IPC-7530A Draft Document for Industry Consensus Only August 2016
1.4.16 Preheat
The section of the soldering equipment which establishes the ramp rate for an assembly before the soak.
A profile zone where the assembly is heated from room temperature to the beginning of the soak zone temperature and is characterized by the ramp slope measurement.
1.4.17 Class 1 Radiant IR-Dominant Systems
Heating of the assembly is accomplished predominantly by infrared (IR) radiation with little or no convection.
1.4.18 Class 2 Convection/IR Systems
Heating of the assembly is accomplished by a combination of IR radiation and convection in varying ratios.
1.4.19 Class 3 Convection-Dominant Systems
Heating of the assembly is accomplished predominantly by convection with little or no IR.
1.4.20 Profile Zones
The profile is divided into distinct time periods which represent portions of the thermal process. Each zone is characterized by one or more measurements extracted from each zone (e.g., temperature, slope or time value).
2 APPLICABLE DOCUMENTS
2.1 IPC 1
IPC-T-50 Terms and Definitions for Interconnecting and Packaging Electronic Circuits
IPC-CA-821 General Requirements for Thermally Conductive Adhesives
IPC-2222 Sectional Design Standard for Rigid Organic Printed Boards
IPC-9501 PWB Assembly Process Simulation for Evaluation of Electronic Components
IPC-9502 PWB Assembly Soldering Process Guideline for Electronic Components
IPC-9504 Assembly Process Simulation for Evaluation of Non-IC Components (Preconditioning Non-IC Components)
2.2 Joint Industry Standard
2
J-STD-001 Requirements for Soldered Electrical and Electronic Assemblies
J-STD-002 Solderability Tests for Component Leads, Terminations, Lugs, Terminals and Wires
2.3 Other Industry Standard
JEP 140 Beaded Thermocouple Temperature Measurement of Semiconductor Packages
3 CONVECTION REFLOW PROFILING
3.1 Time/Temperature Profiles
The solder profile, also known as thermal profile, is one of the key variables in the manufacturing process that
8
IPC-7530A Draft Document for Industry Consensus Only August 2016 significantly impacts product yield, quality and reliability. Conveyor speed and panel temperatures are two variables in solder profile development. The solder profile is not only product specific; it is also flux and solder alloy dependent. Different pastes require different profiles for optimum performance, so it is important to consult the paste manufacturer before developing the solder profile.
For developing the profile, the loaded board is needed for which the profile is being developed. Start with a given belt speed and monitor the top-side board temperature using thermocouples. Most new reflow ovens have built-in thermocouples and software packages to record the thermal profile. Also, commercial hardware and software packages, such as MOLE, data pack and many others are available to make thermal profile development an easy task. Use of such profilers has been important in tin/lead assemblies. Not it is only important, but it is critical that such profilers be used on each product to achieve good yield without exceeding the temperature constraints imposed by different types of components. Table 3-1 provides key reflow profiles for both tin/lead and lead-free assemblies and also for mixed assemblies (backward and forward compatibility profiles). Note that profiles for lead-free and forward-compatibility are the same. Table 3-2 provides profiles for SAC and low temperature lead free alloys containing bismuth.
Table 3-1 Profile Comparison Between SnPb, SAC 305 and Mixed Alloys
Profile Topic SnPb Alloy Profile Mixed/Backward
Compatibility Profile
Alloy Solidus temperature
Target Alloy peak temp range
Absolute Minimum peak reflow temperature **
183 °C
210 °C to 220 °C
205 °C
183 °C/220 °C
228 °C to 232 °C
228 °C
Pb-Free Alloy (SAC
305)/Forward
Compatibility
Profile
217 °C to 220 °C
235 °C to 245 °C
230 °C
Component ramp up rate
Component ramp down rate
2 °C to 4 °C / second * 2 °C to 4 °C / second *
2 °C to 6 °C / second * 2 °C to 6 °C / second *
100 °C to 180 °C * 100 °C to 180 °C * Soak or preheat activation temperature
Soak or preheat activation time 60 to 120 seconds * 60 to 120 seconds *
2 °C to 4 °C / second *
2 °C to 6 °C / second *
140 °C to 220 °C *
60 to 150 seconds *
9
IPC-7530A Draft Document for Industry Consensus Only August 2016
Dwell time above liquidus
Dwell time at peak temp.
60 to 90 seconds
20 seconds max
60 to 90 seconds
20 seconds min
60 to 90 seconds
20 seconds max
Solder Paste used
SMT Component Types
Tin-lead Paste Tin Lead Paste Lead Free (SAC 305) Paste
All SMT Type Tin-Lead and
Lead Free BUT NOT Lead
Free BGA Balls
All SMT Type Tin-Lead and
Lead Free INCLUDING SAC
Lead Free BGA Balls
ALL COMPONETS
INCLUDING BGAs are Lead
Free including BGAs with
SAC 305 Lead Free BGA balls
Reason for Peak Temperatures Lead Free surface finishes on BGA Parts have no problem melting at
2050C. Also all tin-lead surface finishes have 90% tin any way. Lead Free finishes have close to
100% tin with some other lead free elements like Bismuth
A compromise temperature is needed so that tin lead parts do not get overheated and lead free
SAC BGAs with melting point of 22 °C can melt, collapse and fully mix with tin-lead paste. Lower peak temperatures will cause
SAC BGA balls to either not melt or partially melt and increase the incidence of
HoP, Opens and poor reliability
All components are lead free and can take higher heat. However, too high a peak temperature may cause BGA ball drops, opens, dewetting and board warpage and Large
BGAs are tested for maximum of
245c for MSL level rating
* Verify with the supplier
** Coolest Temperature on the board
Table 3-2 Profile Comparison Between SAC Alloy, SnBi (Low-Temp) Alloys and Resin-Containing SnBi Solder
Pastes
Profile Topic
SAC 305 Solder Paste
SnBi Low Temperature
Solder Paste Profile
Profile
Resin Containing SnBi Low
Temperature
Alloy Solidus temperature 217 °C to 220 °C 139 °C to 140 °C 139 °C to 140 °C
Target Alloy peak temp range
Absolute Minimum peak reflow temperature **
Component ramp up rate
Component ramp down rate
Soak or preheat activation temperature
235 °C to 245 °C
230 °C
2 °C to 4 °C / second * 1 °C to 3°C / second *
2 °C to 6 °C / second * 2 °C to 6 °C / second *
140 °C to 220 °C *
160 °C to 200 °C
160 °C
100 °C to 120 °C *
160 °C to 180 °C
160 °C
2 °C to 4 °C / second *
2 °C to 6 °C / second *
None
Soak or preheat activation time 60 to 150 seconds * 30 to 90 seconds *
(to avoid premature curing
None
Dwell time above liquidus
Dwell time at peak temp.
