David J. Gingery - How To Design & Buid Centrifugal Fans For The Home Shop (pdf, 1853 Кб)

David J. Gingery - How To Design & Buid Centrifugal Fans For The Home Shop (pdf, 1853 Кб)
T A B L E OF C O N T E N T S
Introduction
Chapter I: Fan Fundamentals
1
3
Centrifugal Fan Principles
Predictable
Behavior
of
Centrifugal
Basic Fan Types and Applications
bans
3
4
5
The
Nature
of
A
ir
The Effect of Wheel Diameter and Speed
The
Effect
of
A
ir
Velocity
The Effect of Wheel Width
The Effect of Wheel- Width-to-Diameter Ration
Scroll Housing Development
General Proportions for Fans and Blowers
Theoretical
Capacity
of
Fans
Po
wer
Required
9
10
11
I5
17
18
21
23
24
Chapter II: Design Considerations
9
Chapter III: Construction Methods and Materials
27
Wheel Construction
27
An 8"Open Sided Wheel
30
Balancing the Wheel
33
Forming the Housing Scroll
38
Building a Plywood Housing for an Exhaust Fan 38
Making an Alt Metal Housing
41
Discharge Fittings
46
Triangulation
47
Motor and Drive Applications
58
Chapter IV: Fan Testing and Air Measurement
Measuring Air
The "U" Tube Manometer
Measuring Pressure
The Pilot Tube
Taking Pressure Readings
Interpreting and Applying the Readings
Theoretical Velocity of Air at 62° F.
Discharged Into Atmosphere
Volume Flow Calculations
A
ir
Flo
w
in
Calculating
Orifice
A
63
63
64
68
70
73
74
Orifices
rea
77
78
80
83
Chapter V: Shop Fan Applications
Common Applications
Fume Exhaust Fans
Dust Collectors
The Cyclone Separator
Developing Cyclone Patterns
Balancing the System
Appendix
85
85
86
95
98
99
106
109
H o w to Design and Build
Centrifugal Fans for the Home Shop
by David J. Gingery
Copyright 1987
by Lindsay Publications, Inc.
Bradley IL 60915
All rights reserved.
ISBN 1-917914-60-0
1987
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
WARNING
Remember that the materials and
methods described here are from
another era. Workers were less
safety conscious then, and some
methods may be downright dangerous. Be careful! Use good
solid judgement in your work,
and think ahead. Lindsay Publications Inc. has not tested these
methods and materials and does
not endorse them. Our job is
merely to pass along to you information from another era. Safety is
your responsibility.
Write for a complete catalog of
unusual books available from:
Lindsay Publications Inc
PO Box 12
Bradley IL 60915-0012
For a fascinating selection of the highest quality
books for experimenters, inventors, tinkerers, mad
scientists, and a very few normal people... visit
www.lindsaybks.com
NOTICE OF DISCLAIMER
The author of this book is not a professional engineer nor has he
had formal training in the design or operation of the project.
The author is an amateur but has been successful in building and
operating the project discussed herein.
The methods that he used and describes are presented merely as
guidelines for other amateurs in developing such a project. The
project can be dangerous, and dangers have been pointed out
wherever possible. Since the author is not a professional in this
field, there may well be other dangers involved in the building
and operation of the project.
The author hereby disclaims any liability for injury to persons
or property that may result while using this project book, and
the author does not intend by this publication to explain all
dangers known or unknown that may exist in the building and
operation of this project.
Lindsay Publications Inc has not built this project nor does it endorse the methods described. Lindsay Publications Inc assumes
no liability for injury to person or property that may result from
the use of this information.
Centrifugal Fans Can be Dangerous!
Designers, builders, and users of centrifugal fans expose
themselves to special dangers. The rapidly spinning fan disc
with its metal blades is as dangerous as the blades of a kitchen
blender. Fingers can mutilated or amputated as a result of accident or absent-mindedness. Provide guards to protect you and
your children and pets from injury.
Centrifugal fans with blades which are inadequately
fastened may fly apart as a result of centrifugal force. The result is a violent explosion that can cause property damage,
injury, and possibly even death. Provide a sturdy housing
around the fan disc to contain such an explosion. Proper construction and adequate testing is important.
These are two obvious dangers. There are probably others.
They have been pointed out wherever known. Properly built and
used, homebuilt fans can be every bit as safe as the blower in
your home furnace, or the blower in your vacuum cleaner. Be
very careful.
I N T R O D U C T I O N
Nearly everyone is familiar with "squirrel cage" fans
found in home heating, air conditioning and ventilating
systems. The squirrel cage is just one of many forms of
centrifugal fans and blowers designed in a wide range of
sizes for many different applications.
Smaller fans appear on the market from time to time
as surplus or salvage, some of which may find practical
use in home shop applications. It certainly makes little
sense to construct a fan for a special purpose if one is
readily available at low cost. But some applications require air at high pressure and volume, and the fans and
blowers usually available as surplus will probably not
meet the requirements. At this point it becomes practical
to design and build a fan for the job at hand.
It is not difficult to design a fan for a specific purpose when the importance of the effect of various factors
is understood. Although state-of-the-art fan design has
become highly technical, mainly due to advances in jet
propulsion and turbine technology, you can easily design
a fan to suit your specific needs.
The basic principles that are discussed in this manual have remained unchanged for more than 150 years.
Surprisingly, common materials and ordinary tools are
adequate for construction of fans capable of delivering
air at high volume and moderately high pressure.
Because there are many design parameters that can be
manipulated, fans can be designed to meet nearly any requirement of volume, velocity and pressure.
The most common application for a high pressure
and/or high volume fan is in forcing air into a furnace or
1
in exhausting dust and fumes. A blacksmith's forge or a
melting furnace are examples of forced draft.
The exhaustion of welding fumes or the collection of
dust from woodworking machines or grinders can be
easily accomplished in the small shop at low cost. These
are areas of safety, protection and convenience that are
usually neglected because a new fan capable of doing this
work is too expensive. Because such a fan is seldom
found used or surplus, it is worthwhile to consider
building one.
This manual will show you how to determine the
diameter and width of a fan wheel and at what speed to
run it to achieve the desired pressure and volume. Several
methods for building the wheel are discussed. The layout
procedure for the scroll housing has been simplified.
From the formula given for calculating the amount
of power required to run a fan you will learn (perhaps to
your amazement) how much work can be done by a common fractional horsepower motor. You will be shown
how to build simple balancing equipment and how to use
it. You will also learn how to test the performance of experimental fans with an easily built manometer and pitot
tube. Only a few easily understood and applied formulae
are needed to guide you. You will enjoy building several
projects that will upgrade your shop and make your
work environment safer and more comfortable.
As in any shop activity there are dangers that may
not be readily apparent. You should be aware that centrifugal force and generated air pressure puts great strain
upon the fan wheel and other parts of the blower.
Foreign material in the air stream or loose pieces breaking off the wheel can reach velocities of up to several
thousand feet per minute. Very serious injury or possibly
even death can result if persons are struck. Take all practical steps to protect yourself and others. Electrical wiring must be properly installed to avoid shock and fire
hazards. Always be very safety conscious in the shop,
and provide protection promptly whenever danger appears.
2
C H A P T E R
I
Fan Fundamentals
CENTRIFUGAL FAN PRINCIPLES
Although there are many different designs, all centrifugal fans work in the same way. Air trapped between
the vanes of the wheel or rotor is thrown outward by centrifugal force, and replacement air is drawn in at the
center. As the speed of the rotor increases, so does the
velocity, pressure and volume of the air delivered at the
fan outlet. The housing collects or gathers the air as it is
expelled from the rotor and directs it out in a single
stream.
The ability to develop pressure makes the centrifugal fan the logical choice in a ducted air system.
Although the disc or propeller fan can move very large
amounts of air, it would have to be complex and sophis3
ticated to do the same work done by a simple centrifugal
fan when resistance to flow is a significant factor. Some
commercial fans are built to deliver air at pressures that
are so high that they should really be called compressors.
Small shop applications will not need more than four to
six inches of water column pressure or less than 3-1/2
ounces per square inch gauge.
The term "fan" or "blower" will be used interchangeably in this discussion. There are devices and
mechanisms called blowers that are not fans, but any fan
can be called a blower. Although actual applications may
primarily use the inlet air stream rather than the discharge stream, the working principles remain the same.
PREDICTABLE BEHAVIOR OF
CENTRIFUGAL FANS
Since air has mass and substance, a measurable amount
of work is done by a fan. Luckily, the physical laws that
govern its operation are not complicated or difficult to
master.
Volume, pressure and velocity of air movement are
the prime considerations in fan design. If a few physical
and mechanical principles are understood, these measurable variables and the amount of power required to
produce them can be predicted with reasonable accuracy
before construction by calculations with simple formulas.
Although state-of-the-art fan engineering is very
sophisticated, it is still not possible to design a perfect fan
by mere mathematical calculations alone. After the
calculations have determined the approximate size and
proportions, a model must be built and tested. It is quite
reasonable to expect the first model to meet the requirements if ample allowances are made in design. Changing
the wheel speed or adjusting the inlet or outlet will bring
performance to the desired level.
Although very complex formulas have been developed to take into account almost every conceivable factor, we will discuss only the most basic formulas in this
4
manual. We will use simple math to explore the relationships between obvious, easily measured factors to determine unknown or less obvious design factors. The ignored parameters will certainly affect performance. But
rather than apply a more complex formula, we will adjust an over-designed fan to compensate. In fact in many
instances, this might even be the more practical way to
design since the nature and composition of air can be
quite different from day to day. Some fans will need to
be adjusted only the first time used while others may require adjustment at each use. If your particular work requires greater precision than what you find here, you will
find additional data and formulas in any of several
modern engineering manuals found in most public
libraries.
BASIC FAN TYPES AND APPLICATIONS
The diameter, width and speed of the wheel, or rotor, are
certainly the most important elements of design. A
discussion of the various fan types will help us understand the effects of these factors and how the formulas
are applied.
There are three common types of fan rotors in use:
forward curved vane, backward inclined vane and radial
vane. Each type is shown in diagrammatic form below.
FORWARD CURVE
BACKWARD INCLINED
RADIAL VANE
5
The forward curved vane type is the familiar quiet
"squirrel cage fan" found in low pressure applications.
It is made up of many vanes of small area that are curved
in the direction of rotation. The wheel will often be about
as wide as its diameter, and the inlet opening will often be
nearly as large as the wheel diameter. Although it can
generate pressures up to 1-1/2" water column, it is most
often operated below 1" water column.
Compared to squirrel cage fans, backward inclined
vane fans have fewer vanes of greater area that are inclined away from the direction of rotation. This produces
a non-overloading characteristic which makes it ideal for
commercial heating, air conditioning and ventilating applications where load conditions in complex duct systems
vary greatly with time. These fans must run at higher
speeds to do the same work as the forward curved types
resulting in noisier operation. Although capable of
higher pressures, backward inclined vane fans are not
usually operated above 3" water column of pressure.
The radial vane type is characterized by straight
vanes of greater depth with the wheel usually being narrow in proportion to its diameter. It is capable of
pressures well above 12" water column and very high
velocity. Radial vane fans are usually of much heavier
and stronger construction than ordinary ventilating fans,
and are much noisier. This type is most often needed in
shop applications. This is the basic design type discussed
in this manual since it is ideal for exhausting, for conveying dust and dirt, and for forced draft applications.
The number of blades, or vanes, in a wheel has an
effect on performance and efficiency. Low pressure, high
volume fans will have many blades while a high pressure
radial vane fan will have fewer. In general, increasing the
number of blades will reduce slippage and thus increase
efficiency until a point is reached where losses due to friction and reduced inlet area will offset gains. A commercially built radial vane fan might have from 5 to 12 blades
while a backward inclined wheel might have from 10 to
20 blades. A curved vane squirrel cage fan might have
6
from 30 to 60 or more vanes. Since multiples of four are
easy to layout with available home shop methods, I have
found that 8 blades works well for most high pressure
fans, while 16 blades do nicely for higher volume needs
when pressure is not the main requirement.
A number of housing types are in common use, but
the familar scroll shaped housing is likely to be the most
practical for home construction.
7
C H A P T E R
DESIGN
II
CONSIDERATIONS
THE NATURE OF AIR
Although invisible, air has mass and viscosity, and like
most substances its composition varies. It is composed of
approximately 21% oxygen and 79% other gases, mostly
nitrogen, and is more or less polluted wherever found. At
68 degrees Fahrenheit, 50% relative humidity and with a
barometer reading of 29.92" of mercury, a cubic foot of
air weighs very nearly .075 pounds. This is regarded as
"standard air" in fan engineering. The air in your shop
might be standard at this moment, but it will rapidly
change to something other than standard. Most of the air
you work with will be other than "standard," but the
difference will not be very important in most instances.
Air is more dense (heavier per cubic foot) when it is
cold. Warm air rises while cold air falls. It is upon this
principle that a chimney works and that violent wind
storms develop in the atmosphere. A cubic foot of cold
air will contain more oxygen than the same volume of
warm air, and it will require more power to move the
colder air because it is more dense.
There are applications where the air is delivered for
the sake of using its content, usually the oxygen, making
the air's weight, temperature, humidity, and other attributes important factors in delivery. In some modern
melting furnaces the volume of air in the blast is adjusted
9
according to its density by specially designed controls to
ensure that the required amount of oxygen is delivered.
In such large volume applications even a small percentage of error is significant. We are not usually burdened
with such concerns in the small shop.
