Canon | FaxPhone L380S | HP LaserJet 9055MFP & 9065MFP vs

HP LaserJet M1319f MFP vs. Top Competitors
Devices competing with the HP LaserJet M1319f MFP have serious shortcomings.
Competitor
Major weakness(es)
Specifics
Top competitors
With competitors, users
get devices that are slower
and more difficult to use
 HP’s lowest-priced laser MFP (with fax) for superior 4-in-1 print, copy, scan, fax performance.
 HP’s Instant-on technology means faster print and copy performance from Powersave.
 Superior fax functionality with FaxTel, junk-fax blocker, and more stored fax pages (up to
500 pages) which means secure receipt and you don’t lose pages when out of toner or
paper.
 A 19/18 ppm rated speed, hi-speed USB 2.0 and 240 MHz processor with 32 std. memory
provide fast printing and copying performance for even the most complex documents.
 HP’s intelligent, integrated print cartridges ensure consistent print quality and eliminate
complexity and extra maintenance associated with multi-part imaging systems.
 HP’s FPO from Powersave is less than 8.5 sec. vs. 22 sec. for the Brother, which means the HP
can print or copy about 5 pages from Powersave before the Brother completes its first.
 Better scan/copy/fax with HP – not only does HP include a 600x600 colour scanner (vs.
200x300 b&w scanner w/ the Brother), but HP faxes at 33.6 kbps vs. 14.4 kbps.
 Reduce complexity with HP – Brother separates their toner from their imaging drum which is
more complex for users, and also uses a corona wire which requires regular cleaning.
 HP’s FPO from Powersave is less than 8.5 sec. vs. 22 sec. for the Brother, which means the HP
can print or copy about 5 pages from Powersave before the Brother completes its first.
 Better scan/copy/fax with HP – not only does HP include a 600x600 colour scanner (vs.
200x300 b&w scanner w/ the Brother), but HP faxes at 33.6 kbps vs. 14.4 kbps.
 Reduce complexity with HP – Brother separates their toner from their imaging drum which is
more complex for users, and also uses a corona wire which requires regular cleaning.
 HP’s FPO from Powersave is less than 8.5 sec. vs. 22 sec. for the Brother, which means the HP
can print or copy about 5 pages from Powersave before the Brother completes its first.
 Better scanning, copying and faxing with HP – HP uses a colour scanner with 600x600
resolution vs. b&w scanner w/ only 200x300 resolution with the Brother.
 Reduce complexity with HP – Brother separates their toner from their imaging drum which is
more complex for users, and also uses a corona wire which requires regular cleaning.
 HP’s FPO from Powersave is less than 8.5 sec. vs. 24 sec. for the Brother, which means the HP
can print or copy about 5 pages from Powersave before the Brother completes its first.
 Better scanning, copying and faxing with HP – HP uses a colour scanner with 600x600
resolution vs. b&w scanner w/ only 300x600 resolution with the Brother.
 Reduce complexity with HP – Brother separates their toner from their imaging drum which is
more complex for users, and also uses a corona wire which requires regular cleaning.
 Better scanning, copying and faxing with HP – HP uses a colour scanner with 600x600
resolution vs. b&w scanner w/ only 300x300 resolution with the Canon L170.
in general
Brother
IntelliFax-2820
Brother
MFC-7220
Brother
MFC-7225N
Brother
MFC-8220
Canon
Slower warm-up,
Lower quality scan, fax,
Complex two-piece toner
cartridge with corona wire
Slower warm-up,
Lower quality scan, fax;
Complex two-piece toner
cartridge with corona wire
Slower warm-up,
Lower quality scan, fax,
Complex two-piece toner
cartridge with corona wire
Slower warm-up,
Lower quality scan, fax,
Complex two-piece toner
cartridge with corona wire
Poor scan/copy/fax quality,
Slower performance
Faxphone L170
Canon
Faxphone L380S
Samsung
SF-565PR
Slower print/copy,
Slower processing,
Inferior print / scan quality,
Inferior media input
Slow warm-up and
print/copy performance,
Poor print / copy / scan /
fax quality
 Faster performance on complex jobs with HP’s 240 MHz processor and 32 MB standard memory.
 Faster performance on print jobs with HP – not only does HP offer faster processor and 4x the
memory, but HP also uses faster hi-speed USB 2.0 vs. antiquated USB 1.1 for faster connectivity.
 Colour scanning with HP – HP uses a colour scanner vs. b&w scanner with the Canon L380S.
 Faster performance on complex jobs with HP’s 240 MHz processor and 32 MB standard memory.
 Faster performance on print jobs with HP – not only does HP offer faster processor and 4x the
memory, but HP also uses faster hi-speed USB 2.0 vs. antiquated USB 1.1 for faster connectivity.
