advertisement
▼
Scroll to page 2
of 50
=('25W00EU ZED25A00EU =('25W00EU/ZED25A00EU =P\ZDUND SO,QVWUXNFMDXş\WNRZDQLD =P\ZDUND 5HVHWVHF SO 6SLVWUHĹFL 8Ő\WNRZDQLH]JRGQH ]SU]H]QDF]HQLHP 3U]HSLV\EH]SLHF]HħVWZD SUDF\ 3U]HGSLHUZV]\PZĭøF]HQLHP XU]øG]HQLD 3U]\GRVWDZLH 3RGF]DVLQVWDODFML 8ş\ZDQLHFRG]LHQQH %ORNDGDGU]ZL :SU]\SDGNXZ\VWøSLHQLDV]NyG 3U]\XVXZDQLXZ\VĭXşRQHJR XU]øG]HQLD 2FKURQDĹURGRZLVND 2SDNRZDQLH 6WDUHXU]øG]HQLD =DSR]QDQLHVLĊ] XU]øG]HQLHP 3XOSLWREVĭXJL :QċWU]HXU]øG]HQLD 8NĥDG]PLĊNF]DQLDZRG\ 6yOVSHFMDOQD 8VWDZLDQLH 7DEHODWZDUGRłFLZRG\ =DVWRVRZDQLHVROLVSHFMDOQHM ŁURGNLF]\V]F]øFH]GRGDWNLHP VROL :\ĭøF]HQLH]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\ 3ĥ\QQDEĥ\V]F]DMøF\ 1DF]\QLD 1LHSU]\VWRVRZDQHGR]P\ZDUNL 8V]NRG]HQLDV]NĭDLQDF]\į :NĭDGDQLHQDF]\į :\MPRZDQLHQDF]\į )LOLşDQNLLV]NODQNL *DUQNL .RV]\NQDV]WXúFH 3yĭNL 3RGSyUNLVNĭDGDQH 3RMHPQLNQDPDĭHF]ċłFL 3yĭNDQDQRşH =PLDQDZ\VRNRłFL]DZLHV]HQLD NRV]D ĸURGHNF]\V]F]øF\ 1DSHĭQLHQLHłURGNLHP F]\V]F]øF\P .RPSDNWRZHłURGNLF]\V]F]øFH 3U]HJOøGSURJUDPyZ :\EyUSURJUDPX :VND]yZNLGOD,QVW\WXWyZ %DGDZF]\FK )XQNFMHGRGDWNRZH 6NUyFHQLHID]\SURJUDPX 9DULR6SHHG =DSHĭQLHQLHZSRĭRZLH +LJLHQD +\JLHQH 6WUHIDLQWHQV\ZQD (NVWUDVXV]HQLH 8VWDZLHQLHLORłFLSĭ\QX QDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJR :\ĭøF]HQLHZVNDŝQLNDEUDNX Sĭ\QXQDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJR SO 2EVĥXJDXU]øG]HQLD &RURELúZUD]LHXVWHUNL" 3DUDPHWU\SURJUDPyZ &]XMQLN$TXD VWDQXZRG\ :ĭøF]HQLHXU]øG]HQLD :VNDŝQLNF]DVXGRNRįFD SURJUDPX 1DVWDZLDQLHF]DVXZĭøF]HQLD .RQLHFSURJUDPX $XWRPDW\F]QHZ\ĭøF]HQLHSR ]DNRįF]HQLXSURJUDPX :\ĭøF]\úXU]øG]HQLH 3U]HUZDQLHSURJUDPX 3U]HUZDQLHSURJUDPX =PLDQDSURJUDPX 6XV]HQLHLQWHQV\ZQH 3RPSDRGSĭ\ZX 7DEHONDXVWHUHN &]\V]F]HQLHRUD]SU]HJOøG 2JyOQ\VWDQXU]øG]HQLD 6yOVSHFMDOQDLSĭ\Q QDEĭ\V]F]DMøF\ 6LWND 5DPLRQDVSU\VNXMøFH 6HUZLV 8VWDZLDQLHLSRGĥøF]DQLH =DNUHVGRVWDZ\ :VND]yZNLEH]SLHF]HįVWZD 'RVWDZD 'DQHWHFKQLF]QH 8VWDZLHQLH 3RGĭøF]HQLHGRRGSĭ\ZX 3U]\ĭøF]HZRG\SLWQHM 3RGĭøF]HQLHGR]DVLODQLDFLHSĭø ZRGø 3RGĭøF]HQLHHOHNWU\F]QH 'HPRQWDş 7UDQVSRUW =DEH]SLHF]HQLHSU]HGVNXWNDPL PUR]X 2SUyşQLDQLHXU]øG]HQLD 8ş\WNRZDQLH]JRGQH]SU]H]QDF]HQLHP SO 8Ő\WNRZDQLH]JRGQH ]SU]H]QDF]HQLHP HNRZ 8 QLD\WĪ ʋ ʋ ʋ JRGQH] P HQLH]FQD]H]SU] 8U]øG]HQLHSU]H]QDF]RQH MHVWGRXş\WNXZSU\ZDWQ\P JRVSRGDUVWZLHGRPRZ\P RUD]ORNDODFKPLHV]NDOQ\FK =P\ZDUNċXş\ZDúW\ONR ZJRVSRGDUVWZLHGRPRZ\P LW\ONRGRSU]H]QDF]RQHJR FHOX]P\ZDQLDQDF]\į GRPRZ\FK =P\ZDUNDMHVWSU]H]QDF]RQD GRXş\WNXQDPDNV\PDOQHM Z\VRNRłFLPQSP 3U]HSLV\ EH]SLHF]HħVWZDSUDF\ \VSLH]3U Z DWĔVH]FHSL]EH \FDSU 8U]øG]HQLHPRJøREVĭXJLZDú G]LHFLZZLHNXSRZ\şHMODW RUD]RVRE\]RJUDQLF]RQ\PL ]GROQRłFLDPLIL]\F]Q\PL VHQVRU\F]Q\PLOXEXP\VĭRZ\PL DWDNşHRVRE\QLHSRVLDGDMøFH Z\VWDUF]DMøFHJRGRłZLDGF]HQLD OXEZLHG]\MHłOLSR]RVWDMøSRG QDG]RUHPRVRE\ RGSRZLHG]LDOQHM]DLFK EH]SLHF]HįVWZROXE]RVWDĭ\ SRXF]RQHMDNZĭDłFLZLH REVĭXJLZDúXU]øG]HQLHLVø łZLDGRPH]ZLø]DQ\FK]W\P ]DJURşHį ']LHFLQLHPRJøEDZLúVLċ XU]øG]HQLHP&]\V]F]HQLHL F]\QQRłFLNRQVHUZDF\MQHQLH PRJøE\úZ\NRQ\ZDQHSU]H] G]LHFLFK\EDşHPDMøRQH XNRįF]RQHODWLVø QDG]RURZDQHSU]H]RVREċ GRURVĭø ']LHFLRPSRQLşHMURNXş\FLD QLHQDOHş\SR]ZDODúQD ]EOLşDQLHVLċGRXU]øG]HQLDDQL SU]HZRGXSU]\ĭøF]HQLRZHJR 3U]HGSLHUZV]\PZĥøF]HQLHP XU]øG]HQLD 8ZDşQLHSU]HF]\WDMLQVWUXNFMċ REVĭXJLLPRQWDşX=DZLHUDRQD ZDşQHLQIRUPDFMHQDWHPDW XVWDZLDQLDXş\WNRZDQLDL NRQVHUZDFMLXU]øG]HQLD =DFKRZDMZV]\VWNLHGRNXPHQW\ MDNRŝUyGĭRLQIRUPDFMLOXEGOD HZHQWXDOQHJRNROHMQHJR Xş\WNRZQLNDXU]øG]HQLD ,QVWUXNFMċREVĭXJLPRşQD QLHRGSĭDWQLHSREUDú]QDV]HM VWURQ\LQWHUQHWRZHM$GUHV VWURQ\LQWHUQHWRZHM]QDMGXMHVLċ QDW\OQHMRNĭDGFHLQVWUXNFML REVĭXJL SO 3U]HSLV\EH]SLHF]HįVWZDSUDF\ 3U]\GRVWDZLH 1DW\FKPLDVWVSUDZG]Lú RSDNRZDQLHL]P\ZDUNċ SRGZ]JOċGHPV]NyG WUDQVSRUWRZ\FK 1LHXUXFKDPLDú XV]NRG]RQHJRXU]øG]HQLD OHF]]ZUyFLúVLċGRGRVWDZF\ ZWHMVSUDZLH 0DWHULDĭRSDNXQNRZ\XVXQøú ]JRGQLH]RERZLø]XMøF\PL SU]HSLVDPL 1LHSR]RVWDZLDúRSDNRZDQLD OXEMHJRF]ċłFLEDZLøF\PVLċ G]LHFLRP6NĭDGDQHNDUWRQ\ LIROLHVWDQRZLøSRWHQFMDOQH QLHEH]SLHF]HįVWZR XGXV]HQLD ʋ ʋ ʋ ʋ 3RGF]DVLQVWDODFML ʋ ʋ ʋ ʋ 3URV]ċ]ZUyFLúXZDJċQDWR DE\SRLQVWDODFML]P\ZDUNL W\OQDVWURQDXU]øG]HQLD QLHE\ĭDVZRERGQLHGRVWċSQD ]DEH]SLHF]HQLHSU]HG GRWNQLċFLHPJRUøFHM SRZLHU]FKQL 8VWDZLHQLHLSRGĭøF]HQLH SU]HSURZDG]Lú]JRGQLH ]LQVWUXNFMøLQVWDODFML LPRQWDşX 3RGF]DVLQVWDODFML]P\ZDUND PXVLE\úRGĭøF]RQDRGVLHFL 8SHZQLúVLċşHXNĭDG SU]HZRGyZRFKURQQ\FK GRPRZHMLQVWDODFML HOHNWU\F]QHMMHVWSU]HSLVRZR Z\NRQDQ\ ʋ 3DUDPHWU\SU]\ĭøF]D HOHNWU\F]QHJRPXV]øE\ú ]JRGQH]GDQ\PL QDWDEOLF]FH ]QDPLRQRZHM]P\ZDUNL :SU]\SDGNXXV]NRG]HQLD VLHFLRZHJRSU]HZRGX SRGĭøF]HQLRZHJRWHQ PXVL]RVWDúZ\PLHQLRQ\ QDVSHFMDOQ\SU]HZyG :FHOXXQLNQLċFLD]DJURşHį SU]HZyGWHQPRşQDQDE\ú W\ONRSRSU]H]DXWRU\]RZDQ\ VHUZLV -HłOL]P\ZDUNDPDE\ú ]DEXGRZDQDZV]DILH NXFKHQQHMNRQLHF]QHMHVWMHM SUDZLGĭRZHSU]\PRFRZDQLH -HłOL]P\ZDUND]DEXGRZDQD ]RVWDQLHSRGOXESRQDG LQQ\PLXU]øG]HQLDPL JRVSRGDUVWZDGRPRZHJR ZWHG\SURV]ċSU]HVWU]HJDú LQIRUPDFMLRGQRłQLH ]DEXGRZDQLDZSRĭøF]HQLX ]H]P\ZDUNø]DZDUW\FK ZLQVWUXNFMLPRQWDşXGDQHJR XU]øG]HQLD 3RQDGWRSURV]ċUyZQLHş SU]HVWU]HJDúLQVWUXNFML PRQWDşXGOD]P\ZDUNLDE\ ]DSHZQLúEH]SLHF]Qø HNVSORDWDFMċZV]\VWNLFK XU]øG]Hį 3U]HSLV\EH]SLHF]HįVWZDSUDF\ SO ʋ ʋ ʋ ʋ ʋ -HłOLQLHVøGRĭøF]RQH LQIRUPDFMHOXEZLQVWUXNFML PRQWDşXQLHPD RGSRZLHGQLHMZVND]yZNL ZWHG\SURV]ċVLċ VNRQWDNWRZDú]SURGXFHQWHP GDQHJRXU]øG]HQLDDE\VLċ XSHZQLúşH]P\ZDUNDPRşH ]RVWDú]DPRQWRZDQDSRGOXE SRQDGXU]øG]HQLHP -HłOLQLHPRşQDRWU]\PDúRG SURGXFHQWDşDGQ\FK LQIRUPDFMLZWHG\QLHZROQR PRQWRZDú]P\ZDUNLSRGOXE SRQDGGDQ\PXU]øG]HQLHP -HłOLQDG]P\ZDUNø]RVWDQLH ]DEXGRZDQDNXFKHQND PLNURIDORZDZWHG\WDPRşH ]RVWDúXV]NRG]RQD 8U]øG]HQLDSU]H]QDF]RQH GR]DEXGRZDQLD OXE]LQWHJURZDQHLQVWDORZDú W\ONRSRGFLøJĭ\PEODWHP URERF]\PNWyU\MHVW SU]\NUċFRQ\GRVøVLHGQLFK V]DIHNZFHOX]DSHZQLHQLD VWDELOQRłFLXVWDZLHQLD 1LHLQVWDORZDúXU]øG]HQLD ZSREOLşXŝUyGHĭFLHSĭD JU]HMQLNyZSLHFyZ DNXPXODF\MQ\FKSLHFyZ OXELQQ\FKXU]øG]Hį Z\G]LHODMøF\FKFLHSĭR LQLH ]DEXGRZ\ZDúSRGSĭ\Wø JU]HMQø ʋ ʋ ʋ 1DOHş\SDPLċWDúşHRG ŝUyGHĭFLHSĭD QSLQVWDODFML FHQWUDOQHJRRJU]HZDQLD LQVWDODFMLFLHSĭHMZRG\ OXE JRUøF\FKF]ċłFLXU]øG]HQLD PRşHVLċVWRSLúL]RODFMD SU]HZRGXVLHFLRZHJR ]P\ZDUNL1LJG\QLH GRSXV]F]DúGRNRQWDNWX SU]HZRGXVLHFLRZHJR ]P\ZDUNL]HŝUyGĭDPLFLHSĭD OXEJRUøF\PLF]ċłFLDPL XU]øG]HQLD 3RXVWDZLHQLX]P\ZDUNL ZW\F]NDVLHFLRZDPXVLE\ú VZRERGQLHGRVWċSQD 3DWU]3RGĭøF]HQLH HOHNWU\F]QH 3U]\QLHNWyU\FKPRGHODFK :REXGRZLHSU]\ĭøF]DZRG\ ]WZRU]\ZDV]WXF]QHJR ]QDMGXMHVLċHOHNWU\F]Q\ ]DZyUZZċşXGRSĭ\ZRZ\P ]QDMGXMøVLċSU]HZRG\ ĭøF]øFH1LHSU]HFLQDúWHJR ZċşDQLH]DQXU]DúREXGRZ\ ]WZRU]\ZDV]WXF]QHJR ZZRG]LH 8Ő\ZDQLHFRG]LHQQH 3U]HVWU]HJDúSU]HSLVyZ EH]SLHF]HįVWZDLXş\WNRZDQLD Z\GUXNRZDQ\FK QDRSDNRZDQLDFKłURGNyZ F]\V]F]øF\FK LQDEĭ\V]F]DMøF\FK SO 3U]HSLV\EH]SLHF]HįVWZDSUDF\ =DEH]SLHF]HQLHGRVWĊSXG]LHFL EORNDGDGU]ZL 3U]\XVXZDQLXZ\VĥXŐRQHJR XU]øG]HQLD 2SLV]DEH]SLHF]HQLDGRVWċSX G]LHFL]QDMGXMHVLċZW\OH ZRNĭDGFH Z]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX :\VĭXşRQHXU]øG]HQLH QDW\FKPLDVWSR]EDZLúFHFK SU]\GDWQRłFLGRXş\FLD ZFHOXXQLNQLċFLD HZHQWXDOQ\FKZ\SDGNyZ 8U]øG]HQLHQDOHş\XVXQøú ]JRGQLH]RERZLø]XMøF\PL SU]HSLVDPL %ORNDG GU]ZL :SU]\SDGNXZ\VWøSLHQLD V]NyG ʋ ʋ 3U]HSURZDG]HQLHQDSUDZ LLQQ\FKF]\QQRłFL ]DVWU]HşRQHMHVWW\ONR GODVSHFMDOLVWyZ:W\PFHOX XU]øG]HQLHPXVLE\ú RGĭøF]RQHRGVLHFL :\FLøJQøúZW\F]NċVLHFLRZø OXEZ\ĭøF]\úEH]SLHF]QLN =DNUċFLú]DZyUZRG\ 3U]\XV]NRG]HQLDFKD V]F]HJyOQLHSXOSLWXREVĭXJL SċNQLċFLDG]LXU\Z\ĭDPDQH SU]\FLVNL DOERSU]\ QDUXV]HQLXIXQNFMRQRZDQLD GU]ZLQLHZROQR HNVSORDWRZDúXU]øG]HQLD :\FLøJQøúZW\F]NċVLHFLRZø OXEZ\ĭøF]\úEH]SLHF]QLN =DNUċFLú]DZyUZRG\ LZH]ZDúVHUZLV H2VWU]HŐHQLH 1LHEH]SLHF]HħVWZR VNDOHF]HQLD ʋ =P\ZDUNċRWZLHUDúW\ONR QDF]DVZNĭDGDQLD OXEZ\MPRZDQLDQDF]\į DE\XQLNQøúVNDOHF]Hį VSRZRGRZDQ\FK QSSRWNQLċFLHPVLċRGU]ZL ʋ 1RşHLLQQHV]WXúFH]RVWU\PL NRįFyZNDPLPXV]ø]RVWDú ZĭRşRQHGRNRV]\ND QDV]WXúFH]RVWU]DPL VNLHURZDQ\PLZGyĭDOER SR]LRPRXĭRşRQHZSyĭFH QDQRşH ʋ 1LHVLDGDúOXEVWDZDú QDRWZDUW\FKGU]ZLDFK 3U]HSLV\EH]SLHF]HįVWZDSUDF\ SO 3U]\]P\ZDUNDFK ZROQRVWRMøF\FKSURV]ċ ]ZUDFDúXZDJċQDWRDE\ NRV]HQLHE\ĭ\SU]HĭDGRZDQH ʋ -HłOLXU]øG]HQLHQLHMHVW ZVXQLċWHGRQLV]\DW\P VDP\PMHGQD]HłFLDQ ERF]Q\FKMHVWGRVWċSQD ZWHG\]HZ]JOċGX