When air becomes severely polluted, as in a shop
where welding is done, it becomes desirable to exhaust
the polluted air and replace it with clean air. Since exhausters must only move air in sufficient quantity to
replace the bad air, the composition of the air is not a
significant design factor. Rather we need only be concerned with providing sufficient volume of air and
enough pressure to overcome resistance within the duct
system. In cold weather replacement air must be heated
or the work area may soon be too cold for comfort. The
source of the replacement air is a factor too, and you will
soon hear from your neighbors if you impose your
smoke- and fume-laden air upon them.
When dust or other materials are to be conveyed in
an air stream, it is the velocity or speed of the air that
does the work. Obviously, a specific volume of air is required to maintain velocity within a pipe or duct of a
given size. Dust collectors and conveyors require stronger
fans and much greater power to achieve high velocity,
volume and pressure.
With these fundamentals in mind we can consider
the effects of various dimensions and proportions in the
design of centrifugal fans. After doing so, some of the
formulas used in their design will be easily understood
and applied.
THE EFFECT OF WHEEL DIAMETER AND SPEED
Because velocity and pressure are the most easily determined factors in fan behavior, we rely heavily upon them
in designing and testing. The diameter of the wheel, or
rotor, and its speed, affects both factors.
Since the air is expelled at the periphery or outer
edge of the wheel, it will have attained the velocity, or
10
speed, of that surface as it is thrown off by centrifugal
force. To determine air velocity it is only necessary to
know the speed of the wheel's outer edge. The velocity of
air increases directly with an increase of wheel diameter.
Doubling the wheel diameter will double the velocity of
air delivered if the wheel speed remains the same.
The circumference, perimeter or periphery of the
wheel is found by multiplying its diameter by 3.1416. For
example, a 10" diameter wheel will have a circumference
of 31.416" (10" x 3.1416 = 31.416") A point on its
perimeter will travel 2.618 feet (31.416" divided by 12"
per foot = 2.618 feet) in each revolution of the wheel.
If the wheel is driven directly by a motor that runs at
1725 RPM (revolutions per minute) then its peripheral
velocity will be 4516.05 FPM (feet per minute) because
2.618 feet per revolution x 1725 revolutions per minute
equals 4516.05 feet per minute. Thus, the theoretical
velocity of the air thrown off will be 4516.05 feet per
minute. In practice air velocity will diminish as it travels
away from the wheel.
Total output is affected by not only the distance
traveled but by friction, slippage and other less obvious
factors. These can all be taken into account with a "coefficient of discharge factor," which is usually .8 in ordinary work. In other words, you'll get only about 80%
of the output predicted by the formulas.
THE EFFECT OF AIR VELOCITY
When air is moved by force, it will displace, or push
other air out of its way. Moving air exerts pressure in the
direction of its travel called dynamic pressure.
If resistance to air flow is encountered, pressure
builds up until the maximum capacity of the fan is reached. Such pressure, called static pressure, is exerted equally in all directions. If the entire output of the fan is confined to a tank, chamber, or other pressure vessel, the
total pressure measured will be static pressure. Since the
air is not moving, there is no dynamic pressure.
If a part of the air is allowed to escape from the
11
chamber, the static pressure will drop. Since air is now
moving again, the system now exhibits dynamic pressure.
You might think that the dynamic pressure will increase
by exactly the same amount that the static pressure decreased. Not so. In practice the moving air must fight its
way through the static pressure before it can escape into
the rest of the system. The dynamic pressure of the moving air will be reduced by static pressure that resists its
flow. The remaining dynamic pressure is called the
velocity pressure. This is the practical, working pressure
that delivers the stream of moving air. The diagrams
below illustrate the effects of dynamic, static and velocity
pressure in a fan system.
The relationship between the velocity of the air flow
and its velocity pressure is accurately predicted by the
formula:
where:
V = velocity of flow in feet per second
h = velocity pressure in inches W.C.
(water column)
air is assumed to be dry & 60° F.
The formula may be transposed to find any factor when
the other two are known:
The formula in the last instance states that the velocity in feet per second divided by 66 is equal to the square
root of the velocity pressure in inches of water column.
We can apply this formula to our 10" wheel at 1725 rpm
to determine what pressure it will produce.
12
13
We have already calculated that the theoretical velocity of the 10" wheel at 1725 rpm is 4516.05 feet per
minute. The decimal fraction is insignificant. The value
can be rounded to 4516 feet per minute.
Since the formula calls for velocity in feet per second, 4516 feet per min divided by 60 sec per min equals
75.27 feet per second. Dividing this by 66 gives 1.14. If
we square this, we get
This can be verified by using the other two variations of the formula to see if the numbers calculate out
correctly:
In another instance a fan capable of delivering air at
a velocity pressure of 4" W.C. might be required. The
formula is applied to calculate the velocity of flow from
the pressure.
14
Since motor speeds are stated in revolutions per
minute (RPM) and velocity must be in feet per minute,
we must multiply by 60 seconds per minute: 132 FPS x
60 sec per min = 7920 FPM. If a 1725 RPM motor were
to drive a fan directly, a peripheral velocity of 4.59 feet
per revolution of the wheel would be required to deliver
at 4" W.C. pressure:
Obviously, the 4.59 feet is the distance around the wheel,
or the circumference.
From this we know that a 17-1/2" wheel running at 1725
rpm should deliver air at 4" W.C. pressure. Of course, a
smaller wheel running at a higher speed gives the same
result and so does a larger wheel running at a lower
speed. These combinations can be investigated by running numbers through the formula.
THE EFFECT OF WHEEL WIDTH
Fans are rated according to their ability to move a quantity of air against resistance. Ratings are usually given in
cubic feet per minute against a value of static pressure in
inches of water column. The theoretical capacity of a fan
is the product of the velocity of flow in feet per minute
multiplied by the area of the discharge times the coefficient of discharge, which has been given as .8.
15
The theoretical discharge opening is called the
"blast area," and is calculated by multiplying the
diameter of the wheel by its width and dividing the product by a factor that varies from 2.5 to 3 in practice.
Since the larger value allows the greatest margin for error
and inefficiency it is the safest to use in casual design.
The formula to find the blast area is
A = (D x W)/3
where: A = blast area in square inches
D = wheel diameter in inches
W = wheel width in inches
For example, the blast area of a 10" diameter wheel
that is 3" wide would be 10 square inches.
A = (10" x 3 " ) / 3
= 30/3
= 10 square inches
Since the capacity is stated in cubic feet per minute,
A 10" wheel at 1725 rpm delivers at a velocity of 4516
feet per minute. Its theoretic capacity is
4516 ft per min x 0.069 sq ft x 0.8
= 249.28 cu ft per min
That's almost 250 cu ft per minute against a static pressure of zero. Fan output will decrease as the static pressure increases. Larger, faster and more powerful fans are
needed in complex duct and pipe systems where static
pressure is high.
16
THE EFFECT OF
WHEEL-WIDTH-TO-DIAMETER RATIO
When high volume of air is the main consideration, the
wheel should be made as wide as possible. There is an optimum inlet size for each design type that is found by experimentation. One limitation on wheel width is the
amount of air that can freely enter the inlet. In most high
volume fans there will be a double inlet allowing the
wheel to be very wide in proportion to its diameter. Such
fans deliver high volume at low pressure and are not able
to overcome the resistance of long ducts and pipes.
When high velocity and pressure are needed, vanes
will be deeper, and the wheel will be much narrower in
proportion to the diameter. Inlet and outlet openings will
be proportionately smaller as compared to low pressure
fans.
It is not only the width-to-diameter ratio that affects
pressure but also the depth of the vanes. It is apparent
that a wheel with very deep vanes will trap air more effectively and force it to the perimeter of the wheel more efficiently at higher pressure. It is upon this principle that
the "steel pressure fan" design is based. The vanes are
not only quite deep but a plate also covers both sides so
that a closed channel exists between each pair of vanes as
shown in the sketch.
17
Such rotors are very efficient. The outer plate also
serves to make the wheel stronger when relatively light
sheet metal is used to construct the rotor. The width of
some high pressure wheels might be as little as 5% of the
wheel diameter.
SCROLL HOUSING DEVELOPMENT
For most applications a scroll housing is the simplest and
most effective housing for most fans. Some fans use a
series of discharge vanes located around the rotor which
direct air through a plenum chamber into one or more
outlets in the housing.
DISCHARGE VANES
INLET
OUTLET
Such a housing is more complex but such a design is efficient design and its compactness suits many applications.
In most instances the simple scroll housing is both
efficient and very easy to lay out and to build. It would
seem upon first consideration that very close clearances
would be necessary in fan construction. Not so. The fact
is that very casually built fans with loose clearances work
with amazing efficiency. Of course, very high pressure
work would demand very close clearance between the
wheel inlet and the housing and also at the cut-off point,
18
but in pressures below 12" water column, these dimensions are not at all critical.
The two determining factors in scroll design are the
cut-off point clearance and the blast area. Given the
diameter and width of the wheel, the blast area can easily
be calculated. Since the discharge opening is usually from
1-1/2 times to 2-1/2 times the blast area as a rule-ofthumb, we have the first dimensional clue from the
calculation. The cut-off point is that part of the scroll
that comes closest to the wheel. The clearance at this
point is usually from 5% to 10% of the diameter of the
rotor.
As seen in the illustration the scroll is an expanding
spiral, or volute, that directs all of the air thrown off the
wheel into the discharge opening. Although it would certainly require much study and experimentation to develop a nearly perfect scroll, it is not at all difficult to
layout a very good approximation that will serve well in
ordinary work. As an illustration and exercise let's lay
out a scroll housing for a 10" wheel that is 3" wide.
Since the blast area is calculated at 10 square inches,
the discharge opening can be from 15 to 25 square inches. With a clearance of 3/8" on each side of the wheel
19
which is not excessive, the housing can be 3-3/4" wide.
Thus, the discharge opening height can be from 4" to
6-1/2" high. A cutoff point clearance of 1/2" will work
very well. It can be set even closer but the fan will be
noisier. The entire work of layout will be done upon
three centers and three radii.
Layout begins with a horizontal line, AB, intersected by a vertical line, CD, which establishes the wheel
center at O. Additional centers 01 and 02 are located 1"
away on both sides of center O. Additional centers Ol
20
and 02 are located on either side of center O, the separation distance being to 10% of the wheel's diameter.
The next step is to draw the circle in the middle that
represents the wheel. Rl represents the radius of the
wheel of itself, or 5" for our 10" wheel. With the radius
Rl and center O, the circle representing the wheel is
drawn. Shifting the compass or dividers to center Ol and
using radius Rl again an arc is drawn from point B past
point E.
Then, shifting to center 0 2 , radius R2 is used to
draw an arc from B through D to A. The length of radius
R2 is the length from 02 to B.
Next, extend the arc from A to C using Ol as center.
A horizontal line is drawn from C approximately 5", or
one radius of the wheel, to point F. A vertical line is
drawn from point F to represent the height of the
discharge opening. In this instance we choose 4" for the
height to give an opening size of 3-3/4" x 4" or 15
square inches.
Finally, a line is drawn from point G to point E to
complete the layout.
Notice that R2 is equal to Rl plus the distance from
Ol to 0 2 . Likewise R3 is equal to R2 plus the distance
from Ol to 0 2 . If the distance from O to Ol and 02 is
increased, the distance from point C to the wheel will increase, and the practical cut-off point clearance will be
greater. Such increased clearances should be used on lowpressure, high-volume fans.
GENERAL PROPORTIONS
FOR FANS AND BLOWERS
The true delivery of a fan being designed is defined as the
product of the area of the design's discharge area and its
design velocity. This "ideal world" delivery differs from
the "real world" value that we actually get in the prototype. Factors in design formulae "adjust" the calculation results so that we can put "ideal" information into
these formulae and get out "real" information. All this
may sound like a "guess and by-golly" design method,
21
but surprisingly, the calculation results are near enough
to measurable real-world values to be very useful.
One possible problem area involves ratios. Fan
width-to-diameter and inlet-to-diameter ratios greatly affect fan performance, yet the formulae do not take them
into account. Understanding the effect of some of these
ratios will help us decide how much confidence we can
place in our calculation results.
In a single inlet fan, the wheel is usually no wider
than one-half the diameter. As the width of the wheel increases, the volume of air moved increases. If the wheel is
too wide, it must pull a large volume of air quickly
through a relatively small opening. The velocity of incoming air will be too great, and the wheel will starve for
air.
For high-volume/low pressure fans this problem is
solved by using an inlet at both sides of the wheel. The
inlet must be as large as possible to allow the large
volume of air in. To accomplish this, the vanes will be
very shallow and numerous. The inlet diameter will be
from 65% to 75% of the wheel's diameter, and often
larger. The outlet area will be in proportion to the inlet
area. In making a fan free breathing, you must sacrifice
something. Such a fan just can't deliver volume at high
pressure.
High pressure fans will be narrow in proportion to
the wheel diameter, and both the inlet and discharge
openings will be smaller than in a low-pressure fan. The
inlet diameter can be from 35% to 65% of the wheel
diameter. The width of the wheel can be from 10% to
25% of the diameter. Again, outlet size in proportion to
the inlet.
It should be apparent from a comparison of these
two design extremes that deeper, longer vanes will build
up more pressure. Deeper vanes mean that the inlet must
be smaller. (Long vanes are of no use if much of their
length is exposed by a large diameter inlet.) A small inlet
means the fan cannot handle high volume which in turn
means that the wheel can't be as wide as other designs.
22
Remember, a wide fan wants to deliver higher
volume than a narrower fan. To get volume, the narrow,
deep vaned fan must run at higher speed resulting in a
high velocity, high pressure delivery which generates
more noise and greater losses from friction. You can see
each type has its advantages.