 HP’s FPO from Powersave is less than 8.5 sec. vs. 31 sec. for Samsung, which means the HP
can print or copy about 8 pages from Powersave before the Samsung completes its first.
 Faster copying and scanning with HP’s 13 cpm ADF vs. 3.4 cpm for the Samsung ADF.
 Faster performance on print jobs with HP – HP offers faster rated speeds and processor with 4x the
memory, and HP also uses faster hi-speed USB 2.0 vs. antiquated USB 1.1 for faster connectivity.
 Better print/scan/copy/fax quality with HP – HP offers higher print resolution, and HP offers
600dpi colour scanning vs. only 200 dpi b&w scanning with the Samsung.
Pricing last updated
20080122
HP RESTRICTED
HP
Brother
Brother
Brother
Brother
Canon
Canon
Samsung
LJ M1319f
Fax-2820
MFC-7220
MFC-7225N
MFC-8220
L170
L380S
565PR
Engine
Canon
Brother
Brother
Brother
Brother
Canon
Canon
Samsung
PPM print (Ltr A4)
PPM copy (Ltr A4)
19 18 A4
19 18 A4
15 14 A4
15 11 A4
20
20
20
20
21 20 A4
21 20 A4
19
19
19
19
17 16 A4
17 16 A4
Resolution
(print/copy)
FastRes1200
600x600
1200x600
200 x 300
1200x600
200x300
2400x600
200x300
2400x600
300 x 600
1200 x 600
300 x 300
1200 x 600
1200 x 600
600x600
200x200
Scanner type
Colour CIS
B&W CIS
B&W CIS
B&W CIS
B&W CIS
B&W CIS
B&W CIS
B&W CIS
Monthly duty cycle
8,000
10,000
10,000
10,000
20,000
Not specified Not specified 10,000
Memory
32 MB
8 MB
16 MB
32 MB
32 MB
7.2 MB
Processor
240 MHz
Not specified 133 MHz
133 MHz
133 MHz
Not specified Not specified Not specified
Dimensions (mm),
2
footprint (m )
467 x 443 x
2
459 (.21 m )
374 x 374 x
2
262 (.14 m )
374 x 374 x
2
262 (.14 m )
374 x 374 x
2
262 (.14 m )
431 x 335 x
2
451 (.14 m )
518 x 584 x
2
348 (.30 m )
438 x 402 x
2
348 (.18 m )
363 x 390 x
2
308 (.14 m )
Input Cap
250
250
250
250
250
250
250
250
Priority feed
10 sheets
1 sheet
1 sheet
1 sheet
1 sheet
1 sheet
1 sheet
1 sheet
ADF capacity
30 sheets
20 sheet
20 sheet
30 sheet
30 sheets
50 sheet
50 sheet
20 sheet
FAX Kbps
33.6 kbps
14.4 kbps
14.4 kbps
33.6 kbps
33.6 kbps
33.6 kbps
33.6 kbps
33.6 kbps
Handset
Yes
Yes
Yes
Optional
Yes
Hi-speed
USB 2.0
Full-speed
USB 2.0
Full speed
USB 2.0
Yes
Full-speed
USB 2.0,
parallel
Yes
Connectivity
Yes
Full speed
USB 2.0,
10/100
USB 1.1
USB 1.1
USB 1.1
PDLs
Host-based
Host-based
Host-based
PCL/PS3 em
PCL/PS3 em
Host-based
Host-based
Host-based
Price US / EMEA
(incl. €VAT)
$249 /
~€249
$179 /
€259
$199 /
NA
$299 /
€329
$299 /
€599
$269 /
NA
NA /
€749
$299 /
€349
Cost per page
US cents / € cents
3.4 /
~3.4
3.4/
2.8
3.4 /
NA
3.4 /
2.8
2.9 – 2.3 /
2.4 – 1.9
3.7 /
NA
NA /
2.4
3.0 /
2.3
Consumables yield 2000
2500
2500
2500
3500
6700 hi-cap
3500
3500
3000
Toner in the box
1000
1500
1500
1500
3500
2500
2500
1000
Print cartridge
design
Integrated
Two-piece,
12K drum
Two-piece,
12K drum
Two-piece,
12K drum
Two-piece,
20K drum
Integrated
Integrated
Integrated
FPO from Powersave
(60 minutes idle)
< 8.5 sec
22 sec
22 sec
22 sec
24 sec
~ 10 sec
~ 10 sec
31 sec
Rev20080326/LTR
20 A4
20 A4
20 A4
20 A4
HP RESTRICTED
18 A4
18 A4
18 A4
18 A4
8 MB
8 MB
Download PDF