Quantec 2496 Yardstick - design :: production :: audio

Quantec 2496 Yardstick - design :: production :: audio
Quantec 2496 Yardstick
http://www.soundonsound.com/sos/jul11/articles/qu...
Home | Tablet Mag | Podcasts | WIN Prizes | Subscribe | Advertise | About SOS | Help
Sun 27 Mar 2016
Search SOS
Have an account?
Log in
or Register for free
Sound On Sound : Est. 1985
Search
In this article:
Overview
Control Layout
The Algorithm Method
In Use
Verdict
Alternatives
News
Articles
Forum
Video
Subscribe
Shop
Readers' Adverts
Information
WebExtras
Quantec 2496 Yardstick
Room Simulator
Reviews : Effects
Buy PDF
Published in SOS July 2011
Printer-friendly version
Quantec 2496 Yardstick
$5695
Can a 30‑year old algorithm in a tiny blue box really be at the cutting edge of room simulation?
The answer to that question would appear to be "yes”.
pros
Hugh Robjohns
Produces wonderfully
realistic room acoustics in all
sizes and types.
Very natural depth and
space to the sound.
Comprehensive parameters
allow precise matching with
real recorded acoustics.
Fast user interface and
web‑browser GUI option.
Once you've heard it, you'll
want it!
cons
The 2496 is expensive, but
comparable to the
competition.
The 2492 and 2493 base
models lack the fast‑access
buttons around the
OLED display.
Only the 2498 flagship can
handle true surround source
material.
The Quantec Room Simulator (QRS) became something of an
instant legend when it was first introduced in 1982 at the
European AES Convention, held that year in Montreux. This
early digital reverberation unit, housed in a 2U, rackmount case,
with chunky buttons and bright LED numeric displays littering the
front panel, was competing with the likes of the (now) equally
legendary AMS RMX16, Klark Technik DN780, Eventide
SP2016, Ursa Major Space Station, Yamaha Rev 5 and 7 and, of
course, the Lexicon 224.
The QRS was a very expensive and cutting‑edge product in its day, and vintage units change hands for extraordinary prices
today. However, the latest incarnation of the QRS algorithm resides in the '249x Yardstick' — a fourth‑generation product that
is intended to provide a relatively affordable but modern version of the QRS sound. It uses essentially the same algorithms
and produces the same revered room simulation that has, arguably, never been surpassed, but it runs on a modern DSP
platform with optional web browser‑based remote‑control and management facilities.
It should be noted that the QRS approach to reverberation is fundamentally different from that of most reverberation
algorithms. Instead of modelling a room using ray‑tracing concepts (as the TC Electronic products do, for example), or
creating entirely synthetic and modulated effects (as the Lexicon reverbs do), the Quantec approach is based more on an
analysis of the way the air inside a room carries sound. It's really much more about room resonances than reflections, and the
summary
This small box has a very big result is that the QRS generates the very believable character of real rooms, rather than a fabricated sound that we perceive
sound, and creates natural
as a pleasing but synthetic reverb. It's a subtly different approach, but one that a great many top engineers and producers
room acoustics rather than
value highly — particularly in the classical music and broadcast environments (film and TV dubbing and radio dramas,
'just' reverb! The Quantec
especially).
Yardstick is full of
extraordinarily realistic
rooms, all of which seem to
embrace the sound source
rather than smother it. It has
the magical property of
gelling separate sound
sources together within
a believable space, rather
than simply placing
reverberation around them.
information
2492 $4250; 2493
$5275; 2496 $5695; 2498
$9900.
Studio Logic Sound +1
610 346 8037.
info@studiologicsound.com
www.studiologicsound.com
www.quantec.com
However, sound quality isn't the only factor that influences purchases, and it must be said that Quantec, based in Munich,
Germany, have apparently had quite a difficult time in bringing the product to a worldwide market and supporting it adequately
over the past few years. A cursory search on the Internet quickly reveals a lot of dissatisfaction from early adopters, and I fear
that creates something of an unfair impression of a superb product from a very small, independent company.
Quantec have had no local representation in the UK in recent years, and consequently the product is not well known at all, but
with the combined efforts of Gary Ash at Sable Marketing and Chris Collins at Aspen Media (two very experienced
distributors) I'm sure that UK customers, at least, will find that this product is well supported.