QDEH]SLHF]HįVWZR NRQLHF]QHMHVWREXGRZDQLH REV]DUX]DZLDVyZ QLHEH]SLHF]HįVWZR VNDOHF]HQLD 2EXGRZ\WH PRşQDQDE\úMDNR Z\SRVDşHQLHGRGDWNRZH ZSXQNFLHVHUZLVRZ\P RUD]ZKDQGOX VSHFMDOLVW\F]Q\P Z]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX ʋ H2VWU]HŐHQLH 1LHEH]SLHF]HħVWZRZ\EXFKX 1LHGRGDZDúşDGQHJR UR]SXV]F]DOQLNDGRNRPRU\ ]P\ZDQLD:\VWċSXMH QLHEH]SLHF]HįVWZRZ\EXFKX H2VWU]HŐHQLH 1LHEH]SLHF]HħVWZR SRSDU]HQLD 3RGF]DVWUZDQLDSURJUDPX RVWURşQLHRWZLHUDúGU]ZL,VWQLHMH QLHEH]SLHF]HįVWZRSU\VNDQLD JRUøFHMZRG\]ZQċWU]D XU]øG]HQLD H2VWU]HŐHQLH =DJURŐHQLHGODG]LHFL ʋ 3URV]ċXş\ZDú ]DEH]SLHF]HQLD SU]HGG]LHúPLMHłOLWDND IXQNFMDMHVWREHFQD 'RNĭDGQ\RSLV]QDMGXMHVLċ QDNRįFXLQVWUXNFML ʋ 1LHSR]ZDODúG]LHFLRP QD]DEDZċXU]øG]HQLHPOXE MHJRREVĭXJLZDQLH ʋ 8QLHPRşOLZLúG]LHFLRP GRVWċSGRłURGND F]\V]F]øFHJRLSĭ\QX QDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJR0RJøRQH VSRZRGRZDúEDUG]R V]NRGOLZHGOD]GURZLDVNXWNL ZREUċELHMDP\XVWQHMRUD] RF]XOXEGRSURZDG]Lú GRXGXV]HQLD ʋ 1LHSR]ZDODúG]LHFLRP QDSU]HE\ZDQLHZSREOLşX RWZDUWHM]P\ZDUNL: ]P\ZDUFHPRJø]QDMGRZDú VLċPDĭHSU]HGPLRW\NWyUH PRJĭ\E\]RVWDúSRĭNQLċWH SU]H]G]LHFLZRGDZHZQøWU] ]P\ZDUNLQLHMHVWZRGøSLWQø ²PRşH]DZLHUDúUHV]WNL łURGNDF]\V]F]øFHJR SO 2FKURQDłURGRZLVND ʋ ʋ ʋ =ZUDFDúXZDJċQDWR DE\G]LHFLQLHZNĭDGDĭ\UøN GRSRMHPQLND QDWDEOHWNL0DĭHSDOFH PRJøXWNZLúZV]F]HOLQDFK :SU]\SDGNX]P\ZDUHN ]DPRQWRZDQ\FKZ\VRNR ]ZUDFDúXZDJċQDWR DE\SU]\RWZLHUDQLX L]DP\NDQLXGU]ZLG]LHFLQLH GR]QDĭ\SU]\FLłQLċFLDOXE ]PLDşGşHQLDUøNSDOFyZ SRPLċG]\GU]ZLDPL]P\ZDUNL L]QDMGXMøF\PLVLċSRQLşHM GU]ZLDPLV]DINL ']LHFLPRJø]DPNQøúVLċ ZłURGNXXU]øG]HQLD QLHEH]SLHF]HįVWZR XGXV]HQLDVLċ OXEZ\ZRĭDú LQQøQLHEH]SLHF]QøV\WXDFMċ 'ODWHJRSU]\Z\VĭXşRQ\FK XU]øG]HQLDFKZ\FLøJQøú ZW\F]NċVLHFLRZøRGFLøú LXVXQøúNDEHOVLHFLRZ\ =QLV]F]\ú]DPHNGU]ZLRZ\ DE\XQLHPRşOLZLúSRQRZQH ]DPNQLċFLHGU]ZL 2FKURQDĹURGRZLVND RQD2 KUF NDVRGZ ULĞ =DUyZQRRSDNRZDQLHQRZHJR XU]øG]HQLDMDNLVWDUHXU]øG]HQLD ]DZLHUDMøFHQQHVXURZFHZWyUQH LPDWHULDĭ\GRSRQRZQHJR SU]HWZRU]HQLD 3URVLP\RXW\OL]RZDQLHSRV]F]HJyOQ\FK F]ċłFLZHGĭXJURG]DMXPDWHULDĭX 3URVLP\RSRLQIRUPRZDQLHVLċX VSU]HGDZF\OXEORNDOQHMDGPLQLVWUDFML RDNWXDOQ\PVSRVRELHXVXZDQLD RSDNRZDQLD 2SDNRZDQLH :V]\VWNLHF]ċłFL]WZRU]\ZDV]WXF]QHJR RSDWU]RQHVøPLċG]\QDURGRZ\PL R]QDF]HQLDPLVNUyWRZ\PL QS!36SROLVW\URO 8PRşOLZLDWR XW\OL]DFMċXU]øG]HQLD]GRNĭDGQ\P VRUWRZDQLHPRGSDGyZ]WZRU]\ZD V]WXF]QHJRZHGĭXJURG]DMX 3U]HVWU]HJDúSU]HSLVyZEH]SLHF]HįVWZD ]DPLHV]F]RQ\FKZÅ3RGF]DVGRVWDZ\´ =DSR]QDQLHVLċ]XU]øG]HQLHP SO 6WDUHXU]øG]HQLD 3U]HVWU]HJDúSU]HSLVyZEH]SLHF]HįVWZD ]DPLHV]F]RQ\FKZÅ:SU]\SDGNX XVXQLċFLDZ\VĭXşRQHJRXU]øG]HQLD´ 7RXU]øG]HQLHMHVWR]QDF]RQH ]JRGQLH]'\UHNW\Zø(XURSHMVNø 8(RUD]SROVNø8VWDZø ]GQLDZU]HłQLDÅ2 ]Xş\W\PVSU]ċFLHHOHNWU\F]Q\PL HOHNWURQLF]Q\Pµ ']8]GQ SR] V\PEROHPSU]HNUHłORQHJR NRQWHQHUDQDRGSDG\7DNLH R]QDNRZDQLHLQIRUPXMHşHVSU]ċW WHQSRRNUHVLHMHJRXş\WNRZDQLD QLHPRşHE\úXPLHV]F]DQ\ ĭøF]QLH]LQQ\PLRGSDGDPL SRFKRG]øF\PL]JRVSRGDUVWZD GRPRZHJR8ş\WNRZQLNMHVW ]RERZLø]DQ\GRRGGDQLDJR SURZDG]øF\P]ELHUDQLH]Xş\WHJR VSU]ċWXHOHNWU\F]QHJRL HOHNWURQLF]QHJR3URZDG]øF\ ]ELHUDQLHZW\PORNDOQHSXQNW\ ]ELyUNLVNOHS\RUD]JPLQQH MHGQRVWNDWZRU]øRGSRZLHGQL V\VWHPXPRşOLZLDMøF\RGGDQLH WHJRVSU]ċWX:ĭDłFLZH SRVWċSRZDQLH]H]Xş\W\P VSU]ċWHPHOHNWU\F]Q\PL HOHNWURQLF]Q\PSU]\F]\QLDVLċGR XQLNQLċFLDV]NRGOLZ\FKGOD ]GURZLDOXG]LLłURGRZLVND QDWXUDOQHJRNRQVHNZHQFML Z\QLNDMøF\FK]REHFQRłFL VNĭDGQLNyZQLHEH]SLHF]Q\FKRUD] QLHZĭDłFLZHJRVNĭDGRZDQLDL SU]HWZDU]DQLDWDNLHJRVSU]ċWX =DSR]QDQLHVLĊ ]XU]øG]HQLHP HQLD= SR]D ĊLV P HQLHG]ą]XU] 5\VXQNLSXOSLWXREVĭXJLLZQċWU]D XU]øG]HQLD]QDMGXMøVLċQDSRF]øWNX LQVWUXNFML 'RSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKSR]\FMLNLHURZDQH VøRGQRłQLNLZWHNłFLH 3XOSLWREVĥXJL 3U]HĭøF]QLN:Ĭ÷&=:<Ĭ÷&= 2WZLHUDF]GU]ZL 3URJUDPDWRU # 3U]\FLVN67$57 + :\łZLHWODF]F\IURZ\ 3 1DVWDZLDQLHF]DVXZĭøF]HQLD ; )XQNFMHGRGDWNRZH C :VNDŝQLNEUDNXSĭ\QX QDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJR K :VNDŝQLNQDSHĭQLHQLDVROø :VNDŝQLNÅ6NRQWURORZDQLDGRSĭ\ZX ZRG\´ Z]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX ,ORłúZ]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX SO 8NĭDG]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\6yOVSHFMDOQD :QĊWU]HXU]øG]HQLD *yUQ\NRV]QDQDF]\QLD 3yĭNDQDQRşH 3RMHPQLNQDWDEOHWNLGR]P\ZDUNL *yUQHUDPLċVSU\VNXMøFH % 'ROQHUDPLċVSU\VNXMøFH - =ELRUQLNQDVyOVSHFMDOQø 5 6LWND = .RV]\NQDV]WXúFH E 'ROQ\NRV]QDQDF]\QLD M =ELRUQLN]DSDVXłURGND QDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJR .RPRUDQDłURGNLF]\V]F]øFH =DPNQLċFLHNRPRU\łURGND F]\V]F]øFHJR 7DEOLF]ND]QDPLRQRZD Z]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX 8NĥDG]PLĊNF]DQLD ZRG\6yOVSHFMDOQD GD8Ná DQLD]NFP Ċ]L ZRG\ 6yO QDODMFSHV 'RX]\VNLZDQLDGREU\FKZ\QLNyZ ]P\ZDQLDSRWU]HEQDMHVWPLċNNDZRGD W]Q]QLHZLHONø]DZDUWRłFLøZDSQLD :SU]HFLZQ\PUD]LHQDQDF]\QLDFK LZHZQċWU]X]P\ZDUNLZ\G]LHODVLċRVDG ZDSLHQQ\ :RGDELHşøFDRWZDUGRłFLSRZ\şHM PPROOPXVL]RVWDúSRGGDQD ]PLċNF]HQLX1DVWċSXMHWR]DSRPRFø VSHFMDOQHMVROL VyOUHJHQHUDF\MQD ZXNĭDG]LH]PLċNF]DMøF\PZRGċ Z]P\ZDUFH 8VWDZLHQLHL]ZLø]DQH]W\P ]DSRWU]HERZDQLHVROL]DOHşQHMHVW RGVWRSQLDWZDUGRłFLGRVWDUF]DQHMZRG\ SDWU]WDEHOD 8VWDZLDQLH ,ORłúGRGDZDQHMVROLMHVWQDVWDZQD Z]DNUHVLHRG¯¯GR¯Å 3U]\ZDUWRłFLXVWDZLHQLD¯¯VyO QLHMHVWNRQLHF]QD 'RZLHG]LHúVLċMDNLVWRSLHįWZDUGRłFL PDZRGDZRGRFLøJRZD:W\P Z\SDGNX]ZUyFLúVLċ]]DS\WDQLHP GR]DNĭDGXZRGRFLøJyZ :DUWRłúXVWDZLHQLDRGF]\WDúZWDEHOL WZDUGRłFLZRG\ =DPNQøúGU]ZL :ĭøF]\úSU]HĭøF]QLN:Ĭ÷&= :<Ĭ÷&= 1DFLVQøúSU]\FLVN67$57# LSU]\WU]\PDúZFLłQLċW\ 3URJUDPDWRUSU]HNUċFDú DşZ\łZLHWODF]F\IURZ\+ ZVNDşH¯ 3XłFLúSU]\FLVN :\łZLHWODF]F\IURZ\+ZVND]XMH IDEU\F]QLHXVWDZLRQøZDUWRłú¯ 8NĭDG]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\6yOVSHFMDOQD SO :FHOX]PLDQ\WHJRXVWDZLHQLD 3URJUDPDWRUSU]HNUċFDú DşZ\PDJDQDZDUWRłúXNDşHVLċ QDZ\łZLHWODF]XF\IURZ\P+ 1DFLVQøúSU]\FLVN67$57# 1DVWDZLHQLHSR]RVWDMH]DSLVDQH ZSDPLċFL 7DEHODWZDUGRĹFLZRG\ 7ZDUGRńú =DNUHV ZRG\ WZDUGRńFL G+ PPROO :DUWRńú QDVWDZLHQLD PDV]\Q\ PLċNND ¯¯ PLċNND ¯³ ńUHGQLD ¯ ńUHGQLD ¯´ ńUHGQLD ¯ WZDUGD ¯ WZDUGD ¯± WZDUGD ¯Å =DVWRVRZDQLHVROLVSHFMDOQHM 1DSHĭQLDQLHVROøQDOHş\]DZV]H SU]HSURZDG]DúEH]SRłUHGQLR SU]HGZĭøF]HQLHPXU]øG]HQLD']LċNL WHPXSU]HODQ\UR]WZyUVROL]RVWDQLH QDW\FKPLDVWZ\SĭXNDQ\]DSRELHJDMøF Z\VWøSLHQLXZV]HONLHMNRUR]MLZNRPRU]H ]P\ZDUNL 2WZRU]\ú]DNUċWNċSRMHPQLND ]DSDVX- 1DSHĭQLúSRMHPQLNZRGø NRQLHF]QH W\ONRSU]\SLHUZV]\PXUXFKRPLHQLX 1DSHĭQLúVROøVSHFMDOQø QLHVROø NXFKHQQøDQLSDVW\ONDPL 3U]\W\PZRGDMHVWZ\SLHUDQD LZ\Sĭ\ZD -DNW\ONRZVNDŝQLNEUDNXVROLK ]DF]QLHłZLHFLúZSDQHOXQDOHş\]QyZ QDSHĭQLúVROøVSHFMDOQø Z]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX SO 3ĭ\QQDEĭ\V]F]DMøF\ =DVWRVRZDQLHĹURGNyZ F]\V]F]øF\FK]GRGDWNLHPVROL ŁURGNLF]\V]F øFH ]GRGDWNLHPVROL 6WRVXMøF]HVSRORQHłURGNLF]\V]F]øFH ]GRGDWNLHPVROLPRşQD]D]Z\F]DM ]UH]\JQRZDú]GRGDZDQLDVROL VSHFMDOQHMSU]\WZDUGRłFLZRG\ GRG+ I+&ODUNH PPROO 3U]\WZDUGRłFLZRG\ SRZ\şHMG+NRQLHF]QHMHVW VWRVRZDQLHVROLVSHFMDOQHM :\ĥøF]HQLHZVNDŎQLNDEUDNX VROL]PLĊNF]DQLDZRG\ :\ĭøF]HQLH]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\ -HłOLZVNDŝQLNEUDNXVROLK SU]HV]NDG]DZWHG\PRşQDJRZ\ĭøF]\ú QSZSU]\SDGNXXş\ZDQLD]HVSRORQHJR łURGNDF]\V]F]øFHJR]NRPSRQHQWHP VROL ʋ 3RVWċSRZDú]JRGQLH]RSLVHP Å8VWDZLHQLHLORłFLSĭ\QX QDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJR´LXVWDZLúZDUWRłú QD¯¯ 7\PVDP\PZ\ĭøF]RQ\MHVWXNĭDG ]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\RUD]ZVNDŝQLN EUDNXVROL 3ĥ\QQDEĥ\V]F]DMøF\ \Q3á \FąMD]F]\VEáQD -HłOL]DłZLHFLVLċZVNDŝQLNEUDNXSĭ\QX QDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJRCQDSXOSLFLH ZWHG\UH]HUZDSĭ\QXQDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJR Z\VWDUF]\MHV]F]HQDSURFHV\ ]P\ZDQLD3URV]ċX]XSHĭQLúQLHGREyU Sĭ\QXQDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJR 3ĭ\QQDEĭ\V]F]DMøF\MHVWNRQLHF]Q\ GRX]\VNDQLDF]\VWHMSRZLHU]FKQL QDF]\įEH]SODPRUD]OłQLøFHJRV]NĭD 6WRVRZDúW\ONRSĭ\QQDEĭ\V]F]DMøF\ SU]H]QDF]RQ\GR]P\ZDUHNGRPRZ\FK .RPSDNWRZHłURGNLF]\V]F]øFH]H łURGNLHPQDEĭ\V]F]DMøF\PPRşQD VWRVRZDúW\ONRGRZRG\RWZDUGRłFL SRQLşHMG+ I+&ODUNH PPROO 3U]\WZDUGRłFLZRG\ SRZ\şHMG+NRQLHF]QHMHVW