A common application for a high pressure fan is a
vacuum cleaner. The usual proportions are a width of 12
to 18% of the wheel diameter with an inlet from 40 to
50% of the wheel diameter. The vanes will often be a
compound curved variation of the backward inclined
form. Not many modern vacuum cleaners use a scroll
housing. The air will be discharged through curved
vanes. Some units discharge the air from one wheel into
the inlet of another to form a very efficient and powerful
multi-stage blower.
THEORETICAL CAPACITY OF FANS
With an understanding of the effect of various factors
and components it is possible to calculate the theoretical
capacity of any fan given the size of the wheel and its
speed. Since no fan is 100% efficient there must be an
allowance for slippage and for internal losses due to friction. To do this, we multiply theoretical results by a factor of 80%, which is called the coefficient of discharge.
A practical formula for calculating fan capacity is
the product of the blast area multiplied by the discharge
velocity giving a theoretical capacity, which is then multiplied by the coefficient of discharge.
C = B x V x D
where
C
B
V
D
=
=
=
=
capacity in cubic feet per minute
blast area in square feet (B = DW/3)
velocity in feet per minute
coefficient of discharge (.8)
23
Given a 10" diameter wheel 3" wide at 1725 RPM,
what will be its theoretical capacity?
The blast area is
For these calculations it is reasonable to approximate the blast area as .07 square feet.
The peripheral velocity of the wheel is the product
of the circumference of the wheel multiplied by its speed.
A value of 4516 is close enough for these calculations.
4516 ft/min x 0.07 sq ft x 0.8 = 252.896 cu ft/min
Having already found the velocity pressure of a 10"
wheel at 1725 RPM to be 1.3" W.C. we can expect our
blower to deliver approximately 250 cubic feet per
minute at a velocity pressure of 1.3" W.C. against zero
static pressure. Output will be reduced as static pressure
increases until delivery stops at a static pressure of 1.3"
W.C. Resistance to flow can be at either inlet or outlet.
POWER REQUIRED
Since the nature and composition of air can differ so
greatly from time to time and from place to place, some
very complex formulas have been devised to calculate fan
power requirements. All of them are based upon the
standard horsepower of 33,000 foot-pounds per minute.
24
Modifying factors are introduced to take into account
temperature, humidity, barometer reading, etc. for most
work discussed here the basic expression is,
where
HP = horsepower required
C = volume of air in cubic feet per minute
h = pressure in inches water column
E = efficiency which varies from .40 to .60
If the value of C is stated in cubic feet per second the
formula is then,
HP = C x h x 5.2
550 x E
This is because
The formula can be further simplified if the efficiency factor is assumed to be .50.
550 X 0.50 = 275
We can plug this new value into our formula:
HP =
C x h x 5.2
275
25
Applying the formula to our 10" x 3" wheel at
1725 RPM, which delivers approximately 250 CFM at
1.3" W.C. pressure we have,
Since, .125 equals 1/8, we will need slightly less than
1/8 hp to power this fan.
Now we have a reasonable idea of what to expect
from a fan wheel of given size, and how much power it
will require to run it at the speed to give desired delivery.
We also know how to modify its behavior. It will be a
relatively simple matter to build a fan with a variable inlet and outlet size in order to find optimum delivery. A
variety of wheels can be used and the wheel center can be
moved within the housing to vary the cut-off point
clearance.
After discussing some construction methods and
materials, we can look at some simple equipment for
testing and evaluation that will be a help in achieving an
ideal design for specific jobs at hand.
26
C H A P T E R
III
CONSTRUCTION METHODS
AND MATERIALS
While the various parts of a fan can be made of many
commercial materials, only a few can be considered for
use in small home shops. Wood, including plywood,
composition boards, plastics and sheet metal can all be
formed with simple tools and limited skills. Fiberglass
with polyester resin, such as used for boat building and
auto body repairs might offer some interesting possibilities if cost is not a consideration. If the fan must move
only air at normal temperature, plywood, composition
board or light sheet metal will be adequate. These materials are very easy to work.
If abrasive materials, corrosive fumes or high temperatures are involved, the fan may have to be built entirely of metal, and some parts may have to have a protective coating of some type. If high velocity and pressure
are required, a heavier metal must be used, and construction might entail welding or brazing.
WHEEL CONSTRUCTION
The wheel, or rotor, is the first consideration in any fan.
In a commercially built fan it might be a casting in metal,
a plastic molding, a die stamping or possibly a welded
assembly. It might also be a combination of stamped,
cast or molded parts assembled with screws, bolts, rivets
or other means. In the small limited shop it is probably
most practical to build the wheel of sheet metal and to
27
join the members with bolts, rivets or by welding or brazing.
The simplest wheel to build is the straight radial
vane type. All others can be considered a variation of it.
Since the dual inlet squirrel cage fan is so easily found in
surplus or salvage, it makes little sense to construct such
a wheel. In this manual we'll discuss only the single inlet
exhauster or pressure fan.
The components of a simple open-sided wheel are a
disc of metal for the back plate, a hub and some vanes
with a flange for fastening to the back plate with bolts,
screws or rivets. My favorite fasteners for light duty
wheels are "pop rivets" because they are easily installed
from one side with the tool and they will not work loose
as bolts or screws may. I use steel rivets in all but the
lightest duty wheels since they are much stronger than
aluminum. Of course heavy duty wheels should be
assembled with solid hammer set rivets or by welding.
AN OPEN SIDED WHEEL ASSEMBLED WITH HOLLOW RIVETS
28
The hub can be a standard set-screw collar, a small
pulley or the hub from a discarded fan wheel found in
salvage. If the fan is to be belt-driven rather than
mounted directly on the motor shaft a threaded arbor
such as those used for saws and grinders can be used for
mounting. There are also threaded motor shaft adaptors
available in either right or left handed threads.
Universal fan hubs can be had from some professional heating and air-conditioning suppliers. These hubs
are fitted with set screws and are bored to fit standard
shaft sizes. Some are made with milled keyway. They are
drilled and tapped for three or more screws that are used
to mount the back plate on the hub. A set screw collar or
a discarded pulley can be modified by drilling and tapping the screw holes.
29
AN 8" OPEN SIDED WHEEL
All layout work should be done carefully with a sharp
scriber. Attempt to make everything as precise and symmetrical as possible to avoid later balancing problems. If
a brake is not available, flanges on the vanes can be bent
in a vise or by clamping between two heavy bars of
metal. All holes should be carefully center punched
before drilling.
To make the wheel backplate draw an 8" circle on
sheet metal with a compass or dividers. A horizontal line
is then drawn exactly through the center. Next, a vertical
line is drawn through the center of the circle at exact right
angles to the horizontal line. At this point, the circle is
divided into four equal segments.
By drawing two additional diagonal lines through
the center we will have divided the circle into eight equal
parts. Next, locate the mounting holes by using a compass or dividers to mark each of the eight radial lines 2"
from the center and 3-1/2" from the center. Center
punch carefully, and drill sixteen 1/8" holes.
Center punch the center hole carefully and drill to
1/2" or to the size of your arbor. If the center hole is
drilled off center, the fan will probably be useless. At the
very least, the fan will be difficult to balance. I recommend starting with a small hole and enlarging it progressively with larger bits rather than to attempt to drill it to
full size in a single step. A tapered repairman's reamer
can be used if you don't have larger bits, or you can carefully scribe the center bore with the dividers and file to
the line with a round file.
Now, cut out the backplate. Sheet metal of moderate weight, up to 24 gauge, can be cut with snips. Compound lever snips, or aviation snips, can cut up to 22
gauge iron with considerable effort and fatique. A
variable speed electric jig saw with a metal-cutting blade
works quite well on heavy sheet metal up to 16 gauge.
Heavier plate might best be cut with a torch or a metalcutting band saw. A stroll through the local scrap metal
yard might turn up a disc of nicely stamped heavy sheet
metal that will save a lot of labor.
30
If the backplate is to be mounted on a hub, the hub
itself can be used as a drilling template while centered
upon the plate with a shaft through both the hub and the
plate. You can use drills which can pass through the tapped holes in the hub but do not damage the threads. Use
the holes in the hub as a template to drill the holes in the
backplate. Next, enlarge these holes so that the screws
can pass through the backplate and into the tapped hub
holes. In this way, you are assured that mounting holes
will line up with the purchased hub. A reinforcing washer
can be used at each hole to stiffen the plate if necessary.
Drill only one hole in each vane mounting flange,
and mark the center of the second hole with a sharply
scribed line on the flange. Fasten the vane to the backplate with one rivet. Next, locate the center line of the
second hole through the hole in the plate. Clamp the
flange to the plate, and drill the second hole. It is unlikely
that both pairs of holes could be precisely drilled in any
other way with the ordinary hand tools in a small shop.
31
If you are building a double-plate, steel pressure
wheel, both plates should be drilled together to assure
uniformity, symmetry, and ease of assembly.
32
BALANCING THE WHEEL
Careful layout, cutting, drilling and assembly will result
in a wheel with near-perfect balance, satisfactory for
operation at moderate speeds. Larger and faster wheels
will need to be balanced to reduce vibration at speed.
Equipment for dynamic balancing such as used to
spin-balance auto tires is beyond consideration in small
shops. Fortunately, it is easy to build a set of "balancing
ways" with which to test the static balance of wheels and
other simple forms. The object is to create a pair of
perfectly smooth and level ways upon which to rest the
arbor, or axle, of the wheel. If the wheel is out of
balance, it will roll as gravity pulls the heavy area to the
lowest point.
To balance, simply add weight to the point opposite
the heavy area; that is, to the highest area. Or you can
drill holes on the heavy side to remove the undesired
weight. When the wheel is in balance it will rest in any
position upon the ways without turning.
33
The most important parts of the balancing ways are
the edges upon which the arbor will rest. They must be as
thin as possible, truly flat and truly level. Although it
would be best to have sharp edges that are hardened and
ground true, I was able to build an excellent pair of ways
by using a pair of 6" rigid stainless steel rules. Being only
.046" thick, their edges are nearly as frictionless as a
sharp edge. They are quite hard and durable, and the
edges are ground very smooth. A few passes with a fine
stone will remove any burrs or minute roughness.
Although I used very cheap rules rejected because of errors in numbering, I designed the mounting system so
that should expensive, top-quality rules be used, they
would not be damaged in any way.
Since the remaining parts of the balancing ways can
be built from common scrap, the total cost will be very
low in any event. Of course, the design can be scaled up
or down. The one detailed here will easily test a 24" x
5-1/2" wheel that is mounted on a 3/4" arbor.
Welding is the preferred method of joining the
frame parts, but rivets or bolts can be used also. The
assembly must be rigid so that it will remain solid and
level once adjusted.
A look at the sketch will reveal most of the details.
An opposing pair of side frames are made of 1/8" x 1"
angle iron. The pivots for the ways supports can be
riveted or welded to the frames. The joint should be
snugly riveted but free enough so that the weight of the
support will operate it without binding as the leveling
screws are adjusted. The 6" steel rules are fastened to the
ways supports with short 1/4" cap screws and washers
with half-washers used to hold the surface of the washers
snug against the rule.
After both frames are mounted on an 8" square of
3/4" plywood with 1/4" x 1" flat-head machine
screws, the holes for the base leveling bolts can be drilled.
Note that a slot is cut in the end of each of the leveling
bolts with a hacksaw so that they can be adjusted from
the top with a screwdriver.
34
An accurate level is needed to set up the balancing
ways. I use the one built into my machinist's square.
Although it is not a precision level, it works very well
when used with care.
There are significant differences in the quality and
accuracy of levels, differences not always perceptible to
the naked eye. A magnifying glass is usually helpful in
reading a poorer quality level.
A level can be tested by reversing it upon a level surface. If it reads the same in both directions, it is true.
First, the base of the balancing ways is adjusted so
that the unit rests solidly on the bench. If the bench is not
rigid, work on the floor. Simply adjust the base legs until
35
the whole assembly appears to rest reasonably level in
both directions. There can be absolutely no wobble.
Next, by turning the adjusting screws to raise or
lower each support and by testing with your bubble level,
adjust each way separately until both are truly level.
Finally, rest a truly straight arbor across the ways,
and test it with the bubble level. A final adjustment is
made in the base legs to bring the arbor to level.
36
The best arbor for testing is a length of ground and
polished shaft, but clean, smooth cold-rolled steel round
will work. Hot-rolled bar stock or cheap shafting that
has been plated will not be reliable. Any flat spot or
roughness on the shaft or ways will destroy accuracy.
The ultimate accuracy of the balancing ways
depends upon their being truly level in all directions,
although surprisingly good results can be had even if the
ways are not quite true.
37
FORMING THE HOUSING SCROLL
A commercially built fan housing might be cast metal,
molded plastic, sheet metal assembled by spot welding or
other means, or sheet metal die-stamped and assembled.
Occasionally, you may find a discarded commercial
housing and modify it to accommodate a custom, homebuilt wheel. In most such cases, you would make the
housing narrower and reduce the size of the inlet and
outlet.
Most often it will be best to build the entire housing
from scratch. Plywood used with a composition board
like Masonite, in combination with sheet metal is a very
convenient material with which to form a housing when
moving room-temperature air. These materials will probably not be adequate for other gases and temperatures.
BUILDING A PLYWOOD HOUSING
FOR AN EXHAUST FAN
Two rectangles of plywood of 1/2" to 3/4" thickness
will provide a solid support for both the scroll housing
and the motor drive, whether it be a belt drive or a direct
drive with the wheel mounted directly on the motor
shaft.
The scroll sides can easily be cut from 1/8" Masonite and mounted on the plywood side supports with small
screws. These sides act as a form around which a band of
sheet metal is wrapped. Four or five carriage bolts pull
the two plywood side supports together clamping the
sheet metal scroll between them.