Overview
The Quantec Yardstick Room Simulator is available in a number
of different versions, starting with the base model, a two‑in,
two‑out version with only digital AES3 interfaces, called the
2492. It has an all‑analogue‑I/O sibling, the 2493, but this is the
only model in the range with analogue connectivity, as Quantec's
preference is for the user to provide external conversion where
required.
The 2496 model reviewed here is also, therefore, equipped with
digital I/O, in the form of a stereo input and six outputs. The
flagship 2498 version provides full eight‑in, eight‑out connectivity
via AES3 (on a D‑sub connector). The 2492, 2493 and 2496
models can operate at sample rates up to 192kHz, and store up
to 15 algorithms, while the 2498 can accommodate 63
algorithms but is limited to sample rates up to 96kHz. More on
the algorithms later.
The Yardstick comes with a Java‑based browser application,
which allows the user to edit the unit's parameters remotely.
The review model, running the current 3.1 firmware version, was shipped to me in a large box full of polystyrene chips, and
after digging about for a while, I was convinced the office had forgotten to pack the unit at all! The 'Yardstick' is appropriately
named because it is a very slim, stick‑like unit! Housed in an attractive, light‑blue, 1U, rackmounting case, it extends only
36mm behind the rack ears — and it is entirely self‑contained; there's no external power supply or hardware rack to connect.
Compared with virtually every other hardware reverb product on the market, the Quantec doesn't seem credible, given its
diminutive size — but looks can deceive!
The rear panel of the 2496 review model carries four XLR sockets — one for the AES3 (dual‑channel) input, and three more
for the six outputs in AES3 pairs. A trio of DIN sockets cater for MIDI In, Thru and Out, and there are three data configuration
1 of 4
03/27/2016 10:02 AM
Quantec 2496 Yardstick
http://www.soundonsound.com/sos/jul11/articles/qu...
ports: a high‑speed USB socket (B‑type), a 10‑base T Ethernet socket, and an RS232 serial port on a nine‑pin D‑sub
connector. The USB interface appears not to be enabled in the current firmware, but the manual implies that future plans
include USB connectivity, as well as remote control from a DAW plug‑in, via MIDI over Ethernet, and via a handheld Ethernet
remote panel.
As I've mentioned it, the manual contains 210 information‑packed pages, and a second 20‑page MIDI interface guide is also
included. Both are translated from the original German, with some difficult‑to‑follow, and occasionally entertaining, syntax in
places. The technical detail is immense, and every aspect of the product is described precisely and in great depth. This is one
of the very few products I have reviewed in recent years that included chapter and verse on the way it accommodates and
uses AES3 Channel Status data, for example!
Moving on, mains power is accepted on a standard IEC inlet, and the internal universal power supply accommodates all mains
supplies between 85 and 265 V AC. The unit consumes a very modest 15W of power, and the internal DSP processing uses
32‑bit floating-point maths.
Control Layout
The front panel is rather busier than the rear, and is dominated
by two high‑contrast yellow‑on‑black OLED displays. On the
2496 and 2498 versions, the right‑hand display is surrounded by
24 tiny buttons, which provide direct access to various menu
parameters. The top and bottom rows are illuminated
The rear panel of the 2496 Yardstick. All the audio I/O is
push-buttons, while the left and right columns are side‑acting
presented on AES3 XLR sockets, while MIDI, Ethernet, USB
and RS232 connectors provide remote‑control functionality.
toggle switches. A conical rotary encoder wheel to the right of
the displays is used to access the menu tree, along with a pair of
push‑buttons featuring unusually angular caps, which give the impression of a 1980s‑style rocker switch. The rotary encoder
and angular push‑buttons provide the only means of selecting and changing preset parameters in the 2492/2493 models, but
the array of miniature switches around the screen provides faster, direct‑access parameter adjustment on the 2496 and 2498.
I found the user interface rather daunting at first, but it quickly began to make sense as I played with it. It allows surprisingly
fast configuration and adjustment once familiar.
GLOSSARY: technical terms
explained
WIN Great Prizes in SOS
Competitions!
Win APS Klasik & Sub 10
monitors
Win One of 10 Sonnox
plug-ins
Win! Aston Origin Mics
Win! Classic Gear From
Soundgas
A more conventional black rocker switch at the extreme right‑hand side powers the unit on and off, and at the opposite end of
the front panel, eight vertical bar‑graphs show the input and output signal levels. Ten more LEDs arranged below the meters
indicate sample rates, clock sources, DSP status and remote‑control connections.
