Connecting Outputs in Series to Achieve High Voltage Transients

Connecting Outputs in Series to Achieve High Voltage Transients
Chroma Systems Solutions, Inc.
Hipot Testing of Motors and
Safety Standard Compliance
19020, 19032, 19032-P, 19035, 19052, 19053, 19054, 19055, 19056, 19057,
19057-20, 19071, 19073, 19572
Safety Hazards, Electrical Shock, Fire, Hipot Tester, Maximum Current
Detection, Minimum Current Detection, Arc Current Detection,
Insulation Resistance Test, Ground Bond, Sequence Testing, Safety
Application Note
Product Family:
Hipot Testing of Motors and
Safety Standard Compliance
19020, 19032, 19032-P, 19035, 19052, 19053, 19054, 19055, 19056, 19057,
19057-20, 19071, 19073, 19572
Compliance with user safety standards is of paramount importance not just to manufacturers of motors
and motor subsystems, but to system designers as well.
User safety has long been a primary concern for companies that manufacture electrical, motor-driven,
and transformer-type products. In addition, consumer advocates, industry spokesmen, the general
public, and safety organizations such as Underwriters Laboratories (UL) continually monitor safety
issues to recommend and implement changes to policy. It is important for anyone designing motors or
motor subsystems into their products to understand the international safety imperatives created by the
safety organizations. Since UL standards are the most widely used, this article uses them as examples.
Electrical shock and fire are the primary safety hazards addressed by manufacturers. Electrical shock
potential arises when a current path is created between the exposed parts of a motor or motor-driven
device and the user. Compromised insulating materials and impeded ground paths are two common
causes. A fire can start when an electrical short or overload condition produces sparking, overheating,
and ultimately combustion. Minimize these hazards by conducting the rigorous tests outlined in the
many safety standards.
Hipot (Dielectric Withstand) Testing
All safety standards consider hipot testing of motors absolutely essential. A hipot tester (also known as
dielectric withstand tester) imposes a voltage on parts of a motor that are higher than those normally
encountered in service. With the motor or other device stressed in this manner, breakdowns or faults
can be detected and analyzed. If the device under test (DUT) can withstand potentials higher than
normal, hazards at nominal potentials would appear unlikely. Hipot tests include leakage current tests
that sense and analyze current (leakage) that flows through the DUT with potential applied. The tester
is configured to trip at a high current limit, low current limit, arc current limit, or a combination of the
three. An excerpt from UL Safety Standard 1004 "Electric Motors" provides an example.
"An auxiliary switch shall withstand for 1 minute without breakdown the application of a 60 Hertz
essentially sinusoidal potential between live parts and dead metal parts. The test potential shall be
based on either the rating assigned to the switch or the rating of the motor in which it is provided,
whichever is higher, and shall be:"
© Chroma Systems Solutions, Inc.
Page 2 of 9
Application Note
a) For a rating of 1/2 horsepower or less, 250 volts or less, 1000 volts: and
b) For any other rating, 1000 volts plus twice the rated voltage.1
What’s That Mean?
This UL excerpt means that in order for the product to be in compliance, it must adhere to the voltage
potentials specified. This is typical of all safety standards since repeatability (and thus the quality) of
each test must be assured.
Safety standards also specify that a DUT be tested for specific periods of time. Most hipot testers
provide a means for programming test times. On some models, ramp time is also programmable. This
gives the manufacturer the ability to bring the imposed potential to the desired level at a controlled
rate, avoiding product damage and safety hazards. However, it is important that the ramp-to-test
feature not interfere with the full impact of the hipot test. The manufacturer should utilize this feature
carefully, programming a ramp time that will not dilute the efficacy of the test.
Maximum Current Detection
Hipot testers impose a voltage on a DUT, sense current, and simultaneously compare the measured
current with the user-programmable limits. In the case of maximum current detection (Figure 1), the
user programs an absolute high limit at which point the tester shuts down, alerting the user audibly,
visually, or at a remote point via communication over a bus. Safety standards typically specify
compliance limits, so it is then a simple matter to transfer the specified limits of the standard to the
programmable limit module of the tester.
© Chroma Systems Solutions, Inc.
