi
NAD+ ⫹ 2.5 ATP ⫹ H2O
*Throughout this chapter, energy inputs are shown by an open box (ⵧ) and energy outputs by a
black box (䊏).
196
Energy metabolism
Since oxidative phosphorylation is confined to the mitochondria, reduced
NAD⫹ produced in the cell cytoplasm must cross the mitochondrial wall to be
processed in this way. Reduced NAD⫹ itself is not capable of doing so. Passage into
the mitochondria, of the reducing equivalents that it represents, is achieved by the
operation of the malate–aspartate shuttle or the glycerophosphate shuttle. In the
malate– aspartate shuttle, no energy cost is involved. In the glycerophosphate shuttle, the reducing equivalents enter the oxidative phosphorylation pathway at the
FAD⫹ stage and only 1.5 moles of ATP are produced. The malate–aspartate shuttle is predominant in the liver, whereas muscle makes greater use of the glycerophosphate pathway.
The energy fixed as ATP may be used for doing mechanical work during the performance of body processes that are essential for maintaining the animal. Both contraction and relaxation of muscle involve reactions that require a supply of energy,
which is provided by breakdown of ATP to ADP and inorganic phosphate. The energy fixed in ATP may also be used to drive reactions in which the terminal phosphate group is donated to a large variety of acceptor molecules. Among these is
D-glucose:
ATP ⫹ D-glucose : ADP ⫹ D-glucose phosphate
In this way the glucose is energised for subsequent biosynthetic reactions. In other
reactions, such as the first stage of fatty acid synthesis, ATP provides the energy and
is broken down to AMP and inorganic phosphate:
Acetate + coenzyme A ⫹ ATP 4 acetyl-coenzyme A ⫹ pyrophosphate ⫹ AMP
The role of ATP in trapping and utilising energy may be illustrated diagrammatically
as shown in Fig. 9.3.
The quantity of energy that is made available by the rupture of each of the two
terminal phosphate bonds of ATP varies according to the conditions under which the
hydrolysis takes place. Most authorities agree that under the conditions pertaining in
intact cells the amount of energy is about 50 kJ/mole, but this varies with pH, magnesium ion concentration and the concentrations of ATP, ADP and phosphate. The
phosphate bonds are commonly referred to as high-energy bonds, represented by
⬃[P]. This term is not thermodynamically accurate and many workers prefer to use
the term ‘high group transfer potential’.
Fixation of energy in the form of ATP is a transitory phenomenon and any energy
produced in excess of immediate requirements is stored in a more permanent form
ATP
Free energy
from catabolism
ADP
Free energy for chemical work
(biosynthesis), osmotic work
(transport) and mechanical
work (muscular contraction)
AMP
Fig. 9.3 The role of ATP in the utilisation of energy.
197
Chapter 9 Metabolism
in such compounds as the phosphocreatine of muscle, which is formed from creatine
when ATP is in excess:
NH2
NH~ P
C:NH2+
C:NH2+
Creatine kinase
N.CH3
+
ATP
N.CH 3
+
ADP
CH2
CH2
COO–
COO–
Creatine
Phosphocreatine
When the supply of ATP is insufficient to meet energy demand, more ATP is produced from phosphocreatine by the reverse reaction.
Even compounds such as phosphocreatine are minor, temporary energy stores.
The majority of energy stored in the body is stored as depot fat together with small
quantities of carbohydrate in the form of glycogen. In addition, protein may be used
to provide energy under certain circumstances.
In addition to using this stored energy, the body derives energy directly from nutrients absorbed from the digestive tract. The most important of these in simplestomached animals is glucose. However, in ruminant animals, the volatile fatty acids
occupy this position.
Glucose as an energy source
The major pathway by which glucose is metabolised to give energy has two stages.
The first, known as glycolysis, can occur under anaerobic conditions and results in the
production of pyruvate. The sequence of reactions (Fig. 9.4), often referred to as the
Embden–Meyerhof pathway, takes place in the cell cytoplasm.
All the reactions in the pathway are reversible, but reactions 1, 3, 8 and 11 have large
negative ⌬G values under physiological conditions and are essentially irreversible. Two
moles of ATP are used in the initial phosphorylations of steps 1 and 3, and the fructose
diphosphate so formed breaks down to yield two moles of glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate.
Subsequently, one mole of ATP is produced directly at each of steps 8 and 11. Four
moles of ATP are thus produced from one mole of glucose. Since two moles of ATP are
used up, the net production of ATP from ADP is two moles per mole of glucose. Under
aerobic conditions the reduced NAD⫹, produced at step 7, may be oxidised via the oxidative phosphorylation pathway and, assuming the operation of the malate–aspartate
shuttle, 2.5 moles ofATP are produced per mole.The pyruvate produced by glycolysis is
transported into the mitochondria, without energy cost, and is oxidised to carbon
dioxide and water, with further production of energy. The first step in this process is
the oxidative decarboxylation of pyruvate in the presence of thiamin diphosphate:
CH3
C:O
CH3
+
COO–
Pyruvate
198
HS.CoA
Pyruvate dehydrogenase
NAD+
Coenzyme A
+
CO2
COS.CoA
NADH
(+H+)
Acetyl-coenzyme A
Energy metabolism
Glucose
ATP
Phosphate
Mg2+ 1
ADP
H2O
Glucose-6-phosphate
Hexokinase
Glucosephosphate
isomerase
Glucose-6-phosphatase
2
Fructose-6-phosphate
ATP
6-Phosphofructokinase
Mg2+
Phosphate
3
Hexosediphosphatase
ADP
H2O
Fructose-1,6-phosphate
4
Triose phosphate
Dihydroxyacetone
phosphate
5
Fructose-diphosphate aldolase
(6) Glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate
NAD+
Isomerase
7
Glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate
dehydrogenase
NADH + (H+)
3-Phosphoglyceroyl phosphate
ADP
Mg2+ 8
Phosphoglycerate kinase
ATP
3-Phosphoglycerate
Mg2+
Phosphoglyceromutase
9
2-Phosphoglycerate
Mg2+ 10
H2O
Enolase
H2O
Phosphoenolpyruvate
ADP
Mg2+ 11
Pyruvate kinase
ATP
Pyruvate
Fig. 9.4 The glycolytic pathway.
The hydrogen is removed via the normal NAD⫹ pathway.The acetyl-coenzyme
A produced is then oxidised to carbon dioxide and water via the tricarboxylic acid
cycle (also known as the Kreb’s or citric acid cycle), as shown in Fig. 9.5.
The tricarboxylic acid cycle involves four dehydrogenations, three of which are
NAD⫹-linked and one FAD-linked. In addition, one mole of GTP arises directly
with the change of succinyl-coenzyme A to succinate.The total ATP yield from the
oxidation of one mole of glucose can now be estimated. The ATP yield from
199
Chapter 9 Metabolism
Acetyl-coenzyme A
Malate dehydrogenase
Malate
Oxalacetate
NADH
NADH (+H+)
Coenzyme A
Citrate
NAD+
Fumarase
Fumarate
Succinate
FADH2
dehydrogenase
FAD
Succinate
GTP
Succinate coenzyme A
GDP + Pi
synthetase
Succinyl-coenzyme A
CO2
Citrate synthetase
(+H+)
Aconitase
Isocitrate
NAD 2+
Mg
Isocitrate dehydrogenase
NADH (+H+)
Oxalsuccinate
CO2
Isocitrate dehydrogenase
α-Ketoglutarate
HS.CoA
Mg2+
NAD+
α-Ketoglutarate dehydrogenase
complex
Fig. 9.5 The tricarboxylic acid cycle.
substrate-level phosphorylation is determined by the stoichiometry of the chemical
reactions. However, the ATP yield from oxidative phosphorylation is less certain because the stochiometries of proton-pumping, ATP synthesis and the metabolite
transport processes are not fixed values. As stated previously, the flow of a pair of
electrons from NADH to O2 generates sufficient proton-motive force for the synthesis of about 2.5 moles of ATP. Similarly, the flow of electrons from FADH to O2
generates sufficient proton-motive force for the synthesis of about 1.5 moles of ATP.
Consequently, on average about 30 moles of ATP are produced from the complete
oxidation of glucose (Table 9.1).
The capture of energy represented by the formation of 30 high-energy phosphate
bonds may be calculated as 30 ⫻ 50 ⫽ 1500 kJ/mole of glucose. The total free energy content of glucose is 2870 kJ/mole.The efficiency of free energy capture by the
body is thus 1500/2870 ⫽ 0.52. Such calculations assume perfect coupling of reactions and normal environmental cell conditions.
Table 9.1 ATP yield from the complete oxidation of 1 mole of glucose
1 mole glucose to 2 moles pyruvate
ATP yield (substrate-level phosphorylation)
2 NADH (oxidative phosphorylation glycerophosphate shuttle)
2 moles pyruvate to 2 moles acetyl-Co A
2 NADH (oxidative phosphorylation malate–aspartate shuttle)
2
3
5
2 moles acetyl-Co A to CO2 + H2O
ATP yield (substrate-level phosphoryation)
2 FADH (oxidative phosporylation glycerophosphate shuttle)
6 NADH (oxidative phosphoryation glycerophosphate shuttle)
Total ATP yield per mole of glucose
200
2
3
12
30
Energy metabolism
Glycolysis takes place in the cell cytoplasm, whereas the decarboxylation of pyruvate and the subsequent oxidation of acetyl-coenzyme A via the tricarboxylic acid
cycle take place in the mitochondrial matrix. Under anaerobic conditions, oxygen is
not available for the oxidation of reduced NAD⫹ by oxidative phosphorylation. In
order to allow the release of a small amount of energy by continuing the breakdown
of glucose to pyruvate, reduced NAD⫹ must be converted to the oxidised form. If
not, step 7 of Fig. 9.4 will not take place and energy production will be blocked.
Oxidation of reduced NAD⫹ may be achieved under such conditions by the formation of lactate from pyruvate in the presence of lactate dehydrogenase:
CH3
CH3
Lactate dehydrogenase
C:O
+
COO– NADH(+H )
CHOH
NAD+
Pyruvate
COO–
Lactate
When glucose is used as an energy source under anaerobic conditions, lactate accumulates, eventually diffuses into the bloodstream, and is carried to highly aerobic
tissues such as the heart and the liver. Here it may undergo oxidative breakdown to
carbon dioxide and water, with further release of energy, or it may be reconverted
into glucose. Recent evidence suggests that even in highly aerobic muscle tissue,
much of the glucose used for energy is converted to lactate.
Another pathway by which glucose is metabolised within the body is that known
variously as the pentose phosphate pathway, the phosphogluconate oxidative pathway and the hexose phosphate shunt. Although the system encompassing glycolysis
and the tricarboxylic acid cycle is the major pathway of glucose metabolism in the
body, the pentose phosphate pathway is of considerable importance in the cytoplasm
of the cells of the liver, adipose tissue and lactating mammary glands. The steps of
this pathway are shown in Fig. 9.6.
The net result of this series of reactions is the removal of one carbon atom from
glucose as carbon dioxide and the production of two moles of reduced NADP⫹. The
oxidation of one mole of glucose may be represented as:
Glucose-6-phosphate ⫹ 12NADP +
6CO2 ⫹ PO43–⫹ 12NADPH(+H+)
Unlike reduced NAD⫹, reduced NADP⫹ is not used during oxidative phosphorylation to produce ATP, and the main function of the pentose phosphate pathway is to
provide reduced NADP⫹ for tissues that have a specific demand for it, particularly
those actively synthesising fatty acids. Almost one-third of the glucose metabolised
by the liver may follow this pathway, and this figure may be exceeded in adipose
tissue. Reduced NADP⫹ can be converted to reduced NAD⫹ via an energy-linked
transhydrogenase and thus serve indirectly as a source of ATP.
Glycogen as an energy source
Glycogen is the major form of carbohydrate storage in animals and is present in most
animal cells. It may form up to 80 g/kg of fresh liver and up to 100 g/kg of fresh
muscle. Most is present in the latter.The release of energy from glycogen necessitates
201
Chapter 9 Metabolism
Glucose
ATP
Hexokinase
ADP
Glucose-6- P
NADP+
Glucose-6- P dehydrogenase
Glucosephosphate
isomerase
Fructose-1,6-bis- P
Fructose-bis- P
aldolase
NADPH (+H+)
Hexosebis- P isomerase
Glyceraldehyde 3- P
Transketolase
6-Phosphoglucono-δ-lactone
6-Phosphogluconolactonase
Erythrose 4- P
6-Phosphogluconate
Fructose-6- P
Transaldolase
NADP+
Phosphogluconate
dehydrogenase
Glyceraldehyde-3- P
Sedoheptulose-7- P
Transketolase
NADPH (+H+)
Xylulose-5- P
Ketogluconate-6- P
CO2
Ribose-5- P
Ribulose- P
3-epimerase
Ribulose-5- P
Ribosephosphate
isomerase
Fig. 9.6 The pentose phosphate pathway.
its breakdown to glucose, which is then degraded as described previously. Breakdown of glycogen within cells takes place through the action of inorganic phosphate
and glycogen phosphorylase.This enzyme catalyses the hydrolysis of the 1,4-glycosidic
linkages of the glycogen (see Chapter 2) and degradation begins at the non-reducing
end of the chain. Glucose-1-phosphate molecules are released successively until a
branch point is approached.A rearrangement of the molecule then takes place in the
presence of an oligotransferase, which exposes a terminal 1,6-linked glucose unit.
Cleavage of the 1,6 linkage by an oligo-1,6-glucosidase releases free glucose, and
glucose-1-phosphate is produced by further activity of the phosphorylase. The net
effect of glycogen breakdown is the production of glucose-1-phosphate plus a little
glucose. Glucose-1-phosphate is converted by phosphoglucomutase to glucose-6phosphate, which enters glycolysis or the pentose phosphate pathway, as does the
residual glucose. The production of glucose-6-phosphate from glycogen does not involve expenditure of ATP, except for that used in the conversion of residual glucose
to glucose-6-phosphate. Energy production from glycogen is thus slightly more efficient than it is from glucose.
Propionic acid as an energy source
In ruminant animals, considerable amounts of propionate are produced from carbohydrate breakdown in the rumen. The acid then passes across the rumen wall, where
a little is changed to lactate.The remainder is carried to the liver, where it is converted
202
Energy metabolism
H
CH3
Propionate
+
CH2
S
COO–
Coenzyme A
CoA
ATP
Acyl-CoA synthetase
AMP + PPi
CH3
Propionyl-coenzyme A
CH2
COS.CoA
ATP
Propionyl-CoA carboxylase
ADP + Pi
CH2
CH.COOH
Methylmalonyl-coenzyme A
COS.CoA
Methylmalonyl-CoA racemase
Methylmalonyl-CoA isomerase
COOH
CH2
Succinyl-coenzyme A
CH2
COS.CoA
Fig. 9.7 Conversion of propionate to succinyl-coenzyme A.
into glucose by gluconeogenesis. The first stage in this process is its conversion to
succinyl-coenzyme A (Fig. 9.7).
This then enters the tricarboxylic acid cycle and is converted to malate (see Fig. 9.5),
where the equivalent of 2.5 moles of ATP are produced.The malate is transported into
the cytosol, where it is converted to oxalacetate and then phosphoenolpyruvate:
COO–
CH2
CHOH
COO–
Malate
COO–
Malate dehydrogenase
NAD+
NADH
(+H+)
CH2
C:O
CH2
Phosphoenolpyruvate
carboxykinase
ITP
IDP
ATP
ADP
+Pi
C:O ~ P
COO–
COO–
Oxalacetate
Phosphoenolpyruvate
203
Chapter 9 Metabolism
The phosphoenolpyruvate may then be converted to fructose diphosphate by
reversal of steps 10, 9, 8, 7 and 5 in the glycolytic sequence shown in Fig. 9.4. This
is then converted to fructose-6-phosphate by hexose diphosphatase and then to
glucose-6-phosphate by the reverse of step 2 and finally to glucose by glucose-6phosphatase.The glucose may then eventually be used to provide energy.The energy
balance sheet may be prepared as follows:
ATP ⴙ
2 moles propionate to 2 moles succinyl-CoA
2 moles succinyl-CoA to 2 moles malate
2 moles malate to 2 moles phosphoenolpyruvate
2 moles phosphoenolpyruvate to 1 mole glucose
1 mole glucose to CO2 ⫹ H2O
Total
Net gain of ATP
ATP ⴚ
6
5
5
30
40
27
2
5
13
There is thus a net gain of 13.5 moles of ATP per mole of propionic acid.
Small amounts of propionic acid are present in the peripheral blood supply. They
may arise because of incomplete removal by the liver or from oxidation of fatty acids
with an odd number of carbon atoms. Such propionate could conceivably be used directly for energy production.The pathway would be the same as that described as far
as phosphoenolpyruvate.This would then follow glycolysis via pyruvate, acetyl-coenzyme A and the tricarboxylic acid cycle. The balance sheet for this process is:
ATP ⴙ
1 mole propionate to 1 mole succinyl-CoA
1 mole succinyl-CoA to 1 mole malate
1 mole malate to 1 mole phosphoenolpyruvate
1 mole phosphoenolpyruvate to 1 mole acetyl-CoA
1 mole acetyl-CoA to CO2 ⫹ H2O
Total
Net gain of ATP per mole of propionic acid
ATP ⴚ
3
2.5
2.5
3.5
10
18.5
14.5
1
4
Therefore, this pathway is marginally more efficient than that via glucose.
Butyric acid as an energy source
Butyric acid produced in the rumen is converted to ␤-hydroxybutyrate (D-3hydroxybutyrate) during absorption across the ruminal and omasal walls. The pathway for this conversion is shown in Fig. 9.8.
The D-3-hydroxybutyrate may then be used as a source of energy by a number of
tissues, notably skeletal and heart muscle. In non-ruminant animals, but not ruminants, utilisation by the brain increases markedly under conditions of glucose shortage. The reactions involved in energy production are shown in Fig. 9.9.
204
Energy metabolism
Butyrate
CH3.CH2.CH2.COO–
ATP
HS.CoA
AMP
H2O
Acetyl-CoA synthetase
Butyryl-CoA
CH3.CH2.CH2.COS.CoA
FAD
Acyl-CoA dehydrogenase
FADH
Crotonyl-CoA
CH3.CH:CH.COS.CoA
H2O
β-Hydroxybutyryl-CoA
Enoyl-CoA hydratase
CH3.CHOH.CH2.COS.CoA
NAD+
β-Hydroxyacyl dehydrogenase
NADH
(+H+)
Acetoacetyl-CoA
CH3.CO.CH2.COS.CoA
CH3.COS.CoA
Hydroxymethyglutaryl-CoA
CH3.C(CH3)(OH).CH2.COS.CoA
CH3.COS.CoA
Acetoacetate
Hydroxymethylglutaryl-CoA
synthase
Hydroxymethylglutaryl-CoA
lyase
CH3.CO.CH2.COO–
NADH
(+H+)
D-3-Hydroxybutyrate
dehydrogenase
NAD+
D-3-Hydroxybutyrate
CH3.CHOH.CH2.COO–
Fig. 9.8 Production of 3-hydroxybutyrate from butyrate.
The acetyl-coenzyme A is metabolised via the tricarboxylic acid cycle. We
may calculate the energy released from butyrate by the synthetase pathway as
follows:
1 mole butyrate to 1 mole D-3-hydroxybutyrate
1 mole D-3-hydroxybutyrate to 2 moles acetyl-CoA
2 moles acetyl-CoA to CO2 ⫹ H2O
Total
Net gain of ATP per mole butyrate
ATP ⴙ
ATP ⴚ
4
2.5
20
26.5
20
4.5
2
6.5
205
Chapter 9 Metabolism
CH3.CHOH.CH2.COO–
(D-3-Hydroxybutyrate)
NAD+
D-3-Hydroxybutyrate
dehydrogenase
NADH + (H+)
CH3.CO.CH2.COO–
(Acetoacetate)
Coenzyme A
Succinyl-coenzyme A
ATP
Acyl-CoA synthetase
β-Ketoacid-CoA transferase
AMP
CH3.CO.CH2.COS.CoA
(Acetoacetyl-coenzyme A)
Coenzyme A
Acetyl-CoA acetyl transferase
Pyrophosphate
Succinate
2CH3.COS.CoA
(Acetyl-coenzyme A)
Fig. 9.9 Formation of acetyl-coenzyme A from D-3-hydroxybutyrate.
If the change of acetoacetate to acetoacetyl-coenzyme A takes place via the
succinyl-coenzyme A pathway, there is a saving of two moles of ATP and the net gain
per mole of butyric acid is equivalent to 22 high-energy phosphate bonds. However,
the energy cost of producing succinyl-coenzyme A has to be taken into account, and
this pathway is then slightly less efficient than the other.
Acetic acid as an energy source
Acetic acid is the major product of carbohydrate digestion in ruminants and is the
only volatile fatty acid present in the peripheral blood in significant amounts. It is
used by a wide variety of tissues as a source of energy.The initial reaction in this case
is conversion of acetate to acetyl-coenzyme A in the presence of acetyl-coenzyme A
synthetase:
CH3
CH 3
H
+
Acetyl-CoA synthetase
ATP
COO–
S.CoA
Acetate
Coenzyme A
AMP
+PPi
+
H2O
COS.CoA
Acetyl-coenzyme A
The formation of the acetyl-coenzyme A takes place in the cell cytoplasm, whereas
the oxidation via the tricarboxylic acid cycle is confined to the mitochondrial matrix.
The acetyl-coenzyme A is unable to cross the mitochondrial wall and has to be complexed with carnitine to achieve this.Within the mitochondrial matrix, the complex is
broken down, releasing acetyl-coenzyme A, which then enters the tricarboxylic acid
206
Energy metabolism
cycle and is oxidised to yield 10 moles of ATP per mole. Since two high-energy phosphate bonds are used in the initial synthetase-mediated reaction, the net yield of
ATP is 8 moles per mole of acetate.
Fat as an energy source
The store of triacylglycerol in the body is mobilised to provide energy by the action
of lipases, which catalyse the production of glycerol and fatty acids. The glycerol is
glycogenic and enters the glycolytic pathway (see Fig. 9.4) as dihydroxyacetone
phosphate, produced as shown in the following reactions:
CH2OH
CH2OH
Glycerol kinase
CHOH
CH2OH
Glycerol
CHOH
ATP
ADP
CH2O ~ P
Glycerol-3-phosphate
dehydrogenase
CH2OH
C:O
NAD+
NAD+
(+H+)
C:O~ P
Dihydroxyacetone
phosphate
L-Glycerol-
3-phosphate
Glucose may then be produced by the reverse of the aldolase reaction to give
fructose-1,6-diphosphate, which is then converted to glucose by the action of hexose
diphosphatase, glucose-6-phosphate isomerase and glucose-6-phosphatase. If the
glucose is used to produce energy, we may assess the efficiency of glycerol as an
energy source:
2 moles glycerol to 2 moles dihyrdoxyacetone phosphate
2 moles dihyrdroxyacetone phosphate to 1 mole glucose
1 mole glucose to CO2 ⫹ H2O
Total
Net yield of ATP per mole glycerol
ATP ⴙ
ATP ⴚ
5
2
30
35
16.5
2
On the other hand, the dihydroxyacetone phosphate may enter the glycolytic
pathway and be metabolised via pyruvate and the tricarboxylic acid cycle to carbon
dioxide and water, with energy being released. The efficiency of glycerol as an energy source under these circumstances may be assessed as follows:
ATP ⴙ
1 mole glycerol to 1 mole dihydroxyacetone phosphate
1 mole dihydroxyacetone phosphate to 1 mole pyruvate
1 mole pyruvate to CO2 ⫹ H2O
Total
Net yield of ATP per mole glycerol
2.5
4.5
12.5
19.5
18.5
ATP ⴚ
1
1
207
Chapter 9 Metabolism
R.(CH2)n.CH2.CH2.COO–
Fatty acid
ATP
HS.CoA
Fattyacyl-CoA ligase
2PPi + AMP
H2O
R.(CH2)n.CH2.CH2.COS.CoA
Acyl-CoA
FAD
Acyl-CoA dehydrogenase
FADH2
R.(CH2)n.CH:CH.COS.CoA
Enoyl-CoA
H2O
β-Hydroxyacyl-CoA
Enoyl-CoA hydratase
R.(CH2)n.CHOH.CH2.COS.CoA
NAD+
β-Hydroxyacyl-CoA
dehydrogenase
NADH
(+H+)
β-Ketoacyl-CoA
R.(CH2)n.CO.CH2.COS.CoA
HS.CoA
Acetyl-CoA acyl transferase
R.(CH2)n.COS.CoA + CH3COS.CoA
Acyl-coenzyme A
Acetyl-coenzyme A
Fig. 9.10 Oxidation of fatty acids to acetyl-coenzyme A.
By far the most important source of energy provided by triacylglycerols is derived
from the fatty acids. The major pathway for fatty acid degradation is ␤-oxidation,
which results in a progressive shortening of the carbon chain by removal of two carbon atoms at a time. The first stage of ␤-oxidation is the reaction of the fatty acid
with coenzyme A in the presence of ATP and fattyacyl-CoA ligase to give an acylcoenzyme A. This occurs in the cell cytoplasm; the fattyacyl-CoA is then transferred
into the mitochondria as a complex with carnitine and is regenerated there. It then
undergoes a series of reactions to give an acyl-coenzyme A with two less carbon
atoms than the original and a mole of acetyl-CoA is released. The pathway is illustrated in Fig. 9.10.
During the splitting off of the two-carbon acetyl-coenzyme A, the equivalent of
4 moles of ATP is produced.The remaining acyl-coenzyme undergoes the same series
of reactions and the process continues until the carbon chain has been completely
converted to acetyl-coenzyme A. This enters the tricarboxylic acid cycle and is oxidised to carbon dioxide and water, each mole of acetyl-CoA so metabolised giving
10 moles of ATP. Since the initial ligase reaction is necessary only once for each
molecule, more ATP is produced for the same expenditure of energy by the oxidation of long- rather than short-chain acids. The oxidation of the 16-carbon palmitate
is illustrated in Fig. 9.11.
208
Energy metabolism
Palmitate
AMP
ATP
Palmitoyl-CoA
4ATP
Acetyl-CoA
Myristoyl-CoA
Acetyl-CoA
4ATP
Lauryl-CoA
Acetyl-CoA
4ATP
Caproyl-CoA
Acetyl-CoA
4ATP
Capryloyl-CoA
4ATP
Acetyl-CoA
Caprooyl-CoA
Acetyl-CoA
4ATP
Butyroyl-CoA
4ATP
Acetyl-CoA
Acetyl-CoA
Fig. 9.11 ␤-Oxidation of palmitate.
The energy production in this sequence may be summarised as follows:
ATP ⴙ
1 mole palmitate to palmitoyl-CoA
1 mole palmitoyl-CoA to 8 moles acetyl-CoA
8 moles acetyl-CoA to CO2 ⫹ H2O
Total
Net gain of ATP per mole of palmitate
ATP ⴚ
2
28
80
108
106
2
Amino acids as sources of energy
When amino acids are available in excess of the animal’s requirements, or when the
animal is forced to break down body tissues to maintain essential body processes,
amino acids may be catabolised to provide energy. This is important in dogs and
cats, which have been shown to be healthy on a carbohydrate-free diet. In animal
209
Chapter 9 Metabolism
tissues amino acid degradation takes place mainly in the liver, although the kidney
also shows considerable activity. Muscle tissue is relatively inactive.
The first stage in the oxidative degradation of amino acids is the removal of the
amino group by one of two main pathways, oxidative deamination or transamination. In transamination the amino group is transferred to the ␣-carbon atom of a keto
acid, usually ␣-ketoglutarate, resulting in the production of another keto acid and
glutamate. The reactions are catalysed by enzymes known as aminotransferases. The
reaction for aspartate may be represented as:
NH3
CH.COO–
CH2.COO–
O
+
C.COO–
Aspartate
aminotransferase
+
O
NH3
C.COO–
+
CH2.COO–
CH2
CH2.COO–
Aspartate
CH.COO–
CH2
CH2.COO–
α-Ketoglutarate
Oxalacetate
Glutamate
The glutamate so formed, as well as that which becomes available from the digestive tract and from protein breakdown in the tissues, may undergo oxidative deamination in the presence of glutamate dehydrogenase:
NH3+
NAD+ H2O
NADH
(+H+)
CH.COO–
CH2
O
C.COO–
Glutamate dehydrogenase
+
NH4+
CH2
CH2.COO–
CH2.COO–
Glutamate
α-Ketoglutarate
The ␣-ketoglutarate may then be used in further transaminations and the reduced
coenzyme is oxidised by oxidative phosphorylation (see p. 196). Glutamate is the
only amino acid in mammalian tissue that undergoes oxidative deamination at an appreciable rate.The initial transaminations that give rise to it are therefore of major importance when amino acids are being used as sources of energy. Flavin-linked D- and
L-amino acid oxidases, which catalyse the production of keto acids and ammonia, do
exist but are of minor importance only. The final product of amino acid degradation
is acetyl-coenzyme A, which is then processed via the tricarboxylic acid cycle to
yield energy.The acetyl-CoA may be produced directly (as in the case of tryptophan,
leucine and isoleucine), via pyruvate (alanine, glycine, serine, threonine and cysteine) or via acetoacetyl-CoA (phenylalanine, tyrosine, leucine, lysine and tryptophan). Other amino acids are degraded by pathways of varying complexity to give
products such as ␣-ketoglutarate, oxalacetate, fumarate and succinyl-CoA, which
enter the tricarboxylic acid cycle and yield acetyl-CoA via phosphoenolpyruvate
(see p. 200).
One of the consequences of amino acid catabolism is the production of ammonia,
which is highly toxic. Some of this may be used in amination during amino acid synthesis in the body. In this case, ammonia reacts with ␣-ketoglutarate to give glutamate,
210
Energy metabolism
which is then used for protein synthesis.The reaction is the reverse of oxidative deamination, except that NADP⫹ takes the place of NAD⫹. However, most of the ammonia
produced is excreted from the body as urea in mammals and uric acid in birds.
Deamination of amino acids occurs in all the organs of the body but primarily in
the liver. In most other tissues the ammonia is converted to glutamine or alanine (in
muscle) before being transported to the liver and regenerated. In mammals the ammonia is then converted into urea. This is a two-stage process requiring a supply of
energy in the form of ATP. The first stage is the formation of carbamoyl phosphate
from carbon dioxide and ammonia in the presence of carbamoyl phosphate
synthetase:
CO2 + NH4+
O
Carbamoyl phosphate
synthetase
NH2
+ H2O
2ATP
C.O~ P
2ADP
+Pi
The carbamoyl phosphate then reacts with ornithine to start a cycle of reactions resulting in the production of urea (Fig. 9.12).
The aspartate entering the cycle is produced by reaction of glutamate with oxalacetate, the former being produced from ␣-ketoglutarate plus ammonia released
by deamination of an amino acid. The oxalacetate is derived from the fumarate released in the production of arginine from arginosuccinate, which enters the tricarboxylic acid cycle and is converted to malate and then oxalacetate. We then have a
second associated cycle linking the urea and the tricarboxylic acid cycles, which may
be visualised as shown in Fig. 9.13.
In ruminant animals, ammonia is absorbed directly from the rumen and undergoes the same series of reactions. Most of the urea is excreted, but a certain amount,
depending upon the nitrogen status of the animal, is recycled via saliva and directly
across the rumen wall.
Ornithine
Urea
Carbamoyl
phosphate
Ornithine
carbamoyl
transferase
Arginase
H2O
Citrulline
Arginine
Fumarate
2+
Mg
Arginosuccinate
lyase
Arginosuccinate
synthetase
Aspartate
ATP
AMP
Arginosuccinate
Fig. 9.12 The urea cycle.
211
Chapter 9 Metabolism
Ornithine
Urea
cycle
Arginine
Citrulline
Arginosuccinate
Aspartate
Fumarate
Amino acid
α-Ketoglutarate
TCA
cycle
Glutamate
Malate
+
NAD
NH4+
NADH + H+
Glutamate
dehydrogenase
H2O + NAD+
Oxalacetate
NADH + H+
Fig. 9.13 Linkage of the urea and tricarboxylic acid cycles.
In assessing the efficiency of energy production from amino acids, the energy
needed for urea synthesis must be set against that obtained by oxidation of the carbon skeleton of the acid. If we take aspartate as an example, this is first converted to
oxalacetate and glutamate by reaction with ␣-ketoglutarate. The oxalacetate is oxidised via the phosphoenolpyruvate pathway and the tricarboxylic acid cycle. The
glutamate is deaminated to regenerate ␣-ketoglutarate and the ammonia released is
converted to urea. A balance sheet may be prepared:
2 moles aspartate to glutamate ⫹ oxalacetate
2 moles glutamate to ␣-ketoglutarate ⫹ ammonia
2 moles ammonia to glutamine
1 mole ammonia to carbamoyl phosphate
1 mole citrulline to arginosuccinate
1 mole malate to oxalacetate
1 mole ammonia to aspartate
2 moles oxalacetate to carbon dioxide and water
Total
Net gain from 2 moles of aspartate
Net gain from 1 mole of aspartate
212
ATP ⴙ
ATP ⴚ
0
5
0
0
0
2.5
0
20
27.5
19
9.5
0
0
2
2
2
0
2.5
0
8.5
Protein synthesis
In birds, ammonia is excreted as uric acid. This involves the incorporation of ammonia into glutamine by reaction with glutamate:
NH3+
NH3+
Glutamine synthetase
CH.COO–
+
CH.COO–
+
NH4
CH2
ADP
+ Pi
ATP
CH2.COO–
CH2
CH2.CONH2
Glutamine
Glutamate
Glutamine is then involved in a series of reactions with ribose-5-phosphate, glycine
and aspartate to give inosinic acid, which contains a purine nucleus. This series of
reactions may be represented as follows:
8 ATP
2 Glutamine + Glycine + Aspartate
Inosinic acid + Fumarate
The ribose-5-phosphate residue is then removed, giving hypoxanthine, which
undergoes two xanthine-oxidase-mediated oxidations to give xanthine and then
uric acid (Fig. 9.14).
Elimination of 2 moles of ammonia results in a net loss of 6 moles of ATP; in addition, 2 moles of glutamate, 1 mole glycine and 1 mole aspartate are used up and
1 mole fumarate is produced.
9.2
PROTEIN SYNTHESIS
Proteins are synthesised from amino acids, which become available either from the
end products of digestion or as the result of synthetic processes within the body.
Direct amination may take place as in the case of ␣-ketoglutarate, which yields
glutamate:
+
O
NH3
C.COO–
+ NH4+ + NADPH(+H+)
CH2
CH.COO–
CH2.COO–
α-Ketoglutarate
Glutamate
dehydrogenase
CH2
+ NADP+ + H2O
CH2.COO–
Glutamate
213
Chapter 9 Metabolism
O
C
N
NH
C
CH
C
N
Inosinic acid
CH
N
Ribose-5- P
Phosphorylase
Ribose-5- P
O
C
NH
N
C
CH
CH
C
N
N
H
Hypoxanthine
O 2 + H2
Xanthine oxidase
H2O2
O
C
NH
O
N
C
C
CH
C
N
H
N
H
Xanthine
O 2 + H2
Xanthine oxidase
H2O2
O
C
NH
O
C
C
H
N
C
O
C
N
H
N
H
Uric acid
Fig. 9.14 Conversion of inosinic acid to uric acid.
The glutamate may undergo further amination to give glutamine but, more importantly, may undergo transamination reactions with various keto acids to give
amino acids as shown in Fig. 9.15.
214
Protein synthesis
Glutamate
3-Phosphohydroxypyruvate
Pyruvate
Alanine-amino transferase
Phosphoserine transaminase
Oxalacetate
Aspartate
amino transferase
α-Ketoglutarate
α-Ketoglutarate
α-Ketoglutarate
Alanine
Aspartate
Phosphoserine
ATP
Asparagine synthetase
Phosphoserine
phosphatase
ADP
Asparagine
Serine
Fig. 9.15 Amino acid synthesis from glutamate.
Amino acids other than glutamate may undergo such transaminations to produce
new amino acids. Thus, both alanine and glycine react with phosphohydroxypyruvate to give serine:
CH2~ P
Alanine
Glycine
C:O
COO–
3-Phosphohydroxypyruvate
Serine-pyruvateamino transferase
Serine-glyoxalateamino transferase
CH2OH
CH.NH3+
Pyruvate
Glyoxalate
COO–
Serine
Glutamate is the source material of proline, which contains a five-membered ring
structure. The synthesis of proline takes place in two stages and requires energy in
the form of reduced NAD⫹ and NADP⫹:
COO–
CHNH2
NADH
(+H+)
NAD
CH2
COO–
ATP
Glutamate
ADP
CH2
CH2
CH
CH.COO–
NADPH
NADP+
(+H+)
N
Δ’-Pyrroline 5-carboxylate
CH2
CH2
CH
CH.COO–
NH
Proline
Amino acids may also be formed by the reaction of keto acids with ammonium
salts or urea; arginine, as we have already seen, may be synthesised during the formation of urea.
Not all amino acids are capable of being synthesised in the body, and others are
not synthesised at sufficient speed to satisfy the needs of the body. Both these
215
Chapter 9 Metabolism
groups have to be supplied to the animal. Such amino acids are known as essential
or indispensable amino acids (see Chapter 4). The words ‘essential’ and ‘indispensable’, as used here, imply not that other amino acids are not required for the wellbeing of the animal but simply that a supply of them in the diet is unnecessary.All of
the 25 amino acids normally found in the body are physiological essentials; some 10
or 11 are dietary essentials. As would be expected, the actual list of essential amino
acids differs from species to species. In cattle and sheep, bacterial synthesis of amino
acids in the rumen renders the inclusion of any specific amino acids in the diet unnecessary, except under conditions of intensive production, as with high-yielding
dairy cows and small animals making high weight gains.
Amino acids are absorbed from the gut into the bloodstream by active transport
and transferred to the cells. This requires a supply of energy, since the concentration
of amino acids in the cell may be up to 100 times that in the blood and transfer into
the cell has to take place against a very considerable concentration gradient. A continuous exchange takes place between the blood and cellular amino acids, but not
between the free amino acids and those of the tissue proteins. The tissue proteins
themselves undergo breakdown and resynthesis, but their stability varies between
different tissues. For example, liver protein has a half-life of 7 days whereas collagen
is so stable that it may be considered to be almost completely inert.
The process of protein synthesis may be divided conveniently into four stages:
activation of individual amino acids, initiation of peptide chain formation, chain
elongation and chain termination.
Activation
The first step is enzymatic and requires the presence of ATP to give complexes:
Amino acid +
ATP
+ enzyme
Aminoacyl–AMP–enzyme +
pyrophosphate
The amino-acyl group is then coupled to a molecule of transfer RNA (tRNA):
Aminoacyl–AMP – enzyme + tRNA
Aminoacyl– tRNA + AMP + enzyme
Both reactions are catalysed by a single Mg2⫹-dependent aminoacyl synthetase,
specific for the amino acid and the tRNA. The synthetases discriminate between the
20 naturally occurring amino acids but the specificity is not absolute.The tRNA molecule is composed of a single nucleotide chain containing 73–93 ribonucleotides
(see Chapter 4) and exhibits considerable folding stabilised by hydrogen bonding.
At one end of the chain is the final nucleotide arrangement of –C—C—A—OH, i.e.
cytidine–cytidine–adenosine.The amino acid is attached to the ribose of the terminal
adenosine.The other end of the chain frequently terminates in the nucleotide guanosine.We may visualise a typical tRNA molecule as shown in Fig. 9.16.
There is at least one tRNA for each amino acid but only one amino acid for a given
tRNA. Since the terminal regions of the various tRNA species are so similar, their specificity resides within the interior of the molecules. This arrangement consists of a sequence of three bases (anticodon), present in the anticodon loop near the centre of the
chain, the nature and arrangement of which are specific for a particular amino acid.
When the amino acid has been coupled to the tRNA it is carried to one of the
sites of protein synthesis, the ribosomes. These form part of the structures known as
216
Protein synthesis
Adenosine
Cytidine
Guanine
Cytidine
Hydrogen bonds
Fig. 9.16 Diagramatic representation of a tRNA molecule.
polysomes in which several ribosomes are linked by a strand of messenger RNA
(mRNA). It is the sequence of bases on this mRNA strand, originally transcribed
from the nuclear DNA, that dictates the amino acid sequence in the primary structure of the protein to be synthesised. A particular amino acid will be placed at the
mRNA surface at a point having a specific arrangement of three bases, i.e. there is a
base triplet code, known as a codon, for each amino acid. The tRNA carrying the
specific amino acid for a particular codon will have a complementary arrangement
of three bases known as an anticodon. There are 64 possible base triplet combinations, and 61 of these have been shown to code for the 20 amino acids involved in
protein synthesis. There is thus more than one codon for each amino acid. However,
any one codon codes only for one amino acid.The codons for individual amino acids
have been elucidated and some examples are provided in Table 9.2.
Table 9.2 Examples of known codons on mRNA
Codon
Amino acid
UUU
UUA
UCC
UCA
CCC
CGA
AGC
AGA
UGA
Phenylalanine
Leucine
Serine
Serine
Proline
Arginine
Serine
Arginine
Stop
A ⫽ adenine, C ⫽ cytosine, G ⫽ guanine, U ⫽ uracil.
217
Chapter 9 Metabolism
AA3
AA2
AA1
AA1
AA1
AA2
AA1 AA2
AA1
AA2
Large ribosome
subunit
Small ribosome
subunit
mRNA
n
n+1 n+2
Phase 1
n
n+1 n+2
Phase 2
n
n+1 n+2
Phase 3
n
n+1 n+2
Phase 4
n+1 n+2 n+3
Phase 5
Fig. 9.17 Diagramatic representation of the sequence of events occurring in the
ribosome during the process of polypeptide synthesis.
Initiation of peptide chain formation
The ribosomes of higher animals consist of two subunits designated 40S (Svedberg
units) and 60S, according to their sedimentation characteristics in an ultracentrifuge.
These combine to form a functional 80S ribosome.
Initiation of peptide formation involves attachment of the smaller subunit to a
tRNA and the mRNA. The first tRNA codes for methionine and is placed at an AUG
codon (n) at the end of the mRNA chain (Phase 1 of Fig. 9.17).
The larger subunit becomes attached to form the complete ribosome, which is
then ready to accept the next tRNA–amino acid complex at codon n ⫹ 1 (Phase 2).
The insertion of each amino acid residue requires the expenditure of one highenergy phosphate bond, as GTP.
Chain elongation
The requisite amino acid (AA2) is then placed at codon n ⫹ 1 by its specific tRNA, as
shown in Phase 3 in Fig. 9.17. A peptide bond is then formed between AA1 (methionine) and AA2, and the tRNA for methionine is simultaneously ejected (Phase 4).The
ribosome and the mRNA then move relative to one another; codon n ⫹ 1 is placed at
the position previously occupied by codon n and codon n ⫹ 2 moves into that previously occupied by n ⫹ 1, as shown in Phase 5.The process is then repeated, with AA3
being placed at n ⫹ 2, followed by formation of a peptide bond and movement of the
ribosome to expose codon n ⫹ 3. This continues until the chain is complete; each
movement requires the expenditure of one high-energy bond in the form of GTP.
Termination
Chain elongation continues until a codon is reached that does not code for any
amino acid, i.e. UAA, UAG or UGA. It then ceases and the formed peptide chain is
liberated by hydrolysis, which requires the rupture of one high-energy phosphate
bond in GTP. The methionine residue is then removed enzymatically.
218
Fat synthesis
The polypeptide is the primary structure of the protein. The secondary structure
involves twisting of the polypeptide chain to produce either an ␣-helix or a
␤-pleated sheet, both stabilised by hydrogen bonding. The tertiary structure involves
extensive coiling and folding of the chain and is again stabilised by hydrogen bonding, salt linkages and sulphur bridges. The quaternary structure involves polymerisation of these basic units (see Chapter 4).
The mRNA forms a small proportion of the cell’s RNA and has only a transient
existence. In some microorganisms it may function as a template in synthesis 10–20
times only; in mammalian tissues its active life may be much longer and in some
cases it may persist for several days.
The mechanism of protein synthesis discussed above does not involve addition of
amino acids to preformed peptides; synthesis starts with an amino acid and a
polypeptide chain is synthesised by the successive addition of single amino acids.
Unless all the amino acids required to synthesise the peptide are present at the right
time, synthesis will not take place and the amino acids that are present are removed
and may be catabolised. Considerable wastage of amino acids may thus take place if
an incomplete mixture is presented for synthesis.
Energy cost
During protein synthesis, energy is provided by hydrolysis of ATP and GTP, the production of each mole requiring the expenditure of 85.4 kJ by the body. If we make
certain assumptions, then an estimate of the energetic efficiency of protein synthesis
may be made. Let us assume that the average gram molecular weight of amino acids
in a given protein is 100. In such a protein, the number of amino acids is large, say n,
and the number of peptide bonds will be n - 1 but may be taken for all practical purposes as n.We may now construct an energy balance sheet as follows:
Energy expended (kJ)
100 g amino acid
2 moles ATP (activation)
1 mole GTP (initiation)
1 mole GTP (elongation)
1 mole GTP (termination)
100 g protein
Energy stored (kJ)
2437
170.8
85.4
85.4
85.4
2864
2437
2437
Energetic efficiency ⫽ 2437兾2864 ⫽ 0.85
NB The calculation assumes synchronous provision of the required amino acids; efficiency is
probably much less under normal conditions.
9.3
FAT SYNTHESIS
The glycerides (triacylglycerols) of the depot fat are derived from preformed glycerides or may be synthesised in the body from fattyacyl-CoAs and L-glycerol-3phosphate. This can take place in most tissues but is confined mostly to the liver and
adipose tissue.
219
Chapter 9 Metabolism
BOX 9.1 Genetic engineering
Recombinant DNA technology allows the spitting off of a DNA fragment containing a gene of interest and its linkage to a DNA molecule capable of self-replication.This can then be propagated by introduction into a living cell, such as a bacterium, and the characteristics for which the gene codes
conferred to that cell. Early successes of this technique included the cloning and expression in
Escherichia coli of a gene coding for human insulin, and the gene coding for rat growth hormone in
mice. Such genetically modified animals are known as transgenic animals.
The introduction of genes that alter inherent biochemical pathways in organisms may be of significant interest in the nutrition of animals, since it could confer to them some ability that they did
not previously possess such as producing essential nutrients. For example:
■
■
■
■
The amino acid cysteine is essential for wool growth in sheep, which need a source of methionine
to synthesise it. Certain bacteria have the ability to synthesise cysteine, with the pathway involving the action of two enzymes, serine transacetylase and O-acetylserine sulphydralase. The
genes coding for these enzymes have been successfully introduced into sheep, which then express the appropriate pathways but, so far, only in inappropriate tissues.
Genes for biosynthesis of the essential amino acids threonine and lysine from aspartate have
been successfully introduced into mouse cells as a preliminary to their introduction into the pig
genome.
Transgenic mice have been produced that show pancreatic cellulase activity.The potential importance of this achievement for improving digestion in monogastric animals is self-evident.
Gene transfer has already been used to introduce cellulase activity into hind gut bacteria. If the
ability to show cellulase activity under highly acid conditions could be conferred to rumen
microorganisms, then it could have a significant effect in ameliorating the detrimental effects of
high-level concentrate feeding on fibre digestion and forage intake. The transgenic organisms
would of course have to compete with the native rumen flora if they were to be successful in
practice.
Synthesis of fattyacyl-CoAs
It is generally considered that there are three systems of fatty acid synthesis. The
first, which is highly active, is centred in the cell cytoplasm and results mainly in the
production of palmitate from acetyl-coenzyme A or butyryl-coenzyme A. Nearly all
other fatty acids are produced by modification of this acid.The second system occurs
chiefly in the endoplasmic reticulum and to a minor extent in the mitochondria. It
involves elongation of fatty acid chains by two-carbon addition, with malonyl-CoA
as donor. The third system, confined to the endoplasmic reticulum, brings about
desaturation of preformed fatty acids.
Cytosolic synthesis of palmitate
In non-ruminant animals, acetyl-coenzyme A is mainly produced in the mitochondria by oxidative decarboxylation of pyruvate produced from glucose by glycolysis
(see p. 199), but also by oxidative degradation of amino and fatty acids. It must then
220
Fat synthesis
be transported into the cell cytoplasm for fatty acid synthesis to take place. However, the mitochondrial membrane is impervious to acetyl-CoA, which has to be
complexed with carnitine or changed to citrate before transport into the cytoplasm.
Regeneration of acetyl-CoA then takes place as follows:
Citrate ⫹ Coenzyme A
ATP-citrate lyase
ATP
Acetyl-CoA ⫹ Oxalacetate
ADP
In the ruminant animal, acetate is absorbed directly from the gut and is changed
to acetyl-CoA, in the presence of acetyl-CoA synthetase (see p. 206), in the cell cytoplasm. This is the major source of acetyl-CoA in ruminants, in which ATP-citrate
lyase activity is greatly reduced and passage of mitochondrial acetyl-CoA to the
cytoplasm is limited.
The system is active in liver, kidney, brain, lung, mammary gland and adipose tissue.The requirements of the system are reduced NADP⫹,ATP, HCO3- as a source of
carbon dioxide, and manganese ions. The first stage is the transformation of acetylcoenzyme A to malonyl-coenzyme A:
COOH
Acetyl-CoA carboxylase
CH 3
⫹
ATP
⫹ H2O
⫹ CO 2
CH 2
Mn 2+
COS.CoA
⫹
ADP
⫹
Pi
COS.CoA
The malonyl-coenzyme A then reacts with acyl-carrier protein (ACP), in the presence of malonyl-CoA-ACP transacylase, to give the malonyl–ACP complex. Acetylcoenzyme A is then coupled with ACP in the presence of acetyl-CoA-ACP
transacylase, and this reacts with the malonyl–ACP, the chain length being increased
by two carbon atoms to give the butyryl–ACP complex. The reactions involved are
shown in Fig. 9.18.
The butyryl–ACP complex then reacts with malonyl–ACP complex, resulting in
further elongation of the chain by two carbon atoms to give caproyl–ACP. Chain
elongation takes place by successive reactions of the fattyacyl–ACP complexes with
malonyl–coenzyme A until the palmitoyl–ACP complex is produced, when it ceases.
Palmitic acid is liberated by the action of a specific deacylase. The overall reaction
can be presented as:
CH3.COS.CoA + 7COO–.(CH2)COS.CoA + 14NADPH(+H+)
Acetyl-CoA
Malonyl-CoA
CH3.(CH2)14.COO– + 7CO2 + 14NADP+ + 6H2O + 8HS.CoA
Palmitate
Coenzyme A
221
Chapter 9 Metabolism
COOH.CH2.COS.ACP
Malonyl–ACP
CH3.COS.ACP
Acetyl–ACP
+
CO2
β-Ketoacyl-ACP synthase
CH3.CO.CH2.COS.ACP
Acetoacetyl–ACP
NADPH(+H+)
β-Ketoacyl-ACP reductase
NADP+
CH3.CHOH.CH2.COS.ACP
β-Hydroxybutyryl–ACP
Crotonyl-ACP hydratase
H2O
CH3.CH.CH.COS.ACP
Crotonyl–ACP
NADPH(+H+)
Enoyl-ACP reductase
NADP+
CH3.CH2.CH2.COS.ACP
Butyryl–ACP
Fig. 9.18 Cytosolic synthesis of fatty acids.