VWRVRZDQLHSĭ\QXQDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJR 2WZRU]\ú]ELRUQLNMSRSU]H] QDFLłQLċFLHĭøF]QLNDSU]\SRNU\ZLH DQDVWċSQLHXQLHłú H 8ZDJD 1LJG\QLHZV\S\ZDúłURGND F]\V]F]øFHJRGRSRMHPQLNDQDVyO VSHFMDOQø6SRZRGRZDĭRE\WR ]QLV]F]HQLHXNĭDGX]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\ 3ĭ\QQDEĭ\V]F]DMøF\ SO :ODúRVWURşQLHSĭ\QQDEĭ\V]F]DMøF\ PDNV\PDOQLHGR]QDNXSU]\RWZRU]H ZOHZX PD[ =DPNQøúSRNU\ZċDşXVĭ\V]\P\ ]DWU]DłQLċFLH 5R]ODQ\Sĭ\QQDEĭ\V]F]DMøF\Z\WU]Hú łFLHUNøDE\SU]\QDVWċSQ\P SURFHVLH]P\ZDQLDQLHZ\VWøSLĭR QDGPLHUQHZ\G]LHODQLHSLDQ\ 8VWDZLHQLHLORĹFLSĥ\QX QDEĥ\V]F]DMøFHJR ,ORłúGRGDZDQHJRSĭ\QX QDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJRPRşQDXVWDZLú Z]DNUHVLHRG¯¯GR¯±3URV]ċ XVWDZLúLORłúGRGDZDQHJRSĭ\QX QDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJRQD¯DE\ RWU]\PDúEDUG]RGREU\UH]XOWDW VXV]HQLD)DEU\F]QLHXVWDZLRQR VWRSLHį¯ ,ORłúSĭ\QXQDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJR]PLHQLú W\ONRZWHG\JG\QDQDF]\QLDFK SR]RVWDMøVPXJL XVWDZLúQDQLşV]\ VWRSLHį OXESODP\]ZRG\ XVWDZLú QDZ\şV]\VWRSLHį =DPNQøúGU]ZL :ĭøF]\úSU]HĭøF]QLN:Ĭ÷&= :<Ĭ÷&= 1DFLVQøúSU]\FLVN67$57# LSU]\WU]\PDúZFLłQLċW\ 3URJUDPDWRUSU]HNUċFDú DşZ\łZLHWODF]F\IURZ\+ ZVNDşH¯ 3XłFLúSU]\FLVN :\łZLHWODF]F\IURZ\+ZVND]XMH IDEU\F]QLHXVWDZLRQøZDUWRłú¯ SO 1DF]\QLD :FHOX]PLDQ\XVWDZLHQLD 3URJUDPDWRUSU]HNUċFDú DşQDZ\łZLHWODF]XF\IURZ\P+ XNDşHVLċşøGDQDZDUWRłú 1DFLVQøúSU]\FLVN67$57# 8VWDZLHQLHSR]RVWDMH]DSLVDQH ZSDPLċFL 1DF]\QLD D1 \QL]FD 1LHSU]\VWRVRZDQH GR]P\ZDUNL 6]WXúFHLQDF]\QLD]GUHZQD :UDşOLZHV]NĭRGHNRUDF\MQH QDF]\QLDDUW\VW\F]QHLDQW\NL,FK GHNRUDFMHQLHVøERZLHPRGSRUQH QD]P\ZDQLHZ]P\ZDUFH ʋ &]ċłFL]WZRU]\ZDV]WXF]QHJR QLHRGSRUQHQDZ\VRNLHWHPSHUDWXU\ ʋ 1DF]\QLDPLHG]LDQHLF\QNRZH ʋ 1DF]\QLD]DEUXG]RQHSRSLRĭHP ZRVNLHPVPDUHPOXEIDUEø 'HNRUDFMHQDV]NOHF]ċłFL]DOXPLQLXP OXEVUHEUDPDMøVNĭRQQRłFL ]DIDUERZDQLDOXEZ\SĭRZLHQLDSRGF]DV ]P\ZDQLD7DNşHQLHNWyUHURG]DMHV]NĭD MDNQSSU]HGPLRW\NU\V]WDĭRZH PRJø XOHF]PDWRZLHQLXSRZLHOXSURFHVDFK ]P\ZDQLD ʋ :\ĥøF]HQLHZVNDŎQLNDEUDNX Sĥ\QXQDEĥ\V]F]DMøFHJR -HłOLZVNDŝQLNEUDNXSĭ\QX QDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJRCSU]HV]NDG]D ZWHG\PRşQDJRZ\ĭøF]\ú QSZSU]\SDGNXXş\ZDQLD]HVSRORQHJR łURGNDF]\V]F]øFHJRL]NRPSRQHQWHP QDEĭ\V]F]DMøF\P ʋ 3RVWċSRZDú]JRGQLH]RSLVHP Å8VWDZLHQLHLORłFLSĭ\QX QDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJR´LXVWDZLúZDUWRłú QD¯¯ :VNDŝQLNEUDNXSĭ\QX QDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJRCMHVWZ\ĭøF]RQ\ ʋ 8V]NRG]HQLDV]NĥDLQDF]\ħ 3U]\F]\Q\ 5RG]DMV]NĭDLSURFHVMHJR Z\WZDU]DQLD ʋ 6NĭDGFKHPLF]Q\łURGND F]\V]F]øFHJR ʋ 7HPSHUDWXUDZRG\SURJUDPX ]P\ZDMøFHJR =DOHFDVLĊ ʋ 8ş\ZDúV]NĭRLSRUFHODQċR]QDF]RQø SU]H]SURGXFHQWDMDNRQDGDMøFøVLċ GOD]P\ZDUHN ʋ 6WRVRZDúłURGHNF]\V]F]øF\ GRQDF]\įR]QDNRZDQ\MDNR ĭDJRGQ\ ʋ 3R]DNRįF]HQLXSURJUDPX]P\ZDQLD PRşOLZLHV]\ENRZ\FLøJQøúV]NĭR LV]WXúFH]H]P\ZDUNL ʋ 1DF]\QLD SO :NĥDGDQLHQDF]\ħ )LOLŐDQNLLV]NODQNL 8VXQøúZLċNV]HUHV]WNLSRWUDZ =P\ZDQLHZVWċSQHSRGELHşøFø ZRGøQLHMHVWNRQLHF]QH 1DF]\QLDZNĭDGDúZWDNLVSRVyE DE\ ² SHZQLHVWDĭ\LQLHPRJĭ\VLċ SU]HZUyFLú ² ZV]\VWNLHQDF]\QLDE\ĭ\ VNLHURZDQHRWZRUHPZGyĭ ² F]ċłFLZNOċVĭHOXE ]]DJĭċELHQLDPLVWDĭ\VNRłQLHWDN DE\ZRGDPRJĭDVSĭ\Qøú ² DE\QLHSU]HV]NDG]DĭRSU]\ REUDFDQLXRE\GZXUDPLRQ VSU\VNXMøF\FKL% :]P\ZDUFHQLH]P\ZDúEDUG]RPDĭ\FK QDF]\įJG\şZ\SDGDMøRQHĭDWZR ]NRV]\ *yUQ\NRV]QDQDF]\QLD :\MPRZDQLHQDF]\ħ :FHOXXQLNQLċFLD]PRF]HQLDQDF]\į NURSODPLZRG\VSDGDMøF\PL]NRV]D JyUQHJR]DOHFDVLċRSUyşQLDQLH ]P\ZDUNL]DF]\QDMøFQDGROHLNRįF]øF ZJyU]H *RUøFHQDF]\QLDVøZUDşOLZH QDXGHU]HQLDZVWU]øV\'ODWHJR SR]DNRįF]HQLXSURJUDPX]RVWDZLú QDF]\QLDZ]P\ZDUFHDşVLċRFKĭRG]ø DGRSLHURSRWHPZ\Møú :VND]yZND 1DF]\QLDQLHPRJøZ\VWDZDúSRQDG SRMHPQLNQDWDEOHWNL3U]HGPLRW\WH PRJø]DEORNRZDúSRNU\ZċNRPRU\QD łURGHNF]\V]F]øF\DW\PVDP\P SRNU\ZDQLHRWZRU]\VLċFDĭNRZLFLH :VND]yZND 3R]DNRįF]HQLXSURJUDPXZLGRF]QHVø NURSOHZRG\ZHZQøWU]XU]øG]HQLD1LH PDWRZSĭ\ZXQDVXV]HQLHQDF]\į SO 1DF]\QLD *DUQNL .RV]\NQDV]WXúFH 'ROQ\NRV]QDQDF]\QLDE 6]WXúFHQDOHş\]DZV]HZNĭDGDú ZVSRVyEQLHVRUWRZDQ\LRVWU]HP VNLHURZDQ\PZGyĭ :FHOXXQLNQLċFLDVNDOHF]HQLDGĭXJLH RVWUHF]ċłFLLQRşHXNĭDGDúQDSyĭFH QDQRşH 3RUDGD 0RFQR]DEUXG]RQHQDF]\QLD JDUQNL XĭRş\úZGROQ\PNRV]X8]\VNDQ\Z\QLN ]P\ZDQLDMHVWOHSV]\]HZ]JOċGX QDVLOQ\VWUXPLHįZRG\ 3RUDGD 'DOV]HZVND]yZNL]ZLø]DQH ]RSW\PDOQ\PZ\NRU]\VWDQLHPZQċWU]D ]P\ZDUNLVøGRVWċSQHQDQDV]HMVWURQLH LQWHUQHWRZHMMDNREH]SĭDWQ\SOLN GRSREUDQLD2GSRZLHGQLDGUHV LQWHUQHWRZ\]QDMGXMHVLċQDW\OQHMVWURQLH LQVWUXNFMLREVĭXJL 1DF]\QLD SO 3yĥNL 3RMHPQLNQDPDĥHF]ĊĹFL 3yĭNċRUD]PLHMVFHSRQLşHMPRşQD Xş\ZDúGODPDĭ\FKILOLşDQHNRUD] V]NODQHNOXEGODGXş\FKV]WXúFyZMDN QSĭ\şNLNXFKHQQHDOERV]WXúFH SyĭPLVNRZH3yĭNċPRşQDRGFK\OLúGR JyU\MHłOLQLHMHVWSRWU]HEQD Z]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX 7XWDMPRşQDSHZQLHXPLHłFLúOHNNLH F]ċłFL]WZRU]\ZDV]WXF]QHJRMDN QSNXENLSRNU\Z\LWG 3yĭNL 3RMHPQLNQDPDĭHF]ċłFL &/,&. :]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOXPRşOLZHMHVW XVWDZLHQLHQDUyşQ\FKVWRSQLDFK :W\PFHOXQDMSLHUZSLRQRZRXVWDZLú SyĭNċSRFLøJQøúMøGRJyU\ DQDVWċSQLHSRGOHNNRVNRłQ\P NRQWHPSU]HVXQøúZGyĭLXVWDZLú ZşøGDQHMZ\VRNRłFL OXE 3yĭND PXVL]DWU]DVQøú 3RGSyUNLVNĭDG QH 3yĥNDQDQRŐH 3yĭNDQDQRşH Z]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX 'ĭXJLHQRşHLLQQHSU]\ERU\PXV]ø ]RVWDúXĭRşRQHSR]LRPR 3RGSyUNLVNĥDGDQH Z]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX 3RGSyUNLPRşQDVNĭDGDúQDERN FRXĭDWZLDZNĭDGDQLHJDUQNyZPLVHN LV]NODQHN SO 1DF]\QLD =PLDQDZ\VRNRĹFL ]DZLHV]HQLDNRV]D *yUQ\NRV]]GŎZLJQLDPL ERF]Q\PL Z]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX :\VRNRłúXVWDZLHQLDJyUQHJR NRV]DPRşQD]PLHQLúVWRVRZQLH GRSRWU]HEX]\VNXMøFZLċFHMPLHMVFD ZJyUQ\POXEGROQ\PNRV]X GODZ\şV]\FKQDF]\į :\FLøJQøúJyUQ\ NRV]QDQDF]\QLD :FHOXREQLŐHQLDNRV]DQDFLVQøú ZNLHUXQNXGRZQċWU]DSRNROHL RELHGŝZLJQLHOHZøLSUDZø ]QDMGXMøFHVLċQD]HZQċWU]QHMVWURQLH NRV]D7U]\PDúSU]\W\P NRV]QDERNDFK]DJyUQ\EU]HJ DE\QLHPyJĭQDJOHVSDłúQDGyĭ =PLDQ Z\VRN łFL]DZLHV]HQLDNRV]D :\VRNRłúXU]øG]HQLDFP .RV]JyUQ\ .RV]GROQ\ 6WRSLHıPDNV¡ 6WRSLHıPDNV¡ 6WRSLHıPDNV¡ FP FP FP FP FP FP :\VRNRłúXU]øG]HQLDFP .RV]JyUQ\ .RV]GROQ\ 6WRSLHıPDNV¡ 6WRSLHıPDNV¡ 6WRSLHıPDNV¡ FP FP FP FP FP FP :]DOHşQRłFLRGXNV]WDĭWRZDQLX JyUQHJRNRV]DZ3DįVWZD]P\ZDUFH QDOHş\Z\EUDúMHGHQ]GZyFKQLşHM SU]HGVWDZLRQ\FKVSRVREyZ SRVWċSRZDQLD :FHOXSRGQLHVLHQLDNRV]DFKZ\FLú JR]ERNX]DJyUQøNUDZċGŝ LSRGQLHłúGRJyU\ 3U]HGSRQRZQ\PZVXQLċFLHPNRV]D XSHZQLúVLċF]\QDRE\GZXVWURQDFK RSLHUDVLċRQQDWHMVDPHM Z\VRNRĹFL:SU]HFLZQ\PUD]LH QLHPRşQD]DPNQøúGU]ZL]P\ZDUNL DJyUQHUDPLċVSU\VNXMøFH QLHX]\VNDşDGQHJRSRĭøF]HQLD ]RELHJLHPZRG\ ŁURGHNF]\V]F]øF\ SO *yUQ\NRV]]SDUDPLUROHN JyUQ\FKLGROQ\FK :\FLøJQøúJyUQ\ NRV]QDQDF]\QLD :\MøúNRV]JyUQ\L]DZLHVLúJR QDURONDFKJyUQ\FK VWRSLHį OXE GROQ\FK VWRSLHį ĸURGHNF]\V]F]øF\ NRGHĝU \Fą]F]\V]F 'R]ZRORQHMHVWXş\ZDQLHłURGNyZ F]\V]F]øF\FKGR]P\ZDUHNZSRVWDFL WDEOHWHNSURV]NXOXESĭ\QXDOH ZşDGQ\PZ\SDGNXSĭ\QXGR]P\ZDQLD UċF]QHJR:]DOHşQRłFLRGVWDQX ]DEUXG]HQLDPRşQDLQG\ZLGXDOQLH GRVWRVRZDúGR]RZDQLHłURGNyZ F]\V]F]øF\FKZSRVWDFLSURV]NXOXE Sĭ\QX7DEOHWNL]DZLHUDMøZ\VWDUF]DMøFR GXşøLORłúVXEVWDQFMLF]\QQ\FKGOD NDşGHJRSURJUDPX]P\ZDQLD 1RZRF]HVQHZ\GDMQHłURGNL F]\V]F]øFHVWRVXMøJĭyZQLH QLVNRDONDOLF]QøIRUPXĭċ]DZLHUDMøFø HQ]\P\(Q]\P\UR]NĭDGDMøVNURELċL UR]V]F]HSLDMøELDĭNR:FHOXXVXQLċFLD NRORURZ\FKSODP QS]KHUEDW\F]\ NHF]XSX VWRVRZDQHVøQDMF]ċłFLHM łURGNLZ\ELHODMøFHQDED]LHWOHQX :VND]yZND 'RX]\VNDQLDGREU\FKZ\QLNyZ ]P\ZDQLDNRQLHF]QLHSU]HVWU]HJDú ZVND]yZHNQDGUXNRZDQ\FK QDRSDNRZDQLXłURGNDF]\V]F]øFHJR :UD]LHZ\VWøSLHQLDGDOV]\FKS\WDį ]DOHFDP\]ZUyFLúVLċRSRUDGċ GRSURGXFHQWDłURGNDF]\V]F]øFHJR H 2VWU]HŐHQLH²3U]HVWU]HJDú SU]HSLVyZEH]SLHF]HįVWZD LXş\WNRZDQLDZ\GUXNRZDQ\FK QDRSDNRZDQLDFKłURGNyZ F]\V]F]øF\FKLQDEĭ\V]F]DMøF\FK SO ŁURGHNF]\V]F]øF\ 1DSHĥQLHQLHĹURGNLHP F]\V]F]øF\P -HłOLNRPRUDGODłURGND F]\V]F]øFHJRMHVWMHV]F]H ]DPNQLċWDWRSU]HVXQøú ]DVXZNċ FHOHPMHMRWZRU]HQLD ŁURGHNF]\V]F]øF\GRGDúGRVXFKHM NRPRU\łURGNDF]\V]F]øFHJR WDEOHWNċZĭRş\úSRSU]HF]QLH QLHVWDZLDúMHMSLRQRZR 'R]RZDQLH SDWU]]DOHFHQLDSURGXFHQWD QDRSDNRZDQLX 3RG]LDĭNDGR]RZDQLDZSRMHPQLNX QDłURGHNF]\V]F]øF\XĭDWZLD GR]RZDQLHRGSRZLHGQLHMLORłFL SURV]NXOXESĭ\QXF]\V]F]øFHJR 3U]\QRUPDOQ\P]DEUXG]HQLX ]D]Z\F]DMZ\VWDUF]DPO²PO 3U]\Xş\ZDQLXWDEOHWHNZ\VWDUF]D MHGQDWDEOHWND PO PO PO =DPNQøúSRNU\ZċSRMHPQLND QDłURGHNF]\V]F]øF\SU]HVXZDMøFMø GRJyU\DşGR]DF]HSLHQLD]DSDGNL &/,&. 