The OLED displays are very crisp and clear, and there are comprehensive setup parameters for adjusting contrast and
brightness. A display mode button on the bottom row below the right‑hand display allows the user to toggle through various
display modes that show different amounts of information simultaneously, from 14 parameters down to just three. Needless to
say, the 14‑parameter displays are pretty cramped, while the three‑parameter display is much larger and you stand a chance
of reading it without having to sit right in front of the rack. My personal preference is for the six‑parameter mode, which shows
all the critical parameters in a single glance, yet allows instant access to the others via the up/down buttons, also on the
bottom row. Displayed parameter values can be changed instantly using the adjacent toggle switches at the side of the screen
to step up or down and, when in the edit parameter display mode, the left‑hand screen shows the selected parameter, with
a bar-graph of the current value, which can be changed with the rotary encoder.
The row of buttons along the top of the screen provides separate mutes for the input signal, the entire 'room' simulation, the
dry signal feeding through to the output mix, the first reflection, and the room's reverb itself — all very useful when auditioning
different presets or for special effects. The bottom row of buttons allow the display mode and displayed parameters to be
changed, as already mentioned, but also switch between two preset 'scratch' memories, or access the main
configuration menu.
Something worth mentioning at this point is the inclusion of a dry signal path in the mix outputs. Virtually all reverb units
incorporate a dry path and have a dry/wet balance control, but conventionally most engineers set up the reverberation as
a send‑return effect, mixing an all‑wet reverb signal with the dry source signal in the console. However, Quantec recommend
performing that mix within the Yardstick as an integral part of the room simulation, and most presets are pre‑configured that
way (although that can be changed as a global setting). Part of the reason for this is that if you mixed the dry and wet
elements externally, different path delays might be encountered (especially where external converters are employed to provide
analogue I/O), potentially resulting in unwanted comb‑filter effects that would impair the quality of the room simulations.
Despite the clarity of the Yardstick's OLED screens, or in situations where the Yardstick is out of reach, some users might
prefer an alternative interface format, and the unit can be controlled remotely by a garish but very functional Java‑based web
browser interface. The Quantec unit needs to be wired into a local area network, of course. It defaults to an automatic
Dynamic Host Configuration Protocol (DHCP) setting, but can be set up with a manual IP address, after which it can be
controlled and configured remotely via an intuitive graphical screen. The web‑page display reflects the input and output
metering, the selected presets, and all of the mute buttons, and sliders are provided to display and adjust the relevant
parameter values. The whole thing is very clear, logical and intuitive to use.
The Algorithm Method
SOS Readers Ads
GRAB A BARGAIN
£337,759
of Second-User Gear for sale
now — don't miss out!
When operating on higher sample‑rate signals, the internal DSP simply runs the selected algorithm that much faster and
recalculates the necessary processing elements accordingly. However, that also means that when operating on base-rate
signals, the DSP will have unused capacity and could, instead, be used to host a more complex algorithm. Consequently,
many of the QRS algorithms (called plug‑ins and stored in 'banks') are available in simple, medium and complex versions —
each with a number of factory‑preset room simulations. The Simple versions operate at base, double and quad sample rates,
while the medium versions generally operate only at base and double rates, and the complex versions are functional only for
base‑rate signals, because they place much greater demands on the DSP's resources. In general, the different algorithms
provide the same (or similar) preset room simulations, but with varying levels of complexity and accuracy. I mostly used
a Medium algorithm during the review period.
Algorithm plug‑ins are managed through the web-browser interface or via dedicated boot‑loader software, and placed in one
(or more) of 15 bank locations in most 249x models, and in any of 63 locations for the 2498 version. These bank locations
store every aspect of the machine's configuration, algorithms and even preset parameters, including temporary parameter
values in the scratch memories. By copying plug‑ins between different banks, it's possible to store and manage sets of presets
and machine configurations, which can be useful in assembling specific collections for different projects or for different users.
2 of 4
03/27/2016 10:02 AM
Quantec 2496 Yardstick
http://www.soundonsound.com/sos/jul11/articles/qu...
The room simulation is essentially based on the concept of two spaced loudspeakers in a room being auditioned by, in the
case of the 2496, six spaced microphones, all placed in the diffuse field. The first pair of outputs provides the primary stereo
reverberation, but for surround applications the other channels can be employed to produce suitably related but decorrelated
outputs. Thus a stereo input can generate a stereo output or a very acceptable five- or six‑channel output. It's also important
to note that the stereo input generates a true stereo reverberation — the two channels are not summed to feed the algorithm,
something that many digital reverb processors, hardware and software alike, do.