In assessing the energy requirements of the process, the energy cost of producing
malonyl-coenzyme A from acetyl-coenzyme A must be taken into account and can
be presented as:
8Ac-CoA + 7ATP + 14NADPH(+H +)
C15H31.COO– + NADP+ + 7ADP + 6H2O + 7Pi
The mammary gland contains deacylases specific for short- and medium-chain
acyl complexes, and acids of these chain lengths appear in milk fat.
Chain elongation
This system involves the incorporation of two carbon units into medium- and longchain fatty acids and requires ATP and reduced NADP⫹.The pathway is illustrated in
Fig. 9.19.
222
Fat synthesis
R.CH2.COO–
Fatty acid
ATP
AMP
+PPi
Coenzyme A
Acyl-CoA ligase
R.CH2.COS.CoA
Fatty acyl-coenzyme A
Malonyl-CoA
β-Ketoacyl-CoA synthase
Coenzyme A
R.CH2.CO.CH2.COS.CoA
β-Ketoacyl-coenzyme A
NADPH (+H+)
β-Ketoacyl-CoA reductase
NADP+
R.CH2.CHOH.CH2.COS.CoA
β-Hydroxyacyl-coenzyme A
Enoyl-CoA hydratase
H2O
R.CH2.CH:CH.COS.CoA
Enoyl-coenzyme A
NADPH (+H+)
2,3-Unsaturated acyl-CoA reductase
NADP+
R.CH2.CH2.CH2.COS.CoA
Fatty acyl-coenzyme A
Fig. 9.19 Elongation of the fatty acid chain.
The preferred substrate is palmitoyl-CoA, and in most tissues the product is
stearate. Long-chain saturated acids with 18, 20, 22 and 24 carbon atoms are synthesised in the brain, where they are required as components of the brain lipids.
A mitochondrial system for elongation of fatty acid chains, using acetyl-CoA as
the two-carbon donor does exist but has limited activity with acyl-CoA substrates
with 16 or more carbon atoms and is probably concerned with the lengthening of
shorter chains.
Desaturation of preformed fatty acids
Double bonds may be introduced into fatty acid chains by the action of fattyacylCoA desaturases present in the endoplasmic reticulum. Thus, palmitoleic and oleic
acids are produced from the corresponding saturated acids by a ⌬9-desaturase
223
Chapter 9 Metabolism
system, steroyl-CoA desaturase, which introduces a double bond between carbon
atoms 9 and 10.The system is confined to acids with a chain length of 15 or greater.
O2
H2O
CH3.(CH2)6.CH2.CH2.(CH2)6.COO–
CH3.(CH2)6.CH:CH.(CH2)6.COO–
NAD+
NADH
(+H+)
Palmitoleate
Palmitate
Mammalian cells also contain ⌬6 and ⌬5 desaturases but do not have systems
capable of introducing double bonds beyond carbon atom 9. As a result it is not
possible for mammalian tissues to synthesise either linoleic acid (18:2⌬9,12) or ␣linolenic acid (18:3⌬9,12,15).These have to be provided in the diet and are referred to
as essential fatty acids (EFA). Once they have been ingested, a range of acids, including ␥-linolenic, arachidonic, eicosapentaenoic and docosahexanoic acids, can be synthesised from them by successive chain elongation and ⌬6 and/or ⌬5 desaturations
(see Fig. 3.1 in Chapter 3).
Synthesis of L-glycerol-3-phosphate
The usual precursor is dihydroxyacetone phosphate produced by the aldolase reaction of the glycolytic pathway. This is reduced by the NAD-linked glycerol-3phosphate dehydrogenase:
CH2OH
C:O
CH2OH
Glycerol-3-phosphate
dehydrogenase
CH2O~ P
CHOH
CH2O~ P
NADH
(+H+)
Dihydroxyacetone
phosphate
NAD
+
L-Glycerol3-phosphate
It may also be formed from free glycerol, absorbed from the gut or arising from
catalysis of triacylglycerols, in the presence of glycerol kinase. The reaction requires
the expenditure of a high-energy bond as ATP.White adipose tissue does not contain
significant amounts of glycerol kinase, and so most glycerol phosphate is made available by glycolysis.
Synthesis of triacylglycerols
The first stage is the acylation, in the presence of glycerol-3-phosphate acyltransferase, of the free alcohol groups of the glycerol-3-phosphate by two molecules
of fattyacyl-CoA to yield a phosphatidic acid:
224
Fat synthesis
R1.COS.CoA
HS.CoA
R2.COS.CoA
HS.CoA
CH2OH
CH2.OCO.R1
CH2.OCO.R1
CHOH
CHOH
CHOCO.R2
CH2O~ P
CH2O~ P
CH2O~ P
L-Glycerol-3-phosphate
Monoacylglycerol-3-phosphate
Diacylglycerol3-phosphate
The reaction occurs preferentially with acids containing 16 and 18 carbon atoms.
The phosphatidic acid is then hydrolysed to give a diacylglycerol, which reacts with
a third fattyacyl-CoA to give a triacylglycerol:
CH2OCO.R1
Phosphatidate
phosphatase
CHOCO.R2
CH2O~ P
Diacylglycerol3-phosphate
CH2OCO.R1
Diacylglycerol
acyltransferase
CHOCO.R2
H2O
Pi
CH2OH
CH2OCO.R1
CHOCO.R2
R3.COS.CoA
HS.CoA CH OCO.R
2
3
Triacylglycerol
Diacylglycerol
Direct synthesis of triacylglycerols from 2-monoacylglycerols, arising from lipid
digestion in the intestine, takes place in the intestinal mucosa of higher animals.
Energy cost
The efficiency of fat synthesis may be calculated from the pathways described. The
calculation for the synthesis of tripalmitin by the cytoplasmic system would be:
Energy
expended (kJ)
8 moles acetate
8 moles acetate to acetyl-CoA
7 moles acetyl-CoA to malonyl-CoA
7 additions of malonyl-CoA
Energy for 1 mole of palmitate
Energy for 3 moles palmitate
0.5 mole of glucose
0.5 mole glucose to dihydroxyacetone phosphate
1 mole dihydroxyacetone phosphate to
1 mole L-glycerol-3-phosphate
Energy for 1 mole L-glycerol-3-phosphate
Total energy for 1 mole tripalmatin
Energy stored in 1 mole tripalmatin
Efficiency of synthesis ⴝ 32 025.0兾38 702.1 ⴝ
Energy
stored (kJ)
6996.0
1366.4
597.8
3348.3
12 308.5
36 925.5
1435.0
85.4
256.2
1776.6
38 702.1
32 025.0
0.83
225
Chapter 9 Metabolism
9.4
CARBOHYDRATE SYNTHESIS
Glucose
Glucose is an important substrate and energy source in animal tissues:
■
■
■
■
■
■
■
in the metabolism of nervous tissue and erythrocytes;
as the source of glycerol-3-phosphate for fat synthesis;
for the maintenance of blood sugar levels;
for the maintenance of glycogen reserves especially in the liver and muscle;
as the source of oxalacetate to allow oxidation of acetyl-CoA;
to allow clearing of lactate and glycerol;
as the precursor for other carbohydrates.
In non-ruminant animals, glucose becomes available as the result of carbohydrate digestion. When this source is inadequate, glucose may be synthesised from a variety of
non-carbohydrate sources, mainly lactate, glycerol and glucogenic amino acids (gluconeogenesis). In ruminant animals, little or no glucose becomes available as an end product of digestion; the demands for glucose do not, however, differ significantly from
those of the non-ruminant.As a result ruminant animals have developed highly efficient
glucose conservation and gluconeogenic mechanisms. As in the non-ruminant, glucose
may be synthesised from glycerol, lactate and the glucogenic amino acids, but the major
source is propionate (about 90 per cent of which is used for glucose synthesis).
Lactate as a source of glucose
The first step in the production of glucose from lactate is its conversion to pyruvate
by lactate dehydrogenase:
CH3
CH3
Lactate dehydrogenase
CHOH
COO–
Lactate
C:O
NAD+
NADH
(+H+)
COO–
Pyruvate
Glucose cannot be produced from pyruvate by a simple reversal of the glycolytic
sequence since three of the reactions, namely:
■
■
■
the conversion of glucose to glucose-6-phosphate,
the conversion of fructose-6-phosphate to fructose 1,6-diphosphate, and
the conversion of phosphoenolpyruvate to pyruvate,
are so highly exergonic as to be irreversible under normal cell conditions.
In gluconeogenesis, the conversion of pyruvate to phosphoenolpyruvate is
achieved by a two-stage process involving:
■
■
226
pyruvate carboxylase, which converts pyruvate to oxalacetate (in non-ruminant
animals the enzyme is located in the mitochondria and conversion of pyruvate to
oxalacetate can only occur in this location);
phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase, which converts oxalacetate to phosphoenolpyruvate.
Carbohydrate synthesis
2 Pyruvate
2 ATP
Pyruvate carboxylase
2 ADP
2 Oxalacetate
2 GTP
Phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase
2 GDP
2 Phosphoenolpyruvate
Dihydroxyacetone
phosphate
2 ATP
NADH(+H+)
2 ADP
NAD+
2 Glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate
Reverse
glycolysis
Fructose-1-6-bisphosphate
Fructose-1-6-bisphosphatase
Pi
Fructose-6-phosphate
Reverse
glycolysis
Glucose-6-phosphate
Glucose-6-phosphatase
Pi
Glucose
Fig. 9.20 Gluconeogenesis from pyruvate.
The latter may take place in the mitochondria and the phosphoenolpyruvate then
passes into the cell cytoplasm. Alternatively, oxalacetate may be transferred into the
cell cytoplasm by means of the glutamate–aspartate shuttle and converted to phosphoenolpyruvate by cytoplasmic phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase. In the ruminant
animal, pyruvate carboxylase is located in the cell cytoplasm as well as the mitochondria, and pyruvate can be changed to phosphoenolpyruvate entirely in the cytoplasm.
In the cell cytoplasm, the phosphoenolpyruvate is converted to fructose 1,6diphosphate by the reverse of stages 10–5 of the glycolytic sequence (see Fig. 9.4).
This is then changed to fructose-6-phosphate by fructose-1,6-diphosphatase and
then to glucose-6-phosphate by the reverse of stage 2. The final change to glucose is
achieved by glucose-6-phosphatase. The whole process is illustrated in Fig. 9.20.
Amino acids as sources of glucose
Catabolism of amino acids, except for leucine and lysine, results in synthesis of tricarboxylic acid cycle intermediates or the production of pyruvate (see p. 210). Conversion of the latter into glucose then takes place as shown in Fig. 9.20. The
tricarboxylic acid cycle intermediates enter the cycle and are converted into malate,
227
Chapter 9 Metabolism
which crosses into the cell cytoplasm, where it is converted into oxalacetate by
malate dehydrogenase:
COO–
COO–
Malate dehydrogenase
CHOH
C:O
NADH (+H+)
NAD+
CH2
CH2
COO–
COO–
Malate
Oxalacetate
The oxalacetate enters the glucogenic pathway.
Glycerol as a source of glucose
Glycerol is first phosphorylated, by glycerol kinase, to glycerol-3-phosphate. This is
oxidised, by glycerol-3-phosphate dehydrogenase, to dihydroxyacetone phosphate,
which enters the glucogenic pathway.
Propionate as a source of glucose
Propionate is first changed to succinyl-CoA (see Fig. 9.7). This enters the tricarboxylic acid cycle and is converted to malate and leaves the mitochondria as such.
Conversion to glucose then takes place via the usual route through oxalacetate and
phosphoenolpyruvate.
The major pathways of gluconeogenesis are represented in Fig. 9.21.
Consideration of the energy changes involved in the various metabolic pathways
shows that it involves a considerable demand for energy (Table 9.3).
In non-ruminant animals, amino acids and lactate form the major sources for gluconeogenesis; in ruminant animals, propionate is pre-eminent. Under normal feeding
Propionate
Succinate
Amino acids
Lactate
TCA
intermediates
Pyruvate
Malate
Oxalacetate
Glycerol
Phosphoenolpyruvate
Glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate
Glucose
Fig. 9.21 Major pathways of gluconeogenesis.
228
Dihydroxy-acetone phosphate
Carbohydrate synthesis
Table 9.3 Energy cost of gluconeogenesis
Source
Aspartate
Propionate
Lactate
Glycerol
Input
Energy cost (kJ)
Energy retained (kJ)
Efficiency
2 moles + 10 ATP
2 moles + 4 ATP
2 moles + 6 ATP
2 moles - 4 ATP
3968
3248
3246
2982
2870
2870
2870
2870
0.72
0.88
0.88
0.96
conditions propionate probably provides about 70 per cent of the glucose requirement of ruminant animals, but it becomes of lesser importance as the level of feeding falls. Under starvation conditions its contribution approaches zero and glycerol
becomes of major significance in gluconeogenesis.
Glycogen synthesis
Glycogen is a complex polysaccharide made up of condensed glucose residues (see
Chapter 2) and has the ability to add on further glucose units when they become
available within the body. The actual source material for glycogen synthesis is uridine diphosphate glucose (UDPG), which is produced from a variety of sources as
shown in Fig. 9.22.
Glycogen is produced by the reaction of uridine diphosphate glucose with primer
molecules, the most active of which is glycogen itself. Molecules with as few as four
glucose residues may serve as primers, but the reaction rate is slow. As the complexity of the primer increases, so does the reaction rate. Synthesis involves the reaction
Galactose
Glucose
ATP
ATP
ATP
Fructose
Mannose
ATP
Glucokinase
Fructokinase
Mannokinase
ADP
ADP
ADP
+ Pi
+ Pi
+ Pi
GlucoseFructoseMannose6-phosphate
6-phosphate
6-phosphate
Galactokinase
ADP
+ Pi
Phosphoglucomutase
Glucose1-phosphate
Galactose1-phosphate
UTP
Galactose-1-phosphate
uridyltransferase
Glucose-1-phosphate
uridyltransferase
PPi
UDP glucose4-epimerase
Uridine
diphosphate galactose
Uridine
diphosphate glucose
Fig. 9.22 Formation of uridine diphospate glucose.
229
Chapter 9 Metabolism
of uridine diphosphate glucose with the fourth hydroxyl group of the non-reducing
end of the primer chain in the presence of glycogen synthase:
UDP-glucose ⫹ (glucose)n
Glycogen synthase
(glucose)n⫹1 ⫹ UDP
The 1,6 linkages responsible for the branching within the glycogen molecule are
formed by transfer of a terminal oligosaccharide fragment of six or seven glucose
residues from the end of the glycogen chain to a 6-hydroxyl group in a glucose
residue in the interior of the chain. This takes place in the presence of branching enzyme or, more correctly, amylo-(1,4-1,6) transglycosylase.
Lactose synthesis
Lactose (milk sugar) is produced in large quantities in the mammary gland of lactating animals. It is formed by condensation of one glucose and one galactose molecule.
A supply of glucose is readily available, but the galactose has to be synthesised,
virtually in its entirety, from glucose, and this involves a configurational change at
carbon atom 4.The glucose is first converted to glucose-1-phosphate and then to uridine diphosphate glucose, from which uridine diphosphate galactose is produced by
the action of UDP-galactose-4-epimerase, as shown in Fig. 9.23.
Lactose is then formed by the action of the UDP-D-galactose with glucose in the
presence of the lactose synthetase system:
UDP-galactose ⫹ D-glucose
Lactose synthetase
UDP ⫹ lactose
The synthetase system is a complex of the enzyme galactosyl transferase with ␣lactalbumin. The enzyme catalyses the attachment of galactose to protein containing a carbohydrate residue; ␣-lactalbumin alters the specificity of the enzyme so
that it catalyses the linkage of galactose to glucose. The enzyme is present in the
non-lactating gland but is only feebly active.With the onset of lactation, ␣-lactalbumin
is produced in the gland and in its presence the enzyme becomes highly active in
D-Glucose
ATP
ADP
+Pi
Hexokinase
D-Glucose-6-phosphate
Phosphoglucomutase
D-Glucose-1-phosphate
UTP
Glucose-1-phosphate uridyl
transferase
PPi
Uridine diphosphate D-glucose
UDP-glucose 4-epimerase
Uridine diphosphate D-galactose
Fig. 9.23 Conversion of glucose to uridine diphosphate galactose.
230
Carbohydrate synthesis
catalysing the linkage. The energetic efficiency of lactose synthesis may be assessed
as follows:
Energy
expended (kJ)
2 moles glucose
2 moles glucose to 2 moles glucose-1-phosphate
1 mole glucose-1-phosphate to uridine diphoshate
galactose
Energy required for 1 mole lactose
Energy retained in 1 mole lactose
Energy
stored (kJ)
5606
170.8
85.4
5862.2
5648.4
Energetic efficiency ⴝ 5648.4兾5862.2 ⴝ 0.96
BOX 9.2 Metabolic disease
Metabolic disease results from metabolic stress caused when metabolic outputs exceed inputs, metabolic inputs exceed outputs, or a breakdown occurs in the processing system.
A typical example of a metabolic disease arising when metabolic output exceeds input is ketosis.
Ketosis occurs in ruminant animals that have a high demand for glucose, such as dairy cows in early
lactation, where glucose is required for lactose synthesis in the udder, and ewes in late pregnancy,
where glucose is required as an energy source for the developing fetus. In both cases, oxaloacetic
acid is used preferentially for glucose synthesis via gluconeogenesis and is therefore not available to
combine with acetyl-CoA in the tricarboxylic acid cycle. The problem is often exacerbated because
animals are in negative energy balance and therefore mobilising body fat as a source of energy. The
acetyl-CoA arising from body fat mobilisation cannot be utilised efficiently owing to a lack of oxaloacetic acid and is therefore converted to acetoacetate, D-␤-hydroxybutyrate and acetone (ketone
bodies), which accumulate in the bloodstream and become toxic.
An example of a metabolic disease arising when metabolic input exceeds output is NH3 toxicity.
Amino acids and nitrogen in the bloodstream in excess of requirements are transported to the liver,
where they are deaminated. Under the influence of glutamate dehydrogenase, the NH4 is combined
with ␣-ketogluterate to produce glutarate. If ruminant animals are fed on high-protein diets, where
rumen-degradable nitrogen (RDN) is provided in excess of the requirements for microbial protein
synthesis or fermentable energy (FME) is deficient, then excess nitrogen may be absorbed across the
rumen wall into the bloodstream, taken to the liver, and converted to glutamate before excretion
via the urea cycle. However, the conversion of NH4 to glutarate depletes the available pool of
␣-ketogluterate and impairs the activity of the tricarboxylic acid cycle, resulting in reduced ATP
formation and ammonia toxicity.
The metabolic role of many minerals and vitamins is as prosthetic groups or coenzymes in different enzyme systems. Consequently, mineral and vitamin deficiencies can cause a breakdown of the
processing system and precipitate metabolic disease. For example, methylmalonyl-CoA isomerase
(see p. 203) is an important vitamin B12-dependent enzyme in the gluconeogenic pathway. A deficiency of vitamin B12 (or cobalt) may reduce enzyme activity, decrease the efficiency of glucose synthesis and predispose the animal to ketosis. Similarly, ceruloplasmin is a copper-dependent enzyme
responsible for releasing iron from cells into blood plasma. A copper deficiency may reduce ceruloplasmin activity, decrease the efficiency of iron utilisation for haemoglobin synthesis and predispose
the animal to anaemia.
231
Chapter 9 Metabolism
Estimates of the energetic efficiency of the various synthetic processes presented,
although interesting, should not be given too much weight since their validity depends on a number of factors, including assumptions of complete coupling under
ideal conditions, the availability of different substrates, and uncertainly with regard
to ATP yield from the oxidation of NADH and FADH via oxidative phosphorylation.
9.5
CONTROL OF METABOLISM
An organism must adjust to a constantly changing internal and external environment.
In order to achieve this, efficient intercellular communication has to be established.
Such communication is vested in two distinct but integrated systems. The first is the
nervous system with a fixed physical framework; the second is the endocrine system
utilising hormones that are transported from the secreting glands to various target tissues.The integration of the two systems is well illustrated by two examples: vasopressin
is synthesised in the hypothalamus and is transported along nerve fibres to the pituitary
gland, from which it is secreted; on the other hand, certain hormones such as insulin
and adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH) have receptor sites within the brain. Hormones do not initiate processes but exert their control by regulating existing processes.
This they do by influencing the rates of synthesis and breakdown of enzymes and by affecting the efficiency of enzyme catalysis and the permeability of cell membranes.
At the cellular level, chemical processes must take place at rates consistent with
the needs of the whole organism. This is achieved by control of enzyme activity,
which depends upon:
■
■
■
■
■
■
232
the amount of enzyme available, which is the result of enzyme synthesis and
breakdown;
the presence of the enzyme in an active or inactive (proenzyme) form. Action of
the enzyme then depends upon the presence of certain proteolytic agents, which
expose or create active sites on the proenzyme. The enzymes concerned in digestion and blood clotting are typical examples;
the compartmentalisation of specific processes within the cytoplasm or organelles
of the cell, brought about by the impermeability of membranes to the passage of
certain metabolites; for example, fat synthesis takes place in the cell cytoplasm,
whereas fat oxidation is limited to the mitochondria, and the futile cycling that
would take place were the two processes to occur in the same locus is obviated.
The impermeability may be overcome by shuttle systems that require cytoplasmic
and organelle forms of the same catalytic activity. This provides a measure of fine
control via the availability of substrate;
the presence of proteins that bind to enzymes and inhibit their activity, and of
substances that complex with, and render unavailable, metal ions essential for the
activity of specific enzymes;
the presence of proteins that alter the specificity of the enzyme; the role of
␣-lactalbumin in the case of galactosyl transferase is a good example – the level of
␣-lactalbumin is under hormonal control and therefore so is lactose synthesis;
the operation of feedback inhibition, probably the most common regulatory
mechanism operating in metabolism. In this case, the activity of an enzyme is inhibited by the presence of an end product of the reaction or pathway. In the synthesis of valine from pyruvate, for example, the first step is the formation of
Summary
acetolactate, catalysed by acetolactate synthetase.The activity of this enzyme and
the rate of valine formation are reduced by the presence of valine. A similar situation arises when accumulation of an end product affects the rate of a reaction or
pathway by a simple mass action effect. For example, the rate of glucose breakdown via the gylcolytic pathway is controlled by the reaction
1,3-diphosphoglycerate + ADP + Pi : 3-phosphoglycerate + ATP
When ATP is being consumed rapidly, its breakdown ensures a plentiful supply of
ADP and phosphoric acid; the reaction thus proceeds rapidly from left to right. If, on
the other hand,ATP is not being used, the supply of ADP and inorganic phosphate is
reduced and so is the speed of the reaction.
SUMMARY
1. Metabolism is the name given to the sequence or succession of chemical reactions
that take place in living organisms. It involves
both the synthesis (anabolism) and breakdown (catabolism) of complex compounds.
2. Exergonic (catabolic) reactions release energy
and endergonic (anabolic) reactions require
an input of energy. The two are linked by
mediating compounds, the most important
of which is adenosine triphosphate (ATP).
3. ATP is produced from a number of energy
substrates by either substrate-level or oxidative phosphorylation. Glucose is oxidised via
the glycolytic pathway and the tricarboxylic
cycle.
4. Glycogen is the main storage carbohydrate
in the animal’s body. It is first broken down
to give glucose, which is then oxidised as
described. Acetic, propionic and butryric
acids are metabolised in the tricarboxylic
acid cycle.
5. Fat is the primary energy store in the body.
Energy is released by lipolysis, followed by
␤-oxidation of the fatty acids. The glycerol
is changed to glucose before oxidation.
6. Amino acids may be used as sources of energy when in excess or when other forms of
energy are deficient. The process involves
excretion of the nitrogen as urea and is
relatively inefficient.
7. Protein synthesis requires activation of amino
acids, initiation of chain formation, chain
elongation and termination, all of which
have an energy cost.
8. Fatty acid synthesis occurs in the cell cytoplasm and produces palmitic acid. The addition of two-carbon units to preformed longand medium-chain fatty acids takes place at
the endoplasmic reticulum, as does desaturation. However, mammals are incapable of introducing double bonds beyond carbon atom
9 (see Chapter 3).
9. Lactose is synthesised from glucose and galactose in the mammary gland by a complex enzyme system that is ␣-lactalbumin-dependent.
10. Glucose is central in a large number of metabolic processes. In monogastric animals, it is
obtained by direct absorption from the small
intestine. In ruminant animals, this does not
take place and highly efficient gluconeogenic
and glucose-conserving mechanisms have
been developed.
11. On a whole-body basis, metabolism is controlled by an integrated system consisting of
a nervous system with a fixed physical structure and an endocrine system secreting hormones that travel to various target tissues. At
the cellular level, control is exerted by manipulation of the active enzyme supply and by
feedback inhibition.
233
Chapter 9 Metabolism
FURTHER READING
Berg M J, Tymoczko J I and Stryer L 2006 Biochemistry, 6th edn, New York,W H Freeman.
Devlin T M (ed.) 1997 Textbook of Biochemistry with Clinical Correlations, 4th edn, New
York, John Wiley & Sons.
Mathews C K and van Holde K E 1999 Biochemistry, 3rd edn, Redwood City, CA, Benjamin
Cummings Publishing Co.
Murray R K, Granner D K, Mayes P A and Rodwell V W 1993 Harper’s Biochemistry, 23rd edn,
Norwalk, CT Appleton and Lange.
234
PART 3
Quantifying the nutrient content of
foods: digestibility, energy and protein
values
Part 2 described how animals obtain and utilise nutrients from foods. This part is concerned
with quantifying the amounts of nutrients supplied.
Chapter 10 describes ways of quantifying the digestion of nutrients over the whole digestive
tract and for different sections using a range of digestibility techniques and then considers the
factors that affect digestibility.
Not all of the energy supplied by foods is available to the animal. There are losses associated
with both digestion and metabolism. Chapter 11 discusses these losses and the methods used
to measure the efficiency of energy use by animals.
As a consequence of their differing digestive systems and related metabolism, different
systems are used for expressing the energy value of foods according to the type of animal
concerned. Chapter 12 describes these systems and the methods used to predict the energy
value of foods.
Chapter 13 examines the protein value of foods and the measures used to quantify protein
supply to both monogastric and ruminant animals, which, again, differ as a consequence
of their digestive systems. Details are given of the current protein evaluation systems used
in the UK.
10
Evaluation of foods: digestibility
10.1
Measurement of digestibility
10.2
Validity of digestibility coefficients
10.3
Digestibility in different sections of the digestive tract
10.4
Factors affecting digestibility
10.5
Measurement of mineral availability
This chapter marks a change from qualitative to quantitative nutrition. The chapters
preceding it have shown which substances are required by animals, how they are
supplied from foods and the manner in which they are utilised. This chapter and those
following it are concerned with the assessment of (1) the quantities in which nutrients
are supplied by foods, and (2) the quantities in which they are required by different
classes of farm animal.
The potential value of a food to supply particular nutrients can be determined by
chemical analysis. However, the actual value of the food to the animal can be determined only after making allowances for the inevitable losses that occur during digestion, absorption and metabolism. The first and most important loss of nutrients is
represented by the proportion that is not absorbed but is excreted in the faeces.
The digestibility of a food is most accurately defined as the proportion that is not
excreted in the faeces and that is, therefore, assumed to be absorbed by the animal. It is
commonly expressed in terms of dry matter and as a coefficient or a percentage. For
example, if a cow ate 9 kg of hay containing 8 kg of dry matter and excreted 3 kg of dry
matter in its faeces, the digestibility of the hay dry matter would be:
8 - 3
= 0.625
8
or
8 - 3
* 100 = 62.5%
8
Digestibility coefficients can be calculated in the same way for each constituent of
the dry matter. Although the proportion of the food not excreted in the faeces is commonly assumed to be equal to that which is absorbed from the digestive tract, there are
objections to this assumption, which will be discussed later.
237
Chapter 10 Evaluation of foods: digestibility
10.1
MEASUREMENT OF DIGESTIBILITY
Digestibility trials
In a digestibility trial, the food under investigation is given to the animal in known
amounts and faecal output is measured. More than one animal (typically four) are
used, because animals, even of the same species, age and sex, differ slightly in their
digestive ability, and because replication allows more opportunity for the detection
of experimental error.
In trials with mammals, male or castrated animals are preferred to females because it is then easier to separate the faeces from the urine. The animals should be
docile and in good health. Small animals can be confined in metabolism cages, which
facilitate the separation of faeces and urine by an arrangement of sieves, but larger
animals such as cattle and sheep are fitted with harnesses and faeces-collection bags
made of rubber or a similar impervious material. For females a bladder catheter can
be used to separate the urine from the faeces.
For poultry, the determination of digestibility is complicated by the fact that faeces and urine are voided from a single orifice, the cloaca. The compounds present in
urine are mainly nitrogenous, and faeces and urine can be separated chemically if
the nitrogenous compounds of urine can be separated from those of faeces. The separation is based on the fact either that most urine nitrogen is in the form of uric acid,
or that most faecal nitrogen is present as true protein. It is also possible to alter the
fowl’s anatomy by surgery so that faeces and urine are voided separately.
If possible the food required for the trial should be mixed thoroughly beforehand to
ensure a uniform composition. Typically a digestibility trial consists of three periods,
each lasting for 7–10 days. During the adaptation period, animals are gradually adapted
to the experimental diet. Once adapted, animals are then maintained on the experimental diet for a preliminary period to ensure that they are fully accustomed to the experimental diet and to clear the digestive tract of previous food residues. Finally, during
the collection period, food intake and faecal output are recorded. A longer collection
period generally provides more accurate results. With simple-stomached animals the
faecal output resulting from a particular input of food can be identified by adding an indigestible coloured substance such as ferric oxide or carmine to the first and last meals
of the collection period; the beginning and the end of faecal collection are then delayed
until the dye appears in and disappears from the excreta.With ruminants this method is
not successful because the dyed meal mixes with others in the rumen; instead, an arbitrary time lag of 24–48 hours is normally allowed for the passage of food residues, i.e.
the measurement of faecal output begins 1–2 days after that of food intake, and continues for the same period after measurement of food intake has ended.
In all digestibility trials, and particularly those with ruminants, it is highly desirable that meals should be given at the same time each day and that the amounts of
food eaten should not vary from day to day.When intake is irregular there is the possibility, for example, that if the last meal of the experimental period is unusually
large, then the subsequent increase in faecal output may be delayed until after the
end of faecal collection. In this situation the output of faeces resulting from the
measured intake of food will be underestimated and digestibility overestimated.
The trial is completed by analysing samples of the food used and the faeces
collected. Box 10.1 provides an example of the calculation of nutrient digestibility
coefficients for hay fed to sheep.
238
Measurement of digestibility
BOX 10.1 Calculation of the nutrient digestibility coefficients of hay fed to sheep
A digestibility trial was carried out using three sheep to determine the digestibility of hay. During
the 10-day faecal collection period, feed intake and faecal output were recorded. Samples of hay
and faeces were analysed in the laboratory:
Dry matter
(DM)
1. Nutrient analysis (g/kg DM)
Hay
Faeces
2. Nutrient flux (kg/day)
Consumed
Excreted
Absorbed
3. Digestibility coefficients
4. Digestible nutrients (g/kg DM)
1.63
0.76
0.87
0.534
–
Organic
matter
Crude
protein
Ether
extract
919
870
93
110
15
15
1.50
0.66
0.84
0.560
515
0.151
0.084
0.067
0.444
41
0.024
0.011
0.013
0.541
8
Acid detergent
fibre
350
317
0.570
0.240
0.330
0.579
203
Notes
1. The average quantity of hay dry matter (DM) consumed was 1.63 kg/day and the average
quantity of DM excreted in the faeces was 0.76 kg/day. The chemical composition of the hay
and faeces are presented in Section 1.
2. From the quantities of DM consumed and excreted and the chemical composition of the hay and
faeces, the quantities of individual nutrients consumed, excreted and (by difference) absorbed
can be calculated (Section 2).
3. Digestibility coefficients for each nutrient can then be calculated by expressing the weight of each
nutrient absorbed as a proportion of the weight consumed, e.g. DM digestibility = 0.87/1.63 =
0.534 (Section 3).
4. Finally, the composition of the hay can be expressed in terms of digestible nutrients, e.g.
digestible organic matter = 919 ⫻ 0.560 = 515 g/kg DM (Section 4).
The general formula for the calculation of digestibility coefficients is:
nutrient consumed - nutrient in faeces
nutrient consumed
A measure that is often used to reflect the energy concentration of foods is the
concentration of digestible organic matter in the dry matter (DOMD). For the hay in
Box 10.1 this is 515 g/kg DM, or 51.5 per cent.This percentage figure is often referred
to as the D value.
In the example presented in Box 10.1 the food in question was forage and could be
offered to the animals as the only ration component. Concentrate foods and fat supplements, however, may cause digestive disturbances if given alone to ruminants, and
their digestibility is often determined by giving them in combination with forage of
known digestibility.Thus, the hay in the example in Box 10.1 could have been used in
a second trial in which the sheep also received 0.50 kg oats per day. If the dry matter
content of the oats was 900 g/kg, then daily dry matter intake would increase by
239
Chapter 10 Evaluation of foods: digestibility
0.45 kg. If faecal output increased from 0.76 kg to 0.91 kg per day, then the digestibility of the dry matter in oats would be calculated as follows:
0.45 - (0.91 - 0.76)
0.45
=
0.45 - 0.15
= 0.667
0.45
In this example, the hay is designated as the basal diet and the oats as the test
food. The general formula for calculating the digestibility of the test food is:
nutrient in test food - (nutrient in faeces - nutrient in faeces from basal diet)
nutrient in test food
Fat supplements are generally included in ruminant diets at relatively low levels.
The digestibility of a fat supplement can be determined by assuming that long-chain
fatty acids (LCFA) in a control diet and the basal ingredients of a diet containing the
fat supplement have the same digestibility coefficients. If the intake and LCFA composition of the fat supplement are known, then the LCFA intake from the fat supplement can be calculated. Similarly, if the digestibilities of the LCFA in the control diet
are known, then the LCFA output from the basal ingredients can be subtracted from
the total LCFA output of animals fed the supplemental fat to determine the output
of fatty acids derived from the supplemental fat. Fatty acid digestibility can then be
calculated as indicated above. This technique is particularly advantageous when the
LCFA composition of the basal ingredients and test fat are distinctly different, and it
has the advantage over other techniques involving total fat or gross energy as, relative to the basal diet, the proportion of LCFA added is generally a lot higher.
Calculating the digestibility of concentrate foods and fat supplements by difference
assumes that the test food has no effect on the digestibility of the basal diet ingredients.This is not always the case (see p. 248).
Indicator methods
In some circumstances the lack of suitable equipment or the particular nature of the
trial makes it impractical to measure either food intake or faecal output directly. For
instance, when animals are fed as a group or in a grazing situation, it may be impossible to measure the intake of each individual. However, digestibility can still be measured if the food contains some indicator substance that is known to be completely
indigestible. If the concentrations of this indicator substance in the food and in small
samples of the faeces of each animal are then determined, the ratio between these
concentrations can be used to calculate digestibility. For example, if the concentration
of the indicator increased from 10 g/kg DM in the food to 20 g/kg DM in the faeces,
this would mean that half of the dry matter had been digested and absorbed. In equation form this is presented as:
Dry matter digestibility =
indicator in faeces (g>kg DM) - indicator in food (g>kg DM)
Indicator in faeces (g>kg DM)
Internal or external indicators may be used. Internal indicators are natural constituents of the food such as lignin, acid-indigestible fibre or acid-insoluble ash (mainly
silica). More recently, the long-chain hydrocarbons (n-alkanes, C25–C35) found in the
waxy cuticle of leaves have been used as internal indicators, especially in grazing studies. External indicators are substances that are added to foods. Chromic oxide (Cr2O3)
240
Measurement of digestibility
is perhaps the most common external indicator as it is very insoluble and hence indigestible; moreover, chromium (Cr) is not present as a natural constituent of most
foods. In non-ruminant nutrition, titanium oxide (Ti2O3) is often used as an external
indicator.
External indicators such as chromic oxide may also be used to estimate faecal output rather than digestibility. In this application, the indicator is normally given for 10–
15 days in fixed amounts (e.g. administered in a gelatin capsule) and once its excretion
is assumed to have stabilised its concentration in faecal samples is determined. Faecal
dry matter output (kg/day) is then calculated as:
Indicator dose (g>day)>indicator in faeces (g>kg DM)
For example, if an animal is given 10 g of chromic oxide per day and the concentration of indicator in the faeces is 4 g/kg DM, then faeces output would be calculated
as 10/4 = 2.5 kg DM/day. If food intake is known, then dry matter digestibility could
be calculated as (dry matter intake - faecal DM output)/DM intake. Alternatively, if
DM digestibility is known, then dry matter intake could be calculated as faecal DM
output/DM digestibility. The n-alkane technique is very useful in this context. As
plants contain mainly odd-chain n-alkanes in their waxy cuticle, even-chain (C32)
n-alkanes can be used as an external indicator to determine faecal output. At the
same time, the odd-chain n-alkanes (C35) can be used to estimate diet digestibility.
Dry matter intake can then be estimated in group-fed or grazing animals.
Measuring the digestibility of herbage eaten by grazing animals presents a particular problem. In theory, internal indicators such as lignin can be used to estimate
herbage digestibility. However, in practice, this application of the indicator technique is complicated by the difficulty of obtaining representative samples of the
food (i.e. pasture herbage) consumed. Animals graze selectively, preferring young
plants to old, and preferring leaf to stem, and a sample of the sward picked by hand
or cut with a mower is therefore unlikely to be representative of that consumed by
the animal. One way of obtaining representative samples is to use an animal with
an oesophageal fistula (an opening from the lumen of the oesophagus to the skin
surface). When this is closed by a plug, food passes normally between mouth and
stomach; when the plug is temporarily removed, herbage consumed can be collected in a bag hung below the fistula. Samples of grazed herbage obtained in this
way can then be analysed, together with samples of faeces, for the indicator. The
n-alkane technique may also be useful in this context as there are large and characteristic differences in the n-alkane content of different plant species. By relating the
pattern of faecal n-alkane output to the n-alkane pattern in different plant species
or parts, the technique allows estimates of the diet composition of grazing animals
to be made.
Laboratory methods
Since digestibility trials are laborious and expensive to carry out, numerous attempts
have been made to determine the digestibility of foods by reproducing in the laboratory the reactions that take place in the alimentary tract of the animal. Digestion in
non-ruminants is not easily simulated in its entirety, but the digestibility of food protein may be determined from its susceptibility to attack in vitro by pepsin and hydrochloric acid. It is also possible to collect digestive tract secretions via cannulae
and to use them to digest foods in vitro.
241
Chapter 10 Evaluation of foods: digestibility
The digestibility of foods for ruminants can be measured quite accurately in the laboratory by treating them first with rumen liquor and then with pepsin. During the first
stage of this so-called two-stage in vitro method, a finely ground sample of the food is
incubated for 48 hours with buffered rumen liquor in a tube under anaerobic conditions. In the second stage, the bacteria are killed by acidifying with hydrochloric acid
to pH 2 and are then digested (together with some undigested food protein) by incubating them with pepsin for a further 48 hours. The insoluble residue is filtered off,
dried and ignited, and its organic matter subtracted from that present in the food to
provide an estimate of digestible organic matter. Digestibility determined in vitro is
generally slightly lower than that determined in vivo, and corrective equations are
required to relate one measure to the other; an example is illustrated in Fig. 10.1a.
Until it was superseded by other methods (see below), this technique was used routinely in the analysis of farm forages for advisory purposes and for determining the
digestibility of small samples such as those available to the plant breeder. A further
application is found in estimating the digestibility of grazed pasture herbage when this
is collected from an animal with an oesophageal fistula as described above.
Collection of rumen liquor used in the first stage of this laboratory procedure
presents a number of difficulties. Rumen liquor is collected from animals that have
been fitted with a rumen fistula that allows direct access into the rumen. Alternatively, it can be obtained by stomach tube. However, there are animal welfare implications associated with both of these techniques. In addition, rumen liquor may vary
in its fermentative characteristics and solids content depending on the diet of the animal from which it is collected. In an attempt to obtain more repeatable estimates of
0.85
All forages:
y = 1.02x1 – 0.0041
(RSD ± 0.016)
Digestibility in vivo (y)
0.80
Grasses:
y = 0.3472 + 0.56x2
(RSD ± 0.018)
0.75
Legumes:
y = 0.0694 + 0.87x2
0.70
Key:
(RSD ± 0.032)
Grasses
Italian ryegrass
Perennial ryegrass
Timothy
Legumes
Lucerne
Red clover
Sainfoin
0.65
0.60
0.55
0.55
0.60
0.65
0.70
0.75
0.80
(a) Rumen liquor and pepsin (x1)
0.50
0.55
Digestibility in vitro
0.60
0.65
0.70
0.75
0.80
(b) Pepsin and cellulase (x2)
0.85
0.90
Fig. 10.1 Laboratory methods for estimating the dry matter digestibility of forages. (a) Incubation in
rumen liquor followed by digestion with pepsin. (b) Digestion with pepsin followed by digestion with
cellulase.
Adapted from Terry R A et al. 1978 Journal of the British Grassland Society 22: 13.
242
Validity of digestibility coefficients
digestibility, rumen liquor is sometimes replaced by fungal cellulase preparations.
Figure 10.1b shows how incubation with pepsin followed by incubation with cellulase can be used to estimate the digestibility of forages for sheep. The relationship in
Fig. 10.1b, however, is less close than that found for the same forages between digestibility estimated by fermentation with rumen liquor and that determined in
sheep (Fig. 10.1a). More recently, the pepsin pretreatment has been replaced by neutral detergent fibre (NDF) to give neutral cellulase digestibility (NCD). Both the
pepsin–cellulase and NDF–cellulase methods require separate prediction equations
for different forages, and the residual standard deviations for these equations are
larger than those of the single equation used for the rumen liquor–pepsin method.
Rumen liquor is also used in another laboratory method for assessing the
digestibility of foods of ruminants. In this method, the quantity or proportion of food
digested is estimated indirectly from the volume of gas produced during fermentation. Gas production in the rumen, and hence in the test tube, is proportional to the
quantity of food fermented. About half of the gas is carbon dioxide arising from the
neutralisation of acids by buffers, and the rest is a mixture of methane and carbon
dioxide arising from the fermentation of carbohydrates and proteins to volatile fatty
acids. The advantage of this method over the laboratory methods discussed above is
that it can be readily applied to large numbers of food samples, especially if gas production is recorded automatically. One disadvantage is that gas production reflects
only one aspect of rumen fermentation, namely volatile fatty acid production, and
not the synthesis of microbial biomass. Thus, gas production measurements need to
be related to the quantity of nutrients remaining after fermentation.
Over the past decade there has been a change in the routine evaluation of foods for
advisory purposes (e.g. evaluating a silage sample from a farm) from methods requiring
rumen liquor obtained from fistulated animals to those requiring only laboratory apparatus. In Britain the preferred technique is near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy (see
Chapter 1), which has been shown to provide more accurate predictions of digestibility
than the two-stage in vitro method when applied to defined groups of feeds, such as
grass silages.This method is quickly executed and requires minimal sample preparation,
but the equipment required is expensive, and the chemical nature of the food constituents contributing to the near-infrared spectrum has yet to be established.
10.2
VALIDITY OF DIGESTIBILITY COEFFICIENTS
The assumption that the proportion of food digested and absorbed can be determined by subtracting the proportion excreted in faeces from that consumed is open
to question for two reasons. First, in ruminants, methane arising from the fermentation of carbohydrates is lost by eructation and is not absorbed. This loss leads to
overestimation of the digestible carbohydrate and digestible energy content of ruminant foods. Second, as discussed in Chapter 8, not all the faeces consist of undigested food residues. Part of the faecal material is contributed by enzymes and other
substances secreted into the gut and not reabsorbed, and by cellular material
abraded from the lining of the gut. Thus, if a pig, for example, is fed on a nitrogenfree diet, it continues to excrete nitrogen in the faeces. Since this nitrogen is derived
from the body and not directly from the food, it is known as metabolic faecal nitrogen, and the amount excreted is approximately proportional to the animal’s dry matter intake. Faeces also contain appreciable quantities of ether-extractable substances
243
Chapter 10 Evaluation of foods: digestibility
and minerals of metabolic origin. Since faeces serves as the route of excretion for
certain mineral elements, particularly calcium, some of the ash fraction in faeces is
contributed by mineral elements being secreted into the gut.
The excretion in faeces of substances not arising directly from the food leads to
underestimation of the proportion of the food actually absorbed by the animal. The
values obtained in digestibility trials are therefore called apparent digestibility coefficients to distinguish them from true digestibility coefficients. In practice, true digestibility coefficients are difficult to determine, because the fractions in faeces
attributable to the food and to the animal are in most cases indistinguishable from
one another. Apparent digestibility coefficients for the organic constituents of foods
are satisfactory for most purposes, and they do represent the net result of the ingestion of food. Apparent digestibility coefficients for some mineral elements, however,
may be quite meaningless (see p. 251).
10.3
DIGESTIBILITY IN DIFFERENT SECTIONS OF
THE DIGESTIVE TRACT
As explained in Chapter 8, nutrients may be absorbed from several parts of the
digestive tract. Even in non-ruminants, absorption occurs in two distinctly different
parts, the small and large intestines, and in ruminants volatile fatty acids are absorbed
from the rumen. A food constituent that is digested (and absorbed) at one site may
give rise to nutrients that differ quite considerably from those resulting from its digestion at another site. The nutritive value of a food to the animal depends not only on
the extent to which it is digested (i.e. its digestibility) but also on its site of digestion.
For example, a carbohydrate such as starch may be fermented in the rumen to volatile
fatty acids (and methane) or digested in the small intestine to glucose.
The digestibility of foods in successive sections of the digestive tract is most conveniently measured by the use of cannulated animals, prepared as described on
p. 159. An example of the use of cannulated animals to measure digestion in successive sections of the digestive tract of sheep is shown in Table 10.1. In this experiment
the sheep were cannulated at the duodenum and terminal ileum, thus allowing digestion to be partitioned between the stomach, the small intestine and the large intestine.The whole tract digestibility of the organic matter of the pelleted grass (0.78)
Table 10.1 Digestion of chopped or ground and pelleted dried grass in successive
portions of the alimentary tract of sheep
Food constituent:
Form of grass:
Proportion digested in
Stomach
Small intestine
Large intestine
Whole tract
Organic matter
Cellulose
Chopped
Pelleted
Chopped
Pelleted
0.52
0.27
0.04
0.83
0.45
0.20
0.13
0.78
0.80
0.02
0.05
0.87
0.56
-0.02
0.23
0.77
After Beever D E, Coelho da Silva J P, Prescott J H D and Armstrong D G 1972 British Journal of Nutrition
28: 347.
244
Digestibility in different sections of the digestive tract
was considerably lower than that of the chopped grass (0.83), microbial digestion of
the former being partially transferred from the stomach (i.e. the rumen) to the large
intestine. These differences were even more apparent for cellulose digestion, to
which the small intestine made a negligible contribution.
In Chapter 8 reference was made to the degradation of dietary protein in the
rumen. The nitrogen in food protein is either rumen-degradable (RDP) or rumenundegradable (UDP). The RDP fraction is either used for microbial protein synthesis
or absorbed across the rumen wall as ammonia, whereas the UDP fraction is resistant
to microbial attack and escapes degradation. The fate of dietary protein (or nitrogen)
in ruminants may be determined by collecting digesta from successive sections of the
digestive tract.Table 10.2 contrasts the digestion of nitrogen in two types of ryegrass.
Although the two grasses were similar in total nitrogen content (line 1), considerably
more nitrogen was ‘lost’ from the stomach, presumably by absorption of ammonia,
with the first grass (line 5). Conversely, with this grass, less nitrogen was absorbed in
the small intestine, expressed either as total nitrogen (line 6), protein (line 9) or
amino acids (line 10). The difference between total nitrogen and protein nitrogen
absorption in the small intestine (lines 6–9) reflects absorption of ammonia, and the
difference between protein and amino acid nitrogen absorbed in the small intestine
(lines 9 and 10) reflects the nucleic acid nitrogen of microbial protein. A further loss
of nitrogen, again presumably as ammonia, occurred in the large intestine (line 7).
The net outcome was that although the short-rotation ryegrass contained slightly less
nitrogen, of slightly lower overall digestibility, it provided the sheep with about 25 per
cent more in terms of absorbed amino acids than did the perennial ryegrass.With the
perennial ryegrass, of the nitrogen absorbed (32.0 g/day), less than half (14.6 g/day)
was in the form of amino acids.
Animals fitted with a rumen cannula can be used to estimate the proportion of a
food that is digested in the rumen, or rumen degradability. Typically, food samples
(3–5 g of dry matter) are placed in small bags made of permeable synthetic material
with a standard pore size (400–1600 µm2), which are then inserted into the rumen
Table 10.2 Protein digestion and absorption by sheep given 800 g organic matter
per day from one of two types of ryegrass
Perennial
ryegrass
Short-rotation
ryegrass
Total N (g/day)
(1) In feed
(2) At duodenum
(3) At terminal ileum
(4) In faeces
37.8
27.8
9.0
5.8
34.9
31.7
9.3
6.7
Total N absorbed (g/day)
(5) Stomach
(6) Small intestine
(7) Large intestine
(8) Overall
10.0
18.8
3.2
32.0
3.2
22.4
2.6
28.2
Protein N absorbed (g/day)a
Amino acid N absorbed (g/day)
(9) In small intestine
15.0
19.1
(10) In small intestine
14.6
18.3
a
Protein calculated as 6.25 (non-ammonia nitrogen).
Adapted from MacRae J C and Ulyatt M J 1974 Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge 82: 309.
245
Chapter 10 Evaluation of foods: digestibility
Proportion of barley disappearing (%)
90
70
Nitrogen
50
30
10
90
70
Dry matter
50
30
10
3
6
9
12
15
18
21
24
Incubation period (h)
Fig. 10.2 Disappearance of dry matter and nitrogen from samples of barley incubated
in artificial fibre bags in the rumen of sheep. Vertical lines indicate variation between
replicate samples, expressed as standard deviations.
Adapted from Mehrez A Z and Ørskov E R 1977 Journal of Agriculture Science, Cambridge
88: 645.
through the cannula and incubated for different periods of time. Bags are withdrawn
successively and then washed and dried to determine the amount of undigested material remaining. The disappearance of food at any time point can then be predicted
mathematically.This technique is known as the in sacco degradability technique and is
commonly used to measure protein supply to ruminants, which is described in more
detail in Chapter 13 (see also Fig. 10.2).
Another technique for studying the digestion of food in different sections of the
digestive tract involves the use of small bags similar to those employed to study
rumen degradability. For this so-called mobile nylon bag technique, small samples of
food (0.5–1.0 g) contained in bags are inserted into the gut via a cannula (e.g. into
the duodenum) and later recovered via a second cannula (e.g. at the ileo-caecal junction). The loss of nutrients between the two sites is taken to be the portion digested
and absorbed. This technique is commonly used in pigs; in this species, digestibility
to the end of the small intestine (sometimes called ‘ileal digestibility’) is reckoned to
give a more accurate measure of the nutritive value of a food than would digestibility in the whole tract. For example, suppose that with a food of high nutritive value
all the lysine was released from proteins and absorbed by the pig before the digesta
reached the end of the ileum (i.e. ileal lysine digestibility = 1.0). However, microorganisms in the caecum and colon are capable of synthesising additional lysine, which
would be incorporated into microbial protein and excreted in faeces. This would
reduce apparent lysine digestibility in the whole tract to less than 1.0. The mobile
246
Factors affecting digestibility
nylon bag technique is also used in horses, in which the bags may be introduced into
the stomach via a nasogastric tube.