3RMHPQLNQDłURGHNF]\V]F]øF\ RWZLHUDVLċDXWRPDW\F]QLH ZRGSRZLHGQLPPRPHQFLH ZVSRVyE]DOHşQ\RGSURJUDPX 3URV]HNOXESĭ\QF]\V]F]øF\ UR]SURZDG]DVLċLUR]SXV]F]D ZXU]øG]HQLXWDEOHWNDZSDGD GRRGSRZLHGQLHJRSRMHPQLND LUR]SXV]F]DVLċZQLPGR]XMøF RGSRZLHGQLHłURGNL 3RUDGD 3U]\PQLHMV]HMLORłFL]DEUXG]RQ\FK QDF]\į]D]Z\F]DMZ\VWDUF]DQLHFR PQLHMV]DQLşSRGDQDLORłúłURGND F]\V]F]øFHJR 2GSRZLHGQLHłURGNLF]\V]F]øFHL NRQVHUZXMøFHPRşQDQDE\úSRSU]H] QDV]øVWURQċLQWHUQHWRZøOXESRSU]H] DXWRU\]RZDQ\VHUZLV SDWU]VWURQDW\OQD ŁURGHNF]\V]F]øF\ SO .RPSDNWRZHĹURGNL F]\V]F]øFH 2SUyF]NRQZHQFMRQDOQ\FK SRMHG\QF]\FK łURGNyZF]\V]F]øF\FK RIHURZDQHVøSURGXNW\]GRGDWNRZ\PL IXQNFMDPL3URGXNW\WH]DZLHUDMøF]ċVWR RSUyF]łURGNDF]\V]F]øFHJRWDNşH NRPSRQHQWQDEĭ\V]F]DMøF\ RUD]VXEVW\WXWVROL LQ LZ]DOHşQRłFL RGNRPELQDFML LQLQLWG GRGDWNRZHNRPSRQHQW\MDNQSłURGHN GRRFKURQ\V]NĭDOXEłURGHN QDEĭ\V]F]DMøF\GRVWDOLV]ODFKHWQHM .RPSDNWRZHłURGNLF]\V]F]øFHG]LDĭDMø W\ONRGRRNUHłORQHJRVWRSQLDWZDUGRłFL ZRG\ QDMF]ċłFLHMGRG+ 3RZ\şHM WHMZDUWRłFLNRQLHF]QHMHVWGRGDQLHVROL RUD]łURGNDQDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJR -HłOLVWRVRZDQHVøNRPSDNWRZHłURGNL F]\V]F]øFHZWHG\SU]HELHJSURJUDPX ]P\ZDQLDGRSDVRZXMHVLċ DXWRPDW\F]QLHWDNDE\]DZV]H RVLøJQøúQDMOHSV]HPRşOLZHUH]XOWDW\ ]P\ZDQLDLVXV]HQLD H 2VWU]HŐHQLH²1LHZNĭDGDú MDNLFKNROZLHNPDĭ\FKF]ċłFL GR]P\ZDQLDGRSRMHPQLND QDWDEOHWNċXWUXGQLDWR UyZQRPLHUQHUR]SXV]F]HQLHVLċWDEOHWNL H 2VWU]HŐHQLH²1LHXŐ\ZDú SRMHPQLNDQDWDEOHWNċMDNRXFKZ\WX GODNRV]DJyUQHJRZF]DVLHZNĭDGDQLD GRGDWNRZ\FKQDF]\įSRZĭøF]HQLX SURJUDPX]P\ZDQLD7DEOHWNDPRşHMXş VLċZQLP]QDMGRZDúLJUR]LVW\N ]F]ċłFLRZRUR]SXV]F]RQøWDEOHWNø :VND]yZNL ʋ 2SW\PDOQHUH]XOWDW\]P\ZDQLD LVXV]HQLDRWU]\PXMHVLċ SU]\VWRVRZDQLXSRMHG\QF]\FK łURGNyZF]\V]F]øF\FKZSRĭøF]HQLX ]RGG]LHOQ\PGR]RZDQLHPVROL LSĭ\QXQDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJR ʋ 3RGF]DVNUyWNLFKSURJUDPyZ HZHQWXDOQLHQLHGRFKRG]L GRUR]ZLQLċFLDSHĭQHMVNXWHF]QRłFL F]\V]F]HQLD]SRZRGXUyşQHM ]GROQRłFLUR]SXV]F]DQLDVLċWDEOHWHN LSR]RVWDMøQLHUR]SXV]F]RQHUHV]WNL łURGNDF]\V]F]øFHJR3URV]NRZH łURGNLF]\V]F]øFHVøOHSLHM SU]\VWRVRZDQHGRW\FKSURJUDPyZ ʋ :SU]\SDGNXSURJUDPXÅ,QWHQV\ZQ\´ SU]\QLHNWyU\FKPRGHODFK GR]RZDQLHMHGQHMWDEOHWNLMHVW Z\VWDUF]DMøFH:UD]LHXş\FLD SURV]NXLVWQLHMHPRşOLZRłú QDV\SDQLDQLHZLHONLHMLORłFLłURGND F]\V]F]øFHJRQDZHZQċWU]QøVWURQċ GU]ZL]P\ZDUNL ʋ 1DZHWMHłOLłZLHFLVLċZVNDŝQLNEUDNX Sĭ\QXQDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJRLOXEVROL WRZSU]\SDGNXXş\FLD NRPSDNWRZ\FKłURGNyZ F]\V]F]øF\FKSURJUDP]P\ZDQLD SUDFXMHQLHQDJDQQLH ʋ =DVWRVRZDQLHłURGNyZF]\V]F]øF\FK ZRWRF]FHRFKURQQHMXOHJDMøFHM UR]SXV]F]HQLXZZRG]LHRWRF]Nċ GRW\NDúW\ONRVXFK\PLUċNDPL LZV\SDúłURGHNF]\V]F]øF\W\ONRGR DEVROXWQLHVXFKHJRSRMHPQLND QDłURGHNF]\V]F]øF\ :SU]HFLZQ\PZ\SDGNXPRşH QDVWøSLúSU]\NOHMHQLH ʋ :UD]LH]PLDQ\łURGNyZ F]\V]F]øF\FK]NRPSDNWRZ\FK QDSRMHG\QF]HQDOHş\]ZUyFLú XZDJċQDXVWDZLHQLHZĭDłFLZHM ZDUWRłFLXNĭDGX]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\ LLORłFLSĭ\QXQDEĭ\V]F]DMøFHJR SO 3U]HJOøGSURJUDPyZ 3U]HJOøGSURJUDPyZ GąJOH]3U P DRJUyZ SU :W\PSU]HJOøG]LHSU]HGVWDZLRQRPDNV\PDOQLHPRŐOLZøLORĹúSURJUDPyZ 2GSRZLHGQLHSURJUDP\NWyUHVøGRG\VSR]\FMLZ3DħVWZD]P\ZDUFHRUD]LFK SR]\FMH]D]QDF]RQHVøQDSXOSLFLHREVĥXJL 5RG]DMQDF]\į 5RG]DM]DEUXG]HQLD 3URJUDP JDUQNLSDWHOQLH QLHZUDţOLZH QDF]\QLD LV]WXúFH PRFQRSU]\NOHMRQH SU]\SDORQHOXE SU]\VFKQLċWHUHV]WNL SRWUDZUHV]WNL SRWUDZ]DZLHUDMøFH VNURELċOXEELDįNR ,QWHQV\ZQLH Ä 1RUPDOQ\ Ä 1RUPDOQ\ UyţQHQDF]\QLD LV]WXúFH ZV]\VWNLH =P\ZDQLHZVWċSQH =P\ZDQLH 3įXNDQLHSRńUHGQLH 3įXNDQLH ]QDEį\V]F]DQLHP 6XV]HQLH ZV]\VWNLH =P\ZDQLHZVWċSQH =P\ZDQLH 3įXNDQLHSRńUHGQLH 3įXNDQLH ]QDEį\V]F]DQLHP 6XV]HQLH ZV]\VWNLH =P\ZDQLHZVWċSQH =P\ZDQLH 3įXNDQLHSRńUHGQLH 3įXNDQLH ]QDEį\V]F]DQLHP 6XV]HQLH ZV]\VWNLH =P\ZDQLHZVWċSQH =P\ZDQLH 3įXNDQLHSRńUHGQLH 3įXNDQLH ]QDEį\V]F]DQLHP 6XV]HQLH OHNNRSU]\VFKQLċWH ]Z\F]DMQHUHV]WNL SRWUDZ kj (FR 0RşOLZHIXQNFMH 3U]HELHJSURJUDPX GRGDWNRZH 3U]HJOøGSURJUDPyZ SO ZUDţOLZH QDF]\QLD LV]WXúFHV]NįR ĮDJRGQLH RUD]QDF]\QLD OHNNRSU]\NOHMRQH ]WZRU]\ZD ńZLHţHUHV]WNLSRWUDZ V]WXF]QHJR QLHRGSRUQH QDRGG]LDį\ZDQLH WHUPLF]QH 6]\ENR pq xÍ ]LPQHSįXNDQLH ZV]\VWNLHURG]DMH F]\V]F]HQLH QDF]\ı SRńUHGQLH =P\ZDQLH ZVWċSQH 6WUHIDLQWHQV\ZQD 6NUyFHQLHF]DVX 3RįRZD]DįDGXQNX 6XV]HQLHHNVWUD =P\ZDQLHZVWċSQH =P\ZDQLH 3įXNDQLHSRńUHGQLH 3įXNDQLH ]QDEį\V]F]DQLHP 6XV]HQLH 6XV]HQLHHNVWUD =P\ZDQLH 3įXNDQLHSRńUHGQLH 3įXNDQLH ]QDEį\V]F]DQLHP ţDGQH =P\ZDQLHZVWċSQH SO )XQNFMHGRGDWNRZH :\EyUSURJUDPX :]DOHşQRłFLRGURG]DMXQDF]\į LVWRSQLD]DEUXG]HQLDPRşQDZ\EUDú RGSRZLHGQLSURJUDP :VND]yZNLGOD,QVW\WXWyZ %DGDZF]\FK ,QVW\WXW\%DGDZF]HRWU]\PDMø ZVND]yZNLGODEDGDįSRUyZQDZF]\FK QSZHGĭXJ(1 &KRG]LWXWDMRZDUXQNLSU]HSURZDG]DQLD WHVWyZ²QLHRUH]XOWDW\OXESDUDPHWU\ ]Xş\FLD =DS\WDQLDSURVLP\Z\V\ĭDúSRF]Wø PDLORZø GLVKZDVKHU#WHVWDSSOLDQFHVFRP :\PDJDQ\EċG]LHQXPHU XU]øG]HQLD (ä1U LQXPHUIDEU\NDF\MQ\ )' RE\GZDQXPHU\]QDMGXMøVLċ QDWDEOLF]FH]QDPLRQRZHM XPLHV]F]RQHMQDGU]ZLDFKXU]øG]HQLD )XQNFMHGRGDWNRZH HM)XQNF NRZHWGRD Z]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX 8VWDZLDQHSU]\FLVNDPLIXQNFML GRGDWNRZ\FK; 6NUyFHQLHID]\SURJUDPX9DULR6SH G ­6NUyFHQLHID]\SURJUDPX 9DULR6SHHG =DSRPRFøIXQNFML!!6NUyFHQLHID]\ SURJUDPXPRşQDVNUyFLúF]DVSUDF\ Z]DOHşQRłFLRGZ\EUDQHJRSURJUDPX ]P\ZDQLDRRNGR.DşGD ]PLDQDF]DVXWUZDQLDMHVWSRND]\ZDQD QDZ\łZLHWODF]XF\IURZ\P+ 2SW\PDOQDVNXWHF]QRłú]P\ZDQLDSU]\ VNUyFRQ\PF]DVLHWUZDQLDSURJUDPXMHVW RVLøJDQDSU]H]]ZLċNV]HQLH]Xş\FLD ZRG\LHQHUJLL =DSHĭQLHQLHZSRĭ ZLH =DSHĥQLHQLHZSRĥRZLH :SU]\SDGNXPDĭHMLORłFLQDF]\į GR]P\ZDQLD QSV]NODQHNILOLşDQHN WDOHU]\ PRşQDZĭøF]\úIXQNFMċÅSRĭRZD ]DĭDGXQNX´']LċNLWHPXRV]F]ċG]DQD MHVWZRGDHQHUJLDLF]DV'R]P\ZDQLD ZV\SDúQLHFRPQLHMłURGND F]\V]F]øFHJRGRSRMHPQLND QLş]DOHFDQHMHVWSU]\SHĭQ\P]DĭDGXQNX ]P\ZDUNL 2EVĭXJDXU]øG]HQLD SO ²+LJLHQD +\JLHQH 2EVĥXJDXU]øG]HQLD +LJHQD+\JLHQ 3RGF]DVSURFHVXF]\V]F]HQLD WHPSHUDWXUDMHVWSRGZ\şV]RQD :Z\QLNXWHJRRVLøJDVLċZ\şV]\VWDQ KLJLHQLF]Q\7DIXQNFMDGRGDWNRZDMHVW LGHDOQDGR]P\ZDQLDQSGHVHN GRNURMHQLDOXEEXWHOHNGRNDUPLHQLD QLHPRZOøW ½6WUHIDLQWHQV\ZQD 6WUHIDLQWHQV\ZQD ,GHDOQDGODUyşQRURGQHJR]DĭDGXQNX 0RFQLHM]DEUXG]RQHJDUQNLLSDWHOQLH PRşQD]P\ZDúZNRV]XGROQ\PUD]HP ]QRUPDOQLH]DEUXG]RQ\PLQDF]\QLDPL XĭRşRQ\PLZNRV]XJyUQ\P ,QWHQV\ZQRłúQDWU\VNLZDQLDZNRV]X GROQ\PMHVWZ]PRşRQDWHPSHUDWXUD ]P\ZDQLDWURFKċSRGZ\şV]RQD (NVWUDVXV]HQLH (NVWUDVX ]HQLH 3RGZ\şV]RQDWHPSHUDWXUDSRGF]DV SĭXNDQLD]QDEĭ\V]F]DQLHP LSU]HGĭXşRQDID]DVXV]HQLDXPRşOLZLDMø OHSV]HZ\VXV]HQLHWDNşHF]ċłFL ]WZRU]\ZDV]WXF]QHJR=Xş\FLHHQHUJLL XOHJDQLHZLHONLHPX]ZLċNV]HQLX XJD2 áEV DQLHG]ą]XU 3DUDPHWU\SURJUDPyZ 'DQHSURJUDPX SDUDPHWU\]Xş\FLD SU]HGVWDZLRQRZNUyWNLHMLQVWUXNFML 'DQHRGQRV]øVLċGRZDUXQNyZ QRUPDOQ\FKLZDUWRłFLXVWDZLHQLD WZDUGRłFLZRG\¯5yşQHF]\QQLNL Z\ZLHUDMøFHZSĭ\ZMDNQSWHPSHUDWXUD ZRG\OXEFLłQLHQLHZRGRFLøJXPRJø VSRZRGRZDúRGFK\ĭNL &]XMQLN$TXDVWDQXZRG\ &]XMQLN$TXD VWDQXZRG\ Z]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX $TXDVHQVRUWRRSW\F]Q\SU]\U]øG SRPLDURZ\ EUDPNDIRWRNRPyUNRZD PLHU]øF\VWDQ]PċWQLHQLDZRG\ &]XMQLN$TXDMHVWXş\ZDQ\Z]DOHşQRłFL RGVSHF\ILNLZ\EUDQHJRSURJUDPX $NW\ZRZDQLHIXQNFML$TXDVHQVRUSROHJD QDSU]HMċFLXÅF]\VWHM´ZRG\SĭXF]øFHM GRQDVWċSQHJR]P\ZDQLDZZ\QLNX F]HJR]PQLHMV]HQLXXOHJD]Xş\FLHZRG\ RGGROLWUyZ:SU]\SDGNX PRFQLHMV]HJR]DEUXG]HQLDQDVWċSXMH Z\SRPSRZDQLHL]DVWøSLHQLHF]\VWø ZRGø:SURJUDPDFKDXWRPDW\F]Q\FK GRGDWNRZRGRSDVRZ\ZDQDMHVW WHPSHUDWXUDLF]DVWUZDQLDSURJUDPX GRVWRSQLD]DEUXG]HQLD SO 2EVĭXJDXU]øG]HQLD :ĥøF]HQLHXU]øG]HQLD 2WZRU]\úFDĭNRZLFLH]DZyUZRG\ :ĭøF]\úSU]HĭøF]QLN:Ĭ÷&= :<Ĭ÷&= 3U]HNUċFLúSURJUDPDWRU QDşøGDQ\SURJUDP 1DZ\łZLHWODF]XF\IURZ\P+PLJD SU]HZLG\ZDQ\F]DVWUZDQLD SURJUDPX 1DFLVQøúSU]\FLVN67$57# 3U]HELHJSURJUDPXVWDUWXMH :VND]yZND ZFHOXHNRORJLF]QHMHNVSORDWDFML ]P\ZDUNLGRQDF]\ħ 3URJUDP(FRMHVWSURJUDPHP V]F]HJyOQLHFKURQLøF\PĹURGRZLVNR QDWXUDOQH-HVWWRÅSURJUDP VWDQGDUGRZ\´ZHGĥXJ5R]SRU]øG]HQLD .RPLVML8(SU]HGVWDZLDMøF\ ZQDMEDUG]LHMZ\GDMQ\VSRVyE VWDQGDUGRZ\F\NO]P\ZDQLDQRUPDOQLH ]DEUXG]RQ\FKQDF]\ħRUD]SRĥøF]RQH ]XŐ\FLHHQHUJLLHOHNWU\F]QHMLZRG\ Z\NRU]\VWDQHMGR]P\ZDQLDWHJR URG]DMXQDF]\ħ :VNDŎQLNF]DVXGRNRħFD SURJUDPX 3RGF]DVZ\ERUXSURJUDPXSRND]\ZDQ\ MHVWQDZ\łZLHWODF]XF\IURZ\P+ SR]RVWDĭ\F]DVSU]HELHJXSURJUDPX &]DVWUZDQLDSURJUDPXSRGF]DVMHJR SU]HELHJXMHVW]DOHşQ\RGWHPSHUDWXU\ ZRG\LORłFLQDF]\įMDNLVWRSQLD ]DEUXG]HQLDLPRşHXOHJDú]PLDQRP Z ]DOHşQRłFLRGZ\EUDQHJRSURJUDPX 1DVWDZLDQLHF]DVXZĭøF]HQLD 1DVWDZLDQLHF]DVXZĥøF]HQLD Z]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX 6WDUWSURJUDPXPRşQDRSyŝQLú PDNV\PDOQLHRJRG]LQ\ZVSRVyE VWRSQLRZDQ\FRMHGQøJRG]LQċ =DPNQøúGU]ZL :ĭøF]\úSU]HĭøF]QLN:Ĭ÷&= :<Ĭ÷&= 3U]\FLVN3WDNGĭXJRQDFLVNDú DşZ\łZLHWODF]F\IURZ\+ SU]HĭøF]\VLċQD¤¯³ 3U]\FLVN3W\OHUD]\QDFLVQøú DşEċG]LHZ\łZLHWODQ\şøGDQ\F]DV 1DFLVQøúSU]\FLVN67$57# IXQNFMDSUHVHOHNFMLF]DVXMHVW DNW\ZRZDQD :FHOXZ\ĭøF]HQLDIXQNFMLSUHVHOHNFML F]DVXSU]\FLVN3W\OHUD]\ QDFLVQøúDşQDZ\łZLHWODF]X F\IURZ\PEċG]LHSRND]DQ\¤¯¯ :\ELHUDQLHSURJUDPXPRşQD GRZROQLH]PLHQLúDşGRPRPHQWX VWDUWXSURJUDPX .RQLHFSURJUDPX 3URJUDPMHVW]DNRįF]RQ\JG\ QDZ\łZLHWODF]XF\IURZ\P+SRMDZL VLċZDUWRłú¯¯¯ 2EVĭXJDXU]øG]HQLD SO $XWRPDW\F]QHZ\ĥøF]HQLH SR]DNRħF]HQLXSURJUDPX :\ĥøF]\úXU]øG]HQLH $XWRPDW\F]QHZ\ĭøF]HQLHSR]DNRįF]HQLXSURJUDPX Z]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX :FHOX]DRV]F]ċG]HQLDHQHUJLL ]P\ZDUNDZ\ĭøF]DVLċPLQXWċ SR]DNRįF]HQLXSURJUDPX QDVWDZLHQLH IDEU\F]QH $XWRPDW\F]QHZ\ĭøF]HQLHPRşQD XVWDZLúRGƯ¯GRƯ Ư¯ 8U]øG]HQLHQLHZ\ĭøF]D VLċDXWRPDW\F]QLH Ư³ .RQLHFSRPLQ Ư .RQLHFSRPLQ =DPNQøúGU]ZL :ĭøF]\úSU]HĭøF]QLN:Ĭ÷&= :<Ĭ÷&= 1DFLVQøúSU]\FLVN67$57# LSU]\WU]\PDúZFLłQLċW\ 3URJUDPDWRUSU]HNUċFDú DşZ\łZLHWODF]F\IURZ\+ZVNDşH Ư 3XłFLúSU]\FLVN :\łZLHWODF]F\IURZ\+ZVND]XMH IDEU\F]QLHXVWDZLRQøZDUWRłúƯ³ :FHOX]PLDQ\WHJRXVWDZLHQLD 3URJUDPDWRUSU]HNUċFDú DşZ\PDJDQDZDUWRłúXNDşHVLċ QDZ\łZLHWODF]XF\IURZ\P+ 1DFLVQøúSU]\FLVN67$57# 1DVWDZLHQLHSR]RVWDMH]DSLVDQH ZSDPLċFL .UyWNRSR]DNRįF]HQLXSURJUDPX :\ĭøF]\úSU]HĭøF]QLN:Ĭ÷&= :<Ĭ÷&= =DPNQøúNXUHNGRSĭ\ZXZRG\ ]EċGQHSU]\$TXD6WRS :\MøúQDF]\QLDSRLFKRFKĭRG]HQLX :VND]yZND 3R]DNRįF]HQLXSURJUDPXSR]RVWDZLú XU]øG]HQLHDşVLċRFKĭRG]L']LċNLWHPX PRşQD]DSRELHFZ\GRVWDZDQLXVLċSDU\ NWyUDQDGĭXşV]øPHWċSRZRGXMHV]NRG\ QDPHEODFK 3U]HUZDQLHSURJUDPX :\ĭøF]\úSU]HĭøF]QLN:Ĭ÷&= :<Ĭ÷&= /DPSNLNRQWUROQH]JDVQø3URJUDP SR]RVWDMH]DSLVDQ\ZSDPLċFL :SU]\SDGNXRWZRU]HQLDGU]ZL ]P\ZDUNLSRGĭøF]RQHMGR]DVLODQLD FLHSĭøZRGøOXEMXşUR]JU]DQHM PDV]\Q\QDOHş\QDMSLHUZQDNLOND PLQXWOHNNRSU]\PNQøúGU]ZL DSRWHPGRSLHURFDĭNRZLFLH ]DPNQøú:SU]HFLZQ\PZ\SDGNX ]SRZRGXUR]V]HU]DOQRłFLFLHSOQHM QDGFLłQLHQLH PRJøRWZRU]\úVLċ GU]ZLXU]øG]HQLDOXEPRşHZ\Sĭ\Qøú ZRGD]XU]øG]HQLD :FHOXNRQW\QXDFMLSURJUDPX]QyZ ZĭøF]\úSU]HĭøF]QLN:Ĭ÷&= :<Ĭ÷&= SO 2EVĭXJDXU]øG]HQLD 3U]HUZDQLHSURJUDPX 5HVHW 6XV]HQLHLQWHQV\ZQH 3U]\FLVN67$57#QDFLVNDú SU]H]RNVHN :\łZLHWODF]F\IURZ\+ SU]HGVWDZLD¯¯³ 3U]HELHJSURJUDPXWUZD RNPLQXWċ1DZ\łZLHWODF]X F\IURZ\P+SRMDZLDVLċ¯¯¯ :\ĭøF]\úSU]HĭøF]QLN:Ĭ÷&= :<Ĭ÷&= 3ĭXNDQLHNRįFRZHMHVWSU]HSURZDG]DQH SU]\SRGZ\şV]RQHMWHPSHUDWXU]H DE\SROHSV]\úZ\QLNLVXV]HQLD&]DV WUZDQLDPRşHVLċQLH]QDF]QLH SU]HGĭXş\ú 2VWURşQLH]ZUDşOLZ\PL QDF]\QLDPL =DPNQøúGU]ZL :ĭøF]\úSU]HĭøF]QLN:Ĭ÷&= :<Ĭ÷&= 1DFLVQøúSU]\FLVN67$57# LSU]\WU]\PDúZFLłQLċW\ 3URJUDPDWRUSU]HNUċFDú DşZ\łZLHWODF]F\IURZ\+ ZVNDşHʯ¯ 3XłFLúSU]\FLVN :\łZLHWODF]F\IURZ\+ZVND]XMH IDEU\F]QLHXVWDZLRQøZDUWRłúʯ¯ VXV]HQLHLQWHQV\ZQHZ\ĭøF]RQH 8VWDZLHQLH]PLHQLúZQDVWċSXMøF\ VSRVyE 3U]H]SU]HNUċFDQLH SURJUDPDWRUDPRşQDZĭøF]\ú VXV]HQLHLQWHQV\ZQHʯ³OXE Z\ĭøF]\úʯ¯ 1DFLVQøúSU]\FLVN67$57# :DUWRłúQDVWDZLHQLDMHVW]DSLVDQD ZSDPLċFL 3U]HUZDQLHSURJUDPX =PLDQDSURJUDPX 3RQDFLłQLċFLXSU]\FLVNX67$57# QLHMHVWPRşOLZD]PLDQDSURJUDPX =PLDQDSURJUDPXMHVWPRşOLZDW\ONR SRSU]H]MHJRSU]HUZDQLH 5HVHW &]\V]F]HQLHRUD]SU]HJOøG SO &]\V]F]HQLHRUD] SU]HJOøG HQLH]F& ]\V] ]DRU GąJOH]SU 5HJXODUQDNRQWURODLNRQVHUZDFMD XU]øG]HQLDSRPDJD]ZLċNV]\ú MHJRQLH]DZRGQRłú7RSRPDJD ZRV]F]ċG]DQLXF]DVXLSLHQLċG]\ 2JyOQ\VWDQXU]øG]HQLD 3URV]ċVNRQWURORZDúZQċWU]H SRGZ]JOċGHPRVDGyZZDSLHQQ\FK LWĭXV]F]X :UD]LHVWZLHUG]HQLDZ\VWċSRZDQLD WDNLFKRVDGyZ ʋ 1DSHĭQLúSRMHPQLNQDłURGHN F]\V]F]øF\łURGNLHPF]\V]F]øF\P :ĭøF]\ú]P\ZDUNċEH]QDF]\į QDVWDZLDMøFSURJUDP]QDMZ\şV]ø WHPSHUDWXUø]P\ZDQLD 'RF]\V]F]HQLDXU]øG]HQLDVWRVRZDú W\ONRVSHFMDOQHłURGNLF]\V]F]øFH SUHSDUDW\SU]H]QDF]RQHGRF]\V]F]HQLD ]P\ZDUHN ʋ $E\XU]øG]HQLHVĭXş\ĭRMDNQDMGĭXşHM QDOHş\JRUHJXODUQLHF]\łFLúSU]\ Xş\FLXVSHFMDOQHJRłURGND F]\V]F]øFHJRGR]P\ZDUHN ʋ $E\XV]F]HOQLHQLHGU]ZLE\ĭR]DZV]H F]\VWHLKLJLHQLF]QHSURV]ċMH UHJXODUQLHSU]HP\ZDúZLOJRWQø łFLHUNøXş\ZDMøFWURFKċSĭ\QX GR]P\ZDQLD ʋ -HłOLXU]øG]HQLHQLHEċG]LHXş\ZDQH SU]H]GĭXşV]\F]DVSURV]ċ SR]RVWDZLúOHNNRXFK\ORQHGU]ZLDE\ ]DSRELHFSRZVWDZDQLX QLHSU]\MHPQ\FK]DSDFKyZ ʋ 'RF]\V]F]HQLD]P\ZDUNLQLJG\QLH Xş\ZDúP\MNLSDURZHM JHQHUDWRUDSDU\ 3URGXFHQWQLHSRQRVLRGSRZLHG]LDOQRłFL ]DHZHQWXDOQHV]NRG\ &]ċłúF]RĭRZøXU]øG]HQLDLSXOSLW REVĭXJLUHJXODUQLHSU]HP\ZDúOHNNR ZLOJRWQøłFLHUNøZ\VWDUF]\ZRGD LWURFKċSĭ\QXGR]P\ZDQLD1LHXş\ZDú JøEHNGRV]RURZDQLDRUD]V]RUXMøF\FK łURGNyZF]\V]F]øF\FK LFK]DVWRVRZDQLHPRşHVSRZRGRZDú ]DGUDSDQLDSRZLHU]FKQLXU]øG]HQLD :SU]\SDGNXXU]øG]Hį]HVWDOL V]ODFKHWQHM8QLNDúVWRVRZDQLDłFLHUHN ]PDWHULDĭXJøEF]DVWHJROXESU]HG SLHUZV]\PXş\FLHZ\SĭXNDúMH ZLHORNURWQLHDE\XQLNQøúNRUR]ML H 2VWU]HŐHQLH²=DJURŐHQLHGOD ]GURZLD 1LJG\QLHXş\ZDúLQQ\FKłURGNyZ F]\V]F]øF\FKGODJRVSRGDUVWZD GRPRZHJRQDSU]\NĭDG]DZLHUDMøF\FK FKORU 6yOVSHFMDOQDLSĥ\Q QDEĥ\V]F]DMøF\ ʋ 6NRQWURORZDúZVNDŝQLNLVWDQX QDSHĭQLHQLDKLC:UD]LH SRWU]HE\QDSHĭQLúVROøLOXESĭ\QHP QDEĭ\V]F]DMøF\P SO &]\V]F]HQLHRUD]SU]HJOøG 6LWND 5DPLRQDVSU\VNXMøFH 6LWND5]DWU]\PXMøGXşH ]DQLHF]\V]F]HQLD]QDMGXMøFHVLċ ZZRG]LHSR]RVWDĭHMSRP\FLXQDF]\į QLHGRSXV]F]DMøFLFKGRSRPS\ =DQLHF]\V]F]HQLDWHPRJøRGF]DVX GRF]DVX]DWNDúVLWND 8NĭDGILOWUXMøF\VNĭDGDVLċ]VLWD ]JUXEQHJRSĭDVNLHJRVLWDGUREQHJR LPLNURVLWD 3RNDşG\P]P\ZDQLXVNRQWURORZDú ILOWUSRGNøWHPRVDGyZ 2GNUċFLúF\OLQGHUVLWRZ\ MDNSRND]DQRQDU\VXQNX LZ\FLøJQøúXNĭDGILOWUXMøF\ :DSįL]DQLHF]\V]F]HQLDSRFKRG]øFH ]ZRG\GR]P\ZDQLDPRJø]DEORNRZDú G\V]HLĭRş\VNDUDPLRQVSU\VNXMøF\FK L% 6NRQWURORZDúG\V]HUDPLRQ VSU\VNXMøF\FKSRGZ]JOċGHP ]DWNDQLD 2GNUċFLúJyUQHUDPLċ VSU\VNXMøFH 'ROQHUDPLċVSU\VNXMøFH% Z\FLøJQøúGRJyU\ :\P\úUDPLRQDVSU\VNXMøFH SRGELHşøFøZRGø =DĭRş\úOXESU]\NUċFLú]QyZUDPLRQD VSU\VNXMøFH 8VXQøúHZHQWXDOQLHZ\VWċSXMøFH UHV]WNLLRF]\łFLúVLWDSRGELHşøFø ZRGø 8NĭDGILOWUXMøF\]DPRQWRZDú ZFKURQRORJLF]QLHRGZURWQHM NROHMQRłFL]ZUDFDMøFSU]\W\P XZDJċDE\SR]DPNQLċFLXVWU]DĭNL VWDĭ\QDSU]HFLZNRVLHELH &RURELúZUD]LHXVWHUNL" SO &RURELúZUD]LH XVWHUNL" &R üRELU Z HL]DU "NLUHWVX =GRłZLDGF]HįZ\QLNDşHZLċNV]Rłú XVWHUHNZ\VWċSXMøF\FKZFRG]LHQQHM HNVSORDWDFMLPRşQDXVXQøúZHZĭDVQ\P ]DNUHVLHEH]Z]\ZDQLDVHUZLVX7\P VDP\P]DSHZQLRQH]RVWDMHV]\ENLH SU]\ZUyFHQLHVSUDZQRłFLXU]øG]HQLD: QLQLHMV]\PSU]HJOøG]LHXVWHUHN SU]HGVWDZLRQHVøPRşOLZHSU]\F]\Q\ XVWHUHNRUD]ZVND]yZNLGRW\F]øFHLFK XVXQLċFLD :WDNLPSU]\SDGNXQDOHş\ =DVDGQLF]RQDMSLHUZRGĭøF]\ú XU]øG]HQLHRGVLHFLHOHNWU\F]QHM :\MøúNRV]JyUQ\LGROQ\E :\PRQWRZDúILOWU\5 &]HUSDNLHPXVXQøúZRGċHZHQW]D SRPRFøJøENL %LDĭøSRNU\ZċSRPS\SRGZDş\ú]D SRPRFøĭ\şHF]NL MDNSRND]DQR QDU\VXQNX 3RNU\ZċFKZ\FLú]D SU]HJUyGNċLSRGQLHłúMøVNRłQLHGR ZQċWU]D&DĭNRZLFLH]GMøúSRNU\Zċ :VND]yZND -HşHOLXU]øG]HQLHQLHZĭøF]\VLċOXE ]DWU]\PDVLċSRGF]DV]P\ZDQLDQDF]\į ]QLHZLDGRP\FKSU]\F]\QSURV]ċ QDMSLHUZSU]HSURZDG]LúIXQNFMċ Å$QXORZDQLHSURJUDPX´ 5HVHW SDWU]UR]G]LDĭÅ2EVĭXJDXU]øG]HQLD´ H 2VWU]HŐHQLH²1DOHş\SDPLċWDú RW\PşH:\NRQ\ZDQLHQDSUDZ\MHVW GR]ZRORQHW\ONRVSHFMDOLVWRP:UD]LH SRWU]HE\Z\PLDQ\F]ċłFLSURV]ċ]ZUyFLú XZDJċE\Xş\WRW\ONRRU\JLQDOQ\FK F]ċłFL]DPLHQQ\FK1LHSUDZLGĭRZR Z\NRQDQHQDSUDZ\OXEXş\FLHLQQ\FK QLşRU\JLQDOQHF]ċłFL]DPLHQQHPRJø VSRZRGRZDú]QDF]QHV]NRG\LVWDQRZLú ]DJURşHQLHGODXş\WNRZQLND 6NRQWURORZDúZLUQLNVNU]\GHĭNRZ\ F]\]QDMGXMøVLċZQLPSU]\SDGNRZH SU]HGPLRW\LZUD]LHZ\VWċSRZDQLD XVXQøúMH 3RNU\ZċXPLHłFLúZSLHUZRWQHM SR]\FMLLQDFLVQøúMøZGyĭZFHOX ]DWU]DłQLċFLD]DF]HSyZ NOLNQLċFLH 3RPSDRGSĥ\ZX 'XşHUHV]WNLSRWUDZOXESU]\SDGNRZH SU]HGPLRW\NWyUHQLH]RVWDĭ\]DWU]\PDQH QDVLWDFKPRJøVSRZRGRZDú ]DEORNRZDQLHSRPS\RGSĭ\ZX/XVWUR ZRG\SĭXF]øFHMMHVWZWHG\QDGVLWHP &/,&. H 2VWU]HŐHQLH²1LHEH]SLHF]HħVWZR VNDOHF]HQLDVLĊ 3RGF]DVF]\V]F]HQLDSRPS\RGSĭ\ZX ]ZUDFDúXZDJċQDWRDE\VLċ QLHVNDOHF]\úNDZDĭNDPLV]NĭDOXE RVWU\PLSU]HGPLRWDPL =DPRQWRZDúILOWU\ 3RQRZQLHZĭRş\úNRV]H SO &RURELúZUD]LHXVWHUNL" 7DEHONDXVWHUHN 8VWHUND ŃZLHFLVLċZVNDšQLN Å6SUDZG]LúGRSį\Z ZRG\´ 3U]\F]\QD =DįDPDQLHZċţDGRSį\ZXZRG\ =DPNQLċW\]DZyUGRSį\ZXZRG\ =DZyUZRG\]DEORNRZDQ\OXE SRNU\W\RVDGHPZDSLHQQ\P =DWNDQ\ILOWUGRSį\ZXZRG\ ŃZLHFLVLċNRGEįċGX §¯Å ŃZLHFLVLċNRGEįċGX §³ :\F]\ńFLúILOWUZZċţXGRSį\ZX3RQRZQLH GRNUċFLúSU]\įøF]HGRSį\ZXZRG\ 6SUDZG]LúV]F]HOQRńú3U]\ZUyFLú]DVLODQLH SUøGRZH:įøF]\úXU]øG]HQLH 1DF]\QLDXNįDGDúZWDNLVSRVyEDE\RWZyU 2WZyU]DV\VDQLD SRSUDZHM VWURQLHZHZQøWU]XU]øG]HQLD MHVW ]DV\VDQLDE\įRGVįRQLċW\ ]DVįRQLċW\QDF]\QLDPL (OHPHQWJU]HMQ\SRNU\W\RVDGHP 3U]HSURZDG]LúF]\V]F]HQLHXU]øG]HQLD ZDSLHQQ\PDOER]DEUXG]RQ\ ńURGNDPLF]\V]F]øF\PLGR]P\ZDUHNDOER Xţ\úRGZDSQLDF]D(NVSORDWRZDú]P\ZDUNċ ]ZįøF]RQ\PXNįDGHP]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\ LVSUDZG]LúQDVWDZLHQLH SDWU]UR]G]LDį 8NįDG]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\6yOVSHFMDOQD $NW\ZQ\V\VWHPRFKURQ\ZRG\ =DPNQøú]DZyUZRG\ 3URV]ċZH]ZDúVHUZLVSRGDMøFNRGEįċGX ŃZLHFLVLċNRGEįċGX §³ ŃZLHFLVLċNRGEįċGX§³ ŃZLHFLVLċNRGEįċGX 6WDį\GRSį\ZZRG\ §³± )LOWU\5]DQLHF]\V]F]RQHOXE ŃZLHFLVLċNRG EįċGX§ ]DWNDQH ŁURGNL]DUDGF]H :øţGRSį\ZXZRG\XįRţ\úEH]]DįDPDı 2WZRU]\ú]DZyUZRG\ 2WZRU]\ú]DZyUZRG\ 1DWċţHQLHSU]HSį\ZXZRG\SU]\RWZDUW\P GRSį\ZLHPXVLZ\QRVLúSU]\QDMPQLHMO PLQ :\įøF]\úXU]øG]HQLHLZ\FLøJQøúZW\F]Nċ =DNUċFLú]DZyUZRG\2GNUċFLúSU]\įøF]H GRSį\ZXZRG\ :\F]\ńFLúILOWU\ 3DWU]Å&]\V]F]HQLHRUD]SU]HJOøG´ &RURELúZUD]LHXVWHUNL" SO 8VWHUND ŃZLHFLVLċNRG EįċGX§ 3U]\F]\QD =DWNDQ\OXE]DįDPDQ\Zøţ RGSį\ZRZ\ 3RGįøF]HQLHV\IRQXMHVWMHV]F]H ]DPNQLċWH /XšQDRVįRQDSRPS\RGSį\ZX ŃZLHFLVLċNRG EįċGX§ 3RPSDRGSį\ZXMHVW ]DEORNRZDQDOXERVįRQDSRPS\ RGSį\ZXQLHMHVW]DWU]DńQLċWD =E\WQLVNLHQDSLċFLH ŃZLHFLVLċNRG EįċGX§Å 1DZ\ńZLHWODF]XF\IURZ\P 3UDZGRSRGREQLHZ\VWøSLįD SRMDZLDVLċLQQ\NRGEįċGX XVWHUNDWHFKQLF]QD §¯³GR§´¯ 0LJDZVNDšQLN 'U]ZLQLHVøGRNįDGQLH ]DPNQLċWH ŃZLHFLVLċZVNDšQLNEUDNX %UDNSį\QXQDEį\V]F]DMøFHJR VROLKLOXESį\QX %UDNVROL QDEį\V]F]DMøFHJRC &]XMQLNQLHUR]SR]QDMHSDVW\OHN VROL :VNDšQLNEUDNXVROLK :VNDšQLNZ\įøF]RQ\ LOXESį\QX QDEį\V]F]DMøFHJRCQLH ńZLHFLVLċ :\VWDUF]DMøF\]DSDVVROL VSHFMDOQHMSį\QX QDEį\V]F]DMøFHJR 3R]DNRıF]HQLXSURJUDPX =DWNDQ\V\VWHPILOWUXMøF\OXE REV]DUSRGILOWUDPL5 ZRGDSR]RVWDMH ZXU]øG]HQLX 3URJUDPQLHMHVWMHV]F]H ]DNRıF]RQ\ ŁURGNL]DUDGF]H 8įRţ\úZøţEH]]DįDPDıHZHQWXDOQLH XVXQøúSR]RVWDįRńFL 6SUDZG]LúSRGįøF]HQLHSU]\V\IRQLH LHZHQWXDOQLHRWZRU]\ú 3UDZLGįRZR]DWU]DVQøúRVįRQċ 3DWU]Å3RPSDRGSį\ZX´ :\F]\ńFLúSRPSċLSUDZLGįRZR]DWU]DVQøú RVįRQċ 3DWU]Å3RPSDRGSį\ZX´ 1LHMHVWWREįøGXU]øG]HQLDVSUDZG]Lú QDSLċFLHLLQVWDODFMċHOHNWU\F]Qø :\įøF]\úXU]øG]HQLHSU]HįøF]QLNLHP :Į÷&=:<Į÷&= 3RFKZLOL SRQRZQLHZįøF]\úXU]øG]HQLH -HńOLSUREOHPZ\VWøSLSRQRZQLHZWHG\ ]DNUċFLú]DZyUZRG\Z\MøúZW\F]Nċ VLHFLRZø 3URV]ċZH]ZDúVHUZLVSRGDMøFNRGEįċGX =DPNQøúGU]ZL=ZUDFDúXZDJċQDWRDE\ ]NRV]DQLHZ\VWDZDį\ţDGQHSU]HGPLRW\ QDF]\QLDRGńZLHţDF] XWUXGQLDMøF ]DPNQLċFLHGU]ZL 1DSHįQLúSį\QHPQDEį\V]F]DMøF\P 1DSHįQLúVROøVSHFMDOQø =DVWRVRZDúLQQøVyOVSHFMDOQø $NW\ZDFMDGHDNW\ZDFMD SDWU]UR]G]LDį 8NįDG]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\6yOVSHFMDOQDOXE 3į\QQDEį\V]F]DMøF\ 6SUDZG]LúZVNDšQLNLQDSHįQLHQLH :\F]\ńFLúILOWU\LREV]DUSRGILOWUDPL SDWU] Å3RPSDRGSį\ZX´ 3RF]HNDúGRNRıFDSURJUDPXOXE SU]HSURZDG]LúIXQNFMċ5HVHW SDWU] Å$QXORZDQLHSURJUDPX´ SO &RURELúZUD]LHXVWHUNL" 8VWHUND 1DF]\QLDQLHVøVXFKH 3U]\F]\QD %UDNOXE]DPDįRSį\QX QDEį\V]F]DMøFHJRZ]ELRUQLNX :\EUDQRSURJUDPEH]VXV]HQLD ŁURGNL]DUDGF]H 1DSHįQLúSį\QHPQDEį\V]F]DMøF\P :\EUDúSURJUDP]VXV]HQLHP SDWU] Å3U]HJOøGSURJUDPyZ´Å3U]HELHJ SURJUDPX´ :RGDZ]DJįċELHQLDFKQDF]\ıOXE =ZUDFDúXZDJċQDXNRńQHXV\WXRZDQLH V]WXúFyZ SU]\ZNįDGDQLXQDF]\ıXįRţ\úQDF]\QLD XNRńQLH 3URV]ċXţ\úLQQ\NRPSDNWRZ\ńURGHN F]\V]F]øF\]OHSV]øVNXWHF]QRńFLø VXV]HQLD'RGDWNRZH]DVWRVRZDQLHSį\QX QDEį\V]F]DMøFHJR]ZLċNV]DVNXWHF]QRńú VXV]HQLD $NW\ZRZDúVXV]HQLHLQWHQV\ZQH SDWU] 1LHDNW\ZRZDQRVXV]HQLD LQWHQV\ZQHJRZFHOX]ZLċNV]HQLD Å2EVįXJDXU]øG]HQLD´ HIHNWXVXV]HQLD 3RF]HNDúGRNRıFDSURJUDPXOXEZ\Møú =E\WZF]HńQLHZ\MċWRQDF]\QLD QDF]\QLDGRSLHURPLQXWSR]DNRıF]HQLX OXESURFHVVXV]HQLDQLH]RVWDį SURJUDPX MHV]F]H]DNRıF]RQ\ 3URV]ċVWRVRZDúPDUNRZ\Sį\Q =įDVNXWHF]QRńúVXV]HQLD QDEį\V]F]DMøF\(NRORJLF]QHSURGXNW\PDMø HNRORJLF]QHJRSį\QX ]QDF]QLHJRUV]øVNXWHF]QRńúG]LDįDQLD QDEį\V]F]DMøFHJR 1DF]\QLD]WZRU]\ZD 6]F]HJyOQHZįDńFLZRńFL 7ZRU]\ZRV]WXF]QHRG]QDF]DVLċQLţV]ø V]WXF]QHJRQLHVøVXFKH WZRU]\ZDV]WXF]QHJR ZįDńFLZRńFLøNXPXORZDQLDFLHSįDLGODWHJR JRU]HMVLċVXV]\ 6]WXúFHQLHVøVXFKH 1LHNRU]\VWQLHSRXNįDGDQH 3URV]ċSRXNįDGDúV]WXúHSRMHG\QF]R V]WXúFHZNRV]\NXQDV]WXúFH XQLNDMøFLFKVW\NDQLDVLċ 1LHNRU]\VWQLHSRXNįDGDQH 3URV]ċSUDZLGįRZRSRXNįDGDúV]WXúH V]WXúFHZV]XIODG]LHQDV]WXúFH LZHGįXJPRţOLZRńFLSRMHG\QF]R :QċWU]HXU]øG]HQLDPRNUH 1LHMHVWWREįøGXU]øG]HQLD =HZ]JOċGXQD]DVDGċVXV]HQLD SRSURFHVLH]P\ZDQLD NRQGHVDF\MQHJRNURSOHZRG\VøSRţøGDQH RUD]XZDUXQNRZDQHIL]\F]QLH:LOJRWQH SRZLHWU]HVNUDSODVLċQDńFLDQNDFKZQċWU]D ]P\ZDUNLZRGDVSį\ZDL]RVWDMH RGSRPSRZDQD =įDVNXWHF]QRńúVXV]HQLD Xţ\ZDQHJRNRPSDNWRZHJR SURGXNWXF]\V]F]øFHJR &RURELúZUD]LHXVWHUNL" SO 8VWHUND 5HV]WNLSRWUDZ QDQDF]\QLDFK 3U]\F]\QD 1DF]\QLD]DFLDVQRXįRţRQH SU]HSHįQLRQ\NRV]QDQDF]\QLD 8WUXGQLRQ\UXFKREURWRZ\ UDPLHQLDVSU\VNXMøFHJR '\V]HUDPLRQVSU\VNXMøF\FK ]DWNDQH )LOWU\5]DQLHF]\V]F]RQH ŠOHRVDG]RQHILOWU\5RUD] OXEQLH]DWU]DńQLċWH =DVįDE\SURJUDP]P\ZDQLD 1DF]\QLD]RVWDį\ZVWċSQLH]E\W VLOQLHRF]\V]F]RQHGODWHJR F]XMQLN]DGHF\GRZDįZįøF]\ú VįDEV]\SURJUDP6LOQH ]DEUXG]HQLDQLHGDMøVLċ F]ċńFLRZRXVXQøú :\VRNLHZøVNLHV]NįDQLHVø GRVWDWHF]QLHZ\SįXNLZDQH ZURJDFK]P\ZDUNL .RV]JyUQ\QLHMHVW XVWDZLRQ\QDWHMVDPHMZ\VRNRńFL SROHZHMLSUDZHMVWURQLH ŁURGNL]DUDGF]H 1DF]\QLDXįRţ\úZWDNLVSRVyEDE\ ]DJZDUDQWRZDúZ\VWDUF]DMøFRPLHMVFDWDN DE\VWUXPLHQLHZRG\PRJį\GRWU]Hú GRSRZLHU]FKQLQDF]\ı8QLNDúVW\NDQLDVLċ ZįRţRQ\FKSU]HGPLRWyZ 8įRţ\úQDF]\QLDZWDNLVSRVyEDE\UDPLRQD VSU\VNXMøFHPRJį\VLċVZRERGQLHREUDFDú :\F]\ńFLúG\V]HUDPLRQVSU\VNXMøF\FK 3DWU]Å&]\V]F]HQLHRUD]SU]HJOøG´ :\F]\ńFLúILOWU\ SDWU]Å&]\V]F]HQLHRUD] SU]HJOøG´ 3UDZLGįRZR]DįRţ\úILOWU\L]DWU]DVQøú :\EUDúLQWHQV\ZQLHMV]\SURJUDP]P\ZDQLD 1LH]P\ZDúZVWċSQLHQDF]\ı8VXQøúW\ONR ZLċNV]HUHV]WNLSRWUDZ =DOHFHQLHSURJUDPX(FROXE ,QWHQV\ZQLH 1LHXNįDGDúZ\VRNLFKZøVNLFKV]NLHį]E\W XNRńQLHLQLHXVWDZLDúLFKZURJDFK ]P\ZDUNL 8VWDZLúJyUQ\NRV]]ERF]Q\PLGšZLJQLDPL QDWHMVDPHMZ\VRNRńFL SO &RURELúZUD]LHXVWHUNL" 8VWHUND 3R]RVWDįRńFLńURGND F]\V]F]øFHJR 3U]\F]\QD 3RNU\ZDSRMHPQLNDQDńURGHN F]\V]F]øF\MHVW]DEORNRZDQD SU]H]QDF]\QLDGODWHJRSRNU\ZD QLHRWZLHUDVLċFDįNRZLFLH 3RNU\ZDSRMHPQLNDQDńURGHN F]\V]F]øF\]DEORNRZDQDSU]H] WDEOHWNċ 8ţ\WRWDEOHWNLZSURJUDPLH V]\ENLPOXENUyWNLP &]DVSRWU]HEQ\ GODUR]SXV]F]HQLDVLċńURGND F]\V]F]øFHJRQLH]RVWDMH RVLøJQLċW\ZZ\EUDQ\P SURJUDPLH 6NXWHF]QRńúF]\V]F]HQLD L]GROQRńúUR]SXV]F]HQLDVLċ SURGXNWXSU]HGįXţDVLċSU]\ GįXţV]\PSU]HFKRZ\ZDQLX SURGXNWXOXEńURGHNF]\V]F]øF\ MHVWPRFQR]EU\ORQ\ 3ODP\]ZRG\QDF]ċńFLDFK =HZ]JOċGyZIL]\F]Q\FKQLH ]WZRU]\ZDV]WXF]QHJR PRţQD]DSRELHFWZRU]HQLXVLċ NURSOLZRG\QDSRZLHU]FKQLDFK ]WZRU]\ZDV]WXF]QHJR3R Z\VXV]HQLXZLGRF]QHVøSODP\ ]ZRG\ 1DORW\ZSRMHPQLNXOXE QDGU]ZLDFK² UR]SXV]F]DOQHZZRG]LH OXEGDMøFHVLċ]HWU]Hú ŁURGNL]DUDGF]H 3RNU\ZDSRMHPQLNDQDńURGHNF]\V]F]øF\ QLHPRţHE\ú]DEORNRZDQDSU]H]QDF]\QLD 1LHNįDńúQDF]\ıOXERGńZLHţDF]\ GR]P\ZDUHNGRSRMHPQLNDQDWDEOHWNL 7DEOHWNDPXVLE\úZįRţRQDSRSU]HF]QLH² QLHVWDZLDúSLRQRZR &]DVUR]SXV]F]HQLDVLċWDEOHWNLMHVW]DGįXJL GODSURJUDPXV]\ENLHJROXENUyWNLHJR 8ţ\úSURV]NXGR]P\ZDUHNOXEZ\EUDú LQWHQV\ZQLHMV]\SURJUDP =PLHQLúńURGHNF]\V]F]øF\ :\EUDúLQWHQV\ZQLHMV]\SURJUDP ZLċFHM ZRG\ =ZUDFDúXZDJċQDXNRńQHXV\WXRZDQLH SU]\ZNįDGDQLXQDF]\ı =DVWRVRZDúSį\QQDEį\V]F]DMøF\ (ZHQWXDOQLH]ZLċNV]\úQDVWDZLHQLH ]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\ 2VDG]DMøVLċVNįDGQLNLńURGND =PLHQLúPDUNċńURGNDF]\V]F]øFHJR F]\V]F]øFHJR1DMF]ċńFLHMQDORW\ :\F]\ńFLúXU]øG]HQLHPHFKDQLF]QLH WHQLHPRţQDXVXQøúFKHPLF]QLH SRSU]H]SUHSDUDW\SU]H]QDF]RQH GRF]\V]F]HQLD]P\ZDUHN =ZLċNV]\úQDVWDZLHQLH]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\ 3U]\ÅELDį\PQDORFLH´QDGQLH SRMHPQLND]E\WQLVNRQDVWDZLRQR RUD]HZHQWXDOQLH]PLHQLúńURGHN F]\V]F]øF\ XNįDG]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\ 3RNU\ZD]ELRUQLNDVROL-QLH 