Page 3 of 9
Application Note
Maximum Current Limit
Measured Current
Figure 1 Maximum Current Detection
Minimum Current Detection
Although not specified in safety standards, minimum current detection capability found on instruments
such as the Chroma Sentry and Guardian models, increases productivity by eliminating measurement
time and effort. Minimum current detection identifies improperly connected or faulty cabling or
fixturing at the start of the test.
A negligible amount of current safely flows through the DUT and associated cables and fixtures when
they are in good working order and connected to a hipot tester. Hipot testers that have minimum
current detection capability recognize the difference between this safe nominal current and a problem
condition. They will alert the user if the cables or DUT are not correctly connected, or if the cables or
fixture are faulty.
Programming minimum current detection is very similar to programming maximum current. The user
specifies a minimum current limit that if not reached after testing begins, shuts down the tester and
alerts the user (Figure 2). This saves time, increases productivity, and is invaluable to those who know
(or will find out the hard way) that bad parts can pass some tests with no actual connection to the part.
© Chroma Systems Solutions, Inc.
Page 4 of 9
Application Note
Measured Current
Minimum Current Threshold
Figure 2 Minimum Current Detection
Arc Current Detection
Although arc detection is not currently directly addressed in safety standards, it is being considered for
inclusion in the future because it can further minimize hazard potential. A current arc is an electrical
impulse that bridges a gap separating two conductive areas. A good example is current that bridges the
electrodes of an automobile spark plug when an adequate potential is applied.
Arc detection is conducted using one of two methods. The first consists of a fixed time period (typically
microseconds) during which current is sensed and compared with the programmed limit (Figure 3). The
second method employs a fixed current limit and a user-programmable time period. Arc detection is an
"anticipatory" tool, meaning that the tester can determine at what level an electrical signal will be at
some point in the future. It is based on the trend or change in current during each specified time period.
This tool can rapidly remove the potential from a DUT if it is not connected correctly, which minimizes
damage and safety hazards.
© Chroma Systems Solutions, Inc.
Page 5 of 9
Application Note
During the 10uS window, if the
measured current varies from the
initial current by "x", where "x" is
the user programmed current
limit, the hipot tester indicated a
FAIL condition.
delta I
delta I
Initial Current
that occur for
indicate arcing
Figure 3 Arc Detection
Insulation Resistance Tests
Insulation resistance tests are commonly performed to satisfy specific motor safety requirements as
they relate to electrical insulation and insulating systems, and bushing and winding tests. Insulation
resistance tests consist of high-resistance measurements at relatively high potentials, accompanied by
pass/fail detection. The resistance range for an insulation test typically ranges from 1MΩ to the PΩ and
TΩ regions. Voltage potentials vary from 100V to 1000V DC. The instruments can be programmed to
provide simple pass/fail annunciation. An excerpt from the UL 1004 Safety Standard for Electric Motors:
© Chroma Systems Solutions, Inc.
Page 6 of 9
Application Note
"Material used to support live parts shall be acceptable with respect to resistance to flame propagation,
resistance to arc tracking, resistance to ignition from electrical sources, resistance to moisture
absorption, dielectric strength, and mechanical strength"2
Although an insulation resistance test will not satisfy all requirements listed in the above directive, it
will satisfy many of them. Keep in mind that to gain compliance with a safety standard, other electrical
and mechanical instruments, in addition to hipot testers, are required.
Ground Bond
Ground bond tests are arguably the most important tests found in safety standards. They ensure that
accessible parts of a device that can become energized can safely conduct the energy to ground and
safely away from the user. This is the reason that products are checked for continuity during final
testing. No manufacturer would want a customer to find the ground continuity deficiencies of its
product. The safety standard excerpts below are good examples of ground continuity requirements.
From UL 1004 Safety Standard, "Electric Motors" Fifth Edition, pg.27, section 21A:
"For a motor provided with an attached grounding-type power-supply cord, electrical continuity shall be
provided between all exposed dead-metal parts and the point of connection of the grounding conductor
of the power-supply cord of a motor. “
From UL 982 "Motor Operated Household Food Preparing Machines" Fourth Edition, pg. 30, section
"If a grounding means is provided on an appliance, whether required or not, all exposed dead metal
parts and all dead metal parts which are exposed to contact during any servicing operation and which
are likely to become energized shall be connected to the grounding means. Servicing, here mentioned
means ‘user servicing’, not repairs made by a qualified service person. The following are considered to
constitute means for grounding:"
a. In an appliance intended to be permanently connected by a metal-enclosed wiring system
b. In an appliance intended to be permanently connected by a non-metal-enclosed wiring system.
c. In a cord-connected appliance
The safety standards are straightforward with regard to continuity, and usually no more than a tenth of
an ohm is permitted to impede a signal to ground. The basic continuity test is a low-resistance
measurement, but since high current potentials are required to simulate real-world conditions, a simple
milliohmmeter cannot accurately perform the test.