As described in Chapter 8 some non-ruminant herbivores such as rabbits and
hares have evolved as hind-gut fermentors. In these animals, indigestible dietary material is fermented to volatile fatty acids in the caecum and colon. In addition, microbial protein and vitamins are synthesised. However, in a similar way to horses, a lack
of proteolytic enzymes and a transport system for vitamins in the hind gut prevents
absorption of these nutrients. As a consequence, hind-gut fermentors have evolved
different strategies to utilise nutrients synthesised by microbes. At certain times of
the day rabbits and hares produce caecotrophes (soft faeces) with a high protein,
vitamin and mineral content, whilst during the rest of the day they produce hard faeces, high in indigestible fibre. Caecotrophes typically represent one-third of total faecal
material.The caecotrophes are almost totally re-ingested and contribute 5–18 per cent
of dry matter and 15–30 per cent of nitrogen intake. Nutrient supply to rabbits, particularly protein and amino acids, is the sum of the contribution from the diet and
the contribution from reingested soft faeces. Apparent whole tract digestibility is determined as described previously. However, the contribution of soft faeces is normally assessed by placing a wooden collar (25 cm diameter) on the rabbit to prevent
caecotrophy, typically for a 24-hour period.The hard and soft faecal pellets can then
be separated and the contribution of caecotrophes to total dry matter and nutrient
intake can be determined.
10.4
FACTORS AFFECTING DIGESTIBILITY
Food composition
The digestibility of a food is closely related to its chemical composition, and a food
such as barley, which varies little in composition from one sample to another, will
show little variation in digestibility. Other foods, particularly fresh or conserved
herbages, are much less constant in composition and therefore vary more in digestibility. The fibre fraction of a food has the greatest influence on its digestibility,
and both the quantity and quality of the fibre are important.
Modern methods of food analysis attempt to distinguish between the cell wall and
cell content fractions. When forages are heated with neutral detergent solution, the
cell contents dissolve and the cell walls remain as a residue called neutral-detergent
fibre (NDF) consisting of total cell wall material.The cell wall fraction may be further
divided into acid-detergent fibre (ADF), representing cellulose and lignin, and aciddetergent lignin (ADL), representing lignin (see Chapter 1). The cell contents are almost completely digested (i.e. true digestibility = 1.0), although their apparent
digestibility will be approximately 10–15 per cent lower due to the excretion of metabolic products into the digestive tract (see p. 243). The digestibility of cell walls is
much more variable and depends on the degree of lignification, which is expressed as
ADL. But cell wall digestibility also depends on the structure of plant tissues. For
example, tropical grasses are generally less digestible than their temperate counterparts because their leaves contain more vascular bundles, and hence more lignin, and
because they have dense masses of cells that resist invasion by microorganisms.
The digestibility of foods may be reduced by nutrient deficiencies or excesses,
particularly in ruminants. For example, a deficiency of rumen-degradable nitrogen or
247
Chapter 10 Evaluation of foods: digestibility
sulphur may restrict microbial protein synthesis and thus reduce fibre digestibility.
An excess of dietary lipid will also inhibit the activity of rumen microorganisms.The
high silica content of some foods, particularly rice straw, reduces their digestibility.
In foods for non-ruminants, anti-nutritional constituents that bind to proteins and
amino acids, such as tannins and saponins, may reduce their digestibility.
Ration composition
The digestibility of a food is influenced not only by its own composition but also by
the composition of other foods consumed with it. These associative effects may be
positive or negative, although negative associative effects are perhaps the most common. A positive associative effect occurs when the digestibility of one ration component is enhanced by feeding it in combination with another. For example, the
digestibility of poor-quality forage such as straw may be enhanced by feeding it in
combination with a protein supplement. In this example, the provision of protein may
enhance the activity of the rumen microorganisms, which are then better able to digest the straw.A negative associative effect occurs when the digestibility of one ration
component is reduced by feeding it in combination with another. For example, the
supplementation of forage with a readily available source of carbohydrate such as
starch may reduce the digestibility of the forage. In these circumstances, rapid fermentation of starch to volatile fatty acids depresses the rumen pH to 6 or less. The
low pH inhibits the activity of cellulolytic microorganisms and fibre digestibility is
reduced. In addition to having an effect on cellulolysis through reducing rumen pH
(‘pH effect’), starch may also have a more direct effect on cellulolysis. Some rumen
microorganisms are capable of fermenting both starch and cellulose and may, given
the choice, ferment starch in preference to cellulose (‘carbohydrate effect’). Hence,
the reduction in cellulolysis observed on high-starch diets may be only partially alleviated by the addition of buffering agents such as sodium bicarbonate.
The existence of associative effects presents a serious problem for ration formulation and the determination of digestibility by difference (see p. 240). For example, if
forage and concentrate foods have digestibility coefficients of 0.6 and 0.8, respectively, it may be assumed that the overall digestibility of a mixed ration containing
equal proportions of forage and concentrate would be 0.7. However, due to associative effects, this is unlikely to be the case, as digestibility of the forage is likely to be
reduced by feeding it in combination with a concentrate.Although associative effects
are known to exist, their effect depends on the relative proportions of forage and
concentrate in the ration, the chemical composition of the ration components and
the level of feeding. Consequently, they are very difficult to predict and therefore
cannot be accounted for in feeding systems.
Food processing
Foods are often processed before feeding in order to increase and optimise their digestibility. The commonest treatments applied are normally chopping, chaffing,
crushing and grinding. Typically, cereal grains should be crushed for cattle and
ground for pigs, otherwise they may pass through the digestive tract intact. The
grinding of cereal grains fed to cattle may enhance their rate of fermentation to such
an extent that it predisposes the animal to rumen acidosis. Sheep on the other hand
are able to effectively chew whole grain during rumination, thereby reducing the
248
Factors affecting digestibility
need for mechanical processing. However, this appears to be dependent on the dynamics of regurgitation, which are influenced by both the type of cereal grain and
the nature of the basal diet. Oats appears to be more efficiently-regurgitated than
barley, and regurgitation appears to be more difficult when cereal grains are fed in
combination with forages such as silage, suggesting that grain shape and entrapment
in interwoven particles may be important factors. Consequently, if fed with silage,
cereal grains should be crushed (see Chapter 22).
Forages are subjected to several processes of comminution. The mildest process,
chaffing, has little direct effect on their digestibility but may reduce it indirectly by
preventing selection of the more digestible components by animals. The wafering of
forages, a process involving their compression into round or square section blocks,
also has little effect on their digestibility. The most severe process, fine grinding
(often followed by pelleting), has a marked effect on the manner in which forages are
digested and hence on their digestibility. Because of their reduced particle size,
ground forages pass through the rumen faster than long or chopped material. Consequently, the fibrous components may be less completely fermented (see Table 10.1).
The grinding of forages may reduce the digestibility of the fibre fraction by as much
as 20 per cent and of the dry matter as a whole by 5–15 per cent. This reduction is
often greatest for forages with an intrinsically low digestibility, and it may be exaggerated at high feeding levels, because although grinding increases the rate of passage
and reduces digestibility, it also increases food intake (see Chapter 17).
Forages such as the cereal straws, in which the cellulose is mixed or bound with a
high proportion of lignin, may be treated chemically to separate the two components.The treatment processes and their effects are described in detail in Chapter 20.
The chemicals used are mainly alkalis (sodium and ammonium hydroxides), and
they improve the dry matter digestibility of cereal straws quite dramatically, from
0.4 to 0.5–0.7.
Foods are sometimes subjected to heat treatment to improve their digestibility.
Traditionally, potatoes are boiled before feeding to pigs, but heat may be applied to
other foods as steam or by microwave irradiation (a process known as micronisation). When applied to cereals, such processes cause relatively small increases in digestibility, although sorghum appears to be more responsive than other grains. Heat
treatments are most effective when used for the specific purpose of inactivating digestive enzyme inhibitors that are present in some feeds. The best examples of these
inhibitors are found in protein concentrates (see Chapter 23). Potatoes, and root
crops such as swedes (Brassica napus), may also contain protease inhibitors that are
inactivated by heat treatment. In pigs, the benefit of such treatment is not so much
the improvement in digestibility as the transfer of protein digestion from fermentation in the caecum to normal enzyme digestion in the small intestine.
Enzyme supplementation of foods
In non-ruminants, the digestive system is ill-equipped to deal with some foods because the animals lack appropriate enzyme systems. Enzyme preparations (usually
of fungal origin) may be added to foods to increase nutrient availability. The most
consistently successful enzyme additive has been the use of ␤-glucanase in poultry
diets containing barley. ␤-Glucans, which constitute a large part of the endosperm
cell wall of cereals (see Chapter 2), are largely indigestible. If they escape digestion,
they appear in the excreta as gels that cause undesirable ‘sticky droppings’. ␤-Glucans
249
Chapter 10 Evaluation of foods: digestibility
also protect other dietary components from digestion. Consequently, their enzymatic destruction causes a general improvement in digestibility. Further examples of
the use of enzyme supplementation are described in Chapter 24.
Animal factors
Digestibility is more a property of the food rather than of the animal consuming it.
However, this is not to say that a food given to different animals will be digested to
the same extent. The most important animal factor affecting digestibility is animal
species. Foods that are low in fibre are equally well digested by both ruminants and
non-ruminants, but foods high in fibre are better digested by ruminants.Apparent digestibility coefficients for protein are frequently higher for pigs because their excretion of metabolic faecal nitrogen is smaller than that of ruminants. Differences in
digestive ability between sheep and cattle tend to be small and of little significance,
and hence digestibility values are often determined in sheep and applied to cattle.
However, highly digestible foods such as cereal grains tend to be better digested in
sheep, and poorly digestible foods such as low-quality roughages tend to be better
digested by cattle. Digestibility values determined in sheep are not always applicable
to cattle; for example, the digestibility of the grain component in whole-crop cereal
silages (see Chapter 19) is lower in cattle than in sheep because whole grains pass
through the digestive tract intact.
Level of feeding
An increase in the quantity of food consumed by an animal generally causes an
increase in the rate of passage of digesta. The food is then exposed to the action of
digestive enzymes for a shorter period of time and digestibility is reduced.
In animals, level of feeding is often expressed in multiples of the quantity of food
required for maintenance (i.e. the quantity required to maintain equilibrium; see
Chapter 14). Maintenance is defined as unity. In ruminant feeding systems, the level
of feeding for growing and fattening animals can be 2.0–3.0 times their maintenance
requirement and for lactating animals 3.0–5.0 times their maintenance requirement.
For high-fibre diets such as hay, silage and grazed grass, increasing the level of feeding by 1 unit (e.g. from maintenance to twice maintenance) reduces the digestibility
of the diet by only a small proportion (0.01–0.02). For mixed diets and those containing smaller particles, the reduction in digestibility per unit increase in feeding
level is greater (0.02–0.03). For a typical dairy cow diet, the dry matter digestibility
might fall from 0.75 at a maintenance level of feeding to 0.70 at three times maintenance. Falls of this magnitude may be due to negative associative effects, which become more pronounced at higher levels of feeding. The greatest reductions in
digestibility with increasing feeding level occur with ground and pelleted forages and
some fibrous by-products (0.05 per unit change in level), the reason being that the
rate of passage of foods with a small particle size is increased to a greater extent than
is possible with long forages, which generally require more extensive fermentation in
the rumen before further passage.
In non-ruminants, level of feeding rises to 2.0–3.0 times maintenance in poultry,
3.0–4.0 times maintenance in growing pigs and 4.0–6.0 times maintenance in lactating
sows, but there is little evidence for an effect of level of feeding on the digestibility of
conventional (i.e. low-fibre) diets.
250
Measurement of mineral availability
10.5
MEASUREMENT OF MINERAL AVAILABILITY
In many cases it is inappropriate to determine apparent digestibility coefficients for
mineral elements because endogenous excretion, arising from secretions into the digestive tract, can be high, particularly for minerals such as calcium, phosphorus,
magnesium and iron. For example, in ruminants, the quantity of phosphorus secreted into the gut via saliva is generally greater than the quantity in foods. In
addition, the digestive tract is a major route of excretion for many mineral elements
that have been absorbed in excess of requirements. For example, excess copper may
be excreted into the digestive tract in bile. For mineral elements, the measure of importance is true digestibility or ‘availability’.To measure the availability of a mineral
element one must distinguish between the proportion of mineral element in the
faeces that is of dietary origin and that which has been voided into the digestive tract
from the animal’s tissues. This distinction may be made by labelling the element
within the body, and hence the proportion voided into the digestive tract, with a
radioisotope.
Mineral elements in digesta exist in one of three forms: as metallic ions in solution, as constituents of metallo-organic complexes in solution, and as constituents of
insoluble substances. Those present in the first form are readily absorbed and those
in the third form are not absorbed at all. The metallo-organic complexes, some of
which are chelates (see p. 107), show variable availability. Some mineral elements
may be converted from one form to another, and so broadly speaking the availability of an element depends on the form in which it occurs in the food and on the extent to which conditions in the gut favour conversion from one form to another.
Thus, the availability of sodium and potassium, which occur in digesta almost entirely as ions, is close to 1.0. At the other extreme, the availability of copper, which
occurs almost entirely as soluble or insoluble complexes, is generally less than 0.1.To
take a further example, phosphorus is present in many foods as a constituent of
phytic acid (see p. 115), and its availability depends on the presence of phytases, of
microbial or animal origin, in the digestive tract. A potent factor controlling the
interconversion of soluble and insoluble forms of mineral elements is the pH of the
digesta. In addition, there may be specific agents that bind mineral elements and
thus prevent their absorption. For example, calcium may be precipitated by oxalates
and copper by sulphides.
The availability of mineral elements is commonly high in young animals fed on
milk and milk products but declines as the diet changes to solid foods. An additional
complication is that the absorption, and hence apparent availability, of some mineral
elements is under homeostatic control (determined by the animal’s need for them).
Iron absorption, discussed in Chapter 8, is the clearest example of this effect, but in
ruminants the efficiency of calcium absorption also appears to be dependent on the
animal’s requirements.
Whilst no attempt is made here or in Chapter 8 to provide a complete list of factors affecting the availability of mineral elements, those mentioned serve to illustrate
why availability coefficients are not included in tables of food composition. The
availability of a mineral in a particular food depends so much on other constituents
of the diet and the type of animal that average availability coefficients would be of
little significance.
251
Chapter 10 Evaluation of foods: digestibility
SUMMARY
1. The nutrient digestibility coefficients for a
food (D) can be calculated from the weights of
nutrient consumed (I) and excreted in faeces
(F) by the formula (I ⫺ F)/I.
2. In a typical digestibility trial, the food under investigation is fed to animals for 21–30 days, with
faeces being collected for the last 7–10 days.
3. If food intake and/or faeces output cannot be
measured quantitatively, digestibility may be
estimated indirectly from the relative concentrations of an indigestible substance in the
food and faeces known as an indicator.
4. The digestibility of foods may be estimated in
the laboratory (in vitro) by incubating them in
rumen liquor or various chemical and enzymatic techniques. Near-infrared reflectance
spectroscopy (NIRS) is now used routinely to
estimate the digestibility of foods for farm
advisory work.
5. For most nutrients a proportion of each nutrient excreted in faeces is derived from the animal’s body and not from the food. The
measurement of apparent digestibility does
not take this into account and therefore
underestimates true digestibility.
6. The insertion of cannulae into different parts
of the animal’s digestive allows digesta to be
sampled from each part and digestibility to be
calculated for different sections. For example,
rumen degradability can be estimated by inserting small samples of food in synthetic
nylon bags into the rumen through a rumen
cannula (in sacco).
7. The digestibility of a food in an animal depends on its chemical composition, the composition of foods fed with it and the way in
which it has been processed, together with its
level of feeding and any additional enzyme
supplementation or chemical treatment.
8. The digestibility of mineral elements (mineral
availability) is affected by secretion and excretion of minerals into the digestive tract, the
form of the mineral element, interactions with
other dietary components and the physiological state of the animal.
QUESTIONS
10.1 A pig was given 2.0 kg/day DM of a food containing 150 g/kg DM crude protein and excreted 0.4 kg/day DM of faeces containing 175 g/kg DM protein.
Calculate both the DM and the crude protein digestibility and the digestible
crude protein (DCP) content of the food.
10.2 As a check on the measurement of digestibility in Question 1, the food contained 10.0 g/kg DM of chromic oxide as an indicator and the faeces contained
50.0 g/kg DM chromic oxide. Did the measured DM digestibility agree with
that estimated using the indicator?
10.3 Of the 2.0 kg/day DM given to the pig in Question 1, 0.3 kg/day DM came
from soya bean meal, containing 450 g/kg DM crude protein, for which the
DM and crude protein digestibility coefficients were known to be 0.75 and
0.85, respectively. The rest of the ration was a cereal. What was the DM and
crude protein digestibility of the cereal?
252
Further reading
FURTHER READING
Ammerman C B, Baker D H and Lewis A J (eds) 1995 Bioavailability of Nutrients for
Animals: Amino Acids, Minerals and Vitamins, San Diego, CA, Academic Press.
British Society of Animal Science 1997 In Vitro Techniques for Measuring Nutrient Supply to
Ruminants, occasional publication, no. 22, Edinburgh, British Society of Animal Science.
Givens D I and Deaville E R 1999 The current and future role of near infrared reflectance
spectroscopy in animal nutrition: a review. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 50:
1131–45.
Mayes R W and Dove H 2000 Measurement of dietary nutrient intake in free-ranging
mammalian herbivores. Nutrition Research Reviews 13: 107–38.
Nutrition Society 1977 Methods for evaluating feeds for large farm animals. Proceedings of
the Nutrition Society 36: 169–225.
Schneider B H and Flatt W P 1975 The Evaluation of Feeds through Digestibility Experiments,
Athens, GA, University of Georgia Press.
Van Soest P J 1994 Nutritional Ecology of Ruminants, 2nd edn, Corvallis, OR, O and B
Books.
Wheeler J L and Mochrie R D (eds) 1981 Forage Evaluation: Concepts and Techniques,
Melbourne, CSIRO and Lexington, KY, American Forage and Grassland Council.
253
11
Evaluation of foods: energy
content of foods and energy
partition within the animal
11.1
Demand for energy
11.2
Supply of energy
11.3
Animal calorimetry: methods of measuring heat production and energy
retention
11.4
Utilisation of metabolisable energy
The major organic components present in food are required by animals as raw materials for the synthesis of body tissues and animal products such as milk and eggs. They
are also needed as sources of energy to support work done by the animal. A unifying
feature of these diverse functions is that they all involve a transfer of energy, which
applies equally when chemical energy is converted into mechanical or heat energy, as
when nutrients are oxidised, and when chemical energy is converted from one form to
another, for example when body fat is synthesised from dietary carbohydrate. The
ability of a food to supply energy is therefore of great importance in determining its
nutritive value. The purpose of this chapter and the next is to discuss factors affecting
the energy content of foods, the partition of food energy within the animal, the
measurement of energy metabolism, and the different methods used to express
energy supply.
11.1
DEMAND FOR ENERGY
Before discussing the factors that affect energy supply from foods, it might be useful
to briefly explain the factors affecting energy demand, although these factors will be
discussed in more detail in Chapters 14, 15 and 16. An animal requires energy for
both maintenance and production. The energy requirement for maintenance represents the energy required for the vital body processes that are essential for life, for
example the work associated with essential muscular activity (beating of the heart),
the work associated with active transport (movement of dissolved substances against
the concentration gradient), and the energy associated with the synthesis of essential
body constituents such as enzymes and hormones. An animal deprived of food continues to require energy for these processes, otherwise it will die. In a starved animal, the energy required for vital body processes is obtained from the catabolism of
body reserves, initially glycogen, but then body fat and protein. In a fed animal, the
254
Supply of energy
primary demand for energy is to meet this maintenance requirement and to prevent
the catabolism of body tissues.
When the energy in food is used for maintenance, the animal does no work on its
surroundings and all the energy used is converted to heat, which, although useful for
maintaining body temperature, is expended from the animal’s body. In a fasting animal, the amount of heat produced is equal to the energy derived from tissue catabolism, which, when measured under specific conditions, is known as the animal’s
basal metabolic rate or fasting metabolism. The way in which estimates of basal
metabolism are used to assess the maintenance energy requirement of animals is
explained in Chapter 14.
Energy supplied by food in excess of the maintenance requirement is used for
production. In young growing animals, energy is stored in new tissues primarily as
protein. However, as animals mature, an increasing proportion is stored as fat. In
pregnant and lactating animals, energy is stored in the products of conception (foetus
and placenta) and in milk constituents, respectively. Other forms of production include the energy required for activity or exercise and the energy required for the
synthesis of wool or eggs. No process, not even maintenance, can be said to have absolute priority for food energy; for example a young animal receiving adequate protein but insufficient energy for maintenance may still continue to deposit body
protein, whilst breaking down body fat. Similarly, wool growth continues in animals
at sub-maintenance energy intakes and even in fasted animals.
11.2
SUPPLY OF ENERGY
Gross energy (GE)
Energy is stored in the chemical components of food as chemical energy.The amount
of chemical energy in a food is measured by converting it to heat and determining
the heat production.This is carried out by oxidising the food by burning.The amount
of heat arising from the complete oxidation of a unit weight of food is known as its
gross energy (GE) value or heat of combustion (see Box 11.1).
BOX 11.1 Measurement of gross energy
Gross energy is measured in an apparatus called a bomb calorimeter, which in its simplest form is a
strong steel vessel (bomb) resting in an insulated bucket of water. The food sample is pelleted and
placed in the bomb, which is then pressurised to 25 atmospheres with oxygen. The initial temperature of the water in the bucket is recorded before the sample is electrically ignited.The food sample
burns vigorously in an atmosphere of oxygen, and the heat produced during oxidation is dissipated
through the wall of the bomb, causing the temperature of the water in the bucket to rise.When equilibrium is reached, the final temperature is recorded. The quantity of heat produced is then calculated from the weight of the food sample oxidised, the weight of water, the temperature rise in the
water, and the specific heat capacities of the water and bomb. Bomb calorimetry is used to measure
the gross energy content of whole foods and their components and the energy content of animal tissues and excretory products.
255
Chapter 11 Evaluation of foods: energy content of foods and energy partition within the animal
Food
constituents
Glucose 15.6
Starch 17.7
Cellulose 17.5
Casein 24.5
Butterfat 38.5
Fat (from oilseeds) 39.0
Fermentation
products
Acetic acid 14.6
Propionic acid 20.8
Volatile fatty acids
Butyric acid 24.9
Lactic acid 15.2
Methane 55.0
Animal tissues
(ash-free)
Muscle 23.6
Foods
Maize grain 18.5
Fat 39.3
Oat grain 19.6
Oat straw 18.5
Linseed-oil meal 21.4
Grass hay 18.9
Milk (400 g fat/kg) 24.9
Fig. 11.1 Some typical gross energy values (MJ/kg DM).
Some typical GE values for various foods are presented in Fig. 11.1. The primary
determinant of the GE content of organic compounds is their degree of oxidation, as
expressed as the ratio of carbon plus hydrogen to oxygen. All carbohydrates have
similar ratios and therefore have approximately the same GE content (approximately
17.5 MJ/kg DM). However, triglyceride fats typically have a higher ratio (contain
less oxygen) and therefore have a higher GE value (39.0 MJ/kg DM). Individual fatty
acids vary in their GE content depending on their carbon chain length and degree of
saturation, with those with shorter chains (volatile fatty acids) and a greater number
of double bonds having a lower energy content. Proteins have a higher GE content
than carbohydrates because they contain the additional oxidisable elements nitrogen
and sulphur. Methane has a very high GE content because it consists entirely of carbon and hydrogen.
In spite of the differences in GE content between different food components, the
fact that carbohydrates are the predominate component in the food of most farm
animals means that in reality GE values vary very little. Only foods rich in fat such
as full-fat soya bean meal, which contains 222 g/kg DM ether extract, have significantly higher values, and those rich in ash, which has no nutritional value, have
significantly lower values. Most common foods have a GE content of approximately
18.4 MJ/kg DM.
256
Supply of energy
Gross energy (= heat of combustion)
Faeces energy
Urine
energy
Digestible energy (= energy of digested food)
Methane
energy
Metabolisable energy
Heat increment
Net energy
Used for
maintenance
(energy retention
Used for
or balance)
production
Total heat production
of animal
Fig. 11.2 The partition of food energy in animals. Losses of energy are shown as
the boxed items on the left.
Not all of the GE in foods is available for use by the animal. Some is lost from the
animal as various solid, liquid or gaseous excretory products, and some is lost as
heat.These sources of energy loss are illustrated in Fig. 11.2.The subtraction of these
energy losses from a food’s GE content produces further descriptive measures of
food energy supply; for example, subtracting the GE lost in faeces from the GE in
food gives a measure of digestible energy. This and other measures of energy supply
will now be discussed further.
Digestible energy (DE)
Digestible energy represents energy absorbed by the animal. Apparent digestible energy is calculated as the GE provided by a unit of food minus the GE content of the
faeces resulting from the consumption of that unit of food. In the example digestibility trial presented in Box 10.1 in Chapter 10, the sheep consumed 1.63 kg hay and
excreted 0.76 kg faecal DM. If we assume that the GE content of the hay and the
faeces, determined by bomb calorimetry, were 18.0 MJ/kg DM and 18.7 MJ/kg DM,
respectively, then the total GE intake would be 29.3 MJ/day and the total GE output
would be 14.2 MJ/day. The apparent GE digestibility and digestible energy content
of the hay would be calculated as follows:
29.3 - 14.2
29.3
= 0.515
DE = 18.0 * 0.515
= 9.3 MJ/kg DM
GE digestibility =
As faecal energy loss represents by far the most important and variable loss of energy from animal foods, DE is a far better measure of the energy available to support
animal production than GE. Digestible energy is often used as the measure of energy
supply for pigs and horses, where additional energy losses in urine and methane are
relatively small and consistent.
257
Chapter 11 Evaluation of foods: energy content of foods and energy partition within the animal
Metabolisable energy (ME)
In addition to energy lost in faeces, energy is also lost as energy-containing compounds in urine, and as combustible gases such as methane produced as a consequence of microbial fermentation in either the rumen or hind gut. Metabolisable
energy represents energy that is available for use by the animal and is calculated as
DE minus energy lost in urine and combustible gases (see Box 11.2).The energy lost
in urine is present as nitrogen-containing compounds such as urea, hippuric acid,
creatinine and allantoin, and in non-nitrogenous compounds such as glucuronates
and citric acid.
The combustible gases produced in the rumen and hind gut consist almost entirely of methane (CH4). Methane production is closely related to food intake, and
at a maintenance level of nutrition approximately 7–9 per cent of the gross energy
of the food (11–13 per cent of the digestible energy) is lost as methane. At higher
levels of feeding, the proportion falls to 6–7 per cent of gross energy, the reduction
being most marked for highly digestible foods. With previously fermented foods,
such as brewer’s grain, methane production is low (3 per cent of gross energy).
When methane production cannot be easily measured directly, it can be estimated
as 8 per cent of gross energy intake. Another approximation allows the ME value
of ruminant foods to be calculated from their DE value by multiplying by 0.81. This
implies that, on average, about 19 per cent of the energy apparently digested is excreted
in the urine and as methane.
For poultry, ME is measured more easily than DE, because the faeces and urine
are voided together.A rapid standardised method has been developed for determining
BOX 11.2 Measurement of metabolisable energy
The ME value of a food is determined in a feeding trial similar to a digestibility trial, but in which
urine and methane are collected as well as faeces. Metabolism cages for sheep and pigs usually incorporate a device for collecting urine. With cattle, urine is collected in rubber urinals attached
below the abdomen for males and over the vulva for females, and is piped by gravity or suction to
a collection vessel.An alternative method of collecting urine from females, which is commonly used
in pigs, is to insert a rubber catheter into the vagina.
When methane production is measured to estimate unproductive energy losses, the animal is
usually kept in an airtight container known as a respiration chamber (see p. 267). More recently, the
significance of methane production from ruminants in relation to global warming has stimulated the
development of an alternative technique that allows methane to be measured from individual animals, whether confined or not. In this technique, a calibrated permeation tube containing sulphur
hexafluoride (SF6) is inserted into the rumen and releases SF6 through a permeable membrane at a
controlled rate. After a 5-day adaptation period, breath samples are collected from near the nose of
each animal using capillary tubing over a 24-hour period into pre-evacuated canisters. The concentrations of SF6 and CH4 are measured by gas chromatography and the methane emission rate, corrected for background levels, is calculated as:
QCH4 = QSF6 * [CH4]>[SF6]
where [CH4] and [SF6] are measured concentrations in excess of background and QSF6 is the rate
of SF6 release from the permeation tube.
258
Supply of energy
the ME value of poultry foods. Cockerels are fasted (or fed a small quantity of glucose solution) for 48 hours until their digestive tract is empty, and then force-fed a
single meal (30–40 g) of the food under investigation using a stainless-steel funnel
and plunger inserted carefully down the oesophagus into the crop. Excreta are then
collected until all the residues arising from the single meal have been voided. At the
same time the small quantities of excreta voided by fasted (or glucose-fed) birds are
collected, as a measure of endogenous losses.The energy derived from these endogenous losses is then subtracted from the energy derived from the excreta of the fed
birds, and so the estimate of ME obtained is a true rather than apparent value (see
p. 243).This is known as true metabolisable energy (TME) and is not directly comparable with measures of ME obtained using other techniques.
Factors affecting the metabolisable energy values of foods
Table 11.1 shows the ME values of a number of foods. It is clear that, of the energy
losses so far considered, faecal losses are by far the most important. Even for highly
digestibility foods such as barley, twice as much energy is lost in the faeces as in the
urine and methane. The main factors affecting the ME value of a food are therefore
those that influence its digestibility.These have been discussed earlier (see Chapter 10);
the emphasis here is on urine and methane losses.
The ME value of a food will vary, depending on the species of animal to which
it is given or, more specifically, on the type of digestion to which it will be subjected. Fermentative digestion, in the rumen or further along the gut, incurs losses
of energy as methane. A lesser effect of the intervention of microorganisms in
Table 11.1 Metabolisable energy values of some typical foods (MJ/kg DM)
Animal
Fowl
Pig
Sheep
Cattle
Food
Maize
Wheat
Barley
Maize
Oats
Barley
Coconut cake meal
Barley
Dried ryegrass (young)
Dried ryegrass (mature)
Grass hay (young)
Grass hay (mature)
Grass silage
Maize
Barley
Wheat bran
Lucerne hay
Gross
energy
18.4
18.1
18.2
18.9
19.4
17.5
19.0
18.5
19.5
19.0
18.0
17.9
19.0
18.9
18.3
19.0
18.3
Energy lost in
Faeces
2.2
2.8
4.9
1.6
5.5
2.8
6.4
3.0
3.4
7.1
5.4
7.6
5.0
2.8
4.1
6.0
8.2
Urine
0.4
0.6
0.5
2.6
0.6
1.5
0.6
0.9
0.5
0.9
0.8
0.8
1.0
1.0
ME
Methane
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
2.0
1.6
1.4
1.5
1.4
1.5
1.3
1.1
1.4
1.3
16.2
15.3
13.3
16.9
13.3
14.2
10.0
12.9
13.0
9.9
10.2
8.4
11.6
14.0
12.3
10.6
7.8
259
Chapter 11 Evaluation of foods: energy content of foods and energy partition within the animal
digestion is an increase in the losses of energy in either urine (as the breakdown
products of the nucleic acids of bacteria that have been digested and absorbed) or
faeces (as microorganisms grown in the hind gut and not digested). In general,
losses of energy in methane and in urine are greater for ruminants than for nonruminants, and so foods such as concentrates, which are digested to the same extent
in ruminants and non-ruminants, will have a higher ME value for non-ruminants
(cf. values for barley in Table 11.1). However, fibrous foods given to non-ruminants
will also incur losses due to fermentative digestion in the hind gut. In ruminants,
foods such as silages that have been fermented before consumption by the animal
will incur smaller energy losses in digestion but will already have incurred losses in
the silo. Thus, silages are said to contain less fermentable metabolisable energy
(FME) than comparable foods such as hays; this difference, however, is of greater
importance to the protein nutrition of ruminants (see Chapters 8 and 13) than to
energy nutrition.
A final comment on the effect of animal species is that differences between cattle
and sheep in urine and methane losses of energy are small and of no significance.
The ME value of a food will vary depending on whether the amino acids supplied
are retained by the animal for protein synthesis or deaminated and their nitrogen excreted in the urine as urea. For this reason, ME values are sometimes corrected to
zero nitrogen balance by deducting either 28 kJ (pigs), 31 kJ (ruminants) or 34 kJ
(poultry) for each 1 g of nitrogen retained. The factor most appropriate to each
species of animal depends on the extent to which nitrogen is excreted as urea (gross
energy 23 kJ/g nitrogen) or other compounds (e.g. uric acid, 28 kJ/g nitrogen). If an
animal is excreting more nitrogen in its urine than it is absorbing from its food (i.e. is
in negative nitrogen balance; see Chapter 13), then some of the urine nitrogen is not
derived from the food, and in this case the ME value must be subjected to a positive
correction.
In ruminants, increases in the level of feeding and the manner in which food is
processed may in some cases affect its ME value. As discussed earlier (see Chapter 10), increases in the level of feeding, or the grinding and pelleting of forages, result
in higher rates of passage and increased faecal energy loss (see Table 10.2 in Chapter 10). However, this may be partly offset by reductions in methane production.
Nevertheless, for finely ground roughages and for mixed roughage and concentrate
diets, ME values are reduced by increases in level of feeding. For poultry, the grinding
of cereals has no consistent effect on ME values.
In theory it should be possible to prevent the production of methane in the
rumen and thereby avoid losing 8–12 per cent of gross energy intake in this form.
In practice it is possible to suppress methane production by adding antimicrobial
drugs to the diet (one effective chemical is chloroform), but the consequences are
not consistently favourable. Energy may be diverted to another gaseous by-product,
hydrogen (see Fig. 8.3 in Chapter 8); furthermore, the rumen microorganisms may
adapt to the presence of the drug and revert to the synthesis of methane. The coccidiostat monensin, which has been widely used as a feed-borne growth promoter
for beef cattle, is considered to be a methane suppressant. However, there is some
evidence that methanogenic microorganisms can adapt to this agent. Since the ban
on the use of antimicrobial growth promoters as feed additives by the EU in
January 2006 and the increasing recognition of methane from ruminants as an
important greenhouse gas, there has been renewed interest in alternative methods
260
Supply of energy
of reducing methane production with products such as yeast culture and plant
extract (see Chapter 24).
Heat increment of foods
The ingestion of food by an animal is followed by losses of energy not only as the
chemical energy of its solid, liquid and gaseous excreta but also as heat. Animals are
continuously producing heat and losing it to their surroundings, either directly by radiation, conduction and convection, or indirectly by the evaporation of water. If a
fasting animal is given food, then within a few hours its heat production will increase
above the level represented by basal metabolism. This increase is known as the heat
increment of the food; it is quite marked in humans after a large meal. The heat increment may be expressed in absolute terms (MJ/kg DM) or relatively as a proportion of either GE or ME. Unless the animal is in a particularly cold environment, this
heat energy is of no value to the animal and must be considered, like the energy of
the excreta, as a tax on the energy of the food.
The causes of the heat increment are to be found in the processes associated with
digestion of foods and metabolism of the nutrients derived from them.The act of eating, which includes chewing, swallowing and the secretion of saliva, requires muscular activity, for which energy is supplied by the oxidation of nutrients; in ruminants
chewing fibrous foods, the energy cost of eating is estimated to be 3–6 per cent of
ME intake.The energy cost of rumination, however, is much less than the cost of eating and is estimated to be about 0.3 per cent of ME intake. Ruminants also generate
heat through the metabolism of their gut microorganisms; this is estimated to
amount to about 7–8 per cent of ME intake (or alternatively 0.6 kJ per kJ of
methane produced).
More heat is produced when nutrients are metabolised. For example, it was
shown in Chapter 9 that if glucose is oxidised for the formation of ATP, then the efficiency of free energy capture is only about 0.52, with 0.48 being lost as heat. Moreover, the efficiency will be even less if temporary storage of nutrients is required (e.g.
glucose stored as glycogen) because more reactions are required. Similar inefficiency
is apparent in the synthesis of the body’s structural constituents. The linking of one
amino acid to another, for example, requires the expenditure of four pyrophosphate
high-energy bonds, and if the ATP that provides these is obtained through glucose
oxidation, then about 2.5 MJ of energy will be released as heat for each kilogram of
protein formed. Protein synthesis, it should be noted, occurs not only in growing
animals but also in those kept at a maintenance level, in which protein synthesis is a
part of the process of protein turnover (see p. 216). Protein metabolism is estimated
to account for about 10 per cent of the animal’s heat production.The animal also expends high-energy phosphate bonds to do the work involved in the movement of
substances (e.g. Na+ and K+ ions) against concentration gradients. This so-called ion
pumping may also contribute 10 per cent of the animal’s heat production. Heat is
produced within the body in those regions with the most active metabolism. Thus, it
has been estimated that in ruminants, which have a large and metabolically active
gut, as much as half of the total heat production originates from the gut and liver.
We shall see later that the heat increment of foods varies considerably, depending
on the nature of the food, the type of animal consuming it and the various processes
for which nutrients are used.
261
Chapter 11 Evaluation of foods: energy content of foods and energy partition within the animal
Net energy (NE) and energy retention
Subtraction of the heat increment of a food from its ME value gives the net energy
(NE) value of a food.The NE value of a food is the energy that is available to the animal for useful purposes, i.e. for body maintenance and for various form of production (see Fig. 11.2).
Net energy used for maintenance is mainly used to perform work within the body
and will leave the animal as heat. That used for growth and fattening and for milk,
egg or wool production either is stored in the body or leaves it as chemical energy,
and the quantity so used is referred to as the animal’s energy retention.
It is important to understand that of the heat lost by the animal only a part, the
heat increment of the food, is truly waste energy, which can be regarded as a direct
tax on the food energy. The heat resulting from the energy used for body maintenance is considered to represent energy that has been used by the animal and degraded into a useless form during the process of utilisation.
11.3
ANIMAL CALORIMETRY: METHODS FOR MEASURING HEAT
PRODUCTION AND ENERGY RETENTION
Calorimetry means the measurement of heat.The partition of food energy presented
in Fig. 11.2 shows that if the ME intake of an animal is known, then the measurement of its total heat production will allow its energy retention to be calculated by
difference (likewise, the measurement of energy retention will allow heat production
to be calculated). In practice, measurement of either heat production or energy
retention is used to establish the NE value of a food.
The methods used to measure heat production and energy retention in animals
can be quite complicated, both in principle and in practice. In the past, the complexity and cost of the apparatus required for animal calorimetry limited its use to a
small number of nutritional research establishments. Improved funding of research
has gradually removed this restriction, but even so, animal calorimetry remains a
specialised topic and few nutritionists become involved in it. Nevertheless, the study
of animal calorimetry on paper (as in this book) is valuable to all students of nutrition, because it reinforces their knowledge of the principles of energy metabolism. In
the pages that follow, the principles of the methods used in animal calorimetry are
explained within the main body of the text, and the apparatus employed is described
in Boxes 11.3, 11.4 and 11.5.
The heat production of animals can be measured physically using a procedure
known as direct calorimetry. Alternatively, heat production can be estimated from
the respiratory exchange of the animal. For this, a respiration chamber is normally
used and the approach is one of indirect calorimetry. Respiration chambers can also
be used to estimate energy retention rather than heat production, by a procedure
known as the carbon and nitrogen balance technique.
Direct calorimetry
Animals do not store heat, except for relatively short periods of time, and when
measurements are made over periods of 24 hours or longer it is generally safe to assume that the quantity of heat lost from the animal is equal to the quantity produced.
262
Animal calorimetry: methods for measuring heat production and energy retention
80
C
60
Heat
production 40
(MJ/day)
B
D
A
E
20
0
20
40
60
80
100
Metabolisable energy intake (MJ/day)
Fig. 11.3 The difference method for estimating the heat increment of foods. A is
the basal metabolism and B and C represent heat production at metabolisable
energy intakes of 40 MJ and 100 MJ, respectively. For the sake of simplicity, the
relationship between heat production and metabolisable energy intake is shown
here as being linear, i.e. ABC is a straight line; however, as explained later in the
chapter, this is not usually the case.
To determine the heat increment of a food, animals are given the food at two levels
of ME intake and their heat production is measured at each level.The heat increment
is calculated as shown in Fig. 11.3. Two levels are needed because a part of the animal’s heat production is contributed by its basal metabolism. An increase in food intake causes total heat production to rise, but the basal metabolism is assumed to
remain the same. The increase in heat production is thus the heat increment of the
extra food given.
In the example shown in Fig. 11.3, food was given at two levels to supply 40 MJ
and 100 MJ ME.The additional energy, 60 MJ (BD in the figure) was associated with
an increase in heat production of 24 MJ (CD in the figure). The heat increment as a
fraction of the additional energy provided can be calculated as follows:
CD>BD or 24>60 = 0.4
It is also possible to make the lower level of intake zero, and to estimate the heat
increment as the difference in heat production between basal (or fasting) metabolism
and that produced in the fed animal. Using this method, the heat increment of the
food can be calculated as follows:
BE>AE or 16>40 = 0.4
If a single food is being investigated, then it may be given as the sole item of the
diet at both levels. If the food is one that would not normally be given alone, then
the lower level may be obtained by giving a basal ration and the higher level by the
263
Chapter 11 Evaluation of foods: energy content of foods and energy partition within the animal
BOX 11.3 Animal calorimeters
Heat is lost from an animal body principally by radiation, conduction and convection from body
surfaces and by evaporation of water from the skin and lungs. An animal calorimeter is essentially
an airtight, insulated chamber. In most early calorimeters, sensible heat losses (i.e. those associated
with radiation, conduction and convection) were taken up in water circulated through coils within
the chamber; the quantity of heat removed from the chamber was then calculated from the flow
rate of water and the difference between its entry and exit temperature. Evaporative heat losses
were measured by recording the volume of air drawn through the chamber and its moisture content
on entry and exit. In a more recent type of calorimeter, the gradient layer calorimeter, the quantity
of heat is measured electrically as it passes through the wall of the chamber. This type of calorimeter lends itself to automation, and both sensible and evaporative heat losses can be recorded
automatically. Most calorimeters incorporate apparatus to measure respiratory exchange and therefore can be used for indirect calorimetry as well.
same basal ration plus some of the food under investigation. For example, the heat
increment of barley eaten by sheep could be measured by feeding the sheep first on
a basal ration of hay and then on an equal amount of the same hay plus some of the
barley.
Because animal calorimeters are expensive to build and earlier types required
much labour to operate them, animal calorimetry today is mainly carried out by the
indirect method described below.
Indirect calorimetry by measurement of respiratory exchange
The substances that are oxidised in an animal’s body, and whose energy is therefore
converted into heat, consist mainly of carbohydrates, fats and proteins. The overall
reaction for the oxidation of a carbohydrate such as glucose is:
C6H12O6 + 6O2 : 6CO2 + 6H2O + 2820 kJ
[11.1]
and for the oxidation of the typical fat such as tripalmitin is:
C3H5(OOC.C15H31)3 + 72.5O2 : 51CO2 + 49H2O + 3202 kJ
[11.2]
One gram-molecule of oxygen occupies 22.4 l at normal temperature and pressure (NPT). Thus, if an animal is obtaining all its energy from the oxidation of glucose, then the utilisation of one litre of oxygen would lead to the production of
2820/(6 * 22.4) = 20.98 kJ of heat; for mixtures of carbohydrates, an average value
is 21.12 kJ/l. Such values are known as thermal equivalents of oxygen and are used
in indirect calorimetry to estimate heat production from oxygen consumption. For
animals catabolising mixtures of fats, the thermal equivalent of oxygen is 19.61 kJ/l
(cf. 19.73 kJ/l calculated for a single fat from Equation 11.2).
Animals do not normally obtain energy exclusively from either carbohydrate or
fat. They oxidise a mixture of these (and protein). Consequently, in order to apply
the appropriate thermal equivalent, it is necessary to know how much of the oxygen
is used for oxidation of each nutrient. The proportions are calculated from what is
known as the respiratory quotient (RQ).This is the ratio between the volume of carbon
264
Animal calorimetry: methods for measuring heat production and energy retention
dioxide produced by the animal and the volume of oxygen used. Since, under the same
conditions of temperature and pressure, equal volumes of gases contain equal numbers of molecules, the RQ can be calculated from the molecules of carbon dioxide
produced and oxygen used. From Equation 11.1 the RQ for carbohydrate is calculated as 6CO2/6O2 = 1, and from Equation 11.2 the RQ of the fat tripalmitin is calculated as 51CO2/72.5O2 = 0.70. If the RQ of an animal is known, the proportions
of fat and carbohydrate oxidised can then be determined from standard tables.
For example, an RQ of 0.9 indicates the oxidation of a mixture of 67.5 per cent carbohydrate and 32.5 per cent fat, and the thermal equivalent of oxygen for such a
mixture is 20.60 kJ/l.
The mixture oxidised generally includes protein. The quantity of protein
catabolised can be estimated from the output of nitrogen in the urine, with 0.16 g of
urinary nitrogen being excreted for each gram of protein oxidised. The heat of combustion of protein (i.e. the heat produced when it is completely oxidised) varies according to the amino acid proportions but averages 22.2 kJ/g. Protein, however, is
incompletely oxidised in animals because the body cannot oxidise nitrogen, and the
average amount of heat produced by the catabolism of protein is 18.0 kJ/g. For each
gram of protein oxidised, 0.77 l of carbon dioxide is produced and 0.96 l of oxygen
used, giving an RQ of 0.8.
Heat is produced not only when nutrients are oxidised but also when they are
used for the synthesis of animal tissues. However, it has been found that the quantities of heat produced during tissue synthesis bear the same relationship to respiratory exchange as they do when the nutrients are completely oxidised.
The relationship between respiratory exchange and heat production is disturbed
if the oxidation of carbohydrate and fat is incomplete. This situation arises in the
metabolic disorder known as ketosis, in which fatty acids are not completely oxidised to carbon dioxide and water, and carbon and hydrogen leave the body as ketones or ketone-like substances. Incomplete oxidation also occurs under normal
conditions in ruminants, because an end product of carbohydrate fermentation in
the rumen is methane. In practice, heat production calculated from respiratory exchange in ruminants is corrected for this effect by the deduction of 2.42 kJ for each
litre of methane produced.
The calculations explained above may be combined into a single equation called
the Brouwer equation (after the Dutch scientist E Brouwer):
HP = 16.18 VO2 + 5.16 VCO2 - 5.90 N - 2.42 CH4
[11.3]
where HP ⫽ heat production (kJ), VO2 ⫽ oxygen consumption (litres), VCO2 ⫽
carbon dioxide production (litres), N ⫽ urinary nitrogen excretion (g) and CH4 ⫽
methane production (litres).
For poultry the N coefficient is 1.20 (instead of 5.90), as poultry excrete nitrogen
in the form of uric acid, which is more oxidised than urea.
In some situations, discussed in more detail later, heat production has to be estimated from oxygen consumption alone. If a respiratory quotient of 0.82 and a
thermal equivalent of 20.0 kJ/l are assumed, then departures from this RQ in the
range of 0.7–1.0 cause a maximum bias of no more than 3.5 per cent in the estimate
of heat production. A further simplification is possible in respect of protein metabolism. The thermal equivalent of oxygen used for protein oxidation is 18.8 kJ/l, not
very different from the value of 20.0 assumed for carbohydrate and fat oxidation.
265
Chapter 11 Evaluation of foods: energy content of foods and energy partition within the animal
Table 11.2 Calculation of the heat production of a calf from values for its
respiratory exchange and urinary nitrogen excretion
Results of the experiment (/24 hours)
Oxygen consumption (l)
Carbon dioxide produced (l)
Nitrogen excreted in urine (g)
Heat from protein metabolism
Protein oxidised (g)
Heat produced (kJ)
Oxygen used (l)
Carbon dioxide produced (l)
Heat from carbohydrate and fat metabolism
Oxygen used (l)
Carbon dioxide produced (l)
Non-protein respiratory quotient (RQ)
Thermal equivalent of oxygen when RQ ⫽ 0.79 (kJ/l)
Heat produced (kJ)
Total heat produced (kJ)
392.0
310.7
14.8
(14.8 ⫻ 6.25)
(92.5 ⫻ 18.0)
(92.5 ⫻ 0.96)
(92.5 ⫻ 0.77)
92.5
1665
88.8
71.2
(392.0 – 88.8)
(310.7 – 71.2)
(239.5/303.2)
303.2
239.5
0.79
20.0
6064
7729
(303.2 ⫻ 20.0)
(1665 ⫹ 6064)
After Blaxter K L, Graham McC and Rook J A F 1955 Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge 45: 10.
If only a small proportion of the heat production is derived from protein oxidation,
then it is unnecessary to assess it separately and urinary nitrogen output need not
be measured.
An example of the calculation of heat production from respiratory exchange is
shown in Table 11.2. If the Brouwer equation (Equation 11.3) had been applied to
the respiratory exchange data of Table 11.2, then heat production would have been
estimated as 7858 kJ.
In recent years, the emphasis of scientists studying animal energetics has moved
away from whole-body metabolism towards studying the energy exchange of specific
organs or tissues.The basic methodology of such studies is that catheters are inserted
into the major blood vessels supplying and draining a particular organ. Both the flow
and composition of blood are measured in order to allow oxygen uptake and carbon
dioxide production to be estimated. At the same time, the uptake of other metabolites, such as glucose, can also be measured.
Measurement of energy retention by the carbon and nitrogen
balance technique
In indirect calorimetry, using respiratory exchange, heat production is estimated, and
energy retention is calculated as the difference between metabolisable energy intake
and heat production (as in Table 11.2). An alternative approach is to estimate energy
retention more directly and to calculate heat production by difference.
The main forms in which energy is stored by the growing and fattening animal are
protein and fat, as carbohydrate reserves of the body are small and relatively constant.The quantities of protein and fat stored can be estimated by carrying out a carbon and nitrogen balance trial – that is, by measuring the amounts of these elements
266
Animal calorimetry: methods for measuring heat production and energy retention
BOX 11.4 Measurement of respiratory exchange using respiration chambers
The apparatus most commonly used for farm animals is a respiration chamber. The simplest type of
chamber, the closed-circuit type (Fig. 11.4a), consists of an airtight chamber for the animal together
with vessels holding absorbents for carbon dioxide and water vapour.The chamber incorporates devices for feeding, watering and even milking the animal. The oxygen used by the animal is replaced
from a metered supply. At the end of a trial period (24 hours), the carbon dioxide produced can be
measured by weighing the absorbent; any methane produced can be measured by sampling and
analysing the air in the chamber. The main disadvantage of the closed-circuit chamber is that large
quantities of absorbents are required; thus, for a cow, 100 kg of soda lime would be needed each
day to absorb carbon dioxide and 250 kg of silica gel to absorb water vapour.
In the alternative, open-circuit type of chamber (Fig. 11.4b), air is drawn through the chamber at
a metered rate and sampled for analysis on entry and exit.Thus, carbon dioxide production, methane
production and oxygen consumption can be estimated. As the differences in composition between
inlet and outlet air must be kept small if conditions for the animal are to be kept normal, very accurate measures of gas flow and composition are required. Modern equipment, based on infrared
analysers, meet this criterion, and open-circuit chambers have now largely replaced closed-circuit
chambers.With some chambers it is possible to alternate between closed- and open-circuit operation.