Since most standard motor shafts will probably be
too short to reach through the full thickness of the support and the scroll for direct drive of the wheel, one side
of the plywood side supports will need a large circle cut
into it to allow part of the motor housing to extend
somewhat into the fan housing.
Notice in the sketches that the center cut-out for
motor clearance is only through the back support. The
38
39
scroll form of 1/8" Masonite is drilled in the center only
for the motor shaft.
To permit installation of the wheel on the shaft,
another large circle will have to be cut on the inlet side
through which the wheel can be slipped onto the shaft.
An adapter is installed over the inlet side hole to reduce
the inlet opening to the correct size.
A motor or arbor support can be built from plywood and dimension lumber. The dimensions of the
motor support can be determined by examining the
motor to be used, or from the arbor if a belt drive is to be
used.
The discharge opening can be converted from the
rectangular shape as constructed to the more standard
round pipe shape with a light sheet metal fitting.
A handle of pipe or dowel can be added to make the
unit easier to move.
A switch mounted in a standard electrical box
should be installed for safety and convenience. Be sure
the wiring is of adequate size for the amount of current
drawn. Use a three-wire grounded plug on portable fans.
Be very careful to protect yourself and others from electrical shock. Many people are
accidentally electro40
cuted every year. Ask for professional help if you are not
fully confident of your own ability and knowledge.
The photo is of a 9" x 3" fan driven by a 1/4 hp
motor that does very nicely as an exhaust fan for
welding. The inlet is 5" diameter and the discharge is 3".
MAKING AN ALL METAL HOUSING
We may need to move gases other than air that are corrosive, gases that carry abrasive materials suspended in
them, gases of high temperature and/or humidity. In
such cases, the fan housing should be metal.
It is not as difficult to form a sheet metal housing
with ordinary hand tools as might first be imagined.
In most cases light sheet metal will be used, but if a
very strong welded assembly is required, consider using
16 gauge or heavier metal. A heavy metal housing may
need welding which is no problem if you have the equipment and the skill. Even metal as light as 22 gauge can be
arc welded, although it is likely to warp and buckle.
The general layout method is the same for all scrolls
but a margin must be added to the profile when lighter
sheet metal is used so that a seam can be made. If the
housing must be absolutely air-tight, the seam can be soldered or brazed. It may also be acceptable to use a caulking material so long as it will withstand temperature and
other operating conditions.
Steel sheet metal as heavy as 22 gauge can reasonably be cut with aviation pattern snips which are made in
both right and left hand cut as well as straight cut. You
need at least the right and left hand snips if you hope to
produce a smooth cut. The left hand snips do approximately the same thing as the straight cut snips if you
must economize. It is the compound lever action of these
snips that makes it possible to cut heavier metal with
them. By using the right and left hand snips alternately
the waste can be curled away so that the cut may advance.
Pliers may have to be used to pry the waste away
when heavy metal is being cut. The cut will be much
41
smoother if you do not permit the blades to close at the
tip. Rather, re-open the snips, and take a fresh bite just
before they close entirely so that the metal won't be deformed leaving a jagged point. With patience and practice you'll be able to produce smooth cuts.
If a smooth exterior surface is important for any
reason, then the addendum for the seam should be added
to the profile. The addendum can be added to the shell,
but the final appearance will not be as pleasing.
It is a simple matter to turn a flange on the profile if
a turning or edging machine is available, but such equip42
ment is usually not available in the home shop. Although
a bit tedious, a simple flange can be formed with pliers,
hammer and anvil. The secret of success lies in raising the
flange gradually.
First, bend the flange up about 20 degrees with the
pliers all the way around. Make a second pass with the
pliers to raise the flange a bit beyond 45 degrees.
A third pass can be made with the pliers, or you can
then begin to finish the job with hammer and anvil. The
anvil can be any piece of metal that has more mass and
weight than the hammer and that will fit inside the curve
of the flange. A casual stroll through the scrap metal
yard will turn up something appropriate: a small flywheel, cast iron pulley, a short piece cut from a bar of 2"
or 3" round. An old flat iron such as grandma used to
iron grandpa's Sunday shirt makes an excellent anvil for
such work. Although the flange will be rough and wavey
at first, you will soon learn how to strike it just right to
cold forge it smoothly against the anvil.
43
An alternate method of forging the flange is to cut
notches in the addendum so that tabs from 3/8" to 1/2"
wide are formed. Then each alternate tab can be bent at
right angles to form a support for the shell and then the
remaining tabs are bent over the shell to complete the
seam. When carefully done the appearance can be quite
good and such a seam can be made tight by soldering or
brazing.
While either the flange or tab seam might be the
most attractive, both are tedious to form by hand. Since
appearance is usually not important in a fan housing, we
can use the easier method of putting the flange on the
shell instead of the scroll profile. In doing so, most of the
time-consuming labor is eliminated.
By forming up the shell so that the flange faces outwards, a convenient surface for assembly is formed. In
44
addition there will be no screw ends inside the housing. If
light sheet metal is used, it will be easy to use machine
screws and nuts for assembly instead of self-tapping
sheet metal screws. When turned to the outside the flange
must stretch to conform to the curve of the scroll instead
of compressing and puckering as happens when turned to
45
the inside. This method produces a very neat and practical fan housing for most purposes.
A 3/8" wide seam is a convenient width with which
to work. Twice this width, or 3/4", must be added to
overall width of the housing to provide two flanges. The
scroll profiles are layed out with a 3/8" addendum all
around so that they will fit over the flanges on the shell.
The shell is rolled around a plywood form made to the
size of the scroll.
One side of the scroll can be permanently sealed by
riveting, soldering, brazing, or caulking. The other side
should be attached with self-tapping screws or machine
screws and nuts to allow removal in the event repairs are
needed. A gasket must be installed on this removable side
if an air-tight seal is necessary.
DISCHARGE FITTINGS
Since the discharge opening of the fan will be rectangular
and since many applications require round pipe fittings,
46
it will probably be necessary to attach a transition fitting
to the discharge opening.
It may be acceptable in some cases to simply fit a
plate with a short round collar over the discharge opening. It is a simple matter to cut a round hole in the plate
and to install a collar by notching the edge and folding
tabs.
A formal transition piece is easy to make and will
offer less friction to the air. Not only that, it will look
better. There are some applications where a formal transition fitting must be used. It is well worth the effort to
learn the simple yet fascinating layout procedure called
"triangulation." Once you have mastered the process
you can produce neat sheet metal transition fittings for
any purpose.
The only problem with triangulation is that the procedure looks complicated at first glance. But it isn't.
Since the average pattern layout time is less than 15 minutes per fitting, you know the procedure can't be too
awfully difficult.
TAB COLLAR
TRANSITION
TRIANGULATION
As the name of the process implies, triangulation is a
process of solving a series of triangles in order to find the
true length of the lines from their apparent lengths as
seen in a plan view of the transition piece.
47
Notice that in the isometric view of a transition on
page 49 that a number of triangles are seen contained
within the shape of the transition body. The lines that extend from the lettered corners of the rectangular base to
the numbered points on the circular part are actually the
bending lines.
If you already had on hand a transition of the correct size, it would be a simple matter to measure the lines
and progressively lay out a pattern for a duplicate on a
piece of sheet metal. Such is not usually the case, though.
Believe it or not, it is actually easier to take the dimensions from a full size plan view than it would be to take
them from an existing transition.
Because lines are not usually drawn on a transition
piece, you must learn to visualize them in your mind. In
your first attempts actually drawing the lines will probably help you develop the pattern, but as you master this
simple art, you will find the lines are not necessary.
On page 49 is an isometric view of a transition piece
we'll attempt to layout as an example. Below it is the pattern needed to form up that shape.
The seam, two sides of the base, and a portion of the
circular collar are not visible in the isometric view. Fortunately, invisible parts are identical to those we can see.
The isometric view has no value in the layout process
since none of its dimensions are of true length. It only
helps us visualize the shape of the figure we will lay out.
Notice that the same triangles contained in the isometric
shape are seen also in the full pattern.
The top plan view shows the true circular size as well
as the true size of the base rectangle. The circular part is
divided into eight equal parts which are numbered for
reference. The corners of the rectangular base are lettered, and the location of the seam is indicated by the
dotted line from "S" to point 7 on the circular collar.
If the transition were cut from point "S" to point 7
and flattened out, you would have the full pattern
stretched out in front of you. We'll do this cutting and
flattening in our imagination as we transfer dimensions
48
49
one at a time from the top plan view to the full pattern.
The result is called "the stretchout."
Above the top plan view is a side elevation view
drawn full size. To its right is an end elevation view. Because neither of these views are used in the layout procedure, it is not necessary to draw them each time you lay
out a pattern. They are provided to help you see the
figure from all useful angles.
Notice that only a very few dimensions in the side
and end elevations are true in length. In pattern layout
practice only the height is taken from the side or end
elevation, and all other dimensions are taken from the
top plan view. It is not necessary to draw the views to
know the height, but the top plan view must be drawn,
and its circular part divided.
Every dimension seen in the top plan view is true,
but some of them actually represent the base of a triangle. Because neither the vertical leg of the triangle or
its hypotenuse can be seen in the top plan view, a "solution triangle" is needed to transfer a few of the dimensions to the full pattern.
This sounds confusing, but it is not at all difficult in
practice. Absolutely no mathematics is involved, and you
do not even have to understand Pythagorian theorem to
solve the triangles. We simply draw a duplicate triangle
and take the dimension of its hypotenuse from the duplicate with the dividers or compass.
All triangles are made up of three sides and three
angles. A right triangle always contains a 90-degree angle
between two sides. If you draw a duplicate of an existing
triangle such that base and vertical dimensions of both
are the same, then the hypotenuses will also be identical.
Each of the lines in the isometric view and the full
pattern extending from the corners of the rectangular
base to the circular part, such as A-1, B-1, and D-4, is actually the hypotenuse of a triangle. The same lines seen in
the top plan view are much foreshortened because they
are being viewed from an angle. If we could remove these
foreshortened lines, we would see the base of the
50
triangle. The base is seen in true length since we are viewing it "straight on" and not at an angle.
The height of all of the triangles in this instance are
the same. Since the vertical line that represents the height
of the triangle is merely a dot in the top plan view, we
must take the true height from the end or side elevation.
It is now a simple matter to draw a duplicate triangle
on another piece of paper with the base length taken
from the top plan view, and the height taken from the
side or end elevation.
For example, the distance from A to 1 in the top
plan view represents the base of a right triangle the height
of which is H in the end elevation. The hypotenuse of
this triangle is the true length we use to lay out the pattern. Each of the true dimensions we will need is found in
the same way.
You don't need to draw a new triangle for every
triangle that must be solved. You can draw a straight
horizontal line that is longer than any of the dimensions
you'll be working with in the top plan view, and let it
serve as the base line. Next, draw a vertical line at exactly
right angles to it with exactly the same height as the transition piece. This single " L " shape drawing can be used
for all the solution triangles since all of them are right
triangles with the same heights but with different base
lengths. For the sake of clarity, let's call this " L " our
solution jig.
Notice that the height does not include an allowance
for a joint at the base or at the collar end of the transition.
When the apparent length of any of the dimensions
in question is applied to the base its true length can be
easily measured as seen in the sample on page 49. For instance, if the dimension A 1 is taken from the top plan
view and transferred to the base of " L " shape solution
jig, then the true length of A1 is hypotenuse. We can lay
out dimension A2 taken from the top plan view of the
solution jig, and find its true length by measuring the
hypotenuse. We use the solution jig over and over. There
51
is no need to construct a new one each time.
In practice, once you've put the dimension on the
base of the solution jig, you don't need to actually
measure the hypotenuse. Use dividers or a compass to
move dimensions from the top plan view to the solution
jig base line. The length of the hypotenuse which represents the true length can be transferred to the growing
full pattern with the same dividers or compass. It takes
much longer to describe the process than it does to perform it.
Now compare the lengths of the line drawn from the
corner marked A to the point on the circle marked 3 as it
appears in the various views on page 49. Notice that its
length is different in each of the views. That is because
line A3 is not shown in its true length in any of these
views. The full pattern length of A3 must be the true
length.
The length from A to 3 on the top plan view is
transferred to the base line of our solution jig. We draw
in the hypotenuse to form a solution triangle. The length
of the hypotenuse is the true length of line A3. It is this
length that is transferred with dividers to the full pattern.
The process is actually that simple.
Each of the bending lines seen on the isometric view
from the lettered corners to the numbered points on the
circular collar is actually the hypotenuse of a triangle, the
base length of which is clearly seen in true dimension in
the top plan view. As you look straight down at the
triangles from above you can see only the length of the
base. It is a simple matter to transfer that apparent
dimension to the solution triangle to find the true dimension in its hypotenuse.
A practice exercise will help to make it all very clear.
You need a clean piece of paper, compass or divider, a
ruler and a pencil. A draftsman's triangle is useful to
draw the corners and the solution triangle at true right
angles. But for heaven's sake, don't panic. The work is
not exact or demanding of any artistic talent.
First, we need a top plan view. Draw a rectangle to
52
represent the base of the transition piece as seen from
above. The illustration on page 49 happens to be 2" long
and 3/4" wide, but you can use any dimension that is
convenient.
Use the compass or dividers to draw the circle exactly in the center of the rectangle. The circle in the illustration is 1" diameter. You can locate the circular part off
center in actual applications, but in this exercise doing so
just makes it a little more work to develop the pattern
because each dimension is unique. Divide the circle
through its center both vertically and horizontally and
then divide each of its quarters exactly in two to make up
8 equal divisions.