In Use
The QRS Yardstick requires a different mind set than when using more conventional reverberation units. The number of
available parameters, and the number of different algorithm plug‑ins, for that matter, is limited in comparison to many synthetic
reverb offerings. For example, instead of being able to control the early reflections separately from the reverberation tail, or to
choose entirely different algorithms for different kinds of reverberant spaces, the QRS approach is to present a single,
fully‑integrated room simulation. There is a parameter to adjust the 'first reflection', but this is more for a 'slap‑back' effect than
to adjust the room's early reflections in isolation. Nevertheless, the single room algorithm can, if you manipulate the available
parameters (or choose pre‑defined presets), be shaped to simulate a wide range of acoustic spaces with remarkable fidelity
and naturalness.
For the inveterate tweaker, though, there are plenty of user‑adjustable parameters, including room size, density and RT60
time (with three separate values for the overall time, and the high‑ and low‑frequency multipliers), just for starters. The
threshold frequencies for the high and low RT60 values can also be adjusted with high and low 'edge' parameters, and there
are 'bass edge' (a high‑pass filter) and 'bass gain' parameters to determine the LF response of the reverb signal, too. The
QRS algorithm essentially generates the LF spectrum of the simulated room by emulating the resonant effects of an enclosed
space, and the high end by modelling absorption — recreating the way the air shapes the sound within a room, as in real life.
There are also parameter controls for the relative levels and delays of the dry signal, the first (slap‑back) reflection, and
reverberation itself, as well as a low‑pass filter for the reverberation signal. In most cases, the parameter values jump in
pre‑determined increments — after all, who could tell the difference between density values of 10 and 11 percent? Instead,
the Yardstick offers useful value steps that scale at roughly 1.6 times the previous value, so in the case of the Density
parameter the available values are 0, 10, 16, 25, 40, 63, 100, 125, 160 and 200 percent. The correlation between output
channels can also be adjusted, as can the mapping of the dry input signals to the various outputs in the 2496 and 2498
versions.
In practice, using the yardstick is much like any other reverb; a likely preset is selected and the parameters fine‑tuned as
necessary. The ability to load different presets (factory or user) into two scratch memories (Scratch A is editable while Scratch
B is fixed as a reference) and switch between them makes comparisons and tweaking very quick and easy. The factory
collection of presets is divided into a music library and a dialogue library, the latter intended mainly for film, TV and radio
production applications.
The music offerings are grouped into subsets: small, medium and large rooms, concert halls, sacred spaces, plates, and
various. Within each are specific offerings, such as furnished and unfurnished living rooms, small theatre, various sized
concert halls — importantly, offered both with and without audiences — and an assortment of churches and cathedrals,
including two classics from the original QRS: St Peters in Rome, and the almost endlessly reverberant Taj Mahal mausoleum.
There are also six plates with different pre-delay settings, and four emulations of early low‑cost digital reverbs (intended to
highlight the advantage of the QRS algorithm, rather than for use as effects in their own right!)
The dialogue library contains a lot of unusual, but amazingly useful environments, ranging from small enclosed spaces like
a breadbin, a wardrobe and an oil barrel, to various vehicles (car, truck, box‑van and submarine), and on to a vast collection of
different rooms. These include small spaces like saunas, tents and cramped offices, through medium-sized spaces like
a small garage and cinema, to larger classrooms, hallways, and even a circus tent. There are also more cavernous spaces,
such as a multi‑storey car park, an aircraft hangar and a power‑plant hall. A number of outdoor spaces are also included:
various alleyways and streets, railways station platforms, parks and a small copse. Most of these presets hit the required spot
straight away, and all respond well to a little parameter tweaking when necessary to tailor the sound slightly.
Comparing the furnished and unfurnished living‑room presets highlights the remarkable realism of the QRS algorithm, and the
circus tent preset also stands out as an unusually accurate but distinctive sound character, which is very difficult to recreate
with other reverb units.
At the end of the day, though, it all comes down to the sound of the reverberation, and, quite simply, the QRS is an
astonishingly good reverberator. In many ways it is unlike anything else on the market, because whereas most hardware and
software products produce nice‑sounding simulations of generic spaces, the QRS seems to produce real rooms. It's very hard
to put into words on paper, but the Yardstick seems to be able to place the source within a real space in a far more convincing
way than most other reverbs manage — even convolution reverbs. This ability becomes even more striking when working with
a complete stereo mix of a genuine acoustic performance, because the musicians appear to sit within a very natural room
space, instead of having a synthetic room character pasted over the top of them.