Closed-circuit operation for perhaps 30 minutes, with no gas absorption, produces appreciable
changes in the composition of the chamber air. Then a brief period (about 3 minutes) of open-circuit
operation allows the chamber air to be flushed out through a flow meter and sampling device.
(a) Closed circuit
Pump
Valve
Chamber
CO2 and water absorbers
Meter
Oxygen
inlet
(b) Open circuit
Aliquots of entry
and exit air for
oxygen analysis
Aliquots of exit
air for CO2 and
methane analysis
For methane
analysis
CO2 absorbers
Pump Gas meter
Chamber
Fig. 11.4 Diagrams of respiration chambers.
267
Chapter 11 Evaluation of foods: energy content of foods and energy partition within the animal
BOX 11.5 Measurement of respiratory exchange in unconfined animals
Respiratory exchange can be measured without an animal chamber if the subject is fitted with a
face mask, which is then connected to either a closed or an open circuit for determining either oxygen consumption alone or both oxygen consumption and carbon dioxide production.This method is
suitable for short periods of measurement but cannot be used to estimate heat production when the
animal is eating. For longer-term measurements of energy metabolism in unconfined (e.g. grazing)
animals, heat production can be estimated with reasonable accuracy from carbon dioxide production alone. The latter is measured by infusing into the body fluids a source of radio-labelled carbon
dioxide (14C sodium bicarbonate) and sampling body fluids to determine the degree to which the
labelled carbon dioxide is diluted by that produced by the animal.
entering and leaving the body and so, by difference, the amounts retained. The energy retained can then be calculated by multiplying the quantities of nutrients stored
by their calorific values.
Both carbon and nitrogen enter the body in food, and nitrogen leaves it in faeces
and urine. However, carbon also leaves the body as methane and carbon dioxide.
Consequently, the balance trial must therefore be carried out in a respiration chamber. The procedure for calculating energy retention from carbon and nitrogen balance data is best illustrated by considering an animal in which storage of both fat and
protein is taking place. In such an animal, intakes of carbon and nitrogen will be
greater than the quantities excreted, and the animal is said to be in positive balance
with respect to these elements. The quantity of protein stored is calculated by multiplying the nitrogen balance by 1000/160 (= 6.25), as body protein is assumed to
contain 160 g N/kg. It also contains 512 g C/kg, and the amount of carbon stored as
protein can therefore be calculated.The remaining carbon is stored as fat, which contains 746 g C/kg. Fat storage is therefore calculated by dividing the carbon balance,
less that stored as protein, by 0.746.The energy present in the protein and fat stored
is then calculated by using average calorific values for body tissue.These values vary
from one species to another; for cattle and sheep, those now recommended are
39.3 MJ/kg for fat and 23.6 MJ/kg for protein. An example of this method of calculating energy retention (and heat production) is shown in Table 11.3.
The advantages of the carbon and nitrogen balance technique are that no measure
of oxygen consumption (or RQ) is required and that energy retention is subdivided
into that stored as protein and that stored as fat.
Measuring energy retention by the comparative slaughter technique
Because calorimetric experiments require elaborate apparatus and can only be conducted with small numbers of animals, energy retention is often measured in other
ways. In many feeding trials the animal’s intake of digestible or metabolisable energy
can be measured satisfactorily, but their energy retention can only be estimated from
changes in liveweight.Weight change, however, provides an inaccurate estimate of energy retention, first because it may simply represent changes in the contents of the gut
or bladder, and second because the energy content of true tissue gain varies over a
wide range depending on the relative proportions of bone, muscle and fat deposited
(see Chapter 14).These complications are only partly overcome when energy retention
268
Animal calorimetry: methods for measuring heat production and energy retention
Table 11.3 Calculation of the energy retention and heat production of a sheep
from its carbon and nitrogen balance
Results of experiment (/ 24 hours)
Intake
Excretion in faeces
Excretion in urine
Excretion in methane
Excretion in CO2
Balance
Intake of metabolisable energy
Protein and fat storage
Protein stored (g)
Carbon stored as protein (g)
Carbon stored as fat (g)
Fat stored (g)
Energy retention and heat production
Energy stored as protein (MJ)
Energy stored as fat (MJ)
Total energy retention (MJ)
Heat production (MJ)
C (g)
684.5
279.3
33.6
20.3
278.0
73.3
–
N (g)
41.67
13.96
25.41
–
–
2.30
–
Energy (MJ)
28.41
11.47
1.50
1.49
–
–
13.95
(2.3 ⫻ 6.25)
(14.4 ⫻ 0.512)
(73.3 - 7.4)
(65.9/0.746)
14.4
7.4
65.9
88.3
(14.4 ⫻ (23.6/1000))
(88.3 ⫻ (39.3/1000))
(0.34 ⫹ 3.47)
13.95 - 3.81
0.34
3.47
3.81
10.14
After Graham N McC 1955 Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge 46: 292.
is in the form of milk or eggs, where energy content can be easily measured because
energy retention in these products is invariably accompanied by retention in other tissues (e.g. lactating cows are normally gaining or losing weight and energy).
Energy retention can, however, be measured in feeding trials if the energy content
of the animal is estimated at the beginning and end of the experiment. In the comparative slaughter method, this is done by dividing the animals into two groups and
slaughtering one group of animals (the initial slaughter group) at the beginning of
the trial. The energy content of the slaughtered animals is then determined by bomb
calorimetry, the samples used being taken either from the whole, minced body or
from body tissues that have been separated by dissection. A relationship is then obtained between the liveweight of the animals and their energy content, and this is
used to predict the initial energy content of animals in the second group. The latter
are slaughtered at the end of the trial and treated in the same manner as those in the
initial slaughter group. The energy gained can then be calculated.
Table 11.4 shows an example of the use of the comparative slaughter technique in
an experiment in which, for comparative purposes, respiratory exchange calorimetry
was also employed. Cockerels were slaughtered either before or after a 4-day period
in respiration chambers. Their energy gain was calculated as the difference between
initial and final body energy content, and deducted from the bird’s known
metabolisable energy intake to give an estimate of heat production, which agreed
within 2 per cent with the estimate obtained by respiratory exchange calorimetry.
Most comparative slaughter trials would last longer and hence give a greater increment in energy balance than that shown in Table 11.4. It is also worth noting that
comparative slaughter trials often give lower estimates of energy retention than trials conducted with animals in calorimeters, possibly because the former allow more
opportunity for animals to expend energy on muscular activity.
269
Chapter 11 Evaluation of foods: energy content of foods and energy partition within the animal
Table 11.4 Use of the comparative slaughter technique to estimate the energy
retention and heat production of poultry
Details of birds
Initial
Final
Difference
Liveweight (g)
Gross energy (kJ)
Metabolisable energy intake (kJ)
Heat production (kJ) (2255–679)
Heat production by respiration calorimetry (kJ)
2755
27491
2823
28170
2255
1576
1548
68
679
After Fuller H L, Dale N M and Smith C F 1983 Journal of Nutrition 113: 1403.
The comparative slaughter method requires no elaborate apparatus but is expensive
and laborious when applied to larger animal species.The method becomes less costly
if body composition, and hence energy content, can be measured in the living animal, or, failing that, in the whole, undissected carcass. Several chemical methods
have been developed for estimating body composition in vivo. For most of them the
principle employed is that the lean body mass of animals (i.e. empty body weight
less weight of fat) is relatively constant in composition. For example, in cattle 1 kg
lean body mass contains 729 g water, 216 g protein and 53 g ash. This means that if
the weight of water in the living animal can be measured, the weights of protein and
ash can then be estimated. In addition, if the total weight is known, the weight of fat
can be estimated by subtracting the lean body mass. In practice, total body water can
be estimated by so-called dilution techniques, in which a known quantity of a
marker substance is injected into the animal, allowed to equilibrate with body water
and its equilibrium concentration determined. The marker substances most commonly used are water containing the radioactive isotope of hydrogen tritium, or its
heavy isotope deuterium. One difficulty with these techniques is that the markers
mix not only with actual body water but also with water present in the gut (in ruminants as much as 30 per cent of total body water may be in gut contents). A second
chemical method for estimating body composition in vivo is based on the constant
concentration of potassium in the lean body mass.
The composition of a carcass is often estimated without dissection or chemical
analysis from its specific gravity. Fat has an appreciably lower specific gravity than
bone and muscle, and the fatter the carcass, the lower will be its specific gravity. The
specific gravity of a carcass is determined by weighing it in air and in water, but this
method has technical difficulties (e.g. air trapped under water) that make it imprecise. Nevertheless, estimates of energy utilisation obtained by comparative slaughter
and specific gravity measurements have been used in the USA to establish a complete cattle feeding system (see Chapter 12).
11.4
UTILISATION OF METABOLISABLE ENERGY
The general relationship between the ME intake of an animal and its energy retention is shown in Fig. 11.5. When ME intake is zero (i.e. the animal is fasted), energy
retention is negative; in this situation, the animal uses its reserves to provide energy
for the maintenance of its essential bodily functions, and this energy leaves the animal as heat. As ME intake increases, energy loss (i.e. negative retention) diminishes;
270
Utilisation of metabolisable energy
Energy retention (MJ/day)
20
15
10
5
0
−5
−10
0
10
20
30
40
50
ME intake (MJ/day)
Fig. 11.5 Efficiency of metabolisable energy utilisation (an example based on
metabolisable energy utilisation by a growing ruminant).
when energy retention is zero, ME intake is sufficient to meet the animal’s requirement for body maintenance.As ME intake increases further, the animal begins to retain energy, either in its body tissues or in products such as milk and eggs.
The slope of the line relating retention to intake is a measure of the efficiency of
ME utilisation. For example, if the ME intake of an animal was increased by 10 MJ
and its retention increased by 7 MJ, then the efficiency of utilisation of ME would be
calculated as 7兾10 = 0.7. (Conversely, the heat increment would be calculated as
3兾10 = 0.3 of the ME.) These efficiency values are conventionally called k factors,
with the letter k carrying a subscript to indicate the function for which ME is being
used. The commonly used k factors are shown in Box 11.6.
The term kf has been used to denote both the specific efficiency of fat deposition
(as indicated above) and the general efficiency of energy deposition in what were
once called ‘fattening’ animals. Today, the preferred term for the latter use is kg, as
animals are now considered to grow rather than fatten.
BOX 11.6 Efficiency factors (k) used to describe the efficiency of metabolisable energy
(ME) utilisation
k factor
Efficiency of ME utilisation for
km
kp
kf
kg (or kpf)
kl
kc
kw
kwool
Maintenance
Protein deposition
Fat deposition
Growth in general
Milk production
Foetal growth (the conceptus)
Work (e.g. in draught animals)
Wool growth
271
Chapter 11 Evaluation of foods: energy content of foods and energy partition within the animal
In Fig. 11.5 the line relating ME intake to energy retention changes in slope when
the ME intake reaches maintenance (energy retention = 0), becoming less steep and
indicating a reduction in efficiency. Scientists argue as to whether there should be an
abrupt bend (as in Fig. 11.5) or whether the relationship between ME intake and energy retention should be represented by a smooth curve. Conceptually, however, it is
convenient to envisage a difference in the efficiency of ME utilisation below and
above maintenance. The apparently greater efficiency below maintenance is due to
the fact that km is not an absolute measure of the efficiency of energy utilisation from
absorbed nutrients but is a relative measure of the efficiency with which nutrients
obtained from food can be used to replace energy sources obtained from body reserves; this rather difficult concept is illustrated later.
An additional feature of Fig. 11.5 is the shaded area on either side of the lines.
This is intended to indicate that the efficiency of ME utilisation is quite variable. We
shall see later that the principal causes of this variation in efficiency are, first, the nature of the chemical compounds from which ME is derived (hence the nature of the
food and the manner in which it is digested) and, second, the function for which
these compounds are used by the animal.
Utilisation of metabolisable energy for maintenance
For maintenance purposes, the animal oxidises nutrients absorbed from its food
principally to provide energy for work. If no food is provided, then it obtains this energy mainly by the oxidation of body fat.When food is provided, but in quantities insufficient to provide all the energy needed for maintenance, the task of providing
ATP is partially transferred from body fat reserves to the nutrients absorbed. If the
energy derived from these absorbed nutrients is transferred to ATP as efficiently as
that derived from body fat, then no additional heat will be produced, apart from that
associated specifically with the consumption, digestion and absorption of food. Heat
of fermentation comes into this category and also the work of digestion (i.e. heat
arising from energy used for mastication of food and its propulsion through the gut,
in the absorption of nutrients and in their transport to tissues).
The efficiency of free energy capture when body fats are oxidised and ATP is
formed can be calculated from the reactions shown in Chapter 9 to be of the order
of 0.67. For glucose, to take an example of a nutrient, the efficiency is similar, at
about 0.70. One would therefore expect that glucose given to a fasting animal would
be utilised without any increase in heat production, or in other words with apparent
(calorimetric) efficiency of 1.0. Table 11.5 shows that this is approximately true. In
sheep the efficiency is reduced through fermentation losses if the glucose passes into
the rumen, but these losses are avoided if it is infused directly into the abomasum.
Table 11.5 also shows that, as one would expect, dietary fat is used for maintenance with high energetic efficiency. However, when protein is used to provide energy for maintenance, there is an appreciable heat increment of about 0.2, which is in
part attributable to the energy required for urea synthesis (see Chapter 9). In ruminants, energy for maintenance is absorbed largely in the form of volatile fatty acids.
Experiments in which the pure acids have been infused singly into the rumen of fasting sheep have shown that there are differences between them in the efficiency with
which their energy is utilised (Table 11.5). But when the acids are combined into
mixtures representing the extremes likely to be found in the rumen, the efficiency of
utilisation is uniform and high. Nevertheless the efficiency is still less than that for
272
Utilisation of metabolisable energy
Table 11.5 Efficiency of metabolisable energy utilisation for maintenance
from various nutrients and foods
Ruminant
Food constituent
Glucose
Starch
Olive oil
Casein
Fermentation product
Acetic acid
Propionic acid
Butyric acid
Mixture Ac
Mixture Bd
Concentrates
Maize
Balanced diets
Forages
Dried ryegrass (young)
Dried ryegrass (mature)
Meadow hay
Lucerne hay
Grass silage
0.94 (1.00)b
0.80
0.70 (0.82)b
Pig etc.a
Fowl
0.95
0.88
0.97
0.76
0.89
0.97
0.95
0.84
0.85
0.90
0.59
0.86
0.76
0.87
0.86
0.80
0.70
0.78
0.74
0.70
0.82
0.65–0.71
a
Including dog and rat.
Values in parentheses are from administration via the duodenum.
c
Mixture A: acetic acid 0.25, propionic acid 0.45, butyric acid 0.30.
d
Mixture B: acetic acid 0.75, propionic acid 0.15, butyric acid 0.10.
b
glucose, and this discrepancy, together with the energy lost through heat of fermentation in ruminants, leads one to expect that ME will be utilised more efficiently for
maintenance in those animals in which it is absorbed in the form of glucose than in
ruminants.
Very few experiments have been conducted to determine the efficiency of ME
utilisation of foods for maintenance, and these few have been restricted almost entirely to ruminant animals fed forages. A selection of the results is presented in
Table 11.5.
Most of the ME from forages would have been absorbed in the form of volatile
fatty acids. The efficiency of ME utilisation is less, however, than for synthetic mixtures of these acids, since with whole foods heat losses are increased by heat of fermentation and by the energy used for work of digestion. In spite of this, the ME in
these foods was used with quite high efficiency.
Utilisation of metabolisable energy for productive purposes
Although energy may be stored by animals in a wide variety of products – in body
fat, muscle, milk, eggs and wool – the energy of these products is contained mainly in
fat and protein (only in milk is much energy stored as carbohydrate). The efficiency
273
Chapter 11 Evaluation of foods: energy content of foods and energy partition within the animal
with which ME is used for productive purposes therefore depends largely on the energetic efficiency of the metabolic pathways involved in the synthesis of fat and protein from absorbed nutrients. These pathways have been outlined in Chapter 9. In
general, the synthesis of either fat or protein is a more complicated process than its
catabolism, in the same way that the construction of a building is more difficult than
its demolition. Not only must the building materials be present in the right proportions, but also they must arrive on the scene at the right time, and the absence of a
particular material may prevent or seriously impair the whole process. Thus, it was
shown in Chapter 9 that fatty acid synthesis is dependent on a supply of reduced
NADP+. Because of the greater complexity of synthetic processes, it is more difficult
to estimate their theoretical efficiency.
Utilisation of metabolisable energy for growth
In Chapter 9, the synthesis of a triacylglycerol from acetate and glucose was shown
to have a theoretical efficiency of 0.83. A higher value would be expected for fat
synthesis from long-chain fatty acids of dietary origin, but a lower value would be
expected for the formation of fat from protein, as energy would be needed to synthesise the urea by which amino acid nitrogen would be excreted. In protein synthesis, the energy cost of linking amino acids together is relatively small, and if these are
present in the right proportions the theoretical efficiency of protein synthesis is
about 0.85 (see Chapter 9). However, if some amino acids have to be synthesised
while others undergo deamination, the efficiency will be considerably less; as discussed later, the observed efficiency of protein synthesis is generally much lower
than the observed efficiency of fat synthesis. The synthesis of lactose from glucose
can be achieved with an efficiency of 0.96 (see Chapter 9), but in the dairy cow the
glucose so utilised is largely derived from propionic acid (or possibly amino acids) by
gluconeogenesis, and the efficiency of lactose synthesis will be lower.
The figures given above are all calculated from the appropriate metabolic pathways, and in relating them to the efficiency of ME utilisation it is important to remember that they will be reduced by those energy losses mentioned earlier (see
p. 261) that are directly related to the consumption, digestion and absorption of food.
Measuring in an animal the energetic efficiency with which a single body substance
such as protein is synthesised is complicated by the fact mentioned previously that
animals seldom store energy as single substances or even as single products. However, when growing animals are storing energy as protein and fat, it is possible to calculate, by the mathematical procedure known as regression analysis, the energy used
for each of these processes. Analyses of this kind have been made for many calorimetric experiments carried out with pigs, and the results are shown in Table 11.6.
The actual values are always lower than the theoretical, the discrepancies being
relatively small for fat deposition but much larger for protein deposition. Thus, for
protein, the value of about 0.5 estimated by calorimetry is much less than the
theoretical value, given earlier, of 0.85. The main reason for this large discrepancy is
believed to be that protein deposition is not only a matter of protein synthesis but is
the consequence of two processes, synthesis and breakdown. Proteins in most body
tissues are continuously being broken down and resynthesised, by reactions that
generate heat. This turnover of protein reduces the calorimetric efficiency of protein
deposition. One would expect that proteins in tissues with a high rate of turnover
(such as those in the alimentary tract) would be deposited with particularly low
274
Utilisation of metabolisable energy
Table 11.6 Typical values for the efficiency of metabolisable energy utilisation for
growth in pigs
Form of energy stored
Origin of value
Substrate or diet
Fat (kf)
Theoretical
Acetate + glucose
Dietary fat
Dietary protein
Normal diets
Dietary fat
Dietary carbohydrate
Dietary protein
Volatile fatty acids
Amino acids
Amino acids
Many diets (mean)
Barley
Maize
Soya bean meal
Actual (calorimetric)
Protein (kp)
Protein and fat (kg)
Theoretical
Actual (calorimetric)
Actual
Efficiency
0.81
0.99
0.69
0.74
0.86
0.76
0.66
0.65–0.71
0.88
0.45–0.55
0.71
0.60
0.62
0.48
calorimetric efficiency, whereas those with little or no turnover would be deposited
more efficiently. Thus, milk proteins, which leave the animal before they can be broken down, should be synthesised with high calorimetric efficiency. For pigs (and
other non-ruminants) on normal diets, one would expect the efficiency of ME utilisation for growth as a whole to be intermediate between the efficiency values found
for fat and protein deposition. In pigs, protein deposition commonly accounts for
20 per cent of total energy retention and the expected efficiency of ME utilsation for
growth (kg) would therefore be 0.7. This value has been confirmed by many calorimetric experiments made with pigs.
In poultry, values for the efficiency of ME utilisation for growth are similar to
those found in pigs. They lie in the range 0.60–0.80 but for balanced diets are close
to 0.70.
For ruminants, the efficiency of utilisation of ME for growth is generally lower
than that for pigs, and it is also more variable, as shown in Table 11.7. When cattle
and sheep are fed on diets similar to those commonly given to pigs (i.e. based largely
on cereal-containing concentrates), the efficiency factor kg rarely exceeds 0.62 and is
therefore about 10 per cent lower than the mean value for pigs suggested above
(0.7). However, kg values for ruminants are much lower and more variable when
they are fed on forages. The best forages, such as dried immature ryegrass, give kg
values over 0.5, whereas poor-quality forages, such as wheat straw, give values as low
as 0.2. We shall see later (in Chapter 12) that the kg values of forages for ruminants
are related to their metabolisable energy concentrations. These kg values are clearly
far below both the theoretical and calorimetric values shown in Table 11.6, and we
now need to consider how they can be explained.
Heat of fermentation, as explained earlier (see p. 261), accounts for part of the
lower calorimetric efficiency of growth in ruminants; thus, it would explain much of
the 10 per cent difference in kg between pigs and ruminants fed on similar, mainly
concentrate-based diets. However, for a fuller explanation we need to consider the end
products of digestion in ruminants. We have already seen in Chapter 8 that much of
275
Chapter 11 Evaluation of foods: energy content of foods and energy partition within the animal
Table 11.7 Efficiency of utilisation of metabolisable energy from various nutrients
and foods for growth and fattening in ruminants
Food constituent
Glucose
Sucrose
Starch
Cellulose
Groundnut oil
Mixed proteins
Casein
Concentrates
Barley
Oats
Maize
Groundnut meal
Soya bean meal
0.54 (0.72)a
0.58
0.64
0.61
0.58
0.51
0.50 (0.65)a
0.60
0.61
0.62
0.54
0.48
Fermentation product
Acetic acid
Propionic acid
Butyric acid
Mixture Ab
Mixture Bc
Lactic acid
Ethanol
Forages
Dried ryegrass (young)
Dried ryegrass (mature)
Meadow hay
Lucerne hay
Grass silages
Wheat straw
Dried grass (chopped)
Dried grass (pelleted)
0.33–0.60
0.56
0.62
0.58
0.32
0.75
0.72
0.52
0.34
0.30
0.52
0.21–0.60
0.24
0.31
0.46
a
Values in parentheses are for administration via the duodenum.
Mixture A: acetic acid 0.25, propionic acid 0.45, butyric acid 0.30.
c
Mixture B: acetic acid 0.75, propionic acid 0.15, butyric acid 0.10.
b
the energy of the end products of digestion in ruminants is in the form of volatile
fatty acids, with relatively small amounts of energy in the form of lipids, amino acids
(from microbial and food protein) and carbohydrates that have escaped rumen fermentation. Furthermore, the composition of the volatile fatty acid mixture varies according to the diet fed, with a higher proportion of acetic acid being produced from
forage diets and a higher proportion of propionic acid being produced from concentrate diets. At an early stage in the study of energy metabolism of ruminants, it was
recognised that ME derived from poorly digested forages, such as straws and lowquality hays, was utilised for growth with low efficiency (0.2–0.4; see Table 11.7). At
first, this low efficiency was attributed to the ‘work of digestion’, the energy required
for mastication of fibrous foods and the propulsion of their undigested residues
through the gut. Later, it seemed likely that the high proportion of acetic acid associated with fibrous foods was responsible for their low kg values.When different mixtures of volatile fatty acids were infused into the rumen of fattening sheep, large
differences in kg was observed (see Table 11.7). However, subsequent experiments in
which less extreme mixtures of volatile fatty acids were used, in which the acid mixtures were better balanced with other nutrients (e.g. protein) and in which younger
(growing rather than fattening) animals were used, showed much smaller effects of
volatile fatty acid proportions on kg.The current view is that acetic acid derived from
a well-balanced diet is used no less efficiently than propionic or butyric acid. Attention has therefore been directed again at the work of digestion as the cause of low efficiency of ME utilisation from low-quality forages. As explained earlier (see p. 262),
the gut and associated tissues that are served by the portal blood system (the portaldrained viscera) are very metabolically active and have been shown to account for
as much as 50 per cent of the heat increment of feeding in ruminants. As yet, a
276
Utilisation of metabolisable energy
relationship between the fibrousness of a diet and the heat increment of feeding has
not been established, but the processing of forages by grinding and pelleting has
been shown to improve the efficiency of ME utilisation (see Table 11.7).
Whatever the explanation for the poor efficiency of ME utilisation for growth by
ruminants given low-quality forages, the practical problem remains. Ruminant production systems based on such feeds, as is the case in most of the tropical developing countries, are characterised by poor efficiency. Nevertheless, it is now recognised
that the efficiency can be improved by ensuring that the volatile fatty acids arising
from digestion of poor-quality forages are balanced by supplements of other nutrients, especially protein and a-linked polysaccharides, which can escape fermentation
in the rumen.
Utilisation of metabolisable energy for milk and egg production
The production of milk and eggs rarely occurs alone and is usually accompanied by
either gains or losses of fat or protein from the body of the lactating mammal or laying bird. This means that estimates of the partial efficiency of ME utilisation for milk
or egg synthesis are usually made by mathematical partition of the ME utilised. As
the synthesis of milk or eggs requires more complex diets, it is not possible to provide efficiency coefficients for single nutrients as was done for maintenance and
growth in Tables 11.5–11.7.
Over the past 40 years, many energy balance trials have been conducted with lactating cows, principally in the USA and in the Netherlands; similar trials have also
been conducted using sheep and goats. Analysis of the results of these experiments
has shown that the efficiency of ME utilisation for milk synthesis (kl) varies relatively
little over a wide range of diets, 0.56–0.66 for diets in the range 7.0–13.0 MJ/kg
DM, respectively. Given the type of diet normally given to lactating ruminants, a
constant value of 0.60–0.62 is often adopted. From the same analysis, it has also
been calculated that when lactating animals are gaining energy (mainly as fat), the
efficiency of ME utilisation for gain (kg) is only slightly less that that for milk synthesis (0.60). Thus, kg for lactating ruminants is at the top end of the range of efficiency
factors for non-lactating ruminants (see Table 11.7). Lactating animals can also mobilise the energy in body reserves to support milk synthesis with an efficiency of
about 0.84 (kt).This means that a cow that builds up her energy reserves towards the
end of the first lactation, and then mobilises them for milk synthesis at the start of
the next lactation, has an overall efficiency of 0.60 * 0.84 = 0.50.
Over the past 10 years a substantial number of calorimetric measurements have
been conducted using dairy cows in the UK, and a new rationing system for dairy
cows (Feed into Milk 2004) has adopted a slightly different approach to the calculation of ME requirements based on modelling the relationship between milk energy
output and ME intake (see Chapter 12). These data indicate a curvilinear relationship between ME intake and milk energy output, as suggested for growing animals
(see p. 272), and a variable value for (kl). The mathematically derived values for kg
and kt from these studies are 0.65 and 0.78, respectively.
The higher efficiency of ME utilisation by lactating animals compared with growing animals is probably the result of simpler forms of energy being stored in milk,
namely lactose and both long - and short-chain fatty acids. Milk protein may also be
synthesised efficiently because it is rapidly removed from the body and not subject
to the same turnover of amino acids experienced by other body proteins. In lactating
277
Chapter 11 Evaluation of foods: energy content of foods and energy partition within the animal
sows the efficiency of ME utilisation for milk synthesis is about the same as kg in
growing pigs (0.65–0.70).
The efficiency of ME utilisation for egg synthesis in laying hens has been estimated to be in the range 0.60–0.80, with a mean value of 0.69. For egg protein synthesis the efficiency is estimated to be 0.45–0.50, and for egg lipids 0.75–0.80. The
synthesis of body tissue in laying hens is also highly efficient (0.75–0.80).
Other factors affecting the utilisation of metabolisable energy
Associative effects
In Chapter 10 it was explained that the digestibility of a food is influenced not only
by its own composition but also by the composition of other foods consumed with it.
Associative effects of this kind have also been observed in relation to the efficiency
of ME utilisation. In one experiment, ME derived from maize meal was used for gain
with an apparent efficiency varying between 0.58 and 0.74, depending on the nature
of the basal diet to which it was added. In ruminants, such differences are likely to
arise through variations in the way in which the whole diet is digested, and hence in
the form in which energy substrates are absorbed. The implications are that values
for the efficiency of ME utilisation for individual foods are of limited significance.
Balance of nutrients
The effects of the relative proportions of nutrients in a diet have been partly covered
above. However, a fattening animal will tend to use metabolisable energy more efficiently if it is provided as carbohydrate rather than protein. Similarly, if a growing
animal is provided with insufficient protein, or with insufficient amounts of a particular amino acid, then protein synthesis will be reduced and it will tend to store energy as fat rather than protein. In this situation, the efficiency of ME utilisation will
probably be altered.
Mineral and vitamin deficiencies can also interfere with the efficiency of ME
utilisation. A deficiency of phosphorus has been shown to reduce the efficiency of
ME utilisation in cattle by about 10 per cent.This effect is hardly surprising given the
vital role of phosphorus in the energy-yielding reactions associated with intermediary metabolism.
SUMMARY
1. The gross energy (GE) content of foods is measured as the heat of combustion in a bomb
calorimeter. Typical values are 17.5 MJ/kg,
23.6 MJ/kg and 39.3 MJ/kg DM for carbohydrates, proteins and fats, respectively, with common feeds being approximately 18.4 MJ/kg DM.
2. The digestible energy (DE) of a food is its GE
minus the energy excreted in the faeces (both
expressed as MJ/kg DM of food consumed).
278
3. The metabolisable energy (ME) of a food is its
GE minus the energy excreted in faeces, urine
and methane (all expressed as MJ/kg DM food
consumed).
4. Methane production by ruminants is usually
measured using a respiration chamber. However, indirect methods such as the sulphur
hexafluoride (SF6) technique may also be
used.
Questions
5. Poultry excrete faeces and urine together (but
negligible methane). Apparent ME measurements (AME) can be corrected for endogenous
losses (measured in fasted birds) to provide
estimates of true metabolisable energy (TME).
6. In ruminants, losses of energy in urine and
methane are relatively constant (amounting
to about 19 per cent of DE) but may be affected by diet (e.g. high protein intake will
increase urine energy loss).
7. In addition to their energy losses in faeces,
urine and methane, animals also lose energy
as heat. Part of their heat loss arises from the
work done by the animal in digesting and
metabolising food (heat increment of feeding). The remainder, called the basal or fasting metabolism, arises from the work done
by the animal associated with essential body
processes (i.e. maintenance).
8. The net energy (NE) value of a food is calculated by subtracting the heat increment from
its ME value. Net energy is used by the animal
to meet its maintenance requirements and to
form new body tissues (growth) or products
(milk or eggs). The energy of these tissues
and products is known as energy retention.
9. The heat lost by animals may be measured directly in an enclosed chamber called an animal calorimeter. Alternatively, it may be
estimated from the animal’s respiratory exchange (oxygen consumption and carbon
dioxide production) in a respiration chamber.
10. Energy retention may be estimated indirectly
as ME intake minus heat production, or directly from the animal’s carbon and nitrogen
retention in a respiration chamber. It may
also be measured using the comparative
slaughter technique, where a known amount
of ME is given and body composition is
measured at the beginning and end of the
experiment.
11. The two most important measurements when
evaluating food for energy are the ME value
and the efficiency of ME utilisation (k). The
latter is calculated as NE output/ME intake
and varies depending on the species of animal, the process for which ME is being used
and the nature of ME supply.
12. Foods with high ME values tend to have
higher k values because they are digested
and metabolised with less energy expenditure. Ruminants have lower k values than do
non-ruminants, mainly because of the heat
arising from microbial metabolism (heat of
fermentation).
13. The efficiency of ME utilisation for maintenance (km) is 0.7–0.8, and for tissue growth
(kg) is 0.4–0.6, depending on the relative
proportion of protein and fat retained. The
efficiency of protein retention (kp) is lower
(0.45–0.55) than that of fat retention (kf,
0.65–0.85). For milk synthesis the efficiency
(kl) is about 0.62 and for egg production
0.70.
QUESTIONS
11.1 A sheep consuming 1.2 kg/day silage DM containing 19.0 MJ GE/kg excreted
6.0 MJ GE/day in the faeces, 1.56 MJ GE/day in urine and 1.80 MJ GE/day as
methane. Calculate the DE and ME content of the silage.
11.2 The energy retention of the sheep used in Question 1 was measured by placing
it in a respiration chamber. Whilst in the chamber, the sheep consumed 536 l
oxygen and excreted 429 l of carbon dioxide, 45.8 l of methane and 19.0 g of
urinary nitrogen. Using the Brouwer equation, calculate its heat production
and energy retention.
11.3 A pig in a respiration chamber stored 182.5 g carbon and 10.4 g nitrogen each
day. Calculate its protein and fat deposition and the energy content of tissue gain.
279
Chapter 11 Evaluation of foods: energy content of foods and energy partition within the animal
11.4 A growing steer was offered 8.0 kg DM maize silage (ME: 11.0 MJ/kg DM) and
retained 12.0 MJ/day in its tissues. Its fasting metabolism (FM) was 42.0
MJ/day and the efficiency of ME utilisation for maintenance (km) was 0.7. Calculate the efficiency of ME utilisation for gain (kg).
FURTHER READING
Blaxter K L 1967 The Energy Metabolism of Ruminants, London, Hutchinson.
Blaxter K L 1989 Energy Metabolism in Animals and Man, Cambridge, Cambridge University
Press.
McLean J A and Tobin G 1987 Animal and Human Calorimetry, Cambridge, Cambridge
University Press.
McCracken K, Unsworth E F and Wylie A R G 1998 Energy Metabolism of Farm Animals,
Wallingford, CABI.
Minson D J 1990 Forage in Ruminant Nutrition, New York, Academic Press.
Reid J T, White C D, Anrique R and Fortin A 1980 Nutritional energetics of livestock: some
present boundaries of knowledge and future research needs. Journal of Animal Science
51: 1393–415.
280
12
Evaluation of foods: systems
for expressing the energy
value of foods
12.1
Energy systems and energy models
12.2
Energy systems for ruminants
12.3
Energy systems for pigs and poultry
12.4
Energy systems for horses
12.5
Predicting the energy value of foods
For the farmer or nutritional advisor there are two essential steps in the scientific rationing
of animals. First, the nutrient requirements of the animal must be assessed; second,
foods must be selected to satisfy these requirements. This balance between supply and
demand is made separately for each nutrient. However, in most cases the nutrient given
top priority is energy. There are good reasons for this. In the first place energy-yielding
constituents of foods such as carbohydrates are those present in the food in the greatest quantity. Consequently, if a diet is formulated to meet the requirement for other nutrients first, but is then found to be deficient in energy, major changes to the foodstuffs
used will probably be required. In contrast, a mineral or vitamin deficiency can often be
rectified very easily by the provision of a concentrated supplement.
A further feature of energy-yielding constituents that distinguishes them from others
is the manner in which animals respond to changes in energy supply. For example,
whereas the performance of a steer gaining at 1.0 kg/day may eventually be reduced if
it is given a diet that is deficient in a particular nutrient, increases in the supply of a single nutrient above the requirement generally have little effect. Increasing the level of
vitamin A supplied to twice the requirement is unlikely to affect its liveweight gain
(although it might increase its vitamin A reserves). However, if the supply of energy is
increased, the animal will attempt to retain more energy either in the form of protein
(if nitrogen intake is adequate) or in the form of fat and its liveweight gain will increase. Energy is the main nutrient limiting animal production, and animals tend to
show a continuous response to changes in energy supply. If other nutrients are present
in quantities that are only just sufficient to meet requirements, then the response to an
increase in energy supply is likely to be an undesirable one. Increasing the storage of
body fat, for example, is likely to increase the requirement for the minerals and vitamins associated with body fat synthesis and therefore precipitate a deficiency of these
nutrients. When formulating diets, it is essential to ensure that the animal’s energy requirement is satisfied and that the correct balance between energy and other nutrients
is maintained.
281
Chapter 12 Evaluation of foods: systems for expressing the energy value of foods
12.1
ENERGY SYSTEMS AND ENERGY MODELS
An energy system is essentially a set of rules relating energy supply to energy requirements. The system can be used either to predict animal performance from a given
level of energy supply or to calculate the energy supply required to promote a particular level of performance. The simplest energy systems consist of two sets of figures, one set reflecting the animal’s energy requirements, and the other set the energy
values of foods. Ideally both sets of figures should be expressed in similar units. For
example, if an animal growing at a rate of 1.0 kg per day stores 15.0 MJ of energy,
then its net energy requirement for growth would be 15.0 MJ/kg gain. If the food to
be given contained 5.0 MJ of net energy per kilogram, then the quantity required can
easily be calculated as 15/5 = 3 kg. In this example, both the animal’s requirement
for energy and the energy value of its food are expressed in terms of net energy
(NE), and the system used is described as a net energy system. We saw in the previous chapter, however, that the NE content of a food is not a fixed value but varies
depending on the species of animal, the productive process and the nature of energy
supply. For example, metabolisable energy supplied by a food is used more efficiently
for maintenance than for growth (or for milk or egg production). Consequently, a
food will have at least two NE values. For this reason, it may be preferable to state the
energy content of foods in units that are less variable, and in fact most energy systems
are based on metabolisable energy (ME) as the measure of energy supply. However,
when food energy supply is expressed as ME and animal energy requirements are
expressed as NE, it is not possible to equate one with the other.To bring them together
an additional factor is needed in the system, the efficiency of ME utilisation (k).
Thus, in the example given above, if the energy content of the food was expressed
as 10.0 MJ ME per kilogram and the efficiency of ME utilisation for growth (kg)
was 0.5, the NE content of the food would be calculated as 10 * 0.5 = 5.0 MJ/kg
as before.
The use of efficiency factors allows energy systems to be more detailed and more
complex than they would be if based solely on energy supply and requirements.
Thus, it would be possible to subdivide food energy supply into that provided by
protein, fat and carbohydrate (energy substrates). Similarly, an animal’s energy requirement could be subdivided into that required for deposition of protein and that
required for the deposition of fat. Different efficiency constants could then be included to represent the biochemical pathways linking energy substrate supply to different forms of energy retention.The system would then be what is commonly called
a ‘model’, although there is no sharp distinction between energy systems and models
(energy systems can be described as simple models). Energy models are often highly
complex and are generally intended as scientific rather than practical tools. They are
designed to incorporate all the relevant scientific information that is currently available, and their operation is useful in identifying gaps in current knowledge. In growing animals they can be used to predict not only energy retention and growth rate
but also the way in which energy is partitioned between different tissues and organs
within an animal’s body. In the case of lactating animals, they can be used to predict
energy partition between different body tissues and milk constituents.
Such complexity is not included in current energy systems. However, the increasing use of computers for ration formulation (even on farm) makes it easier for practical systems to become more complex and detailed without becoming unworkable.
282
Energy systems for ruminants
Nevertheless, in this chapter, the emphasis will be on practical energy systems rather
than models. A book edited by M K Theodorou and J France (2000) (see Further
reading) describes current developments in both systems and models.
Before some actual energy systems are discussed, two further points must be made.
First, as described in the previous chapter, the techniques used to assess the energy
content of foods are often complicated, laborious and expensive. Consequently, they
cannot be applied, for example, to samples of hay or silage supplied by a farmer to
an advisory chemist. For this reason, an essential feature of most energy systems is a
method for predicting the energy content of foods from characteristics than can be
more easily determined in the laboratory. Second, it is important to realise that energy systems for herbivores (ruminants and horses) are more complex than those
used for pigs and poultry. The main reasons for this are the greater complexity of the
digestive tract (see Chapter 8) and the greater variety of foods used.
12.2
ENERGY SYSTEMS FOR RUMINANTS
Early energy systems
Energy systems have a history going back to the first half of the nineteenth century,
but they did not provide an adequate description of energy utilisation until methods
of animal calorimetry became available in the second half of that century. Around
1900, H P Armsby at the University of Pennsylvania and O Kellner at the Möckern
Experiment Station in Germany used the results of their calorimetric studies to
devise energy systems based on the NE value of foods. These systems differed in
some respects, most evidently in the units used. Armsby expressed NE values in
terms of calories (the unit preceding joules), whereas Kellner, believing that farmers
would have difficulty in understanding calories, expressed NE values of foods relative to the NE value of the common food constituent starch. For example, if the NE
value of barley was found to be 1.91 Mcal (megacalories) per kilogram, and that of
starch 2.36 Mcal/kg, then 1 kg of barley was calculated to have a starch equivalent of
1.91/2.36 = 0.81 kg. Both Kellner’s and Armsby’s systems encountered difficulties
because of differences in the NE values of foods for maintenance and growth, etc.,
and they used approximations to avoid these problems. Kellner’s starch equivalent
system was used (mainly in Europe) as the basis of practical rationing systems until
the 1970s.A full description of the starch equivalent system was included in the first
two editions of this book (1966 and 1973).
Armsby’s NE system was incorporated in what was at one time the standard reference work on the feeding of livestock in the USA, F B Morrison’s Feeds and Feeding, but was not much used in practice.The preferred system in the Americas was for
many years the total digestible nutrients (TDN) system. The total digestible nutrient
content of a food was calculated as the combined weight in 100 kg of food of digestible
crude protein and digestible carbohydrate (crude fibre plus nitrogen-free extractives),
plus 2.25 times the weight of digestible ether extract. The ether extract is multiplied
by 2.25 because the energy value of fat is approximately 2.25 times higher than that of
carbohydrate. If the digestible crude protein plus carbohydrate of the hay in Box 10.1
(see p. 239) is calculated as the digestible organic matter minus the digestible ether
extract (i.e. 515 - 8 = 507), then the TDN content would be calculated as 507 + (8 *
2.25) = 525 g/kg, or 52.5 kg/100kg.The TDN system, like Kellner’s starch equivalent
283
Chapter 12 Evaluation of foods: systems for expressing the energy value of foods
system, employed units that were not units of energy. However,TDN values can fairly
easily be translated into ME values. Both systems are now virtually obsolete.
The UK metabolisable energy system
In the UK the energy system currently used for ruminants was first proposed by the
Agricultural Research Council in 1965. The original system was then revised by the
Council in 1980 and published as The Nutrient Requirements of Ruminant Livestock (ARC 1980). In 1982, a working party consisting of research, advisory and
commercial nutritionists was set up to consider and test the ARC 1980 system and
their recommendations, published in 1990, were implemented in the UK by means
of an advisory manual entitled Energy and Protein Requirements of Ruminants in
1993. In 2004 an improved system, designed specifically for dairy cows, Feed into
Milk, was introduced (see Further reading). The description of the system provided
here is initially restricted to its essential features and its simplest forms of operation.
The versions of the system that are used in practice include some modifications that
will be discussed later. The system allows for the factorial calculation of the energy
requirements of six classes of livestock (cattle and sheep that are growing, pregnant
or lactating), but the examples given in this chapter will be restricted to growing and
lactating cattle.The energy requirements of the other classes of ruminants are referred
to in later chapters.
In the UK metabolisable energy system, the energy values of foods are expressed in
terms of ME, and the ME value of a diet is calculated by adding together the relative
contributions from the foods making up that diet.The energy requirements of animals
are expressed in absolute terms, as NE. The essential feature of the system, linking
energy supply with requirements, is a series of equations to predict the efficiencies
of ME utilisation (k) for maintenance, pregnancy, growth and lactation (Table 12.1).
These predictions are based on the ME concentration of the diet (M/D), although this
is expressed as the fraction ME/GE (sometimes called metabolisability), rather than
MJ/kg DM. Metabolisability can be calculated by dividing the ME content of the diet
by its GE content, making the assumption that the mean gross energy value of food is
18.4 MJ/kg DM (although this factor is too high for foods with a high ash content and
too low for those with a high protein or fat content). The efficiency values presented
in Table 12.1 illustrate several points made earlier (in this chapter and in Chapter 11).
Table 12.1 Efficiency of metabolisable energy utilisation by ruminants for
maintenance, pregnancy, growth and lactation
Dietary ME concentration (MJ/kg DM)
Metabolisability (qm)
Maintenance (km)
Pregnancy (kc )a
Growth (kg)
Lactation (kl)
Equations: km = 0.35qm + 0.503
kg = 0.78qm + 0.006
kl = 0.35qm + 0.420
a
284
Constant value with no influence of qm.
7.4
9.2
11.0
12.9
0.4
0.643
0.133
0.218
0.560
0.5
0.678
0.133
0.396
0.595
0.6
0.714
0.133
0.474
0.630
0.7
0.750
0.133
0.552
0.665
Energy systems for ruminants
Although km and kl vary with metabolisability (qm), they vary much less than kg. Put
another way, kg for a low-quality food (qm = 0.4) is 50 per cent of km, whereas kg for
a high-quality food (qm = 0.7) is 74 per cent of km.
The system can be used in two ways, either to predict the performance of animals
given a specific ration or to formulate a ration for a desired level of performance.
Operation of the system is illustrated for beef cattle in Boxes 12.1 and 12.2 and an
example of ration formulation for dairy cows is presented in Box 12.3. Ration formulation is often more difficult than prediction of performance because the ME concentration of the ration cannot be calculated until the ration has been formulated.
This means that for factors that are dependent on qm, provisional data must be used
initially, and the calculations have to be repeated until the factors and diet match
each other.The repetition of calculations (known as iteration) is easily carried out by
a computer, but if a computer is not available the approximate method illustrated in
Box 12.2 can be used. For convenience, the example in Box 12.2 starts at the end
point of the example in Box 12.1.
A new term required for Box 12.2 is kmp, the average efficiency with which ME is
used for the combined functions of maintenance and production. This factor will be
intermediate to km and kg and its value will vary depending on the production level
BOX 12.1 Prediction of performance in growing cattle
A 300 kg steer is offered a ration containing 4.5 kg hay (DM 890 g/kg; ME 8.0 MJ/kg DM) and
2.2 kg of a cereal-based concentrate (DM 900 g/kg; ME 14.0 MJ/kg DM).
Calculation of energy supply (MJ ME/day)
Fresh intake (kg/day)
Dry matter intake (kg/day)
ME intake (MJ/day)
Hay
Concentrate
4.5
2.2
4.0
2.0
32
28
Total
6.7
6.0
60
ME concentration of the ration (MJ/kg DM)
Metabolisability (qm)
(60/6)
(10.0/18.4)
10.0
0.54
Calculation of energy requirements (MJ NE/day)
Maintenance (MJ/day)
Liveweight gain (MJ/kg gain)
km (from Table 12.1)
kg (from Table 12.1)
23.0
15.0
0.692
0.427
Prediction of performance
ME requirement for maintenance (MJ/day)
ME available for gain (MJ/day)
NE gained (MJ/day)
Liveweight gain (kg/day)
(23/0.692)
(60 - 33)
(27 * 0.427)
(11.5/15.0)
33.0
27.0
11.5
0.77
285
Chapter 12 Evaluation of foods: systems for expressing the energy value of foods
BOX 12.2 Ration formulation for growing cattle
A 300 kg steer is required to grow at a rate of 0.77 kg/day on a diet consisting of 3.0 kg hay (DM
890 g/kg; ME 8.0 MJ/kg DM) and an unknown quantity of concentrate (DM 900 g/kg;
ME 14.0 MJ/kg DM).
Calculation of energy requirement (MJ NE/day)
Maintenance
Liveweight gain (0.77 kg/day)
23.0
11.5
Total
34.5
Food and efficiency data
Metabolisability (qm)
km
kg
kmp
Net energy (MJ/kg DM)
Hay
Concentrate
0.435
0.655
0.345
0.504
4.03
0.760
0.769
0.599
0.703
9.84
Ration formulation
NE supplied from hay (MJ/day)
NE required from concentrate (MJ/day)
Concentrate DM required (kg/day)
Fresh concentrate required (kg/day)
(3 * 0.89 * 4.03)
34.5 – 10.80
23.7兾9.84
2.4兾0.9
10.8
23.7
2.4
2.7
Therefore, the ration required should consist of 3.0 kg hay and 2.7 kg concentrate per day.
of the animal. It is calculated from the relative requirements of NE for maintenance
and production by the following formula:
kmp = (NEm + NEg)>(NEm>km + NEg>kg)
The relative proportions of NE required for maintenance and production, calculated
as (NEm + NEg)兾NEm, is sometimes referred to as animal production level (APL). In
this example, the APL would be calculated as: (23 + 11.5)兾23 = 1.5.
Prediction of performance in dairy cows is more difficult than in growing cattle
and is complicated by the fact that cows are often gaining or losing weight at the
same time as producing milk. In order to predict milk production, estimates of both
milk composition and liveweight change, are required. Similarly, in order to predict
liveweight change, an estimate of milk production would be required. In reality, cows
are likely to partition energy supply between different body tissues and milk constituents, and predicting how they will respond to changes in energy supply presents
an ongoing challenge to nutritional research.
Ration formulation for dairy cows can be as complicated as it is for beef cattle because the efficiency of ME utilisation for lactation varies with diet M/D and qm (see
286
Energy systems for ruminants
Table 12.1). However, in practice, some simplification is possible because the energy
concentration of dairy cow diets does not vary over such a wide range as that of
growing cattle, and it is reasonable to assume constant values. If km is assumed to be
0.72 and kl is assumed to be 0.62, then ration formulation becomes relatively easy
(see Box 12.3). The gross energy content of milk, and therefore the NE required for
milk production, varies depending on its fat and protein content. In Box 12.3 the fat
and protein content of the milk are assumed to be 40 g/kg and 32 g/kg, respectively,
and the corresponding NE requirement for milk production is 3.12 MJ/kg. In practice, it is also important to formulate diets that meet the animal’s energy requirements at the lowest cost, within the constraint of dry matter intake (DMI). This can
be done by computer using a mathematical technique known as linear programming.
However, a simple method of doing this, assuming that silage is the cheapest ration
component, is illustrated in Box 12.3. Ration formulation for dairy cows is often
BOX 12.3 Ration formulation for dairy cows
A 600 kg cow is required to produce 30 l of milk per day (40 g/kg fat and 32 g/kg protein) on a ration
consisting of grass silage (DM 250 g/kg; ME 10.5 MJ/kg DM) and dairy concentrate (DM 860 g/kg;
ME 13.0 MJ/kg DM). It is anticipated that the cow will consume 18.0 kg DM/day.
Calculation of energy requirements (MJ/day)
Maintenance
Milk production
30 * 3.12
Total
NE
k
ME
41.0
93.6
0.72
0.62
57.0
152.0
134.6
ME concentration of the ration (MJ/kg DM)
Metabolisability (qm)
209.0
209.0兾18.0
11.6兾18.4
11.6
0.63
Ration formulation
The relative proportions of silage and dairy concentrate required to satisfy the energy requirements
within the constraint of dry matter intake can be calculated using the following equation:
Forage DM = (DMI * (MC - M>D))>(MC - MF)
where DMI = dry matter intake (kg), MC = ME content of the concentrate (MJ/kg DM), MF = ME
content of the forage (MJ/kg DM) and M/D = energy concentration in ration required (MJ/kg DM).
Silage DM (kg/day)
Concentrate DM (kg/day)
Fresh silage (kg/day)
Fresh concentrate (kg/day)
(18.0 * (13.0 - 11.6))兾(13.0 - 10.5)
(18.0 - 10.1)
(10.1兾0.25)
(7.9兾0.86)
10.1
7.9
40.4
9.2
Therefore, the ration required should consist of 40.4 kg silage and 9.2 kg dairy concentrate per day.