© Chroma Systems Solutions, Inc.
Page 7 of 9
Application Note
More Ground Bond
To differentiate between ground bond and ground continuity, look at the current used in the test. Both
tests verify that all conductive parts of a product that are exposed to user contact are connected to
power line ground. The ground bond test verifies the integrity of that ground connection with a high
current (20-30A) AC signal. This bond test is a better simulation of how the product will perform under
an actual fault condition.
For ground bond tests, a test instrument is set up to impose and direct an electrical current from
exposed metal to the ground plane. The tester imposes the current and simultaneously monitors the
resistance between these two points. The typical current and resistance ranges required for ground
bond testers are 1A to 30A and 1mΩ to 0.5Ω, respectively. Of course, a resistance present in the path
of the test signal indicates a problem and should be corrected before product is shipped to the end
The Value of Sequence Testing
During safety compliance testing, it is often useful to run a series of tests automatically in sequence
(e.g. insulation resistance test, hipot test, and insulation resistance test). In this example, the first
insulation resistance test provides a base-line resistance measurement. The hipot test then stresses the
DUT, and the final insulation resistance test determines the effect of the hipot test on the insulation
resistance of the DUT. If the results of the second insulation test match the first, the integrity of the
insulation has not been compromised. If the insulation resistance of the second test is much lower than
the first, the DUT's insulation resistance has been diminished.
Sequence testing is an invaluable tool for detecting latent product failures. Such failures are somewhat
common and offer some evidence of their existence. However, unless the proper test equipment and
methods are employed, these latent defects will be discovered by the customer and not during the
manufacturer's final test. It's easy to see why an instrument that offers sequence testing is attractive in
detecting failures before the customer is exposed to them.
Latent defects in a motor, for example, which will not likely result in an actual breakdown until the
customer receives the unit, can only be uncovered by performing a sequence of tests. A hipot test,
which is the best indicator of future motor failure, is first performed. Next, an insulation resistance test
is conducted, which is the most common way to determine existing defects (including those that can be
caused by the hipot test itself). Many hipot testers (mostly of the digital variety such as the Chroma
line) can conduct sequence testing and test parameter storage. This provides not only the ability to
program and run a sequence of tests, but to store the tests in groups for later recall as well.
The standards governing the design of products using electric motors and motor subsystems clearly
define the electrical requirements that must be met. The standards are usually not difficult to satisfy,
but must be well understood in order to do so. Attention to the detail of the standards, along with strict
© Chroma Systems Solutions, Inc.
Page 8 of 9
Application Note
quality control, will ensure that the consumer is not the one who ultimately determines the safety of
the product.
A Guide to the Safety Organizations
Underwriters Laboratories, Inc., founded in 1894, examines and tests devices, systems, and materials to
determine their relation to hazards to life and property. They define and publish standards and
specifications affecting such hazards.
The major international safety organizations make their standards available to anyone, most at a cost.
To locate national and international testing laboratories and safety organizations check the world-wideweb for the latest information. A few are listed below:
Underwriters Laboratories, Inc. (UL)
333 Pfingsten Road
Northbrook, Illinois 60062-2096
(708) 272-8800
American National Standards Institute (ANSI)
1 West 42nd street
New York, New York 10036
(212) 642-4900
International Standards Association (ISO)
1 Rue de Varembe, Case postale 56 CH-1211
Geneve 20 Switzerland
+ 41 22 749 01 11
Occupational Health & Safety Act (OSHA)
JFK Federal Building, Room E340
Boston, Massachusetts 02203
(617) 565-9860
© Chroma Systems Solutions, Inc.
Page 9 of 9
Was this manual useful for you? yes no
Thank you for your participation!

* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project

Download PDF