Post Reflow Resin Cure Temp
Post Reflow Resin Cure Time
60 to 90 seconds
20 seconds max
N/A
N/A
30 to 90 seconds *
20 seconds max *
N/A
N/A
(to avoid premature curing
60 to 210 seconds *
Varies #
125 °C to 130 °C #
130 to 240 secs #
10
IPC-7530A Draft Document for Industry Consensus Only August 2016
Solder Paste used
SMT Component Types
ALL COMPONETS
INCLUDING BGAs are Lead
Free including BGAs with
SAC 305 Lead Free BGA balls eutectic) Low temperature without resin
ALL COMPONETS
INCLUDING BGAs are Lead
Free including BGAs with
SAC 305 Lead Free BGA balls (Do NOT use BGAs with SnPb solder balls)
SnBi (eutectic or noneutectic) Low temperature
WITH resin
ALL COMPONETS
INCLUDING BGAs are Lead
Free including BGAs with
SAC 305 Lead Free BGA balls (Do NOT use BGAs with SnPb solder balls)
* Verify with the supplier
** Coolest Component on Board
# Some resin containing solder pastes require extended time after the reflow phase in the reflow profile to cure the
With tin/lead, there has been general consensus in the industry about the composition of solder to be used: eutectic solder with 63 % tin and 37 % lead composition with melting point of 183 °C. With this composition, there was a big difference between the melting point (183 °C) and peak temperature (220 °C). It provides a very wide window (35C) his is a very wide window and reflow profile development is much easier.
In lead-free assembly, the commonly used SAC (Sn, Ag and Cu) solders contain 3 % to 4% silver, 0.5 % to 0.7% copper and the rest tin. These alloys have a melting point around 220 °C. A few components, such as some aluminum electrolytic capacitors, put restrictions on maximum temperature and duration above 230 °C to which they can be subjected. Additional constraints will be dictated by low-cost laminates, plastic connectors and moisture-sensitive components if used.
To accommodate such constraints, the peak temperature in lead-free assemblies should be maintained between
230 °C and 245 °C, a variation of only 15 °C, which is a tight process window. This is about a 60 % drop from the 35
°C variation with tin/lead assemblies as mentioned earlier. The difficulty of achieving a reflow profile to meet the defined process window is further increased if large components with high thermal mass are used on the same board with smaller, temperature-sensitive components. The reasons are simple. The large components with high thermal mass require a larger heat input to meet the process window requirements for peak temperature and time above liquidus. However, this large heat input may result in smaller, temperature-sensitive components falling outside the process window requirements. To resolve this issue, very tight process control and narrow temperature bandwidth across the board are necessary. Many assembly houses may have a hard time meeting such requirements, especially on complex boards, without concerted time and effort in developing reflow profiles.
The problem can be further compounded by backward compatibility issues in which some lead-free components are used on a primarily tin/lead board. In such cases, the profile must accommodate both tin/lead and lead-free package requirements.
Figure 3-1 shows a schematic of a profile. Figure 3-2 shows a real-world example for a SnPb profile. Figure 3-3 shows an example of a SAC 305 profile for a single-sided board moving at 24 in/sec. Figure 3-4 is the same board but double-sided. Note almost the same oven temperature but a slower belt speed of 21 in/sec.
11
IPC-7530A Draft Document for Industry Consensus Only August 2016
Figure 3-1 Schematic of Reflow Profile
Figure 3-2 SnPb Profile With Multiple Thermocouples
12
IPC-7530A Draft Document for Industry Consensus Only August 2016
Figure 3-3 Example of a SAC 305 Profile for a Single-Sided Board (Speed is 24 in/sec)
Figure 3-4 Example of a SAC 305 Profile for a Double-Sided Board (Speed is 21 in/sec)
There are two major types of profiles – ramp to soak and then to peak or RSP (Figure 3-5 top) and ramp to peak or
RP (Figure 3-5 bottom). The key difference between them is absence of soak zone in RP profile. Use of soak zone in RSP profile allows more uniform temperature across the board is very useful in achieving uniform temperature in a board with large variation in thermal masses of different components on the board. RSP profiles also make it easier to achieve lower voids in solder joints especially in BGAs. Ramp to peak or RP profiles may increase incidence of voids in solder joint but they minimize incidence of head on pillow in BGAs. Head on pillow is a serious defect. Presence of voids, especially under IPC 610 specification limits, is not a serious concern for product
13