287
Chapter 12 Evaluation of foods: systems for expressing the energy value of foods
complicated by changes in body energy reserves. If cows are gaining weight and storing body energy as fat, then their requirements need to be considered in term of
three components: maintenance, milk production and tissue gain.Alternatively, if cows
are losing weight, then allowance must be made for the energy contributed from
mobilisation of body fat reserves towards milk production.
Refinements of the UK metabolisable energy system
As the food intake of an animal increases, the metabolisability of the food declines
owing to an increase in rate of passage and a reduction in rumen retention time (see
p. 260). Food intake can be defined as level of feeding, which is the ME intake relative to that required for maintenance.Thus, in Box 12.1 the level of feeding would be
calculated as 60/33 = 1.82. It must be noted, however, that this is not exactly the
same as the animal production level (APL), as the former is calculated in ME and the
latter in NE. For growing cattle the level of feeding is commonly 2–2.5, but for lactating
dairy cows and ewes it rises to 3–5. In the current version of the ME system, the ME
requirement of lactating ewes (and until recently cows) is increased by 1.8 per cent
for each unit increase in level of feeding above 1. Thus, for ewes with a level of feeding of 3, the calculated ME requirement would be increased by 2 * 1.8 = 3.6 per cent
to account for the effects of increasing food intake on the ME content of the ration (although it would be more logical to apply this correction for feeding level to the supply side of the system).The effect of animal species (sheep v. cattle) and feeding level
on the ME concentration of foods has recently been re-evaluated. As a result, in the
Feed into Milk system (FiM) (see Thomas 2004), it is recommended that the ME concentration of foods fed at high production levels to dairy cows should only be reduced by 2 per cent compared with values determined at maintenance with sheep.
As suggested in Chapter 11, increasing the energy intake of growing animals has
been shown to result in a progressive reduction in energy retention. This curvilinearity indicates an effect of level of feeding on the efficiency of ME utilisation. For
growing cattle kg is assumed to have its normal predicted level when the level of
feeding is twice maintenance. However, if the level of feeding is greater than this kg
is reduced, and if the level of feeding is less than this kg is increased. For example, if
cattle on a diet containing 10 MJ/kg DM are fed at 2.5 times maintenance, kg would
be reduced from 0.43 to 0.39. The same correction applies to growing lambs. In the
current version of the ME system the curvilinear relationship between net energy retention (R) and ME intake (I) in growing animals, both scaled by fasting metabolism,
is described as follows:
R = B(1 - e - kI) - I
where B = km/(km - kg) and k = km * ln(km/kg).
Another refinement to the ME system that has been advocated but not generally
adopted is to modify kg depending on the nature of the diet. Evidence suggests that
in addition to varying with diet metabolisability and productive process, kg also varies
with the nature of the diet. For example, when diets containing 11 MJ/kg DM are formulated from high-quality forage, or poorer-quality forage plus concentrates, the
concentrate-based diet will have a kg value that is about 5 per cent higher than that
of the forage-based diet. Within forages, there is evidence that kg values are greater
for temperate first-growth (spring) material than later growths with the same ME
concentration, and are higher for temperate than for tropical forages. However, it is
288
Energy systems for ruminants
difficult to classify diets into different categories, and consequently the single equation presented in Table 12.1 is used in the current version of the ME system.
The ME system as presented provides a sound basis for the scientific rationing of
ruminant animals. However, evidence suggests that it does not adequately describe
the energy requirements of modern high genetic merit dairy cows. Consequently, FiM
2004 using a database of calorimetric measurements from high genetic merit cows
given diets representative of UK feeding practices, adopted a different approach to
the calculation of ME requirements based on modelling the relationship between
milk energy output (El) and ME intake. Using this approach, the efficiency of ME
utilisation for lactation (kl) is defined as follows:
kl =
milk energy derived from dietary ME
dietary ME available for milk production
For example, if a group of dairy cows were producing 35 l/day of milk containing
3.2 MJ/l, then milk energy output would be 109 MJ/day. If these same cows had a
dietary ME intake available for milk production of 175 MJ/day, then kl would be
calculated as 109/175 = 0.622. For cows that are gaining weight (positive energy balance), dietary ME available for milk production is calculated by subtracting the ME
used for weight gain. Similarly, for cows that are losing weight (negative energy balance), milk energy output is reduced by subtracting the net energy derived from
weight loss. In order to make these adjustments, an iterative statistical approach was
used to determine the efficiency of body energy utilisation for lactation (kt) and the
efficiency of ME utilisation for gain (kg) to be 0.78 and 0.65, respectively. Once these
values had been obtained and ME intake and milk energy output adjusted accordingly, a curvilinear relationship between dietary ME intake available for milk production and milk energy output derived from dietary ME was obtained (Fig. 12.1).
The approach adopted by FiM 2004 for calculating the ME requirement of dairy cows
involves first calculating the ME requirement for weight gain, or the net energy available for milk production from weight loss, and then calculating the ME requirement
Milk energy derived from ME
1.2
k1 = Δy/Δx
1.0
0.8
Δy
0.6
Δx
0.4
0.2
0.0
−0.2
0.2
0.6
1.0
1.4
1.8
2.2
MEI directed towards milk production
−0.4
Fig. 12.1 Relationship between milk energy derived from metabolisable energy
intake (MJ/kg W 0.75) and metabolisable energy directed towards milk production
(MJ/kg W 0.75).
From Thomas C 2004 Feed into Milk: A New Applied Feeding System for Dairy Cows, Nottingham,
Nottingham University Press.
289
Chapter 12 Evaluation of foods: systems for expressing the energy value of foods
for maintenance and milk production from milk energy output corrected for weight
loss (Elcorr). The ME required for weight gain (MgFiM) is calculated from the NE
requirement for gain (EVg) as follows:
MgFiM = (EVg * weight gain)>kg
Similarly, the NE for milk production derived from weight loss (ElWC) is calculated as follows:
ElWC = EVg * weight loss * kt
The ME required for maintenance and production (Mml, (MJ/kg W0.75)) is calculated as follows:
Mml = (loge((5.06 - Elcorr)>(5.06 + 0.453)))> - 0.1326
where Elcorr = (El + ElWC)兾W0.75.
Although the approach adopted by FiM 2004 is fundamentally different from the
factorial approach adopted by the ME system, it utilises existing information and
provides a sound biological framework for the incorporation of new developments.
In its review of the ME system in 1990, the working party referred to earlier concluded that the system generally underestimated the ME requirements of growing
cattle (but not other classes of ruminants) and recommended that the energy requirement for growth (but not maintenance) should be increased by 10–15 per cent.
In contrast, initial validation of FiM 2004 suggests that it slightly overpredicts ME
requirements. Consequently, it is recommended that 10 MJ per day is subtracted
from the calculated ME requirement of dairy cows. In both cases, the source of error
is unknown, but although it seems undesirable to introduce arbitrary correction factors into otherwise logical systems, it is important that both systems accurately
reflect levels of performance achieved in practice.
Alternative energy systems for ruminants
The Australian Standing Committee on Agriculture’s feeding standards for ruminants
(CSIRO 1990), based on the ARC 1980 system, have been revised and updated (CSIRO
2007).The differences between the Australian and ARC systems mainly reflect differences in animal production systems between the two countries, the Australian system
being intended mainly for use with grazing animals.To this effect, the Australian system incorporates refined estimates of maintenance requirements that include the
energy costs of grazing and employs refined estimates of kg for forage diets, which
take into account the poorer efficiency of ME utilisation from tropical and latergrowth temperate forages. The system also includes an estimate of the efficiency of
ME utilisation for wool growth (kwool, 0.18). Finally, the Australian system makes no
corrections to kg for level of feeding, but for all classes of stock there is a positive
correction to the maintenance requirement as total ME intake rises above the maintenance level; this correction increases the maintenance requirement by 10 per cent
at a feeding level of twice maintenance.
In 1988 the European Association of Animal Production carried out a survey of
the feeding systems in use in European countries. The report on energy systems for
ruminants (see Van der Honing and Alderman in Further reading) demonstrated the
wide variety of systems in use in Europe, and it is not possible to describe all of them
here. The Netherlands, Belgium, France, Germany, Switzerland, Italy and Austria all
290
Energy systems for ruminants
have systems with many features in common. However, the Dutch system will be described here as an example. The ME content of foods is calculated from digestible
nutrients and is then converted to a NE value. For growing animals, the basis for this
conversion is that the animal production level (see p. 286) is assumed to be constant
at 1.5, and hence that kmp, as explained earlier in this chapter, has a unique value for
a food of known ME concentration. Each food can therefore be given a single NE
value for maintenance and production (NEmp), but this is converted to a unit value
by dividing it by the presumed NEmp of barley (6.9 MJ/kg, or about 8 MJ/kg DM). For
lactating cows a corresponding NE value for maintenance and lactation is calculated
by assuming that kl is 0.60 when diet qm = 0.57 (i.e. when M/D = 10.5 MJ/kg DM)
and varies by 0.4 per cent with every unit change in diet qm. For example, if diet
M/D = 11.5 and qm = 0.62, kl = 0.60 + (0.4 * (0.62 - 0.57)) = 0.62 and the NE value
of the food for lactation (NEl) = 11.5 * 0.62 = 7.1 MJ/kg DM. The calculation is further complicated by reducing the predicted value of NEl by 2.5 per cent to allow for
the normally high feeding level of dairy cows, and by converting NEl to a unit value
(barley again being assuming to contain 6.9 MJ NE/kg). In addition to being used for
cows, NEl values are used in the rationing of younger dairy animals (i.e. heifers being
used as dairy replacements).
The simplifying assumptions made by the Dutch scheme to calculate the NE values of foods are therefore that (1) for growing animals APL = 1.5 and (2) for growing
heifers, kmp = kl.A third assumption, which is not stated but is implicit in the system,
is that km = kl. All three assumptions are liable to introduce inaccuracies that are allowed for by adjusting the NE requirements of animals. For example, with regard to
assumption (2), it is recognised that in slowly growing heifers, where most of the energy intake is used for maintenance, kl is an underestimate of kmp, whereas in rapidly
growing heifers kl is an overestimate of kmp. The NE requirements of slow-growing
heifers have therefore been reduced and those of fast-growing heifers increased to
cancel out these biases in the estimation of the NE values of foods.
The energy systems grouped with the Dutch system are similar to it in principle,
but differ in detail. Thus, the ME values of foods may be calculated by different procedures, with different corrections being applied to account for the effects of level of
feeding. In addition, the units employed may be MJ of energy rather than unit values. For example, in Switzerland, the units are MJ of NE. Several countries in
Scandinavia have adopted NE systems that are based on Kellner’s starch equivalent
system but now use Scandinavian feed units (Norway and Finland) or fattening feed
units (Denmark), although Sweden uses a ME system.
Having used a system based on total digestible nutrients (see p. 283) for many
years, the USA has now changed to NE systems for beef and dairy cattle. These systems are described in publications of the National Research Council (see Further
reading). Metabolisable energy is calculated as 0.82 * DE and DE is calculated as
4.409 Mcal (18.45 MJ) per kilogram of TDN. For beef cattle, foods are given NE values for both maintenance (NEm) and gain (NEg), calculated from the ME content
(Mcal/kg DM) of the food using the following equations:
NEm = (1.37 ME) - (0.138 ME2) + (0.0105 ME3) - 1.12
NEg = (1.42 ME) - (0.174 ME2) + (0.0122 ME3) - 1.65
These equations predict the NEm and NEg values of a food containing 11.0 MJ ME/kg
DM (2.63 Mcal) to be 7.2 and 4.6 MJ/kg DM, respectively, compared with values
291
Chapter 12 Evaluation of foods: systems for expressing the energy value of foods
calculated using the UK ME system (derived from Table 12.1) of 7.8 and 5.2 MJ/kg
DM, respectively. For a poor-quality food containing 7.4 MJ ME/kg DM (1.77 Mcal),
NEm and NEg values calculated using the US system would be 3.9 and 1.6 MJ/kg DM,
and corresponding values derived using the UK system would be 4.8 and 2.4 MJ/kg
DM, respectively. Thus, values calculated using the US system are considerably lower
than those derived using the UK system, particularly for poor-quality foods.
In the US system, NE values for lactation (NEl) are calculated from TDN, DE or
NE by an equation similar to that used in the Dutch system. For example, in the US
system, foods containing 10 or 12 MJ ME/kg DM would be calculated to provide 6.0
and 7.1 MJ NEl/kg DM, respectively, whereas in the Dutch system, they would be
calculated to provide 5.8 and 7.2 MJ NEl/kg DM, respectively. Net energy requirements for body maintenance and milk synthesis are expressed as NEl, as they are in
the Dutch and related European systems.
The US NE systems for both beef and dairy cattle are currently being modified
to incorporate the Cornell net carbohydrate and protein system referred to in
Chapter 1. This system includes calculations of both the energy and protein values of feeds. The principle on which it operates is that if the quantity and characteristics (such as solubility) of each nutrient present in the food are known, then
the rate at which it can be digested and the products of digestion that are absorbed from the rumen and lower gut can be calculated. The energy and protein
values of these products can then be summed to give an estimate of the values
of the food as a whole. To be operated efficiently, the system requires unusually
detailed analytical data for the foods being used (see Box 1.1 in Chapter 1). Thus,
carbohydrates in foods are divided into two kinds of fibre (fermentable or not
fermentable in the rumen) and two kinds of non-fibrous components (starch and
sugars). Proteins are similarly divided into five fractions, which vary in the rates
at which they are degraded in the rumen. In the latest versions of the US National Research Council publications referred to above, the procedures of the
Cornell system are offered as an alternative to simpler methods of calculating NE
values from ME values. The latest US system for dairy cows is mentioned in
Chapter 16.
Future energy systems for ruminants
The first edition of this book was published in 1966 at a time when older energy
systems such as Kellner’s starch equivalent system were being re-evaluated in light
of newly acquired calorimetric data and new systems, such as the UK ME system,
were being introduced. The hope at the time was that new information on energy
metabolism would help to produce a more accurate system that might be less complicated and therefore more acceptable for international use. In the event, this hope
has not been fully realised. Greater accuracy may perhaps have been achieved, but
at the expense of greater complexity and an increase in the number of systems
being used.
The energy systems for ruminants that have been most improved are those relating to the lactating dairy cow. As the reader will now appreciate, energy systems can
accommodate the dairy cow better than they can growing cattle (or sheep). The efficiency of ME utilisation varies less in dairy cows than in growing animals, and the
energy content of the product (milk) is less variable and more predictable than is the
case with liveweight gain. A number of studies have compared energy systems for
292
Energy systems for ruminants
110
S/R ratio (%)
105
100
95
90
85
80
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Metabolisable energy (UK, MAFF 1975)
Metabolisable energy (Sweden)
Metabolisable energy (UK, ARC 1980)
Net energy lactation (Netherlands)
Net energy fattening (Rostock)
Net energy lactation (France)
Net energy lactation (USA)
Feed units (Finland)
Feed units (Denmark)
Fig. 12.2 Comparison of energy systems for predicting the requirement of dairy
cows. The S/R ratio, calculated by dividing the energy intake by the calculated
energy requirement, describes how precisely each system predicts energy
requirements.
Adapted from Kaustell K et al. 1997 Livestock Production Science 51: 255.
dairy cows, and the results of one such study are presented in Fig. 12.2. In this study,
a data set of 51 milk production trials representing 261 diets was used to compare
energy supply (S) with calculated energy requirements (R) for nine different energy
systems.The S/R ratio, calculated by dividing the energy intake by the calculated energy requirement, and expressed as a percentage, describes how precisely each system predicts dietary energy supply. This study illustrates that although some systems
appear to be slightly better than others, most do not differ greatly.
Current energy system for dairy cows, whether based on ME or NE, do not consider
the characteristics of energy substrate supply. In contrast, mechanistic models are able
to take into account the site of digestion, the type of nutrients absorbed and the nutrients required for milk component synthesis. Consequently, they may be better able
to predict both nutrient supply and requirements. Figure 12.3 presents the results of
study designed to compare the ability of the Dutch NE system, the UK ME system
(AFRC 1993), the Feed into Milk system (FiM 2004) and a mechanistic model to
predict energy (or nutrient) requirements and supply for milk production from grassbased diets. For all systems, energy (or nutrient) supply exceeded requirements,
although the extent of oversupply was greater for the AFRC 1993 system (11.4 per
cent) compared with the FiM 2004 system (8.5 per cent) and the Dutch NE system
(6.4 per cent). However, for the mechanistic model, the predicted supply of glucogenic nutrients was on average only 2.6 per cent higher than the requirement.
293
Chapter 12 Evaluation of foods: systems for expressing the energy value of foods
(a)
(b)
250
Energy requirement (MJ/day)
Energy requirement (kVEM/day)
22
20
18
16
14
230
210
190
170
14
16
18
20
22
Energy supply (kVEM/day)
170
190
210
230
Energy supply (MJ/day)
(d)
(c)
2400
Nutrient requirement (g/day)
250
Energy requirement (MJ/day)
250
230
210
190
170
170
190
210
230
Energy supply (MJ/day)
250
2200
2000
1800
1600
1600 1800 2000 2200 2400
Nutrient supply (g/day)
Fig. 12.3 Comparison of the supply and requirement for energy or glucogenic
nutrients for grass-based diets using (a) the Dutch NE system, (b) the UK ME
system, (c) the FiM system and (d) the mechanistic model. The solid line represents
the linear regression between supply and requirement, and the dashed line is the
line of unity that represents a perfect match between supply and requirement.
From Dijkstra J et al. 2008 Animal Feed Science and Technology 143: 203.
In the future, as energy systems become more complex to incorporate new information, and the need for simplicity is reduced by the increasing availability of computers,
energy systems are likely to become parts of much larger mathematical models of nutrient requirements that are capable of dealing simultaneously with energy, amino
acids, vitamins and minerals (and with the interactions between them). Complex systems tend to obscure the principles upon which they are based. Consequently, students of animal nutrition should pay particular attention to the principles of energy
metabolism outlined in the previous chapter and at the same time familiarise themselves with the energy systems currently used in their own countries.
294
Energy systems for pigs and poultry
12.3
ENERGY SYSTEMS FOR PIGS AND POULTRY
Energy systems for pigs and poultry are less complicated than those for ruminants,
in both their derivation and application. One reason for this is that, because pigs and
poultry digest cellulose to a limited extent, they are limited to a range of foods that vary
little in their ME concentration. It is also generally considered that in pigs and poultry
the efficiency of ME utilisation differs to a relatively small extent between foods. A
further reason is that, unlike ruminants, pigs and poultry are less commonly rationed
for a given level of production and are usually fed to appetite in the hope that they
will achieve maximum rates of meat or egg production. Nevertheless, the energy
concentration of foods and diets remains an important consideration because animals tend to adjust their intake to provide a constant energy supply (see Chapter 17).
If the energy concentration of the diet is increased (for example, by adding fat), then
non-ruminant animals tend to reduce their intake. Therefore, if no adjustment is
made to the concentrations of amino acids or other nutrients, they are likely to suffer deficiencies. In the practical rationing of pigs and poultry, the energy concentration of the diet is considered to be more important than the energy requirement of
the animal.
An NE system for pigs was first introduced at the same time as the starch equivalent system for ruminants (by G Fingerling, Kellner’s successor at the Möckern
Experimental Station), and revised versions of this, or alternative NE systems, have
been used in a few European countries until the present day. However, most countries, including the USA and the UK, have based their energy systems for pigs on either DE or ME, although these two are closely related (ME = 0.96 DE). However,
over the past 15 years, the greater range of foods available for inclusion in pig diets,
including fibrous by-products, has prompted further development of NE systems. As
a measure of energy supply, NE is far superior to DE (or ME) if there are differences
between foods in the efficiency of ME utilisation. For many pig diets, the efficiency
of ME utilisation is reasonably constant; for example,Table 11.6 in Chapter 11 shows
that the efficiency of ME utilisation for growth (kg) is close to 0.71. Fibrous foods
provide an exception, as the end products of fermentative digestion are used less
efficiently in the pig than is glucose absorbed from the small intestine (as they are in
ruminants). In 1981, the UK Agricultural Research Council, in its publication the
Nutrient Requirements of Pigs, suggested that the production of methane and heat
loss associated with the metabolism of volatile fatty acids reduced the NE value of
‘fermented’ DE to no more than two-thirds of the DE derived from energy substrates
absorbed from the small intestine.
It is also well recognised that when kg is subdivided into separate factors for deposition of protein (kp) and fat (kf), these factors are different. Consequently, separate
values for kp (0.56) and kf (0.74) have been used to calculate the energy requirement of pigs for growth in both the US and the UK systems. This difference has become increasingly important because of the breeding policy of selecting pigs to store
less fat and more protein.
As stated above, until recently, the energy system used for pigs in the UK was
based on DE. However, after extensive consultation with the industry and other
stakeholders, an NE system was introduced in 2003 (see Further reading). In this
system, both energy requirements and the energy value of foods are expressed in
terms of NE. As explained previously (see Chapter 10), the NE value of a food is
295
Chapter 12 Evaluation of foods: systems for expressing the energy value of foods
essentially the animal’s basal metabolic rate and energy required for protein and
lipid retention, which is calculated by multiplying the ME value of the food by the
efficiency of ME utilisation. However, as the efficiency of ME utilisation varies depending on energy substrate supply, the balance of processes (basal metabolism,
protein and lipid retention) and the physiological state of the animal, the NE
value of a food depends on both the characteristics of the food and those of the
animal to which it is fed. In the UK system, different NE values of foods are calculated for growing pigs and lactating sows, and for pregnant sows, based on the
measured DE or digestible nutrient composition of foods using prediction equations
as follows:
NE (MJ>kg DM) = (0.0121 DCP) + (0.0350 DEE) + (0.0143 ST)
+ (0.0116 S) + (0.0086 Dres)
NE (MJ>kg DM) = (0.703 DE) + (0.0066 EE) + (0.0020 ST)
+ (0.0041 CP) + (0.0041 CF)
where ST, S, EE and CF indicate starch, sugars, ether extract and crude fibre, and DCP
and DEE indicate digestible crude protein and digestible ether extract. Dres indicates
digestible organic matter minus other digestible nutrients used in the equation.
Consequently, the NE values of foods high in protein and non-starch polysaccharides are lower compared with those high in starch and fats. Similarly, NE values of
foods are lower for growing pigs and lactating sows compared with those for pregnant sows (see Appendix A2.2.2). The NE system provides a more appropriate
framework than the previous DE system for matching animal energy requirements
with energy supply from foods.
The first comprehensive energy system for poultry was developed in the USA by
Fraps, who used the comparative slaughter technique to measure energy retention
in young chickens. The figures obtained were called ‘productive energy values’ to
emphasise that they were NE values for growth rather than maintenance. Fraps also
devised methods for predicting the energy value of poultry foods from either their
gross or digestible nutrient composition. Fraps’s productive energy values were used
by some nutritionists to formulate diets until the early 1970s, but they were never
widely accepted, and in most parts of the world ME has been used to express the
energy value of poultry foods. The use of ME is justified by the fact that commercial poultry production in different parts of the world is very similar, with both
broiler and layer stock being produced by a small number of multinational breeding
companies and subject to similar husbandry methods. As a consequence, their
NE requirements are relatively consistent and, given the range of foods normally
included in poultry diets, the efficiency of ME utilisation does not vary to any great
extent. However, modern poultry production is highly competitive, and recent
calorimetric studies have indicated that different energy substrates may be used
with different efficiencies. In particular, ME supplied as fat is used more efficiently
than ME supplied as carbohydrate or protein. As a result, there has been renewed
interest in NE systems for poultry, which would include equations for predicting NE
values from ME values, but these have not been adopted (see Further reading). The
fact that ME is so easily measured in poultry as both faeces and urine are voided
together is undoubtedly a strong factor favouring its retention in energy systems
for poultry.
296
Energy systems for horses
12.4
ENERGY SYSTEMS FOR HORSES
At one time, the US National Research Council used total digestible nutrients to express both the energy requirements and energy value of foods for horses. However,
there are now two main energy systems available for use with horses. In most parts
of the world, including the Americas, Australasia and parts of Europe (including the
UK), the system used is based on DE, but in France over the past 20 years a system
based on NE has been developed. The original DE system, first published by the National Research Council in 1989, was revised and reprinted in 2007. In the DE system, both energy requirements and energy supply are expressed in terms of DE, and
DE requirements are calculated using a factorial approach similar to that adopted for
ruminants. However, because the number of feeding trials conducted with horses is
limited, and the database of measured DE values for foods is smaller than for ruminants, food DE values are often predicted from their chemical composition.
The French NE system was originally developed by the Institut National de la
Recherche Agronomique in 1984. In this system, both animal requirements and the
energy supply are expressed as Unite Fouragère Cheval (UFC; horse feed units). One
UFC is equivalent to the NE contained in 1 kg of barley (9.414 MJ). The system relies on maintenance being the major energy requirement of horses and therefore assumes that only one NE value for each food is required. To calculate NE values for
foods, the system utilises information on the gross energy values of foods and their
digestibility, the efficiency of conversion of DE to ME, the relative proportions of different energy substrates absorbed and the efficiency of energy substrate utilisation.
The organic matter digestibility (OMD) and DE values of foods are predicted from
OMD values determined in sheep.The efficiency of conversion of ME to DE depends
on the extent of energy losses in urine and methane. In horses, urine and methane
loses are much lower and less variable than in ruminants, with typical values being
4.26 per cent and 1–4 per cent for urine and methane, respectively. However, reliable
prediction of urine and methane losses has proved difficult and DE : ME ratios are
predicted from food composition, with typical values being 0.90–0.95 for cereals,
0.84–0.88 for forages, legume seeds and cereal by-products, and 0.78–0.80 for
oilseed meals. Because of the structure of the equine digestive tract (see Chapter 8),
the nature of the energy substrates available for absorption depends on the chemical
composition of the food consumed and the site of digestion. Foods with the same DE
value may contribute different energy substrates. In the French NE system, energy
substrates (glucose, long-chain fatty acids and amino acids) absorbed in the small
intestine are estimated from the enzymatic digestion of food components, based
on measured values in horses and those derived from studies with pigs and ruminants. The undigested food residue that leaves the small intestine is then subjected
to microbial fermentation in the hind gut and volatile fatty acid production is estimated from whole-tract OMD minus OM digested in the small intestine. The relative proportions of different VFAs produced are then predicted from the fibre
content of foods. Finally, the efficiency of ME utilisation for maintenance (km) is
calculated as follows:
km = 0.85 EGL + 0.80 ELCFA + 0.70 EAA + (0.63 to 0.68) EVFA
where EGL, ELCFC, EAA and EVFA represent the energy absorbed as glucose, long-chain
fatty acids, amino acids and volatile fatty acids, respectively.
297
Chapter 12 Evaluation of foods: systems for expressing the energy value of foods
Because horses cannot ruminate, they spend twice as long as ruminants chewing
their food, with a consequent energy cost, which depends on the physical form and
nature of the food consumed. The NE system also takes into account the energy cost
of eating in assessing km.
Both the DE and NE systems have their strengths and limitations. Owing to the
complexity of digestion and metabolism in horses, the relationship between DE and
NE for a range of foods is poor. For example, forages are normally digested by microbial fermentation in the hind gut, with associated energy losses as methane, heat of
fermentation and the efficiency of utilisation of volatile fatty acids. On the other
hand, cereals are normally digested in the small intestine, with energy being absorbed
and metabolised as glucose, with fewer energy losses. Consequently, the DE system
overestimates energy supply from high-fibre feeds and underestimates energy supply
from high-starch feeds. However, this bias is reduced when mixed diets are fed. In
the NE system, NE values are based on predicting the proportions of different energy
substrates absorbed. However, no account is taken of the effects of different feeds
and feeding methods on the site and extent of digestion, or nutrient uptake. For
example, the level of feeding and the extent of processing have been shown to
have a major impact on pre-caecal starch digestion and the relative proportions of
glucose and volatile fatty acids absorbed. In the NE system, the use of a single NE
value for foods based on the efficiency of ME utilisation for maintenance is justified by the fact that maintenance accounts for approximately 50–90 per cent of the
energy required by lactating and pregnant horses and 60–90 per cent of the energy
required by growing and working horses. However, it is unlikely that ME will be
used with the same efficiency for all physiological processes, and failure to account
for differences between processes may introduce errors into the system for particular types of horse, such as those undertaking heavy work or growing rapidly.
Overall, both the DE and NE systems appear to produce similar results. However,
although the NE system provides a sound theoretical framework for matching energy supply to requirement and can readily incorporate new information, it is
complex and may be considered incomplete. In addition, the use of barley as a
reference feed may be confusing in parts of the world where barley is not commonly fed to horses. The DE system has the practical advantage that more is
known about predicting the DE value of foods from their chemical composition; it
is also simple and therefore better understood by nutritionists, veterinarians and
horse owners.
12.5
PREDICTING THE ENERGY VALUE OF FOODS
The precision of any energy system depends on the accuracy with which the energy
content of individual foods or diets can be estimated. The ME content of grass
silage, for example, varies from perhaps 8.0 MJ/kg DM to 12.5 MJ/kg DM, depending on the type of grass from which it is made and the silage-making processes employed. A farmer wishing to assess silage quality may be able to get an approximate
indication of its energy value by identifying the silage type and referring to an appropriate textbook (see Appendix 2). However, a more precise assessment can be
obtained by subjecting the silage to chemical analysis and using the information
obtained to type the silage more accurately, or predict its energy value using prediction equations. For example, the following equations allow the energy values of
298
Predicting the energy value of foods
grass silages for ruminants and forages for horses to be predicted from their chemical composition:
Ruminants (silages):
ME (MJ/kg DM) = 15.0 - (0.0140 MADF)
ME (MJ/kg DM) = 5.45 + (0.0085 NCD)
Horses (forages):
DE (MJ/kg) = 17.66 - (0.046 ADF) + (0.0139 CP) + (0.000468 ADF2)
where MADF, NCD, ADF and CP indicate modified acid detergent fibre, neutral
cellulose digestibility, acid detergent fibre and crude protein, respectively.
An alternative approach to chemical analysis is to estimate digestibility by in vitro
fermentation (see p. 241) and predict the energy value from the digestible organic
matter content of the food. For forages given to ruminants, the following equation is
often used:
ME (MJ/kg DM) = 0.016 DOMD
where DOMD (g) indicates digestible organic matter per kilogram of dry matter.
The introduction of new methods of analysis, such as near-infrared spectrometry
(NIRS), has speeded up the prediction of digestibility and energy values for a range
of foods (see Chapter 10). However, it must be remembered that all laboratory methods of predicting the energy value of foods are dependent on the availability of reliable data obtained from properly conducted metabolism trials with animals. It is the
systematic evaluation of many food samples in such trials that provides the regression equations that are subsequently used to predict energy values from laboratory
measurements.
For cereal grains and other concentrate foods, the prediction of energy value is
easier than for forages, because such foods are less variable in chemical composition;
appropriate values can therefore be taken from tables in appropriate textbooks. However, there are occasions when the energy values of concentrate foods need to be predicted from their chemical composition. For example, many countries are introducing
legislation that requires compound feed manufacturers to declare the energy value
(typically, the ME value) of their products. Consequently, a simple method of checking such values is required. In the UK, the following equations can be used to predict
the energy content of compound foods fed to ruminants, horses, pigs and poultry:
Ruminants:
ME (MJ/kg DM) = (0.014 NCDG) + (0.025 AEE)
Horses:
DE (MJ/kg) = 17.02 - (0.023 ADF)
Pigs:
DE (MJ/kg DM) = 17.47 + (0.0079 CP) + (0.0158 AEE)
- (0.0331 Ash) - (0.0140 NDF)
Poultry:
ME (MJ/kg) = (0.01551 CP) + (0.03431 AEE) + (0.01669 ST)
+ (0.01301 S)
299
Chapter 12 Evaluation of foods: systems for expressing the energy value of foods
where CP, AEE, Ash, ST and S indicate crude protein, acid ether extract, ash, starch
and total sugars, respectively, and NCDG indicates neutral cellulose plus gamanase
digestibility. All are expressed as g/kg DM (ruminants and pigs) or g/kg food (horses
and poultry).
The four equations differ in principle. The equation for poultry assigns a logically
derived factor for each constituent. For example, assuming the energy value of fat to
be 0.0393 MJ/g, the factor for acid ether extract indicates that 0.03431/0.0393 =
0.87 of the gross energy of the lipid in poultry food is metabolisable. The equations
for horses and pigs start with a constant value and adjust it upwards, depending on
the protein and acid ether extract content, and downwards, depending on the ash
and fibre content. The equation for ruminants is based on a biological rather than a
chemical evaluation of the food but includes an adjustment for acid ether extract.
Earlier equations were based on the original components of the proximate analysis.
An example of an earlier equation for pig foods, based on a compilation of European
studies made by the European Association for Animal Production, is:
ME (MJ/kg DM) = (0.018 CP) + (0.0315 AEE) + (0.0163 NFE)
- (0.0149 CF)
The precision of this and other equations can be assessed from their residual
standard deviations (rsd). The ME equation based on proximate constituents (rsd
0.54) is less precise than the DE equation based on modern analytical components
(rsd 0.33).
SUMMARY
1. Energy systems consist of three components:
(1) the energy requirements of the animal,
(2) the energy values of foods and (3) information of the efficiency of energy utilisation
linking (1) and (2).
2. Energy systems can be considered to be
simple models used either to predict the performance of animals on a prescribed ration
or to formulate rations for animals with a
desired level of performance.
3. In the UK metabolisable energy system for
ruminants, animal requirements are expressed
in terms of net energy (NE) and food energy
values are expressed as metabolisable energy
(ME). Animal ME requirements are calculated
using efficiency factors (k) for different
productive processes (e.g. maintenance,
lactation or growth), which depend on the
ME concentration of the diet (M/D).
4. The UK metabolisable energy system has
been refined by including corrections to
300
account for the effects of level of feeding on
both the ME value of the foods and the
efficiency of ME utilisation.
5. In the UK, the ME requirements of dairy cows
for maintenance and lactation can be calculated from the curvilinear relationship
between milk energy derived from dietary
ME and dietary ME directed towards milk
production proposed by Feed into Milk 2004.
6. As an alternative to ME, various countries in
continental Europe and the USA have
adopted energy systems based on NE. In
these systems, the NE value of foods is calculated from ME and different NE values are
derived for different productive purposes
(e.g. maintenance, growth or lactation).
7. Most energy systems for ruminants produce
similar results. However, as new information
becomes available, the systems are becoming
more complex. In the future, with increasing
use of computers, mechanistic models may be
Further reading
able to more accurately predict animal
energy requirements and the energy value
of animal foods.
8. Energy systems for pigs and poultry are
largely based on either DE or ME because the
efficiency of DE utilisation (or ME) is relatively constant. However, with increasing use
of fibrous by-products and more information
on the efficiency of energy substrate utilisation, there is renewed interest in NE systems.
In the UK, a NE system has been introduced
for pigs.
9. Energy systems for horses, based on either DE
or NE, produce similar results. The NE system
provides a sound theoretical framework but
is complex to use. The DE system is relatively
simple and easily understood by nutritionists,
veterinarians and horse owners.
10. The energy value of some foods is variable.
Consequently, most systems include equations for predicting the energy value of foods
from their chemical composition determined
by laboratory analysis.
QUESTIONS
12.1 Predict the performance of a group of 30 kg wether lambs (castrated males)
offered a diet consisting of 1.0 kg hay (DM 800 g/kg, ME 9.0 MJ/kg DM) and
0.3 kg concentrate (DM 860 g/kg, ME 13.0 MJ/kg DM).The net energy requirements for maintenance and growth of a 30 kg wether lamb are 3.2 MJ/day and
14.0 MJ/kg, respectively.
12.2 Formulate a diet to meet the energy requirements of a group of 650 kg
Holstein * Freisian cows producing 36 l milk. Grass silage (DM 280 g/kg, ME
10.8 MJ/kg DM) and dairy concentrate (DM 860 g/kg, ME 13.5 MJ/kg DM)
are available. It is anticipated that the cows will consume 19.5 kg/day dry matter and no weight change is expected.The net energy requirements for maintenance and milk production are 44.8 MJ/day and 3.0 MJ/l, respectively.
12.3 A food intended for growing pigs was analysed in the laboratory to contain the
following chemical components:
g/kg DM
Crude protein
Acid ether extract
Neutral detergent fibre
Ash
160
50
150
60
Calculate the digestible energy value of the food and the expected liveweight
gain of 35 kg growing pigs (DE maintenance 7.0 MJ/day) offered 1.0 kg DM
per head per day. The pig’s weight gain contains 210 g/kg muscle DM (170 g
protein) and 200 g/kg fat. (The information presented in both Chapters 11 and
12 may be useful here.)
FURTHER READING
Agnew R E and Yan T 2000 Impact of recent research on energy feeding systems for dairy cattle. Livestock Production Science 66: 197–215.
301
Chapter 12 Evaluation of foods: systems for expressing the energy value of foods
Agricultural Research Council 1980 The Nutrient Requirements of Ruminant Livestock,
Farnham Royal, Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux.
Agricultural Research Council 1981 The Nutrient Requirements of Pigs, Farnham Royal, Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux.
Agricultural and Food Research Council (AFRC) 1993 Energy and Protein Requirements of
Ruminants (An Advisory Manual prepared by the AFRC Technical Committee on Responses
to Nutrients),Wallingford, CABI.
Alderman G 1985 Prediction of the energy value of compound feeds. In: Haresign W and Cole
D J A (eds) Recent Advances in Animal Nutrition – 1985, London, Butterworth.
Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation 2007 Nutrient Requirements
of Domesticated Ruminants, Collingwood,Vic., Australia, CSIRO Publishing.
Henry Y, Vogt H and Zoiopoulos P E 1988 Feed evaluation and nutritional requirements: pigs
and poultry. Livestock Production Science 19: 299–354.
Morris T R and Freeman B M (eds) 1974 Energy Requirements of Poultry, Poultry Science
Symposium no. 9, Edinburgh, British Poultry Science.
National Academy of Sciences/National Research Council 2001 Nutrient Requirements
of Dairy Cattle, 7th rev. edn,Washington, DC, National Research Council.
National Academy of Sciences/National Research Council 2007 Nutrient Requirements of
Horses,Washington, DC, National Research Council.
National Academy of Sciences/National Research Council 2000 Nutrient Requirements of
Beef Cattle, 7th rev. edn,Washington, DC, National Research Council.
Pirgozliev V and Rose S P 1999 Net energy systems for poultry feeds: a quantitative review.
World’s Poultry Science Journal 55: 23–36.
Theodorou M K and France J (eds) 2000 Feeding Systems and Feed Evaluation Models,
Wallingford, CABI.
Thomas C 2004 Feed into Milk: A New Applied Feeding System for Dairy Cows, Nottingham,
Nottingham University Press.
Van der Honing Y and Alderman G 1988 Feed evaluation and nutritional requirements:
ruminants. Livestock Production Science 19: 217–78.
Van Es A J H 1978 Feed evaluation for ruminants 1: the systems in use from May 1977
onwards in the Netherlands. Livestock Production Science 5: 331–45.
Whittemore C T 1997 An analysis of methods for the utilisation of net energy concepts to
improve the accuracy of feed evaluation in diets for pigs. Animal Feed Science and
Technology 68: 89–99.
Whittemore CT, Hazzledine MJ and Close WH 2003 The Nutrient Requirements of Pigs,
Penicuik, British Society of Animal Science.
Wiseman J and Cole D J A (eds) 1990 Feedstuff Evaluation, London, Butterworth.
HISTORICAL REFERENCES
Armsby H P 1917 The Nutrition of Farm Animals, New York, Macmillan.
Kellner O 1926 The Scientific Feeding of Farm Animals, 2nd edn (translated by W Goodwin),
London, Duckworth.
302
13
Evaluation of foods: protein
13.1
Crude protein
13.2
Digestible crude protein
13.3
Determination of endogenous nitrogen
13.4
Measures of protein quality for monogastric animals
13.5
Measures of food protein used in practice in the feeding of pigs and poultry
13.6
Measures of food protein used in practice in the feeding of horses
13.7
Measures of protein quality for ruminant animals
13.8
The UK metabolisable protein system
13.9
The UK Feed into Milk protein system for dairy cows
Proteins are made up of amino acids, the classification of which into essential (indispensable) and non-essential (dispensable) has already been described in Chapter 4 and
in Chapter 9 under ‘protein synthesis’. For food to be used with maximum efficiency, the
animal must receive sufficient quantities of both the essential and non-essential amino
acids to meet its metabolic demands. Simple-stomached animals such as pigs and poultry obtain these acids from the breakdown of food proteins during digestion and absorption. In the case of ruminant animals, the situation is more complex.
Considerable degradation and synthesis of protein occur in the rumen, and the material that finally becomes available for digestion by the animal may differ considerably
from that originally present in the food. Different approaches to the evaluation of protein sources are therefore necessary for ruminant and non-ruminant animals.
In the past, foods were evaluated as sources of protein by somewhat crude and simple methods that took no account of the species of animal for which the foods were intended. Some of these methods are still sometimes used. These will be dealt with first,
and then the more refined methods of assessing protein quality for simple-stomached
and ruminant animals will be discussed separately.
13.1
CRUDE PROTEIN
Most of the nitrogen required by the animal is used for protein synthesis. Most of the
food nitrogen is also present as protein, and it is convenient and almost universal for the
nitrogen requirements of animals and the nitrogen status of foods to be stated in terms
of protein. Chemically, the protein content of a food is calculated from its nitrogen
303
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
content determined by a modification of the classical Kjeldahl technique or the Dumas
method; this gives a figure that includes most forms of nitrogen, although nitrites,
nitrates and certain cyclic nitrogen compounds require special techniques for their
recovery. Two assumptions are made in calculating the protein content from that of
nitrogen: first, that all the nitrogen of the food is present as protein; and second, that all
food protein contains 160 g N/kg.The nitrogen content of the food is then expressed in
terms of crude protein (CP):
CP (g/kg) = g N/kg * 1000/160
or more commonly:
CP (g/kg) = g N/kg * 6.25
Both the assumptions are unsound. Different food proteins have different nitrogen contents and, therefore, different factors should be used in the conversion of
nitrogen to protein for individual foods. Table 13.1 shows the nitrogen contents of
a number of common proteins, together with the appropriate nitrogen conversion
factors.
Although fundamentally unsound, the use of an average conversion factor of 6.25
for all food proteins is justified in practice, since protein requirements of farm animals, expressed in terms of N ⫻ 6.25, are requirements for nitrogen and not for protein per se. The publication of tables of protein contents based on true conversion
factors could lead to considerable confusion and inefficiency in feeding.The assumption that the whole of the food nitrogen is present as protein is also false, since many
simple nitrogenous compounds, such as amides, amino acids, glycosides, alkaloids,
ammonium salts and compound lipids, may be present (see Chapter 4). Quantitatively, only the amides and the amino acids are important, and these are present in
large amounts in only a few foods such as young grass, silage and immature root
crops.About 95 per cent of the nitrogen of most mature seeds is present as true protein, whereas leaves have 80–90 per cent, stems and roots 60 per cent, and storage
organs such as potatoes and carrots 30–40 per cent, in this form. In the diets of pigs
and poultry, cereals and oilseeds predominate, and they contain little non-protein nitrogen. Hence, in practice, there is little to be gained from attempting to differentiate
between the two types of nitrogen, particularly as a considerable proportion of the
Table 13.1 Factors for converting nitrogen to crude protein
Food protein
Nitrogen (g/kg)
Conversion factor
Cotton seed
Soya bean
Barley
Maize
Oats
Wheat
Egg
Meat
Milk
188.7
175.1
171.5
160.0
171.5
171.5
160.0
160.0
156.8
5.30
5.71
5.83
6.25
5.83
5.83
6.25
6.25
6.38
Adapted from Jones D B 1931 USDA Circ. 183.
304
Digestible crude protein
non-protein fraction, amino acids and amides for example, may be utilised for amino
acid synthesis by the animal. Tradition apart, there seems little justification for the
use of the term ‘crude protein’ in nutrition. The expression of both animal requirements and the status of foods in terms of nitrogen would be more logical and would
avoid confusion.
13.2
DIGESTIBLE CRUDE PROTEIN
The crude protein figure provides a measure of the nitrogen present in the food but
gives little indication of its value to the animal. Before the food becomes available to
the animal, the food must undergo digestion, during which it is broken down to simpler substances that are absorbed into the body.The digestible protein in a food may
be determined by digestibility trials in which nitrogen intake is measured along with
the nitrogen voided in the faeces, as described in Chapter 10.
Digestibility coefficients based on collection and analysis of digesta from the terminal ileum are generally considered to give a more accurate measure of the nitrogen
absorbed than do those based on the more usual faecal collection. Ileal collection
eliminates the lower gut as a source of errors and is justified since absorption from
the large intestine is held to make little or no contribution to the protein status of the
animal. Furthermore, a higher correlation has been demonstrated between daily
liveweight gain in pigs and ileal rather than whole-tract digestibility (r ⫽ 0.76 v. 0.34),
particularly with unusual protein sources.
It is assumed that the difference between the quantities of nitrogen in the food
and faeces (or digesta in the case of ileal collection) represents the quantity absorbed in a utilisable form by the body and that all nitrogen that appears in the faeces is of dietary origin. In the light of the fate of ruminal ammonia (see Chapter 8)
and the presence in faeces and digesta of nitrogen of metabolic or endogenous origin
(see Chapter 10), these assumptions are untenable. The figures so obtained are for
apparently digestible protein. Determination of the true digestibility must take account of the contribution of nitrogen of endogenous origin to that of the digesta.The
endogenous nitrogen (EN) contains non-food substances entering the intestine, such
as saliva, bile, gastric and pancreatic secretions, and cells sloughed off the mucous
membrane of the gut. It may also contain significant amounts of bacterial nitrogen,
which is not endogenous in origin. Endogenous nitrogen may be divided into two
fractions: that which is unrelated to the quality and the quantity of the dietary protein and is dependent only upon the quantity of dry matter passing through the gut
and termed basal nitrogen loss (BN), and that which is related to the quality and
quantity of the dietary protein and other ingredient characteristics such as fibre or
anti-nutritional factors, and termed specific endogenous nitrogen (SN). These different fractions are shown in Fig. 13.1.
As a result of the inclusion of BN (which is constant for a given level of dry matter intake), in the calculation of apparent digestibility, different values will be obtained for different levels of dietary protein inclusion. It has been suggested that this
anomaly may be overcome by eliminating BN from the calculation to give a figure
for ‘standardised digestiblity’. For pigs and poultry, amino acid supply rather than
protein is considered, and ileal digestibility rather than whole-tract digestibility is
used. Therefore, endogenous amino acids are calculated as the sum of basal amino
305
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
Amount of
nitrogen
excreted
Dietary origin nitrogen
Specific endogenous nitrogen (SN)
Basal endogenous nitrogen (BN)
Rate of incorporation of feedstuff in the diet or
dietary nitrogen content
Fig. 13.1 Origin of excreted nitrogen.
acid loss (BAA) and specific endogenous amino acid loss (SAA). Standardised ileal
digestibility (SID) is then calculated as follows:
SID (g/kg) =
dietary AA intake - (ileal AA flow - ileal BAA flow)
dietary AA intake
* 1000
Means of estimating BAA are described later.
The use of standardised digestibility figures overcomes the problem of multiple
values and the systematic undervaluation of the digestibility of low-protein foods
that is inherent in apparent digestibility figures. Standardised digestibility is sometimes referred to as true digestibility, but it remains an apparent value and does not
give a realistic picture of the true digestibility of the nitrogen. For this, the specific
endogenous contribution to faecal or digesta nitrogen (or amino acids) must be
taken into account.
13.3
DETERMINATION OF ENDOGENOUS NITROGEN
The magnitude of the endogenous nitrogen component may be estimated by one of
the following procedures:
■
■
306
Measuring the nitrogen in digesta when protein-free diets are consumed, the assumption being that this is entirely endogenous in origin. The procedure is nonphysiological, normal protein metabolism may be affected, and nitrogen secretion
into the gut may be reduced. Furthermore, the diet may lack the stimulatory effect of normal diets on endogenous secretions. However, the fibrous nature of
protein-free diets increase the contribution of that part of the endogenous component resulting from abrasion of the gut membrane. The technique cannot be used
with ruminant animals as nitrogen-free diets inhibit rumen fermentation.
Measuring the nitrogen in digesta when completely digestible protein is consumed.
Determination of endogenous nitrogen
■
■
■
■
Measuring the recoveries of nitrogen, from digesta, when graded levels of protein
are consumed.The recoveries are regressed on intake; extrapolation to zero intake
is taken as the endogenous nitrogen loss. It is assumed that endogenous nitrogen
loss is not related to protein intake. This is not a valid assumption and the estimates obtained by this method are, at best, minimum values.
Isotope dilution, in which the stable nitrogen isotope 15N is introduced in known
concentration in the food. The concentration in the faeces/digesta is then measured and the dilution with nitrogen of non-food (endogenous) origin is calculated.
Treating dietary lysine with guanidine to give homoarginine. This is assumed to
escape digestion in the gut and any lysine appearing in the digesta is assumed to be
of endogenous origin.The relationship between lysine and the other amino acids is
considered to be constant and is used in calculating their true digestibility.
Peptide alimentation of the alimentary canal with hydrolysed casein and separation of the exogenous and endogenous components on the basis of molecular
weight, the endogenous being greater than 10 000.
The results may vary widely with the different techniques employed. Even two of
the most favoured current techniques, that based on homoarginine and that using
15
N-labelled dietary protein, show average differences of about 5 per cent in the true
digestibility values derived from them. Some figures obtained using 15N labelling are
given in Table 13.2.
As well as varying with the technique used, the magnitude of the endogenous nitrogen fraction is influenced by the type and amount of non-starch polysaccharide in
the diet and the protein status of the experimental animals. Some workers consider
that endogenous secretions are a component of the net value of the food and that digesta nitrogen should be set against dietary nitrogen, whatever its origin. Others regard digestibility as purely a property of the food and consider that endogenous
nitrogen should be eliminated from its calculation.The digestibility of the nitrogen of
a complete diet could then be calculated additively from the digestibility values of
the proteins of the foods making up the diet. Owing to the variability of the values
for endogenous nitrogen, any assumed figure used to transform apparent to true
digestibility values will be of doubtful validity, and so will the resulting coefficients.
Table 13.2 Apparent and true ileal protein digestibility values as determined by
the 15N-isotope dilution techniques
Digestibility (%)
Apparent
True
Endogenous protein
As g/kg dry matter intake
As percentage of total crude
protein present at the distal ileum
As g/100 g crude protein intake
Soya bean
meal
Canola
meal
Wheat
Barley
83.8
97.5
66.0
84.1
80.0
99.0
69.5
94.2
25.5
84.6
30.5
53.5
27.4
94.5
27.7
81.1
13.7
18.0
19.1
24.7
Adapted from Sauer W C and de Lange K 1992 Novel methods for determining protein and amino acid
digestibility values in feedstuffs. In: Nissen S (ed.) Modern Methods in Protein Nutrition and Metabolism,
London, Academic Press.
307
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
Most of the figures in current use are apparent values, but in feeding systems in which
metabolic nitrogen loss is treated as part of the maintenance nitrogen demand, true
rather than apparent coefficients have to be used.
There is evidence that figures for the apparent ileal digestibility of lysine, and
some other amino acids, overestimate availability to the animal, which reinforces the
view that it is dangerous to equate digestibility with availability.