3UDZLGįRZRGRNUċFLúSRNU\Zċ]ELRUQLNDVROL MHVWGRNUċFRQD 3DWU]Å8V]NRG]HQLDV]NįDLQDF]\ı´ 7\ONRSU]\V]NODQNDFKV]NOH 3RF]øWNXMøFDNRUR]MDV]NįDGDMċ VLċZ\WU]HúW\ONRSR]RUQLH &RURELúZUD]LHXVWHUNL" SO 8VWHUND %LDįHFLHţNLHGRXVXQLċFLD QDORW\QDQDF]\QLDFK SRMHPQLNDFKOXEGU]ZLDFK 3U]\F]\QD 2VDG]DMøVLċVNįDGQLNLńURGND F]\V]F]øFHJR1DMF]ċńFLHMQDORW\ WHQLHPRţQDXVXQøúFKHPLF]QLH SRSU]H]SUHSDUDW\SU]H]QDF]RQH GRF]\V]F]HQLD]P\ZDUHN ŠOHQDVWDZLRQ\]DNUHVWZDUGRńFL OXEWZDUGRńúZRG\SRZ\ţHM PPROO ŃURGHNF]\V]F]øF\LQOXE ńURGHNF]\V]F]øF\ELR HNRORJLF]Q\QLHMHVW Z\VWDUF]DMøFRVNXWHF]Q\ =DPDįRńURGNDF]\V]F]øFHJR :\EUDQR]DVįDE\SURJUDP ]P\ZDQLD 5HV]WNLKHUEDW\OXEV]PLQNL =E\WQLVNDWHPSHUDWXUD QDQDF]\QLDFK ]P\ZDQLD =DPDįRQLHZįDńFLZ\ńURGHN F]\V]F]øF\ 1DF]\QLD]RVWDį\ZVWċSQLH]E\W VLOQLHRF]\V]F]RQHGODWHJR F]XMQLN]DGHF\GRZDįZįøF]\ú VįDEV]\SURJUDP6LOQH ]DEUXG]HQLDQLHGDMøVLċ F]ċńFLRZRXVXQøú .RORURZH QLHELHVNLHţyįWH 7ZRU]HQLHVLċZDUVWZ ]HVNįDGQLNyZZDU]\Z QD EUø]RZH FLHţNLH SU]\NįDGNDSXVW\VHOHUDNDUWRIOL GRXVXQLċFLD PDNDURQX OXEZRG\ELHţøFHM GRQLHPRţOLZH QDSU]\NįDGPDQJDQX GRXVXQLċFLDQDORW\ ZXU]øG]HQLXOXEQD 7ZRU]HQLHVLċZDUVWZ QDF]\QLDFK]HVWDOL PHWDOLF]Q\FKVNįDGQLNyZ V]ODFKHWQHM QDQDF]\QLDFK]HVUHEUDOXE DOXPLQLXP .RORURZH ţyįWH 7ZRU]HQLHVLċZDUVWZ SRPDUDıF]RZHEUø]RZH ]HVNįDGQLNyZUHV]WHNSRWUDZ įDWZHGRXVXQLċFLDRVDG\ RUD]ZRG\ ZDSLHı ÅP\GODQ\´ ZHZQċWU]XXU]øG]HQLD SU]HGHZV]\VWNLPQDGQLH ZQċWU]D]P\ZDUNL &]ċńFL]WZRU]\ZDV]WXF]QHJR =DIDUERZDQLHF]ċńFL PRJøVLċ]DIDUERZDúSRGF]DV ]WZRU]\ZDV]WXF]QHJR HNVSORDWDFML]P\ZDUNL ZHZQøWU]XU]øG]HQLD ŁURGNL]DUDGF]H =PLHQLúPDUNċńURGNDF]\V]F]øFHJR :\F]\ńFLúXU]øG]HQLHPHFKDQLF]QLH 8VWDZLúXNįDG]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\ZHGįXJ LQVWUXNFMLREVįXJLOXEGRGDúVROL 8VWDZLúXNįDG]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\ZHGįXJ LQVWUXNFMLREVįXJLOXEXţ\ZDúRGG]LHOQ\FK ńURGNyZ PDUNRZHńURGNLF]\V]F]øFHVyO Sį\QQDEį\V]F]DMøF\ =ZLċNV]\úGR]RZDQLHńURGNDF]\V]F]øFHJR OXE]PLHQLúSURGXNW :\EUDúLQWHQV\ZQLHMV]\SURJUDP]P\ZDQLD :\EUDúSURJUDP]Z\ţV]øWHPSHUDWXUø ]P\ZDQLD 1DSHįQLúZįDńFLZ\PńURGNLHP F]\V]F]øF\PSUDZLGįRZRGR]XMøF 1LH]P\ZDúZVWċSQLHQDF]\ı8VXQøúW\ONR ZLċNV]HUHV]WNLSRWUDZ =DOHFHQLHSURJUDPX(FR 0RţQDF]ċńFLRZRXVXQøúVWRVXMøF SUHSDUDW\GRF]\V]F]HQLD]P\ZDUHNOXE SRSU]H]F]\V]F]HQLHPHFKDQLF]QH1DORW\ QLHVøV]NRGOLZHGOD]GURZLD 0RţQDF]ċńFLRZRXVXQøúVWRVXMøF SUHSDUDW\GRF]\V]F]HQLD]P\ZDUHNOXE SRSU]H]F]\V]F]HQLHPHFKDQLF]QH 6SUDZG]LúIXQNFMRQRZDQLHXNįDGX ]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\ GRGDúVyOVSHFMDOQø Z]JOċGQLHSU]\VWRVRZDQLXNRPSDNWRZ\FK ńURGNyZF]\V]F]øF\FK WDEOHWHN ZįøF]\ú ]PLċNF]DQLHZRG\ SDWU]UR]G]LDįÅ8NįDG ]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\6yOVSHFMDOQD´ =DIDUERZDQLDVøQRUPDOQHLQLHZ\ZLHUDMø XMHPQHJRZSį\ZXQDIXQNFMRQRZDQLH ]P\ZDUNL SO &RURELúZUD]LHXVWHUNL" 8VWHUND =DIDUERZDQLHF]ċńFL ]WZRU]\ZDV]WXF]QHJR 3U]\F]\QD =E\WQLVNDWHPSHUDWXUD ]P\ZDQLD 1DF]\QLD]RVWDį\ZVWċSQLH]E\W VLOQLHRF]\V]F]RQHGODWHJR F]XMQLN]DGHF\GRZDįZįøF]\ú VįDEV]\SURJUDP6LOQH ]DEUXG]HQLDQLHGDMøVLċ F]ċńFLRZRXVXQøú =DGXţDLORńúSį\QX 6PXJLPRţOLZH QDEį\V]F]DMøFHJR GRXVXQLċFLDQDV]NįDFK V]NįDFK]PHWDOLF]Q\P %UDNSį\QXQDEį\V]F]DMøFHJROXE Z\JOøGHPLV]WXúFDFK ]DQLVNLHXVWDZQLHQLH 5HV]WNLńURGNDF]\V]F]øFHJR ZVHNZHQFMLSURJUDPXSįXNDQLH ]QDEį\V]F]DQLHP3RNU\ZD SRMHPQLNDQDńURGHNF]\V]F]øF\ ]DEORNRZDQDSU]H]QDF]\QLD SRNU\ZDQLHRWZLHUDVLċ FDįNRZLFLH 1DF]\QLD]RVWDį\ZVWċSQLH]E\W VLOQLHRF]\V]F]RQHGODWHJR F]XMQLN]DGHF\GRZDįZįøF]\ú VįDEV]\SURJUDP6LOQH ]DEUXG]HQLDQLHGDMøVLċ F]ċńFLRZRXVXQøú 6]NįRQDGDMHVLċGR]P\ZDQLD 3RF]øWNXMøFHOXE Z]P\ZDUNDFKDOHQLHMHVW Z\VWċSXMøFH QLHRGZUDFDOQH]PċWQLHQLH RGSRUQHQD]P\ZDQLH Z]P\ZDUNDFK V]NįD ŁURGNL]DUDGF]H :\EUDúSURJUDP]Z\ţV]øWHPSHUDWXUø ]P\ZDQLD 1LH]P\ZDúZVWċSQLHQDF]\ı8VXQøúW\ONR ZLċNV]HUHV]WNLSRWUDZ =DOHFHQLHSURJUDPX(FR 8VWDZLúLORńúSį\QXQDEį\V]F]DMøFHJR QDQLţV]\VWRSLHı 'RGDúSį\QQDEį\V]F]DMøF\LVSUDZG]Lú GR]RZDQLH ]DOHFHQLHVWRSQLD 3RNU\ZDSRMHPQLNDQDńURGHNF]\V]F]øF\ QLHPRţHE\ú]DEORNRZDQDSU]H]QDF]\QLD 1LHNįDńúQDF]\ıOXERGńZLHţDF]\ GR]P\ZDUHNGRSRMHPQLNDQDWDEOHWNL 1LH]P\ZDúZVWċSQLHQDF]\ı8VXQøúW\ONR ZLċNV]HUHV]WNLSRWUDZ =DOHFHQLHSURJUDPX(FR 6WRVRZDúV]NįRRGSRUQHQD]P\ZDQLH Z]P\ZDUNDFK 8QLNDúGįXJLFKSURFHVyZSDURZDQLD F]DV SR]DNRıF]HQLX]P\ZDQLD 6WRVRZDúSURJUDP]P\ZDQLD]QLţV]ø WHPSHUDWXUø 1DVWDZLúXNįDG]PLċNF]DQLDZRG\ZHGįXJ WZDUGRńFLZRG\ HZHQWXDOQLHVWRSLHıQLţHM =DVWRVRZDúńURGHNGRRFKURQ\V]NįD &RURELúZUD]LHXVWHUNL" SO 8VWHUND ŃODG\UG]\QDV]WXúFDFK 8U]øG]HQLHQLH]DF]\QD SUDFRZDú 3U]\F]\QD 1LHZ\VWDUF]DMøFDRGSRUQRńú V]WXúFyZQDUG]HZLHQLH'RW\F]\ F]ċńFLHMRVWU]\QRţ\ 6]WXúFHUG]HZLHMøWDNţHZWHG\ JG\]P\ZDQHVøU]HF]\NWyUHVø QLHUG]HZQH XFKZ\W\JDUQNyZ XV]NRG]RQHNRV]HQDQDF]\QLD LWG =DZ\VRNLHVWċţHQLHVROL ZZRG]LHGR]P\ZDQLD]SRZRGX QLHGRNUċFRQHMSRNU\Z\ SRMHPQLNDQDVyOOXEUR]V\SDQD VyOSRGF]DVQDSHįQLDQLD =HSVXW\EH]SLHF]QLNGRPRZ\ .DEHOVLHFLRZ\Z\MċW\]JQLD]GND 3URJUDPUR]SRF]\QDVLċ VDPRF]\QQLH 'U]ZLXU]øG]HQLDQLH VøSUDZLGįRZR]DPNQLċWH 1LHRGF]HNDQR]DNRıF]HQLD SURJUDPX $NW\ZQ\SURJUDP 3U]HSURZDG]DQLHQDVWDZLHı PRţOLZHW\ONRQDSRF]øWNX SURJUDPX )XQNFMD]DEH]SLHF]HQLDSU]HG RWZRU]HQLHPGU]ZLSU]H]G]LHFL MHVWDNW\ZQD 'U]ZLQLHPRţQD]DPNQøú =DPHNZGU]ZLDFKSU]HVNRF]\į =DPNQLċFLHGU]ZLXQLHPRţOLZLRQH ]HZ]JOċGXQDPRQWDţ 1DVWDZLHQLHXU]øG]HQLD WZDUGRńúSįXNDQLH ]QDEį\V]F]DQLHP QLH MHVWPRţOLZH 'U]ZLFLċţNRVLċRWZLHUDMø 3RNU\Z\SRMHPQLND QDńURGHNF]\V]F]øF\ QLHPRţQD]DPNQøú 3RMHPQLNQDńURGHNF]\V]F]øF\ ]DEORNRZDQ\SRSU]H]VNOHMRQH UHV]WNLńURGNDF]\V]F]øFHJR ŁURGNL]DUDGF]H 8ţ\ZDúQLHUG]HZQ\FKV]WXúFyZ 1LH]P\ZDúF]ċńFLUG]HZLHMøF\FK UG]HZQ\FK 0RFQRGRNUċFLúSRNU\ZċSRMHPQLNDQDVyO OXEXVXQøúUR]V\SDQøVyO 6SUDZG]LúEH]SLHF]QLN 8SHZQLúVLċţHNDEHOVLHFLRZ\MHVWZįRţRQ\ GRJQLD]GNDRUD]SU]\įøF]RQ\GRXU]øG]HQLD ]W\įX 6SUDZG]LúF]\JQLD]GNRMHVW VSUDZQH =DPNQøúGU]ZL 3U]HSURZDG]Lú5HVHW 3DWU]Å$QXORZDQLHSURJUDPX´ 3U]HSURZDG]Lú5HVHW SDWU]Å$QXORZDQLH SURJUDPX´ RUD]SU]HSURZDG]LúQDVWDZLHQLH ZHGįXJLQVWUXNFMLREVįXJL 'HDNW\ZRZDú]DEH]SLHF]HQLHSU]HG G]LHúPL 3DWU]QDNRıFXLQVWUXNFMLREVįXJL =DPNQøúGU]ZLXţ\ZDMøFZLċFHMVLį\ 6SUDZG]Lú]DPRQWRZDQLHXU]øG]HQLDGU]ZL RUD]LQQHSU]HGPLRW\]DEXGRZDQLDF]ċńFL PHEOLQLHPRJøVLċRFLHUDúXGHU]Dú RVLHELHSRGF]DV]DP\NDQLDGU]ZL 8VXQøúUHV]WNLńURGNDF]\V]F]øFHJR SO &RURELúZUD]LHXVWHUNL" 8VWHUND 5HV]WNLńURGND F]\V]F]øFHJRZSRMHPQLNX QDńURGHNF]\V]F]øF\OXE ZSRMHPQLNXQDWDEOHWNL 3U]\F]\QD ŃURGHNF]\V]F]øF\QLHMHVW Z\SįXNLZDQ\]HZ]JOċGX QD]DEORNRZDQHUDPLRQD VSU\VNXMøFHSU]H]QDF]\QLD 3RMHPQLNQDńURGHNF]\V]F]øF\ E\įZLOJRWQ\SRGF]DVQDSHįQLDQLD 8U]øG]HQLH]DWU]\PXMHVLċ 'U]ZLQLHVøGRNįDGQLH ]DPNQLċWH SRGF]DVSURJUDPXOXE SURJUDPSU]HU\ZDVLċ 1LHNįDńúQDF]\ıOXERGńZLHţDF]\ GR]P\ZDUHNGRSRMHPQLND QDWDEOHWNL *yUQ\NRV]QDFLVNDQDGU]ZLLQLH SR]ZDODQDSUDZLGįRZH ]DPNQLċFLHGU]ZL 3U]HUZDQ\GRSį\ZSUøGXRUD] OXEZRG\ 2GJįRVXGHU]Hı]DZRUyZ =ZLø]DQH]GRPRZøLQVWDODFMø QDSHįQLDMøF\FK QLHMHVWWREįøGXU]øG]HQLD 1LHPDZSį\ZXQDIXQNFMċ XU]øG]HQLD 8GHU]DMøF\OXEVWXNDMøF\ 5DPLċVSU\VNXMøFHXGHU]D RGJįRV RQDF]\QLDQDF]\QLDQLH]RVWDį\ SUDZLGįRZRZįRţRQH GRXU]øG]HQLD 3U]\QLHZLHONLP]DįDGXQNX VWUXPLHQLHZRG\XGHU]DMø EH]SRńUHGQLRRNRPRUċ ]P\ZDUNL /HNNLHQDF]\QLDUXV]DMøVLċ SRGF]DV]P\ZDQLD 1DG]Z\F]DMQHZ\G]LHODQLH ŃURGHNGRUċF]QHJRP\FLD SLDQ\ QDF]\ıZ]ELRUQLNXSį\QX QDEį\V]F]DMøFHJR 5R]ODQ\Sį\QQDEį\V]F]DMøF\ Z]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX ŁURGNL]DUDGF]H =DSHZQLúVZRERGQ\REUyWUDPLRQ VSU\VNXMøF\FK :V\SDúńURGHNF]\V]F]øF\W\ONR GRVXFKHJRSRMHPQLNDQDńURGHN F]\V]F]øF\ =DPNQøúGU]ZL 6SUDZG]LúF]\W\OQDńFLDQNDQLH]RVWDįD ZFLńQLċWDSU]H]JQLD]GNROXE QLH]GHPRQWRZDQ\XFKZ\WQDZċţD 3U]\ZUyFLúGRSį\ZSUøGXRUD]OXEZRG\ %UDNńURGNyZ]DUDGF]\FK 1DF]\QLDXįRţ\úZWDNLVSRVyEDE\UDPLRQD VSU\VNXMøFHQLHXGHU]Dį\RQDF]\QLD :įRţ\úZLċFHMQDF]\ıOXEUyZQRPLHUQLH UR]VWDZLúQDF]\QLDZ]P\ZDUFH /HNNLHQDF]\QLDZNįDGDúZWDNLVSRVyEDE\ QLHPRJį\VLċUXV]Dú 1LH]ZįRF]QLHQDSHįQLú]ELRUQLNSį\QHP QDEį\V]F]DMøF\P 8VXQøúSį\QQDEį\V]F]DMøF\ńFLHUNø 6HUZLV SO 6HUZLV 8VWDZLDQLH LSRGĥøF]DQLH VZ 6 ULH -HłOLQLHXGDĭRVLċ3DįVWZXXVXQøú XVWHUNLSURVLP\]ZUyFLúVLċGRVHUZLVX =QDMG]LHP\ZĭDłFLZHUR]ZLø]DQLH UyZQLHşE\XQLNQøú]EċGQHJRZH]ZDQLD WHFKQLNDVHUZLVX,QIRUPDFMHGRW\F]øFH QDMEOLşV]HJRDXWRU\]RZDQHJRVHUZLVX ]QDMGXMøVLċQDW\OQLHMVWURQLHLQVWUXNFML