Letter the corners, and number the divisions. Draw
lines from each of the corners to the nearest point on the
circular collar to indicate the bases of the triangles from
which the true lengths of the bending lines will be found.
Draw a horizontal line that is longer than any of the
base lines. Next, draw a vertical line at a right angle to it.
The height of this vertical line must be the same as the
true height of the transition piece. The height in the illustration is 1".
Now you have everything you need to lay out the
full pattern. We'll do it one step at a time, and it will not
take very long. You're risking nothing but a bit of paper
and a few minutes of time.
In practice, the distance between the points of division on the circle are not precisely true but are usually
close enough for ordinary work. There is also a very
slight error in the height of the triangle used to establish
points 1 and 5 on the full pattern, but the 1/32" error is
not large enough to justify drawing a second solution jig,
or solution triangle. For the purpose of this exercise you
can ignore such tiny errors.
The distances between the circular divisions and the
rectangular base dimensions can be transferred directly
from the top plan view to the full pattern layout.
The layout may be started with any length from the
base of the transition piece, although it is customary to
53
begin with the widest dimension whenever possible. To
start, simply draw a line as long as the length of line B to
A (BA). Make a tiny sharp punch mark at each end of
the line from which the compass or dividers can pivot.
The narrow flange that will be used to fasten the transition to the fan outlet can be added now if you like.
Points A and B are the first reference and pivot points in
the layout procedure.
Find the length of A1 on the top plan view, and apply it to the base line of the solution jig. Draw in a hypotenuse to form the solution triangle. The length of the
hypotenuse is the true length of A1. Spread the dividers,
putting each point on one end of the hypotenuse. To
transfer this true length to the full pattern, use the punch
mark at A as the pivot point and scribe a short arc with
the free divider point. Since B\ is the same length, use the
same divider separation and point B as the pivot to scribe
a second arc. Make this second arc intersect the first. The
point of intersection of these arcs establishes point 1 of
the circular part of the pattern.
Set the dividers on the distance between 1 and 2 on
the top plan view, and scribe short arcs to represent
points 2 and 8 on the pattern layout. Draw a solution triangle to find the true length of line A2 in the top plan
view. Using both A and B as pivots, scribe arcs with the
true radius A2 intersect with arcs 2 and 8 on the pattern layout.
54
It should now be obvious that pattern development
is not much more difficult than a child's "connect-thedot" puzzle. As you might expect, the next step is to
scribe short arcs to represent points 3 and 7. Then draw a
solution triangle using the apparent length of A3 to get
the true length of A3. Note that A3 and B7 are the same
length in this example. Points 7 and 3 on the full pattern
are formed at the intersection of the arcs. At this point
one half of the circular collar portion of the pattern is
complete.
Now it is necessary to transfer the end dimensions of
the rectangular transition piece base so that the circular
part can be advanced. The dimension SB is taken directly
from the top plan view and is transferred by scribing a
short arc to the left of pivot point B on the pattern
layout. Draw a solution triangle to find the true length of
S7 using the apparent length taken from the top plan
view. Set the dividers to this true length. Using point 7 on
the pattern layout as a pivot, scribe a short arc intersecting the arc drawn from point B.
55
Sooner or later, you will need to add an addendum
at the base for the joint and at the left hand edge for the
seam. You may wish to make that addition now.
In the same way that SB was developed, the dimension of AD is transferred directly from the top plan view
to the pattern. The true length of D3 is found and is used
to scribe an arc intersecting with the AD arc to establish
point D on the pattern layout.
The full pattern is now completed by simply following these procedures to lay out the remaining triangles
seen on the top plan view. After you have worked your
way around the top plan view, you will have a full pattern in which the full circle and all four sides of the rectangular base have been established.
With the collar centered in the top plan view, the
transition piece is symmetrical. You could save time by
laying out half a pattern, cutting two, and assembling the
halves. You save layout time, but increase your assembly
time. This option exists only for symmetrical transition
pieces.
56
57
The triangulation method works well with many
shapes and configurations that may prove very useful in
forming hoods, dust collectors, and other fittings in your
shop. A few are illustrated on page 57.
MOTOR AND DRIVE APPLICATIONS
The simplest and most economical way to drive a fan is
to mount the wheel directly on the motor shaft, eliminating the need for bearings, additional shafts, pulleys,
belts, etc. If you are building a fan for a specific job, and
the air requirement is constant, a direct drive fan is usually the best choice.
In some applications it may be necessary to change
the fan speed from time to time, or the motor on hand
may not be of the correct speed, or its shaft or bearings
may not be substantial enough to support the wheel
directly. In such cases a belt drive is always best.
Pillow block bearings are available in many sizes
and grades. Ball bearings are generally considered superior to sleeve bearings but they are also more costly. When
properly installed and lubricated, sleeve bearings will last
many years in intermittant service as in the home shop.
There are some very convenient and durable "sawarbors" available that offer a pair of bearings, pulley,
and a shaft with a threaded end, heavy washers, and nut.
Such an arbor makes mounting a fan wheel quite easy.
58
A simple framework of wood or metal is all that is
needed to mount the motor or the motor and belt-drive
to the fan housing. Some motors have studs at the drive
end that provide a convenient way to mount to the fan
housing. Brackets can be fitted to the motor, too. Combinations of these two approaches may have to be used to
mount a peculiarly designed motor.
Pulley sizes for a belt drive are easily worked out by
simple calculations. The product of the driving pulley
diameter multiplied by its speed in RPM will always be
equal to the product of the driven pulley diameter
multiplied by its speed in RPM.
For example, a 3" motor pulley at 1725 RPM will
drive a 1-1/2" fan pulley at 3450 RPM.
3 X 1725 = 5175
Since 1-1/2 x RPM must also equal 5175,
RPM
=
RPM =
product
pulley diameter
5175
1-1/2
= 3450
If you have a fan that must run at 3450 RPM and a
motor that runs at 1725 RPM, you need to know what
size pulleys to apply. Since the fan must run faster than
the motor, the fan pulley must be smaller than the motor
pulley. Select a pulley for the fan from those you have on
hand, suppose a 1-1/2" diameter. Multiply its diameter
by the desired speed.
1-1/2 x 3450 = 5175
Then divide the product by the speed of the motor to get
the correct pulley size for the motor.
59
Divide the greater speed by the lesser speed to get the
speed ratio. The ratio of pulley diameters must be the
same. In the example above the ratio was two to one. The
fan speed is twice the motor speed, and the motor pulley
is twice the diameter of the fan pulley. You could combine a 4" driving pulley with a 2" driven pulley for the
same effect, or any combination of pulleys so long as
their diameters are of the correct ratio.
Obviously, the calculations work exactly the same
when a speed reduction is required. A 1-1/2" motor
pulley at 3450 RPM will drive a 3" fan pulley at 1725
RPM.
60
61
C H A P T E R
IV
Fan Testing and Air Measurement
MEASURING AIR
So far, we have designed a centrifugal fan with a 10" x
3" wheel to run at 1725 RPM and deliver 250 cubic feet
of air per minute at a pressure of 1.3" water column.
Such a fan can be built and successfully applied to a job
without adjustment or modification. Some applications,
however, will require more accurate control of air
volume and pressure. Some means of measuring these attributes will be needed.
Although air may seem intangible, it has weight and
mass. Air is usually described in terms of its pressure,
velocity and volume of flow, of which pressure is most
easily measured. Since there is a relationship between
pressure, velocity, and volume, the unknown values can
be calculated once the pressure is known.
Very sensitive, accurate instruments have been developed for laboratory use, but these are not usually
found in the small shop because of their high price. Fortunately, it is easy to build simple measuring equipment
of sufficient accuracy for our needs. We can make all of
the measurements we need with a simple manometer,
pitot tube and orifice. We need no other equipment.
Sometimes the exact composition of air must be
considered during fan design. Much of what has been
learned in fan design can be found in engineering formulas and tables. For most of our needs we can use
63
"standard air," which is what you and I breathe at a
temperature of 68 degrees Fahrenheit, a relative humidity
of 50%, and a barometer reading of 29.92" of mercury.
Such standard air weighs approximately .075 pounds per
cubic foot, and it is composed of approximately 20% oxygen and 80% nitrogen by volume, with very small
amounts of other gases and pollutants.
As air's density and weight varies with its temperature and humidity, its behavior in a fan system will vary.
Cold air is more dense, and thus heavier, so a fan will
deliver a greater weight or quantity of air when it is cold
than when it is warm. Racing auto engines and airplane
engines develop more power in cold air because there is
more oxygen in a given volume of cold air than in hot air.
It will require more power to deliver cold air, and this can
be a significant factor.
In an application where a fan is to provide air to a
furnace, we don't have exotic equipment to weigh the air.
The best we can do is provide a fan with excess capacity,
adjusting its delivery with a simple gate or shutter at the
intake when observing the nature of the flame. In this
way we dispense with the need for expensive, complex
equipment and the technical formulas required to interpret and apply the readings.
THE " U " TUBE MANOMETER
Although fans can be built to deliver very high pressures
sometimes needed by industry, most fans develop low
pressures, usually below one pound per square inch.
Mechanical gauges are available to indicate these low
pressures but they are very costly. Most of us could not
justify even a moderately priced gauge for the home
shop. Fortunately, an expensive gauge is unnecessary. A
simple manometer will do.
A " U " tube manometer displays the effect of pressure on a column of liquid within a transparent tube.
When the tube is filled with water, it is called a "water
gauge." One ounce of pressure will raise the water column 1.73 inches. If the tube were filled with mercury
64
which is much more dense than water, the same one
ounce of pressure would raise the mercury column just
.127 inches. Water is obviously the correct gauge liquid
for our low pressure needs.
A manometer is simply a transparent tube that is
formed in the shape of a " U " and that is partially filled
with water. When pressure is applied to either leg of the
65
gauge, the water is forced down in one leg and up an
equal amount in the other. The difference between the
level of the water in both legs provides a reading of the
pressure applied.
A simple direct reading scale can be prepared by
mounting a scale of sequentially numbered marks at
1/2" intervals next to one leg. A half-inch rise in one leg
would be a 1" difference since the other leg will move a
1/2" in the other direction.
A very durable and accurate water gauge can be
made with clear plastic tubing and other common materials. Most commercial manometers use a tube with an internal diameter of 3/16" to 1/4" although other sizes are
sometimes used. Inexpensive clear plastic tubing with a
bore of 1/4" and an outside diameter of 3/8" is readily
available in most hardware stores. Not only does it make
an excellent gauge, but it also serves as a convenient connecting hose to the pitot tube or the gauge port in the fan
system.
It is important to minimize distortion in the "U"
bend of the manometer. Since plastic tubing is soft and
flexible, it requires an accurately-made mounting to
mold the bend and to hold the legs erect. With 3/8" thick
wood and simple hardware, a mount can be built that
provides a uniformly shaped channel of 3/8" width into
which the tubing can be pressed.
All of the elements of a water gauge are shown in the
drawing on page 65. The wooden form provides a snug
channel into which the tubing is pressed. A fender washer
and wood screw hold the tubing in place at the bottom
end while a simple sheet metal cap with holes for the
1/4" copper tubing holds the manometer tube in the
mount. In addition to anchoring the manometer tube in
the mount, the copper tubing also provides a convenient
connection for the hose to the pitot tube or test port. A
simple scale marked out on sheet aluminum that is bent
around the body of the mount to a snug sliding fit
enables you to "zero" the gauge before use. If each
numbered increment is 1/2" then the readings indicated
are 1" of water column.
66
Dimensions for a wooden form are suggested on
page 67. Although a 3/8" channel could be routed out, it
is probably easier to make the form in 3 pieces and join
them with brads and glue. A coat of clear varnish just
before the tube is finally pressed in will make the whole
unit more durable and attractive. A small amount of
food coloring in the water makes the column more visible. Although laboratory practice sometimes calls for
distilled water to be used, our colored tap water will not
affect the accuracy of our casual measurements.
The readings of the manometer in inches of water
column are converted to ounces per square inch by
dividing by 1.73. A scale can be prepared to read directly
in ounces per square inch with major divisions at 55/64"
intervals since 1.73" of water column is equal to 1 ounce
67
per square inch. The readings in ounces per square inch
are converted to inches of water by multiplying by .58.
(You must divide 1.73 by 2 because one side of the
manometer rises while the other falls. The difference between .865 and 55/64 is about .006"—insignificant in our
work.)
MEASURING PRESSURE
Soon after you build the manometer, you will discover
how sensitive it is. If you connect a hose to either leg and
blow gently at the end of the hose, the opposite column
will rise. Although some commercial manometers are
graduated finely enough to read even very tiny pressures,
we need not be concerned with anything finer than 1/8"
water column.
We have already discussed the three types of pressure found in a fan system: velocity pressure, static pressure, and dynamic pressure. Of these, velocity pressure is
the most useful for design work.
While the dynamic pressure is the source of both
static and velocity pressure, its measurement is of very
little use to us in testing. Since dynamic pressure acts only
in the direction of flow, you can read it by merely connecting a hose to the manometer and placing the opposite
end squarely into the air stream. This will be the highest
reading in the system since it indicates the total pressure.
Static pressure is the result of resistance to the
dynamic pressure, and it acts in all directions. It can be
read directly by placing the test hose anywhere in the
system where it will not receive the forward pressure of
the stream of air. The reading is normally taken from a
tap in the duct that is at right angles to the stream and
where no obstruction might deflect the stream into the
tap.