13.4
MEASURES OF PROTEIN QUALITY FOR
MONOGASTRIC ANIMALS
Digestible protein figures are not entirely satisfactory measures of the value of a protein
to an animal, because the efficiency with which the absorbed protein is used differs considerably from one source to another. In order to allow for such differences, methods for
evaluating proteins, such as the protein efficiency ratio (PER), the net protein retention
(NPR) and the gross protein value (GPV), which are based on the growth response of
experimental animals to the protein under consideration, have been devised.
Protein efficiency ratio
This is defined as follows:
PER =
gain in body weight (g)
protein consumed (g)
The rat is the usual experimental animal.
Net protein retention
This is calculated as follows:
NPR =
weight gain of TPG - weight loss of NPG
weight of protein consumed
where TPG = group given the test protein and NPG = group of protein-free diet.
Gross protein value
The liveweight gains of chicks receiving a basal diet containing 80 g crude protein/kg
are compared with those of chicks receiving the basal diet plus 30 g/kg of a test protein,
and of yet others receiving the basal diet plus 30 g/kg of casein. The extra liveweight
gain per unit of supplementary test protein stated as a proportion of the extra
liveweight gain per unit of supplementary casein is the GPV of the test protein, i.e.:
GPV = A>A°
where A = g increased weight gain/g test protein and A° = g increased weight
gain/g casein.
Nitrogen balance
Liveweight gains may not be related to protein stored, and a more accurate evaluation of a protein may be obtained by using the results of nitrogen balance experiments. In such experiments, the nitrogen consumed in the food is measured,
308
Measures of protein quality for monogastric animals
Table 13.3 Nitrogen balance for a Large White/Landrace pig on a diet of wheat,
soya bean meal and herring meal
Daily intake (g)
Food nitrogen
Faecal nitrogen
Urinary nitrogen
Nitrogen retained by body
Total
Balance
Daily output (g)
46.42
46.42
4.99
19.64
21.79
46.42
⫹21.79
Adapted from Morgan C A and Whittemore C T, unpublished.
together with that voided in the faeces, urine and any other nitrogen-containing
products such as milk, wool and eggs. When the nitrogen intake is equal to the
output, the animal is said to be in nitrogen equilibrium; when intake exceeds output, it is in positive balance; when output exceeds intake, it is in negative balance.
Table 13.3 illustrates the calculation of a nitrogen balance for a 50 kg pig in positive nitrogen balance to the extent of 21.79 g/day.
Balance trials are susceptible to several sources of error:
■
■
■
■
inadequate adaptation of experimental animals to the diet and the environment;
collection and weighing of faeces and urine;
storage of faeces and urine;
preparation and sampling of faeces and urine for chemical analysis.
The results of balance trials have been shown to diverge considerably from those
obtained with the comparative slaughter technique (see Chapter 11). This too is liable to error, owing largely to the difficulty of animal selection for the initial slaughter group, which, if inadequate, can invalidate the comparison with the slaughter
group. With larger animals, errors can arise from poor sampling of the carcasses
owing to their physical size.They have then to be dissected into component parts for
sampling, instead of the body sampling possible with smaller animals. In general, the
balance technique gives higher estimates of nitrogen retention, and most authorities
agree that such estimates are not as reliable as those based on slaughter.
Biological value
This is a direct measure of the proportion of the food protein that can be utilised by
the animal for synthesising body tissues and compounds, and may be defined as the
proportion of the absorbed nitrogen that is retained by the body. A balance trial is
conducted in which nitrogen intake and urinary and faecal excretions of nitrogen are
measured, along with the endogenous fractions in these two materials.The biological
value is then calculated as follows:
BV =
N intake - (faecal N - MFN) - (urinary N - EUN)
N intake - (faecal N - MFN)
where MFN ⫽ metabolic (endogenous) faecal nitrogen and EUN ⫽ endogenous
urinary nitrogen.
309
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
Table 13.4 Calculation of biological value for maintenance and
growth of the rat
Food consumed daily (g)
Nitrogen in food (g/kg)
Daily nitrogen intake (mg)
Total nitrogen excreted daily in urine (mg)
Endogenous nitrogen excreted daily in urine (mg)
Total nitrogen excreted daily in faeces (mg)
Metabolic faecal nitrogen excreted daily (mg)
BV =
6.0
10.43
62.6
32.8
22.0
20.9
10.7
62.6 - 120.9 - 10.72 - 132.8 - 22.02
62.6 - 120.9 - 10.72
= 0.79
Adapted from Mitchell H H 1942 Journal of Biological Chemistry 58: 873.
An example of such a calculation is given in Table 13.4.
The endogenous urinary nitrogen results from irreversible reactions involved in
the breakdown and replacement of various protein secretions and structures within
the body. Thus, both the faecal and urinary endogenous fractions represent nitrogen
that has been absorbed and utilised by the animal rather than nitrogen that cannot
be so utilised. Their exclusion from the faecal and urinary values in the above formula gives a measure of the true biological value.
In determining biological value, as much as possible of the dietary protein should
be provided by that under test. Protein intake must be sufficient to allow adequate nitrogen retention, but it must not be in excess of that required for maximum retention;
if the latter level were exceeded, then the general amino acid catabolism resulting
would depress the estimate of biological value. For the same reason, sufficient nonprotein nitrogenous nutrients must be given to prevent protein being catabolised to
provide energy. The diet must also be adequate in other respects. Table 13.5 gives
biological values for the proteins of some typical foods.
Table 13.5 Biological values of the protein in
various foods for maintenance and growth for
the growing pig
Food
Milk
Fish meal
Soya bean meal
Cotton seed meal
Linseed meal
Maize
Barley
Peas
BV
0.95–0.97
0.74–0.89
0.63–0.76
0.63
0.61
0.49–0.61
0.57–0.71
0.62–0.65
Adapted from Armstrong D G and Mitchell H H 1955
Journal of Animal Science 14: 53.
310
Measures of protein quality for monogastric animals
Such biological values are for the combined functions of maintenance, meaning
the replacement of existing proteins, and growth (i.e. the formation of new tissues).
Biological values for maintenance alone may be calculated from balance data. A linear relationship exists between nitrogen intake and balance below equilibrium,
which may be represented by the following equation:
y = bx - a
where y ⫽ N balance, x ⫽ N absorbed, a ⫽ N loss at zero intake (all expressed as gN
per basal kJ), and b ⫽ nitrogen balance index, i.e. that fraction of the absorbed nitrogen retained by the body and is equal to the BV for maintenance.
The product of BV and digestibility is termed the net protein utilisation (NPU)
and is the proportion of the nitrogen intake retained by the animal.
The amino acids absorbed by the animal are required for the synthesis of body
proteins. The efficiency with which this synthesis is effected depends partly on how
closely the amino acid proportions of the absorbed mixture resemble those of the
body proteins and partly on the extent to which the proportions can be modified.
The biological value of a food protein therefore depends upon the number and
kinds of amino acids present in the molecule: the closer the amino acid composition
of the food protein approaches that of the body protein, the higher will be its biological value. Animals have little ability to store amino acids in the free state, and if
an amino acid is not required immediately for protein synthesis then it is readily
broken down and either transformed into a non-essential amino acid or used as an
energy source. Since essential amino acids cannot be effectively synthesised in the
animal body, an imbalance of these in the diet leads to wastage. Food proteins with
either a deficiency or an excess of any particular amino acid will tend to have low
biological values.
If we consider two food proteins, one deficient in lysine and rich in methionine,
and the other deficient in methionine but containing an excess of lysine, then, if
these proteins are given separately to young pigs, they will have low biological values because of the imbalance of these acids. If, however, the two proteins are given
together, then the mixture will be better balanced and have a higher value than either given alone. Such proteins complement each other. In practice, and for a similar
reason, it often happens that a diet containing a large variety of proteins has a higher
biological value than a diet containing only a few proteins. This also explains why
biological values of individual foods cannot be applied when mixtures of foods are
used, since the biological value of a mixture is not simply a mean of the individual
components. For the same reason, it is impossible to predict the value of a protein as
a supplement to a given diet from its biological value.
Animal proteins generally have higher biological values than plant proteins, although there are exceptions. Gelatin, for example, is deficient in several essential
amino acids.
The amino acid composition of a given food protein will be relatively constant
(see Appendix 2, Table A2.1.3), but that of the protein to be synthesised will vary
considerably with the type of animal and the various functions it has to perform. For
the normal growth of rats, pigs and chicks, for example, lysine, tryptophan, histidine,
methionine, phenylalanine, leucine, isoleucine, threonine, valine and arginine are
dietary essentials. Humans do not require histidine, whereas chicks need glycine, in
addition to those acids required by the rat, to ensure optimum growth. On the other
hand, arginine is not a dietary essential for maintenance of the rat or pig.
311
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
The situation is complicated further by the fact that some amino acids can be replaced, at least in part, by others; for example, methionine can be partly replaced
by cystine, and tyrosine can partly replace phenylalanine. In such cases, the two
amino acids are frequently considered together in assessing the animal’s requirements. It is clear that no single figure for biological value will suffice as a measure
of the nutritive value of a food protein for different animals and different functions. The differences between the amino acid requirements of young pigs and
those of laying hens, for example, are shown in Appendix 2, Tables A2.9.1 and
A2.10. The consequent need for multiple figures severely limits the use of the biological value concept in feeding practice.
The biological methods of evaluation reflect the content of the limiting amino
acid in the protein. Changes in the levels of other amino acids will not affect the values until one or other of them becomes limiting.Thus, in milk protein, with an excess
of lysine, change in lysine content will not affect the biological measures until it is reduced to such a level that it itself becomes the limiting acid. The biological measures
are therefore of limited value in assessing the effects of certain processes, heat treatment for example, on nutritive value.
Since biological value is dependent primarily upon essential amino acid constitution, it would seem logical to assess the nutritive value of a protein by determining its essential amino acid constitution and then comparing this with the
known amino acid requirements of a particular class of animal. Application of
modern chromatographic techniques coupled with automated procedures allows
relatively quick and convenient resolution of mixtures of amino acids. However,
the acid hydrolysis used to produce such mixtures from protein destroys practically all the tryptophan and a considerable proportion of the cystine and methionine. Tryptophan has to be released by a separate alkaline hydrolysis, and cystine
and methionine have to be oxidised to cysteic acid and methionine sulphone to
ensure their quantitative recovery. Losses of amino acids and the production of
artefacts, which are greater with foods of high carbohydrate content, are reduced
if the hydrolysis is carried out in vacuo. Evaluations of proteins in terms of each
individual amino acid would be laborious and inconvenient, and several attempts
have been made to state the results of amino acid analyses in a more useful and
convenient form.
Chemical score
In this concept, it is considered that the quality of a protein is decided by the amino
acid that is in greatest deficit when compared with a standard.The standard generally
used has been egg protein, but many workers now use a defined amino acid mixture,
the FAO Recommended Reference Amino Acid Pattern. The content of each of the
essential amino acids of a protein is expressed as a proportion of that in the standard
(the standard pattern ratio) and the lowest proportion taken as the score. In wheat
protein, for example, the essential amino acid in greatest deficit is lysine. The contents of lysine in egg and wheat proteins are 72 g/kg and 27 g/kg, respectively, and
the chemical score for wheat protein is therefore 27/72 ⫽ 0.37. Scores correlate well
with biological values for rats and human beings, but not for poultry.They are useful
for grouping proteins but suffer a serious disadvantage in that no account is taken of
the deficiencies of acids other than that in greatest deficit.
312
Measures of protein quality for monogastric animals
The essential amino acid index (EAAI)
This is the geometric mean of the egg, or standard pattern, ratios of the essential
amino acids. It has the advantage of predicting the effect of supplementation in combinations of proteins. On the other hand, it has the disadvantage that proteins of very
different amino acid composition may have the same or a very similar index.
Both the chemical score and the essential amino acid index are based upon gross
amino acid composition. It would be more logical to use figures for the acids available to the animal. Such figures may be obtained in several ways. Determinations of
digestibility in vivo involve amino acid analyses of the food and faeces. The figures
so obtained are suspect because the faeces contain varying amounts of amino acids
not present in the food, mainly as a result of microbial activity in the large intestine.
Thus, net synthesis of methionine and lysine has been shown to take place in the
hind gut of the pig. On the other hand, cysteine, threonine and tryptophan disappear
from the large intestine but make little or no contribution to the amino acid nutrition of the animal. This drawback may be overcome by determining apparent ileal
digestibility, by measuring amino acids in the digesta at the terminal ileum instead of
in the faeces. A more accurate estimate of the dietary amino acids absorbed is provided if the contribution of amino acids of endogenous origin to those found at the
terminal ileum is used in the calculation of truly digestible amino acids. Digestibility
trials in vivo are laborious, time-consuming, require considerable technical resources
and skill, and are expensive. Determinations in vitro involve the action of one or, at
most, a few enzymes and are not strictly comparable with the action in vivo, which
entails a series of enzymes.
Biological assay of available amino acids
The available amino acid content of a food protein may be assayed by measuring the
liveweight gain, food conversion efficiency or nitrogen retention of animals given the
intact protein as a supplement to a diet deficient in the particular amino acid under
investigation.The chick is the usual experimental animal and the response to the test
material is compared with the response to supplements of pure amino acids. The
method has been used successfully for lysine, methionine and cystine but, in addition to the usual disadvantages associated with biological methods – time, technical
expertise and supply of suitable animals – there is the major problem of constructing
diets deficient in specific amino acids but adequate in other respects.
Microbiological assay of essential amino acids
Certain microorganisms have amino acid requirements similar to those of higher animals and have been used for the evaluation of food proteins.The methods are based
on measuring the growth of the microorganisms in culture media that include the
protein under test. Best results have been obtained with Streptococcus zymogenes
and Tetrahymena pyriformis. The former is used after an acid or enzymic predigestion of the food protein; estimates of the availability of lysine and methionine have
agreed well with chick assays and measurements of NPU. T. pyriformis has intrinsic
proteolytic activity and is used, for soluble proteins, without predigestion. An
improved method, using predigestion with the enzyme pronase and measuring
313
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
response in terms of the tetrahymanol content of the culture medium, has given results for available lysine, methionine and tryptophan that correlate well with those
of biological assays.Tetrahymanol, the characteristic pentacyclic terpene synthesised
by T. pyriformis, is determined by gas–liquid chromatography.
Chemical methods
It would be ideal if there were simple chemical procedures for determining the availability of amino acids, the results of which correlated well with those of accepted
biological methods. The most widely used method is that for FDNB-reactive lysine,
which was originally proposed by K J Carpenter and has since undergone modification both by Carpenter and by other workers.The theoretical justification for the use
of the method is that practically the only source of utilisable lysine in foods is that
which has the epsilon-amino group free to react with various chemical reagents. The
protein under test is allowed to react under alkaline conditions with fluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (FDNB) to give DNP-lysine, the concentration of which can be measured colorometrically. In practice, the method has been found to agree well with
biological procedures for evaluating proteins as supplements to diets, such as those
containing high proportions of cereals, in which lysine is limiting.The correlation has
also been good with diets based largely on animal protein. With vegetable protein
and diets containing high levels of carbohydrate, the method is not so satisfactory,
the results being too low owing to destruction of the coloured lysine derivative during acid hydrolysis. Various methods have been proposed to counter this, but none
has proved completely satisfactory. From the available evidence it seems clear that
FDNB-available lysine overestimates the availability of the acid when applied to
heat-treated meals, as illustrated in Table 13.6.
The gross protein value is probably the most commonly used biological method for
evaluating proteins. Gross protein values measure the ability of proteins to supplement diets consisting largely of cereals and they correlate well with FDNB-reactive
lysine figures.
Dye-binding methods
These have been used widely for estimating protein in such foods as cereals and
milk. The methods are rapid and give reproducible results, and attempts have been
made to use them for measuring total basic amino acids and reactive lysine. The
Table 13.6 Mean amounts of total lysine, FDNB-reactive lysine and truly digestible
lysine in heat-treated meat and bone meals
Sample
Total lysine (g/100 g)
FDNB-available lysine
(g/100 g)
Ileal truly digestible lysine
(g/100 g)
1
2
3
4
5
6
2.65
2.17
2.59
1.91
2.82
2.53
2.73
2.32
3.89
2.57
2.68
2.11
1.72
1.75
1.93
1.97
2.88
2.03
Adapted from Moughan P J 1991. In: Haresign W and Cole D J A (eds) Recent Advances in Animal
Nutrition, London, Butterworth-Heinemann.
314
Measures of food protein used in practice in the feeding of pigs and poultry
latter requires blocking of the epsilon-amino group to prevent reaction with the dye.
Orange G has been used, along with 2,4,6-trinitrobenzene sulphonic acid and propionic anhydride as blocking agents, and has proved effective for estimating the lysine
content of cereals. It is less effective for fish and meat meals.
The increased use of synthetic lysine in foods presents a further problem. This
amino acid has both amino groups available for reaction with FDNB. The resulting
compound is soluble in ether and is not estimated by the Carpenter method.
Interpretation of amino acid assays
Several factors may be responsible for a lack of agreement between estimates of protein quality based on amino acid content and those made in animal experiments:
■
■
■
■
■
13.5
Even small changes in the concentration of one or more amino acids may increase
the amounts of others required to maintain growth rates.
Certain acids, such as tryptophan and histidine, may be toxic, albeit at concentrations far greater than normally occur in food proteins.
Antagonisms may exist between specific acids, which prejudice their utilisation.
Thus, the addition of as little as 20 g/kg of leucine to a diet deficient in isoleucine
may have deleterious effects on performance, and the arginine requirement of the
rat may be increased by giving higher levels of lysine.
Antinutritional factors (ANF) are frequently present in foods used primarily as
protein sources. Chief among these are enzyme inhibitors, lectins, polyphenols
and certain non-protein amino acids. All are capable of lowering the absorption
and/or the utilisation of amino acids by the animal but are not taken into account
in evaluations of protein sources based on amino acid content. The nature and
mode of action of anti-nutritional factors is dealt with in Chapter 24 with particular reference to their importance in individual foods.
There is considerable evidence that growing animals, such as young rats and
chicks, do not fulfil their growth potential if the dietary nitrogen is entirely in the
form of essential amino acids.Additional nitrogen is required and is best supplied
as a mixture of non-essential amino acids; glutamate, alanine and ammonium citrate are also effective sources. Allowance must be made for these factors when a
protein source is being evaluated on the basis of its content of one or more essential amino acids.
MEASURES OF FOOD PROTEIN USED IN PRACTICE IN THE
FEEDING OF PIGS AND POULTRY
The difficulty of assessing the value of a dietary protein is reflected in the variety of
methods that have been proposed, all of which have considerable limitations. A
crude protein figure gives a measure of the total nitrogen content and is useful since
the digestibility of the proteins in foods commonly given to pigs and poultry is fairly
constant. This is not true for new or unusual sources of protein, and this approach is
not a valid one.
The quality of dietary protein is indicated by stating the contents of all of the
essential amino acids or of those most likely to be in deficit. Practical pig and poultry diets are based largely on cereals, and assessment of foods as sources of protein
for such animals is a matter of measuring their ability to supplement the amino acid
315
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
deficiencies of the cereals.The main deficiencies in these cases are of lysine or methionine, and so the most useful measures of protein quality are those that reflect the available lysine or methionine content of the food. The determination of available lysine is
now accepted as a routine procedure for protein foods in many laboratories.
Dietary protein for growing pigs can also be expressed in the form of ideal protein.This is a modification of the chemical score. If the main limiting amino acid is lysine at 50 g/kg CP, then if we use the recommended content of lysine in the ideal
protein of 70 g/kg CP, the score would be 50/70 ⫽ 0.70 and the ideal protein content would be 700 g/kg CP. A diet with 170 g/kg of this protein would then supply
170 ⫻ 0.7 ⫽ 119 g ideal protein/kg. Requirements are usually stated in terms of apparently digested ideal protein (ADIP) and a digestibility of 0.75 is assumed in transforming the ideal protein supply to an ADIP supply.
In the UK, the most recent method for describing amino acid requirements and
dietary supply for pigs is standardised ileal digestible amino acids. The concept of
standardised ilieal amino acids was described earlier on p. 306. This approach has
the advantage over ideal protein by using ileal digestibility and therefore avoiding
microbial amino acid production in the hind gut inherent in using whole-tract digestibility, and also accounting for basal endogenous amino acid loss. This approach
also avoids the feed value reducing as amino acid intake declines. The standardised
ileal digestible amino acid requirement is calculated in relation to lysine, with the
balance of the other essential amino acids expressed for the processes of growth,
pregnancy and lactation, as shown in Table 13.7. The balance of amino acids reflects
differences in the composition of the proteins synthesised. In the case of lactating
sows and young fast-growing pigs, the maintenance requirement is small in relation
to the total, and the composition of the product (body and milk protein) will dominate the demand for amino acids. Consequently, for lactating sows, phenylalanine ⫹
tyrosine, leucine and valine are required in greater proportions, whereas pregnant
sows have a relatively greater requirement for methionine ⫹ cystine.A value of 0.84
Table 13.7 Recommended balance of amino acids in relation to lysine (⫽ 1.00)
Lysine
Methionine
Methionine ⫹ cystine
Threonine
Tryptophan
Isoleucine
Leucine
Histidine
Phenylalanine
Phenylalanine ⫹ tyrosine
Valine
Growing pigs
(10–120 kg)
Pregnant sows
Lactating sows
1.00
0.30
0.59
0.65
0.19
0.58
1.00
0.34
0.57
1.00
0.70
1.00
0.37
0.65
0.71
0.20
0.70
1.00
0.33
0.55
1.00
0.74
1.00
0.30
0.55
0.66
0.18
0.60
1.12
0.40
0.56
1.14
0.76
A minimum requirement for non-essential amino acids is approximately 2.5 times the level
(g/kg diet) of the sum of the 11 named essential amino acids.
Adapted from British Society of Animal Science 2003 Nutrient Requirement Standards for Pigs, Penicuik,
British Society of Animal Science.
316
Measures of food protein used in practice in the feeding of horses
can be used to convert standarised ileal digestible lysine (g/day) to total dietary
lysine (g/day). In theory this conversion factor is variable, but in practice it is assumed to be constant. As the standardised measure debits basal endogenous losses
to the animals, feedstuffs are credited with a slightly higher (3–8 per cent) digestible
amino acid content than previously uncorrected ileal digestibility values. Values for
the standardised ileal digestibility of the essential amino acids in common pig feed
ingredients are presented in Appendix 2.
The concept of standardised ileal digestible amino acids makes no allowance for
an excess of an individual amino acid, which, in certain circumstances, could be substantial. It is usual therefore to limit the concentration of any one amino acid to less
than 1.2 times that of the value presented in Table 13.7. It is also assumed in calculating the requirement for standardised ileal digestible amino acids that the proportions of amino acids made available to the metabolic body pool are the same as
those in the dietary protein. This will not be so if the acids are not digested or absorbed to the same extent.
For poultry, evaluation of protein sources is based upon the amounts of the three
major limiting amino acids, lysine, methionine and tryptophan. It is generally assumed that diets adequate in these acids will automatically provide sufficient
amounts of the others. As for pigs, dietary requirements and supply are based on
standardised ileal digestibility (SID). This may be measured using precision-fed caecectomised adult cockerels or, more commonly, young broilers fed a diet that includes
an indigestible marker. The concentration of the marker in the ileal digesta determined following slaughter allows apparent ileal digestibility to be calculated, which is
then corrected for basal amino acid flow from broilers fed a nitrogen-free diet.
13.6
MEASURES OF FOOD PROTEIN USED IN PRACTICE IN THE
FEEDING OF HORSES
The digestion of protein within the horse occurs mainly in the fore gut through enzymic digestion in the stomach and small intestine, as described in Chapter 8.Amino
acids produced from microbial protein synthesis in the hind gut are not absorbed in
sufficient quantities to provide any meaningful contribution to amino acid supply.
For example, studies that have infused lysine into the hind gut have shown no effect
on plasma lysine levels and there is no active absorption of amino acids in the large
intestine.
Within the horse, protein quality is predominately a function of the dietary amino
acid profile and the digestibility of the protein source in the fore gut. Despite this, the
rationing system used in the USA expresses dietary supply and requirements in relation to dietary crude protein. This approach may be valid if the digestibility of the
proteins in foods commonly given to horses is fairly constant, but it is questionable
considering the range of protein content and quality present in many forages. Studies
that have examined protein digestibility in horses have generally relied on apparent
total tract digestibility and do not take into consideration endogenous secretions,
which can vary between 3.5 mg and 5.8 mg N/g DM intake, or the contribution from
microbial growth in the hind gut.True ileal digestibility values have been reported for
hay, concentrates and mixed diets, and precaecal digestion of protein is approximately 0.25–0.30 g/g in forages and 0.70–0.75 g/g in protein supplements.Values for
317
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
forages will vary considerably, depending on species, stage of growth and proportion
of non-protein nitrogen. Non-protein nitrogen sources such as urea, although digestible, do not contribute to amino acid supply and result in little or no nutritional benefit to the horse. Indeed, supplementation with urea results in an
increase in blood ammonia, urea and excretion of urea in the urine, and can lead
to ammonia toxicity. A more accurate estimate of dietary protein supply can be
made by calculating the available protein (AP).The AP content of a feed (g/kg DM)
is defined as the crude protein content (g/kg DM) minus the non-protein nitrogen
content (g/kg DM multiplied by 6.25) minus the acid detergent insoluble nitrogen
(ADIN, g/kg DM, multiplied by 6.25).TheADIN content represents the bound protein
that is unavailable for digestion and absorption.There is a strong correlation (r2 ⫽ 0.91)
betweenAP and digestible protein, andAP is therefore a more useful mean of expressing dietary supply. It is generally recommended for maintenance, pregnancy and
growth that lysine contributes 0.043 of dietary crude protein content, but considering
the differences in lysine requirements for different productive processes in the pig, it
seems unlikely that a constant dietary lysine concentration should apply in horses.
In France a more sophisticated system, the Horse Digestible Crude Protein system (Matières Azotées Digestible Cheval; MADC), is used. The system is based on
the amino acid content of the feeds and whether they are digested in the small or
large intestine. True nitrogen digestibility values in the small intestine are based on
measurements made with ileal fistulated animals or from slaughter studies. The
French system makes an assumption that microbial protein produced in the large intestine can be absorbed, although values are less than 10–30 per cent of the nitrogen
flowing to the small intestine. The amino acid supply to the horse is then the sum of
that truly digested in the small intestine and that digested in the large intestine. Alternatively, the MADC content of a feed can be estimated by multiplying the apparent digestible crude protein content by 1.0 for concentrates, by 0.90 for green
forages, by 0.85 for dried hays, by 0.80 for straw and by 0.70 for good-quality grass
silage. In Holland and Germany apparent digestible crude protein is used.
13.7
MEASURES OF PROTEIN QUALITY FOR RUMINANT ANIMALS
Traditionally, proteins in foods for ruminant animals have been evaluated in terms of
crude protein (CP) or digestible crude protein (DCP). Realisation that the crude protein fraction contained variable amounts of non-protein nitrogen led to the use of
true protein instead of crude protein, but this was unsatisfactory since no allowance
was made for the nutritive value of the non-protein nitrogen fraction.The concept of
protein equivalent (PE), introduced in 1925 but now no longer used in this context,
was an attempt to overcome this difficulty by allowing the non-protein nitrogen fraction half the nutritive value of the true protein. The term ‘protein equivalent’ is currently used in connection with foods containing urea. Such foods must by law be
sold with a statement of their content of protein equivalent of urea; this means the
amount of urea nitrogen multiplied by 6.25.
The use of DCP for evaluating food proteins for ruminants has been largely abandoned. This resulted from a growing awareness of the extensive degradative and
synthetic activities of the microorganisms of the rumen (see Chapter 8). Rumen
microorganisms are responsible for providing the major part of the energy requirements of the host animal by transforming dietary carbohydrates to acetate, propionate
318
Measures of protein quality for ruminant animals
and butyrate. In order to do this and to exploit the energy potential of the food fully,
they must grow and multiply, and this involves large-scale synthesis of microbial protein.The nitrogen for this is obtained, in the form of amino acids, peptides and ammonia, by breakdown of the nitrogen fraction of the food. Bacteria acting on the
structural carbohydrate (SC) fraction of the diet use only ammonia, whereas those acting on the non-structural fraction (NSC) derive about 65 per cent of their nitrogen
from amino acids and peptides, and the remainder from ammonia.
The microbial protein passes from the rumen and is digested in the small intestine, and so makes a contribution to satisfying the amino acid requirements of the
host animal. The magnitude of this contribution depends upon the speed and extent
of microbial breakdown of the dietary nitrogen fraction, the efficiency of the transformation of the degraded material into microbial protein (nitrogenous compounds),
the digestibility of the microbial protein and the biological value of the latter.
The degradative and synthetic processes taking place in the rumen are of major
importance in the nitrogen economy of the host animal since they determine the nature of the amino acid mix made available for protein synthesis at tissue level. The
series of changes undergone by dietary protein between mouth and body tissue in
the ruminant animal is illustrated schematically in Fig. 13.2.
Dietary crude protein
Saliva
Degraded crude protein
Rapidly degraded
crude protein
Undegraded crude protein
Slowly degraded
crude protein
Rumen
Urea
Ammonia
Peptides
Amino acids
Urine
Protozoal protein
Bacterial protein
Undegraded dietary
crude protein
Abomasum and
small intestine
Faeces
Digestible microbial protein
Faeces
Digestible undegraded dietary
protein
Amino acids
Tissue protein
Fig. 13.2 Fate of dietary crude protein in the ruminant animal.
319
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
Satisfying the demands of the rumen microorganisms for readily available nitrogen is a major function of the diet, and to this end a certain proportion of the nitrogen fraction must be degradable by the rumen microorganisms.
Current systems for the evaluation of food protein for ruminant animals involve
determinations of the degradability of protein in the rumen, the synthesis of microbial protein, the digestion in the lower gut of both food and microbial proteins, and
the efficiency of utilisation of absorbed amino acids.The methods used to determine
these components of the system are described next, after which their use in the systems will be illustrated.
Degradability of the nitrogen fraction of the diet
Nitrogen fractions within the diet will vary in their susceptibility to breakdown,
from immediately degraded to undegradable, and from 0 to 1 in the extent to which
they are degraded in the rumen and digested when they reach the small intestine
(see Table 13.8).
Degradability will be affected by such factors as the surface area available for microbial attack and the protective action of other constituents as well as the physical
and chemical nature of the protein. Claims have been made that the solubility of a
protein is correlated with ease of breakdown, but these do not survive critical examination. Thus, casein, which is readily degraded in the rumen, is not readily soluble;
whereas albumin, which is resistant to breakdown, is readily soluble. It has been suggested that a major factor affecting degradability is the amino acid sequence within
the protein molecule. If this is so, then the nature of the microbially produced rumen
peptidases is of considerable importance and it seems doubtful whether any simple
laboratory test for degradability is possible.
The extent to which a nitrogen fraction is degraded in the rumen will depend
upon its innate degradability and the time it spends in the rumen, i.e. rate of passage.
As the rate of passage increases, so the extent of ruminal breakdown is reduced.
Measurement of degradability in vivo
This involves the measurement of dietary nitrogen intake, the endogenous nitrogen
(EN), the non-ammonia nitrogen (NAN) and the microbial nitrogen (MN) of dietary
Table 13.8 Composition, rumen degradation and intestinal digestion of protein fractions
Fraction
Composition
Rumen degradation
(%/hour)
Intestinal
digestibility (%)
A
Ammonia, nitrate, amino
acids, peptides
Globulins, some albumins
Most albumins, glutelins
Prolamins, cell-wall proteins,
denatured proteins
Maillard products, nitrogen bound
to lignin, tannin-bound protein
Instantaneous
None reaches intestine
B1
B2
B3
C
200–300
5–15
0.1–1.5
0
100
100
80
0
Adapted from Chalupa W and Sniffen C J 1994. In: Garnsworthy P C and Cole D J A (eds) Recent Advances in Animal Nutrition,
Nottingham, University of Nottingham Press.
320
Measures of protein quality for ruminant animals
origin passing the duodenum. Degradability (Dg) of nitrogen is then expressed as
follows:
Dg = 1 -
NAN - (MN + EN)
dietary N intake
This method requires accurate measurement of duodenal flow and microbial and
endogenous nitrogen. The flow measurement, which usually requires the use of a
dual-phase marker system, has a large coefficient of variation (between animals),
and many published values must be suspect owing to the small number of animals
used in their determination. Microbial nitrogen in duodenal nitrogen is usually identified by means of marker substances such as diaminopimelic acid (DAPA),
aminoethylphosphoric acid (AEPA), ribonucleic acid and amino acids labelled with
35 32
S, P and 15N. The concentration of marker in the microorganisms is measured in
a sample of rumen fluid. Different markers may give results that vary widely, sometimes by as much as 100 per cent. The assumption that the microorganisms isolated
from rumen fluid are representative of those flowing to the duodenum is of doubtful
validity, since the latter include organisms normally adherent to food particles
and/or the rumen epithelium.The endogenous fraction constitutes about 50–200 g/kg
of the duodenal nitrogen but is difficult to quantify.A value of 150 g/kg is frequently
assumed. Measurements of degradability are thus subject to possible errors owing to
uncertainties in measuring duodenal flow and microbial and endogenous nitrogen,
and are affected by dietary considerations such as the level of feeding and the size
and frequency of meals. It has been calculated that estimates of degradability may
vary over a range of 0.3–0.35 owing to errors of determination alone. Despite its inadequacies, this technique remains the only method currently available for providing an absolute measure of protein degradability and is the standard against which
other methods have to be assessed.
Determination of degradability in sacco (or in situ)
This involves incubation of the food in synthetic fibre bags suspended in the rumen,
as described in Chapter 10.The degradability is calculated as the difference between
the nitrogen initially present in the bag and that present after incubation, stated as a
proportion of the initial nitrogen:
Degradability =
initial N - N after incubation
initial N
When protein disappearance (p) is regressed on time, p increases but at a reducing
rate. The relationship may be described by an equation of the following form:
p = a + b(1 - e - ct)
in which a, b and c are constants that may be fitted by an iterative least-squares procedure. The relationship is illustrated in Fig. 13.3.
In Fig. 13.3, a is the intercept on the y-axis and represents degradability at zero
time. It is the part of the protein that is water-soluble and that is considered to be immediately degradable; b is the difference between a and the asymptote and represents the part of the protein that is degraded more slowly; c is the rate of
disappearance of the potentially degradable fraction b, and t is the time of exposure.
The extent of protein breakdown will depend upon the time for which the protein
321
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
1.00
0.80
Protein
0.60
disappearance
b
0.40
0.20
a
6
12
18
24
t (h)
Fig. 13.3 Relationship of protein disappearance to time of incubation.
remains in the rumen (i.e. upon its rate of passage through the rumen). The effective
degradability P may then be defined as follows:
P = a + 3bc>(c + r)431 - e - (c + r)t4
in which r is the rate of passage from the rumen to the abomasum (see p. 325). As
the time of incubation increases, so the fraction of the protein remaining in the
rumen falls to zero, as does the rate of breakdown, and P may then be defined as
follows:
P = a + bc>(c + r)
In this equation, a is the immediately degradable protein and bc兾(c ⫹ r) is the
slowly degradable fraction.
If we assume a rate of passage of 0.05, with a ⫽ 0.30, b ⫽ 0.70 and c ⫽ 0.02, then
the effective degradability would be 0.3 ⫹ 0.7 ⫻ 0.02兾(0.02 ⫹ 0.05) ⫽ 0.50. The
protein available to the rumen microorganisms would then be 0.50 ⫻ CP.
The technique is subject to several inherent sources of error, which must be controlled if reproducible results are to be obtained. Chief of these are sample size, bag
size, porosity of the bag material and treatment of the bags following removal from
the rumen. Ring tests (i.e. tests carried out at several laboratories) have shown unacceptably high interlaboratory variability, indicating a need for strictly defined standard procedures that have to be adhered to rigidly if the results are to be universally
applied in practice. A standardised procedure is given in the document Agricultural
and Food Research Council (1992) Technical Committee on Responses to Nutrients
Report No. 9, Nutrient Requirements of Ruminant Animals: Protein.
A basic assumption of this method is that disappearance of nitrogen from the
bag, virtually reflecting solubility in rumen fluid, is synonymous with degradability.
It has been known for some time that small amounts of food protein that are solubilised may leave the rumen without being degraded, and this must cast doubt on
the veracity of values obtained using the technique. Even more serious in this context is the recent observation that acid detergent insoluble nitrogen (ADIN), known
322
Measures of protein quality for ruminant animals
to be undegradable, may disappear during incubation. A further complication is the
presence in the bags of rumen bacteria, which contribute to the nitrogen of the contents. The error attributable to microbial attachment can be corrected for by
analysing the bag residues for a microbial marker, but this is expensive and timeconsuming and seldom conducted. The effects of microbial attachment are greatest
in feeds with a high fibre content and low nitrogen content.
Laboratory procedures for determining nitrogen degradability
Solubility in buffer solutions
Significant correlations have been demonstrated between the degradability values for
the nitrogen fractions of foods and their solubility characteristics in a range of buffer
solutions, including McDougall artificial saliva, borate–phosphate buffer and Wise
Burroughs’s buffer.When the methods are used for a range of foods, errors of prediction may be high, but within food types predictions are improved sufficiently to allow
the use of buffer solubility in the routine monitoring of concentrate foods.
When used in conjunction with methods for the fractionation of dietary nitrogen
to predict degradability, solubility in buffer solution has shown good correlation with
figures based on enzyme solubility (see below).
Solubility in enzyme solutions
Solubilisation of protein by purified enzymes from fungi and bacteria has been
widely investigated as a means of estimating degradability. Different proteases have
given varying results when compared with the in sacco technique. This is not unexpected in view of the fact that a single enzyme is being used to simulate the action
of the complex multienzyme system of the rumen. As with the buffer solutions, accuracy of prediction is poor over a range of foods but improves when the technique
is applied within food types. The most promising enzyme sources have been
Streptococcus griseus, Streptococcus bovis, Bacteroides amylophilus and
Butyrovibrio strain 7. Streptococcus griseus protease is the preferred source of enzyme for estimating degradability in the French protein digested in the intestine
(PDI) system.The method used incorporates corrections for different food types, and
the regression equation of degradability in sacco on enzyme solubility has a quoted
residual standard deviation (rsd) of 0.025. Thus, estimates of degradability could be
expected to be within ⫾ 0.05 of the in sacco value on 95 per cent of occasions.
Chemical analysis
A number of workers have shown significant correlations between crude protein
content and degradability, reflecting the decreased proportion of the nitrogen fraction bound to fibre with increasing nitrogen content. The following equation for predicting the nitrogen degradability of grasses has been claimed to have an acceptable
error of prediction:
Dg = (0.9 - 2.4r)(CP - 0.059NDF)>CP
where Dg is degradability, CP and NDF are as g/kg and r is the outflow rate per hour.
In the Cornell net protein and carbohydrate system, food protein is separated
into fractions based on a combination of borate–phosphate extractions and the
detergent system of carbohydrate analysis of Goering and Van Soest (Fig. 13.4).
323
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
Total nitrogen
Borate
buffer
solution
Soluble
Neutraldetergent
solution
Insoluble
Soluble
Insoluble
Aciddetergent
solution
Soluble
A
A
A
B1
B1
B1
B2
B2
B2
B3
B3
C
C
Insoluble
B3
C
A = soluble in buffer; B1 = soluble in buffer and precipitated by trichloracetic acid;
B2 = insoluble in buffer but soluble in neutral- and acid-detergent solutions;
B3 = insoluble in buffer, insoluble in neutral-detergent solution but soluble
in acid-detergent solution; C = insoluble in buffer and both neutral- and acid-detergent solutions.
Fig. 13.4 Partitioning of dietary protein.
From Chalupa W and Sniffen C J 1994. In: Garnsworthy P C and Cole D J A (eds) Recent Advances in Animal
Nutrition, Nottingham, University of Nottingham Press.
The protein is then allocated a degradability value based on the proportions of
the various fractions present and their enzyme-determined degradability values (see
Table 13.8).
Near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy
Near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy (NIRS) measurements reflect the types and
proportions of organic structures within a material.As such, they are used widely for
the routine analysis of foods and their nutritional evaluation (see Chapter 1). The
technique might therefore be expected to provide a solution to the problem of determining degradability. Current indications are that NIRS has the ability to estimate nitrogen degradability with a high degree of precision and considerable accuracy, with
R2 values of 0.80–0.87 being claimed.
In vitro rumen fermentation techniques
In vitro techniques mimic rumen fermentation by incubating a test protein with
rumen fluid. In order to improve repeatability and reproducibility, most techniques
have been standardised. Systems can be either a simple batch system that measures
the volume or pressure of gas produced as an indicator of microbial activity, or a
more sophisticated continuous culture system, with the most developed being the
Rusitec or dual-phase continuous culture system. In general, in vitro measures of
rumen degradation are less time-consuming and expensive than in vivo measurements, but they are limited by their inability to recycle nitrogen to the rumen
microorganisms. They also need a source of rumen fluid to start the culture and
require the use of microbial markers with their inherent limitations, as described
earlier. End-product inhibition of batch cultures may cause severe deviations from
the digestive process occurring in vivo.
324
Measures of protein quality for ruminant animals
Rate of passage (r)
The extent to which a protein is broken down in the rumen depends not only on its
innate degradability but also upon the length of time for which it is exposed to
breakdown and therefore upon its rate of passage through the rumen. It may be defined as follows:
Dg = Kd>(Kd + r)
where Dg ⫽ rumen degradability, Kd ⫽ rate of digestion and r ⫽ rate of passage.
The rate of passage of food from the rumen is affected by a complex of food and
animal factors. Passage is faster for:
■
■
■
■
smaller particles;
particles of higher density;
more highly hydrated particles;
more highly digested particles.
Passage will thus increase as digestion and rumination proceeds.
Rate of passage increases with increased dry matter intake and is thereby affected
by a number of animal and environmental factors:
■
■
■
■
Advancing pregnancy limits rumen fill and increases rate of passage.
Lactation increases intake and rate of passage.
Excessive body condition can reduce intake and rate of passage.
High environmental temperatures will reduce intake and throughput.
The value for r may be determined by treatment of the protein with dichromate.
The treatment renders the protein completely indigestible, there is no loss of
chromium from the protein subsequent to treatment, and particle size distribution is
not affected. The rate of dilution of chromium in samples of rumen contents taken
over a period of time (see Chapter 8) can therefore provide an estimate of the rate of
passage of the protein from the rumen.
Efficiency of nitrogen capture
The efficiency with which nitrogen is captured by the microorganisms of the rumen depends not only upon the speed and extent of breakdown but also upon the synchronous provision of a readily available, utilisable source of energy to fuel the synthesis of
microbial protein. Failure to achieve this balance can result in too rapid and extensive
a breakdown, and the synthetic powers of the rumen microorganisms may be overwhelmed. Wastage may then occur, since the excess ammonia is absorbed and largely
excreted as urea; some, however, is recycled via the rumen wall and contributes further to the nitrogen economy of the rumen.The extent of recycling has been estimated
as about 70 per cent of nitrogen intake for diets of low protein content (about 50 g/kg)
and as little as 11 per cent for foods with about 200 g/kg. The extent of recycling in a
particular situation may be calculated using the following equation:
Y = 121.7 - 12.01X + 0.3235X2
where Y ⫽ recycled urea nitrogen as a percentage of nitrogen intake and X ⫽ per
cent crude protein in dry matter.
325
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
The part of the food crude protein that is immediately degradable is unlikely to be
as effective a source of nitrogen for the microorganisms as that which is more slowly
degraded. It is generally considered that the slowly degraded nitrogen fraction is incorporated into microbial protein with an efficiency of 1.0, whereas that immediately
degraded is used less efficiently. Estimates of the efficiency with which immediately
degraded protein is incorporated vary, but 0.8 is a commonly used figure.
Yield of microbial protein
The yield of microbial protein that becomes available for digestion and absorption
post-ruminally by the host has been related to the energy of the diet stated in terms
of digestible organic matter (DOM), digestible organic matter digested in the rumen
(DOMADR), total digestible nutrients (TDN), metabolisable energy (ME), fermentable organic matter (FOM), fermentable metabolisable energy (FME), rumendegradable carbohydrate and rumen-degradable dry matter. The last four eliminate
products of fermentation and fat, neither of which is considered to provide energy
that can be utilised by the rumen microorganisms.The energy of fermentation products is significant in the case of silages and some distillery and brewery by-products.
Hays are not considered to have undergone fermentation, though they often
contain measurable amounts of fermentation acids such as acetic and propionic acid.
The routine measurement of the contribution of fermentation products to metabolisable energy in individual foods has not been a feasible proposition, and assumed
values are commonly used. The validity of such values is questionable in view of the
variation in the magnitude and diversity of the fermentation products in individual
foods.
A simple relationship between available energy and microbial protein yield cannot reflect the true position. It takes no account of the following:
■
■
■
The maintenance requirement of the microorganisms, which has been estimated
to vary from 0.022 g to 0.187 g carbohydrate/g bacteria per hour: when fermentation is slow, as with diets rich in structural carbohydrate, maintenance costs may
be significant and estimates of microbial yield may be exaggerated.
The rumen environment: lowering the rumen pH from 6.7 to 5.7 has been shown
to halve microbial protein production, which may be significant when diets are
rich in soluble carbohydrate and low in fibre, with consequent production of lactic acid and ruminal acidosis.
Variation in the form of nitrogen required by the different types of microorganism: thus, the organisms splitting non-structural carbohydrates (NSC) are able to
utilise peptide nitrogen and ammonia, whereas those splitting structural carbohydrates are unable to use amino nitrogen and have to rely on ammonia as their
source of nitrogen. It has been shown that the yield of NSC-splitting bacteria is
increased by almost 20 per cent when the proportion of peptides in the total
NSC ⫹ peptides increases from 0 per cent to 14 per cent.Above 14 per cent there
is no further increase in yield.
The relationships used in predicting microbial protein from fermentable energy
have high standard errors of estimate and should be used with caution. In addition,
such relationships may be used to calculate yields of microbial protein only when
the supply of energy is limiting.When the supply of protein to the microorganisms is
limiting, this will determine the yield of microbial protein.
326
Measures of protein quality for ruminant animals
Sophisticated models attempt to relate microbial yield to the rate of carbohydrate
fermentation and rate of passage, the theoretical growth rate, the energy cost of bacterial maintenance and the form of nitrogen available to the rumen microorganisms. Many
of the relationships involved in such calculations are based on laboratory characterisation of the food, and the value of the model will depend on the validity of the relationships between the laboratory determinations and the values used in the models.
True digestibility of protein
The microbial protein synthesised in the rumen may be protozoal or bacterial, the
relative proportions depending upon conditions within that organ. Thus, low rumen
pH tends to reduce protozoal activity and stimulate that of certain bacteria.The mixture of bacterial and protozoal protein, along with dietary protein not degraded in
the rumen, passes to the abomasum and small intestine. Here, it is broken down to
amino acids, which are then absorbed into the body. The digestibility of bacterial
protein is lower (about 0.75) than that of the protozoal (about 0.90), and the overall
digestibility of microbial protein will depend to some extent upon the rumen environment. However, protozoal protein constitutes only 5–15 per cent of the total
microbial protein flow from the rumen, and its influence on the overall digestibility
of microbial protein will be small. The composition of bacteria is variable, but that
shown in Table 13.9 is an acceptable approximation.
About 15 per cent of the total nitrogen is in the form of nucleic acids, about
25 per cent is cell wall protein and the remainder is true protein. Available evidence
indicates that the digestibility of nucleic acid nitrogen is of the order of 0.8–0.9, and
that of microbial true protein 0.85–0.9. It is commonly assumed that the protein
associated with the cell walls is completely indigestible. Most estimates of the true
digestibility of microbial protein are of the order of 0.85–0.87, which is higher than
might be expected in view of the proportions of the fractions present in the protein.
Although nucleic acids are highly digestible, their nitrogen is of no use to the animal,
because after absorption it is totally excreted in the urine. Measurement of these
breakdown products in the urine (particularly derivatives from purine-based nucleic
acids) can be used to determine the extent of microbial growth in the rumen. The
measurement of urinary purine derivatives avoids the need for surgically modified
animals and has been shown to correlate well with other measures of microbial protein synthesis in the rumen. However, the output of purine derivatives in urine has
been shown to vary considerably throughout the day, requiring all of the urine to be
collected.Attempts to relate microbial protein synthesis in the rumen to milk purine
derivative levels have been unsuccessful.
Table 13.9 Composition of rumen bacteria
g/kg dry matter
Crude protein
True protein
Cell wall protein
Nucleic acid (nitrogen ⫻ 6.25)
Carbohydrate
Fat
Ash
625
375
155
95
210
120
45
327
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
The digestibility of the undegraded dietary protein is a characteristic of the protein mix in the food and may vary considerably from diet to diet. The true digestibility of the undegraded dietary protein will vary with the proportion of the various
protein fractions present. Thus, amino acids, peptides, globulins, albumins and
glutelins will be almost completely digested; prolamins, proteins associated with the
cell walls and denatured proteins will have digestibility values of about 0.8; the protein of Maillard products and nitrogen bound to lignin will be completely indigestible. Some estimates of the true digestibility values of the various protein
fractions are shown in Table 13.8.
Digestibility has been shown to be related inversely to the content of acid detergent insoluble nitrogen (ADIN), which reflects the part of the food nitrogen that is
bound closely to insoluble fibre. The digestible undegradable protein content (DUP)
of a food is calculated thus:
DUP = 0.9 (undegradable protein - ADIN * 6.25)
This equation is based on the assumptions that ADIN is indigestible and that the digestible fraction has a true digestibility of 0.9.
In the case of foods such as maize gluten and some distillery and brewery byproducts, which have been heat treated under moist conditions, Maillard-type reactions (see Chapter 4) may occur, resulting in an increase in the concentration of
nitrogenous compounds insoluble in acid detergent. Such ‘acquired ADIN’ does have
a finite although low digestibility, and the above equation is unreliable when used for
such foods. The use of ADIN is also limited in feeds with a high tannin content, as
tannins bind protein in the gut, resulting in a greater output in the faeces than intake.
Other methods that have been used to estimate the digestibility of undegradable
protein in the small intestine include in vitro incubation with acid followed by proteases, and the insertion of mobile synthetic fibre bags containing previously ruminally degraded feed into the small intestine of cannulated animals, and recovery
from an ileal cannula or faeces. The difference between the protein inserted into the
bag and recovered at the terminal ileum provides an estimate of true digestion of undegraded protein in the small intestine.
Efficiency of utilisation of absorbed amino acids
The mixture of amino acids of dietary origin absorbed from the small intestine (i.e.
the truly digested amino acids) is utilised for the synthesis of tissue protein. The efficiency of this process, which depends upon the composition of the mix relative to
that of the protein to be synthesised, is best represented by its true biological value.
This will in turn depend upon the biological values of the digested undegraded
dietary protein and the digested microbial protein, and upon the relative proportions
of each contributing to the mix. In addition, it will vary with the primary function
for which it is required. Microbial protein is thought to have a relatively constant
biological value of about 0.8, whereas that of dietary origin will be variable and
characteristic of the foods making up the diet. Prediction of such dietary values is
extremely difficult, since the biological values of the individual proteins are no guide
to their value in combinations. The variability of estimates with which truly digestible true protein presented for absorption is used for various functions is illustrated in Table 13.10.