REVĭXJLOXEZ]DĭøF]RQ\PZ\ND]LH SODFyZHNVHUZLVRZ\FK3URVLP\ RWHOHIRQLF]QHSRGDQLHQXPHUX XU]øG]HQLD (ä1U LQXPHUX IDEU\NDF\MQHJR )' QXPHU\WH ]QDMGXMøVLċQDWDEOLF]FH ]QDPLRQRZHMXPLHV]F]RQHM QDGU]ZLDFKXU]øG]HQLD HQLDZ 8 LWV HQLD]FąSRGáL :ĭDłFLZDHNVSORDWDFMD]P\ZDUNL Z\PDJDSUDZLGĭRZHJRSRGĭøF]HQLD 3DUDPHWU\GRSĭ\ZXLRGSĭ\ZXZRG\ DWDNşHGDQHSU]\ĭøF]DHOHNWU\F]QHJR PXV]øVSHĭQLDúZ\PDJDQHNU\WHULD NWyUHSU]HGVWDZLRQRZQDVWċSQ\FK UR]G]LDĭDFKZ]JOZLQVWUXNFMLPRQWDşX 3RGF]DVPRQWDşXSU]HVWU]HJDúSRGDQHM NROHMQRłFLZ\NRQ\ZDQLDF]\QQRłFL .RQWURODSU]\GRVWDZLH 8VWDZLHQLH 3RGĭøF]HQLHGRRGSĭ\ZX 3U]\ĭøF]HZRG\SLWQHM 3RGĭøF]HQLHHOHNWU\F]QH (1U )' (1U )' 3URV]Ċ]DXIDúNRPSHWHQFML SURGXFHQWD:UD]LHXVWHUNLSURV]ċ ]ZUyFLúVLċGRQDV7\PVDP\P ]DSHZQLRQD]RVWDQLHQDSUDZD SU]HSURZDG]RQDSU]H]SURIHVMRQDOQ\ VHUZLVG\VSRQXMøF\RU\JLQDOQ\PL F]ċłFLDPL]DPLHQQ\PL Z]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX SO 8VWDZLDQLHLSRGĭøF]DQLH =DNUHVGRVWDZ\ 'DQHWHFKQLF]QH :UD]LHXVWHUHNSURV]ċVLċ]ZUyFLú GRSXQNWX]DNXSXOXEGRQDV]HJR VHUZLVX ʋ =P\ZDUND ʋ ,QVWUXNFMDREVĭXJL ʋ ,QVWUXNFMDPRQWDşX ʋ *ZDUDQFMD ʋ 0DWHULDĭPRQWDşRZ\ ʋ %ODFKDFKURQLøFDSU]HGSDUø ʋ *XPRZ\IDUWXFK ʋ .DEHOVLHFLRZ\ Z]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX :DJD PDNVNJ 1DSLĊFLH ²9+]OXE+] :DUWRĹúSRGĥøF]HQLD ²N: %H]SLHF]QLN $ 8.$ 3REyUPRF\ 6WDQZ\ĭøF]RQ\ 3R : 6WDQZĭøF]RQ\ JRWRZRłúGRSUDF\ 3O : ]JRGQLH]]DU]øG]HQLDPL 8( QU L )XQNFMHGRGDWNRZHLXVWDZLHQLDPRJø ]ZLċNV]\úSREyUPRF\ &LĹQLHQLHZRG\ SU]\QDMPQLHM03D EDU PDNV\PDOQLH03D EDU :SU]\SDGNXZ\şV]HJRFLłQLHQLDZRG\ ]DLQVWDORZDú]DZyUUHGXNF\MQ\ FLłQLHQLD ,ORĹúGRSĥ\ZX PLQLPDOQLHOLWUyZPLQXWċ 7HPSHUDWXUDZRG\ 3UHIHURZDQDZRGD]LPQDSU]\ZRG]LH FLHSĭHM²Z]DOHşQRłFLRGURG]DMXZċşD GRSĭ\ZXZRG\²PDNVWHPS& SDWU]Å3U]\ĭøF]HZRG\SLWQHM´ 3RMHPQRĹú ²QDNU\úVWRĭRZ\FK Z]DOHşQRłFL RGPRGHOX :VND]yZNLEH]SLHF]HħVWZD 3U]HVWU]HJDúZVND]yZHN EH]SLHF]HįVWZD]DPLHV]F]RQ\FK ZUR]G]LDOHÅ3RGF]DVLQVWDODFML´ 'RVWDZD =P\ZDUND]RVWDĭDIDEU\F]QLHSRGGDQD JUXQWRZQHMNRQWUROLSUDZLGĭRZRłFL G]LDĭDQLD:Z\QLNXWHJRSR]RVWDĭ\ łODG\ZRG\NWyUH]QLNQøSRSLHUZV]\P SURFHVLH]P\ZDQLD 8VWDZLDQLHLSRGĭøF]DQLH SO 8VWDZLHQLH 3U]\ĥøF]HZRG\SLWQHM .RQLHF]QHZ\PLDU\PRQWDşRZH SU]HGVWDZLRQRZLQVWUXNFMLPRQWDşX =P\ZDUNċQDOHş\Z\SR]LRPRZDú SU]\SRPRF\QyJ]HłUXEDPL UHJXODF\MQ\PL8SHZQLúVLċ FRGRSHZQRłFLXVWDZLHQLD ʋ 8U]øG]HQLRPSU]H]QDF]RQ\P GR]DEXGRZDQLDSRGEODWHP URERF]\POXEGR]LQWHJURZDQLD NWyUH]RVWDQøSyŝQLHMXVWDZLRQHMDNR ZROQRVWRMøFHQDOHş\]DSHZQLú RGSRZLHGQLøVWDWHF]QRłúXVWDZLHQLD QSSU]H]SU]\NUċFHQLHGRłFLDQ\ DOER]DPRQWRZDQLHFLøJĭHJREODWX URERF]HJRSU]\NUċFRQHJR GRVøVLHGQLFKV]DIHN ʋ =DEXGRZDQLHXU]øG]HQLDZEORNX NXFKHQQ\PSRPLċG]\łFLDQDPL GUHZQLDQ\PLOXE]WZRU]\ZD V]WXF]QHJRMHVWGR]ZRORQH 3U]\ĭøF]HZRG\SLWQHMZ\NRQDú ]JRGQLH]LQVWUXNFMøPRQWDşX ]DSRPRFøGRVWDUF]RQ\FKF]ċłFL GR]DZRUXNXUNRZHJRZRG\ 1DOHş\]ZUDFDúXZDJċQDWRDE\ SU]\ĭøF]HZRG\SLWQHMQLHE\ĭR ]DĭDPDQH]JQLHFLRQHOXEVNUċFRQH :SU]\SDGNXZ\PLDQ\XU]øG]HQLD QDOHş\]DZV]H]DLQVWDORZDúQRZ\ ZøşGRSĭ\ZXZRG\ &LĹQLHQLHZRG\ 3U]\QDMPQLHM03D EDU PDNV\PDOQLH03D EDU :SU]\SDGNXZ\şV]HJRFLłQLHQLDZRG\ ]DLQVWDORZDú]DZyUUHGXNF\MQ\ FLłQLHQLD ,ORĹúGRSĥ\ZX 0LQLPDOQLHOLWUyZPLQXWċ 7HPSHUDWXUDZRG\ 3U]HVWU]HJDúQDGUXNQDZċşXGRSĭ\ZX ZRG\ 7HPSHUDWXUDZRG\PRşHZ\QRVLú PDNV\PDOQLH& ZRGD]LPQD SU]\ PRGHODFK]QDGUXNLHP 3RGĥøF]HQLHGRRGSĥ\ZX .RQLHF]QHF]\QQRłFLURERF]H SU]HGVWDZLRQRZLQVWUXNFMLPRQWDşX ZUD]LHSRWU]HE\]DPRQWRZDúV\IRQ ]NUyúFHPRGSĭ\ZX :øşRGSĭ\ZXSRĭøF]\ú]NUyúFHP RGSĭ\ZX]DSRPRFøGRVWDUF]RQ\FK F]ċłFL =ZUyFLúXZDJċşHE\ZøşRGSĭ\ZRZ\ QLHE\ĭ]DĭDPDQ\]JQLHFLRQ\ OXEVNUċFRQ\LşHE\SRNU\ZD ]DP\NDMøFDZRGSĭ\ZLH QLHXWUXGQLDĭDRGSĭ\ZXłFLHNyZ 'ODZV]\VWNLFKLQQ\FKPRGHOL 3UHIHURZDQDZRGD]LPQDSU]\ZRG]LH FLHSĭHMPDNVWHPS& SO 8VWDZLDQLHLSRGĭøF]DQLH 3RGĥøF]HQLHGR]DVLODQLD FLHSĥøZRGø 3RGĭøF]HQLHGR]DVLODQLDFLHSĭøZRGø Z]DOHşQRłFLRGPRGHOX =P\ZDUNċPRşQDSRGĭøF]\úGR]LPQHM OXEGRFLHSĭHMZRG\GRPDNVWHPS & 3RGĭøF]HQLHGRFLHSĭHMZRG\]DOHFDVLċ ZWHG\JG\ZRGDSRFKRG]L ]HQHUJHW\F]QLHNRU]\VWQHJR SRGĭøF]HQLDSU]\RGSRZLHGQLHM LQVWDODFMLQSSRGĭøF]HQLHGRNROHNWRUyZ VĭRQHF]Q\FK]RELHJLHPSU]HSĭ\ZRZ\P ']LċNLWHPXRV]F]ċG]DQDMHVWHQHUJLD LF]DV 3RSU]H]QDVWDZLHQLH]DVLODQLDFLHSĭø ZRGø©¯³PRşQDRSW\PDOQLHQDVWDZLú XU]øG]HQLHQDHNVSORDWDFMċFLHSĭøZRGø =DOHFDQDWHPSHUDWXUDZRG\ WHPSHUDWXUDZRG\ZSĭ\ZDMøFHM Z\QRVL RGFRQDMPQLHM&GRPDNV\PDOQLH & 1LH]DOHFDVLċSRGĭøF]HQLD GRHNVSORDWDFMLFLHSĭøZRGøMHłOLZRGD SRFKRG]L]ERMOHUDHOHNWU\F]QHJR 1DVWDZLHQLH]DVLODQLDFLHSĥøZRGø =DPNQøúGU]ZL :ĭøF]\úSU]HĭøF]QLN:Ĭ÷&= :<Ĭ÷&= 1DFLVQøúSU]\FLVN67$57# LSU]\WU]\PDúZFLłQLċW\ 3URJUDPDWRUSU]HNUċFDú DşZ\łZLHWODF]F\IURZ\+ ZVNDşH©¯³ 3XłFLúSU]\FLVN :\łZLHWODF]F\IURZ\+ZVND]XMH IDEU\F]QLHXVWDZLRQøZDUWRłú©¯¯ :FHOX]PLDQ\WHJRXVWDZLHQLD 3U]H]SU]HNUċFDQLH SURJUDPDWRUDPRşQD Z\ĭøF]\ú©¯¯OXEZĭøF]\ú©¯³ QDVWDZLHQLH]DVLODQLDFLHSĭøZRGø 1DFLVQøúSU]\FLVN67$57# :DUWRłúQDVWDZLHQLDMHVW]DSLVDQD ZSDPLċFL 8VWDZLDQLHLSRGĭøF]DQLH SO 3RGĥøF]HQLHHOHNWU\F]QH ʋ ʋ ʋ ʋ ʋ ʋ 8U]øG]HQLHSRGĭøF]\úW\ONRGRVLHFL SUøGX]PLHQQHJRZ]DNUHVLH RG9GR9RUD]+]OXE +]SRSU]H]SU]HSLVRZR ]DLQVWDORZDQHJQLD]GNRZW\NRZH ]SU]HZRGHPRFKURQQ\P.RQLHF]QH EH]SLHF]QLNL²SDWU]WDEOLF]ND LGHQW\ILNDF\MQD *QLD]GNRZW\NRZHPXVL]QDMGRZDú VLċZSREOLşXXU]øG]HQLDLPXVLE\ú ZROQRGRVWċSQHWDNşH SR]DEXGRZDQLX -HłOLSR]DEXGRZDQLXZW\F]ND QLHMHVWZROQRGRVWċSQDZWHG\ VSHĭQLHQLHZĭDłFLZ\FKSU]HSLVyZ EH]SLHF]HįVWZDSUDF\Z\PDJD ]DLQVWDORZDQLDRGĭøF]QLNDZV]\VWNLFK ELHJXQyZ]UR]ZDUFLHPVW\NyZ FRQDMPQLHMPP 3U]HUDELDQLHSU]\ĭøF]D GR]ZRORQHMHVWW\ONRXSUDZQLRQ\P VSHFMDOLVWRP 3U]HGĭXşDF]GODVLHFLRZHJR SU]HZRGX]DVLODMøFHJRPRşQDQDE\ú W\ONRZDXWRU\]RZDQ\PVHUZLVLH :SU]\SDGNX]DVWRVRZDQLD Z\ĭøF]QLNDRFKURQQHJRSUøGX XSĭ\ZRZHJRZROQRXş\ZDúW\ONR Z\ĭøF]QLNDRSDWU]RQHJR ]QDNLHP³7\ONRRQJZDUDQWXMH VSHĭQLHQLHDNWXDOQLHRERZLø]XMøF\FK SU]HSLVyZ 8U]øG]HQLHMHVWZ\SRVDşRQH ZV\VWHP]DEH]SLHF]DMøF\ SU]HGZ\Sĭ\ZHPZRG\3URVLP\ R]ZUyFHQLHXZDJLQDWRşHV\VWHP WHQG]LDĭDW\ONRSU]\SRGĭøF]RQ\P ]DVLODQLXSUøGRZ\P 'HPRQWDŐ =DFKRZDúWDNşHWXWDMNROHMQRłú Z\NRQ\ZDQLDF]\QQRłFL 2GĭøF]\úXU]øG]HQLHRGVLHFL HOHNWU\F]QHM =DNUċFLúGRSĭ\ZZRG\ 2GĭøF]\úSU]\ĭøF]DRGSĭ\ZXLZRG\ SLWQHM :\NUċFLúłUXE\PRFXMøFHXU]øG]HQLH GRPHEOL =GHPRQWRZDúSDQHOFRNRĭRZ\² RLOHMHVW :\FLøJQøúXU]øG]HQLHRVWURşQLH SRFLøJDMøFSU]\W\P]DZċşH SO 8VWDZLDQLHLSRGĭøF]DQLH 7UDQVSRUW =DEH]SLHF]HQLH SU]HGVNXWNDPLPUR]X =DEH]SLHF]HQLHSU]HGVNXWNDPLPUR]X2SUyşQLDQLHXU]øG]HQLD 2SUyşQLú]P\ZDUNċL]DEH]SLHF]\ú OXŝQHF]ċłFL 2SUyŐQLHQLH]P\ZDUNLZ\PDJD Z\NRQDQLDQLŐHMZ\PLHQLRQ\FK F]\QQRĹFL 2WZRU]\ú]DZyUZRG\ =DPNQøúGU]ZL :ĭøF]\úSU]HĭøF]QLN:Ĭ÷&= :<Ĭ÷&= :\EUDúSURJUDP]QDMZ\şV]ø WHPSHUDWXUø 1DZ\łZLHWODF]XF\IURZ\P+ SRMDZLVLċSU]\SXV]F]DOQ\F]DV WUZDQLDSURJUDPX 1DFLVQøúSU]\FLVN67$57# 3U]HELHJSURJUDPXVWDUWXMH 3RXSĭ\ZLHRNPLQXWSU]\FLVN 67$57#WDNGĭXJRSU]\WU]\PDú ZFLłQLċW\DşZ\łZLHWODF]F\IURZ\ ZVNDşH¯¯³ 3RRNRĭRPLQSRNDşHVLċ QDZ\łZLHWODF]XF\IURZ\P¯¯¯ :\ĭøF]\úSU]HĭøF]QLN:Ĭ÷&= :<Ĭ÷&= =DPNQøú]DZyUZRG\RGĭøF]\ú ZøşGRSĭ\ZRZ\LRSUyşQLú 8U]øG]HQLHWUDQVSRUWRZDúW\ONR ZSR]\FMLSLRQRZHM &KURQLWRSU]HGZQLNQLċFLHPUHV]W\ ZRG\GRVWHURZQLNDPDV]\Q\ LVSRZRGRZDQLHPEĭċGQHJRSU]HELHJX SURJUDPX -HłOLXU]øG]HQLHVWRLZSRPLHV]F]HQLX QDUDşRQ\PQDPUy] QSGRPHN OHWQLVNRZ\ QDOHş\MHFDĭNRZLFLH RSUyşQLú SDWU]WUDQVSRUW =PLDQ\]DVWU]HşRQH =DEH]SLHF]HQLHGRVWĊSXG]LHFL EORNDGDGU]ZL â 2VWU]HŐHQLH $NW\ZDFMD]DEH]SLHF]HQLDSU]HGG]LHúPL 2WZRU]\úGU]ZLF]NLSU]\DNW\ZQ\P ]DEH]SLHF]HQLXSU]HGG]LHúPL 'HDNW\ZDFMD]DEH]SLHF]HQLDSU]HGG]LHúPL 3R]RVWDZLDMøFXU]øG]HQLHEH]âQDG]RUX]DZV]H FDĭNRZLFLH]DP\NDúGU]ZLF]NLXU]øG]HQLD 7\ONRZâWHQVSRVyEPRşQDFKURQLúG]LHFL SU]HGPRşOLZ\PLQLHEH]SLHF]HįVWZDPL 1DWU\VNGRâ]P\ZDQLDEODFKGRâSLHF]HQLDâ :LċNV]HEODFK\NUDWNLF]\WDOHU]HRâłUHGQLF\ZLċNV]HMQLşFP ZLċNV]HHOHPHQW\ ]DVWDZ\VWRĭRZHM PRşQDF]\łFLú]DSRPRFøWHMJĭRZLF\UR]SU\VNRZHM :âW\PFHOXZ\MøúNRV]âJyUQ\LâZĭRş\úQDWU\VNZâVSRVyESU]HGVWDZLRQ\QDâU\VXQNX %ODFK\QDOHş\XVWDZLúZâVSRVyESU]HGVWDZLRQ\QDâU\VXQNXDE\âVWUXPLHįZRG\ PyJĭGRMłúGRâZV]\VWNLFKF]ċłFL PDNV\PDOQLHâEODFK\GRâSLHF]HQLDOXEâUXV]W\ =P\ZDUNċXş\WNRZDú]DZV]H]âNRV]HPJyUQ\POXEJĭRZLFøQDWU\VNRZøGRâEODFK âZâQLHNWyU\FKPRGHODFK %6+6SU]ċW*RVSRGDUVWZD'RPRZHJR6S]RR $O-HUR]ROLPVNLH :DUV]DZD SO (* 32/$1' ZZZ]HOPHUFRP
advertisement
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Related manuals
advertisement