When mixing rock and pop music, a 'reverb effect' is often precisely what is required and expected, and perhaps the
Quantec's realism isn't entirely required or appropriate in that situation. However, a perennial frustration for me in my former
career when editing stereo classical material, or working as a TV dubbing mixer, was that the available reverb processors
generally failed to create convincing rooms that could be used to match material recorded at different times or in different
locations. It was usually possible to get something close with extensive parameter manipulation, but I never felt the match was
100 percent. Most reverberators produce an effect rather than a real room emulation. Convolution reverbs offer a better
alternative, but only if the required room character already exists as an impulse response. In contrast, the Quantec Yardstick
seems far better able to create a vast range of realistic‑sounding rooms straight away, and to be able to generate spaces to
match existing rooms with relative ease. Consequently, I think the primary markets for the Yardstick are in classical music and
media post‑production applications, where it offers significant advantages over the traditional reverb tools.
Verdict
Overall, the quality of the Yardstick's reverberation is stunningly real — smooth, natural and organic‑sounding, with a tangible
sense of space and scale. Whether auditioned on speakers or headphones (and with the channel‑correlation level set
accordingly), the Yardstick produces far more believable acoustic spaces than I've found anywhere else. It really is a quite
remarkable processor, and all the more so given the age of the underpinning algorithm. It just shows that the underlying model
concept, rather than sheer DSP processing power, is what determines the realism of artificial reverberation, and clearly
3 of 4
03/27/2016 10:02 AM
Quantec 2496 Yardstick
http://www.soundonsound.com/sos/jul11/articles/qu...
Quantec developed something very special 30 years ago! The Yardstick creates room acoustics rather than 'just'
reverberation, and in any application where creating or matching real room acoustics is critically important, it is a must‑have.
I really don't want to let the review unit go!
Alternatives
Since the 2496 is a two‑in, six out unit, it should really be compared with similar surround‑capable reverbs, and there's
really only one: the Lexicon PCM96 Surround reverb. This Lexicon model with digital I/O costs slightly less than the
Quantec, while the model with analogue I/O is slightly more expensive. However, the Lexicon can be used as a DAW
plug‑in, which is a function not yet available on the Quantec. The 2492 and 2493 stereo‑in, stereo‑out models are more or
less expensive than other comparable high‑end stereo reverbs such as the Bricasti M7, the Lexicon PCM96, the TC
Electronic Reverb 4000 and the Eventide Reverb 2016.
Published in SOS July 2011
Home | Search | News | Current Issue | Tablet Mag | Articles | Forum | Blog | Subscribe | Shop | Readers Ads
Advertise | Information | Privacy Policy | Support | Login Help
Current Magazine
Email: Contact SOS
Telephone: +44 (0)1954 789888
Fax: +44 (0)1954 789895
Registered Office: Media House, Trafalgar Way, Bar Hill,
Cambridge, CB23 8SQ, United Kingdom.
Sound On Sound Ltd is registered in England and Wales.
Company number: 3015516 VAT number: GB 638 5307 26
Web Edition
Tablet Mag app
Buy PDF articles
Magazine Feedback
Subscribe
Subscribe Now
Web Subscription FAQs
News
Search
New Search
Forum Search
Search Tips
Articles
Competitions
Reviews
Technique
Sound Advice
People
Glossary
Home
Help + Support
Podcasts
SOS Shop
Forum
My SOS
Today's Hot Topics
Forum Channel List
Forum Search
My Forum Home
My Forum Settings
My Private Messages
Forum Rules & Etiquette
Change Password
Change My Email
Change My Address
My Subscription
My eNewsletters
My Downloads
Video
Advertising
Magazine On-sale Dates
About SOS
Contact SOS Staff
Controlled Circulation
Licensing Enquiries
SOS Logos & Graphics
SOS Site Analytics
Privacy Policy
Watch exhibition videos, tutorials,
interviews, masterclasses
Readers Classifieds
Submit New Adverts
View My Adverts
Information
We accept the following payment methods in our web Shop:
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2016. All rights reserved.
The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden without the prior written consent of the
Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents.
The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers.
Web site designed & maintained by PB Associates | SOS | Relative Media
4 of 4
03/27/2016 10:02 AM
Was this manual useful for you? yes no
Thank you for your participation!

* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project

Download PDF

advertising