328
Measures of protein quality for ruminant animals
Table 13.10 Comparison of estimates of the efficiency of utilisation of truly
digested true protein made in some protein evaluation systems for ruminants
System
PDI
CPFD
DVE
AAT-PBV
AP
ADPLS
CNCPS
Maintenance
0.80
0.67
0.67
0.70
0.67
Lactation
Growth
0.64
0.80
0.64
0.75
0.67
0.70
0.65
0.28–0.68
0.80
0.50
0.70
0.41–0.75
Wool/hair
0.60
PDI ⫽ the French protein digested in the intestine system; CPFD ⫽ the German crude protein
flow at duodenum system; DVE ⫽ the Dutch digestible protein in the intestine system; AATPBV ⫽ the Nordic system; AP ⫽ the American absorbed true protein system; ADPLS ⫽ the
Australian apparently digested protein leaving the stomach system; CNCPS ⫽ the Cornell net
protein and carbohydrate system.
The Agricultural and Food Research Council, in its 1992 publication (see Further
reading), describes the efficiency of utilisation of truly digested true protein in terms
of the limiting efficiency of use of an ideally balanced amino acid mixture (kaai),
taken as 0.85 under most conditions and 1.0 for maintenance. Relative values (RV)
were then proposed for different functions:
Growth
Pregnancy
Lactation
Wool growth
0.7
1.0
0.8
0.3
The two factors were then combined to give the following working values (kn):
Maintenance
Growth
Pregnancy
Lactation
Wool growth
knm ⫽ 1.00
kng ⫽ 0.59
knc ⫽ 0.85
knl ⫽ 0.68
knw ⫽ 0.26
An alternative approach is to estimate the supply of essential amino acids made
available to the tissues (i.e. those absorbed from the small intestine) and to relate
this to the amino acid requirements of the animal. This approach needs information
on the truly digestible amino acid content of the undegraded dietary and the microbial protein.
The essential amino acid content of ruminal microbial protein is frequently
claimed to be relatively constant. In fact, large differences in the amino acid composition of samples of microbial protein have been shown to exist. Some figures, based
on 441 samples from 35 experiments covering 61 diets, are given in Table 13.11.
There is evidence that the essential amino acid composition of undegradable
dietary protein may differ significantly from that of the original dietary material, and
329
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
Table 13.11 Amino acid composition of ruminal bacteria (g/100 g of amino acids)
Amino acid
Mean
Arginine
Histidine
Isoleucine
Leucine
Lysine
Methionine
Phenylalanine
Threonine
Valine
Alanine
Aspartic acid
Glutamic acid
Glycine
Proline
Serine
Tyrosine
5.1
2.0
5.7
8.1
7.9
2.6
5.1
5.8
6.2
7.5
12.2
13.1
5.8
3.7
4.6
4.9
Minimum
3.8
1.2
4.6
5.3
4.9
1.1
4.4
5.0
4.7
5.0
10.9
11.6
5.0
2.4
3.4
3.9
Maximum
Standard
Coefficient of
deviation
variation (%)
0.7
0.4
0.4
0.8
0.9
0.7
0.3
0.5
0.6
0.6
0.6
0.7
0.5
0.5
0.4
0.6
13.2
21.3
7.4
10.3
11.9
25.6
6.4
8.9
10.1
7.3
4.8
5.3
8.2
13.2
8.9
13.2
6.8
3.6
6.7
9.7
9.5
4.9
6.3
7.8
7.6
8.6
13.5
14.4
7.6
5.3
5.4
7.7
From Clark J H, Klusmeyer T H and Cameron M R 1992 Journal of Dairy Science 75: 2304–23.
it has been suggested that estimates of its contribution to the amino acid supply
should be based on the amino acid profile of the insoluble fraction of the dietary
protein rather than that of the whole dietary protein. A comparison of the essential
amino acid profiles of whole and insoluble proteins in some common foods is shown
in Table 13.12.
Table 13.12 Amino acid composition of whole and insoluble protein in some
common foods (g/100 g protein)
Dried brewer’s
grains
Maize
A
Methionine
Lysine
Histidine
Phenylalanine
Threonine
Leucine
Isoleucine
Valine
Arginine
1.6
2.2
2.2
4.2
2.7
10.3
3.4
3.5
3.7
B
1.4
1.7
1.9
4.5
2.7
11.6
2.9
3.9
2.7
Soya bean
meal
Maize
silage
Timothy
hay
A
B
A
B
A
B
A
B
1.4
2.1
1.7
4.4
2.6
8.1
3.8
3.8
3.6
0.6
2.1
1.3
3.9
2.3
6.8
3.2
3.6
3.0
1.0
5.2
1.7
4.1
3.0
6.2
4.4
3.4
6.0
0.8
6.6
1.3
3.9
3.0
6.2
4.3
3.8
7.8
0.9
1.8
0.9
3.0
2.4
6.5
2.8
3.7
1.7
0.9
2.2
0.9
3.1
2.2
6.9
2.5
3.5
2.2
0.7
2.9
1.1
3.4
2.9
5.2
3.4
3.5
3.2
0.9
2.8
1.1
3.4
2.8
5.4
2.8
3.9
3.0
A is dietary protein. B is insoluble protein (aa in whole protein - aa in buffer-soluble protein aa in cell wall protein).
After Muscato T V, Sniffen C J, Krishnamoorthy U and Van Soest P J 1983 Journal of Dairy Science 66:
2198–207.
330
The UK metabolisable protein system
A measure of the effect of assuming one or other of the measures of amino acid
composition can be gained if we consider the following daily ration:
DM (kg)
Maize silage
Maize
Soya bean meal
Total
B as per cent of A
10.0
5.0
3.0
18.0
CP (g)
1100
490
1509
3099
Methionine (g)
Lysine (g)
A
B
A
B
9.9
7.8
15.1
32.8
9.9
6.9
12.0
28.8
88
19.8
10.8
78.4
109.0
24.2
8.3
99.5
132.0
121
A is calculated by assuming the amino acid composition of the whole protein. B is calculated
by assuming the composition of the insoluble available fraction.
Amino acids are usually considered to have the same true digestibility as true
protein, but there is evidence that the efficiency with which individual amino acids
are metabolised will vary with the biological value of the protein and the amino acid
supply relative to requirement.
A system for the quantitative nutrition of ruminant animals should embody the
processes described, which requires that factors such as degradability, efficiency of
nitrogen capture, microbial protein yield, digestibility of microbial protein, digestibility
of dietary undegraded protein and the true biological value of the absorbed nitrogen
or its essential amino acid content be quantified.
13.8
THE UK METABOLISABLE PROTEIN SYSTEM
The system is fully described in the 1992 report of the Agricultural and Food Research
Council’s Technical Committee on Responses to Nutrients (see Further reading).
The microbial demand for protein is stated in terms of effective rumen-degradable
protein (ERDP) and foods have to be evaluated in the same terms. The ERDP of a
food is calculated as follows:
ERDP = CP * 30.8a + bc>(c + r)4
where a, b and c are the fitted parameters derived from the determination in sacco
of the degradability of the food, 0.8 is the efficiency of capture of the nitrogen of the
readily degradable fraction, and r is the outflow rate and is varied as follows:
Animal
Cattle and sheep at low planes of nutrition
Calves, beef cattle, sheep and dairy cows (up to twice
the maintenance level of feeding)
Dairy cows yielding more than 15 kg of milk per day
r
0.02
0.05
0.08
Alternatively, the following equation may be used for calculating r for levels of
feeding (L) as multiples of ME for maintenance:
r = - 0.02 + 0.14(1 - e-0.35L)
331
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
Account is thus taken of the differential capture of rapidly and slowly degradable
proteins and the rate of passage through the rumen.
The demand for amino acids at tissue level is quantified in terms of truly digestible protein required to be absorbed from the small intestine and designated
‘metabolisable protein’ (MP), as described in Chapters 14–16.
Microbial protein contributes towards satisfying this demand. The yield of microbial crude protein is related to the energy available to the rumen microorganisms in
terms of fermentable metabolisable energy:
FME = ME - MEfat - MEferm
MEferm is assumed to be 0.1 ME for silages and 0.05 ME for brewery and distillery
by-products, and MEfat is 35 MJ/kg. The assumption made here for silage must be
suspect. The major fermentation product in well-made silages is lactate, and there is
evidence that several rumen bacteria, notably Megasphaera elsdenii (see Table 8.3 in
Chapter 8), are able to utilise lactate with the production of propionate. The microbial crude protein yield (g) is calculated as follows:
FME (MJ)y
where y ⫽ 9 at maintenance, 10 for growth and 11 for lactation; or alternatively:
y = 7 + 6(1 - e-0.35L)
The proportion of the microbial crude protein present as true protein is assumed
to be 0.75 and the true digestibility to be 0.85, and the contribution of microbial
protein (DMP) to the truly absorbed amino acids is:
DMP (g>kg DM) = FME (y * 0.75 * 0.85) = 0.6375(FMEy)
When this contribution is taken into account, there remains a residual metabolisable protein requirement, which may be calculated as MP - DMP and which has to
be satisfied by the truly digestible undegraded protein of the diet.The true digestibility of dietary undegraded protein is calculated on the assumption that the ADIN
content is indigestible and that the remainder has a true digestibility of 0.9.The truly
digestible undegraded true protein (DUP) is then:
DUP = 0.95CP31 - a - bc>(c + r)4 - 6.25ADIN6
where a, b and c are the usual in sacco constants and DUP, CP and ADIN are g/kg DM.
The metabolisable protein supplied by the food may be calculated as MP (g/kg
DM) ⫽ DMP ⫹ DUP. An example of the evaluation of a protein source in these
terms is given in Box 13.1.
The metabolisable protein content of a food is of no use as a guide to the food’s
ability to satisfy the residual demand for metabolisable protein, since it includes a
contribution from ERDP, which has already been taken into account in the form of
DMP. The protein content of foods is thus stated in terms of ERDP and DUP.
332
Feed into Milk
BOX 13.1 Evaluation of a protein source for a ruminant animal
Animal: 70 kg ewe with twin lambs producing 3 kg milk/day, y ⫽ 11.
A concentrate feed has:
CP (g/kg DM) ⫽ 550
EE (g/kg DM) ⫽ 20
ME (MJ/kg DM) ⫽ 12.5
a ⫽ 0.2
b ⫽ 0.65
c ⫽ 0.06
r ⫽ 0.05
ADIN (g/kg DM) ⫽ 0.20
Then:
ERDP (g/kg DM) ⫽ 550{0.8 ⫻ 0.2 ⫹ [0.65 ⫻ 0.06兾(0.06 ⫹ 0.05)]} ⫽ 283
FME (MJ/kg DM) ⫽ 12.5 - (35 ⫻ 0.02) ⫽ 11.8
ERDP/FME ⫽ 283/11.8 ⫽ 23.98 > y and energy is limiting.
Then:
DMP (g) ⫽ 0.6375(11.8 ⫻ 11) ⫽ 82.7
DUP (g/kg DM) ⫽ 0.9{[550(1 - 0.2 - (0.65 ⫻ 0.06兾(0.06 ⫹ 0.05)))] - 6.25 ⫻ 0.2} ⫽ 219.4
MP (g/kg)(DMP ⫹ DUP) ⫽ 82.7 ⫹ 219.4 ⫽ 302.1
Then:
ERDP ⫽ 283 g/kg DM
DUP ⫽ 219 g/kg DM
13.9
FEED INTO MILK
A rationing system developed specifically for dairy cows, Feed into Milk (FiM) is
now used in the UK, full details of which can be obtained in the advisory manual by
Thomas (2004; see Further reading). The system retains many of the characteristics
of AFRC (1992), with a few notable modifications. For example, FME is replaced as
the unit of energy supply for microbial protein synthesis by adenosine triphosphate
(ATP), which is derived from the degradation of feed dry matter in the rumen. Microbial DM is produced in a three-stage process: microbial degradation of feeds to
simple compounds, the fermentation of these compounds to yield ATP, and the conversion of this ATP to microbial protein (Fig. 13.5). The microbial degradation of
feeds is calculated using the in sacco degradability characteristics of feed DM and
protein, along with rumen outflow rates for liquid, forage and concentrates.
For both protein and DM degradability, FiM uses a modification of the in sacco
technique described by AFRC (1992). The soluble or ‘a’ fraction is in reality the
washable fraction that includes fine particles that leave the synthetic fibre bags but
are not immediately available. FiM attempts to account for this by correcting for
water soluble losses (‘s’) by immersing the feed in water for 1 hour and filtering
through a 16 µm filter paper and calculating ‘s’ using the following equation:
‘s’ =
(Xin - Xretained)
Xin
333
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
Feed DM
Soluble
and very
small
particles
Calculated using s, a, b
and c values for feed DM
kliq
Degraded
DM (g)
(ssp)
Concentrate
particles
kc
Forage
particles
kf
Degraded
DM (g)
(conc.)
Degraded
DM (g)
(forage)
ATP yield (ATPy)
conc. (mol/g DM)
ATP yield (ATPy)
forage (mol/g DM)
Yield of ATP depends
on content of crude
protein in feed
ATP yield (ATPy)
ssp (mol/g DM)
Efficiency of conversion
depends on rumen
outflow rate
YATP (ssp)
YATP (conc.)
YATP (forage)
Total microbial
protein yield (g/day)
Fig. 13.5 Production of microbial protein from feed DM in Feed into Milk (FiM).
kliq, kc and kf are fractional outflow rates from the rumen for small particles,
concentrates and forages. ATPy is the yield of ATP from DM, and YATP is the
efficiency of conversion of ATP into microbial protein from soluble and small
particles (ssp), concentrates (conc.) and forage (forage).
Adapted from Thomas (2004).
where X is either g DM or nitrogen. Fine particles are then calculated as the difference between the in sacco initial wash value (‘a’) and ‘s’. The fine particles are assumed to have the same degradability characteristics (‘b’ and ‘c’ values) as the large
particles but flow out of the rumen with the liquid phase. The soluble component
(‘s’) is assumed to have a rate of degradation of 0.9/hour and also flows out of the
rumen with the liquid fraction. For silages, the ‘s’ fraction is first corrected by subtracting fermentation acids.
The DM and nitrogen within a feed are considered to belong to one of three
pools: the soluble/small particle pool (derived from both the forages and concentrates), the forage particle pool, or the concentrate particle pool (depending on
whether the feed is a forage or concentrate). There is a a separate outflow rate from
the rumen for the three pools: a liquid outflow rate for the soluble/small particle
pool (kliq), a forage (kf) outflow rate for the long forage particles, and a concentrate
(kc) outflow rate for the large concentrate particles. The outflow rates are calculated
334
Feed into Milk
Table 13.13 Influence of DM intake and proportion of forage in the
diet (kg DM/kg DM) on predicted liquid (kliq), forage (kf) and
concentrate (kc) outflow rates (proportion per hour) using FiM (2004)
DM intake (kg/day)
18
Forage proportion
kliq
kf
kc
0.8
0.087
0.049
0.064
20
0.5
0.076
0.045
0.058
22
0.35
0.075
0.046
0.060
from the DM intake, the animal liveweight (W) and the proportion of forage in the
ration:
kliq = 0.0245 + (0.25 DMI>(W0.75) + 0.04f2
kf = 0.0035 + (0.22 DMI>W0.75) + 0.02f2
kc = 0.0025 + 1.25 kf
where DMI is dry matter intake (kg/d),W is liveweight (kg) and f is the proportion of
forage in the diet (DM basis). In practice, liquid, forage and concentrate outflow rates
are relatively constant over a range of DM intakes and forage proportions, as shown
in Table 13.13. To simplify the calculations, set outflow rates of 0.08, 0.045 and 0.06
for kliq, kf and kc, respectively, may be used.
Effective degradable nitrogen
The supply of effective degradable nitrogen (edn) from each feed is calculated from
the degradability characteristics of the nitrogen fractions determined in sacco and
the appropriate outflow rates for the three fractions using the following equation:
edn = (0.9sN>(0.9 + kliq)) + (bDN cN>(cN + kliq)) + (bN cN>(cN + k))
where edn is effective degradable nitrogen, sN, bDN, bN and cN are the soluble,
degradable small particle, degradable large particle nitrogen and fractional rate of
degradation fractions of the feed (for either concentrates or forage). The proportion
of nitrogen contained in the small particles (bDN) is calculated from the a, s and b
fractions of the feed as (bN (aN - sN))兾(1 - aN) and k is the fractional outflow rate of
the forage (kf) or concentrate (kc), depending on the feed type being evaluated.
Potential microbial crude protein supply from degradable nitrogen is determined as
edn ⫻ 6.25.As in AFRC (1992), it is assumed that the true protein content of microbial crude protein is 750 g/kg crude protein and that the digestibility of the true protein is 850 g/kg. Therefore, digestible microbial true protein (DMTP) is 0.6375
microbial crude protein. The supply of digestible undegradable protein (DUP) is calculated in the same manner as described by AFRC (1992).
Degradability of dry matter
The effective degradability of the DM of the soluble/small particles (eddmssp) is calculated as follows:
eddmssp = (0.9s>(0.9 + kliq)) + (bDc>(c + kliq))
335
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
For the large particles in concentrates or forages, the effective degradability
(eddmlp) is calculated as follows:
eddmlp = (bc>(c + k))
Conversion of degraded dry matter to ATP
The degraded DM is then converted into a yield of ATP (mol/day) that is available
for microbial maintenance and growth.An in vitro technique is proposed as the standard reference method to estimate the efficiency of production of ATP per unit of
degraded DM. Alternatively, the yield of ATP may be predicted from the following
equation:
ATP yield (mol/kg DM apparently degraded) = 27.3 - 0.0248CP (g/kg DM)
Caution should be exercised when using this equation, particularly for feeds that
are high in non-protein nitrogen, as these may underestimate the ATP yield.
Conversion of ATP to microbial protein
The ATP yield (mol/kg DM) is converted by the rumen microbes to produce microbial DM. The efficiency of this conversion (YATP g microbial DM per mol ATP) is determined by the growth rate of the microbes, with faster-growing microbes using the
energy more efficiently than those growing more slowly. The rate of growth of the
microbes is determined by the phase with which they associate (i.e. soluble/small
particles, forage or concentrate particles) and its outflow rate from the rumen and is
calculated as follows:
YATP = 9 + 50k
where k is the fractional outflow rate of liquid for the soluble/small particles, the forage or concentrates, depending on the feed type. For example, for a liquid outflow
rate of 0.08 per hour, YATP will be 13 g microbial DM per mol ATP, whereas a forage
outflow rate of 0.045 per hour will yield 11.3 g DM per mol ATP. The total yield of
microbial DM (MDM g/day) for a particular feed from each feed fraction is then calculated as follows:
MDM = (ATPssp * YATPssp) + (ATPlp * YATPlp)
whereATPssp ⫽ yieldATP from soluble/small particles (mol/g DM),YATPssp ⫽ efficiency
of conversion of ATP to microbial DM for microbes associates with soluble/small
particles in forages or concentrates (g DM/mol ATP), ATPlp ⫽ yield ATP from large
particles in forages or concentrates (mol/g DM), and YATPssp ⫽ efficiency of conversion of ATP to microbial DM for microbes associated with large particles (gDM/mol
ATP).
Finally, to convert microbial DM to microbial protein, it is assumed that rumen
microbes contain 100 gN/kg DM and that microbial crude protein consists of 160 g
N/kg DM, providing a microbial crude protein content of 625 g/kg microbial DM.
Microbial crude protein is converted to digestible microbial true protein by multiplying by 0.6375, as described earlier.
The preceding calculations are complicated and lend themselves more easily
to being undertaken by a computer program or spreadsheet than by hand. If
constant outflow rates for the liquid, forage and concentrates phases of 0.08, 0.045
336
Summary
and 0.06 per hour, respectively, are used, then each feed will have a fixed metabolisable protein supply derived from either the sum of the digestible microbial crude
protein produced from the effectively degraded nitrogen supply and DUP (MPN), or
the sum of the digestible microbial protein produced from the rumen available energy supply and DUP (MPE). These values are additive for each ingredient within a
ration, making diet formulation quick and simple. For example, a dairy cow fed 7 kg
DM per day of a concentrate with an MPE value of 135 g/kg DM and an MPN value
of 158 g/kg DM and consuming 10.5 kg DM per day of grass silage with an MPE
value of 84 g/kg DM and an MPN value of 89 g/kg DM would have a predicted daily
metabolisable protein supply from rumen available energy (MPE) of (7 ⫻ 135) ⫹
(10.5 ⫻ 84) ⫽ 1827 g.The corresponding MPN values would be (7 ⫻ 158) ⫹ (10.5 ⫻
89) ⫽ 2041 g. As the diet is limited first by MPE, daily metabolisable protein supply
is predicted to be 1827 g per day. The MPE and MPN values are routinely provided
for forages when analysed by NIRS.
FiM also assumes a constant ruminal pH of approximately pH 6.2 and ignores the
detrimental effects that low pH can have on ruminal metabolism. The system does,
however, provide an estimate of whether rumen pH is likely to be altered through
the calculation of a rumen stability value (RSV). The RSV of a feed is dependent on
its fibre content, whether it is a concentrate or forage, and the potential acid load
(PAL). The PAL content is a measure of the amount of acid that will be produced by
the feed on incubation with rumen liquor, expressed as meq/kg DM. Typically, hay
will have a PAL of 800 meq/kg DM and barley 1150 meq/kg DM. The requirement
for RSV is affected by cow age, milk yield and quality, and the feeding system used.
For example, fourth-lactation cows fed a total mixed ration will have a lower RSV
requirement than first-lactation animals fed concentrates twice daily in the parlour.
If the RSV balance (RSV from diet - RSV requirement) is greater than ⫹20, then it
is assumed that no problems with acidosis should be encountered; if it is below 0,
then it is advised that the diet should be modified.
SUMMARY
1. For food protein to be used with maximum
efficiency, its constituent essential and nonessential amino acids must be present in the
diet in sufficient quantities to meet the animal’s metabolic demands.
2. Crude protein is a measure of food protein
calculated as nitrogen content multiplied by
6.25. Digestible crude protein is calculated as
6.25 times the difference between nitrogen
intake and nitrogen voided in the faeces.
3. Ileal digestibility is measured as the difference between nitrogen intake and nitrogen
voided at the terminal ileum.
4. For true digestibility, the endogenous component of the faecal or ileal matter must be
known.
5. Standardised digestibility takes account of
only part of the endogenous nitrogen and
remains an apparent figure.
6. Standardised methods (protein efficiency
ratio, net protein ratio and gross protein
value) based on the growth response of
experimental animals are used to evaluate
protein sources for monogastric
animals.
7. Nitrogen balance is the difference between
nitrogen intake and nitrogen output in the
form of faeces, urine, milk and eggs. As an estimate of protein deposition in the animal’s
tissues, it is subject to several errors, and the
results have been known to diverge from
those of the comparative slaughter technique.
337
Chapter 13 Evaluation of foods: protein
8. Biological value is stated as the proportion of
the nitrogen intake that is actually retained
and takes account of endogenous urinary and
faecal nitrogen, whereas chemical score and
the essential amino acid index are based on
the proportion of the main limiting amino
acid of the protein in relation to that in a
standard protein.
9. Assays of available amino acids may be made
by measuring the liveweight gain or food conversion efficiency of animals given the intact
protein as a supplement to a diet deficient in a
particular essential amino acid. Certain microorganisms have amino acid requirements
similar to those of higher animals and have
been used for protein evaluation.
10. Determination of available lysine by reaction
of fluoro-4-dinitrobenzene with the reactive
epsilon group has been shown to correlate
well with gross protein values of animal
foods and for supplements for high-cereal
diets.
11. Dye-binding methods have proved satisfactory for cereal and milk products.
12. Standardised ileal digestibility is now used for
evaluating proteins for pigs. This approach
has the advantage of using ileal digestibility
and therefore avoiding microbial amino acid
production in the hind gut inherent in using
whole-tract digestibility, and also accounting
for basal endogenous amino acid loss. Values
are also additive, simplifying diet formulation.
13. For poultry, evaluation of protein sources is
also based on standardised ileal digestibility
of the three major amino acids: lysine, methionine and tryptophan.
14. For horses, evaluation of protein sources is
based on crude protein or digestible crude
protein.
15. In evaluating protein sources for ruminant
animals, account must be taken of:
■
■
■
■
■
■
the degradability of the protein within the
rumen;
the rate of passage of the food through
the rumen;
the efficiency of capture of degraded protein by the rumen microbes;
the yield of microbial protein;
the true digestibility of the protein reaching the small intestine;
the efficiency of utilisation of nitrogen
absorbed from the small intestine.
16. The UK metabolisable protein system divides
the requirement of an animal into that which
is required for supplying the needs of the
rumen microbes and that which is required at
tissue level. After estimating the contribution
of microbial protein to satisfying this demand, the requirement for undegraded
dietary protein is calculated.
17. The UK Feed into Milk (FiM) system uses ATP
as the unit of energy for microbial growth,
which is derived from the ruminal degradation
of dietary DM and rumen outflow rates for
liquid, concentrates and forages. Metabolisable protein supply to the tissues is calculated
as the sum of that produced from rumen available nitrogen plus digestible undegradable
protein (MPN) or rumen-available energy plus
digestible undegradable protein (MPE),
whichever is the lower value. The system also
provides an indication of the effect of diet on
rumen pH.
QUESTIONS
13.1 For a growing pig, calculate the apparent nitrogen retention when fed 1.5 kg/day
of a diet containing 29.5 g N/kg, with a daily faecal output of 5.6 g N and urinary nitrogen output of 19.5 g N.
13.2 Calculate the biological value (BV) of the following protein when consumed by
rats. Daily food consumed was 6.4 g, nitrogen content of the food was 12.62 g/kg,
total nitrogen excreted in the urine per day was 37 mg, endogenous nitrogen
338
Further reading
excreted in the urine per day was 23.0 mg, total nitrogen excreted in the faeces
per day was 21.3 mg and metabolic faecal nitrogen excreted daily was 10.4 mg.
13.3 A protein feed for ruminants has the following in sacco degradability characteristics: a ⫽ 0.32, b ⫽ 0.51, c ⫽ 0.06. Assuming a rumen outflow rate of 0.05
per hour, what is the predicted degradability? If the feed had a crude protein
content of 240 g/kg DM, how much protein (g/kg DM) would be predicted to
be released within the rumen, and what would the ERDP content be?
13.4 Using Feed into Milk (FiM), what is the predicted supply of metabolisable protein (MP) to a dairy cow fed 10 kg DM per day of grass silage, 2 kg DM per day
soya bean meal and 6 kg DM per day of molassed sugar beet pulp. The MPE
and MPN content (g/kg DM) of the grass silage is 82 and 87, the soya bean
meal 271 and 417, and the sugar beet pulp 130 and 83, respectively.
FURTHER READING
Agricultural Research Council 1980 The Nutrient Requirements of Ruminant Livestock, Farnham Royal, Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux.
Agricultural Research Council 1984 The Nutrient Requirements of Ruminant Livestock, Supplement No. 1, Farnham Royal, Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux.
Agricultural and Food Research Council 1992 Technical Committee on Responses to Nutrients, report no. 9, Nutritive Requirements of Ruminant Animals: Protein, Farnham Royal,
Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux. (See also Nutrition Abstracts and Reviews, Series B
62: 787–835.)
British Society of Animal Science 2003 Nutrient Requirement Standards for Pigs, Penicuik,
British Society of Animal Science.
Chalupa W 1991 Model generated protein degradation nutrition information. In: Proceedings
of the Cornell Nutrition Conference, Ithaca, NY, p. 44.
Cronjé P B 2000 Ruminant Physiology: Digestion, Metabolism, Growth and Reproduction.
Wallingford, CABI.
Julliand V and Martin-Rosset W 2004 Nutrition of the Performance Horse: Which System in
Europe for Evaluating the Nutritional Requirements? Wageningen, Wageningen Academic
Publishers.
National Research Council 2007 Nutrient Requirements of Horses, 6th rev. edn, Washington,
DC, National Academies Press.
National Research Council 2001 Nutrient Requirements of Dairy Cattle, 7th rev. edn,Washington,
DC, National Academies Press.
Nissen S (ed.) 1992 Modern Methods in Protein Nutrition and Metabolism, London,Academic
Press.
Sejrsen K, Hvelplund T and Nielsen M O 2006 Ruminant Physiology: Digestion, Metabolism
and Impact of Nutrition on Gene Expression, Immunology and Stress, Wageningen,
Wageningen Academic Publishers.
Thomas C 2004 Feed into Milk: A New Applied Feeding System for Dairy Cows, Nottingham,
Nottingham University Press.
Van Weerden I, van Weerden E J and Huisman J (eds) 1992 Nutritive and Digestive Physiology
in Monogastric Farm Animals,Wageningen, Pudoc.
Wiseman J and Cole D J A (eds) 1990 Feedstuff Evaluation, London, Butterworth.
339
PART 4
The nutrient requirements of animals
The animal uses the nutrients obtained from foods for a variety of purposes. This part
describes how the nutrient requirements of the animal are quantified and expressed as
feeding standards.
Chapter 14 covers the nutrient requirements for maintenance and growth and explains how
growth can be controlled by nutrient supply.
Nutrient requirements for reproduction are considered in Chapter 15, which also includes
nutritional influences on puberty, fertility and fecundity and the requirements for egg
production in poultry and growth of the foetus.
Chapter 16 describes the synthesis of milk components, followed by the requirements for
lactation in the main farm animal species.
Formulation of a ration or diet requires knowledge of the nutrient requirements of the
animal (discussed in this part) and the nutritional value of the foods (discussed in Part 3) and,
in order to combine these two, the amount of foods the animal can consume. Therefore,
Chapter 17 gives details of factors affecting food intake in both monogastrics and ruminants
and the methods used to predict food intake.
14
Feeding standards for
maintenance and growth
14.1 Nutrient requirements for maintenance
14.2 Nutrient requirements for growth
14.3 Nutrient requirements for wool production
14.4 Mineral and vitamin requirements for maintenance and growth
14.5 Nutritional control of growth
The amounts of nutrients required by animals are often described by the general term
‘feeding standards’. Two other terms used in the same context are ‘nutrient requirements’ and ‘nutrient allowances’. Neither of these terms is strictly defined. However,
a nutrient requirement is generally agreed to be the average amount required for
a particular function, whereas a nutrient allowance is greater than this by a safety
margin designed primarily to allow for variations in the requirement between individual animals.
Feeding standards may be expressed either as quantities of nutrients or in dietary
proportions. Thus, the phosphorus requirement of a 50 kg pig might be stated as 11 g P/day
or as 5 g P/kg of the diet. The former method of expression is used mainly for animals
given exact quantities of foods, and the latter for animals fed to appetite. Various units
are used for feeding standards. For example, the energy requirements of ruminants
may be stated in terms of net energy (NE), metabolisable energy (ME), digestible energy (DE) or feed units, and their protein requirements in terms of crude protein (CP),
digestible crude protein (DCP) or metabolisable protein (MP). It is desirable that the
units used in the standards should be the same as those used in feed evaluation. Standards may be provided separately for each process of the animal or as overall figures
for combined processes. For example, the requirements of cattle and sheep are often
given separately for maintenance and for milk production, but those for growing
chickens are for maintenance and growth combined. In some cases, the requirements
for single processes are not known; this is particularly true for vitamin and trace element
requirements.
As mentioned above, the translation of requirements into allowances that are used
in feeding practice often involves the addition of safety margins. The justification for
such safety margin is illustrated by the following example. Suppose that in 500 kg cattle
the NE requirement for maintenance varies between individuals from 30 MJ/day to
36 MJ/day, with a mean value of 33 MJ/day. Although some of this variation may reflect
inaccuracies in the methods of measurement used, much of it undoubtedly reflects real
343
Chapter 14 Feeding standards for maintenance and growth
differences between animals. If this is the case, then the adoption of a mean value of
33 MJ/day as the value to be used in practice would result in some of the cattle being
overfed and some being underfed. Underfeeding is generally regarded as the greater
evil, and so a safety margin is often added to the requirement when calculating the
allowance to be fed. This safety margin is designed to ensure that no animals, or only
those with an exceptionally high requirement, will be underfed. It may be an arbitrary
value or, better, one based mathematically on the variation between animals; the larger
the variation, the greater the safety margin. The use of safety margins has been criticised on the grounds that overfeeding, say, 90 per cent of the population in order to ensure that 10 per cent are not grossly underfed is wasteful. However, they are justified
for nutrients where the consequences of deficiency are serious and where the costs of
oversupply are relatively low (e.g. magnesium). However, for nutrients such as energy,
the use of safety margins is probably not justified. Oversupply of energy is likely to be
expensive, and although animals will respond to the excess, an increase in the rate of
production may not be desirable as excess energy might be stored as body fat.
Individual variations between animals, and between samples of a food, must always
be considered when applying feeding standards as such variation will inevitably lead to
inaccuracies. For this reason, feeding standards should be considered as guides to feeding practice and not as inflexible rules; they do not replace the art of the farmer in the
finer adjustment of food intake to animal performance. The application of feeding
standards is not restricted to individual animals; they can also be used at farm scale to
calculate, for example, the total winter feed requirement of a dairy herd, or used at
national level to assist in planning food imports.
Between 1960 and the mid-1980s, feeding standards in the UK were developed by
research scientists coordinated by the Agricultural Research Council, and translated into
practical manuals by nutritional advisors working for the Ministry of Agriculture and
associated governmental or commercial organisations (see Further reading). In 1983, a
single organisation comprising both research scientists and nutritional advisors, the
Technical Committee on Responses to Nutrients, became responsible for both revising
standards and producing technical manuals. More recently, feeding standards for both
pigs and dairy cows have been developed by consortia consisting of both government
bodies and commercial organisations. However, at the time of writing (2009), there is
no UK organisation with overall responsibility for feeding standards, despite the continuing need for revision of current standards to incorporate new research findings.
Feeding standards have been developed in many other countries. In the USA, the
standards used have been developed by the National Research Council; similarly, Australia
has a national committee to develop and publish standards. In Europe, the Netherlands
has a Central Feed Bureau to publish and revise standards, and Germany, France and the
Scandinavian countries have similar organisations. Some of the manuals produced by
these organisations are listed in the further reading section, and examples of their use
are included in the text. However, it is not possible to provide a comprehensive coverage
of all the standards available.
The main users of feeding standards are commercial companies that supply concentrate feeds as complete diets for pigs and poultry and as complementary feeds to forages
consumed by ruminants. Nutritional advisers and consultants also use them to formulate
diets and advise farmers. Commercial feed companies often modify published standards
in order to meet the specific needs of their customers. For example, the nutrient requirements of poultry tend to change from one generation to the next because of the speed
of genetic selection and improvement. Consequently, national feeding standards fail to
344
Nutrient requirements for maintenance
keep up with these changes. The variety of feeding standards available, the tendency
for them to be frequently revised, and the increasing use of computers in ration formulation have encouraged users to be more flexible in their selection of feeding standards.
In addition, the emphasis today is less on formulating rations to meet minimum requirements and more on predicting animal responses to changes in nutrient supply (hence
the formation of the UK Technical Committee on Responses to Nutrients).
Feeding standards have been criticised on the grounds that they may not be applicable on farms. For example, grazing animals will eat what they can harvest rather
than a prescribed ration. However, if grazing animals fail to grow because of a suspected copper deficiency, then knowledge of the copper requirement may be required
to confirm that the element is deficient. In developing countries, standards are often
difficult to apply because the foods needed to supplement local resources are not
available. In developed countries, there may be a tendency to oversupply nutrients
that are freely available and cheap (e.g. calcium). However, the need to avoid oversupply (by applying standards) has been recognised in countries where the excretion of
excess nutrients by livestock causes environmental pollution, for example pollution of
soil and water in the Netherlands by phosphorus and nitrogen compounds. In the near
future, feeding standards are likely to prescribe maximum as well as minimum levels of
nutrient supply.
14.1
NUTRIENT REQUIREMENTS FOR MAINTENANCE
An animal is in a state of maintenance when its body composition remains constant,
when it does not give rise to any product such as milk, and when it does not perform
any work on its environment.As animals are rarely kept in this non-productive state,
it might seem of academic interest to determine nutrient requirements for maintenance; however, the total requirements of many classes of animal, particularly ruminants, are calculated factorially by summation of the requirements for maintenance
and production. Consequently, knowledge of the maintenance requirements of animals is of practical as well as theoretical significance.The relative importance of energy
requirements for maintenance is illustrated in Table 14.1, which shows the relative
contribution of maintenance and production to the total energy requirement of different classes of animal.
The animals exemplified in Table 14.1 are all highly productive, but less productive animals use proportionately more of their energy intake for maintenance. It may
be calculated, for example, that, on average, cattle in Africa use about 85 per cent of
their energy intake for maintenance.
Animals deprived of food are forced to draw on their body reserves to meet their
nutrient requirements for maintenance.We have seen already that fasted animals must
catabolise body reserves to provide the energy required for essential body processes
such as respiration and circulation of blood.As the energy so utilised leaves the body
as heat, the animal is then in a state of negative energy balance.The same is also true
of other nutrients; for example, an animal fed on a protein-free diet will continue to
lose nitrogen in its faeces and urine and is therefore in negative nitrogen balance.The
purpose of a maintenance diet is to prevent this drain on body reserves, and the
maintenance requirement for a nutrient can be defined as the quantity required to
ensure that the animal experiences neither a gain nor a loss of that nutrient. The requirement for maintenance is thus the minimum quantity promoting zero balance
345
Chapter 14 Feeding standards for maintenance and growth
Table 14.1 Relative contribution of maintenance and production to the total
energy requirement of different classes of animals
Net energy requirement (MJ)
Maintenance
Daily values
600 kg dairy cow producing 30 kg
of milk
300 kg steer gaining 1 kg per day
50 kg pig gaining 0.75 kg per day
1 kg broiler chicken gaining
35 g per day
Annual values
600 kg dairy cow producing
40 kg calf and 6000 kg milk
200 kg sow producing 16 (1.5 kg)
piglets and 750 kg milk
2.0 kg hen producing 250 eggs
Production
Maintenance (%
total requirement)
42
93
31
23
7
0.50
16
10
0.32
59
41
61
15 727
18 600
46
7 100
4 600
61
190
95
67
(the qualification ‘minimum’ is necessary, because if the animal is unable to store the
nutrient in question, then increasing the quantity supplied above that required for
maintenance will still result in zero balance).
Energy requirements for maintenance
Basal and fasting metabolism
As explained earlier (see p. 261), energy expended in the maintenance of an animal
leaves the body in the form of heat.The quantity of heat arising in this way is known
as the animal’s basal metabolism, and its measurement provides a direct estimate of
the NE that the animal requires from its food in order to meet the demands of maintenance. The measurement of basal metabolism is complicated by the fact that heat
produced by the animal comes not only from this source but also from the digestion
and metabolism of food components (the heat increment of feeding) and from the
voluntary muscular activity of the animal. Heat production may also be increased
further if the animal is kept in a cold environment (see p. 350).
When basal metabolism is measured, the complicating effect of the heat increment of feeding is eliminated by depriving the animal of food. The period of fast required for the digestion and metabolism of previous meals to be completed varies
considerably between species. In man an overnight fast is considered sufficient but in
ruminants digestion, absorption and metabolism continue for several days after feeding stops, and a fast of at least 4 days is needed; the same period is recommended for
pigs, and a period of 2 days for fowl. There are a number of criteria for establishing
whether the animal has reached the post-absorptive state. If heat production can be
measured continuously, then the most satisfactory indication is the decline in heat
production to a steady, constant level.A second indication is given by the respiratory
quotient (see p. 264). During fasting, the oxidation mixture gradually changes
from absorbed carbohydrate, fat and protein to body fat and some body protein.
346
Nutrient requirements for maintenance
This replacement in the mixture of carbohydrate by fat is accompanied by a decline
in the non-protein respiratory quotient, and when the theoretical value for fat (0.7)
is reached it can be assumed that energy is being obtained only from body reserves.
In ruminants, an additional indication that the post-absorptive state has been
reached is a decline in methane production (and therefore digestive activity) to a
very low level.
The contribution of voluntary muscular activity to heat production can be reduced
to a low level when basal metabolism is measured in human subjects, but in farm
animals the cooperation needed to obtain a state of complete relaxation can rarely be
achieved. Fasting may limit activity, but even the small activity represented by standing as opposed to lying is sufficient to increase heat production. Consequently, in farm
animal studies the term ‘fasting metabolism’ is used in preference to ‘basal metabolism’,
since strict basal conditions are unlikely to be obtained.A term often used in conjunction with fasting metabolism is ‘fasting catabolism’; this includes the relatively small
quantities of energy lost by fasting animals in their urine.
Some typical values for fasting metabolism are given in Table 14.2. As one would
expect, the values are higher for larger than for smaller animals, but column 2 shows
that per unit of liveweight, fasting metabolism is still higher in small animals. At a
relatively early stage in the study of basal metabolism, it was recognised that fasting
heat production is related more closely to the surface area of animals than to their
weight, and it became customary to compare values for animals of different sizes by
expressing them in relation to surface area (column 3 of Table 14.2). The surface area
of animals is difficult to measure, and methods were therefore devised for predicting
it from body weight. The principle of such methods is that, in bodies of the same
shape and of equal density, surface area is proportional to the two-thirds power of
weight (W0.67).The logical development of this approach was to omit the calculation
of surface area and to express fasting metabolism in relation to W0.67.When the link between fasting metabolism and body weight was examined further it was found that
the closest relationship was between metabolism and W0.73, not W0.67. The function
W0.73 was used as a reference base for fasting metabolism of farm animals until 1964,
when it was decided to round off the exponent to 0.75 (see column 4 of Table 14.2).
There has been considerable discussion as to whether surface area or W0.75 (often
called metabolic liveweight) is the better base. This will not be repeated here but is
contained in the books listed in Further reading. Mathematically, there is nothing to
Table 14.2 Some typical values for the fasting metabolism of adult animals
of various species
Animal
Cow
Pig
Human
Sheep
Fowl
Rat
Liveweight (kg)
500
70
70
50
2
0.3
Fasting metabolism (MJ/day)
Per m2
Per
animal
(1)
Per kg
liveweight (W)
(2)
surface area
(3)
Per
kg W0.75
(4)
34.1
7.5
7.1
4.3
0.60
0.12
0.068
0.107
0.101
0.086
0.300
0.400
7.0
5.1
3.9
3.6
–
3.6
0.32
0.31
0.29
0.23
0.36
0.30
347
Chapter 14 Feeding standards for maintenance and growth
choose between the two bases, for their relationships with fasting metabolism are
equally close.
The fasting metabolism of adult animals ranging in size from mice to elephants
was found by S Brody to have an average value of 70 kcal/kg W0.73 per day; the approximate equivalent is 0.27 MJ/kg W0.75 per day. There are, however, considerable
variations between species, as shown in Table 14.2. For example, cattle tend to have
a fasting metabolism about 15 per cent higher than the interspecies mean, and sheep
have a fasting metabolism that is 15 per cent lower. There are also variations within
species, notably those due to age and sex. Fasting metabolism per unit of metabolic
liveweight is higher in young than in old animals, being for example 0.39 MJ/kg W0.75
per day in a young calf but only 0.32 MJ/kg W0.75 in a mature cow; it is also 15 per
cent higher in male cattle than in females or castrated males.
Energy balance and feeding trials
The quantity of energy required for maintenance is, by definition, that which promotes energy equilibrium (zero energy balance). This quantity can be estimated directly in fed, as opposed to fasted, animals if the energy content of their food is
known and their energy balance can be measured in feeding trials. In theory the
quantities of food given could be adjusted until the animals were in exact energy
equilibrium, but in practice it is easier to allow them to make small gains or losses
and then to use a model of the kind depicted in Fig. 11.5 in Chapter 11 to estimate
the energy intake required for equilibrium. For example, suppose a 300 kg steer was
given 3.3 kg/day DM of a food with M/D of 11.0 MJ/kg DM and with a kg = 0.5. If
the steer retained 2.0 MJ/day, then its ME requirement for maintenance would be
calculated as follows:
(3.3 * 11) - (2>0.5) = 32.3 MJ ME /day
A similar approach can also be followed in feeding trials in which animals are not
kept in calorimeters.The animals are given known quantities of food energy, and their
liveweights and liveweight gains or losses are measured. The partition of energy intake between that used for maintenance and that used for liveweight gain can be made
in two ways. The simpler method involves the use of known feeding standards for
liveweight gain. The alternative is to use the figures for energy intake (I), liveweight
(W) and liveweight gain (G) to solve the following equation:
I = aW0.75 + b G
The coefficients a and b then provide estimates of the quantities of food energy
used for maintenance and for each unit of liveweight gain, respectively. This form of
analysis can be extended to animals with more than one type of production, such as
dairy cows, by adding extra terms to the right-hand side of the equation.
The main objection to using feeding trials to determine energy requirements for
maintenance (and also for production) in this way is that liveweight change is a relatively poor measure of energy balance. However, it is possible to put the method on
a sounder energy basis by using the comparative slaughter technique to estimate
changes in the energy content of animals.
Fasting metabolism as a basis for estimating maintenance requirements
The feeding trial method of estimating maintenance requirements has the advantage
of being applied to animals kept under normal farm conditions, rather than under
348
Nutrient requirements for maintenance
Table 14.3 Energy costs of physical activity in a 50 kg sheep
Activity
Cost per kg
liveweight
Duration or
frequency
of activity
Cost per
day (kJ)
Standing
Changing position
Walking
Climbing
Eating
Ruminating
Fasting metabolism
0.4 kJ/h
0.26 kJ
2.6 kJ/km
28 kJ/km
2.5 kJ/h
2.0 kJ/h
9 h/day
6 times/day
5 km/day
0.2 km/day
2–8 h/day
8 h/day
180
78
650
280
250–1000
800
4300
the somewhat unnatural conditions represented by fasting animals in a calorimeter.
Consequently, it is often difficult to translate values for fasting metabolism into practical maintenance requirements. One factor to be taken into account is that animals on
the farm commonly use more energy for voluntary muscular activity.Another factor is
that productive livestock must operate with a higher metabolic rate than fasted animals
and thereby incur a higher maintenance cost. Third, animals on the farm experience
greater extremes of climate and may need to use energy specifically to maintain their
normal body temperature. The first two factors are discussed below, and the effects of
climate on energy requirements for maintenance are discussed on p. 350.
Estimates of the energy costs of various forms of voluntary muscular activity are
shown in Table 14.3. In the first column the costs are given per unit of liveweight.The
second column gives estimates of the number of units of activity likely to be undertaken, and the third column gives estimated daily costs for a 50 kg sheep. For example, if the sheep walks 5.0 km per day (line 3) and the unit cost is 2.6 kJ per
kilogram liveweight per kilometre, then a 50 kg sheep will incur a cost of 2.6 * 5.0 *
50 = 650 kJ per day. Table 14.3 includes a value for fasting metabolism, and it can be
calculated that the NE required by the sheep for maintenance will be increased by
(650/4300) * 100 = 15.0 per cent if it walks 5.0 km per day.
Some of the activities listed in Table 14.3 are likely to be carried out by all animals (standing, getting up and lying down, plus a minimal amount of locomotion).
Consequently, their energy cost is always added to the fasting metabolism when calculating maintenance requirements. For example, in the AFRC (1993) system (see Further reading), the activity allowance for a housed lactating ewe is 9.6 kJ per kilogram
liveweight per day. For a 50 kg sheep this amounts to 480 kJ per day, or about 11 per
cent of the fasting metabolism.
The energy costs of eating (prehension, chewing and swallowing) and of rumination are included in the heat increment of feeding (i.e. they are taken into account in
the estimation of efficiency constants, k). However, if animals are grazing, rather
than having foods delivered to them, their energy requirements for muscular activity
will be much increased. Table 14.3 shows that if a 50 kg sheep has to walk 5 km and
climb 0.2 km a day in search of food, and has to extend its eating time from 2 hours
to 8 hours a day, its energy cost will be increased by 650 + 280 + 750 = 1680 kJ per
day, which is equivalent to nearly 40 per cent of its fasting metabolism. In general,
grazing animals are likely to have maintenance requirements that are 25–50 per cent
greater than those of housed animals. However, the actual increase will depend upon
349
Chapter 14 Feeding standards for maintenance and growth
the terrain and vegetation type. The efficiency with which ME is used to meet the
costs of muscular activity (kw) is generally assumed to be the same as km.
Although fasting metabolism is measured under standardised conditions, evidence suggests that the value obtained for a particular animal depends on that animal’s previous energy status. If an animal on a high plane of nutrition is suddenly
fasted, then its metabolic rate will be higher than that of a similar animal that has
previously been kept on a lower plane. In one comparison made with 35 kg lambs,
those previously fed on a high plane had a fasting metabolism 20 per cent higher
than those previously fed on a moderate plane. The same effect is demonstrated
when one attempts to provide animals with just enough food to keep their weight
constant (i.e. to keep them at maintenance).As time passes, the ration has to be progressively reduced to maintain the required equilibrium. The inference is that animals can adapt to low-level (maintenance) rations either by improving their efficiency
of energy utilisation or, more likely, by reducing non-essential muscular activity.This
means that if an animal’s fasting metabolism is determined after a period on a low
plane of nutrition, as is commonly the case, then the value obtained, even when
increased to allow for additional muscular activity, may well underestimate its maintenance requirement when offered a high plane of nutrition. This source of error is
recognised in the Australian energy system for ruminants (see p. 290), maintenance
requirements being increased as levels of energy intake rise.
The fasting metabolism of an animal when expressed per unit of metabolic weight
may vary depending on the animal’s body composition. Metabolically active tissues
such as the internal organs and musculature require more energy for maintenance
than less metabolically active tissues. Consequently, a fat animal is likely to have a
lower fasting metabolism than a thin animal of the same weight.
Influence of climate on energy metabolism and requirements
for maintenance
The influence of climate on the nutrition of farm animals is not confined to energy
requirements for maintenance but extends to other aspects of energy metabolism
and also to nutrients other than energy. Nevertheless, climate has the greatest influence on energy requirements, and in cold climates animals kept at or below the
maintenance level are most affected.
Both mammals and birds are homeotherms, which means that they attempt to
keep their body temperature constant. Animals produce heat continuously and, if
they are to maintain a constant body temperature, must lose heat to their surroundings. The two main routes of heat loss are the so-called sensible losses by radiation,
conduction and convection from their body surface, and evaporative losses of water
from the body surface and lungs (2.52 MJ/kg water). The rate at which heat is lost is
dependent in the first instance on the difference in temperature between the animal
and its surroundings; for farm animals, the rectal temperature, which is slightly lower
than the deep body temperature, lies in the range 36–43 °C. The rate of heat loss is
also influenced by animal characteristics, such as insulation provided by the tissues and
coat, and by environmental characteristics, such as air velocity, relative humidity and
solar radiation. In effect, the rate of heat loss is determined by a complex interaction
of factors contributed by both the animal and its environment.
Figure 14.1 illustrates the physics and physiology of heat loss from animals. In
this example, the solid line represents the heat production of a fasted pig, resting at
a ‘comfortable’ temperature of 22°C. Its heat production (and loss) is 5 MJ/day, and
350
Nutrient requirements for maintenance
10
Heat production (MJ/day)
Fed pig
Se
H
ea
t
Fa pr
st od
ed u
pi ctio
g n
ns
ib
le
lo
ss
5
Lower
critical
temperature
Upper
critical
temperaure
Thermoneutral
zone
Evaporative loss
5
15
10
20
25
Temperature of environment (oC)
30
35
Fig. 14.1 The effect of environmental temperature on the heat production of a pig.
this is divided almost equally between sensible and evaporative losses. If the air temperature is gradually reduced, the pig will begin to lose heat more rapidly. It can
reduce this effect to a certain extent by reducing its evaporative losses and perhaps
reducing blood flow (and heat transfer) to the body surface. The latter response will
reduce the skin temperature and presumably make the animal feel cold.As the fall in
air temperature continues, a stage is reached where the pig can maintain its deep
body temperature only by increasing its heat production, which it might do by increasing muscular activity, i.e. by shivering. The environmental temperature below
which heat production is increased is known as the lower critical temperature and in
this example is 20 °C.