68
Dynamic pressure minus static pressure is velocity
pressure. When one leg of the water gauge is connected
to a port to read dynamic pressure and the other leg is
69
connected to a port to read the static pressure, the velocity pressure can be read directly from the manometer. The
static pressure and dynamic pressure oppose each other.
The difference, velocity pressure, is, in a sense,
calculated within the gauge.
THE PITOT TUBE
While two gauge ports might be the best idea when a
gauge is to be installed permanently in a system, a "pitot
tube" ("pee-toe tube") is the correct tool to use when a
number of fans or systems are to be evaluated. It is a
tube within a tube that applies both dynamic and static
pressure simultaneously to the water gauge.
70
Pitot tube construction and principle of operation is
simple. The 1/8" copper inner tube extends all the way
through the outer tube. When aimed into the air stream,
total dynamic pressure is delivered to one side of the
gauge by a hose connected to the lower end shown in the
construction view.
Notice that there are 8 small holes in the outer tube
3" from the rounded end at section A—A. Static pressure enters the large tube here and is applied to the other
side of the gauge through a hose connected to the tee.
The gauge will indicate the difference between dynamic
pressure and the static pressure which is the velocity pressure.
Although the specifications and dimensions given in
the drawing on page 70 differ slightly from official specifications for a laboratory grade pitot tube, the difference
71
in accuracy is negligible for our needs. If you need a laboratory grade instrument you can find exact specifications in engineering manuals.
For the outer tube 3/8" copper tubing is chosen
because the officially specified 5/16" tubing can be difficult to find. The 1/8" inner tubing may be hard to find
as well. I salvaged mine from a discarded thermocouple
taken from a gas furnace safety valve. Sometimes 1/8"
copper tubing can be found in refrigeration units or in
automotive oil pressure gauge connections. The 3/8" x
1/4" x 1/4" copper sweat tee is probably most easily
purchased from a commercial refrigeration supplier.
You'll need a nosepiece and a center support near
the ring of holes. These parts can be fabricated from
3/8" diameter brass or steel rod, plastic, or even wood
turned to shape on a small lathe or in a drill chuck. Metal
parts can be soldered, but you need an appropriate glue
for other materials.
It was easy to turn a brass nosepiece on my small
lathe and solder it into place.
Use new copper tubing if at all possible. Copper tubing gets very stiff with age and bending. You might have
a problem with the short radius bend if you use old tubing.
A propane torch provides ample heat for soldering
the joints. Clean the joints brightly, and use rosin core
solder or solid solder with rosin paste flux.
The eight 1/16" holes in the outer tube should be
spaced as equally as possible, and free of burrs both inside and out. Official specifications are for holes of not
less than .040" for most classes of work, but there is no
need to be that precise here.
Assembly is easy if you follow the correct sequence.
First, solder the 1/8" tubing about 1/4" into the
nosepiece. Solder the support piece in its proper location
on the 1/8" tubing. After drilling the 1/16" radial holes
in the 3/8" outer tubing, slip the inner tube assembly into the outer tube, and solder the nosepiece to the outer
tube.
There is no need to solder the support piece to the
72
outer tube, and to attempt to do so would probably make
a mess of the radial holes.
Next, solder the 1/4" tubes into the tee, and solder
the tee to the free end of the 3/8" outer tube. Now bend
the tubes around a 3/4" radius.
The 1/4" static pressure tube soldered to the tee
should face in the same direction as the nosepiece and
should be exactly parallel to it. You will not be able to see
the nose of the pitot tube when it is inserted into an air
stream. You'll be able to aim the nose by observing the
1/4" static pressure tube which will remain outside the
air flow.
The final step is to solder the 1/8" tube into the
1/4" tube so that there can be no leakage between the
outside of the surface of the 1/8" tube and the inside surface of the 1/4" tube. Polish the instrument brightly,
and give it a coat of clear lacquer.
TAKING PRESSURE READINGS
To read velocity pressure directly in any fan system, connect hoses from each of the 1/4" tubes to each leg of the
water gauge.
Adjust the manometer so that both legs are vertical.
Next adjust the scale so that zero is adjacent to the surface of the water in one leg. The meniscus, or curvature
of the surface of the water, must be taken into account.
Although the meniscus is slight in small tubes, it can be a
significant factor in larger diameter tubes. A water
meniscus is concave, but a mercury meniscus is convex.
WATER
MERCURY
73
When very precise readings are needed, in hundredths of an inch for instance, the meniscus can introduce substantial error. For our purposes it will be adequate to merely insure that you read consistently either at
the edge of the meniscus or at the base. Reading at the
base of the meniscus will usually give a more accurate
reading.
INTERPRETING AND APPLYING THE READINGS
When a fan system is equipped with gauge ports, each leg
of the manometer is connected to a port. The difference
between the static pressure in one leg and the dynamic
pressure in the other gives a reading of the velocity pressure. These ports are built into the system and cannot be
moved.
A pitot tube is mobile and can be moved about to indicate the pressure in various locations throughout the
system. Obviously, the permanent ports will indicate
pressure only at one point in the system, but the pressure
varies to some extent in every system.
Pressure variation is usually greatest in large crosssectional area duct systems. Usually, many readings are
taken as the pitot tube is moved to points on an imaginary grid on the duct cross section. The readings are added
together, and the total is divided by the number of
readings to give the average reading over the total area of
duct. In very small duct systems a single reading in one
location will be adequate.
If only a single pressure can be measured, static
pressure is desired over dynamic pressure.
74
Notice that the system shown on page 74 has an
orifice that resists air flow creating static pressure within
the duct. If a fan has sufficient capacity to deliver
enough air to fill the system and to produce a given static
pressure as air escapes through the orifice, the static
pressure created is an indication of the amount of work
being done.
This reading can provide a way of comparing fans.
A more powerful fan will produce a greater static pressure reading, while a weaker fan produces a lower
reading.
Once a system is working well, the static pressure
reading can be used as a standard, or benchmark, for
future operation. Should the system performance decline
or should the system be modified, this benchmark can
help in getting the system up and running again.
Except when used to measure pressure drop in air
traveling through an orifice or other metering device, the
static pressure reading is not useful in volume flow or
velocity calculations. Formulae for such calculations are
quite complex, and readings must be very accurate. The
equipment discussed here is not sensitive enough to be
useful for these calculations.
Sensitive pressure-actuated switches can be installed
in a system to light an indicator, sound a warning, shut
down the system or even make adjustments that will raise
or lower pressure. Static pressure, the force that operates these controls, can indicate whether or not a fan
is operating correctly.
A simple device called a "sail switch" can be installed in the air stream to do the work of the pressure
switch. It is simply a broad surface, usually thin plastic
stretched over a wire frame, that catches the moving air
much like the sail on a sailboat to actuate a mechanical
switch. Here, the dynamic pressure is the force that operates the sail switch.
In some instances the dynamic pressure reading
might represent the actual velocity pressure. Most often
static pressure is subtracted from dynamic pressure to
75
give velocity pressure, and this, in turn, is used for
volume flow calculations. When there is no significant
resistance to air flow (no static pressure) in a system, a
simple disc or propeller fan is usually the best choice.
Gauge ports can be installed in either the suction or
pressure half of a system. Since pressure is above atmospheric pressure on the pressure half of the system,
readings will be positive when one leg of the gauge is left
open to the atmosphere.
Readings in the suction half of the system will be
negative when one leg of the gauge is left open to the atmosphere since the pressure is below atmospheric pressure.
Readings taken with the pitot tube will be the same
whether in the suction or pressure duct when both legs of
the gauge are connected to give velocity pressure
readings. The velocity pressure reading will always be
positive when the inlet tube is pointed into the direction
of air flow.
PRESSURE
SUCTION
The most important use of the velocity pressure
reading is to determine the velocity of flow, and thus, the
volume of air being delivered. A pressure-to-volume conversion chart is shown below.
76
THEORETICAL VELOCITY OF AIR AT
62 DEGREES FAHRENHEIT DISCHARGED
INTO ATMOSPHERE
77
The values in this chart are calculated from the formula: V - 66/h. Figures above the line in the pressure
column indicate ounces per square inch, and those below
the line indicate inches of water column. The velocity is
in feet per second. Multiplying feet per second by 60
gives flow in feet per minute.
VOLUME FLOW CALCULATIONS
Very accurate instruments are available that can measure
volume of flow directly, but they are generally too expensive for the home machinist. Fortunately, it is simple
enough to calculate the volume of flow from pressure
readings. Since velocity is easily calculated from the
measured pressure, we go one step further to calculate
volume of flow by multiplying the area through which
the air flows by its velocity.
It is very important to realize that the apparent area
through which the air flows may not be the actual area
upon which to base the calculations. Friction causes turbulence within a duct that tends to restrict flow near the
duct surface, and causes the velocity near the center to increase.
A high reading taken near the center of a duct and
applied to the total cross-sectional area as measured
would certainly render a false volume calculation. This
high central reading is just not representative of air flow
in every point in the duct.
The same principle applies to lower readings taken
near the duct surface. Here again, the low reading is not
representative of air flow in every point in the duct.
Even an average of readings in a section of duct
might be misleading unless all modifying factors are
taken into consideration.
Because losses due to friction and turbulence can be
significant in even short lengths of duct, a simpler, more
direct means of measurement and calculation is desireable.
The simplest way to determine volume of flow is to
measure velocity pressure as air flows through an orifice.
78
Find the corresponding velocity in the chart, or calculate
it from the formula given. Multiply the volume in feet
per second by 60 to find feet per minute. Finally, multiply the cross-sectional area of the orifice in square feet by
the velocity in feet per minute to get the APPARENT
volume of flow in cubic feet per minute.
A modifying factor, the coefficient of discharge, of
from .60 to .93 determined by the type of orifice used
must be introduced into the calculations. A sharp-edged
orifice in a thin plate is the easiest to make and use. Its
factor of .60 is the most reliable of all. It is necessary only to cut a very accurate hole in a piece of sheet metal or
durable material with very sharp clean edges.
A 4" round orifice has a total area of 12.5664 square
inches which is .087 square feet.
If the velocity pressure at the orifice is 3" W.C. then
the velocity is 114 feet per second or 6480 feet per
minute.
79
The volume of flow is then 355.68 cubic feet per
minute.
AIR FLOW IN ORIFICES
Air flow through an orifice results in the "vena contracta" effect. Fluid flowing through an orifice of some
cross-sectional area will contract into a stream just
beyond the orifice having a cross-sectional area less than
that of the orifice. This is the result of moving air hitting
still air and creating turbulence.
Although the effect is not visible in clear air, it can
be observed by introducing smoke into the air stream,
thereby making air flow visible. The phenomenon is
sometimes clearly visible in a stream as water flows between two rocks.
It has been established that the location of the
smallest cross-sectional area of the contracted air stream
is located approximately 1/2 orifice diameter down
stream from the orifice, and that it is .60 of the diameter
of the orifice. Remember, these numbers apply to thin
80
plate orifices only. The vena contracta of a 3" orifice,
for instance, will be 1-1/2" away from the orifice, and
will be 1.8" in diameter.
81
A distinct advantage of the thin plate sharp edge
orifice is that it introduces practically no friction. The
only modifying factors needed when using it are those resulting from the vena contracta effect.
There are several other useful orifices. The most interesting is the long radius or "well formed" orifice
which is designed to conform to the natural shape of the
vena contracta. Its coefficient of discharge is as high as
.93, meaning there is less loss than the thin plate variety.
It has much value in some laboratory work.
When the leading edge of the thin plate orifice is
rounded, the coefficient of discharge increases to as high
as .65 to .75.
Other types and forms vary in the coefficient of discharge and each has some feature that makes it appropriate to some particular use. A few are shown below.
SHARP EDGE
ORIFICE
SHORT PIPE
NOZZLE
ROUND EDGE
ORIFICE
REENTRANT
NOZZLE
LONG RADIUS
WELL FORMED
ORIFICE
CONVERGING
NOZZLE
The most important considerations in fabricating an
orifice are accuracy in dimension and shape, and very
smooth surfaces.
82
The sharp edge orifice must have very sharp, clean
edges. Ideally the work would be done in a lathe, drill
press or milling machine so that the orifice will be truly
round. In many shops it will be necessary to use an electric hand drill with a hole saw, a hand brace with a fly
cutter, or possibly sheet metal snips.
Other materials besides sheet metal can be used. The
work can be done with a router or other wood working
equipment. Plastic or compostion board can be similarly
worked. If the material is thicker than 1/16", the downstream side should be relieved so that the air stream
passes through a thickness of 1/16" or less.
CALCULATING ORIFICE AREA
The purpose of the orifice is to cause the total output of
the fan to flow uniformly through a specific area so that
its volume of flow can be determined. Given the air
speed, we can easily calculate the volume of flow if the
area is known.
In very large systems several orifices may be used
and their totals combined. The idea is to reduce the discharge area which increases velocity and insures uniform
flow. In a large duct or pipe, the air will flow faster near
the center while moving more slowly near the walls of the
duct due to friction and turbulence. There are also areas
near elbows, tees and other obstacles where turbulence or
friction may affect flow.
83
The air flow can be very fast in one portion of a duct
but be very nearly still in another. Readings in one of
these unusual areas would be useless since they do not indicate what is happening in the system overall. It is easy
to check the entire area of the orifice for uniformity of
flow. When uniformity of flow is assured, any reading
will be typical of the entire area.
A sample problem will illustrate the use of an orifice. To find the actual apparent area of a circle, the
square of the diameter is multiplied by .7854. This area is
then multiplied by the orifice coefficient of discharge.
