Chapter 9: Binary Compatibility 911
9 Binary Compatibility
Binary compatibility encompasses several related concepts: application binary interface (ABI)
The set of runtime conventions followed by all of the tools that deal with binary representations of a program, including compilers, assemblers, linkers, and language runtime support. Some ABIs are formal with a written specification, possibly designed by multiple interested parties. Others are simply the way things are actually done by a particular set of tools.
ABI conformance
A compiler conforms to an ABI if it generates code that follows all of the specifications enumerated by that ABI. A library conforms to an ABI if it is implemented according to that ABI. An application conforms to an ABI if it is built using tools that conform to that ABI and does not contain source code that specifically changes behavior specified by the ABI.
calling conventions
Calling conventions are a subset of an ABI that specify of how arguments are passed and function results are returned.
interoperability
Different sets of tools are interoperable if they generate files that can be used in the same program. The set of tools includes compilers, assemblers, linkers, libraries, header files, startup files, and debuggers. Binaries produced by different sets of tools are not interoperable unless they implement the same ABI.
This applies to different versions of the same tools as well as tools from different vendors.
intercallability
Whether a function in a binary built by one set of tools can call a function in a binary built by a different set of tools is a subset of interoperability.
implementation-defined features
Language standards include lists of implementation-defined features whose behavior can vary from one implementation to another. Some of these features are normally covered by a platform’s ABI and others are not. The features that are not covered by an ABI generally affect how a program behaves, but not intercallability.
compatibility
Conformance to the same ABI and the same behavior of implementation-defined features are both relevant for compatibility.
The application binary interface implemented by a C or C ++ compiler affects code generation and runtime support for:
• size and alignment of data types
• layout of structured types
• calling conventions
912 Using the GNU Compiler Collection (GCC)
• register usage conventions
• interfaces for runtime arithmetic support
• object file formats
In addition, the application binary interface implemented by a C ++ compiler affects code generation and runtime support for:
• name mangling
• exception handling
• invoking constructors and destructors
• layout, alignment, and padding of classes
• layout and alignment of virtual tables
Some GCC compilation options cause the compiler to generate code that does not conform to the platform’s default ABI. Other options cause different program behavior for implementation-defined features that are not covered by an ABI. These options are provided for consistency with other compilers that do not follow the platform’s default ABI or the usual behavior of implementation-defined features for the platform. Be very careful about using such options.
Most platforms have a well-defined ABI that covers C code, but ABIs that cover C ++ functionality are not yet common.
Starting with GCC 3.2, GCC binary conventions for C ++ are based on a written, vendorneutral C ++ ABI that was designed to be specific to 64-bit Itanium but also includes generic specifications that apply to any platform. This C ++ ABI is also implemented by other compiler vendors on some platforms, notably GNU/Linux and BSD systems. We have tried hard to provide a stable ABI that will be compatible with future GCC releases, but it is possible that we will encounter problems that make this difficult. Such problems could include different interpretations of the C ++ ABI by different vendors, bugs in the ABI, or bugs in the implementation of the ABI in different compilers. GCC’s ‘ -Wabi ’ switch warns when G ++ generates code that is probably not compatible with the C ++ ABI.
The C ++ library used with a C ++ compiler includes the Standard C ++ Library, with functionality defined in the C ++ Standard, plus language runtime support. The runtime support is included in a C ++ ABI, but there is no formal ABI for the Standard C ++ Library.
Two implementations of that library are interoperable if one follows the de-facto ABI of the other and if they are both built with the same compiler, or with compilers that conform to the same ABI for C ++ compiler and runtime support.
When G ++ and another C ++ compiler conform to the same C ++ ABI, but the implementations of the Standard C ++ Library that they normally use do not follow the same ABI for the Standard C ++ Library, object files built with those compilers can be used in the same program only if they use the same C ++ library. This requires specifying the location of the
C ++ library header files when invoking the compiler whose usual library is not being used.
The location of GCC’s C ++ header files depends on how the GCC build was configured, but can be seen by using the G ++ ‘ -v ’ option. With default configuration options for G ++ 3.3
the compile line for a different C ++ compiler needs to include
-I gcc_install_directory /include/c++/3.3
Similarly, compiling code with G ++ that must use a C ++ library other than the GNU C ++ library requires specifying the location of the header files for that other library.
Chapter 9: Binary Compatibility 913
The most straightforward way to link a program to use a particular C ++ library is to use a C ++ driver that specifies that C ++ library by default. The g++ driver, for example, tells the linker where to find GCC’s C ++ library (‘ libstdc++ ’) plus the other libraries and startup files it needs, in the proper order.
If a program must use a different C ++ library and it’s not possible to do the final link using a C ++ driver that uses that library by default, it is necessary to tell g++ the location and name of that library. It might also be necessary to specify different startup files and other runtime support libraries, and to suppress the use of GCC’s support libraries with one or more of the options ‘ -nostdlib ’, ‘ -nostartfiles ’, and ‘ -nodefaultlibs ’.