If the pig were fed rather than fasted, then its heat production would be increased
by the heat increment of feeding and its lower critical temperature would be reduced
(see Fig. 14.1, broken line). In this example, the pig would not have to increase its
heat production until the environmental temperature dropped to 7 °C.
If this pig were subjected to an increasing temperature, it would have difficulty in
losing heat by sensible losses and would need to increase its evaporative loss. Eventually, a temperature would be reached at which the pig would need to reduce its
heat production, which it might do by restricting its muscular activity and also by reducing its food intake. The temperature above which animals must reduce their heat
production is known as the upper critical temperature.The range between the lower
and upper critical temperatures is known as the thermoneutral zone.
We can now move from this simple situation of the pig exposed to only one climatic
variable, temperature, to other animals and other climates.The lower critical temperatures of animals kept in different environments are presented in Table 14.4. Ruminants have a wider thermoneutral zone and a lower critical temperature compared
351
Chapter 14 Feeding standards for maintenance and growth
Table 14.4 Some examples of the lower critical temperatures (°C) of farm animals
in different environments
Animal Type
State
Production level
Wind speed (km/h)
0
15
Sheep
Lamb
Adult
Newborn
Shorn
50 mm wool
Cattle
Calf
Beef
–
Fasted
Fasted
Maintenance
Ad libitum
Ad libitum
–
Maintenance
Gaining 0.8 kg/day
Maintenance
30 litres milk/day
28
31
22
7
-10
-40
18
-16
-32
-8
-30
Cow
100 mm wool
Newborn
Store
Growing (30 mm coat)
Dairy (20 mm coat)
Straw
Pig
Sow
Adult 160 kg
Growing Individual
Group
Maintenance
High
High
22
14
7
34
35
28
18
5
–
28
-3
-10
10
-20
Floor
Concrete
–
19
13
with non-ruminants because ruminants have a greater capacity to regulate evaporative heat losses and their heat increment of feeding is higher (i.e. lower efficiency
constants, k) than that of non-ruminants. In addition, ruminants tend to produce
heat at a constant rate throughout the day, whereas non-ruminants tend to digest and
metabolise their food quickly and then experience cold when the heat increment has
declined. Smaller animals tend to be more susceptible to cold because they are often
less well insulated. However, this is often balanced by having a higher basal metabolic
rate per unit of body weight. Nevertheless, the lower critical temperature of an adult
sheep (50 kg) is higher than that of a cow (500 kg) kept in a similar environment
(Table 14.4).
An animal’s insulation depends on its subcutaneous fat (pig) and coat depth (sheep
fleece, cattle hair, poultry feathers). Thus, a sheep that has been shorn is particularly
vulnerable to cold, even in summer, and especially if its food intake is restricted. By
disturbing the coat or fleece, wind reduces insulation and, as shown in Table 14.4, increases the critical temperature. Rain increases heat loss both by reducing insulation
and through the heat of vaporisation. In an adult sheep with a 50 mm coat, 30 mm of
rain per day can raise the critical temperature by 2–6 °C. In housed animals, insulation depends on the floor type and group size. Pigs kept on straw have a lower critical temperature than that of pigs kept on concrete. Similarly, pigs kept in groups can
huddle together to reduce their surface area and lower their critical temperature.
The farm animals that are most likely to suffer from cold stress are newborn
lambs, calves and pigs. They are small and tend to have poor insulation because of
low levels of subcutaneous fat or a thin coat of hair or wool. In addition, they are wet
when born. If the newborn animal also fails to obtain sufficient milk from its mother,
then its heat increment of feeding may be low. Newborn animals have a special type
352
Nutrient requirements for maintenance
of tissue known as brown adipose tissue for generating heat soon after birth, which
is deposited at strategic points such as the shoulder and abdomen. Fat droplets are
stored in metabolically active cells that have a good blood supply. When the fat is
metabolised, the oxidation is uncoupled, with energy being released as heat rather
than being captured as ATP. The heat so generated is then carried to other parts of
the animal’s body by the blood. Reserves of brown adipose tissue are relatively small
and its protective role is limited. Consequently, it is very important that young animals receive food in the form of colostrum and milk as soon as possible after birth.
A comparison of an animal’s lower critical temperature with the environmental
temperature tells us whether the animal requires an additional source of energy to
increase its heat production. However, it does not tell us how much energy should be
supplied. The various strategies for alleviating cold stress are (1) to make the environment warmer (e.g. improving the insulation of buildings or reducing draughts),
(2) to allow the animal to increase its heat production from existing resources (e.g.
by metabolising fat reserves) and (3) to increase the animal’s heat production by
manipulating its diet. The last would seem to be the preferable nutritional strategy.
In housed animals, the increase in heat loss for every 1 °C fall in temperature
below the lower critical temperature is reasonably constant. A value of 18 kJ per kg
W0.75 per day has been quoted for adult pigs. Thus, if a sow weighing 160 kg (45 kg
W0.75) were kept on a maintenance diet (19.4 MJ ME per day) at a temperature 5 °C
below its lower critical temperature (22°C), its daily heat loss would be potentially
45 * 5 * 18 = 4050 kJ (4.05 MJ) greater than its heat production. This represents
about 20 per cent of its maintenance requirement.When ME is used to meet a deficit
in heat production, the efficiency of ME utilisation is 100 per cent (i.e. k = 1). Consequently, the sow would require an additional 4.05 MJ ME/day to ensure energy
equilibrium. An alternative strategy would be to increase the sow’s ME intake to a
level at which the additional heat increment would meet the heat deficit. For example, if kg was 0.7, the sow would need 13.5 MJ ME/day above its maintenance
requirement, which would yield 4.05 MJ as heat and 9.45 MJ as retained energy.
Laying hens are normally fed to appetite and are therefore able to adjust their
food and energy intake to regulate body temperature.As the environmental temperature falls below 25 °C, their ME intake increases by 22 kJ for each 1 °C fall. For a
1.8 kg bird, this is equivalent to 14 kJ per kg W0.75 (cf. 18 kJ for sows). The extra
energy consumed appears to be used solely to generate heat and has little effect on
egg production. Calculations of this kind can be used by the farmer to determine
whether it is more economical to provide extra heat or insulation for poultry buildings or extra food for the birds.
For housed ruminants, the increases in heat loss associated with a 1 °C fall in environmental temperature are comparable (10–20 kJ per kg W0.75 per day) to those for
pigs and poultry, but are much greater (20–40 kJ) for ruminants kept out of doors and
exposed to wind and rain. In ruminants it is often possible to influence heat production
by changing the quality of the diet. Metabolisable energy derived from low-quality
forage-based diets is used with a lower efficiency (k) than that derived from high-quality
concentrate-based diets, and thus more heat is liberated to keep the animal warm.
In hot climates, the animal’s problem is one of disposing of the excess heat it produces. We have seen already in Fig. 14.1 that as air temperature increases, sensible
heat losses (radiation, conduction and convection) reduce and more heat is lost by
evaporation. Domestic species vary considerably in their ability to lose heat by the
evaporation of water. Most mammals are poorly equipped with sweat glands and
353
Chapter 14 Feeding standards for maintenance and growth
birds have none. However, cattle, particularly tropical cattle (Bos indicus), are able to
lose appreciable quantities of water and heat by sweating. Evaporation of water from
the skin can be increased through surface water acquired by wallowing. However,
the major route by which water vapour is lost is via the respiratory tract. The farmer
can assist the animal to lose heat by providing shade, ventilation and possibly water
sprays. However, if these and the animal’s own heat loss mechanisms become overtaxed, the animal has to reduce its heat production, which it does by reducing its
food and energy intake. This means that potentially high-producing animals, such as
dairy cows, are seriously handicapped in the tropics by their inability to maintain
high levels of energy intake. Ruminant animals are generally poorly equipped for hot
climates because of their reliance on low-quality forage-based diets with a low efficiency of ME utilisation and a high heat increment of feeding.
Feeding standards for maintenance (energy)
Ruminants
Energy requirements for maintenance can be calculated from various feeding standards. Although it is not possible to include all the standards, requirements calculated using some of the most widely known standards are presented here.The energy
requirements for maintenance of cattle published by AFRC (1993) are based on fasting metabolism (F, MJ/day) and can be predicted as follows:
F = 0.53(W>1.08)0.67
Fasting weight is predicted from liveweight (W ) by dividing by 1.08, and metabolic weight is calculated using the power 0.67 rather than the more usual 0.75. The
fasting metabolism of bulls is considered to be 15 per cent higher than that of steers
and heifers of a similar weight, and an activity allowance (A, MJ/day) of 0.0071 W
and 0.0095 W is included for growing cattle and dairy cattle, respectively. Thus, the
NE requirement for maintenance (NEm) of a 600 kg dairy cow would be calculated
as follows:
NEm = 0.53(600>1.08)0.67 + (0.0095 * 600)
= 42.3 MJ/day
If the ME content of the cow’s diet was 11.0 MJ/kg DM, the efficiency of ME utilisation for maintenance (km) would be 0.714 (see Table 12.1 in Chapter 12) and the
ME requirement for maintenance (MEm) would be calculated as follows:
MEm = 42.3>0.714
= 59.2 MJ/day
As stated previously, if an animal on a high plane of nutrition is suddenly fasted,
then its fasting metabolism will be higher than that of a similar animal previously kept
on a lower plane of nutrition. As the estimates of fasting metabolism adopted by
AFRC (1993) were derived from beef and dairy steers fed at maintenance before
fasting, they may underestimate the fasting metabolism of dairy cows fed at higher
levels of production. Evidence suggests that the fasting metabolism of modern dairy
cows of high genetic merit, and on a high plane of nutrition, may be substantially
greater than that previously suggested, and a value of 0.453 MJ/kg W 0.75 has been
adopted by FiM (2004), which, based on their modelling approach (see Fig. 12.1),
354
Nutrient requirements for maintenance
gives a fixed MEm of 0.647 MJ/kg W0.75. The higher maintenance requirement of
animals at high levels of production probably reflects the higher mass of metabolically active organs such as the gut and liver.
As with cattle, the maintenance requirements of sheep published by AFRC (1993)
are based on fasting metabolism and an activity allowance that varies between
0.0067 W for housed fattening lambs and 0.024 W for ewes on hill grazing.The NEm
requirement of a 50 kg hill ewe can be predicted as follows:
NEm = 0.23(W>1.08)0.75 + 0.024 W
= 5.3 MJ/day
In contrast to AFRC (1993), where maintenance requirements are derived from
calorimetric methods, the maintenance requirements of beef cattle published by
NRC (2000) are derived using the comparative slaughter technique. This has the advantage of allowing experiments to be conducted under conditions more similar to
those encountered in practice, and the effects of activity are implicitly incorporated.
The NEm requirement of beef cattle can be predicted from empty body weight (EBW)
as follows:
NEm = 0.322 EBW0.75
where EBW = W * 0.85.
Maintenance requirements are then adjusted for the effects of breed and sex, with
the requirements of Bos indicus breeds being reduced by 10 per cent and the requirement of dairy breeds being increased by 20 per cent.The adjustment for effects
of sex is similar to that made by AFRC (1993). Further refinements are also included
for the effects of climatic factors and previous nutritional status. The NEm requirements of dairy cattle published by NRC (2001) are derived from calorimetric studies
and are predicted as follows:
NEm = 0.335 W0.75
It is interesting to note that the NEm requirements of beef cattle derived using
comparative slaughter techniques and adjusted by 20 per cent for dairy breeds are
similar to those of dairy cows derived using calorimetric methods. The NEm requirement of sheep predicted by NRC (2007) of 0.23 W0.75 is similar to that adopted by
AFRC (1993).
One of the most comprehensive approaches used to predict the energy requirements for maintenance of ruminants is provided by CSIRO (2007), which has
adopted two generalised equations for the prediction of MEm as follows:
Ration formulation:
MEm = KSM(0.28 W 0.75 exp(-0.03A))>km + 0.1 MEp + MEgraze + Ecold
Prediction of performance:
MEm = KSM(0.26 W 0.75 exp(-0.03A))>km + 0.09 MEI + MEgraze + Ecold
where:
K = 1 for sheep and goats, 1.2 for B. indicus and 1.4 for B. taurus cattle;
S = 1 for females and castrates and 1.15 for males;
M = 1 + (0.23 * proportion of DE from milk);
A = age in years (maximum 6);
355
Chapter 14 Feeding standards for maintenance and growth
km = efficiency of ME utilisation for maintenance;
MEp = ME used directly for production;
MEI = total ME intake;
MEgraze = additional energy expenditure of grazing;
MEcold = additional energy expenditure when the temperature is below the lower
critical temperature.
The inclusion of MEp (or MEI) in the prediction of MEm recognises the fact that
fasting metabolism is known to vary directly with level of feeding.As a consequence,
maintenance requirements predicted by CSIRO (2007) are 5–10 per cent higher
than those predicted by AFRC (1993).
Pigs and poultry
The energy requirements of pigs and poultry are normally stated for both maintenance
and production combined, although some theoretical standard maintenance requirements have been calculated.The UK Technical Committee on Responses to Nutrients
predicts the maintenance requirements of sows (ME, MJ/day) to be 0.44 W 0.75
(17.9 MJ for a 140 kg sow), with the requirement of boars being 15 per cent higher.
Using the BSAS (2003) NE system, the fasting metabolism of pigs (F, MJ/day) is predicted as 0.750 W 0.60 and an activity allowance of 0.1 and 0.05 times maintenance
is included for lactating sows or growing pigs, and boars, respectively. The activity of
pregnant sows is assumed to be negligible. For laying hens, the maintenance requirement (ME MJ/day) is predicted to be 0.55 W 0.75.
Horses
The minimum maintenance requirements of horses (DE, MJ/day) predicted by NRC
(2007) is 0.126 W, which is applicable to sedentary or docile horses. This value is
increased by 10 per cent (0.139 W ) for alert horses with moderate levels of activity
and by 20 per cent (0.152 W ) for young active horses. Thus, a 500 kg horse with
moderate activity would require 69.5 MJ DE per day. Using the French NE system,
the maintenance requirement of horses (NE, MJ/day) would be estimated to be
0.351 W 0.75, which for a 500 kg horse gives 37.1 MJ/day. When this is converted
to DE and a 10 per cent activity allowance is included, this equates to 68.1 MJ/day,
which is similar to that predicted by NRC (2007).
In addition to the energy required for maintenance, equine athletes also require
additional energy for work (exercise). The amount of energy required for work depends on a variety of factors, such as level of training, type of exercise, rider weight
and experience, and climate and ground conditions. Consequently, it is classified by
NRC (2007) into four categories – light, moderate, heavy and very heavy work – and
calculated as 20, 40, 60 and 90 per cent of the maintenance requirement, respectively.
Examples of the sort of activity associated with each level of work are presented in
Table 14.5.
Protein requirements for maintenance
If an animal is fed on a nitrogen-free but otherwise adequate diet, it will continue to
lose nitrogen in its faeces and urine. The nitrogen in faeces, as described earlier (see
Chapter 10), consisting of enzymes and sloughed cells arising from the digestive tract,
and from microbial residues, is referred to as metabolic faecal nitrogen (or protein).
If the animal continues to eat, then it will continue to lose nitrogen in its faeces.
356
Nutrient requirements for maintenance
Table 14.5 Examples of the weekly workload of horses in the light, moderate,
heavy and very heavy exercise categories
Exercise
category
Mean
heart rate
(beats/min)
Description (hours/week)
Types of events
Recreational riding
Beginning training
Show horses (occasional)
Recreational riding
School horses
Show horses (frequent)
Ranch work
Polo
Low/medium-level eventing
Race training (middle stages)
Racing (speed or endurance)
Elite three-day eventing
Light
80
1–3 (40% walk, 50% trot,
10% canter)
Moderate
90
3–5 (30% walk, 55% trot,
10% canter, 5% low
jumping)
4–5 (20% walk, 50% trot,
15% canter, 15% gallop
and jumping)
Heavy
Very heavy
110
110–150
Various, ranging from
1 hour per week of speed
work to 6–12 hours of
slow work
Adapted from National Research Council 2007, Nutrient Requirements of Horses, Washington, DC,
National Research Council.
It is less obvious, perhaps, why an animal on a nitrogen-free diet should continue
to lose nitrogen in its urine. In part, this excretion represents nitrogen that has been
incorporated into materials that are subsequently expended and that cannot be recovered for reuse within the body. For example, the creatine of muscles is eventually
converted into creatinine, which is excreted in the urine. However, by far the greater
part of the nitrogen in the urine of animals fed on a nitrogen-free diet is in the form
of urea (in mammals), the typical by-product of amino acid catabolism, which arises
from the turnover of body protein, as described in Chapter 11. The rate of protein
turnover varies considerably from one tissue to another, with some proteins, such as
those in the liver and intestines, being replaced in hours or days, and others, such as
those in bone and nerve tissue, being replaced in months or years. The amino acids
released when body proteins are broken down form a pool from which replacement
proteins can be synthesised.An amino acid may therefore be present in the liver one
day and in muscle protein the next. In effect, body proteins exchange amino acids
among themselves. However, like protein synthesis from absorbed amino acids, this
recycling is not completely efficient. Amino acids derived from one protein may not
be required in the next. Consequently, they are catabolised and the nitrogen converted to urea, which is subsequently excreted in urine.
When an animal is initially placed on a nitrogen-free diet, the quantity of nitrogen
in its urine falls progressively for several days before stabilising at a lower level.
When nitrogen is reintroduced, there is a similar lag in the re-establishment of equilibrium. This suggests that animals possess a protein reserve that can be utilised in
times of scarcity and restored in times of plenty.The tissues most readily depleted in
times of scarcity are those that are metabolically the most active and where the proteins are most labile, such as the liver. Depletion of liver nitrogen is associated with
357
Chapter 14 Feeding standards for maintenance and growth
some reduction in enzyme activity, and the reserve protein is therefore considered to
be a ‘working reserve’, which consists of the cytoplasmic proteins themselves.
Once the reserve protein has been depleted, urinary nitrogen excretion reaches a
minimal and approximately constant level. However, this level will be maintained
only if energy intake is adequate. If tissue protein is catabolised specifically to provide energy, then urinary nitrogen excretion will increase again.The amount of nitrogen excreted at this minimal level is known as the endogenous urinary nitrogen and
represents the smallest loss of body nitrogen commensurate with the continued existence of the animal. Endogenous urinary nitrogen can therefore be used to estimate
the nitrogen (or protein) requirement for maintenance. It is analogous to basal metabolism, and in fact there is a relationship between the two. The proportionality
commonly quoted is 2 mg endogenous urinary nitrogen per kcal basal metabolism
(about 500 mg/MJ). For adult ruminants, however, the ratio is somewhat lower, at
300–400 mg endogenous urinary nitrogen per MJ fasting metabolism.The reason for
this is that ruminants on low-protein diets are capable of recycling urea back to the
rumen or large intestine. As a consequence, nitrogen that would be excreted in the
urine of non-ruminants is subsequently excreted in the form of microbial residues.
The total or basal endogenous nitrogen is calculated as the sum of endogenous urinary nitrogen plus metabolic faecal nitrogen. For ruminants, basal endogenous nitrogen is approximately 350 mg N/kg W 0.75 and is equivalent to 1000–1500 mg/MJ
fasting metabolism, which is two or three times higher than that in non-ruminants.
When nitrogen is reintroduced into the diet, the quantity of nitrogen excreted in
the urine increases because of the inefficiency of utilisation of amino acids derived
from the diet. Urinary nitrogen excreted in excess of the endogenous component is
known as exogenous urinary nitrogen.This name implies that such nitrogen is derived
from food and not from body origin. However, with the exception of the creatinine
fraction of the endogenous portion, it is doubtful whether such a strict division is
justified. It is better to regard the so-called exogenous fraction as the extension of an
existing nitrogen loss rather than an additional loss because it reflects mainly an increase in protein turnover and the inefficiency of amino acid utilisation.
The quantity of nitrogen (or protein) required for maintenance is that which will
balance the endogenous urinary and metabolic faecal losses of nitrogen (and also the
small dermal losses in hair, scurf and sweat). The two most common methods used to
measure these losses are analogous to those employed to measure energy requirements for maintenance. The first, analogous to the determination of fasting catabolism, involves measuring the animal’s nitrogen losses when it is fed on a nitrogen-free
diet, and calculating the quantity of food nitrogen required to balance these losses.
The second, analogous to the measurement of maintenance requirements using feeding trials (see p. 348), involves measuring the nitrogen intake required to produce
nitrogen equilibrium.
Feeding standards for maintenance (protein)
Ruminants
The starting point for the factorial calculation of the protein requirements of ruminants adopted by AFRC (1993) is basal endogenous nitrogen (BEN) excretion, which
can be predicted as follows:
BEN (g N/day) = 0.35 W 0.75
358
Nutrient requirements for maintenance
For a 600 kg cow the BEN loss would be 42.4 g/day. In cattle, dermal losses in hair
and scurf are predicted to be 0.018 W 0.75, which gives an additional loss of 2.2 g/day,
and a total loss of 44.6 g/day (or 279 g protein). In the UK metabolisable protein
system described in Chapter 13, absorbed amino acids are assumed to be utilised for
maintenance with an efficiency of 1.0. Consequently, the metabolisable protein
requirement for maintenance (MPm) of a 600 kg cow would be 279 g/day. The approach adopted by AFRC (1993) has been criticised on the basis that estimates of
BEN were derived from studies conducted with animals nourished by intragastric
infusion and therefore lacking a fully functional rumen. In addition, it does not differentiate between endogenous urinary nitrogen and metabolic faecal nitrogen, which
is now known to vary directly with level of feeding.
Perhaps the greatest area of uncertainty in the estimation of protein requirements
for maintenance is associated with the prediction of metabolic faecal nitrogen and the
extent to which endogenous nitrogen secreted into the gut contributes to metabolic
faecal nitrogen output. The approach described by NRC (2001) and adopted by FiM
(2004) for dairy cows recognises that metabolic faecal protein (MFP) varies directly
with level of feeding and that much of the endogenous nitrogen entering the digestive tract is reabsorbed, either directly or after degradation and incorporation into
microbial protein. Endogenous urinary protein (EUP, g/day) and dermal losses in
hair and scurf (g/day) are predicted as 4.1W 0.50 and 0.3W 0.60, respectively, whereas
MFP (g/day) is predicted from dry matter intake (DMI, kg/d) as 30 * DMI. This
approach recognises that some of the microbial protein synthesised in the rumen is
indigestible in the small intestine but may be degraded and absorbed in the large
intestine, and it assumes that 50 per cent of the indigestible microbial protein reaching the hind gut is excreted in the faeces. Finally, a correction for endogenous protein
is included, which again recognises that the excretion of enzymes and sloughed cells
varies directly with level of feeding. Therefore, MPm is predicted as follows:
MPm = 4.1 W 0.50 + 0.3 W 0.60 + 30 DMI - 0.5((DMTP>0.8) - DMTP)
+ 2.34 DMI
where DMI = dry matter intake (kg/day) and DMTP = digestible microbial true
protein (g/d).
The protein requirements for maintenance adopted by CSIRO (2007) are based
on ARC (1980), but they specify separate estimates for EUP and MFP and recognise
that MFP varies directly with level of feeding. For B. taurus breeds of cattle, EUP is
predicted as follows:
EUP (g/day) = 16.1 ln W - 42.2
For B. indicus breeds, the predicted quantity is reduced by 20 per cent. For sheep,
EUP is predicted as follows:
EUP (g/day) = 0.147 W + 3.375
For both cattle and sheep, MFP is predicted as 15.2 g/kg DMI, and dermal losses
(g/day) are predicted as AFRC (1993) as 0.11W 0.75(0.018W 0.75 * 6.25).
As indicated above, most of the protein systems for ruminants (see Chapter 13)
used around the world base their estimates of protein requirements for maintenance
on endogenous losses of nitrogen but use different factors to translate endogenous
losses into dietary requirements. For example, using the UK metabolisable protein
359
Chapter 14 Feeding standards for maintenance and growth
system, the MPm of a 600 kg cow can be calculated to be 279 g/day (as above). This
protein is likely to be derived from microbial protein (MCP). When an allowance is
made for the proportion of true protein in MCP (0.75) and for the digestibility of
this true protein (0.85), the requirement for MCP is:
MCP for maintenance (g/day) = 279>(0.75 * 0.85)
= 438 g
The quantity of MCP produced in the rumen depends on the quantity of organic
matter fermented and hence on the quantity of fermentable metabolisable energy
(FME). For cattle fed at a maintenance level, the relationship is quantified as approximately 9 g MCP per MJ FME. Consequently, if the FME intake of the cow is 53 MJ/day
(approximates to its energy requirement for maintenance), the quantity of MCP supplied would be 53 * 9 = 477 g/day.As can be seen, MCP alone (i.e. without any contribution from digestible undegradable protein, DUP) should be sufficient to meet
the animal’s requirement for maintenance. In fact, for ruminants, it is often the
case that a diet that satisfies the energy requirement for maintenance of the animal
and the protein or nitrogen requirement of the rumen microorganisms will also satisfy the animal’s protein requirement for maintenance.
The final step in the calculation might be to estimate the minimum level of protein
required in the cow’s diet. As microbial protein supply, and hence the protein requirement of the rumen microorganisms, is greater than the animal’s requirement, the
diet must supply sufficient effective rumen-degradable protein (ERDP) for the rumen
microorganisms.Thus, ideally the diet should provide protein with a high degradability. If the diet had an FME content of 8 MJ/kg DM, then the quantity required would
be 53兾8 = 6.6 kg/day and the ERDP content required would be 477兾6.6 = 73 g/kg
DM. This is similar to low- or medium-quality grass silage. At the low rumen outflow
rate expected at maintenance levels of feeding (0.02), protein degradability of silage
would be about 0.7, so the minimum protein content of the silage would need to be
73兾0.7 = 104 g/kg DM. This diet would also supply about 15 g/kg DM of DUP,
although the animal would not require this for maintenance.
Pigs and poultry
As with energy, the protein requirements of pigs and poultry are usually stated for
maintenance and production together. However, it is possible to calculate the requirements of these animals for maintenance alone from endogenous losses. For example,
BSAS (2003) predicts that the protein requirement for maintenance of pigs can be met
by supplying 0.9 g of standardised ileal digestible protein (see Chapter 13) per kgW 0.75
per day. The recommended lysine requirement of pigs for maintenance is calculated
as 5.4 per cent of the standardised ileal digestible protein requirement.
Horses
For horses, protein requirements are stated in terms of crude protein (CP), and the
maintenance requirements published by NRC (2007) have been estimated by regressing nitrogen intake against nitrogen retention to give an average nitrogen requirement for maintenance of 0.202 g N/kg/day, which is equivalent to a CP requirement
of 1.26 g/kg/day. However, based on variation in maintenance requirements between
horses and the assumption that more active horses have more lean tissue to support,
three levels for maintenance are provided, similar to those described for energy.
360
Nutrient requirements for growth
Thus, the minimum CP requirements for maintenance of sedentary and more active
horses are predicted as 1.08 and 1.44 g/kg/day, respectively.
In addition to protein required for maintenance, horses that are undertaking work
(exercise) require additional protein for muscle gain (MG) and sweat loss (SL). The
CP required for MG depends on the level of exercise intensity, and NRC (2007) estimates the requirement to be 0.089, 0.177, 0.266 and 0.354 g/kgW for horses undertaking light, moderate, heavy and very heavy exercise, respectively (see Table 14.5).
Sweat loss also increases with exercise intensity and has been estimated to be 0.25,
0.50, 1.00 and 2.00 per cent of body weight for horses in each exercise category. On
average, the CP content of sweat is 7.8 g/kg. If the efficiency of protein utilisation is
assumed to be 50 per cent and the digestibility of dietary protein is assumed to be
79 per cent, then the additional protein requirement for exercise can be predicted as
follows:
CP exercise (g/day) = (MG * W ) + [(SL * 7.8 * W )>0.633]
The recommended lysine requirement of horses for maintenance and exercise is
calculated as 4.3 per cent of the CP requirement.
NUTRIENT REQUIREMENTS FOR GROWTH
As animals grow they increase in both size and weight.All animals start their lives as a
single cell weighing almost nothing, and then grow to reach mature weights that range
from 2 kg for a laying hen to over 1000 kg or more for a bull. The pattern by which
animals grow from conception to maturity can be represented by a sigmoid (s-shaped)
curve, as presented in Fig. 14.2. During the foetal period and from birth to puberty,
the rate of growth increases; after puberty, it progressively decreases as the animal
reaches maturity. In practice, a number of factors such as the animal’s environment
and nutrition may cause its growth to deviate from this sigmoid curve. Periods of
500
400
Liveweight (kg)
14.2
300
200
Conception
100
Puberty
0
0
1
2
3
Age (years)
4
5
6
Fig. 14.2 The typical sigmoid growth curve of a dairy cow.
361
Chapter 14 Feeding standards for maintenance and growth
food scarcity (cold or dry seasons) may retard growth or even cause the animal to lose
weight, after which periods of food abundance will allow the animal to grow more
rapidly. In general, animals kept under conditions of so-called ‘intensive’ husbandry
will follow the growth curve illustrated in Fig. 14.2, whereas those kept under natural
(extensive) conditions will follow more interrupted curves, with their overall growth
rate being more variable than the idealised pattern.
As animals grow, not only do they increase in size and weight but also they show
what is termed development. By this we mean that the various parts of the animal,
defined as anatomical components (e.g. legs), organs (e.g. liver) and tissues (e.g. muscle) grow at different rates, so that as the animal grows its proportions change. For
example, in cattle, the birth weight of a calf is approximately 40 kg and the head,
which is relatively large, accounts for 6.2 per cent of its body weight. However, by
the time the calf reaches 100 kg, the head accounts for only 4.5 per cent of its body
weight and this proportion continues to decline until the animal reaches maturity. In
the 1940s, John Hammond, at Cambridge University, described the development of
animals as a series of ‘growth waves’. For example, in relation to the major tissues,
during early life (including prenatal life) nerve and bone tissues are given priority for
nutrients and grow rapidly, later muscle has priority, and finally adipose tissue grows
the most rapidly.When animals grow fast, these waves of growth overlap each other,
such that a fast-growing animal will begin to deposit substantial amounts of fat
whilst muscle growth is still in progress.
Animal growth and animal nutrition are inherently linked, in the sense that one
can influence the other. The growth pattern of an animal determines its nutrient requirements. Conversely, by altering its nutrition, an animal’s growth pattern can be
modified. Another aspect of this interaction is that the growth pattern of an animal
determines the composition of the product of growth (i.e. meat), and so affects the
consumer of meat, man.
When feeding animals for meat production, farmers are often aiming to produce
carcasses with a particular specification in terms of weight and composition. However, animals used for other purposes, such as reproduction, milk or egg production,
may need to follow growth patterns that differ from those of meat animals.The main
objective of this section of the chapter is to show how nutrient requirements for
growth are determined and how they may vary, depending on the nature of the animal and the purpose for which it is kept. A secondary objective is to show how animal growth and development may be modified by control of nutrition. Although
growth starts from conception, that which occurs in utero (or in the avian egg) forms
a specialised subject that is covered in Chapter 15. This section is concerned solely
with postnatal growth.
The chemical composition of gain
Although growth and development can be measured in terms of body parts, organs
and tissues, nutritionists are primarily interested in growth of the chemical components that make up an animal’s body, because this determines their nutrient requirements. Protein, water and ash (together with essential lipids such as phospholipids and
carbohydrates such as glycogen), are combined in relatively constant proportions to
form the lean body mass of an animal referred to earlier (see p. 270). In addition, the
animal contains a variable proportion of storage lipid. Both protein and lipid contribute
to the energy content of the body. In addition to these integral components, the body
362
Nutrient requirements for growth
8000
160
140
7000
Protein or fat (kg)
120
6000
100
5000
80
4000
Protein
60
3000
40
2000
20
1000
0
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
500
Energy (MJ)
Fat
Energy
550
Empty body weight (kg)
Fig. 14.3 Growth of protein, fat and energy in cattle.
Plotted from the data of the Agricultural Research Council 1980 The Nutrient Requirements of Ruminant
Livestock, Farnham Royal, Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux.
also contains the extraneous and variable gut and bladder contents.The growth of all
these components can be investigated by slaughtering and analysing animals at successive stages of growth. Figure 14.3 presents the results of a large data set showing
the body composition of cattle, with the weight of each body component being plotted against empty body weight, which is liveweight minus gut and bladder contents.
Figure 14.3 shows that as the empty body weight of an animal increases, the
weights of all the chemical components that make up the body increase, but at differing rates. Fat is deposited at an increasing rate and the lean body components
(exemplified in Fig. 14.3 by protein) are deposited at decreasing rates. The energy
content of the body increases in a similar way to the fat content. The relationship
between the weight of each component and empty body weight appears to be curvilinear. However, when all the weights are expressed as their logarithms, the relationships can be described by straight lines.
The equations for the logarithmic relationships are of the form:
log y = log b + a log x
where y = weight of the component and x = empty body weight. The algebraic form
of this equation is:
y = bxa
Such equations are known as allometric equations and were first introduced by J S
Huxley in 1932.The coefficient a is known as the growth coefficient and is a measure of
the rate of growth of a part relative to the rate of growth of the whole animal. If it has a
value greater than unity, then the part is growing faster than the whole, and its contribution to the whole is increasing.The part in question is thus described as a late-maturing
part. Conversely, if the growth coefficient is less than unity, then the part’s contribution
to the whole is decreasing and the part can be described as early-maturing.
363
Chapter 14 Feeding standards for maintenance and growth
Table 14.6 Composition of the empty body weight (EBW) gain
made by cattle of a medium-sized breed
Empty body
weight (kg)
50
100
150
200
300
400
500
Protein
(g/kg)
Fat
(g/kg)
181
167
160
155
148
144
140
86
148
204
256
353
442
527
Energy
(MJ/kg)
7.65
9.76
11.80
13.72
17.36
20.77
24.01
Log10 protein ⫽ 0.8893 ⫻ log10 EBW - 0.5037
Log10 fat ⫽ 1.788 ⫻ log10 EBW ⫺ 2.657
Energy ⫽ 23.6 ⫻ protein ⫹ 39.3 ⫻ Fat
Adapted from Agricultural Research Council 1980 The Nutrient Requirements
of Farm Livestock, Farnham Royal, Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux.
Differentiation of the allometric equations allows the composition of empty body
weight gain to be determined for any particular body weight or range in body
weights.Table 14.6 illustrates this procedure when applied to the data used to derive
Fig. 14.3. The table shows that as the animal grows, the composition of its empty
body weight gain changes in accordance with Hammond’s growth waves. In early
life, the gain consists mainly of the water, protein and minerals (ash) required for
growth of bone and muscle; later, the gain contains a higher proportion of fat and as
a result its energy content increases.
Allometric equations can be used to study growth in other ways. For example, the
range of chemical components could be widened to include individual amino acids
or mineral elements, with the analysis being used to define the requirements for
these nutrients. They can also be applied to particular organs or tissues.
Although the principal factor influencing the composition of gain made by growing animals, and hence their nutrient requirements for growth, is their body weight,
there are other factors that affect the composition of gain.Animal species is an obvious factor. At a specific weight, small species (low mature weight) will be at a more
advanced stage of growth and maturity than large species. For example, at a liveweight
of 60 kg the composition of gain made by sheep contains approximately 500 g/kg fat,
whereas that of cattle contains only 75 g/kg.The composition of gain made by several
species is presented in Table 14.7.
If at a given empty body weight the composition of gain differs between small
and large species, then it seems logical that within a species, the composition of
gain will differ between small and large breeds. Table 14.8 illustrates this effect in
cattle. It seems that the real determinant of the composition of gain is not absolute
body weight but rather body weight relative to the mature weight of the animal.
This theory is supported by looking at the effects of sex on the composition of gain
(also presented in Table 14.8). Females are generally smaller than males at maturity.
Consequently, at a specific weight their gain contains more fat and energy than that
of males. Castrates tend to be intermediate between males and females.
364
Nutrient requirements for growth
Table 14.7 Percentage composition and energy content of the gain made by
animals of various ages and liveweight
Animal
Liveweight
(kg)
Age
Fowl (White Leghorn
pullets, slow
growth)
Sheep (Shropshire
ewes)
0.23
0.7
1.4
9
34
59
Pig (Duroc-Jersey
23
females)
45
114
Cow (Holstein heifers) 70
230
450
Composition of gain (g/kg)
4.4 weeks
11.5 weeks
22.4 weeks
1.2 months
6.5 months
19.9 months
–
–
–
1.3 months
10.6 months
32.4 months
Water
Protein
Fat
Energy
Ash (MJ/kg)
695
619
565
579
480
251
390
380
340
671
594
552
222
233
144
153
163
158
127
124
110
190
165
209
56
86
251
248
324
528
460
470
520
84
189
187
39
37
22
22
31
63
29
28
24
–
–
–
6.2
10.0
12.8
13.9
16.5
20.8
21.0
21.4
23.3
7.8
11.4
12.3
Adapted from Mitchell H H 1962 Comparative Nutrition of Man and Domestic Animals, Vol. 1, New York
and London, Academic Press.
Table 14.8 Differences between breeds and sexes in the body composition of
cattle of 300 kg empty body weight
Component
Protein (g/kg)
Fat (g/kg)
Breed
Aberdeen-Angus
Holstein
Aberdeen-Angus
Holstein
Sex
Male
Castrate
Female
172
186
190
136
161
187
227
172
150
167
314
213
Calculated from the data of Ayala H J 1974. PhD thesis, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY, USA.
A final factor influencing the composition of gain is the growth rate of the animal.
From the growth wave theory it seems logical that immature animals with limited
nutrients available for growth, and therefore growing slowly, will use them for bone
and muscle growth, whereas animals with more nutrients available will also store fat.
Thus, the fat content (g/kg) of the gain of a pig growing at 0.9 kg/day is likely to be
greater than that of a pig growing at 0.3 kg/day. This is commonly the case, although
the effect is small in very immature animals and in genotypes selected for restricted
fat deposition.
Feeding standards for growth (energy)
Ruminants
The UK Agricultural Research Council (ARC 1980) analysed data on the body composition of a large number of cattle and sheep of different sexes slaughtered at various
weights and ages. Some of the results of these analyses for cattle are presented in
365
Chapter 14 Feeding standards for maintenance and growth
Figs. 14.3 and 14.5. Based on these data, AFRC (1993) predicts that for cattle the
energy content of the gain made by castrate males of a medium-sized breed can be
predicted as follows:
EVg = (4.1 + 0.0332 W - 0.000009 W 2)>(1 - 0.1475 LWG)
where EVg = energy value of liveweight gain (MJ/kg),W = liveweight (kg) and LWG
= liveweight gain (kg/day).
The first bracketed term in the equation describes the increasing energy content
of gain as cattle increase in size, and the second term describes the correction for the
increasing energy content of gain associated with higher liveweight gains. Thus, the
energy value of the gain (EVg) in a 100 kg animal gaining at 0.5 kg/day is predicted
to be 7.9 MJ/kg, whereas the EVg in a 500 kg animal gaining at the same rate would
be 19.9 MJ/kg. The corresponding values for animals gaining at 1.0 kg/day are predicted to be 8.6 MJ/kg and 21.6 MJ/kg, respectively.
To account for the effects of breed and sex on EVg, a simple 15 per cent correction factor has been adopted.Thus, for small breeds (early-maturing) and females the
value predicted is increased by 15 per cent, and for large breeds (late-maturing) and
males (bulls) the value is reduced by 15 per cent.Thus, a 500 kg female of a small breed
growing at 0.5 kg/day would be predicted to gain 19.9 * 1.15 * 1.15 = 26.3 MJ/kg.
For sheep, the data analysed by ARC (1980) showed a large effect of sex on EVg,
but only a small effect of breed (Merinos having more fat and hence a higher EVg
than other breeds), and no significant effect of rate of gain. Based on these data,
AFRC (1993) predicts that for sheep EVg can be predicted as follows:
Males: EVg = 2.5 + 0.35W
Castrates: EVg = 4.4 + 0.32W
Females: EVg = 2.1 + 0.45W
The predicted EVg of male, castrate and female lambs of 30 kg liveweight would be
13.0 MJ/kg, 14.0 MJ/kg and 15.6 MJ/kg, respectively.
In Australia, CSIRO (2007) has adopted an ingenious approach that allows the EVg
of both cattle and sheep, of almost any breed and of any rate of gain, to be predicted
using a simple set of equations. The basis of the approach adopted by CSIRO (2007)
is to allocate a ‘standard reference weight’ (SRW) to each class of animal, which is
defined as ‘the liveweight that would be achieved by that animal when skeletal development is complete and the condition score is in the middle of the range (i.e. condition score 3 for beef and sheep)’. Thus, the SRW varies between breeds and sexes
and is higher for large (late-maturing) breeds than for small (early-maturing) breeds.
Similarly, the SRW for bulls is higher than that of castrates and females. For example,
male, castrate and female Friesian cattle are allocated SRW of 770 kg, 660 kg and
550 kg, respectively. The main variables for the prediction of EVg are the liveweight
of the animal relative to its SRW and its rate of gain (R), as follows:
NEg = (a + cR) + (b - cR)>[1 + exp(-6 (Z - 0.4))]
where Z = current W兾SRW, R = adjustment for rate of gain or loss = (L - 2), where L
is level feeding (MEI兾MEm), and a, b and c = coefficients used in the equation (a =
6.7, b = 20.3 and c = 1.0).
Using this equation, the NEg of a 30 kg castrated Suffolk lamb (SRW 66 kg) fed at a
level of twice maintenance would be 19.2 MJ/kg, which is higher than that predicted
by AFRC (1993). Although this approach has proved suitable for all breeds of sheep
366
Nutrient requirements for growth
and most breeds of cattle, it has had to be modified for large European breeds, such
as the Charolais and Simmental. These breeds are capable of making gains that are
unusually low in fat and hence energy content. In the USA, the NRC (2000) has also
adopted the concept of a standard reference weight to calculate the energy requirements for gain in cattle.
Pigs
In the UK, the energy requirements for growth of pigs are published by BSAS (2003)
and expressed in terms of NE. Three pig types are defined, which differ in their
growth characteristics, in particular the rate of protein deposition: exceptionally lean
and fast-growing (maximum rate of protein retention 0.230 kg/day), intermediate
(maximum rate of protein retention 0.170 kg/day) and commercial (maximum rate
of protein retention 0.120 kg/day). The effects of sex are not specifically accounted
for, but males are considered to be lean and fast-growing and castrates are considered to be commercial types. The growth of each pig type is modelled and NE
requirements for both maintenance and growth are presented for pigs in different
weight categories. The fixed factors in the model are the NE requirements for maintenance plus activity (0.750 W 0.75 * 1.10), as discussed previously, and the energy
content of protein and fat (23.6 MJ/kg and 39.3 MJ/kg, respectively).The model predicts the rate of protein deposition (Pr) and lipid mass (Lt) from the protein mass
(Pt) of each pig type as follows:
Pr (kg/day) = B * Pt * ln(Ptmax>Pt)
Lt (kg) = 0.5 * Ptb
where Ptmax = the asymptote for protein mass (50, 40 and 30 kg for lean, intermediate and commercial types, respectively), Pt = the present protein mass (kg), B = the
growth rate parameter (0.0125, 0.0117 and 0.0110 for lean, intermediate and commercial types, respectively), and b = allometric exponent (1.10, 1.20 and 1.30 for
lean, intermediate and commercial types, respectively).
Once the protein and lipid mass are known, the liveweight of the animal can be
calculated from its body composition as the sum of its water, ash, protein and lipid
content, assuming that lean tissue contains approximately 238 g/kg protein and that
gut fill constitutes 60 g/kg liveweight, as follows:
Liveweight (kg) = (3.62 Pt0.938 + 0.265 Pt0.928 + Pt + Lt) * 1.06
By modelling pig growth, the rates of protein and lipid retention at different
liveweights can be predicted and NE requirements calculated. For example, for a 65 kg
intermediate-type pig, the model predicts that the rate of protein and lipid retention
would be approximately 0.172 kg/day and 0.170 kg/day, respectively, and the NE
requirement would be calculated for maintenance and growth as follows:
NE = [(0.750 W 0.60 ) * 1.10] + (23.6 * 0.172) + (39.3 * 0.170)
= 20.8 MJ/day
The model can also be used to predict animal performance. For example, if the
NE intake of the pig was restricted to 20.0 MJ/day and the predicted rate of protein
retention is 0.172 kg/day, the rate of lipid retention can be predicted as follows:
NE intake = 20.0 MJ/day
NE for maintenance and activity [(0.750W 0.60) * 1.10] = 10.1
367
Chapter 14 Feeding standards for maintenance and growth
NE for production (20.0 - 10.1) = 9.9
NE for protein deposition (23.6 * 0.172) = 4.1
NE for fat deposition (9.9 - 4.1) = 5.8
Fat deposited (5.8兾39.3) = 0.147 kg/day
The energy requirements of growing pigs may also be expressed in terms of ME
by assuming that the ME requirement for maintenance (MJ/day) is 0.44 W 0.75 and
that the efficiency of ME utilisation for protein and lipid retention is 0.44 and 0.74,
respectively. Similarly, requirements can be expressed in terms of DE by assuming
that ME can be predicted as 0.96 * DE. For the example of the 65 kg intermediatetype pig given above, the ME and DE requirement would be 29.4 MJ/day and
30.6 MJ/day, respectively.
In pigs, the fastest growth is achieved by allowing animals to eat to appetite, and
most commercial pig types can eat to appetite from birth to slaughter without laying
down excessive fat. Food intake is the link between nutrient requirements and the
concentration of nutrients in animal diets, and knowledge of food intake is essential
for the practical application of feeding standards. Typically the food intake of pigs
consuming a diet with a NE content of 9.4 MJ/kg (DE 13.2 MJ/kg) would rise gradually from 1.01 kg/day at 20 kg to 1.96 kg/day at 50 kg and 2.62 kg/day at 90 kg.
Where the food intake is different from published guidelines, then appropriate
adjustments should be made to the nutrient concentration in the diet to ensure that
the nutrient requirements of the pig are satisfied.
Poultry
With the exception of birds reared for breeding (see Chapter 15), growing poultry
are normally fed to appetite, and nutrient requirements are therefore expressed not
as quantities required per day but as the nutrient concentrations in the diet (see
Appendix 2, Table A2.10).
As explained in Chapter 17, the quantities of food eaten by poultry are inversely
related to the concentration of energy in their diets. This means that if the energy concentration of a diet is increased without a corresponding change in the concentration of,
for example, protein, then the birds will begin to eat less of the diet. Consequently,
although their energy intake may remain approximately the same, their protein intake
will fall and the birds may be deficient in protein. In general, a nutrient concentration
that is adequate for a diet of low energy content may be inadequate for a diet of higher
energy content. It follows that feeding standards expressed as nutrient concentrations
are satisfactory only when applied to a diet with a specific energy concentration. The
standards presented in Appendix 2,Table A2.10 for chicks up to 6 weeks of age are appropriate to diets containing 11.5 MJ ME/kg and would need to be adjusted for diets
containing more or less energy. Some adjustments are discussed later in this chapter.
Horses
The energy requirements of growing horses (DE, MJ/kg gain) published by NRC
(2007) are derived from published studies in which the energy intake and growth rate
of horses were recorded. The DE requirement for gain was estimated by subtracting
the DE requirement for maintenance from the DE intake and dividing by the daily
gain. Using these data the DE requirement for gain (MJ/kg gain) can be predicted
from the age of the animal in months (x) as:
DE (MJ/kg gain) = 8.33 + 5.06x - 0.088 x2
368
Nutrient requirements for growth
Note that the likely effects of breed, sex and rate of gain on the energy requirements for gain are not taken into account by this equation. For a horse of 12 months
of age, this equation predicts that the energy requirement for gain would be 56.4 MJ/kg.
Using the French NE system, the energy requirement for growth is estimated using
an allometric equation, which varies with age and rate of gain.
Feeding standards for growth (protein)
Ruminants
In the UK, the protein requirements of growing animals are estimated using the factorial approach described earlier (see p. 358), with the protein requirement for growth
being added to the protein requirements for maintenance to give the total protein
requirement. In cattle, the net protein requirement for growth (NPg, g/day) is predicted from the animal’s liveweight and its rate of gain (LWG, kg/day) as follows:
NPg = LWG * (168.07 - 0.16869 W + 0.0001633 W2)
* (1.12 - 0.1223 LWG)
The predicted value is increased by 10 per cent for bulls and large breeds and
reduced by 10 per cent for heifers and small breeds. Thus, the NPg of a 300 kg bull
of a large breed gaining at 1.2 kg/day would be calculated as 128 * 1.10 * 1.10 *
1.20 = 186 g/day. In sheep, NPg is also calculated from liveweight but, as with energy,
no account is taken of rate of gain, as follows:
Males and castrates: MPg = LWG * (160.4 - 1.22 W + 0.0105 W2)
Females: MPg = LWG * (156.1 - 1.94 W + 0.0173 W2 )
The approach adopted by CSIRO (2007) to calculate the protein requirement for
gain is similar to that described for energy (see p. 355), with the NPg being calculated from the liveweight of the animal relative to its standard reference weight
(SRW) and its rate of gain as:
NPg = (a - cR) - (b - cR)>[1 + exp(-6(Z - 0.4))]
where Z =W兾SRW, R = adjustment for rate of gain or loss = (L - 2), where L = level
of feeding (MEI兾MEm), and a, b and c = coefficients used in equation (a = 5.0,
b = 3.3 and c = 0.1).
Using this equation, the NPg of a 300 kg bull of a large breed (SRW 770 kg) fed
at twice maintenance would be approximately 142 g/kg, which is slightly lower than
the 154 g/kg predicted by AFRC (1993). In the USA, NRC (2000) adopts a similar
approach to that used by CSIRO (2007).
As stated previously, most protein systems for ruminants use different factors to
translate NP requirements into MP and dietary protein requirements. Using the UK
metabolisable protein system, the efficiency of MP utilisation for gain in both cattle
and sheep is assumed to be 0.59. Thus, using the example given above, the MP
requirement for gain would be 186兾0.59 = 315 g/day.When this is added to the MP
requirement for maintenance (166 g/day), the total MP requirement would be 481
g/day. If the fermentable metabolisable energy (FME) intake is 64 MJ/day, the microbial protein yield would be 64 * 10 = 640 g/day, which would supply 640 * 0.75 *
0.85 = 408 g of the animal’s MP requirement. The MP deficit, 481 - 408 = 73 g/day,
would need to be supplied from digestible undegradable protein (DUP). Thus, the
369
Chapter 14 Feeding standards for maintenance and growth
diet would need to supply 640 g/day of effective rumen-degradable protein (ERDP)
and 73 g/day of DUP. If the bull’s dry matter intake was 6.2 kg/day, the dietary concentrations required would be 103 g/kg and 11.8 g/kg DM, respectively.
In the previous example of the calculation of protein requirements, the requirement was calculated for maintenance only and could be satisfied by microbial protein
supplied from the rumen. However, in young, rapidly growing animals, the protein
requirement is relatively high compared with the energy requirement. Consequently,
protein synthesis in the rumen is not always sufficient to satisfy the animal’s requirements, and there is a need for undegradable dietary protein (UDP). To keep the correct balance between rumen-degradable and -undegradable p