For example a 4" orifice has an area of 12.5664 square
inches.
area
= 4 x 4 x .7854
= 12.5664
vena contracta area = area x coefficient of discharge
= 12.5664 x .60
= 7.53984 or approx 7.54
If the velocity is 8000 feet per minute then the volume of
flow is 416 cubic feet per minute.
volume
= area x velocity
= .052 sq ft x 8000 ft per min
= 416 ft per min
84
C H A P T E R
V
Shop Fan Applications
COMMON APPLICATIONS
With the understanding of basic principles and with the
ability to test and evaluate a fan, it is possible to design
and build a fan for a specific purpose and to determine
whether it is performing as required.
It has already been pointed out that the common
squirrel cage fan is of little use in the shop other than for
heating/cooling or light-duty ventilating or exhausting.
These are low pressure jobs that do not require special
fan systems.
For applications such as fume exhausting, dust collection and forced draft for combustion fans must be
carefully designed and built. Fortunately, it is not
necessary to have a degree in engineering to build a fan
system. Application of the rudimentary principles we
have explored will generally produce a system adequate
for the small shop.
Often a single fan is installed in some permanent location in the shop. Attached to the suction side of the fan
is a trunk line with many smaller lines branching off to
various locations to pick up dust and fumes. Valves, such
as blast gates, can be used to open and close branch lines
as they are needed.
A system is "balanced" by adjusting flow in various
sections to correct or improve performance. Baffles,
gates, or orifices may be needed in branches or main
85
ducts to increase velocity in one area or reduce it in
another. The object is to use the total volume of air efficiently. It may be necessary to increase the speed of the
fan to raise total system velocity, or to reduce the fan
speed to relieve motor overload. Observation and common sense are often the only skills needed to balance a
system.
Many dust collector systems are overloaded with
branch lines. Velocity in the branches is too low. It is
usually possible to bring the system to good operating
balance by merely installing stops in each branch so that
unused ones can be shut off. A stop, or blast gate, is a
simple rectangle of sheet metal slid into a pocket installed
in the branch duct to block the blast of air.
If too many gates are shut off, the main duct air velocity will drop just as if too many gates are open.
Material will precipitate out of the air stream and pile up
in the duct.
A properly balanced system will have sufficient
velocity in all areas to carry any material picked up all the
way through the system, using a minimum of power and
without overloading the motor.
FUME EXHAUST FANS
The removal of obnoxious and often dangerous fumes
and vapors is frequently neglected in small shops—especially in private shops where no regulations can be enforced to require protection of workers. Fumes and
vapors from welding equipment, paint, chemicals and
other processes can be injurious to the health even in
small doses. Unfortunately, the ill effects are often not
realized until after long exposure when it is usually not
possible to restore the damaged respiratory or circulatory systems.
You should carefully consider installing an exhaust
system in your shop. Built around a fractional horsepower motor you may already have on hand, an exhaust
system is as easy to build as it is wise to install.
The right place to start is by identifying dangerous
86
conditions in your shop. Most often, an easily-moved
portable unit works best in a small general shop. It is
easier and less costly to whisk away fumes at their source
than to replace all of the air in the shop area.
A 9" x 3" portable fan is shown exhausting the
fumes of a welding job through flexible hoses. Built
mostly of plywood, light gauge sheet metal and standard
hardware, it cost little to build.
The fan rotor is driven directly by the 1/4 hp motor
shaft at 1725 rpm. Capable of moving 200 cubic feet of
air per minute at 1" W.C. pressure, it efficiently carries
away the welding fumes before they fill the shop and become a hazard.
Although domestic clothes dryer hose is not as
durable as the hose that should be used for this type of
work, it is inexpensive and available almost anywhere.
Dryer hose can be used if a metal fume collector and a
short length of metal pipe are used to protect the hose
from heat and sparks.
The dimensions given can be modified to some extent to accommodate the equipment you have on hand.
Although 3/8" thick plywood might be used for the
housing, heavier 1/2" is much stronger, while 5/8" or
3/4" is preferred. For the scroll forms 1/8" masonite or
other composition board is adequate. The wheel should
87
be made of 26 gauge or heavier sheet metal, but the shell
can be as light as 30 gauge flashing material. A 2" diecast pulley was used for the wheel hub. Steel blind rivets
were used to assemble the wheel.
The double plate design is used to provide reinforcement and extra strength to those wheel components fabricated from relatively light material. Although the inlet
and outlet can be increased, if desired, to 6" diameter or
more for greater volume at lower pressure, I used a 4"
diameter on my system in order to use easily available
dryer hose.
It would be best to begin construction with the
rotor. Two 9" discs and eight vanes of 26 gauge or
heavier sheet metal are required along with a hub,
machine screws, blind-rivets and the tool to install rivets.
Layout of the wheel is most easily done directly on
the metal with wing dividers or trammel points. If you
don't have dividers or trammel points, you can improvise with a narrow strip of light gauge metal. Simply
scribe a sharp line on the metal strip, and carefully measure out the radius of the circles to be marked. Punch a
small hole at each end of this radius. By inserting an awl
through each hole, you have, in effect, built a make-shift
trammel.
Scribe a horizontal line longer than the diameter of
the circle, and intersect it with a vertical line to form a
cross. The working center is at the intersection. Use the
dividers or trammel to scribe the circles from the working
center. Lay out the back disc and the front disc, and cut
them out. Clamp them together to drill the rivet holes.
Mark the discs so that they will be assembled in the same
relative positions as drilled. Eighth inch steel rivets are
adequate.
Although it is possible to produce a small, handmade fan rotor that is very nearly balanced, it should be
tested on the ways and precisely balanced. Even a slight
variation will damage the fan over a period of time.
Besides, an out-of-balance wheel can be dangerous.
Next, build the scroll. Eighth inch masonite works
88
BACK DISK
FRONT DISK
9" DIAMETER WITH CENTER HOLE
TO FIT THE MOTOR SHAFT
9" DIAMETER WITH 5-1/2"
CENTER HOLE
VANES
INSTALL HUB WITH SCREWS
MAKE EIGHT
ASSEMBLE ROTOR WITH RIVETS
very well. Two scrolls are needed. The radius centers are
shifted 1" on each side of the wheel center, which is nearly the required 10% of the wheel diameter.
With a wheel width of 3", the blast area is 9 square
inches. A housing width of 3-3/4" provides 3/8" clearance on each side of the wheel. Since the outlet area
should equal 1-1/2 times the blast area, we calculate a
blast area of 13-1/2 square inches.
89
outlet area
= 1.5 x blast area
= 13.5 square inches
If the discharge opening is 3-3/4" wide, the height is calculated to be about 3-1/2".
R-1 on the layout is the same radius as the wheel, or
4-1/2". R-2 is 2" greater than R-1, or 6-1/2". R-3 is 2"
greater than R-2, or 8-1/2". A piece of material 13"
wide and 15" tall will be required for each scroll. Only
the outline is cut at this time. The fan wheel center holes
will be in the same location but of different diameters in
each scroll.
90
The support panels should be built of at least 1/2"
thick plywood. They are 1-1/2" greater in height and
width than the scrolls. Two 14-1/2" x 16-1/2" panels
are required. Carefully center the scrolls on the support
panels both vertically and horizontally so that the assembly will rest squarely on a flat surface when complete.
Fasten the scrolls to the support panels with five small
screws near the outer edge. Drill five 1/4" holes in each
panel as shown for the carriage bolts that will join the
two halves together. In this way two opposing scrolls are
made.
16-1/2"
One panel will be the rear panel, upon which the
motor support is fastened. The other panel will be the
front panel, through which the wheel is installed. The
choice is determined by the direction of motor rotation
so as to give the correct direction of discharge. A circle
slightly larger than the wheel diameter is cut through the
front panel using the wheel axis as center. Cut through
both the panel and the scroll. A hole large enough for the
motor shaft is drilled through the rear panel. If the motor
shaft is not long enough to reach through both panels
and the wheel hub, a clearance hole large enough for the
motor housing is cut in the rear support panel only, leaving the scroll intact except for the shaft hole. A 7"
diameter clearance hole is large enough for most fractional horsepower motors.
91
The size and location of the motor support shelf
must be designed specifically for the motor to be used.
The shaft height is measured from the center of the shaft
to the base and is transferred to the rear support panel to
locate the motor bracket. A rectangle of plywood large
enough for the motor base can be fastened to a solid
wood cleat on the housing. An outer support should be
added as shown to support the motor weight.
The scroll shell can be light galvanized sheet metal
such as is used for roof flashing. It is available in coils of
various lengths and widths from hardware and building
supply stores. A 4" width can be used for this unit
without trimming. The two scrolls take up 1/4" of the
space between the supports leaving 3-3/4". A four foot
length of flashing will be more than enough.
Five 1/4" x 6" carriage bolts join the two support
panels. Assemble them loosely so that the shell can easily
be slipped in between the panels. Begin by bending one
end of the shell neatly over a 1/4" bolt to form the cutoff end of the shell. Hook it over the carriage bolt that
passes through the lower part of the discharge. Study the
photographs below.
Snug up the nut on the bolt enough to hold the shell
in position, and thread the remainder of the shell between the rest of the bolts and the scroll form. Pull the
shell up tight before you tighten the nuts. Trim any excess metal from ends of the shell. The adapter or transition piece is fastened to the discharge opening with rivets
or screws.
92
The inlet fitting can be a sheet metal sleeve fastened
to a plywood cover about 10" square. I made both the
inlet and outlet on my fan 4" in diameter merely for convenience. The inlet could be as large as 6" in diameter for
greater volume of air at lower velocity and pressure.
When fully loaded, this fan will deliver about 200
cubic feet of air per minute at a pressure of slightly more
than 1" W.C. Since a 4" diameter hose has an area of
.087 square feet, the calculated air velocity is about 2300
feet per minute in the hose.
If you use a 6" diameter pipe which has a cross-sectional
93
area of .196 square feet, the velocity would be 1020 feet
per minute which is adequate for a fume collector hood.
A 6" inlet could also feed two 4" hoses. In such a case,
of course, the discharge should be enlarged as well.
The collector hood can be made broad and narrow
to establish a good draft over a wide area. Keep in mind
that the air velocity drops off very rapidly as the distance
from the hood increases. From 3" to 4" is about the
maximum distance allowable. When the opening of the
hood is greater in area than the pipe that supplies it a baffle is added so that the air velocity is maintained
uniformly over the entire area.
94
The collector can be of any practical shape to suit
the job at hand. The one illustrated works very well for
all of my welding needs when placed within 3" to 4" of
the work.
DUST COLLECTORS
When materials such as sawdust or grinding and polishing dust are to be carried away, the fan must be sturdier
and more powerful than when only air with fumes or
vapor is moved. A fan constructed very much like the
one just described but of heavier material could certainly
be used, but welded 16 gauge steel or heavier is a far better method. Of course, the shaft and bearings must be
heavier as well.
A substantial amount of air can be moved with a
1/4 hp or 1/3 hp motor, but most dust collection applications will require higher air velocities. A motor from
1/2 hp to 1 hp will be required. It is interesting to note
that motor horsepower increases as the cube of the increase in fan rotational speed. In other words, if you
double the speed of any centrifugal fan, you will double
its volume and pressure, but the power requirement will
be increased by a factor of eight.
2 x 2 x 2 = 8
Tripling shaft rotation requires an increase of power
equal to 3 to the third power or 27.
3 x 3 x 3 = 27
The sketch below shows a welded unit mounted
upon an angle iron frame so that it can be belt-driven.
This is a desireable design for a dust collector since the
fan speed will almost surely have to be adjusted in order
to balance the system initially and for possible later addition of branch lines.
95
Note that the scroll housing is made with an opening
on the inlet side large enough to admit the wheel. The inlet adapter also serves as the cover. A gasket can be used
to make the cover airtight. The discharge transition can
be of lighter gauge metal than the housing. The angle
iron frame can be of any convenient dimensions so as to
accommodate both the fan and the motor. The upper
rectangular frame supports two self-aligning pillow
blocks, preferably ball bearings. The cross rails in the
lower frame are located so that the motor pulley will fall
in line with the fan pulley. The four upright spacers of
angle iron are long enough to provide clearance for the
motor.
Air velocity in dust collector systems is maintained
at 3500 feet per minute and above. The primary goal is to
keep the air moving fast enough so that the dust will not
settle out and pile up in the system. It is a simple matter
to determine the total volume of air required from the
area of the suction main since area times velocity equals
volume. The suction main is sized to equal the total area
of the branches plus 20%. There are losses within any
system due to friction, turbulence, and especially to the
entry loss at each collector. Although there are formulas,
factors, tables and charts to aid in calculating such
losses, it requires condiderable study to understand them
and apply them effectively. For a small and simple shop
96
it may be simpler to provide an excess of capacity of up
to 50% in a belt-driven fan and reduce or increase the fan
speed to balance the system.
A one horsepower motor will run a 12" x 4" fan at
up to 2600 rpm, moving more than 500 cubic feet of air
per minute at above 5" W.C. This is more than adequate
for most small shop systems.
Even a smaller 1/2 hp or 3/4 hp motor will do an
amazing amount of work. Unless the main and branch
lines are very long, it is likely that such a system would
run with a static pressure loss of 3" W.C. or less. A 6"
diameter suction main could feed up to three branch lines
effectively.
Additional branches can be installed in the system if
blast gates are provided to prevent air from entering an
unused collector and from lowering the suction of the
system. The blast gate stop is removed from the collector
while in use and slipped into the gate of an idle collector
to balance the system. Of course, to open all of the gates
would reduce the velocity in some of the branches. To
close all of the stops would reduce velocity in the main
and dust would settle out and plug up the system. In a
small home shop worked by only one or two persons a
very complete system can be operated with little power.
