IPC-7530A Draft Document for Industry Consensus Only August 2016
4 VAPOR PHASE REFLOW PROFILING
There are many driving forces for the use of vapor-phase soldering (VPS), also known as condensation soldering:
• Fixed peak temperature (215 °C or 230 °C) o
Includes very large and small components with wide variances in thermal mass o
Large and small components both achieve almost the same peak temperature
•
Temperature-sensitive components
•
Pb-free alloys with higher melting points
• Excellent heat-transfer capability
• Inert environment
• Vacuum capability (in some machines)
• Preheat as an integral part of the machine
• Possibility for lower intermetallic (IMC) thickness due to lower peak temperature
• Potential for lower voids if vacuum capability is used
•
Better PWBA cleanliness
•
Higher surface insulation values
•
VPS liquids can access tighter spaces to remove flux residues
Even with these driving forces, VPS has gone through changes in popularity. It was the process of choice in the early 1980s, but its use declined considerably for several reasons, including problems with the VPS process itself and improvements in IR processes. Convection-dominant IR system have been known to provide efficient heating without the inherent problems of VPS.
By the late 1980s, VPS almost disappeared entirely due to excessive incidences of wicking on leads of J- and gullwing devices, which led to solder opens. This wicking was caused by the lead and the land heating at different rates during VPS; it was exacerbated by noncoplanarity (the failure of the lead to touch the land). The surface of the lead reached the solder melting point a few seconds before the surface of the land, which caused the solder paste to melt, wet and wick up the lead before the land became hot enough for the molten solder to wet it. By the time the land reached the melting point of the solder paste, there was not enough solder left on the land to form a good solder joint. In addition to wicking in leaded parts, especially J-lead devices, VPS has also been known to cause tombstoning in chip components.
Figure 4-1 shows a VPS profile showing the leads reaching melting point temperature sooner than the pad. This time delay in reaching melting point for J-leaded components caused wicking and opens in solder joints. Newer
VPS systems with built-in preheat have made this wicking less of a concern (see Figure 4-2). Additionally, the superheat (temperature between melting point and Peak Reflow) is significantly reduced in Pb-free processes to around 40 °C in SnPb alloys and around 20 °C in SAC Pb-free alloys.
VPS uses the latent heat of liquid vaporization to provide heat for soldering. This latent heat is released as the vapor of the inert liquid condenses on component leads and PCB lands. This liquid produces a dense, saturated vapor that displaces air and moisture. The temperature of the saturated vapor zone is the same as the boiling point of the vapor phase liquid. This fluid does not have any environmental concerns.
24
IPC-7530A Draft Document for Industry Consensus Only August 2016
Figure 4-1 VPS Profile Showing Wicking and Opens
25