Some machines, such as a wood lathe or a jointer, may
require the full capacity of the fan. You can close other
branches while they are in use. An ordinary damper will
not serve very well in a dust collector system because of
the high velocity and pressure.
Blast gates are easy to make. Two squares of sheet
metal about 1" larger than the branch pipe diameter are
prepared with a hole in the center about 3/4" smaller in
diameter than the pipe. The hole is notched all around to
the full diameter of the pipe to form tabs. Each alternate
tab is bent vertically to form a socket for the pipe. The
pipe is slipped into the socket, and two or more sheet
metal screws are installed to hold the assembly secure
while the remaining tabs are bent inside the pipe. The
joint is soldered to make it airtight. The screws are
97
removed to leave the inside surface smooth so that lint
and shavings won't accumulate to stop up the pipe.
Three channels are formed to join the two halves
together and they are soldered to leave a smooth sliding
fit for the stop gate. The gate is merely a rectangle of
sheet metal cut to fit the slot, having one end bent at right
angles to form a handle.
THE CYCLONE SEPARATOR
The mysterious-looking hopper-like devices seen on factory rooftops, often towering high above industrial
plants and feed mills, is called a cyclone separator—generally referred to simply as a "cyclone." These devices
98
slow air speeds down to allow dust and dirt carried in the
air stream to precipitate out.
It is not difficult to build one for your shop, and
surprisingly, small ones actually work better than large
ones. Although there are variations in design, the proportions shown are time-tested and work very well if the
air velocity at the inlet is between 3500 and 4000 feet per
minute.
A cyclone can have greater capacity than a shop
vacuum cleaner. Better yet, there is no bag to resist air
flow, waste power, and periodically change.
The air and dust enter at the edge of the separator
causing the air to whirl like a cyclone inside the cylinder.
In the center where the air whirls fastest, centrifugal
force throws the dust particles outward where they lose
velocity and settle out to the bottom of the hopper. The
clean air escapes out the top at a greatly reduced velocity.
Although it sounds far too simple to be true, the
device is very efficient. Some commercial builders have
claimed 99% efficiency. When you see a cyclone with a
significant amount of dust escaping at its outlet, it is an
indication that the hopper is too full or that the air
volume is too great. Either emptying the waste container
or reducing the fan speed will solve the problem.
DEVELOPING CYCLONE PATTERNS
A brief study will show you that the cyclone separator is
made up of cylinders and cones plus a short length of rectangular duct and a transition. You learned how to lay
out a transition piece earlier. The remaining cyclone
shapes are among the easiest sheet metal patterns to
develop.
The unit shown on page 100 is a 5" cyclone. It is easy
to change the dimensions proportionately. Simply divide
all of the dimensions by five and multiply the result by
the new inlet dimension.
Notice that the main body diameter is four times the
inlet diameter, and that the top outlet is twice the inlet
diameter. These are the two critical proportions.
99
The lower cone section is as tall as its diameter. The
rectangular duct section is the same cross-sectional area
as the round inlet pipe.
The lower outlet size is not critical to the operation
of the cyclone, but it must be large enough to permit free
passage of the full capacity of the unit by gravity. No
waste is stored inside the cyclone. Some sort of container
must be used to accumulate the waste.
The cylindircal portion of the body is merely a rolled
up sheet of metal 12" high and 63-3/4" long. The length
is calculated by multiplying the diameter by pi (3.1416).
100
The calculated length is rounded off to 63" for convenience and 3/8" is added to each end for a simple lap seam
to be joined by rivets, sheet metal screws, or bolts and
nuts. For a 5" unit, 26 gauge galvanized iron is adequate.
Larger cyclones must be of heavier material.
The top and bottom sections of the cyclone are truncated cones—that is, cones with the pointed end cut off.
The opening formed by this truncation is a circle. Both
this circle and the circular base have their respective
centers lying on the vertical line of the truncated cone.
The patterns for each cone are developed by a system of radial lines. Although the pattern development is
similar to triangulation, the true lengths of the radial
lines can be taken from the side elevation, or from a solution triangle that represents the side elevation.
To illustrate, we'll concern ouselves with developing
a pattern for just one of the truncated cones. The remaining cones can then be developed by the same process.
As in the transition piece pattern, a top plan view of
the cone can be divided into a number of segments by
radial lines. The base circle and the circle formed by truncation have common centers. They are said to be concentric, or equally centered cones. All radial lines drawn
from the common center to the outer edge of the large
diameter will be the same length. Once the true length of
this single radial line is found, there is no further need for
a top plan view. In fact, for so simple a form, it is not
necessary to draw a top plan view.
101
A single solution triangle that represents a side of
the cone as it is seen in cross-sectional view provides all
dimensions. Two arcs are drawn using the common
center to represent the outside edge of the base and inside
edge of the top opening. The radius for these arcs is
found in the solution triangle.
Only two radial lines are drawn in the actual layout
as seen in the illustration. These lines represent the ends
of the pattern that will be pulled together and fastened to
form the truncated cone.
First, draw a full-size solution triangle as shown.
The overall diameter of the cyclone is 20". Draw the
horizontal base of the solution triangle 10" long, this being one half of the 20" diameter. Obviously, this 10" is
the distance from the outside edge of the cyclone to the
vertical center axis.
Now, draw the vertical edge of the solution triangle
about 2-1/2" tall. You will note from the side view of the
cyclone that the top opening of the top cone is a circle
10" in diameter. Also note that this opening is 1-1/4"
above the base of the cone.
Extend a second horizontal line 5" from the vertical
center axis at a point 1-1/4" above the base line to represent one half of the 10" top opening.
Draw a diagonal line upward from point C at the
base, touching point B at the opening height until it intersects the vertical center line at point A. This is the solution triangle.
102
The distance from A to B on the solution triangle is
the true radius of the arc that forms the opening at the
top of the cone, or in other words, the radius of the inside circle of the concentric circles found in the pattern
stretchout. The distance from A to C is the true radius of
the arc that forms the base of the cone, or outside circle.
The calculated circumference of the second cone
base is the same 63" from the cyclindrical portion. It
should be obvious that if we want these two pieces to
mate properly, they'll have to have the same circumference. Using the radii from the solution triangle, draw two
concentric circles. Draw one radial line through both
circles to create one end of the pattern.
103
Next, step off 63" of length on the outer circle with
dividers to find the other end of the pattern. Draw a second radial line through this 63" point to complete the
layout. In this way we have developed a pattern for a
cone having a circumference of 63" that will match up
with 63" circumference of the cylindrical form developed
earlier.
An extra amount of metal is added to each end to
form a flap or tab for making a lap seam. For a small,
light-gauge unit, 3/8" is sufficient. A similar amount is
added at the inner and outer diameters for the joints.
Of course, the cones can be made in two or more
pieces. Simply add an amount for the seam wherever laps
are made.
The pattern for the bottom cone is developed in exactly the same manner.
The inlet transition differs only slightly from those
discussed earlier. Rather than being equally centered over
the rectangular base, the circular portion has two of its
sides parallel with two sides of the rectangular portion.
Not Equally Centered
104
Equally Centered
The layout procedure is almost the same as that for
a single-plane-rectangular-to-round transition piece. In
this case, however, there are no duplicate dimensions as
found in a pattern for an equally centered transition
piece.
The rectangular portion of the inlet duct must have
the same cross-sectional area as the round portion of the
inlet so that there is no change in velocity through the inlet duct. The rectangular portion of the inlet duct is a
simple short rectangular duct with one end cut as shown
to conform to the curvature of the cyclone body so that
air enters at the edge of the cyclone.
Be sure to add a flap or tab to the rectangular portion of the inlet transition duct so that it can easily be
joined to the cyclone body. A similar flap should be added to the edge of the rectangular end of the transition
duct so that it can be joined to the duct from fan outlet.
All of the parts of the cyclone can be assembled with
sheet metal screws, bolts, or rivets. I recommend you
solder all seams to make them airtight.
If the cyclone is to be exposed to the weather, a conical hood should be installed at a height over the cyclone
discharge opening equal to half the diameter of the opening. This hood should have a diameter of about one third
greater than that of the discharge opening to keep out the
weather.
A collar can be fastened to the lower outlet so that
the cyclone can be connected to a bin or other waste con105
tainer. If any part of the discharge air from the cyclone is
returned to the work area, it must be filtered to remove
fine particles of dust that could be hazardous to the
health, particularly if the air contains silica such as from
grinding and sanding machines.
BALANCING THE SYSTEM
Too much air will not only throw dust out of the cyclone
discharge, but moving more air than necessary wastes
power. On the other hand, with too little air, waste will
clog the system.
Using the manometer, you should check the system
to see that the fan is running fast enough to provide sufficient air velocity at the collectors. The pitot tube can be
used in any of the inlet branches or in the main duct
where the branches join up before entering the fan inlet.
106
Be sure that no dust is being collected by the system when
you test it, or you stand the chance of plugging up the
pitot.
The simplest way to take the needed measurements
is to drill a 3/4" hole to admit the pitot tube in the
branch pipe very near the point where it joins the collector hood.
Although it is difficult to specify an exact ratio for
every inlet type of hood, it is reasonable to assume that a
static pressure reading in the inlet hood should be approximately 1-1/2 times the actual velocity pressure in
the hood. If, for example, a static pressure reading near
the hood is 1-1/2" W.C., the actual velocity pressure
should be approximately 1" W.C., which indicates a
velocity of 3966 feet per minute. In this case, you could
reduce the fan speed slightly if desired. To do so is not all
that important since the excess velocity is only about
10% greater than the minimum required. A reading of
2" would be too great, indicating a reduction in fan
speed.
Use in the shop will be the most reliable test of all. If
all of the hoods are collecting dust, and if waste is not piling up in the suction main or flying out the cyclone discharge, you have a good system.
Many rules-of-thumb have been developed over the
years. Here are a few that you may find useful.
The fan discharge pipe should never be smaller in
cross-sectional area than the suction pipe, but never so
large that velocity is reduced below system requirements.
Elbows in the system should have long turning radii,
and should be as few in number as possible. A long
radius elbow offers as much resistance to the flow of air
as a length of straight pipe 10 diameters long. Resistance
in a short radius elbow is much greater.
Branches should enter the suction main at an angle
of 45 degrees. The suction main should be increased proportionately as each one or two branches are added the
greatest diameter being at the fan intake. This need not
be observed if only one branch is to be used at a time,
107
with the others being shut off with blast gates. Be sure
the suction main is not so large at the inlet that the air
velocity is reduced.
All of the joints in the piping system should have
smooth inside surfaces. Every joint should be soldered,
or should be sealed with tape or caulking to eliminate
leaks. System efficiency can be greatly reduced by many
small leaks.
Safety first! Employ safety precautions wherever
possible. Belt drives most certainly must be guarded. All
electrical work must be done properly to eliminate overloads, shock hazards and fire hazards.
Within these few pages it is impossible to fully explore any single aspect of fan technology. You have
learned the basics, though. You can design and build a
fan for a particular application and have a clear idea of
what sort of performance to expect. Commercially-built
exhaust fans can cost several hundred dollars if purchased new. But with little more than basic hand tools,
you can build a custom fan for a fraction of the new cost.
Quite often, most of the materials needed are already on
hand or easily available as surplus or salvage.
108
A P P E N D I X
Some of the most frequently used formulas and tables
are repeated in this section for quick reference.
COMPOSITION OF AIR
By Weight
By Volume
Oxygen
23.1%
21%
Nitrogen
76.9%
79%
100%
100%
STANDARD AIR
temperature: 68 degrees Fahrenheit
relative humidity: 50%
pressure: 29.92 inches of mercury
WEIGHT OF STANDARD AIR:
.075 pounds per cubic foot
VELOCITY OF FLOW AND VELOCITY PRESSURE
RELATIONSHIP:
V = velocity in feet per second
h = velocity pressure in inches W.C.
109
The velocity in feet per second is equal to the square
root of the velocity pressure in inches W.C. multiplied
by 66.
AREA OF A CIRCLE:
Multiply the square of the diameter by .7854.
CIRCUMFERENCE OF A CIRCLE:
Multiply the diameter by 3.1416 (pi).
PERIPHERAL VELOCITY OF A FAN WHEEL:
Multiply the circumference in feet by the speed in
RPM to learn the velocity in feet per minute.
ONE OUNCE OF PRESSURE PER SQUARE INCH
GAUGE: is equal to 1.73" W.C.
ONE INCH WATER COLUMN: is equal to .58 ounces
per square inch gauge.
BLAST AREA:
A = D x
where:
W
3
A = Blast area in square inches
D = Wheel diameter in inches
W = Wheel width in inches
The blast area is equal to the wheel diameter in inches multiplied by the wheel width in inches and the product divided by 3.
110
THEORETICAL VELOCITY OF AIR AT
62 DEGREES FAHRENHEIT INTO ATMOSPHERE
111
DISCHARGE OPENING:
From 1-1/2 to 2-1/2 times the blast area.
THEORETIC CAPACITY OF FANS:
C = B x V x D
where:
C = Capacity in cubic ft per min (CFM)
B = Blast area in square feet
V = Velocity in feet per minute
D = Coefficient of discharge (.8)
VOLUME OF FLOW IN AN ORIFICE:
Multiply the area of the orifice in square feet by the
velocity of flow in feet per minute. Multiply the resulting
product by the coefficient of discharge. (The coefficient
of discharge for a thin plate sharp edge orifice is .60.)
POWER REQUIRED TO RUN A FAN:
Assuming 50% efficiency
where:
112
HP = Horsepower required
C = volume of flow in feet per second
H = Pressure in inches W.C.
Was this manual useful for you? yes no
Thank you for your participation!

* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project

Download PDF

advertisement